r/planetarymagic • u/CliffordHLow • 8h ago
Mother-Taught
=== MOTHER-TAUGHT ===
The Women of the Schools
Women taught in the schools this art descends from, and sometimes they ran them. For most of a thousand years those schools took that for granted, and the record of it is better than most people in this field have been told.
Many of the people now coming into the Science of Images are women, and some of them have asked, fairly, where the women are in a lineage whose famous names are nearly all men. They have been in it from the beginning, at the root of the Pythagorean school, in the chair at Alexandria, and at the handing-on of the one part of the tradition that could not be learned from a book. In this essay I've kept to what the sources say and named them, and where legends have grown up around a few of these women I've given only what can be shown.
== At the Root ==
Iamblichus tells of a Pythagorean woman named Timycha who bit off her own tongue rather than tell a tyrant why the school would not eat beans. Secrecy was expected of the women of this school as much as the men, so the women must have been trusted with what it kept hidden.
Aristoxenus of Tarentum, writing in the fourth century before Christ, within living memory of the last Pythagoreans, said that Pythagoras "got most of his moral doctrines from the Delphic priestess Themistoclea." Diogenes Laertius repeats it twice, and Porphyry has the same woman under another name. Nothing else is known of her, but the tradition's own account was that the ethics of the first school of this philosophy came from a woman at Delphi, and that Pythagoras said so.
Porphyry says Pythagoras taught "not only men, but also women, among whom was a specially illustrious person named Theano." The sources can't agree whether Theano was his wife or his pupil, or whether there were two of her, but they credit her with commentaries, sayings, a poem and a treatise on virtue. Iamblichus closes his roll of the school with a separate list of "the most illustrious Pythagorean women," sixteen names from Croton to Sparta. It is the oldest list of women philosophers in the Western record, and nobody who reads it can go on thinking the school was a men's club with a founder's wife attached.
The school also made a woman the keeper of its books. A letter quoted by Diogenes Laertius says Pythagoras left his memoirs to his daughter Damo with a charge never to let them out of the house, and that "although she could have sold the writings for a large sum of money, she would not, but reckoned poverty and her father's solemn injunctions more precious than gold, for all that she was a woman." The letter is a later fabrication, like most Pythagorean letters. The picture is still the school's own picture of itself.
Letters and short treatises survive under the names of Theano, Myia, Melissa, Phintys, Perictione and others, on how a wife should bear a husband's infidelity, raise children and keep a household. The letters were printed in Greek at Venice in 1499 and the Renaissance read them as the real thing, but the prevailing view is that they were written centuries later under famous women's names, probably by men, as moral instruction for women. Sarah Pomeroy argued in 2013 that some are what they claim to be, and she may be right about a few. But nobody can show a surviving sentence by a Pythagorean woman of the sixth century. What can be shown is that women writing philosophy under Pythagorean names was an ancient tradition that never stopped, and that Porphyry in the third century could still say of Arignote, Pythagoras's daughter, that her Pythagorean writings "are still extant."
== The Woman Who Taught Socrates About the Daimons ==
The most famous woman in Plato is the one whose existence is least certain. In the Symposium Socrates says that everything he knows about love he learned from Diotima of Mantinea, a woman "skilled in this and in many other matters," who once, by prescribing sacrifices, held off the plague at Athens for ten years. Most scholars think Plato made her up; the name means "honored by Zeus," and Mantinea sounds like mantis, the seer. A few have defended her. Whether she lived or not, the speech Plato gave her contains the doctrine this art depends on.
Socrates asks what Love is, if not a god, and she answers, "A great spirit, Socrates: for the whole of the spiritual is between divine and mortal." Asked what power such a spirit has, she says it is "interpreting and transporting human things to the gods and divine things to men; entreaties and sacrifices from below, and ordinances and requitals from above," and then, "Through it are conveyed all divination and priestcraft concerning sacrifice and ritual and incantations, and all soothsaying and sorcery. God with man does not mingle: but the spiritual is the means of all society and converse of men with gods."
That is the doctrine of the daimon as the go-between, and it is the doctrine of the Ladder of Beings, of the Companion, and of the talisman's tenant. Apuleius built his On the God of Socrates on it; Plotinus took it up in his treatise on Love; Proclus made it systematic; and Ficino, when he wrote his commentary on the Symposium in 1469, put Diotima's speech at the center of the Platonic revival that produced the Three Books of Life. Whether or not she lived, Plato chose to have the Athenians hear the theory of the daimons from a woman and a priestess, and every later Platonist who used the theory knew where it came from.
Plato did the same thing in the Menexenus, where Socrates credits his rhetoric to Aspasia, who he says trained Pericles too. And outside Plato's school, in the same generation, Aristippus of Cyrene trained his daughter Arete in his philosophy, and she trained her son, who was known thereafter as Aristippus Metrodidaktos, "mother-taught." The Cyrenaic school passed from father to daughter to grandson, and nobody in antiquity found that strange enough to remark on, except to give the boy his nickname.
== The Households of the Platonists ==
When Porphyry wrote his life of his master Plotinus he recorded, without emphasis, that "several women were greatly attached to him." They were Gemina, in whose house in Rome Plotinus lived, her daughter of the same name, and Amphiclea, and he says that "all three devoted themselves assiduously to philosophy." He adds that dying men and women of rank left their children and their property in Plotinus's care, so that the house of the greatest philosopher of the third century was full of wards and widows studying the Enneads as they were written. Porphyry himself, late in life, married a widow named Marcella with seven children, and wrote her a letter that survives. He tells her he chose her because "your disposition was suited to true philosophy," and near the end he says the thing the whole lineage had been assuming and nobody had quite written down, "Neither trouble yourself much whether you be male or female in body, nor look upon yourself as a woman." The road to the gods in his philosophy ran through the same discipline for both, and he said so to his wife.
== Hypatia ==
Hypatia of Alexandria has been so much written about, and so badly, that the first service is to say what the sources actually contain, and only two of them count for much. Socrates Scholasticus, a Christian church historian writing within a generation of her death, says she was the daughter of the mathematician Theon and "made such attainments in literature and science as to far surpass all the philosophers of her own time," that "having succeeded to the school of Plato and Plotinus" she taught publicly to whoever came, and that magistrates called on her for advice. The Suda, drawing on Damascius, lists her works, a commentary on Diophantus, one on the Conics of Apollonius, and an astronomical canon, and says that "putting on the philosopher's cloak, although a woman," she expounded Plato and Aristotle in public. Her father's commentary on the third book of Ptolemy's Almagest carries in its heading the words "the edition having been checked by the philosopher Hypatia, my daughter," which is the only sentence about her that we can be fairly sure was written while she lived.
Her pupils were many and some were Christians. The Christian historian does not describe a pagan martyr killed by Christians for her paganism. Among them was Synesius of Cyrene, later a bishop, whose letters to her survive. He addresses her as "mother, sister, teacher, and withal benefactress." He sent her his book On Dreams, which I wrote about in The Grammar of Sleep, with a letter saying it had been "completed, the whole of it, in a single night" at a vision's command, and asked her whether it should be published. He asked her to have a hydroscope made for him and described the instrument. And in his little treatise on the astrolabe he says the design was his own, "including all that she, my most reverend teacher, helped to contribute." The claim that Hypatia invented the astrolabe rests on that one remark, and it is wrong, since the instrument goes back to Hipparchus and Ptolemy and her father wrote on it. What Synesius says is that she taught him enough of it to build one. The head of the Platonic school at Alexandria taught her pupils astronomy as a matter of course, and the pupil who became a bishop built an astrolabe under her instruction.
She was killed in March of 415, during Lent. Socrates says she was caught up in the quarrel between the prefect Orestes and the bishop Cyril, that a rumor spread that she was the obstacle to their reconciliation, and that a mob led by a lector named Peter dragged her from her carriage into the church called the Caesareum, stripped her, "murdered her with tiles," and burned what remained at a place called Cinaron. He adds that "this affair brought not the least opprobrium, not only upon Cyril, but also upon the whole Alexandrian church." The oyster shells of the popular versions are Gibbon's flourish; the Greek word means potsherds or roof tiles. The parabalani, the church's rough-handed attendants, are not named by any source as her killers; that is an inference from a law of the next year restricting them. The Library of Alexandria did not burn at her death; the Serapeum had been destroyed a quarter of a century earlier and no source connects her to any library. She was not young; the best modern estimates put her birth around 355, which makes her about sixty. And she was not the last pagan philosopher of Alexandria. The school went on, under Hierocles and Hermeias and Ammonius, for another century and more, as the end of this essay will show.
With the legends set aside, the record still shows a woman who held the chair of Platonic philosophy in the greatest city of the Greek East, worked on her father's edition of Ptolemy, taught astronomy and the construction of instruments, wrote on the hardest mathematics of her day, and was consulted by the governors of Egypt; and the doctrine of the imaginative spirit, which the Grammar of Sleep essay takes from her pupil's book, is what was taught in her lecture room. It passed from her school to a bishop's book in a single generation. A good deal of this art's philosophy survived by passages of that kind.
== Sosipatra ==
Half a century before Hypatia, in Asia Minor, there was a woman the sources treat as something closer to an initiate than a scholar. Eunapius, who wrote the lives of the fourth-century philosophers, gives Sosipatra more pages than he gives most of the men. She was born near Ephesus on the Cayster, to a rich family. When she was five, two old men "carrying ample wallets and dressed in garments of skins" came to her father's estate, asked to be given charge of the child and the estate for five years, and were, and at the end of the five years returned her to him with the promise that "your daughter shall have a mind not like a woman's or a mere human being's." Eunapius says they were "initiates in the lore called Chaldean," and that they then left for the Western Ocean. Her father, he says, became convinced his daughter was a goddess.
She married the philosopher Eustathius, telling him beforehand that she would bear him three children and that he would die before her, and after his death she settled at Pergamon, where the great Aedesius, Iamblichus's pupil and the master of the school, "loved and cared for her and educated her sons." She taught alongside him, and Eunapius says that "after attending the lectures of Aedesius, the students would go to hear hers." So a woman held a chair in the Iamblichean school, the school from which theurgy as a discipline descends, within a generation of Iamblichus himself.
Eunapius tells two stories about her that concern magic directly. A kinsman of hers named Philometor fell in love with her and, Eunapius says, cast a love spell. Sosipatra felt it working on her and told Maximus of Ephesus, Aedesius's pupil and kinsman, who "strove to counteract and nullify the weaker spell by one more potent and efficacious," and did. It is, as far as I know, the earliest account in the lineage of this art of a love-working being detected by its target and broken by a counter-working, and the target was the philosopher and the breaker her colleague. Later, lecturing on the soul, she stopped mid-sentence and said, "What is this? Behold my kinsman Philometor riding in a carriage! The carriage has been overturned in a rough place in the road," and described his injuries, which were found to be as she had said. Her son Antoninus settled at the Canopic mouth of the Nile and foretold that the temples would cease to be and "even the great and holy temples of Serapis would pass into formless darkness," which they did in 391. Eunapius is our only source for all of this and his admiration shapes it. But the Pergamene school was real, and Sosipatra's place in it is stated as fact by the one man who wrote its history.
== Asclepigenia, and the Handing-on of Theurgy ==
The best-documented case is also the least known, and it concerns the one part of this tradition that cannot be got from books. Marinus, who succeeded Proclus as head of the Academy at Athens and wrote his life, says that Proclus practiced the Chaldean rites and conferences, used the divine iynges, and believed in the oracular responses and other divinations, and that he had learned all this "from Asklepigenia, daughter of Plutarch, to whom exclusively her father had confided and taught the mystic rites preserved by Nestorius, and the whole theurgic science."
Plutarch of Athens, the founder of the Athenian Academy's Neoplatonic phase, had the theurgic rites from his own father or grandfather Nestorius, a hierophant. He passed them to one person, his daughter. She passed them to Proclus, the greatest systematic philosopher of late antiquity and the man whose account of the chain of being and of the sympathies between the stars and the things below them underlies every Renaissance theory of the talisman. The theurgy of the Chaldaean Oracles, the practice that the Platonists themselves regarded as the summit of their philosophy, reached Proclus through a woman, and Marinus says she alone had it to give. Her granddaughter, also Asclepigenia, appears in the next chapter of the same life as the sick child for whom Proclus prayed at the temple of Asclepius, and who recovered as he prayed; the two are often confused, and it is the grandmother who taught him.
== Aedesia, and the End ==
The last woman in this record is Aedesia of Alexandria. Her story is told by Damascius, the last head of the Academy at Athens. She was kin to the great Syrianus, Proclus's teacher, who would have betrothed her to Proclus "had not one of the gods prevented Proclus from entering upon marriage." She married Hermeias instead, and bore him Ammonius and Heliodorus. Damascius calls her the fairest and finest of the women of Alexandria, outstanding in piety and in charity, giving to the needy "even beyond her means." When her husband died the city continued his public stipend to her, and she used it for her sons' education in philosophy, sailing with them to Athens, where Proclus himself admired her. And when she died, Damascius, "a mere lad," recited at her tomb "the customary eulogy adorned with heroic verses."
The same Damascius was not so generous to Hypatia. He wrote that his teacher Isidore differed from her "not only as a man from a woman, but as a true philosopher from a geometer." A geometer is a mathematician, and in Plato's schools mathematics was the training a student went through before philosophy, so he was saying that she had mastered the preliminaries and never reached the real subject. It is a sneer, and the boy who spoke at Aedesia's tomb had reason to know better.
Aedesia's son Ammonius became the teacher of Simplicius, Philoponus, Olympiodorus and Damascius. Among his pupils were the last generation of pagan philosophers and the Christian commentators who carried Aristotle to the Arabs. The last school of the old philosophy was raised by a widow on a city pension. Then the record of women in this lineage goes quiet. Nobody has found a woman in the Arabic transmission of the Science of Images, or in the Latin one; the Picatrix, Thabit, the lapidaries and the Speculum pass from man to man for five hundred years, so far as their names tell us. The silence breaks in the twelfth century with an abbess who wrote her own lapidary, and that is where the second essay begins.
== What the Record Shows ==
As for where their books went, most of them were probably never written. The early Pythagoreans wrote little, Sosipatra lectured, and Asclepigenia handed on a practice. What was written had to be recopied by hand in every generation to last, and copyists copied what the schools assigned. Nearly everything the early Stoics wrote is gone for the same reason, so the loss by itself proves nothing about women. Still, I suspect their sex counted against them. The sentence of Damascius about Hypatia shows how a head of the Academy could rank a woman. And what did get copied under women's names was advice to wives, while the commentaries the Suda credits to Theano were not. Hypatia may have fared a little better. Her work on Ptolemy is credited in the heading of her father's commentary, and some historians of mathematics think part of her commentary on Diophantus survives, unsigned, in the text of Diophantus as we have it. I know of no evidence that anyone destroyed these books on purpose, but they suffered a kind of malign neglect.
The women named here are a small number across a thousand years, and the schools were men's institutions in which women were the exception. But the exceptions turn up at the most important points in the lineage. The tradition said its ethics came from a priestess. Plato gave the theory of the daimons to a woman to teach. The chair at Alexandria was held by a woman who taught the bishop who wrote the book on dreams. The Iamblichean school at Pergamon had a woman lecturing after its master, and she is the first person in the lineage whom we see detect and defeat a love spell. And the theurgy itself, the practice, went from father to daughter to Proclus, and the man who wrote the account says she alone had it. Anyone who tells you the women of this tradition were a modern addition has not read the sources. They were there when it was made.
Sources. Diogenes Laertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers II.72 and 86 (Arete), VIII.8, 21, 42–43 (Themistoclea, Theano, Damo), tr. R. D. Hicks (Loeb, 1925). Porphyry, Life of Pythagoras 4, 19–20, 41, tr. K. S. Guthrie (1919); Life of Plotinus 9, tr. S. MacKenna; To Marcella 1, 3, 33, tr. A. Zimmern (1896). Iamblichus, On the Pythagorean Life 31 (§§189–194), Timycha, and 36 (§267), the catalog of women. Epistolae diversorum philosophorum, oratorum, rhetorum (Venice, Aldus Manutius, 1499), for the letters under the names of Theano, Melissa and Myia. Suda, s.v. Theano (θ 83–84), Arignote (α 3872), Hypatia (υ 166), Aedesia (αι 79). Photius, Bibliotheca, codex 242, for the line on Isidore and Hypatia. The last three from Damascius, Philosophical History, ed. P. Athanassiadi (1999), frr. 43, 56, 106A. Plato, Symposium 201d, 202d–203a, tr. W. R. M. Lamb (Loeb, 1925); Menexenus 235e–236b. Socrates Scholasticus, Ecclesiastical History VII.15, tr. A. C. Zenos (1890). Theon of Alexandria, Commentary on the Almagest, Book III, title; A. Cameron, "Isidore of Miletus and Hypatia," GRBS 31 (1990). Synesius, Letters 15, 16, 81, 154, and On the Gift of the Astrolabe 14, tr. A. Fitzgerald (1926, 1930). Eunapius, Lives of the Philosophers and Sophists 466–471, tr. W. C. Wright (Loeb, 1921). Marinus, Life of Proclus 28–29, tr. K. S. Guthrie (1925); M. Edwards, Neoplatonic Saints (2000). Modern: M. Dzielska, Hypatia of Alexandria (1995); E. J. Watts, Hypatia (2017) and City and School in Late Antique Athens and Alexandria (2006); S. B. Pomeroy, Pythagorean Women (2013), with K. Brodersen's review, BMCR 2014.08.58; H. Thesleff, The Pythagorean Texts of the Hellenistic Period (1965); H. Marx, Sosipatra of Pergamum (2021); D. Nails, The People of Plato (2002).
The essay is on the site at https://www.astrologicalmagic.com/library/mother-taught.html (from Sunday, November 22).