r/pcmasterrace • u/xw1y • 2d ago
Story On Monday Proshop offered to return my RTX 5090 FE. Today my girlfriend was told their repair partner destroyed or discarded it.
TL;DR: Sent my RTX 5090 FE to Proshop under warranty in September and asked for repair or replacement, not a refund. On 6 Nov I told them in writing to keep the card and not dispose of it, and to do nothing irreversible without my written OK. On Monday 16 Nov they offered on the phone to return the card or refund it. Today my girlfriend was told by phone that their service partner destroyed or discarded it. Proshop hasn't confirmed that in writing.
In September my 5090 Founders Edition started dropping clocks and showing weird power readings. It still worked, just not like it should. It's under warranty, so I sent it to Proshop. I took photos of the card in its box before sending it in. I wanted it repaired, not refunded, and I told them that in writing.
On 9 October they mailed me that it was at an external workshop and would be sent back to me as soon as it came back from there. Then weeks without a diagnosis.
On 6 November they wrote that repair or replacement "seems" not possible, so I'd probably get the purchase price back. I answered the same day: keep my card with all its parts, don't do anything irreversible without my written OK, and tell me what the workshop found.
On Monday, 16 November, they offered us on the phone: the card back, or the money. That evening I mailed three questions before choosing. No answer.
Today my girlfriend called them again. She was told their service partner had destroyed or discarded the card, and the guy on the phone said himself that it should never have happened. She cried after that call. She'd been the one making these calls to get an answer.
If what she was told is true, the card is gone. Proshop hasn't explained what happened, there's no workshop report, and the refund they're offering is the February 2025 price, 2,369 euro. The FE listings I've found are asking around 7,000 euro (asking prices, not sales).
I'm the second owner and have the original Proshop invoice. I've submitted a complaint to Thuiswinkel.org, the Dutch webshop complaint body.
I have photos of the card before I sent it. I never thought I'd need them to help establish what happened to it.
Edit: I will be taking legal action and keep you updated
Girlfriends comment about the situation
EDIT 2: Timeline, photos of the card before I sent it, the mails and the invoice. The mails are in Dutch, the captions summarize them in English. Names, addresses and all order, invoice, claim and tracking numbers are blacked out. The card being destroyed or discarded is what my girlfriend was told on the phone. Proshop hasn't confirmed that in writing yet.











