I (35F) have lived with my best friend and roommate (31F) for three years. Last year, we moved into a house my parents purchased, and we're fortunate to pay the same rent we paid for our previous apartment, although we cover utilities ourselves.
I want to acknowledge upfront that this creates an unusual power dynamic. My roommate has expressed concerns about potentially losing her home if I ever decided I didn't want to live with her anymore. I have absolutely no intention of doing that, and I've tried to reassure her.
I'm very conscious that living in a house owned by my family could make her feel like she has less say in what happens here. I've always tried to make it clear that this is her home just as much as it is mine, and that she has rights, choices, and a voice in how we use our shared space. I don't want her to feel like she needs my permission to live her life or have people over.
But I also feel like, in trying so hard to make sure she feels like she has a say in our home, I've ended up in a situation where I'm the one who doesn't feel like I have a say anymore.
Now, onto the situation:
My roommate started dating her girlfriend (35F) in September. She was introduced to our friend group that month, and within two weeks they were dating. By mid-October, her girlfriend was spending 5–6 days a week at our house, and that has continued.
I genuinely like her girlfriend. She's kind, considerate toward me personally, and someone I consider a friend. I have nothing against her as a person. But I also don't want to live with my friends every day, especially someone I've only known for three months.
Here's what's happening:
- She's at our house 5–6 days a week. My roommate almost never visits her girlfriend's home because it's over an hour away, and her girlfriend works remotely.
- She works from home at our house, meaning she's not just visiting for evenings or sleeping over. She's spending significant portions of her days here.
- She's frequently at our house without my roommate. Sometimes she's there completely alone, and sometimes she's there with me when my roommate is gone. This means even the hours I used to have the house to myself now include another person.
- None of these changes were communicated to me beforehand. I wasn't told when the visits became almost daily, when she started staying at the house without my roommate, or when she was allowed to be here alone.
- She's not contributing to rent or utilities, despite spending most of her time here. She does pay for a lot of things for my roommate, like gifts, dinners out, and groceries she cooks for her at our house. That's very sweet, but those things benefit my roommate rather than contributing to our shared household expenses.
- The increased occupancy is affecting household resources. The washing machine is being used more, we're producing more trash (possibly enough to require a larger, more expensive trash can), and there's less available space in the fridge and freezer. Her belongings are also increasingly occupying shared spaces, although my roommate doesn't seem to view her girlfriend's things as clutter in the same way she views mine.
I've tried discussing this with my roommate multiple times, especially the lack of communication.
When I explained that I would have appreciated being told before these changes happened, her response was, "I didn't know you would want communication about that?" She genuinely seemed surprised that I would expect to be informed before someone started spending most of their time in our shared home.
When I bring up how frequently her girlfriend is here, the response I get is that they aren't going to discuss moving in together until they've been dating for six months, and that "she's not here two nights a week."
But to me, being gone two nights a week doesn't change the fact that she's functionally living here the other five to six.
Where I'm really struggling is figuring out how to discuss this without becoming the bad guy.
In previous conversations, when I've brought up how often her girlfriend is here, my roommate has responded in a really sad voice with things like, "Well, I can tell her she can't be here and she has to go back to her city."
And suddenly I feel like a villain who is asking someone to send their girlfriend away.
Other responses have been things like, "She just really likes us!" or "One day she'll feel like family to you, like she does to me."
I don't doubt that she likes me, and I appreciate that. But someone liking me doesn't automatically mean I want to share my home with them nearly every day. And while she might eventually feel like family, I don't think that should be an expectation placed on me.
I don't want my roommate to feel like she has to choose between having a relationship and making me comfortable. But it feels like the conversation keeps becoming an all-or-nothing situation, where either her girlfriend can be here whenever they want, or I'm the person making her leave.
Another factor is that I'm an introvert who needs alone time to recharge. My roommate knows this about me. I used to have regular stretches of time alone in my home, especially when my roommate was out. Now, even when my roommate is gone, her girlfriend may still be here.
I feel like I've lost a significant amount of privacy and solitude in my own home, without ever agreeing to that change or even being told it was going to happen.
And because my roommate, her girlfriend, and I are all part of the same friend group, there's not much separation socially either. Her girlfriend is also at our group outings and activities. I like spending time with her, but I don't get much of a break from being around her, either at home or socially.
I've also talked to mutual friends, some of whom are friends with the girlfriend, and they've told me they were at their partners' houses 4–5 days a week immediately after they started dating. They seem to consider this a perfectly normal part of dating.
And maybe it is! That's part of why I'm posting. I genuinely want to understand whether my expectations are unreasonable.
I just feel like I've effectively gained a third roommate without ever having a conversation about agreeing to live with a third person.
I understand that my roommate has the right to have guests and spend time with her girlfriend in her own home. I'm not asking her to stop dating or never have her girlfriend over.
But I also feel that I should have some say in changes to our shared living environment, especially when those changes affect my privacy, use of common spaces, and household expenses.
And the six-month rule feels strange to me. I understand not wanting to officially move in together too quickly, but if someone is already spending five or six days a week here, working here, and regularly occupying the house without the person they're dating, how different is that functionally from living here?
I also want to be clear that I'm not trying to use my family's ownership of the house as leverage, and I would never threaten my roommate's housing over a disagreement. I just want us to make decisions that significantly affect our shared living environment together, rather than one of us making those decisions and expecting the other to adjust.
I would really appreciate some outside perspectives, but especially advice on how to move forward.
- Is having a partner over 5–6 days a week a normal and reasonable expectation when you have roommates? At what point does a frequent guest become an unofficial additional roommate?
- Is it reasonable to expect advance communication or agreement before a partner starts staying in the house alone, working from there, or being there when the roommate who invited them isn't home?
- How do I approach boundaries without sounding like I'm demanding that my roommate send her girlfriend away? What would reasonable compromises actually look like?
- How do I respond when my concerns are met with sadness or suggestions that the girlfriend just shouldn't come over at all? I don't want to hurt anyone, but I also don't feel like my concerns are being addressed.
- Is it reasonable to want regular time in my home without additional guests, even when those guests are people I like? How would you negotiate that?
I don't want to control my roommate's relationship, and I don't want her girlfriend to feel unwelcome. I just want to feel like my home is still my home, rather than a place where I have to accommodate an additional person I never agreed to live with.
I'm genuinely interested in hearing different perspectives, including people who disagree with me. I'd especially appreciate practical advice from anyone who has successfully navigated something similar without damaging their friendships.
Also, please let me know if there's a more appropriate subreddit for this question.