i live with two sisters who were friends with me before we became roommates. i’ll refer to them as A and B. i’m closer to A than B, but i’ve been feeling hurt by how both of them handled my birthday.
for context, i’ve been working toward a deadline for the past 2–3 weeks. i work full-time and also do freelance work, and during the week of my birthday, i’d mentioned that i was working late and getting off calls around 9–10 pm. A and B are both university students with part-time jobs.
one thing that had been bothering me was the new hunger games movie. i’d been reading the book in our shared spaces and bringing up wanting to see the movie together whenever they asked what i wanted to do for my birthday. i’d been talking about it since the summer, especially after finding out it was releasing the friday after my birthday. i thought that would be a good day since it was the end of the workweek and i’d have more time.
a few weeks before the release, i sent a message in our group chat asking if we could watch it on either of two specific days. neither responded. B, who i’m not as close with, texted A separately saying she thought one of them should reply to me. when i brought it up in person to B, B said she was working but didn’t suggest another day. A eventually got back to me after realizing she hadn’t replied, but by then i’d already bought tickets with another friend because a few days had passed without an answer.
for my actual birthday, A suggested lunch the day before. i told her i wasn’t sure i’d have enough time during the day because of work and suggested dinner instead, but said i’d let her know. i admit i was last minute in confirming because i didn’t know when i’d be able to get off work. i was trying to work overtime that night so i could get ahead and hopefully finish earlier on my birthday. the day of, i ended up saying lunch wouldn’t work, and we agreed on 6 pm for dinner. i recognize that the timing was last minute on my end. the restaurant was about a 45-minute drive away, and A had picked it because her boyfriend said it was good and worth the drive.
at 4:51 pm, A texted, “when do you want to leave?” i replied, “6?” and she said, “Umm it takes 45 mins to get there 😭”. i replied, “well i’m working,” and she responded, “Okk”. i was busy with work and couldn’t keep checking my phone. at 6:09 pm, B asked if we were still doing sushi. A offered to rain-check or go later, but i eventually replied that i didn’t think i could do dinner that day.
they went without me.
i understand that coordinating a 45-minute drive takes planning and that i could have communicated more clearly about when i’d finish. however, we’d already agreed on 6 pm, and i’d mentioned throughout the week that i was working late. i just wish they had offered alternative options or tried to figure out a solution, especially since this was meant to be an informal birthday dinner. even the night before, i’d mentioned that i planned to work late so i wouldn’t have as much to do on my birthday.
it was hurtful that the dinner went ahead without me. when i saw their locations at the restaurant for a few hours, i cried in my room.
A had also been saying for weeks that she would bake me a birthday cake, but the day before my birthday told me she had postponed it because she couldn’t have it ready in time. she had also invited her boyfriend to dinner without asking me first. i don’t have anything against him, but i would have appreciated being asked. afterward, sushi takeout was left outside my bedroom door without anyone telling me when it had been dropped off, so it sat there for an unknown amount of time.
B actually texted me first the day after my birthday asking if i was okay. i replied, “im ngl im really upset,” and she apologized. although i hadn’t clearly explained everything that was bothering me, she seemed to understand what had upset me and acknowledged that i’d been left out. she also admitted she’d forgotten to wish me a happy birthday and offered to do something for me. i appreciated that she reached out without making me defend how i felt. i told her it was okay.
A later texted me, “Hello are u alive from work? Sorry u had tp work on ur bday but I was thinking we could raincheck to maybe monday ? Before u leave”. i eventually sent A a text explaining why i was upset.
this was what i said:
“im ngl, i’m just really hurt and upset by you. i’ve noticed in the past you’ve been inattentive and careless with your relationships. it’s been a recurring problem and yesterday really brought that to light for me.
i really don’t expect much on my birthday but i don’t like how a friend would make me feel so neglected. you didn’t say “happy birthday” to me, either in person or over text. you know that i’ve been incredibly stressed working towards my deadline for the past few weeks, and instead of making my birthday easier or something i could look forward to, i felt like more things were being put on my plate. i suggested watching a movie together which is not a big commitment financially or time wise, yet it was still so difficult to coordinate something and i ended up giving up on that idea with yall. then, you suggested lunch in the middle of my workday, invited your boyfriend to dinner without asking me first, and then put the responsibility on me to figure out the logistics when you knew how overwhelmed i already was. i don’t mind your boyfriend coming, but it was my birthday, and i feel like you should have asked me first. throughout the entire process, i didn’t feel considered. the dinner stopped feeling like it was really about me.
what hurt the most was that you guys ended up going to my birthday dinner without me. it made me feel like following through with the plans was more important than actually celebrating with me, and that my presence at my own birthday dinner wasn’t even necessary.
it still makes me really sad that my birthday ended up feeling like an afterthought. all i wanted was to feel like you remembered and cared and i couldn’t even get a simple “happy birthday” from you.”
i may have been too harsh, but i was really upset when i wrote it.
A responded:
“Im sorry u feel that way it wasn’t my intention to make u feel neglected and ur right I shouldn’t have invited my boyfriend without asking u. But I feel a little upset that because I asked u a few times about ur birthday and u never gave me a set time. It was wrong to eat without u and I should have stayed home and that was being a bad friend on my part. I knew u had work but u never told me u had a deadline and only mentioned that u had meetings so I wasn’t that aware about it until thursday when u kept saying u had a lot of work.
I didnt mean to put the logistics on u I was just looking for a time that u were free. If on ur brithday wasn’t a good time then why didnt u let me know earlier. We could have waited for the weekend or after ur deadline.
i did say happy birthday when I took u to get coffee but im not sure u heard me Im sorry for being unresponsive and about the movie but genuinely thought I texted u I was down for a movie but it never sent. I didnt know work was stressing u out that bad. I wanted to plan something for ur bday and would still like to. We haven’t hung out in a while and we can talk about this more later than over text. Just let me know when ur free and we can do something if ur still up for it”
i appreciate that A acknowledged inviting her boyfriend without asking and admitted that going to dinner without me was wrong. however, i felt that the apology shifted into explaining what i hadn’t communicated. she said i never gave her a set time, even though we’d agreed on 6 pm, and that i hadn’t told her about my deadline, despite me mentioning that i was working late. she also said she had wished me a happy birthday at coffee, although i genuinely don’t remember hearing it.
i wasn’t expecting an elaborate celebration. i just wanted to feel considered and included, especially on my birthday. i know i could have communicated some things better, but i also feel like i’d made several attempts to make plans and was often left to follow up or figure things out myself.
i replied that every day until i leave for thanksgiving break is booked with plans and that we could talk when i get back but i dont even know if these are friendships worth keeping and i’m still really emotional and don’t want to talk in-person.
i’m already planning to move out, which is something i’ve been considering for a while and isn’t solely because of this situation. the location has turned out to be more inconvenient for my day-to-day life than i anticipated, along with a few other things. i’m visiting my parents during thanksgiving and am considering bringing my things with me, but i don’t know if that would be too extreme.
am i overreacting, or were my expectations reasonable? how should i handle this without escalating things?