I ran a simple thought experiment for a video essay: a thousand players, a hundred chips each, betting one chip a hand on red or black at a European roulette wheel.
After 50 hands, 350 of them are ahead. They'll go home with a story. But if they stay: 230 ahead at hand 500, 176 at 1,000, 34 at 5,000. By around hand 3,000, half have lost everything. By 20,000, no one is left.
The reason is almost boring. The single green zero gives the house 1/37 of every bet, about 2.7%. Your expected loss grows with the number of hands; luck only grows with its square root. Over 100 hands, luck's swing (about 10 chips) dwarfs the average loss (about 3). Over 10,000 hands, the loss (about 270) dwarfs the swing (about 100). Even a player who promises to quit at 200 chips has roughly a 1 in 220 chance of getting there. The gambler's ruin problem goes back to Christiaan Huygens in 1657.
What I find more interesting is the human side. Dostoevsky gambled for nearly a decade, pawned his watch, lost his fare home, and dictated The Gambler in about a month to beat a contract that would otherwise have handed his publisher the rights to all his works. He clearly understood the odds. Then, in spring 1871, he wrote to his wife that the "fantasy" that had tormented him for years had passed, and he never played again. Nobody knows exactly what changed.
Natasha Dow Schüll's fieldwork in Las Vegas offers one clue: some players told her they weren't playing to win at all, but to stay in "the zone". The industry's own metric is time on device. (In fairness: lab findings that near-misses make people play longer haven't replicated well, and most people who gamble never get near that zone.)
I made an 11-minute video essay on this (small channel called Idea Prism, my own work, and not an anti-gambling lecture): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GRt6zY7OqHQ
Curious what you think Dostoevsky meant by "fantasy". Was it the belief that the next hand would be different?