I recently picked my playthrough back up after like a months long pause. I am in act 2, just after visiting the temple/ruin north of Dyrford in the main quest.
My 5 non negotiable (for both gameplay reasons, and personal fondness of the characters) party members are:
MC - wood elf druid. Cat form, bow, crowd control.
Eder - fighter. The tank of the party. Tidefall, knockdowns. Simple as
Pallegina - Paladin support offtank
Aloth - pure caster wizard. So much crowd control, also good dps both aoe and single target
Durance - priest. Amazing support. Can act as a backup melee if the situation is dire. Usually snipes with an arquebus after casting the needed buffs.
What I feel like my 5 main members are lacking is ranged dps, or alternatively one more frontliner. My 3 main considerations for the 6th member are:
Grieving Mother - I like that she doesn't relt on per rest spells. The charm/domination effects are amazing. However, I feel like she is lacking in damage, or maybe I just have the wrong spells on her. Also not terribly keen on how cryptic she is.
Sagani - I always like rangers, and I like her personality. She brings the ranged dps that I feel like my party lacks. Also fun to have the animal companion be a 7th member.
Kana - I like how jolly he is, and the chants are powerful. However, he feels really similar to play to me than Pallegina. Offtank with a lot of support. I think I want to like him / chanters but it is not exactly clicking. Kind of same with GM / Ciphers.
Who would you add as the 6th member? Or change them around depending on the mission? I like to stick with the same party for the most part but don't totally oppose swapping one every now and then.