r/orchestra • u/Dry_Common828 • 16h ago
Dumb question from a musician's husband
Hi all
My wife is a retired orchestral violinist and I have no musical ability whatsoever.
I asked her this question recently and she said she didn't know, but if she'd asked it in a lecture she would have been told to leave - so perhaps you fine people can help?
I want to know why you have bars in sheet music, please.
I know that when you move from one bar to another nobody hears anything different - there's no extra count, no rest, no change, you just continue playing as if the end-of-bar divider wasn't in the score at all. So why put them in to begin with?
EDIT: Hi all, just wanted to say thanks for all your answers. Interesting to see there isn't a consensus on this!
To the people who asked, yes she has several ideas about why you need bars in addition to time signatures, but she doesn't enjoy explaining things that need me to have a sense of rhythm (which I do not have) or to be able to identify a beat in a song (which I cannot do) in order to understand the answers.
Much appreciated everyone!