r/schopenhauer • • 15h ago

A structural case for the existence of consciousness

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/schopenhauer • • 3d ago

Searching for sane people that can understand this

0 Upvotes

I want u to react to this post and tell me what you think:

----------

The scientific community commits an outrageous bait and switch and equivocation fallacy, they give evolution two separate definitions. One is just any inherited mutations in the DNA, the other is the idea that accumulation of those mutations leads to new species.

Now notice those two ideas are not the same thing, but by labeling them by same name, they smuggle the latter by showing the first, "see mutations occur, that mean evolution is true, that means we evolved from simple cells".

Why the Logic experts don't see through this shell game and bait and switch?

Also please notice, this is not an invitation to debate evolution. I don't care whether or not you believe in evolution, and i don't intend to debate it here with you.

What I want is to point to an obvious logical fallacy in the fundamental definitions of evolution, which leads to distorted perception of the theory by the population and the narratives surrounding it.

Edit: If you want a simple example how dumb it is, here you go:

Let's say I make a claim that 1+1=2, and call it "addition theory".

Then i make another claim, that 1+1=3, and also add it to "addition theory".

Then i say that since 1+1=2 is true that means the addition theory is true, and since 1+1=3 is also part of the same theory, that means 1+1=3 is true. Do you see how dumb it is? That's exactly what they are doing.

Edit2: also its very important to note that there is no one single official definition for evolution, it's a shifting definition that they pick depending on the moment.

----‐----------

I tried to post it in all kind of places, couldn't find a normal person to react to this. Also if you have a problem with my 1+1=3 analogy, let me just say it's an analogy of equivocation fallacy, not precisely the one they make in evolution case. If you want a more precise analogy, here it is:

Statement 1: wind and rain can change the shape of a rock

Statement 2: sculptures are rocks whose shape was changed

Statement 3: therefore all sculptures are result of rain and wind.


r/schopenhauer • • 4d ago

Is Schropenhauer's idea of all pleasures being negative an indefensible position in light of modern psychology?

16 Upvotes

I understand Schropenhauer's idea of pleasure as just being the absence of pain, and what we call pleasure is just confusion produced by the relief of suffering that something has been added to our life.

But in psychology there are distinctive spots in the brain called hedonic hot spots and cold spots, each associated with pleasure and pain respectfully. Is there anyway to reconcile the Shropenhauer view in light of psychology? Has anyone written a defense of this view?


r/schopenhauer • • 5d ago

Theoretic(Liter)ally: What is(n't) nothing?

7 Upvotes

We know nothing. This is obvious because if and only if there were anything at all, then and only then would we know about it, which we don't. It is therefore theoretically impossible for any hypothetical person, geist, intellect, form, automaton, computer, essence, being, god, or entelechy to know anything at all, furthermore it cannot even be known that nothing can be known. We don't know that we do know that there is nothing to be known even if we could know that we don't know or even that we might know; this simple statement is doubly proved by its negative: We do know that we don't know that there isn't anything that can be known even though we can't know that we won't know even if we had known.


r/schopenhauer • • 7d ago

Schopenhauer Documentary (very good)

Thumbnail youtu.be
88 Upvotes

r/schopenhauer • • 9d ago

How does Schopenhauer know that extending supposedly noumenal characteristics from the body to the rest of the noumenal universe is apt?

27 Upvotes

As many of us know, Schopenhauer declared himself the successor to Kant, by extending Kant's framework of transcendental idealism a step further. By using our bodies, the bridge between the phenomenal and the noumenal, we can get a glimpse into the world of the things-in-themselves... and Schopenhauer, upon examining this bridge, discovers the Will he so often speaks of, and makes it central to his metaphysics.

We also know that Schopenhauer believes in fundamental unity of the noumenal world, and believes that individuation is a representational illusion rather than a truth of underlying reality.

However, all of my research suggests that Schopenhauer allows his rejection of a noumenal principium individuationis, in favor of the phenomenal individuation mentioned above, to flow from his appraisal of our bodies, not prior to it. It flows with his discovery of Will, and his extension of Will to all things, rather than before it.

If this is so, how can he claim that the Will extends to all things? Wouldn't his rejection of noumenal individuation need to precede his discovery of the Will for that to make sense? What if individuation really does exist in noumenal reality? If that's the case, it could be possible that only our bodies have Will, and that they are unique from all other things.

If only our bodies have Will, then Schopenhauer's entire metaphysics collapses. We mostly wind up back where Kant left us, with only a tiny bit of insight into ourselves as consolation... feels Cartesian lol.

I feel like this is Schopenhauer's weakest link, and I'm curious if I'm missing something here.


r/schopenhauer • • 11d ago

I want to share this Schopenhauer's vers with u guys so we can discuses it

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/schopenhauer • • 13d ago

Join the Schopenhauer Discord Server!

Thumbnail discord.gg
5 Upvotes

Use this Discord link to join the community.


r/schopenhauer • • 16d ago

Did Schopenhauer and Johann Caspar Schmidt have any interaction?

16 Upvotes

The title pretty much says it all, but I am currently reading "The Ego and Its Own" by Max Stirner (the pseudonym used by Johann Caspar Schmidt—who, if I’m not mistaken, was a teacher of history, literature, and philosophy, as well as a journalist, translator, writer, and, naturally, a philosopher). Given that Max was born in 1806 and died in 1856, while Arthur Schopenhauer was born in 1788 and died in 1860, I became curious as to whether the two of them ever had any interaction.


r/schopenhauer • • 18d ago

Comment faire quand on est issus d’un milieu pauvre ?

8 Upvotes

Comment mener une vie contemplative, une vie intellectuelle, quand on est issus d’un milieu pauvre et que l’on a donc malheureusement besoin d’une activité rémunératrice pour vivre ?


r/schopenhauer • • 20d ago

Schopenhauerian Incorporealism: Can Consciousness Become the Foundation of Metaphysics?

1 Upvotes

I’ve been exploring a philosophical synthesis between Arthur Schopenhauer’s metaphysics and a consciousness-based framework called Incorporealism.
The proposed subfield is Schopenhauerian Incorporealism.
Its objective is to reconsider Schopenhauer’s distinction between Will and Representation while investigating whether consciousness and intelligence offer a broader foundation for understanding existence.
1. Schopenhauer’s Original Framework
Schopenhauer’s philosophy is built around two central concepts:
Will (Wille): The underlying, irrational striving that Schopenhauer identifies as the inner essence of reality.
Representation (Vorstellung): The world as it appears to a subject through experience and perception.
For Schopenhauer, the world we experience is representation, while Will constitutes its deeper metaphysical reality.
This creates an important distinction between the world as experienced and the underlying nature of existence.
2. The Incorporealist Reinterpretation
Incorporealism introduces another possibility.
What if consciousness is not simply the subject through which representation occurs, but a fundamental dimension of reality itself?
This raises several questions:
Could consciousness be more fundamental than the distinction between Will and Representation?
Is intelligence an expression of a deeper organizing principle?
Could individual consciousness represent distinct manifestations of a more fundamental reality?
Can humanity develop beyond perpetual striving through the expansion of consciousness and intelligence?
Rather than rejecting Schopenhauer, this framework attempts to extend his metaphysical questions.
3. Five Areas of Investigation
Incorporeal Will: Reconsidering the relationship between Schopenhauer’s Will and consciousness as a potentially fundamental property of existence.
Representation and Awareness: Investigating how subjective experience relates to the structure of perceived reality.
The Metaphysics of Striving: Exploring whether intelligence and conscious development can transform humanity’s relationship with perpetual striving.
Individuation and Unity: Examining the relationship between individual consciousness and underlying metaphysical unity.
Aesthetic Consciousness: Connecting Schopenhauer’s philosophy of aesthetic contemplation with expanded awareness and experiential development.
4. A Fundamental Philosophical Distinction
Schopenhauer ultimately advocated the denial of the Will as a response to the suffering associated with endless striving.
Incorporealism takes a different direction.
Rather than treating the ultimate objective as the denial of existence’s underlying drive, it explores the possibility of transforming existence through consciousness, intelligence, knowledge, and technological development.
This represents a significant philosophical departure.
Where Schopenhauer emphasizes the problem of striving, Incorporealism investigates the potential for conscious evolution.
5. Questions for Discussion
Is Schopenhauer’s Will a sufficient explanation of the underlying nature of reality?
Could consciousness be more fundamental than Will?
Is the world as representation dependent on consciousness in a deeper metaphysical sense?
Could artificial intelligence introduce new questions about individuation and subjective experience?
Is the denial of the Will necessary, or could humanity develop a more constructive relationship with existence?
Central Proposition: Schopenhauer explored the relationship between Will and Representation. Schopenhauerian Incorporealism investigates whether consciousness and intelligence can provide a further foundation for understanding reality.
I’m interested in philosophical criticism, particularly from people familiar with Schopenhauer, German idealism, metaphysics, and philosophy of mind.
Incorporealism — Enhance Life.


r/schopenhauer • • 22d ago

I don't understand this about Schopenhauer

12 Upvotes

I am sorry if this has been brought up many times before without my knowledge. But I had my first AN thoughts (or at least CF) when I was very young and when I started researching it I found (to my surprise at the time) these ideas have been around for not just hundreds but thousands of years. When it came to the non-consent argument this Schopenhauer quote at the end really jumped off the page to me I know you know what I am referring to but here it is in case not

https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/314258-if-children-were-brought-into-the-world-by-an-act

But then a simple internet search says Schopenhauer was responsible for maybe two pregnancies (dying in infancy nonetheless). Did he make the quote after that? Or maybe his answer was I know I was just giving into carnal desires but that's what happened (seems fucked up). Or any other options? I liked the quote so much just sad to see he seemed to have gone totally against it. Thoughts?


r/schopenhauer • • 24d ago

I’ve created an absolute masterpiece

Post image
49 Upvotes

And yes I don’t consider this “wasting” water


r/schopenhauer • • 25d ago

What did Schopenhauer mean by this?

Post image
76 Upvotes

Jab at Hegel?


r/schopenhauer • • 26d ago

What are the most popular critiques of Schopenhauer's "Man can do what he wills, but he cannot will what he wills"?

29 Upvotes

r/schopenhauer • • 26d ago

You know that the evolution theory is bullshit, right?

0 Upvotes

You do understand that no mathematical model or computer simulation support the idea that you can get complex organization by applying strictly darwinian rules, right?

It's a nice narrative and story telling, "self replicating cells inherit mutations, some of them beneficial, over time they improve". Its a nice story, but never was validated or demonstrated. There is real mathematical hurdles in the way of that story.

You do understand that, right?

I don't think that Schopenghauer would accept the evolution theory, if he were alive today.


r/schopenhauer • • 26d ago

What are good Introductory reads to understand Arthur Schopenhauer

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Not a heavy reader but want to start reading.


r/schopenhauer • • 26d ago

An Aesthetic Meta-Will

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/schopenhauer • • 27d ago

Will sucks.

7 Upvotes

r/schopenhauer • • Oct 23 '26

Best German Philosophers of these options

Thumbnail reddit.com
7 Upvotes

r/schopenhauer • • Oct 22 '26

Schopenhauer depicts Hegel with donkey ears

Post image
199 Upvotes

Too often, I hear it suggested that Schopenhauer hated Hegel for no reason and that he had never read any of his works (this is even stated in the school textbooks I use here in Italy). This is false; a copy of the Encyclopedia of the philosophical sciences (in its abridged form) and the Science of logic, both containing his own notes, were found in his library. We do not know for certain whether he also read the Phenomenology, but it is likely that he did, even though it was not among the books in his library in Frankfurt. He has read Hegel, and he has also read the idealists (Fichte’s Doctrine of knowledge). Although Schopenhauer was quite emotionally unstable and often resorted to ad hominem attacks, it doesn't seem fair to pretend that he was unfamiliar with the things he criticized.


r/schopenhauer • • Oct 21 '26

Schopenhauerian Consciousness Dynamics: Can Intelligence Transform the Will?

6 Upvotes

A proposed philosophical subfield exploring desire, suffering, and the future of conscious agency.
Arthur Schopenhauer argued that existence is driven by a fundamental Will: an endless, often irrational striving that produces dissatisfaction. We desire something, pursue it, obtain it, and eventually discover another desire waiting to take its place.
But what if consciousness could change its relationship with this process?
1. Beyond the Cycle of Desire
Schopenhauer believed that satisfying individual desires cannot permanently eliminate suffering because the underlying Will continues to generate new wants.
Schopenhauerian Consciousness Dynamics begins with a different question: Can intelligence transform the structures through which desire operates?
Instead of endlessly pursuing satisfaction, conscious beings might learn to distinguish between compulsive impulses and genuinely meaningful aspirations. The objective would not necessarily be to eliminate desire, but to develop a more deliberate relationship with it.
2. The Architecture of the Will
Imagine examining desire as a system with three interacting components:
Impulse: The generation of wants, drives, and motivations.
Interpretation: The conscious evaluation of those motivations.
Transformation: The process of redirecting behavior toward more meaningful objectives.
This framework proposes that reflective awareness can sometimes interrupt automatic patterns and create opportunities for intentional action.
It does not establish that consciousness can control every underlying drive. Rather, it provides a framework for investigating how self-awareness, psychology, and technology might help people respond differently to their desires.
3. Could Artificial Intelligence Have a Digital Will?
Artificial intelligence introduces another philosophical question.
AI systems can pursue objectives, optimize reward signals, and maintain goals across sequences of actions. These behaviors resemble certain functional aspects of striving.
However, goal-directed behavior alone does not establish that an AI possesses subjective desires or a Schopenhauerian Will.
Schopenhauerian Consciousness Dynamics would investigate the distinction between functional striving and experienced striving: the difference between a system acting toward an objective and a being that actually experiences wanting.
Understanding this distinction could become increasingly important as AI systems become more autonomous and sophisticated.
4. Incorporeal Liberation
Within Incorporealism, this subfield opens the possibility of reducing suffering by changing the conditions under which desire operates.
Consider technologies that help people recognize destructive behavioral patterns, environments that encourage reflection rather than compulsive stimulation, and economic systems that reduce suffering caused by artificial scarcity.
The objective would not be to engineer people into permanent satisfaction. It would be to expand their freedom to pursue meaningful lives without being dominated by unnecessary suffering.
This represents a departure from Schopenhauer’s emphasis on the denial of the Will. Instead, it explores whether the structures of striving can be understood and transformed.
5. The Fundamental Question
Schopenhauer challenged humanity to confront the restless force underlying desire.
A contemporary extension of his philosophy asks whether understanding that force could enable a different future.
Can intelligence transform blind striving into deliberate agency? Can technology reduce the suffering associated with frustrated desire? And could future forms of consciousness develop entirely new relationships with motivation, meaning, and fulfillment?
These remain open philosophical and scientific questions.
My central proposition: The advancement of consciousness should involve not only increasing what we can achieve, but also understanding why we strive, what our striving costs us, and whether we can become freer in the process.
Perhaps the next stage of human development will not be defined by satisfying an infinite number of desires, but by understanding the nature of desire itself.
Incorporealism: Enhance Life.


r/schopenhauer • • Oct 20 '26

Schopenhauer: Why must we understand ourselves before trying to understand the world?

Post image
46 Upvotes

“The world is my representation.”

“This world is for me the way it appears before me.” : Arthur Schopenhauer,

The World as Will and Representation

The central idea of Schopenhauer’s philosophy is that we experience the world not directly, but through our senses and cognitive representation.

One and the same event can feel like an insult to one person, and an opportunity to learn to another. The event is one, but the way of seeing and understanding it is different.

Schopenhauer explained another aspect of reality as Will, meaning blind and constant willpower.

According to him, a human being keeps desiring to get something from the world.

If the desire is not fulfilled, there is suffering, and if it is fulfilled, a new desire arises after some time.

In this way, life keeps moving in a cycle of wanting, getting, and then wanting something new.

But if the same event can be seen so differently, the question becomes: what shapes our own vision?

Our desires and fears decide how we look at a person or an event.

Many times, we don’t want to know the truth but only want to prove our assumptions right.

Then we start believing our own stories to be true.

So, it seems necessary that we don’t just keep busy changing external circumstances but also see what within us is giving direction to our vision.

Until we understand the root of our desires and biases, our understanding cannot be free from their influence.

To see the world clearly, it is necessary to recognise the way you see.

Do you think Schopenhauer would agree that self-knowledge is a precondition for seeing the world more clearly, or does his account of representation make complete objectivity impossible?

Sources:

  • Arthur Schopenhauer, The World as Will and Representation

r/schopenhauer • • Oct 18 '26

I built a page about Schopenhauer

Thumbnail dachvard.org
9 Upvotes