I replied to a youtube video of a pro-life woman who shall not be named. She only had a few dozen followers, and I thought I made some good arguments and wanted to share them on a larger platform. Would love to hear other thoughts. I couldn't screenshot the text, so sorry if it's a tad chaotic.
I have no idea why this video was suggested to me, but I'll do my best to respond in a way that makes sense. Also, I don't think you're going to get cancelled. You have nine followers. (In retrospect, I acknowledge that this was petty.)
First off, nobody is saying women shouldn't be mothers anymore. They're saying that women should have the right not to have children if they don't want them. And saying they can just adopt them out is leaving out all of the harmful effects that that will have on both the woman and the child. That pregnancy could have led to health conditions for her, not to mention the psychological burden of knowing your child is out there and not being able to know if they're alright. That child is going to grow up not knowing why their mother didn't want them. And the foster system is a whole other hell I won't even get into.
Second, I don't agree with your deliberate cherry picking and refusal of certain information. You can't just say you don't believe there are women dying because doctors could lose their licences for providing the medical care they need to live. A quick google search will provide you with hundreds of articles from all different news sources on numerous cases. Through 2023, in the 14 states with complete or six-week abortion bans, there was an estimated 9.2% increase in pregnancy-related deaths, and that will rise even more once you take out the ability to drive to another state for an abortion. You cannot say you don't believe abortions are ever necessary to save the woman's life when there is a medical term for exactly that (which, by the way, is called a TFMR, or termination for medical reasons, not a MIF, or mifepristone medication abortion). The reasons for TFMRs come in two categories, fetal and maternal. Fetal TFMRs are done to terminate a fetus with health conditions that would impede its quality of life, such as trisomy 12, 18, or severe abnormalities that would limit survival or cause irreperable impairment. You didn't touch on the topic of fetal complications, and it's something I think you should look into. Maternal reasons for a TFMR include severe mental health crises or physical complications like hyperemesis gravidarum, premature rupture of membranes, severe preeclampsia or eclampsia, placental abruption, molar pregnancies, or ectopic pregnancies, just to name a few. Keep in mind that nearly all TFMRs are done on WANTED pregnancies. Why on Earth would a woman who wanted that child choose to terminate it unless her life was in danger?
Thirdly, banning abortion is not going to stop abortion. People are going to go back to back-alley abortions, just like they did before the introduction of Roe v. Wade in 1973. In the 1930s, there were an estimated annual 5,000-10,000 deaths caused by illegal or self-induced abortions. That dropped to around 1,700 in the 1940s due to introductions of antibiotics like penecillin, and just under 40 in 1972, also due to medical advancements. For reference, these 40 deaths were out of an estimated 130,000 back-alley abortions in that year alone. If access to safe abortion dissapeared today, those numbers would be much, much higher, due to a combination of advancements in women's rights and the decline in access to housing and livable wages. Now that we know we don't have to be subservient to men, more women are able to express their desires not to have kids. Now that we can't afford housing and groceries, even some people who do want kids are in no position to provide for them. And because casual sex is much more normalized than it was back then, more people will get pregnant.
I'd like to introduce you to the concept of harm reduction. Teenagers are going to have sex, whether we want them to or not. So, we provide them with condoms to prevent pregnancy and the spread of STDs. People are going to do drugs, whether we want them to or not. So, we equip workplaces and schools with narcan for emergencies and designate safe consumption sites for people to go that will provide them with a sterile environment to use. It doesn't mean you agree with drug use. But you are saving people's lives by providing these things. If you don't like abortion, don't have an abortion. But banning abortion because you value your personal religious convictions over scientific evidence is both dangerous and absurd.
And finally, you are not a doctor. I am not a doctor. So let's look at what doctors say. A 2024 poll of over 900 physicians found that only 21% opposed elective abortions. A 2021 survey of 913 physicians across more than 20 specialties reported a 78% support rate.
Your video is a feelings-based opinion piece. If you'd like an equally feelings-based response, I would tell you that the potential for life does not override the rights of a living person. If you want a scientific approach, look at the statistics and the findings of experts, and you can clearly see that access to abortion is both morally, fundamentally, and medically necessary. I rest my case.