For each idea, I wrote the hypothesis and pass/fail criteria before running the numbers. I scored every filter on the trades it removes, not the ones it keeps, with confidence intervals by trading day (trades on the same day aren't independent).
Data: my SPY option-chain snapshots (Jul–Nov 2026), live paper trades, and 20 years of SPY/VIX. For the 20-year runs, option prices are modeled from VIX. I checked the model against real chains on the same dates and it landed close, but it's untested in crashes, so read those numbers as rough.
1. "Don't sell premium when GEX is negative."
The trades it removed were profitable on average, and it would have said "no trade" on 15 of 20 days. In a negative-gamma market, the gate just means "sit out."
2. "Only sell when IV > realized vol."
Over 20 years (modeled prices), selling when IV was below realized did a bit worse (2–6 pts of risk). The sign is right, but it's within noise. The catch: which IV. With VIX it almost never triggered this fall. With front-week ATM IV it triggered constantly. Same rule, different filter.
3. "Flip and wall shifts show where price is going."
They matched SPY's next 10-day move 33–42% of the time. A coin does 50%. They're computed from current spot, so they follow price instead of leading it. They describe where price is, not where it's going.
4. "Put spreads are cheap because of skew, so that's an edge."
They really are cheap: ~40% less of their width than matching call spreads, using real option prices. But I ran them through 20 years of actual SPY moves, and they did ~12 pts worse than call spreads. Cheap was fair pricing for a market that drifts up, not a free lunch.
5. "Buy a 90-day strangle, sell weeklies against it."
Real chains, Aug–Oct: 9 of 10 six-week campaigns profitable. 20 years (modeled prices): negative on average in every period, profitable less than half the time. The long leg paid off in March 2020, but not in 2022 or Aug 2024. Three great months were just three great months.
What I didn't do
When an idea failed, I didn't tweak DTE, delta or width until it passed. That's curve-fitting, not testing.
What I took away
• Write the test before you run it. Some of these looked great until I did.
• Score a filter on what it removes.
• One fixed timestamp per signal. Never mix morning and close snapshots.
• A great quarter is a sample size of one regime.
Limits: the live data covers one market regime (mostly falling, negative gamma), the 20-year runs use modeled prices, and there's no historical GEX before July.
The question that matters: would I have added this rule before seeing the result, and would it survive a longer test? For these five: no.
Which popular rule should I test next?
Research on historical and modeled data. Not trading advice.