r/sailormoon • u/CommentApprehensive3 • 1h ago
Talk/Discussion Sailor Moon's biggest problem.
So these post I've done I have showed I have alot of issues with the anime and manga and because I have this on my chest I gotta tell people how I feel. I think the worst aspect across the manga, the 90s anime, Crystal and some of the video games is the worldbuilding/loredumps or rather the lack of actually thinking through what plot events actually entail. What I see alot in sailor moon is what the author tries to get across being disconnected to the actual reality of a situation. I say this because yes, I do like the lore and background to alot of stuff in sailor moon. I look the star seeds, the pure hearts, the dream mirrors and I even like the idea of cosmos and chaos. However, a big issue with alot of stuff is what I'll dub tell don't show or as tvtropes puts it, Informed attributes.
Basically alot of elements we are told throughout the series either doesn't make sense or the implications aren't even properly done. The most blatant examples are with Queen Serenity, Neo Queen Serenity, and straight up the ending of the manga. Now let's start in order.
Silver Millenium and Crystal Tokyo are supposed to be this utopias with great stuff galore and no issues whatsoever. But the thing is, it doesn't really hold water the more you think about it. Extended lifespans is fine somewhat but then you hear stuff like aggression and negative traits being removed which sounds a bit...awkward. And then you see two rebellions in Crystal Tokyo happen. One is from the black moon clan who think it is unnatural for people to live this long in the manga and in the anime they just want to fight for a better home. We're supposed to see Neo Queen Serenity and King Endymion as this good parent, but they really aren't. Chibiusa being stuck as a kid for 900+ years shouldn't be a thing that happens in the manga and her weird complexes in the manga feel like they're because of how Neo Queen Serenity and King Endymion didn't properly give her actual help. Chibiusa was bullied alot and they didn't do anything about it. I know sometimes you have to suffer to get ahead in life but this is absurd. And then you have the anime. The anime tells us these two are loving as well...but no they're neglectful gaslighters. When you realize chibiusa was bullied, they weren't there for her birthday and they never gave her a hug or helped her up when being kind doesn't have an age limit....it feels like Neo Queen Serenity is a hall of fame asshole. Plus, the inners are just expected to live forever...not attaining their dreams, forever being alone without love and not able to fulfill their goals just because of their duty and Neo Queen Serenity just keeps them around. Yeah something ain't adding up.
And if it was just Neo Queen Serenity and Queen Serenity...this post would just be about them. But no it feels like quite a few stuff aren't given care.
Queen Serenity is a bit less egregious because we do see how she does care about Princess Serenity and she is the one to give Usagi the moon crystal power transformation. However, she is just casually making the guardians child soldiers for no discernable reason which is so weird in the manga. I don't like that at all, especially with the implication that princess serenity is growing faster to compensate for Queen Serenity wanting the inners to be serenity's friend. It comes off as a bit headscratching. However the real reason I gotta question if silver millenium was really that good is nehelenia, specifically the manga version. She simply showed up and said that darkness isn't evil it is the inverse of light, and she isn't wrong. She wasn't even threatening Queen Serenity just wanting to strike a deal. The way nehelenia talked didn't even show sarcasm and Queen Serenity straight up blasted her without even considering what she said. I didn't explain it before but the issue I have with Nehelenia's backstory is what she said during that backstory isn't wrong and Queen Serenity just treats nehelenia like a villain without cause. To me that shows intolerance and shows to me that Queen Serenity isn't this bright eyed goody two shoes. I don't even think Queen Serenity is evil but the framing of this scene is meant to be that this day is some awful day the guardians all the guardians remember. Yes I know nehelenia cursed to make the fall of silver millenium happen, but at the same time, whatcha think would happen when you literally seal someone away on sight with such vitrol. I get she had a dark aura around her but a little bit of empathy can go a long way.
And bro the ending of the manga is all of these unconsidered implications put for us to clown on. I do think the ending itself is good and well-written, but it could've been better. My issue with it is that it kinda just makes the lives of the inners and outers not seem that pleasant ahead and due to the problems of how crystal tokyo is showed, we get this weird dissonace where this ending is supposed to be hopeful but it instead feels like we're about to reach the point where things will become dystopic. It also just feels like we don't focus at all on the inners and outers and their lives. The inners and outers are just treated like backups for Usagi rather than their own people half the time and it becomes atrocius at times.