r/piano • • 6d ago

Weekly Thread 'There are no stupid questions' thread - Monday, November 16, 2026

7 Upvotes

Please use this thread to ask ANY piano-related questions you may have!

Also check out our FAQ for answers to common questions.

*Note: This is an automated post. See previous discussions here.


r/piano • • 14h ago

🙋Question/Help (Beginner) 33m - struggling to read notes, when does it get easier

Post image
266 Upvotes

Hi everyone

Been doing piano now for about 2 months. Having lessons once a week during school terms for 30 minutes and practising 30 minutes most nights. But sometimes business and family can interrupt that.

For context im 33 and decided to do piano lessons with my daughter (who's being doing it much longer than me) to show her that her big builder dad can do things other than go to the gym

But man im seriously struggling. Im doing Alfred's all in one course and up to this sheet Music but I seriously struggle with reading notes on the sheet and recall

Do I need to go back to the beginning and try again so my recall and reading is better? Or just keep pushing on and it'll come naturally?


r/piano • • 3h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) Do I sound self-taught? (Chopin Nocturne Op. 27 No. 2)

31 Upvotes

I've been teaching myself piano for the past 6 months and have learned a bit of this piece (along with some of the other Chopin nocturnes and preludes). Do I sound particularly bad? What kind of things would a teacher help me with? I also feel like the FP-10 keyboard action is affecting my playing. It feels sluggish and heavy compared to the few grand pianos I've played, so I've been considering the Kawai CA401. If anyone has thoughts on the action, I would appreciate that as well. Thanks!


r/piano • • 5h ago

☺️My Performance (No Critique Please!) chopins most ‘heroic’ ending - Polonaise, Op. 53

18 Upvotes

lots of energy, but at the cost of inaccuracies, however i don’t care as i play for my own enjoyment first!


r/piano • • 15h ago

🗣️Let's Discuss This "Prodigy" shouldn't be the default label for every kid who plays piano

43 Upvotes

I love watching kids learn piano, but the word "prodigy" is on soo many video titles lately and it's starting to get to me.

Being young and play something doesn't make you a prodigy, and that's totally okay.

A true prodigy performs at an extraordinary level well beyond their age. So please stop calling your 5-year-old one when they're playing half the notes of a Suzuki Book 1 piece with mistakes. I don't blame the kid, they're just learning, and that's great.

What bothers me is the label, especially when the same kid is a piano, singing and violin prodigy, even for the thing they struggle with most. Maybe it's for engagement, maybe people truly believe it, but at 5 everything counts as "prodigy" and at 15 nothing is enough, which can really break someone if they don't become incredibly good as they grow up.

The truly extraordinary kids, like the seven-year-old who played the thirds etude and got accepted into Curtis this March, never have the word in their titles, because the playing speaks for itself. I still don't love the label, since it erases the immense effort behind that level, but with her at least it doesn't leave me with that uncomfortable feeling in my stomach.

I've also met people with natural talent who never got anywhere because they lacked discipline.

So, kids don't need a forced "prodigy" tag for us to appreciate their progress, and a lot of us just enjoy watching people learn and grow.

Just needed to vent, I guess


r/piano • • 3h ago

🗣️Let's Discuss This Discussion about metronome use

4 Upvotes

Hi! Let me start by saying Im a firm believer in using a metronome. That being said, I also find when I use the metronome musicality goes out the window. When I don't use it, I find my playing to be more musical. So, does that mean too much metronome use is possible to the point of drumming musicality out of a student?


r/piano • • 4h ago

🎶Other Portable piano

4 Upvotes

My bf travels all the time and he started playing piano. I am considering to buy a portable piano for him and I am not knowledgeable in this area. My criteria is that he travels with carry on and it must support headphones so he can play in the hotel. As it is a birthday gift, it can be expensive, but I'm looking for good quality worth money and light options. I've seen Yamaha PSS A50 and Yamaha reface CP. which one would you recommend or any other option?

Also let me know if this is a terrible gift idea!


r/piano • • 53m ago

🗣️Let's Discuss This Do you believe ANYONE, with enough practice, can eventually learn Gaspard?

2 Upvotes

Would ANYONE, if they worked hard and long enough, be able to learn and perform Gaspard in your opinion. (Assuming large enough hands and no major disability.)


r/piano • • 9h ago

🎶Other I think this is amazing. Sarah Nicoll's lightweight acoustic vertical grand piano.

Thumbnail
kcl.ac.uk
10 Upvotes

Crossposting this here as suggested.


r/piano • • 9h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) Bach WTC 2 - no.2 c minor

9 Upvotes

☠️☠️☠️☠️


r/piano • • 1h ago

🎶Other Where to donate piano?

2 Upvotes

I currently have an old baby grand that is no longer needed, and transporting would cost more than it’s really worth to try to sell it anywhere but super locally. Do churches and schools still use pianos or has everything gone digital these days? Is it destined for the wood and scrap pile? What have yall done with an old piano?


r/piano • • 4h ago

🎶Other Move a piano in winter?

3 Upvotes

I have an upright Kawaii that is presently sitting in a large house. My husband and I just finished building a lodge on the same property (we recently moved from the EU to the UK). He wants to move my piano next week, when there will be three men capable of lifting it (he did it before with just one other person). They plan on using a motorcycle lift to get it out of the house and into a van, drive the van back to where our house is and roll it into the lodge using a ramp.

My question isn't about their method. My question is about the wisdom of trying to move a piano in the winter -- it will be "outside" in temperatures likely in between 40 to 50 F (5-10C), for at least 10 minutes. Is it okay? Or should he wait until the weather is warmer next year?


r/piano • • 2h ago

🎵My Original Composition Fantasy in Ab Major Coda

2 Upvotes

Finally finished the ending of my piece!! LMK what u think. I’ll post the full thing once I finish the sheets (transcribing is so hard idk what I’m doing 😭)

I’m still editing it here and there so if you have any feedback or suggestions please lmk!!!


r/piano • • 19h ago

🔌Digital Piano Question I need to know what this piece is

45 Upvotes

I'm very new to piano and im just getting into it. I found this video on Tiktok. The piece sounds so amazing. I check the comments and its just all trolls putting misleading answers. Does ANYONE know this piece?

https://www.tiktok.com/@rlt_piano/video/7688460404057525537?q=RLT%20piano&t=1795318155655


r/piano • • 17h ago

🙋Question/Help (Beginner) Is this physically possible without giant hands? Key is B major

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/piano • • 5h ago

🧑‍🏫Question/Help (Intermed./Advanced) Other works of similar scope and technical difficulty to Chopin's Piano Sonata No. 3?

3 Upvotes

I am considering adding Chopin's Piano Sonata No. 3 (B minor Op. 58) to my repertoire. For those who have played it, what is another piece of similar scope and technical difficulty that you feel comes closest to it? My best frames of reference are Beethoven's Op. 53, 57, 109, and 110. I have played Chopin's E major scherzo too. Thanks


r/piano • • 16h ago

🗣️Let's Discuss This Nervous because of Beginner Songs

22 Upvotes

I have a piano recital tomorrow and I’m a 15 year old beginner in a list of like 8 year old piano prodigies. I’m crazy nervous and the songs I learned with my teacher are making me even more nervous. The songs she chose are “Ground Music” (From the Super Mario Franchise) and “River Flows in You”. I practiced a lot but it feels really embarrassing to be playing those after someone younger than me plays an etude or something. Anyone else have a similar experience as me?

I’ll update after performance if anyone cares 😭

Update: Bombed Super Mario. Bombed as in I blanked out three quarters through the song. However, my parents said I nailed River Flows in You so Ig thats a win?

A ten year old boy went before me and played the pirates of the Caribbean theme song almost perfectly and I know I shouldn’t compare after reading the comments but, boy, that was both humbling and humiliating.

Anyways, it was definitely an experience I won’t live down yet at the same time, I think I want to continue doing recitals 🥲


r/piano • • 3h ago

🙋Question/Help (Beginner) Wrote this at 1am

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/piano • • 7h ago

🔌Digital Piano Question Digital Piano with hard cover, one that can second as a writing table/desk when not in use

4 Upvotes

Can't seem to find a nice digital piano with a hard cover - other than lower grade brands from Amazon like Donner and Strich .

I have a small house, and would like a weighted digital piano that has a hard cover so that I can use it as a writing desk when not playing the piano.

Any suggestions?


r/piano • • 7h ago

🎼Useful Resource (learning aid, score, etc.) Wurlitzer Player Piano

4 Upvotes

This is my 1967 Wurlitzer player piano, when I bought it the keys would stick but only when a roll was being played in it, if I played it normally the keys were fine so I opened it up to see what the issue was and thought I would share with everyone, if anyone else has a similar piano maybe this could help. VIDEO OF IT PLAYING IN COMMENTS


r/piano • • 40m ago

🗣️Let's Discuss This Reading music vs Developing your ear?

0 Upvotes

I am NOT suggesting or saying 1 is better than the other!

But if you have to make an definitive choice over which skill is more important to your development. Which one would you pick and why?

I would take learning by ear! Lead sheets are great, but most situations I am in, the sheet is an mp3 for a co-composer, and that doesnt have a lead sheet!


r/piano • • 4h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) Arvo Pärt -- Für Alina

2 Upvotes

Spent 2 hours studying this piece. Way harder than it looks, how could I have interpreted it better?


r/piano • • 1h ago

🗣️Let's Discuss This Why did you choose a digital slab or furniture piano?

0 Upvotes

I’ll be getting a digital piano pretty soon and just wondered what draws people to different form factors (mainly digitals, acoustics aren’t really slabbed unless it’s an E-piano on bells). I’m very biased toward furniture pianos myself and will have to go for a slab instead due to moving and space confined to under my desk.

From what I’ve read on and experienced, the differences I can note come down to:

Furniture Pros
-Better built in sounds & sound system
-Stand included
-Higher end actions
-Triple pedal often included
Furniture Cons
-Greater sound transfer through the floor
-Greater weight, restrictions on moving
-Price
-Fixed keybed height

Slab Pros
-Portability
-Ergonomic accommodation, flexible positioning
-Space for additional accessories
-Price
Slab Cons
-Lower-mid end action designs
-Lacking triple pedal inclusion often
-Requires accessory stands, pedals, etc to use
-Lower end internal sounds & sound system

This isn’t a full list, but it serves food for thought; Given individual circumstances, why did you choose your respective form factor?


r/piano • • 5h ago

🤔Misc. Inquiry/Request Pianno to save?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Hello everyone. Keeping things short, my parents have a piano, that they want to chop into pieces. And i really, really don't like the idea. It's an N9(?) Sponnagel, serial number 13217, so it's around 100years old, if I'm getting my info correct. So the thought of it getting destroyed just hurts me. It's not in perfect shape. Definitely need new strings and some hammers are broken. But still. So my question is, is it worth saving? I'm not sure, how to even tell, if the condition is horrible, or just in need of some love.