For the past few months I have been slowly but surely making the majority of my own Heavy Combat kit myself out of pickle barrel. The intention is to either keep it like that or use it as a test while I slowly upgrade everything to metal.
Anyway, I have made an observation on the two types of barrel I have been able to collect.
Barrel 1: darker blue with two bands along it. This one is dang near perfect. The plastic is thick, very sturdy, easy to shape and holds that shape extremely well. After left alone for a month, these pieces are still holding their shape and I cant bend them at all using normal human strength. The only con to this barrel is the two bands which creates a bit of a aesthetic problem unless you are able to work them into your design, thus I've only been using it for smaller pieces.
Barrel 2: a lighter blue and white on the inside. Has no bands along the sides so it eliminates the issue with barrel 1. Easy to shape as well and seems to be the same thickness as barrel 1. However, I find this plastic, even when left alone for over a week, is significantly easier to bend with a little pressure (but obviously springs back once that pressure is gone) and it also doesnt keep its shape very well. Again, if left for a week after shaping, using the same process as with barrel 1, it'll flatten out a lot by itself. I am still testing methods on how to make it keep its shape but at this point, it seems once these pieces are done, they will need to be tightly strapped at all times to ensure they dont flatten themselves out too much.