r/psychoanalysis • • 9h ago

Link between schizotypy, schizophrenia, and sublimation?

8 Upvotes

Those on the healthy end of the schizotypy spectrum have been found to more frequently engage in creative pursuits, such as art, writing, and idea generation, including in the humanities. This is reflected in the idea that those high in schizoid traits often engage in artistic, abstract, or intellectual activities.

According to Freud: Sublimation refers to a "displacement of libido,” where the libido's impetus has been mitigated, "tamed,” and it's aim deviated to a "finer and higher" joy; a joy, even though of "much lesser intensity than the direct satisfaction of coarser drives [would bring]; that does not convulse our physical framework.”

In addition, a recognition of shared reality seems essential to sublimation, allowing for the effective negotiation between unacceptable individual drives and moral, cultural demands.

Those with vulnerability to psychosis have been theorised under psychoanalytic theory as having a structural difficulty in binding, regulating, and symbolizing libidinal energy.

Activities taken to be paradigmatic to sublimation include art, philosophy, and other creative or intellectual pursuits. While this may not prove that those on the healthier end of the schizotypy spectrum are necessarily engaging in
sublimation when they partake in the described activities, this possibility doesn’t seem to be ruled out either.

As one departs from healthier manifestations of schizotypy, the effective engagement in artistic, abstract, and other creative or intellectual pursuits is lost. Thought may become too idiosyncratic (positive schizotypy) or disorganised, or motivation to engage in activities may be directly thwarted (negative schizotypy). Essentially, engagement in shared reality becomes difficult, as does the ability to sublimate.

The unhealthiest manifestation of schizotypy, as theorised, is schizophrenia.

I am thus wondering if sublimation (particularly concerning creativity or aesthetics) could play a role in the prevention of psychosis, or if there’s some other link between the two?

Could it be that those on the healthier end of the schizotypy spectrum (which involves a vulnerability to psychosis) remain healthier due to their (possible) engagement in sublimation; do those high in schizotypy require higher than average engagement in sublimation to remain healthy (if so, why?); or, could the apparent loss of the ability to sublimate be due to the same process that causes decompensation towards an unhealthier position?


r/psychoanalysis • • 21h ago

I'd like to learn more about Erich Fromm's ideas. He says that "love and work" is one of the ways that human beings overcome what he calls "separateness." Can anyone elaborate?

22 Upvotes

Fromm states in his book Escape From Freedom that the basic situation of man in the modern age is one of "anxious apartness," a situation in which we are separated from each other, from a sense of definite meaning, and from a strong sense of spiritual or religious certainty.

He describes how in the middle ages, people had a sense of certainty about their place in the world because of the presence of all encompassing religious ideas that solidified man's place in the social and ontological order. He also argues that the economic realities of this era gave people a sense of security when contrasted the modern times, in which men are far more in competition with one other. All of this, in Fromm's view, makes for an unprecedented state of isolation and anxiety.

He suggests that love and work are the solution to this sate of anxious apartness:

"There is only one possible, productive solution for the relationship of individualized man with the world: his active solidarity with all men and his spontaneous activity, love and work, which unite him again with the world, not by primary ties but as a free and independent individual."

My question is this: how can meaningful work help to overcome a state of separateness or existential dread? Does he develop on this idea in any of this other works? Is anyone familiar with his thought here? Can you explain what he means by this? How can one's "work" or "career" overcome separateness?