r/puremathematics
•
u/Reality_Shatterer
•
9h ago
A mathematician’s apology — AI ethics in mathematics: The Alpöge case
Having spent more than two decades in mathematics, I have witnessed my fair share of shameful behavior within the mathematical community (although I imagine the same occurs in other fields). However, the level of questionable behavior I have witnessed surrounding the recent developments concerning the Riemann Hypothesis surpasses anything I have seen or heard of before.
I have seen colleagues discredit other researchers’ preprints based on entirely non-mathematical considerations: the authors’ countries of origin, names, and institutional affiliations. There is often an unmistakable bias against researchers from non-Western countries.
Conversely, I have seen colleagues being remarkably lenient toward so-called “big names”, subjecting their work to considerably less scrutiny and granting them far more flexibility when it comes to publishing in reputable journals than other researchers could ever dream of.
I have also witnessed mathematicians shamelessly claiming authorship of collaborative papers they could hardly be bothered to write, let alone read the abstracts of. And no, I am not talking about the familiar advisor–student dynamics, but about misconduct at a much more senior level.
Then came this year, and with it the massive rise of AI in mathematical research. I have seen some names on arXiv practically double their number of preprints in less than a year. I have watched profit-driven companies aggressively pursue some of the most fundamental conjectures in mathematics, making remarkable progress in the process. Has our community become more concerned with the number of papers published than with their actual substance?
If the announced proof of RH is correct, as the independent formal verification checks increasingly suggest, the solution to the most important problem in the history of number theory risks being overshadowed by human greed, questionable behavior, and controversy. What should be a massive celebration for the community has instead been accompanied by doubt, sadness, and, above all, confusion. There is a sense of emptiness, from what I can gather from my colleagues, and it stems not from the problem itself but from the circumstances surrounding it.
A couple of months ago, I strongly sympathized with Buckmaster and Alpöge when concerns arose that AI models might have benefited from their work on the Navier–Stokes problem. Questions were raised about whether researchers’ work could have been exploited without their knowledge or consent. Of course, I have no evidence that such an infringement occurred, and it may never be possible to determine precisely what happened. Nevertheless, the ethical questions raised by the possibility are far from trivial.
I repeat, if their version of events is truthful: I genuinely empathized with Buckmaster and Alpöge. Imagine coming so close to claiming one of the greatest breakthroughs in modern mathematics, only to find yourself potentially deprived of much of the recognition associated with it. This raises another uncomfortable question: why do we do mathematics in the first place? Has our discipline become little more than a playground for glory seekers? Whatever the precise circumstances, that must have been an extraordinarily painful experience.
Then came October 6, 2026, when OpenAI announced over 300 mathematical breakthroughs. Having worked in number theory for more than twenty years, I found the developments surrounding the quasi-Riemann Hypothesis by far the most impressive. The magnitude of these announcements was extraordinary, and their implications for the future of mathematical research were impossible to ignore.
This time, however, the mathematical community decided to speak up and openly debate the role of AI in research.
From a mathematical standpoint, human understanding and the assimilation of new ideas are not merely desirable: they are fundamental to our profession. Mathematics is not simply about producing a proof, declaring victory, and moving on. It is about understanding why an argument works, what lies behind it, and what new mathematical insights can be extracted from it.
AI companies did not seem to grasp this rather elementary principle. Nevertheless, experts in the field gathered to decipher the arguments behind the quasi-Riemann Hypothesis, understand their underlying mechanisms, and ultimately digest the mathematics involved. That is how mathematical knowledge is consolidated. That is how our discipline advances.
On November 20, Levent Alpöge announced what he described as an AI-assisted proof of the Riemann Hypothesis. On the same day, an unpolished draft of Alessandro Masullo’s independently developed, human-written proposed proof was made public. According to the announcement accompanying Masullo’s manuscript, the intention had originally been to spend considerably more time reviewing and polishing the argument before its release. The sudden publication appears to have been prompted by the circumstances surrounding Alpöge’s announcement, although I cannot speak to Masullo’s personal motivations.
What I can question, however, is whether mathematics would benefit far more from a system in which recognition was not awarded primarily to whoever happens to be the last person in a long chain of contributions to claim the final result. And this brings me to a question for Masullo: why work for nine years in secret?
I have always dreamt of a system in which mathematical authorship remains rigorously verified while the authors themselves remain anonymous. For example, researchers could receive an encrypted authorship identifier upon completing their PhD, allowing their contributions to be properly documented without making their identities public. Perhaps this would help prevent mathematics from becoming a relentless pursuit of personal glory, or from exposing researchers to the shame and prejudice that comes from “daring” to solve a big problem.
The whole situation must seem, painfully, almost comical to people outside academia. However, if Masullo’s human proof of RH turns out to be correct, the credit for that independent mathematical discovery should go to Masullo. If the human proof is incorrect but the AI-assisted one is correct, the question of attribution becomes considerably more troubling. We do not have a complete public account of the mathematical material that contributed to the model’s capabilities, and some of the intellectual origins of an AI-generated argument may be impossible to trace.
In my view, **Alpöge deserves no credit for the mathematical discovery itself.** That is my assessment of the circumstances, and I believe the mathematical community should examine the issue of attribution with extraordinary seriousness.
I do not intend to make baseless accusations but to raise legitimate questions. Let me explain my four objections.
**1. The uncertainty surrounding his actual mathematical contribution.**
In his announcement, Alpöge explains that the Riemann Hypothesis has guided his mathematical ambitions for decades. He also describes steering the AI-assisted investigation before Claude eventually outpaced his own mathematical understanding near the decisive stages.
How much of the discovery was genuinely his? How much was the AI’s? Which indispensable ideas originated with him, and which were generated independently by the model?
These are not minor questions. They concern the very meaning of authorship and mathematical discovery.
I do not deny that Alpöge may have made important contributions during the investigation. What I question is whether those contributions justify credit for the final discovery. We cannot simply assume that guiding an AI system toward a problem is equivalent to discovering the mathematics that ultimately solves it.
And we may never be able to determine the exact division of intellectual contributions with sufficient confidence. However, in my view, once you admit that you cannot explain the proof of a result you have published, the question of receiving credit for that proof is settled: **no credit whatsoever.**
**2. Privileged access and conflict of interest.**
Alpöge works for Anthropic, a company developing some of the most powerful AI models available. This raises an obvious question about access to proprietary technology and the enormous inequality of resources between corporate researchers and the rest of the mathematical community.
I believe that, as the community was moving toward accepting the use of AI in research, it was doing so in a democratic spirit: one in which every researcher, regardless of their nationality, institutional affiliation, or professional connections, could benefit from publicly available models using an ordinary computer or smartphone.
But what happens when researchers employed by AI companies have access to substantially more powerful internal models than those available to everyone else? Is that the future of mathematical research we want?
A discipline in which a handful of immensely wealthy companies can purchase computational advantages that no university, independent researcher, or small research group could possibly match?
I regard this as a serious conflict between commercial interests and the values of open mathematical research. The precise nature of Alpöge’s access and the conditions under which he conducted the work deserve complete transparency.
Having access to top technology and then claiming authorship of one of the most important discoveries in mathematical history raises, in my opinion, profound ethical concerns. The apparent acceptance of such inequalities strikes me as shameful.
**3. The disregard for mathematical understanding.**
Perhaps the most disgraceful aspect of Alpöge’s decision, in my view, was the extraordinary haste with which he announced the result despite acknowledging that he had not yet mastered the mathematics underlying the argument.
What I perceive as a **DISREGARD** for the recent public declaration entitled [*A Severe Misalignment of AI in Mathematics*](https://mathandai.org/) (September 2026), endorsed by numerous Fields Medalists, is shocking. The declaration explicitly warned against the race to solve famous mathematical problems as benchmarks for AI companies. It criticized the practice of rushing to announce solutions without allowing sufficient time for proper mathematical exposition, the identification of new methods and ideas, or the acknowledgment of previous work. Above all, it emphasized that solving mathematical problems is merely a means toward a much deeper objective: conceptual understanding and insight.
This was no obscure concern expressed privately by a handful of unknown mathematicians. It was a public warning, endorsed by some of the most distinguished members of our profession, issued just 70 days before Alpöge’s announcement.
And yet, here we are. To announce a result of this magnitude before being able to explain its mathematical foundations, despite such a recent and explicit warning, strikes me as nothing short of shocking.
Why not wait two years, five years, or however long it takes, and release a human-understandable proof?
Why not first work with experts in the relevant fields, simplify the argument, identify its central innovations, and explain to the community what has actually been discovered?
I recognize that Alpöge has expressed his intention to undertake precisely this work. But I question the decision to announce the result before completing it.
We are talking about the Riemann Hypothesis. One of the most extraordinary intellectual challenges in human history.
What was the urgency, when researchers in analytic number theory were still struggling to understand and digest the extraordinary developments surrounding the quasi-Riemann Hypothesis? Had the mathematical community not even been afforded sufficient time to comprehend one monumental breakthrough before another was hastily announced?
Why should the immediate announcement of a claimed solution take precedence over the careful mathematical understanding of the argument?
**4. A monumental formal proof is not a substitute for mathematical knowledge.**
Alpöge reports that an AI-generated exposition exceeded 250,000 pages, while the released Lean formalization contains approximately 17 million lines of code.
I recognize the importance of formal verification. I do not dispute that a formally checked proof can establish the truth of a theorem, even before mathematicians fully understand its underlying ideas.
But I see very little intellectual benefit in a 250,000-page exposition that nobody can realistically read, digest, or meaningfully absorb.
**We want to understand the mathematics behind the Riemann Hypothesis.**
We want to discover the mechanisms that make it true. We want to understand the connections with analytic number theory, automorphic forms, arithmetic geometry, and whatever other ideas the proof may contain.
I did not become a mathematician to use a result like the Riemann Hypothesis as a black box. Frankly, I would feel ashamed to do so.
And this brings me to another uncomfortable question: what motivated the urgency of
Alpöge announcement?
I have no evidence that any special financial incentive was offered, nor do I know whether his earlier painful experience with the Navier–Stokes developments influenced the timing of his decision. I am not alleging either.
Nevertheless, given the extraordinary commercial and professional stakes surrounding AI-assisted mathematical discoveries, I believe questions about institutional incentives, access to proprietary models, and the rush to claim credit are entirely legitimate.
Why should these questions be treated as inappropriate when the future of our profession may depend on the answers?
I believe that transparency is indispensable, particularly when a breakthrough of this magnitude emerges from within an AI company.
Alpöge was a good mathematician before his involvement with AI. That is precisely why I find the whole affair so profoundly disappointing.
In my judgment, his decision to announce a result of this magnitude before he could properly explain its mathematical foundations was, at the very least, reckless. I fear that the consequences will extend far beyond this particular controversy and have a profoundly negative impact on our profession.
The Riemann Hypothesis deserved to be a celebration of mathematical knowledge and human intellectual achievement. Instead, we find ourselves debating commercial interests, unequal access to technology, questionable standards of attribution, and the very meaning of being a mathematician.
**We may finally have a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis, yet we are left questioning what our profession is becoming. The solution to the most important problem in number theory may forever remain overshadowed by the controversy surrounding its discovery. We should be in a state of utter bliss, yet we find ourselves profoundly dissatisfied.**

