r/pcmasterrace • • 2d ago

Story On Monday Proshop offered to return my RTX 5090 FE. Today my girlfriend was told their repair partner destroyed or discarded it.

2.2k Upvotes

TL;DR: Sent my RTX 5090 FE to Proshop under warranty in September and asked for repair or replacement, not a refund. On 6 Nov I told them in writing to keep the card and not dispose of it, and to do nothing irreversible without my written OK. On Monday 16 Nov they offered on the phone to return the card or refund it. Today my girlfriend was told by phone that their service partner destroyed or discarded it. Proshop hasn't confirmed that in writing.

In September my 5090 Founders Edition started dropping clocks and showing weird power readings. It still worked, just not like it should. It's under warranty, so I sent it to Proshop. I took photos of the card in its box before sending it in. I wanted it repaired, not refunded, and I told them that in writing.

On 9 October they mailed me that it was at an external workshop and would be sent back to me as soon as it came back from there. Then weeks without a diagnosis.

On 6 November they wrote that repair or replacement "seems" not possible, so I'd probably get the purchase price back. I answered the same day: keep my card with all its parts, don't do anything irreversible without my written OK, and tell me what the workshop found.

On Monday, 16 November, they offered us on the phone: the card back, or the money. That evening I mailed three questions before choosing. No answer.

Today my girlfriend called them again. She was told their service partner had destroyed or discarded the card, and the guy on the phone said himself that it should never have happened. She cried after that call. She'd been the one making these calls to get an answer.

If what she was told is true, the card is gone. Proshop hasn't explained what happened, there's no workshop report, and the refund they're offering is the February 2025 price, 2,369 euro. The FE listings I've found are asking around 7,000 euro (asking prices, not sales).

I'm the second owner and have the original Proshop invoice. I've submitted a complaint to Thuiswinkel.org, the Dutch webshop complaint body.

I have photos of the card before I sent it. I never thought I'd need them to help establish what happened to it.

Edit: I will be taking legal action and keep you updated
Girlfriends comment about the situation

EDIT 2: Timeline, photos of the card before I sent it, the mails and the invoice. The mails are in Dutch, the captions summarize them in English. Names, addresses and all order, invoice, claim and tracking numbers are blacked out. The card being destroyed or discarded is what my girlfriend was told on the phone. Proshop hasn't confirmed that in writing yet.

1. Timeline. Lines starting with Phone are what we were told on calls. The rest is in the mails and the invoice below
2. My card in its box before I sent it in
3. Same card, ports side. The phone next to it shows Monday 7 Sep
4. 5 Sep: warranty claim created for the RTX 5090 FE
5. 9 Sep: Proshop noted that I want repair or replacement. My mail from 5 Sep is under it: I don't accept a refund while repair or replacement is possible
6. 23 Sep: Proshop confirms they received the card
7. 7 Oct: Proshop says they asked their supplier for repair or replacement "because you said you don't agree to getting the purchase price back". My mail asking for an update is under it
8. 9 Oct: card sent to an external workshop. They'll mail me once it's back and "it will then be sent back to you as soon as possible"
9. 6 Nov: Proshop says the 30 day limit was well exceeded, repair or replacement "seems" not possible and I'll "probably" get the purchase price back. My notice of default from 5 Nov is under it
10. 6 Nov, my reply: no refund as a settlement, and I want the workshop report. My choice stays repair or an equivalent 5090. If they can't supply one I'm open to an offer on a new 5090 with a discount that reflects my card. Keep my card with all its parts, don't dispose of it, nothing irreversible without my written OK (rest of the mail cropped)
11. 19 Nov: their mail right after the call. They send the Thuiswinkel complaint link and ask where to transfer the money. My 3 questions from 16 Nov are quoted under it, never answered. This mail says nothing about what happened to the card
12. Invoice 5 Feb 2025: 1,957.85 + 21% VAT = 2,369 euro for the card (2,377.99 total with shipping)

r/pcmasterrace • • 4d ago

Story I could cry...

1.5k Upvotes

Just a short vent, my girlfriend was so happy to clean the gaming room and rearrange. Then she dumped my 5080 gaming rig right off a 20 inch shelf thing onto the floor. No more video output, or even power to mouse/keyboard. CPU indicator light on mobo, and the other computer in the house is too old to try and start swapping anything back and fourth to troubleshoot.

Update/clarification, lots of comments, suggestions and commiserations. This started as a "short vent" but I'll elaborate.

When it fell, it basically tipped and landed flat on the glass side (glass didn't break)

I did tear down and rebuild it completely to no avail. The only thing physically distinguishable is that the graphics card locking mechanism did suffer damage, and I'm betting there's more damage than what I can see.

The content of fast food wrappers, empty big gulp cups, and pee-bottles in the room was actually 0%. It was just normal cleaning but she got it in her head to rearrange the room while I was at work. Thus moving my PC, in hindsight, to a shit location, which made a small bump become such a big problem.

To everyone saying rip-gf. No domestic violence has occurred. It was an accident, but I retain my right to be pissed, depressed, and disappointed.

Now I'm sitting at work torn between letting her take it to a repair place, or me running to microcenter after work and praying a motherboard will fix it.

r/pcmasterrace • • Oct 13 '26 Bravo

Story It finally happened.

Post image
5.1k Upvotes

28 years later, I finally win my first giveaway; and it’s for this beast!

r/pcmasterrace • • 12d ago Bravo

Story Wife got me a CPU for my birthday thanks to Ai

Post image
7.9k Upvotes

I got one of the Asus crosshair anniversary motherboards a while ago for nostalgia sake but had a 14700k build and was in no rush to build out a system with it.

My birthday was on Sunday and the wife surprised me with a 9950x3d2.

Well thanks to AI she took a photo of the motherboard box and asked what the best CPU was for it haha.

Nerd maths says free CPU 🤷‍♀️

r/pcmasterrace • • 14d ago

Story 4000$ system for only 200$!!!

Thumbnail
gallery
4.4k Upvotes

Okay, I know this may seem like clickbait but I swear to God I just came across the deal of a lifetime and took it by the neck

So I was out with some friends when we decided to hit up our local game x change so I go around looking and then I see this BEAST off a computer and I see the price "200$" so I politely asked if they could hook it up and see if it boots (they even looked at it saw the price and ACKNOWLEDGED it was improperly labeled, called there manager and STILL HONORED THE STICKER PRICE) and it BOOTED then I went into the bio so look at some of the specs

THE SPECS ARE INSANE

Hyte y70 case

Asus prime z790 wifi mobo

2tb tforce ssd

32 GBS of DDR5 RAM at 6000mhz

Intel i9 14900KF

Rtx 4070 ti SUPER

AND IT WORKED FLAWLESSLY the only thing that I had trouble with was the Bluetooth (I just bought a dongle and now it works FLAWLESSLY)

But on that note if anyone knows any cases that fit an atx motherboard and power supply and a 360 mm aio I could I could change into that would be great (the smaller the better)

Also here's a pcpartpicker of the builds worth in current times https://pcpartpicker.com/list/JmhXMF

r/pcmasterrace • • 17d ago

Story "Initial Review" after going to PC from base PS5 Console! (PC not pictured because majority here don't even like pre-builts, but here's my initial experience anyway)

32 Upvotes

Same controller, same favorite game, same internet and equipment, same play style. -Bro, I knew something was holding me back!

I stood up FAR too many hours past my bed time for work after histerically laughing during the first 20 minutes of playing my game with my new prebuilt.

The MOMENT I finished my FIRST match after I saw my stats, I thought it was a fluke.  And usually, when you do well, you have to play a while longer before you're back to bad matches.. but not this night.  Hours later, one after the other, consistent frames, consistent wins. WTF is this lol

Now, I'll wait until the weekend when more people are on to see if I'm crazy or not, but after my experience on the first day... Man... I KNEW the performance of my console was holding me back from playing just a little bit better! 

I mean, I knew PC's were better in performance but not THIS much better!? Holy balls I should've went PC earlier instead of being stubborn for so long! 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

r/pcmasterrace • • Aug 22 '26 Mindblown

Story Tried selling my old 3600X to recoup costs after upgrading. Buyer filed two fake claims, returned it obliterated, and eBay's bot system almost forced the refund.

Post image
11k Upvotes

So I upgraded my rig recently and listed my old Ryzen 5 3600X to recoup a bit of cash from ultilizing my AM4 ugrade path, with today's hardware prices what they are. Tested, 100% pristine pins, packaged safely in a clamshell.

What followed was my crash course in how return fraud works on used hardware:

  • Act I (Fake Non-Delivery): Buyer claimed the package was never delivered. As soon as tracking proved it was sitting on their porch, they instantly changed their story.
  • Act II (Installation Blunder): They attempted installation, leaned a few outer corner pins, and opened an "Arrived Damaged/Not as described" case with photos showing a handful of bent pins. Classic "hope the seller waives return shipping so I get a free CPU" move.
  • Act III (Scorched-Earth Return): I forced the return shipping anyway. Thinking I may have to eat the shipping costs but I can probably fix and resell this at least. Before mailing it back, they went full spite mode: scraping, gouging the PCB, denting the IHS, and raking most of the pins into a solid flattened pancake.
  • Act IV (The Bot System): The second tracking showed "delivered" on the return shipping eBay's automated system attempted to force a full refund out of my account for the item. Only option the system would present to resolve the case.

Because eBay's automated system defaults to forcing a full refund from the seller the second tracking shows a return was delivered, I had to reach out to an actual rep to override it. Even after reviewing the proof of damage, eBay still ended up refunding the buyer out of their own pocket, completely validating the buyer's behavior.

UPDATE: Video clip for clarity https://imgur.com/a/JK1PruX