i am writing to submit a proposal regarding one of the most critical aspects of the competitive experience in League of Legends: the matchmaking system—specifically, how a ranked match determines the extent to which an individual’s performance influences their subsequent progression. This is not merely the complaint of a player who lost a match or feels they were held back by underperforming teammates. The issue I wish to bring to your attention is broader: the system can create significant disparities in the actual quality of the two teams, and the final win/loss outcome often fails to accurately reflect the skill level or performance of individual players. League of Legends is a 5v5 game; the final result is inevitably the product of five players working together—their collective decisions, their ability to cooperate, individual errors, objectives secured, and their capacity to translate advantages into a victory. For this very reason, I believe the competitive system should better distinguish between a defeat caused by a player’s own poor performance and a defeat where an individual played exceptionally well, yet could not single-handedly compensate for a massive gap in the team’s overall performance. 1. The Problem of Team Disparities The core issue is not necessarily the visible rank of the individual players. Five players nominally belonging to the same tier are not necessarily equivalent in terms of actual skill, experience, game knowledge, decision-making, map awareness, mechanics, understanding of objectives, or the ability to capitalize on advantages. Likewise, two teams might appear balanced according to the matchmaking system’s parameters, yet exhibit such a vast difference in performance during the match that the contest becomes fundamentally lopsided. One team might move as a coordinated unit—contesting objectives, capitalizing on advantages, executing rotations, and punishing mistakes. Another team, by contrast, might consistently lose individual duels, concede advantages, fail to participate in objective play, repeatedly leave themselves vulnerable, neglect to leverage the advantages created by their teammates, and make it impossible to maintain control of the match. In such a scenario, we are no longer dealing with a standard match where one team was simply "better than the other." We may reach a point where the contributions of one or two players are mathematically insufficient to compensate for the behavior and performance of the rest of the team. This is the fundamental issue that matchmaking and rating systems should be able to identify. 2. A single match does not necessarily reflect an individual player's skill level. A ranked system must, of course, continue to reward wins and penalize losses—I am not suggesting that we discard the team-based nature of the game or transform *League of Legends* into an individual endeavor. However, I find it problematic to treat the final outcome as an accurate representation of each team member's individual value. A player might create advantages, secure and set up objectives, control vision, execute proper rotations, generate opportunities for teammates, concede resources or kills to help a teammate scale, contribute effectively to team fights, maintain map pressure, deny the opposition specific objectives, and properly capitalize on existing leads—yet still lose the match because the rest of the team fails to maintain, utilize, or translate those advantages into success. In such a case, the simple label of "defeat" is an extremely poor summary compared to the wealth of data the game actually possesses regarding that player's performance. 3. The opposite problem: a win does not necessarily mean that everyone played at the same level. Naturally, the same principle must apply in both directions. A victory does not automatically imply that all five players delivered an equivalent performance. It is possible to win by making a massive contribution, or to win while primarily benefiting from the efforts of others. Therefore, any individual evaluation system should not be designed as one that simply "rewards those who lose." Instead, it should be a system that more accurately measures each player's actual contribution to the match outcome, regardless of whether the team ultimately won. ...won or lost. 4. I am not proposing a system based simply on KDA. It is crucial to clarify this point. I do not believe Riot should merely reward the player with the most kills, the highest CS, or the best KDA. Such a system would be easily manipulated and could encourage selfish behavior. A player might constantly chase unnecessary kills, ignore objectives, fail to help the team, and focus exclusively on personal statistics. That would not be a solution. Instead, the evaluation should be multidimensional and contextual. 5. Evaluating the entire match. The game already contains a vast amount of information that could be used to construct a much more sophisticated assessment of performance. For example: kill participation; damage dealt; damage absorbed (where relevant to the role); gold and experience relative to one's direct opponent; wave management; towers; turret plates; the Rift Herald; Dragons; Baron; vision (placing wards and controlling vision); participation in skirmishes; map pressure; rotations; advantages created; advantages lost; avoidable deaths; the ability to convert an advantage into an objective; resource control; contribution in team fights; the ability to defend or hold a position; performance differential compared to one's direct opponent; and how the match progressed over time. Most importantly, however, these data points should not be evaluated in isolation. 6. The most important factor: context. The same statistic can have a completely different meaning depending on the situation. It is not enough to know that a player did not participate in a specific fight; one must be able to determine why they were absent and what they were doing instead. Similarly, it is not enough to know that a player failed to secure an objective. One must consider whether: the objective was realistically contestable; the team was present; the player had prepared the area, provided vision, used pings, or created pressure. ...or whether it was simply impossible to contest, due to a situation that had been created beforehand. This principle could be applied to many aspects of the game. In other words, one should not evaluate only what a player did, but also what was realistically possible to do given the situation they were in. 7. The problem of individually unrecoverable situations. This is, in my view, one of the most important points. League of Legends is a team game. A single player may be extremely skilled, but they cannot physically control five positions on the map simultaneously. If one player creates an advantage while other team members consistently concede advantages to the opponents, there comes a point beyond which even the best player can no longer compensate for the situation. The system should be capable of recognizing this phenomenon—not to automatically award a win, nor to guarantee a gain in LP, but to ensure that a collective defeat is not interpreted as a fully accurate reflection of an individual's performance. 8. Smurfs and players significantly above their apparent skill level. Another issue concerns accounts that demonstrate performance levels clearly superior to the rank in which they are playing. The visible rank should not be the only parameter used to determine an account's true skill level. If an account consistently delivers performances that are inconsistent with its current rank, the system should be able to rapidly adjust its estimate of the player's actual skill level. This is particularly important because the presence of a player who is vastly superior to the others can completely alter the course of a match. It is not enough to simply say, "the other team has a strong player, too." The real challenge lies in determining how much that player's presence actually shifts the probability of victory for each team. 9. Proposal: Performance Adjustment. My proposal, therefore, is to introduce—or further develop—a "Performance Adjustment" system that is separate from the simple outcome of the match. The idea is not: "You played well, so you gain LP even if you lose." Instead, it would be: "The match result remains fundamental, but the system adjusts the magnitude of the impact of a win or loss based on the individual performance actually observed and the context in which that performance took place." In conceptual terms: MMR/LP change = match result + opponent skill level + match difficulty + contextualized individual performance + impact on the win/loss—all with different, scientifically calibrated weights. The match result should continue to carry a very high weight. But...However, this shouldn't necessarily be the only variable. 10. The system should also consider the gap between what could have been done and what was actually done. This could be one of the most significant innovations. The system has access to every event that occurs during a match. It can, therefore, construct a form of individual impact assessment: What was the situation? What options were available to the player? What decisions did they make? What was the outcome of those decisions? To what extent did the final result actually depend on their choices? This would make it possible to distinguish between a player who loses because they played poorly and a player who loses despite having done everything reasonably possible to keep the match competitive. 11. Such a system should be resistant to abuse. I am aware that this proposal carries risks. An individual evaluation system could incentivize excessive farming, "KDA farming," ignoring objectives, selfish behavior, or players prioritizing personal statistics over winning. For this reason, the specific mathematical details of the evaluation should not be public, and the assessment should not rely on any single statistic. Instead, it should be built upon a complex model—verified against data from millions of matches and continuously calibrated based on its actual ability to predict a player's contribution to a victory. The goal should not be to reward a specific statistic; rather, it should be to estimate how much a player’s behavior contributed to their team's probability of winning. 12. Do not turn League of Legends into an individual game. I want to emphasize once again that I am not suggesting the removal of the core 5v5 principle. Quite the opposite: such a system could actually place greater value on genuine teamwork. A player who creates advantages for their teammates, sets up objectives, provides vision, participates in team fights, and enables the team to win should be recognized for that contribution. Conversely, a player who racks up impressive personal statistics while consistently harming their team should be subject to a negative evaluation. This would be an assessment of one's actual contribution, rather than a simple evaluation of statistics. 13. The issue of player experience: This is not merely a mathematical problem; it has direct consequences for the competitive experience. When a player repeatedly perceives that their outcome depends primarily on the random mix of teammates—who may be performing exceptionally well or exceptionally poorly—they may conclude that their individual effort does not have a sufficiently strong correlation with the results within the ranked system. This can lead to frustration, a loss of motivation, and, above all, the feeling that individual improvement is not being adequately recognized. A competitive system should instead convey this message to the player: "If you truly improve, the system should be able to recognize it over the long term." This should be a core principle of any ranked system. 14. My request to Riot: I am not asking for an automatic win following a strong performance. I am not asking for free LP. I am not asking for the game to remove the team element. I am asking that Riot seriously consider developing a system in which: matchmaking places greater weight on a player's actual ability rather than just their visible rank; accounts demonstrating a significantly higher skill level are identified and recalibrated more quickly; the true disparities between the two teams are analyzed even after the match has concluded; individual performance is evaluated based on the entire game; objectives and strategic contributions are given appropriate weight; evaluations are contextualized according to the actual situation within the match; a defeat is not necessarily interpreted as a comprehensive measure of an individual's skill level; a victory is not automatically taken as proof that all five players performed at an equivalent level; the system is designed to prevent "stat-farming"; and MMR and/or LP can be adjusted in a controlled manner based on the performance actually observed. In conclusion, League of Legends is one of the most complex competitive games ever created, precisely because the outcome depends on the interaction of five players. Yet, this very characteristic makes it especially important to have a ranked system capable of distinguishing an individual's skill level from the simple fact of being on a winning or losing team. A lost match does not necessarily prove that all five players performed poorly. A lost match does not necessarily prove that all five players performed poorly. A won match does not necessarily prove that all five performed well. Furthermore, a match in which there is a vast disparity between the actual performance of the two teams should not be treated by the system as if it were merely a standard, balanced game that ended in a win or a loss. I therefore believe that the matchmaking system needs to be improved, alongside a more intelligent, context-aware, and manipulation-resistant method for evaluating individual performance. The goal should not be to enable the best player to win single-handedly; rather, the objective should be much simpler: to ensure that, over the long term, the ranked system can accurately gauge a player’s skill level—even when the outcome of an individual match is heavily influenced by the collective performance of the team. If Riot intends for the ranked system to truly reflect the competitiveness and growth of its players, this is an area that, in my view, warrants a serious and thorough overhaul. p.s. I’m no newbie—I’ve known this game since Season 2, back when I already had an Elo of 2,100. I beat Diamond-tier players and win ranked games on Diamond accounts, yet I’m easily dropping from Gold 2 all the way down to Silver 4—teetering on the edge of Bronze—all because of a nonsensical matchmaking system. There are people in Diamond who deserve to be in Bronze, and people in Bronze who deserve to be in Platinum or Diamond, and so on... I hope you read this message. See you soon—regards, Diego #RameRonzolo #T0nn0 Rioot Mare