I was reading today's FanGraphs mailbag where they mentioned that Shane Baz received the second biggest contract of any veteran with less than 5 career fWAR and it prompted me to look more deeply into his numbers. While it would seem that Baz had a breakout in 2026, going from 3.2 fWAR combined over his first four seasons to 3.4 fWAR this season alone, fWAR is based entirely on FIP and Fielding Independent Pitching is a very flawed metric.
What's ringing alarm bells in my head is that Baz went from having an above average strikeout rate with the Rays (24.5%) to being well below average with the Orioles (20.0%). Even more worryingly, his swinging strike dropped from 11.8% with the Rays to just 9.2% with the Orioles, a mark that placed him 40th out of 46 qualified starting pitchers in 2026. Baz's Z-Contact%, which is the percentage of pitches thrown within the strike zone that are put in play when the batter swings, went from 85.1% with the Rays to 90.1% with the Orioles, 41st out of 46 qualified starting pitchers.
Baz was never an elite strikeout pitcher but he used to miss bats at an above average rate, only to now be one of the worst in the majors in that respect. And it's not as if he compensated for this higher frequency of contact by inducing weak contact. Baz's soft contact percentage also dropped from 17.1% last season to 13.4% this season, ranking 38th out of 46 qualified starting pitchers.
The reason Baz had a strong FIP is that he somehow managed a 7.1% home run per flyball rate, second best in the major leagues behind Chris Sale. That's not something to be happy about because pitchers have very little control over their HR/FB%. Any pitcher substantially below 10% can be expected to see regression to that level the following season because that rate is most attributable to the batters they face and the park that they play in. So Baz was very lucky in 2026, not good. He gave up more contact than ever and harder contact, while inducing the lowest ground ball rate of his entire career, but for whatever reason not many of those fly balls went over the fence.
The issue is Baz's lack of a reliable breaking ball. After 2024, he replaced his slider with a cutter. The slider had been his best strikeout pitch but was also his biggest liability when he would hang it over the middle. The cutter gives up less hard contact than the slider did but it misses fewer bats.
His primary breaking ball then became his knuckle curveball, which was ok in 2025 (+0.39 runs better than average per pitch) but disastrous in 2026 (-0.77 runs worse than the average per pitch). The culprit there is much less drop than it had previously. The curve's induced vertical break was -14.6 in 2021, -13.2 in 2022, -12.9 in 2024, and -12.5 in 2025, but only -10.1 in 2026. That's nearly two and a half less inches of drop on the pitch this season. The same was true for the pitch's horizontal movement, as it went from an average of 8 inches over his first four seasons to just 5 inches of horizontal break in 2026. The spin rate also declined from 2699 rpm in 2025 to 2623 in 2026.
All of this is a longwinded explanation for why Shane Baz's Stuff+ fell from 105 last season when he was traded, five percent better than the league average, to 98 this season, two points below the league average. If Baz is to maintain an ERA in the low 4s instead of the high 4s, he's going to need to recover his old spin rate and movement on his curveball.