r/Referees • • 19h ago

Discussion Ask /r/referees -- Megathread for Fans / Players / Coaches

1 Upvotes

Welcome! In this megathread, Rule 1 is relaxed. Anyone (referee or not) may ask questions about real-world incidents from recent matches in soccer at all levels, anywhere in the world.

Good questions give context for the match if it's not obvious (e.g. player age, level of competitiveness, country/region), describe the incident (picture/video helps a lot), and include a clear question or prompt such as:

  • Why did the referee call ...?
  • Would the call have been different if ...?
  • Could the player have done ... instead?
  • Is the referee allowed to do ...?
  • Would you have called this the same way?

This is not a platform to disparage any referees, however much you think they made the wrong call. (There are plenty of other subreddits to do that.) The mission of this megathread is to help referees, fans, coaches, and players better understand the Laws of the Game (or the relevant local rules of competition).

Since the format is asking questions of the refereeing community, please do not answer unless you are a referee. Follow-up and clarifying questions from anyone are generally fine, but answers should come only from actual referees.

Rule 1 still applies elsewhere -- we are primarily a community of and for soccer (association football) referees. If you're not a soccer/footy referee, then you are a guest and should act accordingly.

Please give feedback and other meta-level comments about this thread as a standalone reply.

You can view past weeks' megathreads here: https://www.reddit.com/r/Referees/search/?q=Ask+%2Fr%2Freferees+--+Megathread+for+Fans+%2F+Players+%2F+Coaches&sort=new&restrict_sr=on&t=all


r/Referees • • Feb 28 '26

Meta/Moderation Get your cards and whistles ready - /r/referees needs Ideas and more Moderators

10 Upvotes

Fellow match officials:

As we exit winter and prepare for the resumption of league and tournament play (in the Northern hemisphere), give a thought to the community and resources provided by this sub for new and experienced refs alike.

I joined the modteam here almost six years ago and have been the only active mod for more than half that time. The other human mods are now all inactive, redditwide. It's time to enlarge the team.

This is also a good opportunity to discuss the community overall, including the subreddit's written rules, informal practices, and what everyone would like to see from the sub in the future.


If you would like to be a moderator make a comment below noting your interest and address the following prompts:

  • Describe your refereeing experience. Do you have experience educating referees (either formally or informally)? Do you have experience in other roles related to either refereeing or soccer (e.g. assigning, coaching, playing, refereeing other sports...)?
  • Describe your experience in /r/Referees. How long have you considered yourself a member of the community here? Link to a few comments you've made that you are proud of or that exemplify your participation here. Are there any comments or submissions by others that you think are very high quality or that new members should read?
  • Describe your experience as a moderator. Are you a mod of other subs on reddit? Have you held moderator roles on other sites/platforms? Do you have IRL experience (other than refereeing) which is moderator-like? Describe a notable challenge or difficult situation you've faced while modding. Are you familiar with RES and /r/toolbox?

(Note: Prior mod experience may be helpful but is not required. So if you have none, say that. Everyone starts somewhere.)

  • Describe your experience on reddit. How long have you been here? What other subs are you active in? Roughly how often are you on reddit (hours per week, common times when you're logged on)? Are there any contributions you've made in other subs that you want to share with us to demonstrate your expertise or interests?
  • Where are you in the world? (We have a diverse userbase from many time zones and continents. While not required, there would be value in having a moderating team which reflects that.) Although this sub uses English by custom, do you have skills in other languages which may be useful?
  • What else should we know about you?

This should not be an exercise in self-doxxing, so please don't give private information and do feel free to approximate. (If you have significant concerns about answering these questions in public at all, send a message via modmail and we can discuss.) I might ask you follow-up questions, as might other members of the sub.

I will leave this call up for at least a week and see how many responses come in, so if this interests you, submit your response promptly. There's no specific number of mods I'm looking for; every qualified person has a chance. Moderating the sub is not particularly time-consuming (a typical month has between 250-300 human mod actions) and we do not have significant issues with spammers or brigading.


Separately, all members of the /r/referees community are invited to discuss the subreddit in general. Are the rules still appropriate and adequate? What are your thoughts on the pinned weekly thread for questions from non-referees? Is there something you'd like to see more of on the sub (or less)? What are your thoughts on current moderating practices? Any other ideas? Comment them below!


r/Referees • • 10h ago

Advice Request Loud coach

10 Upvotes

Officiating U11 9x9 Premier today. One of the coaches was loud, but was always positive and directing his players, calling out positions, but was never demeaning, vulgar, or negative. He was coaching.

The assignor was nearby and at halftime came up and issued some tips for the assistants. He also told me that I should talk with the coach about how loud he was and also mentioned that he stepped on the pitch a few times.

This was all respectful and instructive, but I said to him, “I will keep an eye on his entering the pitch, but mentioning his volume is seeking conflict. He was always positive and was simply coaching, as coaches tend to do!”

Again, this is a premier team, so they were relatively skilled and are on their way to being excellent players. But I could not accept that I now have to referee volume. Had he said anything untoward, negative, vulgar, etc., I definitely would have said something but I felt that we have enough to do already with the laws we have that I wasn’t going to find my own gray area to venture into simply because the coach was audible a mile away.

I get league emails and never has it been mentioned that part of the bench decorum is that coaches must never exceed –87dB when coaching 😊.

This was the assignor so I kept it civil and said I’d keep an ear open but I never agreed to confront him in volume. Content, yes, but volume? C’mon.


r/Referees • • 21h ago

Discussion Best/worst rule changes

11 Upvotes

What do you think have been the best (and the worst) changes to IFAB’s LOTG in the last, say, 25 years from the perspective of grassroots soccer?


r/Referees • • 15h ago

Advice Request Mundial Turf vs. Umpiro Pro

2 Upvotes

I am looking to get a good pair beside my running shoes for referee. I've seen soooo many good things about Mundial Turf on this sub, but just wanted to see if anyone have tried Umpiro Pro? Curious about thoughts/opinions about both? Price? Comfort?

Thank you


r/Referees • • 1d ago

Discussion Hate Reffing, Never Wanna Again

28 Upvotes

So this is more of a vent. I was voluntold to be the referee of an internal work soccer game. The rules were a bit different, certain areas by the end zone had higher point values. I’m not as experienced in the sport itself, but the unique rules for this were simple enough to understand.

Long story short, people weren’t happy with my calls. Putting it blankly, I called things as I saw them and I wasn’t as lenient as they thought I’d be. Let nothing slip, I didn’t care about people getting mad, I have thick skin in that regard. But, I underestimated how butthurt people can get over the game. To the point to where they go and start complaining to their bosses post game about how biased and unfair I was being over an informal game of soccer.

My respect goes out to actual referees that have to deal with this on the norm, from avid fans or angry players. I’m never reffing again lmao.


r/Referees • • 1d ago

Video Kudos to the crew on UNO/Creighton last night but in particular the center on this advantage call

Thumbnail espn.com
37 Upvotes

Love it when a really good advantage call results in an amazing goal (Kudos to the player obviously for the finish). This was a great first round D1 men’s playoff game too—crosstown rivalry with the underdogs pulling out a 2-0 upset … was one of those games for Creighton with multiple balls off the post and soccer chaos chances that just didn’t quite workout for them. I know one of the refs on this game, was an all Midwest crew and they understood the assignment. Lots of positive ref comments and kudos even on Instagram of all places.


r/Referees • • 1d ago

Question Deliberate trick to circumvent backpass?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

Occurs around 0:20.

Commentators said that the referee 'warned him', but the video doesn't go that far back. If anyone caught the game I'd love some context.

To me he plays it with his foot , albeit a few feet , and then picks it up. Is this a deliberate trick to circumvent?

Mods delete this if it doesn't pass the rule 1 sniff test.


r/Referees • • 1d ago

Question Restart

3 Upvotes

I have been arguing with the rules experts on TT about the proper restart when I goal keeper accidentally throws a ball into their own goal. I know it's a goal kick if they somehow throw it into the opponents goal but what is it when it's their own goal?


r/Referees • • 2d ago

Rules Handball leading to goal question

7 Upvotes

This is a mid-high-level U12 match. In the first minute, the defending team cleared the ball, and it hit the attacking player's hands, which seemed to be protecting his face (an unnatural position, but I didn't call it due to the very close proximity and because he seemed to be protecting his face (a natural reaction), especially at this age group).

Additionally, this occurred at midfield (given it's 9v9 size), so I didn't think this play would influence anything.

Later, however, after the play, the attacker took 2 touches and then scored from way outside the box.

The defender's coach then calls for the handball at the midfield line. I then talk to my AR, and we call it back for a foul because we believe his handball led directly to the goal. Was this the right call?


r/Referees • • 3d ago

News Arsene Wenger’s ‘daylight’ offside rule set to be shelved. Even former Arsenal manager himself is unconvinced by trial of his new system in Canada with football’s law makers expected to urge against its adoption.

Thumbnail thetimes.com
21 Upvotes

r/Referees • • 4d ago

Tips Writing referee tests

14 Upvotes

When writing referee tests... always double check the way it's worded.

Every mistake I make on the tests, it's because I didn't read it right.

Ugh.


r/Referees • • 5d ago

Question Hypothetical Handball Scenario

8 Upvotes

Hi,

I had a question about the application of the handball rule. I ended up coming up with the following (unlikely) scenario to illustrate my point

Suppose Team A has pulled their keeper forward to join the attack on a corner. Team A takes the corner, and in the events that follow, a shot on Team B’s goal strikes a defender for Team B on the elbow (positioned naturally) in his own penalty box. The ball falls right in front of him, and he immediately clears it (very hard) which ultimately leads to the ball dribbling into Team A’s open net.

What is the call?

I want to say penalty for Team A. The handball, albeit unintentional, immediately leads to a goal for Team B, which results in a direct free kick from the place of the handball. In this case, the handball occurs in Team B’s penalty area. Thus the call is penalty for Team A.

What do you think?


r/Referees • • 5d ago

News HS REFS

16 Upvotes

I’m at the first in person HS ref meeting for the year. This is so diverse (few more women would be great) Fantastically fun group of people from every corner of the earth, every walk of life brought together for the beautiful game.


r/Referees • • 5d ago

Tips Getting involved when observing poor sportsmanship?

21 Upvotes

U17 girls game at an elite national showcase tournament. Ten minutes to go in a meaningless but well-played 0-0 game on the final day, no college coaches watching. Low tension, no issues. I am AR2, ball goes across the touchline on my side and rolls down a steep hill. Clearly will be a throw-in for blue from deep inside their defensive half, but for whatever reason a red player runs down to fetch the ball. When she was about halfway up the hill she tosses the ball up to a blue player waiting on top who then proceeds to immediately turn around and take the throw-in. It took the red player probably another 3-4 seconds to get back up the hill and onto the pitch. I was flabbergasted at the poor sportsmanship.

I know this is not an issue for the crew, but something about the situation really triggered me. It was so blatantly callous AND unnecessary. If she would cheat in a meaningless situation like this, what might she do with a State Cup on the line? It felt like a teachable moment.

After the game (ended 0-0) as we were shaking hands, blue coach seemed particularly friendly and approachable. Against my better judgment (700+ games), I decided to bring it to his attention. I waited until all of his players had walked away and in a quiet voice said something like "hey coach, i just wanted to mention, not sure if you noticed on the far side when your player #xx took a quick throw before the opponent who had gone to get the ball for her was back on the pitch." It didn't go over well. He said it was none of the referees' business, I said I agreed but was approaching him not as a ref but as an impartial observer who thought he would want to know. It deteriorated from there with raised voices; he was shocked at my gall, I told him he should be embarrassed...

Obviously, a suboptimal conclusion. In retrospect, I regret bringing it up with the coach and loosing my cool. But curious about how others here might have approached it? Is there ever anything to be gained by (discreetly) stepping out of our lane and trying to do what feels right for the game?


r/Referees • • 5d ago

Image What's your call here? Big Sky Championship match, last 30 seconds of the game. Decision on the field was dangerous play by the defending team (Link in comments)

9 Upvotes

r/Referees • • 6d ago

Discussion "Player Safety"

57 Upvotes

I'm so sick of seeing/hearing player safety be used against referees, not just soccer, all referees.

Its constantly at games or online, "think of player safety", "you going to protect the kids?"

Lets be honest, you don't care about player safety, you care about getting the advantage for your team.

You care about what you falsely believe was a foul not being called and the free kick your team would have gotten.

If you truly cared about player safety you would get loud and obnoxious when your own players commits a heinous foul or one you previously believed to be a foul.

If it was really about player safety you'd make sure your player was properly equipped for the match.

In my many years of playing and reffing I can think of less than a dozen coaches or parents that actually cared about player safety and addressed their own players when they misbehave.

Lets be real; you don't care about player safety, you care about the advantage and the win.


r/Referees • • 5d ago

Advice Request Transfer Issues (US)

5 Upvotes

Hello, all! Seeking some guidance (or some general assistance, if possible).

I moved from the DMV to Massachusetts a bit ago. Now that I’m settled in, I’d like to ensure I am good to referee in the Commonwealth and re-certified for 2027. I set up my account with the Massachusetts State Referee Committee (MSRC) last month and completed both my SafeSport and background check through US Soccer. However, the MSRC website is displaying an “inactive” status for 2026, which blocks me from trying to re-certify for 2027. I reached out to the MSRC via their contact form twice in the past month, but no response. I’ve emailed their administrator a few times, but no response. There is no contact number online either. I’ve also emailed the Metro DC-Virginia State Referee Program, but no response just yet (email sent hours ago).

Would anyone have a contact number for someone at the MSRC? Should I just try to re-certify with the Metro DC-Virginia State Referee Program first? Any other suggestions to rectify this matter? I seem to be at an impasse.


r/Referees • • 5d ago

Advice Request Is it normal for an assignor to charge a fee per game on top of association fees?

5 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I’m a relatively new soccer referee in Southern California, and I’d love to get some feedback from more experienced referees or assignors.
Recently, I traveled about an hour to officiate 3 games. When getting paid the central referee was confused as to how much to paid and I said: on GotSport it says you get paid $75 and the other assistant referee asked if I went with how much it said on GotSport and I said yea, but they divided in a different way so we ended up getting pay $76 each assistant.
Here’s where I’m a little confused:
I’m registered with the local referee association, which charges a $40 annual membership fee.
I was assigned the games through GotSport by one assignor.
However, I communicated with another person who helped coordinate the assignments.
That person told me he charges $6 per game, meaning I had to pay him $18 for the three games.
He gave me the option of paying cash or Zelle. I chose Zelle so I would have a record of the payment.
When I asked about the fee, he explained something about working with referees who have tourist visas and taxes associated with those payments. I didn’t fully understand his explanation, but I clarified that I have a Social Security number and report my income.
I’m not accusing anyone of doing anything wrong. I’m genuinely trying to understand how assigning fees work.
Another thing that confused me was that I had a fourth game assigned in GotSport, but I was told in person that I wasn’t needed. I later confirmed this through text, but the game was never removed from my assignments. I wasn’t charged a fee for that game.
My main questions are:
Is charging $6 per game a common practice?
Is it normal to pay an assignor helper directly through Zelle or cash rather than through the association?
If I’m already paying an annual association fee, is it common to pay additional per game fees?
Should I be concerned about a game remaining assigned to me in GotSport even though I was told not to attend?
For assignors: How are these fees typically handled and documented?
Thank you everyone I hope I made myself clear if not I can always clarify.


r/Referees • • 6d ago

Discussion ITS NOT A DAMN HANDBALL

76 Upvotes

i swear. one of the most difficult things i deal with as a referee is people screaming for a hand ball. coaches, players, parents, all of em. of course i understand, because when you’re taught about the game most of the time you’re simply told “no hands in this game if the ball hits your hand it’s an offense” but that’s not how it works in reality.

the handball rule is incredibly nuanced, and requires many different things to be considered. was the hand in a natural position? how close was the player kicking the ball to the hand? does it provide an advantage?

it’s clear that many participants of soccer don’t fully understand the handball rule, and it’s not as cut dry as you think. ultimately, this leaves refs having to deal with the constant “handball” shouts even though a ball merely touching a hand does NOT make it a hand ball.

I know it’s part of the job, but good god, you’d think families and ESPECIALLY coaches would read up on the law. ITS NOT A DAMN HANDBALL!

what’s your best stories regarding a handball or other laws of the game that non-referees don’t understand?


r/Referees • • 5d ago

Discussion Football/soccer whistles??

3 Upvotes

Hey fellow refs! 😊
I’m looking for a slightly quieter alternative to my Fox 40 Classic to better protect my hearing. I referee youth matches up to U18, and sometimes experience ringing in my ears after games. Im refereeing as a hobby, but i still want something thats loud enough to not reduce my authority/performance, but still something that protects the ear more.
I’m considering the Acme Tornado 622 Reduced Sound or Fox 40 Caul, but I’m open to other suggestions.
Has anyone gone through the same process and found a whistle that’s quieter but still loud enough to command authority on the pitch?
Would love to hear your experiences and recommendations! 🤩


r/Referees • • 6d ago

Advice Request Should I have sent a kid off?

27 Upvotes

Late in a u12 boys high-level game. Game is basically over at two to zero with 2 minutes left but the boys are still playing hard trying to knock a goal in.

Kid goes down on a routine play, no foul, and comes up holding his head and a little bit of sniffling. Ball is coming out to midfield and I stopped play to check on him. He says "play the goddamn game ref." I red card for abusive language. Coach thought it was poor and site coordinator looked at me funny when I was writing the red card report.

What does everyone think? Red card, yellow card or just let it go?

Thanks for the opinions all. Totals so far if anyone is interested. Seems pretty split.

-Yellow card: 10 votes

-No card: 8 votes

-Red card: 7 votes

-Either yellow or red: 3 votes

-You are making the game about you: 3 votes. Is that a thing in some regions? I've never heard that.

-You shouldn't be a referee: 1 vote, although if we were to include parents and kids from the losing teams, I think that number would sky rocket.


r/Referees • • 6d ago

Advice Request Which Age Group For First CR Games

4 Upvotes

I have 2-3 months of AR club experience from U11s to U16s and want to start CR games.

Is it recommended to start games that only requires one CR (U8 age group) or games with ARs for additional help?


r/Referees • • 6d ago

Question Football(soccer) referee whistles- less loud??

6 Upvotes

Hey fellow refs😊
Im a football/soccer referee, that just referee for fun. I only referee youth matches up to u18. I currently have a fox 40 classic because everyone else has it, but i want a whistle that isnt so loud, this goes up to 120-123db. I hate that i have to accept my ear ringing the next 15 min after the match, or just in generel accepting that i probably am damaging my ear. I want reffing to be a pleasant,healthy and safe hobby so i would like a less loud whistle, that still does it job so everyone still easily can hear my whistle
Im currently considering something like acne tornado 622 reduced sound, it says it has up to 106DB but on youtube i can see it goes up to 111DB, but im not sure if its enough to still be authoritive in the pitch. Im also considering something like Fox 40 caul that goes up to 114DB but it has some finger grip that im not sure if its annoying. From what i read on the internet just a light 5-6 db lesser sound is enough to cut 70-80% of the damage and actually makes a big difference

Does anyone have some reccomendations or gone through the same thinking pattern, that they probably rather want to protect their ears, and maybe compromise a small bit on whistle loudness?

In advance thanks alot for your help🤩


r/Referees • • 7d ago

Discussion PK retakes & advantage

8 Upvotes

PK in regular time. GK leaves the goal line early and saves the shot. Rebound is a bouncing ball toward attacker (PK taker’s teammate) and GK is out of position.

What’s your call?

- immediately blow dead for PK retake
- play advantage for rebounder; if attacker misses and it goes out of play, goal kick is restart
- let the play continue; if attacker scores, apply advantage; if attacker misses opportunity, call back for PK retake

How does level of play impact your decision?