r/pcmasterrace • • 16h ago • Bravo 9 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Meme/Macro We're waiting . . .

34k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

50

u/That_Service7348 15h ago • Bravo

Dude, do you know how much hardware has improved since 2018? Cause that's when the ps5 chip was made.

Ps5 pro is a little better, it's got the same 2018 cpu but a 2021 midrange gpu.

Either way, most PCs have more power. Hell, my laptop from 2022 is better than a PS5, and has a GPU on par with the pro but a significantly better CPU with significantly more RAM to keep stuff moving.

49

u/s8rlink 15h ago • Bravo

Do you remember RDR2 launch in PC? I am unsure if everyone saying oh yeah I’ll run this 1440p 60 fps no problem with a mid tier rig will be surprised. I still remember the 2080 had a hard time running a stable 60fps and it wasn’t until the 3090 that 4k 60 stable was achieved 

16

u/testcaseseven Desktop 15h ago

RDR2 was the game that made me upgrade my PC again lol. It was heavier than anything else at the time

1

u/FluteGunner 2h ago

Same actually. I started playing it on a 2080 Super and wasn't happy with the perf. Bought a 4090 and played it at 4k.

9

u/fafarex 12h ago

RDR2 came out at the end of a big period of CPU stagnation when zen2 was out, if you had a 4 to 6 years old CPU that was quite normal to required an upgrade.

Not sur it will be that drastic with gta6

1

u/alman12345 4h ago

I ran RDR2 on a 1660 Ti laptop on high settings over 60FPS, it had a 6 core 9th Gen i7 too. This was about a half year after release.

15

u/ElPomidor 15h ago • Bravo

Search which desktop CPU is equivalent to the PS5 Pro CPU, then search which CPUs can double its performance in gaming scenarios, aka going from 30 to 60 FPS

So probably 7800X3D will be bare minimum for around 60 fps

6

u/That_Service7348 12h ago

Oh, so just the go-to gaming CPU that everyone gets? Neat.

5

u/SwordOfJiang 5900x 9070xt 9h ago

Its not a 1 to 1 comparison though. The playstation's have a pitiful cooler and like 200 watts power draw. The silicon might be better but its using like half as much power as the proper desktop version.

1

u/petrolhead0387 5900X | Red Devil 7900XTX | Vengeance 32GB 3600MHZ | X570 A-Pro 4h ago

Exactly, people are forgetting about the many variables in PCs. Cooling, OC, RAM expansion, faster SSDs, ReBAR, software optimisation, being able to finely tune the game to your own preferences. Like you said it's not a 1-1 comparison, consoles are locked to what the developer wants them to play at, whereas PCs are able to look under the hood and tweak the whole thing.

5

u/Finwe 14h ago

Generally games with heavy sims going on benefit greatly from having more cache and better memory latency, which desktop cpu's have in spades over the consoles. It may perform a lot better than people are thinking.

4

u/personpilot 15h ago

You’re actually fried in the brain if you think a CPU needs to be more than twice as good as a ps5pro to get double performance. It’s not a 1:1 ratio 😂😂🤣

15

u/ElPomidor 15h ago

I know it's not a 1:1 ratio. Usually on PC it's far worse and you need more than twice the powerful CPU to double the performance (due to poor optimization most often)

I'm also talking about strictly CPU bound scenarios

3

u/Snooze36 14h ago

Lol he did not read and comprehend.

1

u/alman12345 4h ago

If the GPU is the bottleneck it's easy to solve, but since it's the CPU it's tougher. Going off what we know from the unlocked FPS post about the Xbox Series X on the GTA6unmoderated sub the 3.8GHz 8 Core Zen 2 is capable of upper 40s to mid 50s in FPS, so a Zen 5 9800x3d whose IPC is already 156% that of the XSX, whose clock speed is over 20% higher in boost, and whose 3D v-cache obliterates the console garbage it's going to be over 100 easily.

1

u/I_dont_want_to_pee 2h ago

It dosen't work like that if something is double better in benchamrks dosen't mean there will be double fps.

1

u/spookynutz 13h ago

You're reasoning is sound, but the conclusion your drawing doesn't really reflect real-world scenarios. CPU scaling largely depends on the workload across all of the hardware. Performance in purely CPU-driven scenarios does need to be twice as good to double rendering performance. Typically more than twice as good, because work is rarely distributed evenly across threads.

However, the above assumes a game that is currently and forever CPU bound. Instead of returning all functions in 33.3ms (30FPS), I must now return them in 16.6ms (60FPS). In that specific scenario you need double the performance, but that is not how modern games work.

In a real-world scenario, a ceiling typically exists at which additional precision no longer conveys any measurable benefit. For example, if NPCs and vehicles are pathing 30 times a second (capping your framerate), your game isn't necessarily improved by pathing them 60 times a second. In that situation, you would decouple simulation from rendering and just leave it as is. It has now reached a threshold beyond which additional frames are no longer dependent on a better CPU or any other hardware. You ultimately reach a point where the bottleneck shifts to another component.

In practice, that means for a game like GTAVI, you could have a PC that is equivalent to the PS5 Pro in every way, only with a 10x faster CPU, yet it only results in an additional 10FPS, because performance is now constrained by something else. Graphics processing, memory bandwidth, memory speed, storage bandwidth, etc.

-1

u/fafarex 12h ago

You're assuming that the game will reach another bottleneck on a balanced configuration, we don't know that yet and some game are very much CPU heavy first, the best recent example being space marine 2.

1

u/December_Hemisphere 11h ago

Ps5 pro is a little better, it's got the same 2018 cpu but a 2021 midrange gpu.

The GPU is the real upgrade on the pro. The 4nm AMD Viola GPU was released on November 7, 2024. It's about 45% faster rendering with upgraded ray tracing and AI upscaling.

1

u/I_dont_want_to_pee 2h ago

But not enough this is a hard game even if your pc would be triple the performacne of ps5 it would be hard to even get 90.

1

u/Federal-Sympathy3869 2h ago

Most PCs are older than the PS5 and are low to mid range, you think people buy a new high-end PC every 2 years or what? Go to a PC repair store and see the PCs we repair, or even better just go to a PC shop and see what they sell. Most people buy low to mid-low range computers because they don't need them for gaming. You are all delulu.

0

u/Gloomy_Efficiency680 9h ago

2022 laptops so RTX 20 or 30 series then, and non of them can match PS5 Pro, which is equivalent of 7700XT. Strongest 30 series laptop is 3080Ti that's thing translate into desktop is 4060Ti at max