I'm 35F, my wife is 39F, and we were planning to have a child using her 23-year-old gay brother as our known donor.
I never wanted to carry. My wife did. But six years ago she was diagnosed with leukemia and had to act fast, no time to save eggs. So she asked me to consider carrying, to do what I needed to in order to get to that place. And we asked her gay little brother to make up for the piece of her not being able to be 50% related, and being happy with 25%.
He's been a yes for years. Not a vague "maybe someday" that we just ran with. This was something our family had talked about for years. We spent the last couple of years getting ourselves ready, emotionally and practically. I was the one who needed more time, and we were finally getting to the point of actually moving forward. Talking testing, timelines, all of it. We thought we were about to hit GO.
And then he threw a wrench into everything.
What we're piecing together now is that he may never have really thought through what donating would mean. Or at least not beyond the abstract idea of helping us have a baby. Once it started becoming real, he started having doubts and anxiety about the emotional implications, his relationship with the child, his boyfriend's feelings, family dynamics, all of it. There were also concerns about conflict in our family and my wife's anxiety. Some things were said that were pretty hurtful, and the whole thing has spiraled into a much bigger rupture than I ever imagined.
To be fair, we didn't sit him down and thoroughly work through every possible implication. We didn't have extensive donor counseling or formal agreements. We didn't really feel the need to at the time because he seemed genuinely comfortable with it and we're all close and connected deeply. It felt simple. He was a yes, we trusted him, and we thought we'd work through the practical details together when the time came. In hindsight, maybe we all made assumptions. Maybe we should have pushed harder to understand what his yes actually meant.
But I'm struggling SO much to understand his perspective, even after reading a lot about known donation and donor psychology.
Part of me still thinks this isn't that deep. He's donating sperm. He's not agreeing to become a father or co-parent. We would be the parents. He would be an uncle, and a very special one. I understand that having a biological child out there can bring up complicated feelings, and I know I'm probably minimizing something that I can't fully understand because I'm not the donor. I don't want to dismiss that. But I also can't help feeling like this has become an enormous emotional drama around something that, in my mind, was supposed to be a beautiful way to help his sister have a family. Especially after everything she went through fighting leukemia.
And I think some of that comes from how close their family is. They have always had conflict, sometimes pretty significant conflict, but they also come back together. They're a very close family. Their history is also a huge part of why this mattered so much.
Their family comes from a culture that experienced genocide. They lost so many relatives and so much of their extended family history. There aren't many relatives left. Rebuilding family and passing on their DNA has a significance that is difficult to separate from the history of what was lost.
My wife also can't carry a pregnancy because she had leukemia. That loss has been enormous for her. Her brother offering to be our donor was a way for her to still have a biological connection to our child. It was something she could hold onto while grieving what cancer had taken from her. I would carry the pregnancy using his sperm, and we would have a child genetically connected to her and to their family.
We never considered a random donor. And it wasn't just about finding sperm from just anyone we knew. It was about her DNA, her brother, their family, and the idea of rebuilding something that history had taken so much from.
We spent years imagining this. Parenting conversations, baby names, practical preparations. I took a long time to get ready, and I know that probably contributed to the disconnect. I thought he was still there, waiting for us to be ready. Apparently he may have thought of it as an open-ended offer that wasn't necessarily going anywhere. We clearly weren't on the same page.
Now we're here. He's expressed serious uncertainty, we've had some pretty painful conversations, and there's been a lot of hurt on both sides. He's also been struggling with his mental health, including disclosing some very serious suicidal thoughts, so that's another layer we're trying to navigate with care. I don't want to make his mental health about us, and I do take it seriously. But it's also been a lot to absorb while we're dealing with this loss ourselves.
And honestly, I'm scared we may never speak to him again. This isn't just a donor arrangement potentially falling apart. It's my wife's brother. It's someone we thought would be part of our child's story, and now we may lose that relationship entirely. Alongside our family building future.
I know I'm looking for validation here, but I also want people to challenge me. I want to understand what it actually feels like from the donor's side, especially from men who have considered or gone through known donation. Is it really as emotionally complicated as some people describe? Did you initially feel fine about it and then have a complete change of heart once it became real? What specifically changed?
For people who have used a sibling or close friend as a donor, how did you navigate the emotional and family dynamics? Did it strengthen your family or create complications you hadn't anticipated?
And for anyone reading this who thinks I'm being unfair to him, please tell me. I genuinely want to understand what I'm missing. But I also need someone to understand why this feels so devastating to us.
I need some validation, probably some scolding, and honestly a little hope that this doesn't have to mean the end of our family relationship or the end of the future we imagined.