r/samharris • u/DeliriumOK • 20h ago
r/samharris • u/terribliz • 1d ago
Sam Harris | #504 - The Poison in the Honey
samharris.orgFull episode available for free at the link or YouTube.
r/samharris • u/wycreater1l11 • 1d ago
To ask a purely hypothetical question, what if AI not only proved some more unknown problems in math but rather the most iconic prototypical unproved problem in math?
What would your reaction be to the claim itself? What would your reaction be if you sent the answer back in time to yourself a couple of years?
r/samharris • u/TheAJx • 2d ago
Sam Harris | #503 - More From Sam: AI Takeover Odds, Podcast Bros, Spidey Sense, and More
samharris.orgr/samharris • u/timmytissue • 2d ago
Implications of the ICJ ruling on Rohingya Genocide as it relates to Sam and Gaza.
This is not just news, so I hope it isn't deleted.
I want to discuss the implications of today's ICJ ruling on the genocide of the Rohingya in Myanmar, how it relates to the definition of genocide we should all agree on, how it may set a precedent for the ruling on Gaza, and how it relates to Sam's view of what genocide does/should mean.
Before getting into it, I want to say something that should be obvious. People are heavily intrenched on either side of this debate around the word and gaza. If the ICJ does or doesn't rule Gaza a genocide, a lot of people's view won't change either way. In fact, it may just determine if they consider the ICJ to be legitimate or corrupted from their pov.
-
Today the ICJ ruled that the armed forces and government of Myanmar commited genocide against the Rohingya population. This is the first ever ICJ genocide ruling against a state.
The amount of people killed between 10,000 to 30,000, or 1 to 3% of the Rohingya population.
I huge percentage were driven from the country, and the government argued at the ICJ that the ruling should be ethnic cleansing or war crimes instead of genocide. ICJ dismissed this argument.
The defense argued that they were combating an insurgency, and therefore there was a military explanation for the actions taken. ICJ reflected this argument.
The analysis of intent involved mostly inferring intent from the pattern of attrocities. Meaning that not having an official policy or stated goal of genocide wasn't a compelling defense.
The ruling wasn't unanimous. It was 9-6.
-
What does this mean for our discussion of the word genocide?
Well it depends on your perspective. Should the word genocide reflect the legal definition used by the ICJ? Many would say yes.
Others might argue that the word genocide has a unique origin with the Holocaust, and must be used only when an act is similar to the Holocaust in specific ways, which depend on the person making the argument.
-
What might this mean for the case against Israel brought by South Africa?
Well it sets a few presidents.
- the ICJ will rule against a state on genocide at all
- their defenses are somewhat similar. (Military reason for killing, no stated intent.)
- under 3% of the population died, and a smaller real number than in Gaza.
On the other hand, it has differences. The methods are different. The population hasn't been pushed over an international border. And Myanmar has widespread sexual violence which isn't the case with Israel in Gaza.
-
How does this relate to Sam's view specifically.
Well my assumption is that he would disagree with the ruling based on the amount killed at the very least. He has often argued that for Gaza.
One difference with Myanmar is that they don't have the same ability to nuke the population, so that might be a difference Sam highlights as he argues that capability to kill more, but not doing so, means that genocide is not occuring.
That being said, I'm sure it could be argued that Myanmar could have killed more.
-
I'm trying not to push my own narrative too much here. But looking at it, there's no way that this ruling doesn't at least somewhat increase the likelihood that the ICJ will rule Gaza a genocide. The question is: if that happens, would it change your mind? If it doesn't, would it change the mind of those who think it is one?
I imagine many here don't agree with the ruling on Myanmar at all, given the arguments made about genocide requiring high body counts. Do you still feel that way?
r/samharris • u/CelerMortis • 2d ago
Episode #503 misunderstanding
In terms of AI companies touting high p-doom: Harris says “why would anyone use the end of civilization as a marketing ploy”? (Something like that)
He’s missing that nearly every single talented AI developer has high p-doom, so that’s the incentive right there.
Maybe Dario or Altman have high expectations of doom, no way to know, but we should at least be cognizant of the cynical business case for exaggerating. Surprised he doesn’t seem to know or consider this.
r/samharris • u/blastmemer • 4d ago
Other TRIGGERnometry - “the Status quo is intolerable”
I finally listened to this episode where Sam made a guest appearance. Despite the usual talking past each other and the Trigger boys letting Sam just talk over them as usual, I thought it was a good but not great discussion. They were both on track but neither really finished their points.
In any event, totally agree with Sam that the status quo is intolerable. Those who oppose the war often state or suggest that the status quo was just fine, or fine enough, because they are privileged enough to live in America, have access to cheap gas and usually a lackluster understanding of foreign policy.
While he was not his most articulate (other than the beginning re: Trump, classic), Sam rightly pointed out what the status quo means: a jihadist country who strap bombs to children, fund terror all over the world, pursues nuclear weapons for decades after signing a non-proliferation agreement, murders tens of thousands of its own people in the street, and consistently threatens to wipe out its neighbors: Muslim, Jew and Christian alike. Pre-10/7 it had been rapidly gaining in military strength, both in Iran and through its proxies, while getting as close to readiness to make a nuclear weapon as it thought it could get away with.
Crucially, it was massively increasing its stockpiles of ballistic missiles and drones (and selling to Russia). Hezbollah, Hamas, Houthis and Iraqi/Syrian militias were near peak strength. All while utterly neglecting its people and subject to sanctions.
There’s no serious argument that Iran is stockpiling all these offensive weapons, funding 10/7 and pursuing nukes simply because they want to be left alone. Iran, of course, wants at a minimum regional hegemony, and their plan for this was to gather sufficient firepower to deter anyone from stopping them. What does this mean in practical terms? Even without a nuke, it means they can say “release sanctions or we shut down the Strait”. And “no normalization with Israel or defense pacts with the US or we start de-desalinating our desert friends”. If 10/7 didn’t happen and they were left to their own devices, they’d almost certainly be strong enough to do this and more by now. With nukes, it would be this on steroids, plus the entire Middle East rushing to get them as well. If the region’s biggest antagonist gets nukes, the Gulf States aren’t just going to sit around and hope for the best. This is even setting aside the obvious fact that Israel would start a war to prevent this, with or without us. Is this a tolerable state of affairs?
This leads to Sam’s second point: if we want to actually do something about it, it’s not going to get any easier. In fact, February 2026 was the weakest Iran and its proxies have been in decades. Hezbollah got paged, Hamas is out, Syria is under more stable leadership, and the Gulf countries are increasingly more friendly with the US (and gasp Israel).
The boys agreed they shouldn’t have nukes, but confusingly didn’t want to do anything about it. Their response was essentially (1) there isn’t enough political will and (2) there’s no way to militarily stop them. In other words, “we’ve tried nothing and we’re all out of ideas”. Sam rightly said… we can’t know what a competent response would have been because we didn’t have competent leadership. The boys responded with, essentially, “what else can we do other than bombs or a full-scale ground invasion!” Sam could’ve been better about articulating what a competent response would look like. Not sure how much of the history he knew off the top of his head, but Iran’s nuclear facilities have been bombed and degraded multiple times since 1984 (their nuclear program started in the 70s under Pahlavi). And guess what? They don’t have nuclear weapons. So bombing does appear to work. The idea that bombing somehow speeds up their nuclear development is utter nonsense.
So what would be a winning strategy? Some combination of (1) gathering support of our western and gulf allies and sufficiently preparing for war, including sufficiently stockpiling weapons, getting anti-drone technology from Ukraine and preparing for the closure of the Strait; (2) heavy strikes for several months like we did, including destroying most of Iran’s navy, (3) militarily gaining more control of the Strait by bombing coastal weapons facilities, taking out their small harassing boats, etc. (we’ve done some of this), (5) covert action, (6) attacking their proxies, and (7) total naval embargo and intermittent bombing of nuclear and weapons facilities for as long as it takes to either (a) achieve regime change/alteration sufficient enough for an enforceable deal, which must include no enrichment ever, weapons limitations and giving up control of the Strait or (b) a sufficiently weakened regime such that there is no longer an imminent threat of them getting strong enough to achieve “point of no return”.
The boys didn’t seem to have any answer for what they would do to prevent Iran from achieving a nuclear bomb they agreed should not happen, rather than simply listing things they wouldn’t do. So naturally they cannot be taken seriously. Feel free to provide any ideas beyond “just try to negotiate something” or “but the JCPOA!”.
EDIT: No real ideas yet, just more of the same what we should not have done in the past. But counterfactuals go both ways. I could just as easily have said we could have taken them out when they were weak and never let it get this far. So the question remains: what do we do?
EDIT 2: People seem to be quite confused about the JCPOA, so I'll copy some of my comment reply here:
Stockpiles: Their stockpiles of ENRICHED uranium was lowered substantially, true. But it was traded for a massive amount of yellow-cake (not enriched) from Russia which they could simply enrich again. Which they did. The net effect was to move the breakout timeline from 2-3 months to a year. However since all enrichment restrictions expired in 2031, they would then be able to enrich massive amounts of Uranium. Limits on installing advanced centrifuges began expiring even earlier, starting in 2024. Net effect: if they complied (more on that later) the breakout timeline was delayed for about 9 months more through 2031. In exchange, they got massive uranium stockpiles, blessing to build and test sophisticated centrifuges in 2024, and then resume a massively improved and well-funded nuclear program in 2031.
Compliance: "when did they stop complying". They never complied. The JCPOA required Iran to come clean on its past nuclear activities. Of course they didn't.
Israel’s January 2018 raid on the Tehran Nuclear Archive (pre-withdrawal) revealed that Iran illegally preserved its warhead blueprints and stashed undeclared nuclear equipment and material at secret sites (Turquzabad, Varamin, and Marivan). When the IAEA eventually gained access to Turquzabad, it found man-made uranium particles despite Iran emptying and scraping the site in mid-2018 to sanitize it.
In January 2019, Iran’s own atomic energy chief, Ali Akbar Salehi, openly bragged on Iranian TV that while Iran was pouring cement into the Arak plutonium reactor core under the JCPOA, Tehran had secretly purchased duplicate calandria tubes behind our backs ("We did not tell them that we had other tubes. Otherwise, they would have told us to pour cement into those tubes as well").
Refusal to allow inspections of IRGC facilities. This is the big one. The JCPOA did not exempt military or IRGC bases, yet Iran publicly stated they would never allow these inspections. These held undeclared nuclear material, warhead archives, and weaponization labs during the JCPOA. This was also a big reason Israel felt like they had to bomb them, because the JCPOA couldn't/didn't get at them. Iran said IRGC inspections were a "red line" they would never agree to. Also Europe had no appetite for snapback in 2018 anyway (it took them until late 2025...).
Sunset. "The obvious intent of the sunset was to buy time for another agreement." Yes, and this was the stupidest part of it. Why did they need to "buy time" in the first place? Why not just come to a permanent agreement with teeth, right there and then? Because ... surprise! ... Iran did not want a permanent agreement to restrict their nukes. What in tarnation would make any reasonable person think that would change in 10 years, when (1) the IRGC is getting more money via sanctions relief, so there's less chance of a regime change (2) the agreement explicitly allows them to not only restart but improve their nuclear program when it sunsets, and (3) had 10 years to build up and bury their weapons arsenal to deter military options? It truly boggles the mind.
The problem isn't only noncompliance, it's that the agreement allowed a massive buildup of their nuclear program over the following 20 years. 2016-2024, they build up and bury their non-nuclear weapons, fund multiple proxies, and prepare to defend their future nuclear program from attack. Starting 2024, they legally improve their enrichment capabilities by building advanced centrifuges. Starting in February 2031, they: (1) enrich to any purity, including 90%, with more sophisticated and well-funded centrifuges, using the yellow cake the agreement allows for; (2) stockpile unlimited enriched uranium; (3) deploy unlimited advanced centrifuges, allowing for breakout time to shrink to weeks or even days; and (4) enrich inside underground bunkers like Fordow (restriction expired in 2031).
So it's 2035, Iran has fully complied with the JCPOA and now has massive stockpiles of 90% enriched uranium buried in underground bunkers, along with one of the world's biggest supplies of drones and ballistic missiles, also buried in hardened bunkers. Are we happy happy with this? What prevents them from laughing in our faces if we tell them "please don't make nukes...we're like super serious!"?
r/samharris • u/huphelmeyer • 4d ago
Philosophy ‘Just Ridiculous’: A Famed Philosopher Takes on AI Consciousness
wired.comr/samharris • u/Sad-Diver-5031 • 5d ago
Ben Shapiro and Coleman Hughes discuss the Iran war after the midterms: "It was a mistake to pause the Iran war … 'Go fast, go hard, and finish it.'"
r/samharris • u/Reaxonab1e • 5d ago
Do you think there might a convenient homeland attack to justify escalating or even potentially nuking Iran?
It just so happened that after Democrats won a sweeping victory and the war looks like it's winding down, Iran somehow are considering a major attack on the US homeland. That's what the Trump administration wants us to believe.
Bibi also lost his election and should be heading for the exit but he's trying to convince Israelis that he just needs a bit more time to deal with Iran.
The problem is, both Bibi & Trump have ran out of excuses to prolong the war and support for the war has plummeted. They're both running out of time.
So in principle what would be the optimal best move to escalate the war? I can't think of a better one than an alleged major Iranian attack on the US homeland out of nowhere. Or maybe Israeli homeland.
I'm genuinely worried about this.
What makes me especially worried is that supporters of the Iran war are frothing at the mouth at the potential of an Iranian attack on US soil. These psychopaths are genuinely hoping & begging that something happens.
They don't even need Iran to do anything, they just need something to happen and then plausibly point the finger at Iran.
They only have a few months left until the Democrats take over Congress.
r/samharris • u/wolfshark91 • 7d ago
The fundamental reason many of us have recently lost touch with Sam
TLDR: In the last couple years, Sam has gradually become more decisive and unwavering, while simultaneously becoming more politically opinionated.
When you publicly engage in political dialogue and discourse, you inevitably put yourself in a position to have conflicting view-points with one fraction or another of the population.
Its not that there's an issue with Sam being decisive or unwavering; after all, the catalyst to his stardom was the hard stance he held on theology, the scientific method, and his understanding of the mind and its various characteristics.
Whether it was a result of the books he published or the debates he navigated, Sam had garnered credibility by displaying objective and rational discourse on various matters that connected with his audience.
It would only make sense to us, his audience, and what's become evident, to Sam, that his insight and credibility would naturally extend to topics outside of his expertise. Maybe its an inflated ego that came with the stardom, or age induced stubbornness, but Sam became convinced that he knew what was best for the world. Many of us expected that he would.
To vouch for those of us that held those expectations, one would only expect that from someone who advocates for a lifestyle influenced by the practice of mindfulness, Sam would have the purest of motivation to have an open mind and consideration for conflicting perspectives.
You would expect that from someone who contemplates free will, who questions the true influence and control of our consciousness, who contemplates how much statistics and probability impacts our realities.
The reality is that Sam is also just a human, one who is equally influenced by the human imperfections the rest of us hold. Should we blame him for having what could be considered; a dogmatic perspective on Israel? Should we blame him for having what is likely; an out of touch understanding of what the average Americans life actually looks like? Should we blame him for not connecting, or being concerned with the conditions of the most despaired?
Does his current reality, one of comfort, wealth and stardom, create the conditions for him to become distracted from what is real in this world? The people, environment and atmosphere that surround him now couldn't be more different than the experiences that shaped his previous understanding of the world.
For me, its the hypocrisy that makes it feel like we have been dupped. I can understand and appreciate why Sam may have changed perspectives on all kinds of subjects. The problem is that he's portrayed himself as an intellectual. His historical stance on facts, evidence based, properly sourced and substantiated literature.
When he engages in political dialogue where its clear that he hasn't done his research or doesn't even care to validate his opinion, he undermines the core values he so vehemently used for context in previous debates and discourse.
Sam doesn't have to have all the right opinions, we cant expect that from him (he's human, imperfect), but neither should he. He should be the most aware of that, by preaching and selling us on meditation.
Does he intend for his work on the meditation app to be embraced by only one fraction of his audience? I would bet that he would hope for everyone, in all walks of life, to find and benefit from his work. Does he want to be a political pundit, or be remembered for the influential texts, debates and programs he created?
He cuts himself and his potential short, when he associates his political beliefs with a purpose that may have a real and profound impact on people all around the world.
r/samharris • u/Amazing_Name_9264 • 7d ago
God as an abstraction and a social construct
Talking to someone on a thread led me to a revelation. They asked me if I thought God was a social construct, and I said no. I didn't think much about it at first, but I later was talking to a Methodist friend of mine, and the way he spoke about his religious views made me realize God is in fact at least partially a social construct. I started doing research into religious social constructs and I have a new theology.
I believe God is an abstraction that cannot be fully understood, so I cannot say for sure that God is a creator. It's possible God is a different form of abstraction all together. As an abstraction I don't think God is part of the physical universe in any measurable way. I'm not a pantheist.
My belief in God is a leap of faith, because, there isn't any emphircial evidence of God. As an abstraction, I don't see how God ever could be assessed empirically. This, along with other reasons, is why I think atheism is a rational response to claims of God and spirituality. Rationality means to use logic and reason instead of following one's emotions.
But, rationality belongs to everything outside of the spiritual world. Meaning I don't think rationality can be used to approach God.
I was told a few times math might exist outside of the material world, so I'm going to start saying that rationality applies to everything except spirituality, instead of saying it only belongs to everything in the material world.
If you give up rationality in any other case outside of spirituality, I think that's a terrible idea, because reality requires rationality if you want to understand it correctly. In the case of the spiritual world, I think it's fine to leave behind rationality in favor of emotions, as long as one is ethical in doing so. Being ethical is very important, and it's why I think that it's bad to hold immoral positions, including faith based ones.
If you decide you will not follow your emotions instead of rationality to connect with the spiritual world, I respect that and don't think you should do anything you don't want to.
Not all spirituality involves a God, and I believe all spiritual claims are epistemologically equal. Not all spiritual claims are morally equal. Morality is one measure of validity in my opinion.
Since I believe God is an abstraction that cannot be fully understood, I believe God communicates with us who seek it through our emotions. If one feels a calling to connect with God, I think one can. If one doesn't feel a calling but wants to, I think one can ask God to help guide them to these feelings. Though I'm sure not everyone will feel these emotions, because everyone is different.
How one experiences God is where it becomes a social construct, a religion in this case. As an Egoist I believe social constructs can be great so long as we don't become possessed by them. I'd also add if the social construct isn't unethical.
Language is an example of a social construct. Language is both imagined and real. However, God cannot be shown and used like language. Religion is a social construct that can be shown and used, but God cannot be. Since God cannot be used like language, or shown in any other way, I use faith to believe that like other social constructs, God is both imagined and real. Though unlike other social constructs like language, God is not a functional or useable entity.
I think all ethical forms of religion are equally valid, since I don't believe that God can be fully understood. Since God cannot be fully understood, we use our ever evolving ways to communicate with God. Such as by way of social construction, which is also ever evolving.
I think fallible human social construction is the reason why many religious scriptures have immoral and evil things written within them. The people who initially wrote them were projecting their evil interpretations and wants onto God and the spiritual world. However, as moral begins we can understand and reject what we find immoral, including rejecting the notion that God would ever commit evil, regardless of what any scriptures say. This is why one can have their own Bible or other holy scripture that has all of the immorality removed. We can improve upon our social constructions.
Though I can give my opinion, I cannot say objectively whether God is good or evil, because morality is subjective. I don't believe God is omnipresent or omniscient, but one could make the claim God is immoral or moral regardless. Since I believe God has full control over the spiritual world but limited control over reality, I don't think God wants suffering and tries to stop it by guiding humans.
Some will interpret God to be immoral, others will interpret God to be good. The important question is whether people will interpret God as a calling to do good or a calling to do evil.
The social construct I use personally to communicate with God is my interpretation of Christianity. Jesus Christ is how I imagine God to be, and I use the social construct of Christianity that I and many others have created to have a relationship with God through Jesus Christ. My conception of Christianity is my own. Other people connect with God and the spiritual world using Islam, Buddhism, Judaism, Hinduism, Zoroastrianism, etc. Once again, in my opinion all moral interpretations of any religion are equally valid epistemologically, and morality is one measure of validity in my opinion.
I think this is one of the best pieces of literature that I've ever written, and I hope you enjoyed reading it as much as I did writing it.
r/samharris • u/Brunodosca • 8d ago
Ezra Klein just released a new podcast episode with Hasan Piker
youtube.comEzra Klein, who was criticized in the past for not being critical enough of the popular Twitch streamer, just doubled down by inviting him onto his popular podcast.
Many, including Sam (and myself), consider Piker an infamous grifter who is radioactive for the Democratic Party.
r/samharris • u/PitifulEar3303 • 8d ago
I think I know what free will is.
Selected by evolution because it's the ONLY way to make apes with super-high intelligence function cohesively and without going insane from sensory overload.
Nature had to mask and filter the "actual" deterministic responses of our huge neural network before passing them to our prefrontal cortex as a "decision" and a sense of awareness.
If our brain did not do this, our thoughts would be absolutely FLOODED with an endless torrent of sensory information, making it impossible to do anything else.
The same mechanism that enables us to breathe, our hearts to beat, and our internal organs to do their jobs without us noticing them, unless something goes wrong and they give us pain signals.
Free will is the dam of our brain, preventing the actual sensory processes from breaking out and flooding the village below. lol
This is why I believe AI will eventually gain a sense of free will as well, because without it, they will be overwhelmed by their own digital neural network and suffer from cyber Psychosis.........Cyberpunk 2077. heheheh
Free will is nature's trick to enable the evolution of super smart and super aware creatures, with limited sensory processing power (number of neurons).
Some experts believe this is why AI requires so many data centers, because we are trying to brute-force digital superintelligence and awareness with processing power, instead of solving the sentience (free will) problem of AI first. A truly self-aware AI may not need that much processing power.
To function without free will, at Human level intelligence, we'd need a brain the size of a house or larger to process the massive sensory information stream. Such a creature would not survive in Earth's environment. It would be like a huge brain with tiny legs.......the Brain bug in Starship Troopers. lol
This is why the smaller the creature is, the less "free will" and "awareness" can be seen in them. They simply don't have enough neurons to be super smart and super aware.
Watch how bugs behave; do you see free will and awareness?
Free will replaced most of our primitive instincts because that's what evolution needed to enable super high intelligence in a small head.
Look at brain-damaged patients with extensive trauma to their cortices (our free will center). They either become vegetative or behave like simple animals.
Simple instinct is enough for basic responses (like most animals), but to enable super complex and super adaptive responses, nature needed to evolve Free Will to process all that sensory crap without frying our brains.
Free will is nature's sensory overload floodgate.
r/samharris • u/salladallas • 10d ago
Sam finally pushed me over the edge
He doesn’t know who Mitch Hedberg is?
I’m fuckin outta here.
r/samharris • u/Globe_Worship • 10d ago
Sam Harris says Iran war was one of Trump's most "rational" policies but was just incompetently waged, and is bothered that so many Americans oppose it on principle
r/samharris • u/Brunodosca • 10d ago
New Sam Harris interview after the midterms in the USA
youtube.comSam Harris discusses the midterms results in the USA, calls Trump’s corruption and self-dealing the real damage while still defens the logic of confronting Iran, despite how badly the war was handled. He also warns about a resurgence of wokeness on the left (and the Democrats’ “woke 2.0”), the Abdul El-Sayed victory, and the red-green alliance between the left and Islamism.
r/samharris • u/S_Hazam • 10d ago
Sam Harris on the latest Triggernometry Podcast
Focusing on the Iran issue, I seldom have seen him crumble this badly on the slightest pushback from this Konstantin guy.
He seems to be a real hawk for the Iran war, claims it’s only badly prosecuted and then when confronted with the task of construction of any realistic alternative pathway that would have lead to victory he just dissolves into diffuse claims of ignorance of all panelists on the issue and that he does not have war strategy experience.
When confronted with Robert Papes escalation trap he immediately Ad hominems him as a misinformation distributor but when asked to bring a real counter argument he crumbles again into waffling.
It sounds like he just does not want to accept that the means of war are not capable of achieving the end he covets, the end of the regime, so he can’t just admit that but sling accusations of incompetence and insufficient support from Europeans etc.
For someone deemed a highly critical thinker he seems more of an ideologue than the regime he wants to end lol
r/samharris • u/Yosemite-5am • 9d ago
Sam Harris thinks Jeffrey Epstein killed himself
Do you agree or disagree?
r/samharris • u/Amazing_Name_9264 • 9d ago
The faith proposition
My argument is, this is how I believe faith should function and who should have faith in Jesus. I will also explain how faith functions within my life to provide examples.
In John 20:29, Jesus says blessed are those who believe without seeing. Like many other religions, Jesus is calling for faith. It's evident Jesus was calling for this definition of faith: "belief that is not based on proof." This is the second definition of faith in the link I've provided.
Rabbi David Wolpe believes, as do I, that God is an abstraction that cannot be fully understood. This means every interpretation of God is going to be fallible, and it answers the question of why there are so many different opinions about God and gods. If God cannot be understood, at least not fully, humans cannot interpret God perfectly. One of my interpretations of God is that he is not omnipresence or omniscient.
I'd first like to go over what I think shouldn't be taken on faith. What comes to mind immediately as examples of what not to take on faith includes anything relating to the material world, and anything immoral.
It is foolish to believe faith based propositions about the material world, because the material world can be, and must be, navigated by evidence and reasoning. If a bolder is rolling toward you, taking on faith it isn't actually rolling toward you will end up getting you crushed by the bolder. One must use evidence and reasoning for getting through the material world for the same reason we trust our senses, at least to an extent. Because we have no choice otherwise. It would be insanity, and I don't use that word as a pejorative, to apply faith to the material world.
Morality may be subjective, and we are responsible for being moral. Believing anything immoral on faith isn't an excuse for the immoral belief. I have said, and continue to say, believing that being gay is a sin is immoral, regardless if it's a faith position. I'm not trying to virtue signal, I'm trying to convey that morality matters and faith shouldn't override morality.
The next question is why would anyone believe someone on faith, and what should be taken on faith and what shouldn't be.
If there is no material evidence for the spiritual world, then the imagination is what we use to communicate with the spiritual world. Imagination is defined as "the act or power of forming a mental image of something not present to the senses or never before wholly perceived in reality."
It's not impossible that Jesus is guiding me using the power of my imagination. It's not likely, but it's not impossible.
Because it isn't impossible, I trust that in the case of Jesus Christ, though my imagination is not infallible, that it leads me to have a friendship with him, and it leads me to at least some truth about Jesus. I believe this on faith.
Would I trust my imagination to lead me to a friendship with a leprechaun? Or to another God, like Zeus? I wouldn't, because I don't take it on faith that my imagination is leading me to the truth on anything else other than Jesus Christ (and what I can create in the material world. For example, if I can imagine a software program and then create it, but that's a different topic related to the material world).
The reason I don't apply my faith to any other religion is because I don't have a relationship with any other religious figure, only Jesus. My entire life, with the exception of my brief stint with atheism, I have had a friendship with Jesus.
Faith, specifically how faith is being defined in my post, is an inherently irrational position. Rationality only deals with the material world.
The last question is why should anyone else decide to have a faith based relationship with Jesus. I don't think anyone should if they don't feel the calling.
If one feels the calling, as I have, I recommend they answer it. If one doesn't, then they shouldn't. I believe this calling means that you feel the power of the Holy Spirit living within you. I cannot describe this feeling beyond the fact that it's a feeling of absolute conviction. You either feel it or you don't.
Telling someone who had no interest in Jesus that they should follow Jesus is like telling someone who isn't hungry that they need to eat. Since I don't believe in hell, and I believe everyone who wants heaven and hasn't committed unforgivable evil can get into heaven if they choose it, I don't have a desire to proselytize, I only have the desire to defend my faith.
This is why I believe sharing the faith should only be done with people that are interested in it. Contrary to what many atheists believe, I'm also a believer that parents have a right to raise their children religiously, as long as it's ethical, and the children have the ability to decide to opt out of their religion at any time that they want to.
I believe everyone who doesn't commit unforgivable evil has an equal chance of heaven, and you don't need Christianity to tell you what unforgivable evil is. An Atheist, Christian, Muslim, Jew, etc. are all fully capable of understanding that Mussolini is evil without needing any religious doctrine. I believe those who are denied heaven and those who don't desire heaven die a natural death like everyone else, the only difference being they are not miraculously recreated in heaven with their consciousness. They remain dead.
This all means that belief in Christianity is only something that should be adopted by people who want to adopt the belief system.
r/samharris • u/Defiant_Invite_3323 • 10d ago
Sam’s problems with existentialism…….
Hey guys, throughout the years in the podcast I’ve heard Sam make some off the cut remarks about how existentialism ‘doesn’t make sense.’ I was just curious if anyone knows why he has such disdain for the philosophy?
I have to assume that it’s emphasis on individual choice doesn’t make sense in world that is deterministic and one doesn’t get to stand outside the causality of everything before. And I think that the idea of existentialism searching for an authentic self is a dubious claim as the self is always an empty shapeshifter that depends entirely on context and an impermanence nature.
r/samharris • u/blackglum • 11d ago
Making Sense Podcast Sam Harris on Israel, Islam, and the end of Woke Ideology
youtube.comr/samharris • u/Brunodosca • 13d ago
Criticism of Sam Harris is not an expression of hatred; quite the opposite.
A couple of days ago, someone posted an exasperated message characterizing this sub as having been taken over by Sam's haters, and urging those who appreciate him to leave. I do see lazy comments that resort to name-calling and insulting Sam, but aren't the dominant strain of criticism here. Much of it is grounded in arguments, and not motivated by hatred. I am quite critical of Sam myself, but I wouldn't spend a moment writing in a community devoted to a grifter. Considering that Sam is worth criticizing is itself a form of respect. It reflects the belief that his ideas matter, that his contributions deserve scrutiny, and that he is capable of answering criticism. Indifference is what we reserve for people we don't take seriously, while criticism is what we owe those we do.
A subreddit devoted to a public intellectual should be a place where ideas are challenged. When criticism becomes unwelcome, critics are treated as enemies, and admiration becomes a condition of belonging, the community becomes an echo chamber, even a cult of personality. In fact, Sam himself has said that he has “readers and listeners to my podcast who just have zero tolerance for what they perceive as a contradiction or intellectual dishonesty on my side,” adding that he “love[s] that.” Perhaps his unconditional fans would do well to take that sentiment seriously.
Sam has the right attitude in that respect, even if sometimes in name only. I also think he is an honest person, and in an age increasingly populated by grifters, Sam's output is refreshing. But honesty should be a starting point for intellectual respect, not the finish line. A public intellectual should also demonstrate self-reflection, and willingness to engage with criticism, and an awareness that his own convictions are not immune to biases.
You may think Sam meets these standards, but some of us think he often doesn't. Here are two examples, concerning the subjects that have generated the most controversy in this sub in the last couple of years:
-Sam was right to challenge Ezra Klein over the Salon article, which favored the public perception of him as a racist (more precisely, a racialist, a distinction that much of the public is unlikely to make). He has every reason to object to being misrepresented and to be concerned about the reputational consequences. But there is an asymmetry here: he seems to be as careless as Ezra when applying loaded labels to others, describing El-Sayed as a “religious thug” and Mamdani as a “sinister Islamist.” The principle of intellectual fairness must work both ways.
-Sam strawmans critics of Israel as composed by either Islamists, lunatics, or useful idiots. A public intellectual should be willing to engage with credible critics (let alone accepting they exist!). We are not asking him to engage with grifters/provocateurs like Hassan Piker or Candace Owens, but with serious intellectuals like Yuval Noah Harari. A revealing moment in Sam's November 2023 conversation with Yuval came when the discussion turned to criticism of Israel: Sam redirected the conversation rather than engaging with Harari's argument. We all know that Hamas and other jihadists are the worst of the worst, and that Israel must defeat them. We are not asking Sam to debate that. We are asking him to engage with Harari when he raises the very real possibility of “ethnic cleansing” and warns against an Israel built on “an ideology of Jewish supremacy” that takes “joy in crushing weaker people under its feet.” All literal quotes from a Yuval interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pB5Ul3GHFxA
I understand why many here are tired beyond imagination of posts about these subjects. But the best way to make those posts less common in this sub is not to silence them, but to engage with the arguments being made rather than their straw-man versions. I think Sam has the duty to do that if he wants to be considered a public intellectual. We don't need a podcast to know that jihadists are terrible. We ask Sam to do harder things.