Best Picture:
Artificial – This is clearly gonna be Neon’s #1 priority. It’s in English, about an extremely baity and timely topic, directed by a former nominee, starring three previous acting nominees. Having a strong acting prospect and a decent release date also helps.
La Bola Negra – Its’ critics’ scores have plummeted a bit, but that shouldn’t really matter considering that audiences are loving it; it’s a tearjerking crowdpleaser about a socially relevant issue, and it’s backed by a great studio to boot.
The Debut – It gets a bit surreal in the second act, and a vocal minority will not be on the film’s wavelength, but it is still audience – friendly, and basically has a locked acting win from a previous winner, top 2 in a second acting category and Screenplay, and competitive in techs as well. Could there be a world where this misses? Yes, but I think it’s pretty safely in for now.
Dune: Part Three – I have no reason to doubt this for Picture; the main question is its package. Is it gonna get in with the bare minimum like Part Two did (Cinematography, Production Design, Visual Effects and Sound) and blank ATL, get all the tech nominations it could have like Part One did or will it also add acting nominations to its haul this time? The trailer seems to be a lot more character – driven (especially for Paul and Chani) than the previous two.
The Invite – I currently think this is A24’s #3, but it clearly has a ton of passion from its target audience, and I think it looks pretty strong in Screenplay and at least one acting category to make it in. It’s my no. 10, though.
The Odyssey – Do I even need to explain why this is in? It has some of the highest critic scores of the year, is an audience hit, has timely and relevant messages and has a massive ensemble to boot, some of whom are win – competitive. Plus that it’s most likely winning a lot of techs. ‘Nuff said.
Project Hail Mary – It’s one of the biggest audience hits and crowdpleasers of the year. It will have a solid BTL haul, Gosling has a strong shot in Actor and it’s pretty much locked in Adapted Screenplay. It’s in.
Wild Horse Nine – This hasn’t gotten as good reviews as I thought it needed to be win – competitive. But the reviews are still solid, Malkovich is a heavy frontrunner for Lead Actor and it’s win – competitive in Screenplay. It is in.
Wildwood – My biggest swing as of now. Aside from it’s heavy BTL potential, what is gonna be its biggest asset is that it’s (very firmly) not for kids. This will help it to break out of the “Animated Feature” box that voters put animated films in. It has fantastic scores across all four platforms (it’s a true four quadrant film) and a certain subset of voters will definitely put this in their top 3.
You Can See Everything – In theory, this looks bonkers. A documentary getting nominated, let alone top 3 in Picture? Pffft However, its critic scores, box office and momentum of word – of – mouth simply cannot be denied. It helps that it also has an acting contender to boot (I will come to that later).
Best Director:
Javier Ambrossi and Javier Calvo for La Bola Negra – Their vision and scope of the project is epic and ambitious, spanning multiple decades and timelines in a top 3 film. Exactly what the branch likes and goes for.
Jesse Eisenberg for The Debut – His staging and blocking in this film is very showy. Of the A24 slate, he definitely has a better chance than Wilde.
Denis Villenueve for Dune: Part Three – I know, I know. But I really think this will happen this time around. Not much to go off of except vibes.
Christopher Nolan for The Odyssey – Yeah. His vision, scope and blocking is why the film works.
Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim for You Can See Everything – Yes, they are ineligible at DGA and Globes, but if their film is really top 3, I don’t see how this isn’t happening. Their directorial choices are what makes the film.
Best Actor in a Leading Role:
Timothée Chalamet for Dune: Part Three – Predicting a Dune film for acting seems silly, but the trailer seems a lot more character driven than the first two. He’s screaming and shouting, he’s transformative and will have heavy makeup on him, and he’s in a stronger Picture contender than anyone else we are talking about for the fifth spot (Ippolito, Jackson, Pattinson, Turturro and Pascal, among others).
Matt Damon for The Odyssey – Aan overdue actor in the Picture frontrunner playing one of the most famous literary characters of all time and having multiple showy monologues but also getting to show off his movie star presence? I would be surprised if he isn’t in win contention, and he is absolutely locked for the nomination.
Ryan Gosling for Project Hail Mary – He’s the centrepiece of one of the biggest audience hits of the year. He’s in nearly every scene, and gets to do it all – he makes you cry, he makes you laugh. Maybe a Margot Robbie like snub could happen but I doubt it.
John Malkovich for Wild Horse Nine – A truly spectacular performance. He’s funny, heartbreaking, dramatic and sometimes even all of these at once. He is also overdue (kinda). I have him as the frontrunner for now.
Andrew Scott for Elsinore – So what if his film is bad? He is giving the type of baity performance the Academy gobbles up. He’s crying and he’s dying. He’s in.
Best Actress in a Leading Role:
Sandra Hüller for Rose – Truthfully, any of the three non – English highbrow performances can win the Globe Drama and get into the final slot. I’m currently predicting it to be Hüller because it’s a showier and baitier performance than the other two. She is transformative, has some good crying scenes in the back half of the film and has a lot of makeup on her. If she wins the Globe, she’s in. Add to that that she’s basically in every film this year, which boosts her profile.
Julianne Moore for The Debut – A locked win. She truly performs the entire spectrum of human emotions in this and some more. She’s funny, heartbreaking, dramatic, silly, explosive, show – stopping; all the adjectives you can think of. She’s in.
Inde Navarrette for Obsession – Still the most memorable performance of the year for a good chunk of the voters. The only issue is that I’m predicting her to be a lone nominee, and being that when this is your breakout role in a bloody horror film with little to no social messages and relevant themes is hard. Still, unless Obsession loses whatever momentum it has left, I think she’s in.
Olivia Wilde for The Invite – I don’t have her getting nominated for Director, which makes it easy to put her in here. It’s a showy performance in a film that’s (probably) getting Picture. She is most likely in.
Zendaya for Dune: Part Three – Pretty much the same reason why I have Chalamet in, except that Actress is a weaker field. They are beefing up Chani’s role a lot, and she has a lot of screaming and crying from the trailer. Add on to that that she’s having a banner year, and voters might want to reward her with her first Oscar nomination. It’s a risky prediction, but I’m fine taking this risk.
Best Actor in a Supporting Role:
Andrew Garfield for Artificial – He’s the closest to a lock we have in the category right now. He’s playing a real – life figure in a villainous role, and is doing a lot of showy acting based on what we see in the trailer.
Paul Giamatti for The Debut – He’s good in the film, but he’s so overshadowed by Moore that it’s easy to imagine voters who are not very high on the film itself leaving him out of the ballot. But he does have enough good moments to squeeze in there with the help of a certain subset of voters, IMO.
Guitarricadelafuente for La Bola Negra – After the triple whammy snubs of Chase Infiniti, Miles Caton and Odessa A’zion last year, it might seem a little foolish to go for a young actor in his debut role where he is a part of a massive ensemble. But when he’s borderline lead, has a ton of moments where he’s crying and also has a moment where he sings, suddenly it seems like he has a better chance. Netflix also almost never misses an acting nomination that they want to get.
John Leguizamo for The Odyssey – He’s a veteran who has never been nominated before playing a sympathetic old man in the Picture frontrunner where he has tons of makeup on him and has a solid moment where he breaks down sobbing, Yup, he’s in.
Sam Rockwell for Wild Horse Nine – A co – lead frauding himself into Supporting, with as many “actorly” moments as Malkovich has. The only scenario where I see him getting snubbed is if he just straight up has no passion, which, TBF, is not impossible.
Best Actress in a Supporting Role:
Penélope Cruz for La Bola Negra – She’s in a 10 minute role, yes, but she’s doing so much in it. She’s singing, dancing, has a conversation with our main character where she delivers a monologue which sums up the main themes of the film etc. It’s an extremely memorable performance where she shows her movie star charisma. Cruz is also personally campaigning more for La Bola Negra than for The Invite, and Netflix has gone all in on her as the face of the film, using posters with her character front – and – centre.
Penélope Cruz for The Invite – She’s also possibly the most memorable performance in another Best Picture nominee. She has an advantage here cause the role’s in English. People who are putting The Invite at no. 1 are also gonna put her for the film at no. 1.
Anne Hathaway for The Odyssey – Currently, I see very little preventing her from just sweeping. She has a sizable role in the Best Picture frontrunner, and most of her scenes are in extreme closeup of her face where she’s emoting, crying and snarling at her son/the suitors. She has also had a great year, and has been already doing the media rounds. Plus, little campaigning can also lead you to a win if you have the performance to back it up ala Sean Penn.
Samantha Morton for The Odyssey – A comeback performance for her, of sorts. She’s been going around in talk shows and interviews, talking about how she was blacklisted by Weinstein. Her scene in the film is memorable and her monologue also sums up one of the main themes of “the devastation of war” in the film, She should have little trouble getting in unless the film underperforms.
Amanda Seyfried for You Can See Everything – Since it seems like she is eligible, we might as well go the distance and predict her for the nomination. Probably one of the most fun and exciting parts of the film, she takes on the role of the audience surrogate in the second half. Her re – enactments are excellent, yes, but that’s not what the voters would vote her in for. They would vote her in for her confrontation with Billy at the dinner table, which is (probably) non – scripted. That makes me a bit worried as to what the voters would really consider “acting”, but I think a solid chunk of voters would consider her re – enactments to be enough.
Best Original Screenplay:
Artificial – From the trailer, it seems like the film will be filled with quips, one – liners and jokes that would land with the audience. It’s a satire; they almost always get in.
Club Kid – I can see the writers’ branch wanting to throw Firstman a nod as a “Congrats! Well done” type thing.
The Debut – The amount of worldbuilding that went into this film is staggering. Even aside from the screenplay of the real world, which is fucking amazing and filled with theatrical long monologues that appeals to the writers, building an entire fictional musical and having it be internally consistent is not a very easy thing to do. I would say that this is currently the frontrunner for the win.
Fjord – For all of the faults of the film, the screenplay is extremely dense, brings up a ton of interesting questions and tackles multiple themes together. Whether it does so successfully is another question but the writers’ branch will go out for European arthouse directors as sole Screenplay nominees.
Wild Horse Nine – Another one of Martin McDonagh’s trademark “tragicomic cynicism mixed with biting satire” films, but this one is a smidge weaker than Three Billboards and Banshees. It can still win due to his overdue narrative, but, yeah.
Best Adapted Screenplay:
La Bola Negra – An easy win, IMO. This really redefines the terms of what an “adaptation” is. It completes an unfinished play, then incorporates it into the structure of another play, and then successfully links both back to a third timeline, all while not missing a beat in terms of storytelling.
Dune: Part Three – Should be easily in, especially if they are changing the narrative of the book by tweaking some plot points.
The Invite – Has the vibes of a classic winner. It’s a chamber piece where characters deliver lengthy monologues and rant at each other for 2 hours straight. It’s just witty dialogue after witty dialogue.
The Odyssey – The screenplay is the weakest part of the film, but the adaptation is still good and solid enough that it should be in.
Project Hail Mary – No reason to doubt it.