r/science • MD PhD | Professor | Medicine • 10h ago • Regret 1 Bravo 1

Psychology Parents who spanked at age 35 had over twice the odds of losing their temper and hitting or throwing things at their children at age 40. The findings suggest everyday spanking and anger-driven hitting may have distinct roots even as milder discipline predicts harsher aggression later on.

https://www.psypost.org/parents-who-spank-are-more-likely-to-hit-a-child-out-of-anger-years-later-study-finds/
8.9k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 10h ago

Welcome to r/science! This is a heavily moderated subreddit in order to keep the discussion on science. However, we recognize that many people want to discuss how they feel the research relates to their own personal lives, so to give people a space to do that, personal anecdotes are allowed as responses to this comment. Any anecdotal comments elsewhere in the discussion will be removed and our normal comment rules apply to all other comments.


Do you have an academic degree? We can verify your credentials in order to assign user flair indicating your area of expertise. Click here to apply.


User: u/mvea
Permalink: https://www.psypost.org/parents-who-spank-are-more-likely-to-hit-a-child-out-of-anger-years-later-study-finds/


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

62

u/mvea MD PhD | Professor | Medicine 10h ago

Parents who spank are more likely to hit a child out of anger years later, study finds

A national study of American parents indicates that at age 35, routine disciplinary spanking and hitting a child out of anger are linked to largely different personal and household characteristics. In an overlapping sample followed over five years, parents who spanked at age 35 had over twice the odds of losing their temper and hitting or throwing things at their children at age 40. Published in Family Process, the findings suggest everyday spanking and anger-driven hitting may have distinct roots even as milder discipline predicts harsher aggression later on.

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/famp.70201

5

u/Ua_Tsaug 8h ago

My child frequently drives me to lose control of my temper, but I can gladly say I've never once hit him, spanked him, or used physical force in any way.

5

u/steamyglory 7h ago

Good, you’re growing. Hopefully you continue growing to the point you are fully in control of your temper as the adult. It’s not appropriate for a child to be responsible for an adult’s temper.

3.2k

u/innocentsalad 10h ago • Regret Bravo

This is, of course, anecdotal, but all I and my friends who have worked with kids have found is that many kids who are physically punished at home don’t behave any better - but they do learn to lie about everything and refuse to take any blame for anything because they’re afraid of getting beaten.

1.3k

u/Zelcron 10h ago • Bravo Heartwarming

Oh hey it's me. I found myself as a young man lying to people for no reason, out of habit. It was a tough one to break.

396

u/graccha 9h ago

My husband and I both do this and it's very funny how much we circle back and go "that was a lie let me try that again".

156

u/contecorsair 8h ago

I did that EVERY time I told a lie or even exaggerated when I was about 20 years old when I became aware of a nasty lying habit (my parents did spank and throw things.) I would verbally and out loud correct myself to strangers about stuff I knew they didn't care about or even if I was alone. It broke the habit in about a year and now I never lie or stretch the truth unintentionally. I've only done it when someone asked me to because they told me something in confidence or to prtect someone (just a handful of times in the past several years). It's so freeing to just be totally honest about my feelings and thoughts and actions with everyone. Also when I stopped lying, it became crazy obvious to me when other people lie. I'm not sure why, you'd think it would be the other way around.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/Parepinzero 8h ago

I do that sometimes, too. I lie, I don't know why, and I say so and then tell the truth. My family is used to it by now.

→ More replies (2)

197

u/SinkHoleDeMayo 10h ago

Yep. Anytime I did something I might get in trouble for, I lied. One reason for not having kids was I didn't want to pass on my anger issues.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/Dizzy-Ad-4857 7h ago

I never really defaulted to compulsive lying (although, on the rare occasions where I deem it necessary or "appropriate" I can be quite the skillful liar) but I did become hyper-vigilant, solitary and hyper independent. I don't like to lie because it excuses me from learning. If I don't own up, chances are I won't learn, and if i learn and get better that's a more effective way to not be in this position again. However i hate relying on people which is another reason i like to own up so I can learn. The more I learn the more I can absolutely avoid you and anyone else because what are you doing here anyways?

I didn't become a compulsive liar, but when my autonomy and solitude were on the line, people became expendable. I will learn from you just so I can dump you and never have you near me again.

It's insidious and unhealthy for many reasons so now I'm trying to unlearn it and learn to accept my limitations and help more readily.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/Banban84 9h ago

Omg! Personal revelation here tonight! This is me! Thank you!

Me and the therapist gonna have fun on Monday!

47

u/Adept_Airline_239 9h ago

Trying to have a stable relationship has been so much fun the last decade

65

u/Zelcron 9h ago • Bravo

There you go lying again

42

u/StrawberryCompany98 10h ago

Same. I was like, why am I even doing this? This is dumb

21

u/GodhunterChrome666 10h ago

Still working on this myself. Not an impulse anymore, but it does tend to be my first idea before better ones pop up

16

u/illstate 9h ago

I think that still called an impulse.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Confident-Poetry6985 7h ago

Hey you. Glad you took the time to find yourself. 

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Suckage 10h ago

Same here. It took ruining my first real relationship to get me to break that stupid habit.

36

u/AnimatorMajor926 10h ago

Me too. I would lie even if I wasn't acused of anything.

→ More replies (1)

221

u/bibliophile222 10h ago • Bravo

Decades of research have come to the same conclusions. It's maddening how common it is when it doesn't even have any positive outcomes and like 30+ years of research have shown how awful it is.

132

u/NameAboutPotatoes 9h ago

Because it makes the parents feel good. 

People will ignore a lot of research showing something is harmful if it makes them feel good. 

97

u/Spire_Citron 8h ago • Bravo

I think part of it is that parents see the immediate compliance it often results in so they think that it works. They don't notice the long term behavioural trend. They have no way of knowing what kind of person their child might have been if they didn't spank them.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (1)

45

u/notabigmelvillecrowd 8h ago • Bravo

I don't think people do it because they think it will help, they just have impulse control and anger issues.

→ More replies (3)

41

u/scienceislice 6h ago

People the people who spank and the people who read and listen to a study saying 'Hitting is bad for kids' are two non-touching circles on a Venn diagram

15

u/RaspberryTwilight 5h ago edited 4h ago

I agree with this. I don't even raise my voice at my kid. I'm very much against both physical and emotional punishment. I teach and guide my kid, I don't make her feel bad in any way on purpose.

In my experience, there are a lot of churches that encourage spanking. Many people don't get their advice from psychologists. They get it from pastors. It's in the Bible. Not all churches encourage it, in my opinion not even most, but it definitely is a thing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

217

u/omyymo 10h ago • Regret

Yep, I memorized when report cards were sent out, used taking the dog out as an excuse to steal mine from the mailbox, and figured out how to doctor them and reseal the envelopes because I was so scared of my parents. Turns out screaming and physical harm doesn't do much to fix clinical depression and ADHD

52

u/Legitimate_Egg_2073 9h ago

I was in grade school in the 70’s I remember the morning after report cards got sent home one of my classmates came to school with a black eye. And everyone just pretended not to notice.

→ More replies (2)

74

u/ravenousfig 10h ago

I forged my aunt (who I lived with)'s signature once on my agenda because I just honestly forgot and was afraid of the consequences. I got caught and it was awful.

Next year I just signed them myself from the start.

28

u/Holiday-Ad-4654 9h ago

Fellow grade school forgers unite!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

69

u/AllYouNeedIsATV 9h ago

The lying this is massive. I don’t lie about big things in public anymore, but my first instinct used to be to lie about anything that could cause anyone inconvenience - even when it really isn’t a big deal. I’m much better about it now, I only lie to my parents.

It also affected my relationship with my sister. We always used to blame each other for things so that the other would be punished more. Now we aren’t that close and it’s harder for us to trust each other with big things. It’s gotten a bit better over time but it took a long while.

61

u/Spire_Citron 8h ago • Regret

I've noticed a huge correlation between kids who are physically disciplined and kids who have problems with violence themselves. In many cases, the link is so blatantly obvious. Yet on reddit whenever there's a post showing a kid being violent, people in the comment sections act like this must be a kid who's never been spanked and if they were, that would fix them.

56

u/truthfulie 10h ago

i grew up in a culture and time where physical punishment was a thing. i too find myself being evasive about things without thinking things through. i don't do that anymore but i'd be lying if i said the thought of 'how do i get out of this one' hasn't entered my mind every now and then. sometimes i even wonder if i'm unknowingly saying certain words to shift the blame.

23

u/a_bearded_hippie 10h ago

Thats exactly what it was. My dad used to spank me, twist my ear in public when I was in trouble. I would lie to people for no reason, it was just like a reaction to not get in trouble or seeking approval. Took me years and years to break that habit and I still struggle with it.

36

u/Mego1989 10h ago

And they learn that it's ok to be violent and yell when you're upset.

29

u/atmoose 9h ago

I got that treatment. I'm not really a lier. However, I did become very independent, and a bit of a loner. If you avoid your parents (or people in general), then it's harder for them to find out if you've done anything wrong.

11

u/wrldwdeu4ria 7h ago

Yep. there were times when I knew it was best to not be around or an excuse would be made for spanking me. As in every day when my dad came home from work.

11

u/zcewaunt 8h ago

And also grow up with trauma that could affect them all their lives.

11

u/DiabolicallyRandom 6h ago

My biggest regret is that I ever spanked my children.

My parents did it, and i turned out fine, right? Right...?

Wrong. Turns out I was pretty fucked up too.

I figured it out before they were fully grown, and I regret it every time I think about it. The damage done cannot be undone, but I have talked with them about it, apologized, and implored them to not repeat my mistakes should they have children of their own.

10

u/InnerDorkness 9h ago

They’ll also hide abuse from others from their parents.
I got some memories of being abused by a neighbor as a child back when I was 27 that I realized I shut out for fear of being punished

10

u/Interesting_Force618 8h ago

I would guess that being hit by the people they depend on most significantly increases antisocial tendencies. I think sociopathy is a byproduct of feeling deeply alone and on your own, and I don’t believe anyone can feel genuinely connected to someone who hits them.

34

u/NoneBinaryLeftGender 9h ago

My partner was spanked as a kid, back then it was still legal to do so, and he actually never behaved any better. He tells me he actually prefered to get spanked instead of being grounded in his room, and when given the choice, he always choose spanking. He says that spanking was quick, then he was free to play outside, while grounding was awful as he wanted to go back outside but was forced to stay inside.

He also told me he had anger issues in his teen years, taking everything out on his stepdad when he tried to get aggressive with him or control him. When the kid you used to be able to overpower grows and can now overpower you, it ain't so nice anymore.

Now he's very gentle, he calmed down a lot after cutting off his family.

9

u/JeffoMcSpeffo 10h ago

Interesting, that may be why I was a compulsive liar when I was a little kid. I don’t have any other explanation why, although I did grow out of it before middle school

6

u/Humble-Violinist6910 6h ago

Clinical studies support the same conclusion 

6

u/Kmic14 5h ago

Yup and even better my parents refuse to acknowledge it happened or that it was abuse because to them it's discipline. They never could be bothered to actually use their words

5

u/CeciNestPasUnPenname 7h ago

This, and my father ended up throwing things at me when I was older! He'd lie and then tell my mother I broke anything he threw too. Funny, I lied when I broke rules, but he was lying too!

4

u/Ellia1998 6h ago

Yup they are keep themselves safe with those lies. Cause the fear the unknown is too much for children to understand. Most kids are told not to tell or they told and did not get the help they needed. So lying and acting out is the only thing they know. Parents taught them that and system back them up. I was in the system most of my children hood over abuse. I told them everything in from of my parents. That just got me in more trouble. You do what you can just to make it everyday.

3

u/LonelyMenace101 6h ago

I was such a good liar as a kid because I was terrified of my mother screaming at me.

3

u/SparkyDogPants 5h ago

Next thing you’ll say is that those kids also solved their problems with violence because that’s how they learned to handle stress.

→ More replies (14)

923

u/randomname617 9h ago • Heartwarming

Who’s spanking their 35 year old

419

u/The_HoIIow_Knight 9h ago • Bravo

Worst title ever.

89

u/PineapplePrimary1642 7h ago

I was also confused, but when I figured out what they meant (i think?) I was still confused. They're saying that hitting kids at 35 is correlated with hitting kids at 40? And this is a publishable finding?

68

u/second_best_fox 6h ago

Spanking your kids as a 35 year old is correlated with losing your temper, hitting (distinguished from spanking), and throwing things at your kids as a 40 year old. The violence escalates.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

59

u/unfriendlybuldge 8h ago

the same parents who are hitting or throwing things at their 40 year old kids

104

u/LakersFan15 8h ago • Bravo

My wife is 35 years old.

Im hoping it will continue til at least 40 as well.

25

u/hxcdancer91 7h ago

Study shows that it’s going to alittle more feral by 40

6

u/BeerorCoffee 6h ago

Gotta learn to dodge by then, because apparently she will be throwing things!

3

u/stev0123456789 6h ago

If I'm still spanking my kid by the time they're 35... I'm going to be beating their ass by the time they're 40. Science.

→ More replies (2)

457

u/yobboman 10h ago

I used to get smacked, sometimes with a strap, ie leather belt, sometimes with a wooden spoon. Both of those items broke over time.

The one thing I learned was to cry in pain louder than necessary, as it would make them stop sooner.

They also used their hands on my bare arse.

I have children now. I did lightly smack the eldest once out of frustration. Felt extreme guilt. Realised it did more harm than good. Never did it again.

Later I discovered he had ADHD, disgraphia and dyslexia.

My children are beautiful souls and I am so glad that I chose to reject corporal punishment.

And yeah I have cPTSD but there was sooo much in my childhood that was absolutely terrible that I am not capable of attribution for that condition.

240

u/tarantulawarfare 9h ago

That’s the one thing I did not learn - cry loudly in pain to make it stop sooner.

Mom wanted to ensure I “learned my lesson” and was “sorry.” So she kept hitting and hitting, wanting to break me and make me cry, because that meant I “learned my lesson.”

I just stopped crying and stopped visibly breaking, and turned myself into stone. She hated it, and the verbal abuse was intense.

And here I am at 48 and she is 78, and I turned to stone on the phone when she called crying that I had not visited in years.

I have two children and do not do corporal punishment or verbal abuse.

92

u/DontAskAboutMyButt 8h ago

I have one memory that is burned into my brain- I was about 13 and had gone through a growth spurt. My mom was mad about something and started hitting me, as usual, and I put my hands up to cover my face/body. She hit my arms and hurt herself, but it didn’t hurt me at all. This made her more angry, of course, but in that moment everything changed between us. We both realized that she couldn’t threaten me physically any more.

I’m going on about 15 years of no contact now, and it’s still the best decision I ever made to protect my peace. I have a kid now, and they’ve never been afraid of me a single day in their lives and never will. It turns out it’s really easy to raise kids when you treat them like they’re people. Sometimes I wonder why it was so hard for her to do that

38

u/Alert-Outside-4103 7h ago

My mom literally broke down and started crying when I stopped her from breaking my things. Because I was strong enough to physically restrain her without injuring her in any way

→ More replies (1)

14

u/314159265358969error 5h ago

Sometimes you end up with a kid who naturally taps straight into your insecurities. Raising that kid becomes quickly a nightmare if you don't know how to handle your own insecurities ; especially since that person is not one that you can «simply keep at distance» (which is the desperation that leads to punishment by principle, which becomes physical once nothing else seems available anymore, since the punishment was unreasonable in the first place ; it's that part that makes me cringe when I see/read critics of so-called "gentle parenting"). A part of me is happy more people have kids in their 30s these days precisely because people rarely get to see their insecurities in their 20s.

What differs me from my dad is the fact that he used violence against a child, regardless of how insanely immature both of our attitudes were. (Yes, we fought also as adults, and I was still socially immature as hell.)

13

u/singularpotato 6h ago

I went the opposite way - instead of crying louder, around 11 or 12 I stopped crying and protesting when they’d hit me because I didn’t want to give them the satisfaction. I still can’t cry in front of people unless something is really, truly overwhelming.

6

u/pm_me_ur_mustelids 7h ago

Hello, are you me? I commented very similarly.

→ More replies (1)

66

u/blowingupthespot 9h ago

Crying more got me hit harder.

30

u/yobboman 9h ago

So sorry mate, that is really messed up

16

u/eltron 7h ago

Same here! It didn’t stop. It’s hard to explain the feelings of terror from physical abuse by your own family and yelling stop only get you hit harder and a never ending moments. It’s not nice.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/E-2theRescue 4h ago

Yup, same. Especially from my "you need to be a man" father.

Weird how all of his "manly" enforcement didn't stop me from lying in bed every night, wishing I could have been a girl. Nor did it stop me from transitioning 30 years later.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/DigDugged 7h ago

I feel like you and everyone who replied to you needs a hug. And someone to tell you you didn't deserve it. That you did your best and you still are. That talking to someone about it will help you understand so much more about yourself, and maybe prepare you to break the cycle.

Because guys, we gotta break this cycle.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/callin-br 9h ago

I feel like we should also have a conversation about how pulling down a kids underwear to hit them has a sexual component to it.

92

u/AmazingAmy712 8h ago

I agree with this. Other replies are saying there's nothing sexual about it and it's just to inflict more pain which I'm sure is the motivation for many, but it doesn't remove the inherent situation of lowering a child's pants and underwear and/or bending them over your lap to strike them. Imo children should be taught that it's absolutely NEVER appropriate for someone to forcibly disrobe you because you displeased them. Doesn't matter why you're doing it.

→ More replies (1)

55

u/ohpeaz 9h ago

Is it for humiliation? I remember feeling mortified as a kid when that was part of it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

29

u/Minute_Account9426 6h ago

cPTSD is essentially when everything is terrible rather than one really terrible event

12

u/archives2024 6h ago

Wow now I actually understand what exactly cptsd is and why i have it. Thanks reddit stranger

→ More replies (1)

6

u/lazylimpet 7h ago

Thank you for breaking the cycle. That takes so much. I'm so sorry for what you went through.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/manuscelerdei 8h ago

I got spanked with a wooden spoon. The only thing I remember was my mom's face when she came in the room. Everything that happened after that, I don't know. But it wasn't great.

5

u/ReFreshing 4h ago

My mom did all the physical abuse when I was growing up. My dad only hit me once and never again, but that one time stuck with me with how much it hurt me emotionally.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/pm_me_ur_mustelids 8h ago

I went the opposite direction as I got older - I realized that if I was silent, it would piss my mother off even more. Yes, I did get hit more and harder but I felt like I was getting back at her at the same time.

Anyway, yes I do have depression, vasovagal episodes, and a rather extreme stress response. For some reason.

320

u/genericusername26 10h ago

I got spanked a few times as a kid, it never once made me think "wow I did something wrong" it just made me angry and scared

125

u/Kobold_Trapmaster 10h ago • Regret

I always knew it was based on my parents' emotions too not the severity of what we'd done. Sometimes I'd laugh when my dad spanked me — I wasn't great at regulating my emotions — so he'd hit me harder. 

If I heard my mother yelling at my brother, I'd hide from her because I knew if she saw me she'd find a reason to get mad at me too.

31

u/NameAboutPotatoes 9h ago

Yeah, if I did something genuinely bad, like if I hurt other kids at school, nobody cared. There were no consequences. On the other hand, if my parents were angry, hitting was likely no matter what I did.

45

u/CoffeeToffeeSoftie 9h ago

It made me humiliated and scared and taught me to accept that treatment and other boundary violations from others

20

u/_illegallyblonde_ 5h ago

Being spanked as a child made me resentful and distrustful of my parents

72

u/BenAdaephonDelat 7h ago

Yep. Because it's child abuse. The only lesson it teaches kids is "it's okay for someone that loves me to hurt me physically if I did something wrong". So it either primes them to becomes victims of domestic abuse, or perpetrators of it.

36

u/cafeteriastyle 6h ago

My coworker and her ex husband hit their kids, and the kids are definitely old enough to have a discussion about their behavior. I hate it for her kids.

The other day her ex husband beat their oldest kid for stepping in dog pee while at their grandparents house. How is that his fault? And what did it matter? People just want an excuse to hit their kids and I will never understand

25

u/Kobold_Trapmaster 6h ago

The other day her ex husband beat their oldest kid for stepping in dog pee while at their grandparents house.

Growing up, me and my siblings would often laugh about the expression "Don't cry over spilled milk" because our dad would yell and curse if we spilled milk.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/jautis 8h ago

I loved the part when I was learning something during homework and somehow getting slapped didn't help me get it faster, so the beatings continued in a self reinforcing cycle.

10

u/Stargazer1919 7h ago

Getting spanked didn't teach me anything. It just made me depressed. I internalized that I did something wrong but I didn't understand why or how. I ended up in trauma response mode (mostly flight or fawn mode, not so much fight) for years and I didn't get out of that until I was over the age of 30.

5

u/Junior_Sign7240 6h ago

That's how I've always seen it. You're supposed to explain why the thing their doing is wrong, by hitting them, they only learn to hide what they're doing. If you hitting a child that's too young to understand, why are you hitting them? And if they're old enough to understand, again, why are you hitting them?

4

u/iwrestlewithjimmy 3h ago

Agree. Never once when I was getting spanked did I think I deserved it. Even as a kid I was like, "I'm a kid, kids do dumb things. Why am I getting punished?" Once I got spanked for prying stones out of their setting in a pair of my mom's earrings because I "wanted to know if they were plastic". That's not really a thing you need to hit a kid over. You just say, "Ask me next time before touching my jewelry" or something. The whole time I was getting spanked I was thinking, "it was dumb and if you just told me I wouldn't have ever done it again".

One day I saw my dad get mad enough to go after my brother and my mom threw herself in front of him and acted like my dad planning to spank him was assault-level. Mom previously did ALL the spanking in the house and even broke a spatula on my sister. This is when I started to put together that she loved him more than us.

→ More replies (3)

353

u/Otaraka 10h ago

The problem being of course proponents tend to deny any issues with escalation over time or the like.   Which is why research about actual behaviour in practise is so important compared to anecdotes.

168

u/imsotrollest 10h ago

Is spanking universally different than hitting your child? I don’t even see how it’s considered an escalation. You are physically hitting your child as a punishment. They are just small and weak enough that you can bend them over your knee against their will at that age

54

u/Spageroni 10h ago

i think it means escalating from spanking to punching

→ More replies (8)

95

u/bannanaduck 10h ago

Legally, yes in the US. Psychologically, no.

→ More replies (5)

37

u/Otaraka 10h ago

Not really which is why escalation is an inherent risk.  You end up with child protection criteria like whether bruising is caused when of course some children can be hit very hard without bruising.

48

u/imsotrollest 10h ago

Spankings can absolutely cause bruising and regularly do, however it’s on the butt which is almost never going to be seen. Abusers will usually strike upper legs and upper arms for the same reason, less likely to cause any serious damage than the torso or back while still being regularly concealed by clothing.

→ More replies (22)

35

u/spaceporter 10h ago

Anyone who has experienced the same annoyance over and over again knows that the reaction to it can easily escalate over time. Who hasn't mocked an opposing team member for something inconsequential repeatedly throughout a game until they overreact and get penalized?

It stands to reason that your starting reaction and your rate of escalation are going to have some bearing on the peak level of aggression shown.

It's great when research substantiates common sense. It's also great when research turns common sense on its head.

43

u/InsaneInTheRAMdrain 10h ago

Anger / aggression impluses have been shown to act like an addiction, the more you give into that impluse the harder it is to control the next time which inevitably leads to escalation.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/CleaRae 10h ago

100% and those reacting are not in a rational state so are not going to calm themselves down and go for it. As their kids stop looking like babies and actually more like adults there is less holding them back from reacting like it’s an adult in front of them.

4

u/E-2theRescue 4h ago

"I was beaten as a child, and I turned out fine" - The person who flies into a psychotic rage and assaults someone half their size, usually with weapons.

12

u/foxhelp 10h ago

From lived experience parents from the 80-90's seemed to mellow out with age, whereas this study is saying they their kids that also spanked seem to be escalating with age.

32

u/sirensinger17 10h ago

I lived with parents who spanked in the 80s-90s as well and my finding is they "mellowed" because I started fighting back. Turns out spanking often worsens a kid's behavior.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

383

u/cheesyshop 10h ago • Mindblown

It’s illegal to spank an adult without their consent. For some reason, though, it’s okay if the victim is a child.

196

u/ThePrussianGrippe 9h ago • Bravo

For some reason, though, it’s okay if the victim is a child.

Children having rights is a fairly new concept societally, and many people will still view their kids as their possessions.

40

u/Designated_Lurker_32 7h ago edited 7h ago • Bravo

And we're still facing incredible pushback to this. A lot of people have a vested interest in keeping children devoid of rights because without these rights, society can continue to have its cake and eat it too.

We like to tell ourselves we have individual freedom and we can express ourselves however we want, but we also love to enforce conformity and to shame people for not following obtuse social rules. We get around this condrum by using childhood as a critical period where we can use and abuse our authority over children to mold them into our ideal of normalcy.

→ More replies (3)

54

u/Parepinzero 8h ago • Bravo

And then people who were spanked as kids argue to their last breath that it's okay to hit children because they turned out okay! Not recognizing that they think hitting children is acceptable, and thus did NOT turn out okay.

7

u/HalleyOrion 1h ago

I've known quite a number of people who've all said this, and none of them have been what I would describe as "okay". They've all had serious temper issues, anxiety issues, etc., that have impacted their ability to have stable, happy adulthoods. Most of them have substance abuse problems that have greatly impacted their health, and most have negative, distant relationships with their parents.

I don't know whether spanking caused those issues, but it's odd how many of them point to themselves as examples of someone who turned out "okay".

17

u/divadschuf 3h ago

I’m pretty sure here in the European Union it’s illegal to spank to your child. I’m glad spanking is seen as domestic violence nowadays.

6

u/Camping_vagn 3h ago

There are countries in EU where is isnt illegal yet. Sadly. 

→ More replies (3)

26

u/melvinmoneybags 10h ago

Hitting or yelling doesn’t get results especially in younger kids they have no clue sometimes what the crime is. My wife and I do a count to 3 and then we intervene and remove them from the situation. If there is a meltdown or freak out then there is a cool down time with no toys by themselves. If that doesn’t work and they still want to act the goat then we take their toys away and stuff they like to play with disappear.

11

u/Stargazer1919 7h ago

I was very curious as a kid but also sheltered. Throughout my childhood and teen years, I didn't understand some rules and norms. I would get in trouble for some things that I didn't even know was wrong. But my parents never bothered to explain anything to me. It was just more screaming and verbal abuse and "because I said so."

Example: I got in major trouble when I said my first swear word. But I had no idea it was a bad word. I was repeating something I heard, which is pretty typical for kids. I got screamed at for a long time that night. I wasn't believed when I said I didn't know it was wrong.

Screaming and verbal abuse never taught me anything. It just made me dissociate and become depressed.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (52)

115

u/Accurate_Potato_5626 10h ago

I was "tapped on the hand with two fingers" at two and spanked in preschool and early elementary school.

At fifteen I was thrown across a master bath and bedroom room and onto a bed while in the middle of a bratty teen sentence. It does indeed escalate, because children become more independent and difficult with time.

42

u/Amethyst-Flare 9h ago

My dad learned to stop trying to use physical punishment when I was old enough to shove him into a wall. That taught him real quick.

24

u/Makuta_Servaela 8h ago

This with my mother. The second to last time she laid her hands on me, I realised I was bigger than her and fought back defensively a bit. A few months later she tried again and I went on the offensive and beat her ass. She has not only never tried it a third time, but she also never put hands on my younger brother, who was still smaller than her, again either.

Plus, my relationship with her improved dramatically. She actually talks to me like a person and we have intelligent discussions and debates.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Accurate_Potato_5626 8h ago edited 8h ago

It tends to do that. My sister and I were never as strong or tall as our parents even in adulthood, so we didn't get that moment.

My mother had a black belt in Judo and Dad was into MMA before it was a thing.

14

u/Amethyst-Flare 8h ago

Oof, evil and powerful. A terrible combination.

6

u/ExactlyThirteenBees 7h ago

Fifteen is when my dad escalated from using the belt to outright strangling me for "talking back" (they were screaming at me to move something and I said "I am give me a minute") so I left his house

→ More replies (6)

212

u/_fairywren 10h ago edited 1h ago • Heartwarming

I was very occasionally smacked as a child. Like maybe two or three times ever. As a young adult I thought "I mean I turned out fine, what's the big deal?" but now in my 30s as someone who is not a parent but regularly cares for children, I cannot imagine smacking them.

I've done so much reading about parenting and trauma-informed care (which is actually best practice for all children - it's just that kids without trauma are more resilient to poor parenting), I no longer believe that smacking is actually the most effective method, and using your words thoughtfully works better in the short and long term.

The idea is that all kids are doing the very best they can with the tools they have, and if they're not thriving, they need better tools - not to be hit.

50

u/SleepWouldBeNice 10h ago

I’ve got an 8 year old and a 4 year old and the vast majority of the time, explaining things clearly and straight forward will work perfectly. Some times I’ll have to raise my voice, but I’m cognizant that yelling too much is counter productive, but at the end of the day, I’m their parent, not their friend. But the way I see it, I can probably cause just as much emotional damage from yelling at them than I could by hitting them, and it doesn’t leave a mark. But again, counter productive.

32

u/_fairywren 10h ago

I think yelling can be helpful if the child is genuinely in danger - if they're not totally desensitised to being yelled at. It should carry some shock value and has its place for sure.

Obviously we are human and sometimes we yell because we're frustrated. That's totally valid and sometimes just can't be helped.

When we explain things (particularly our own feelings) clearly and calmly to our kids, we are modelling regulation and expression.

"I'm frustrated that you haven't put your toys away, because it means I have to pick them up before I can vaccuum, and I have less free time to play."

Or even just "Sam - toys!" will generally get the message across.

"I've told you a thousand times to put your toys away, what do I have to do to get you to listen to me?" - kid has zoned out.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/womerah 7h ago

The idea is that all kids are doing the very best they can with the tools they have, and if they're not thriving, they need better tools - not to be hit.

100%. Children don't have fully developed brains and can therefore not manage their emotions and self-sooth as effectively as an adult. The role of the parent is to act as an external influence to help the child regulate, and to ensure that the child is not exposed to situations that they can't yet regulate themselves in.

For example, school then sport then a supermarket shop might be too taxing, so the kid has a meltdown at the shops. You'd try and help them regulate and then maybe note to avoid such situations in future, perhaps shop another day when there is no sport etc

10

u/HoldMyDomeFoam 9h ago

Same and I can’t imagine hitting my kids even once.

24

u/TexturedSpace 9h ago • Heartwarming

I cannot fathom hitting my children. They are teens now. Family would suggest that I hit them when they were little, insane. The absolute violent violation of trust in the act of hitting is so egregious to me.

8

u/TKler 10h ago

You mean you actually turned out fine in the end? Congratulations

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

59

u/PlayThingToy 10h ago

Being desensitized to your own actions tend to lead to heightened version of those actions

10

u/Interesting_Force618 8h ago

I also think that when we abuse someone, we develop more contempt towards them. I mean, more contempt towards ourselves, really, but we project it onto others because it’s incredibly painful in a society as unforgiving and non understanding as ours to look inward when we have done many harmful things. Love may be the catalyst for kind and humane treatment of others, but kind and humane treatment of others perpetuates love. The better you treat someone, the more love you will feel towards them.

57

u/AReverieofEnvisage 10h ago

I was a jehovahs witness growing up.

My dad would open the Bible and told us how it was his job to punish us for misbehaving. Be it talking during church, falling asleep, or not raising our hand to comment propaganda.

He would also force us to do family Bible studies when he was angry at us.

76

u/kilos_of_doubt 9h ago

I can't think of a better way to condition children to hate the Bible at the very least

21

u/justonemom14 9h ago

Yeah my mom used to threaten to make me pray a rosary when she thought things were really bad. And little kids who won't settle down for bedtime have to endure a Hail Mary. I'm like mom, you're using prayer as a punishment? I don't think that's how it's supposed to work.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/skillywilly56 9h ago

But if they read the magic book they’ll be better people!

15

u/Gloomy-Performer4546 8h ago

yeah, this is religious abuse, and I experienced the "spare the rod, spoil the child" stuff too from my Christian dad. I no longer have a relationship with God because of him.

9

u/ExactlyThirteenBees 7h ago

Hearing kids wailing and being hit while being taken in the back to be punished for slight misbehavior and silently being thankful it isn't you the whole kingdom hall heard this time is such a JW experience

8

u/gottadance 2h ago

My mum is a JW and beat us, quoting the Bible as her parenting manual. She would force us to pray to god to make us well-behaved children a lot. She'd tell the congregation when we misbehaved and 20 other people told us off.

The combination of beating and shame made us incredibly secretive. We had a persona we played for mum and with the congregation. We lied, we pretended we believed in a god that encouraged parents to hit children, but away from them, we were and still are completely different people.

I'll say this for the JWs though. It was one them who told our mother she couldn't hit us with belts, slippers or sticks. She said it was going too far and it should be one smack of the hand. My mum did dial it back a little after that but she still left bruises.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/mariahmce 7h ago

I’m in my late 40s. When I was a kid, my mom was a family therapist and used all the modern child rearing techniques at the time which included NOT spanking kids. I was never yelled at and never spanked. I was VERY unique as a child that my parents didn’t do those things. Now, I consider myself incredibly well adjusted. I have kids and did the same for them, but it’s the norm now. None of my friends would ever consider spanking their kids. Ending familial abuse cycles is a beautiful gift that I’m glad more people are giving their kids.

12

u/speciate 9h ago

This is one of the most obvious correlations I've ever seen on this sub.

23

u/xbleuguyx 8h ago

Is your child old enough to to learn reasoning? Yes? Use your words. No? They have no idea why you're hitting them. Terrible parents hit.

56

u/Totallynotokayokay 10h ago

Violence always escalates

47

u/harswv 10h ago

My mom spanked me occasionally, and she was pretty level-headed about it and I didn’t ever feel scared of her or that she was doing it in anger. So I thought, how bad could it be? When our oldest was little I started disciplining him in the same way, Almost immediately he started hitting me, when he had never done that before. I realized I was just teaching him to solve his problems with physical force. I stopped spanking, he stopped hitting, and we started having rational conversations and natural consequences.

21

u/amidalarama 8h ago

sometimes parents need to get hit back to learn hitting is stupid

→ More replies (1)

19

u/anxious_tfem 7h ago

My mom always said, if a kid is old enough to understand how what they did is wrong then just explain it to them. If they’re too young to then they won’t understand why you’re hitting them. They’ll just remember that their parent, the person who was meant to take care of them and love them unconditionally, gave them emotional and physical scars.

90

u/Angry_Sparrow 10h ago • Mindblown Bravo

Spamming kids has been illegal here for over a decade. It is weird when I remember it isn’t elsewhere.

102

u/Fusorfodder 10h ago

Don't edit your typo

→ More replies (1)

7

u/TheDungen 2h ago

Been illegal where I live in almost 50 years I think. Famous author Astrid Lindgren went on a crusade against it and got it made illegal.

31

u/KiwasiGames 10h ago

Look, spamming out kids is expensive. But as long as you can afford it, it’s generally not illegal.

7

u/atmoose 9h ago

I don't know, processed meat is pricy. Beanning them out is cheaper.

5

u/phonylady 2h ago

Not only is it not illegal most places, many parents gleefully announce that they spank their kids. Or that their parents spanked them and they learned discipline because of it.

Just anecdotally, indians on instagram especially.

21

u/patgeo 10h ago

That's some next gen punishment. Kid pisses you off, send their contact details to a real estate company.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/LadyIgnacia 9h ago edited 9h ago

I hate modern reddit. This is a science sub and 100% of the replies to your serious comment is "Huuurrr durrr you made a typo". Not just one comment. All of them. Discourse on this site has fallen substantially and it is no longer worth engaging most of the time.

I agree with you though. Assaulting and battery of children is wrong. Furthermore every study done on the topic shows it causes children to be MORE violent and not better behaved. Dumb/lazy people like it though cause it is easy.

→ More replies (7)

12

u/mountaindoom 10h ago

I don't like spam!

13

u/NezuminoraQ 10h ago

Next time you'll think before you misbehave then!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

17

u/CharasInCharge 9h ago

Can anecdotally confirm, my parents had me when they were ~28, my dad spanked me around 35, then in my teenage years when he'd get angry he'd pin me or choke me. Now I'm in my 30s and my heart stops any time his name shows up as an incoming call. Trauma is fun stuff

57

u/-businessskeleton- 10h ago

Slapped my son's hand once... Felt horrible. I didn't control my emotions because of his. Wasn't good enough. Changed that day.... Didn't hit again.

15

u/Lummicks 10h ago edited 10h ago

Same thing happened to me. My daughter did something to my son, I think she hit him really good with a plastic bat. He's a gentle giant, so he wouldn't do anything, but I didn't want her to hit. So I spanked her with the tips of my fingers on her butt, one time. You'd think I hit her with a wire hanger with how she responded. I hated how it made me feel and how she reacted. So we both agreed that she's not allowed to hit her brother and I'm not allowed to hit them. First and last time intentional hitting/spanking has happened in our house.

I even had a cousin argue with my wife that kids have to be spanked and fear their parents. Then she told him that we don't hit our kids and they're great kids. He had no response other than that's how he's going to raise his family. I can't stand the guy now

17

u/dandelion-heart 9h ago

I’m glad you learned from it but I can’t imagine the thought process of “Hitting your brother is wrong so I’m going to hit you.”

16

u/AmazingAmy712 8h ago

It happens when your behavioral model as a child did the same and worse to you. Our behaviors are very influenced by childhood experiences and often need to be identified to be changed.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Vagetarian42069 10h ago

That would be me, and that is why I won’t have kids.

10

u/ent_wife_treeboobs 10h ago

Shocking to absolutely no one...

5

u/AproposOf0 9h ago

yeah, that tracks from personal experience. Mum was a horror growing up.

(she calmed down a lot when we left home/post-menopause. Now only Dad gets the snappiness but he deliberately winds her up half the time so I leave them to it)

5

u/LFAdvice0909 9h ago

This is so believable and honestly even now, it's hard for me to assign the word abuse to the discipline we had as a child. But belting until there were welts, smacked in the face over and over. We didn't get whooping every day but it's so clear now as an adult myself that my parents should not have had me at 24/21 or my sister 2 years later. By the time my brother came 10 years after me, it seems as though they finally were ready to be level parents.

Still love them, but don't talk to them and I do think it's for the best. These studies are always fascinating. Imagine taking out your anger, physically on a child.

16

u/figgypudding531 10h ago

Why is the parents’ age relevant?

57

u/pentox70 10h ago

They are implying that it gets worse as they age. That its a slippery slope.

9

u/wrldwdeu4ria 7h ago

I 100% agree with this. And I swear that the adults that do this to their children regularly are getting some kind of dopamine hit out of it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/mountaindoom 10h ago

Not all grown-ups are adults.

4

u/Forcedperspective84 9h ago

We got hit all the time and it was always in anger. I wouldn't wish that on any child.

4

u/Tomsoup4 8h ago

yep my dad spanked me but stopped spanking my little sister when she looked at him one time funny or something.

22

u/beamenacein 10h ago

Not gonna lie. I don't know who these parents are that can throw their 35 or 40 year old kid but I would probably just do what they said.

8

u/CleaRae 10h ago

No surprise that violence begets violence. The mix of parents who do it are the bad parents who are violent and those who don’t know better how to handle an escalation. So what happens for them when kids get older and what started as a swat has zero impact - they increase. They are also working from a place where they are at the end of their tether and irrational and liable to not think and do worse.

We see time and again in many ways that violence and negative punishment does very little in the long run. We should be progressing as a society but get stuck in old ways that never really worked then anyway.

70

u/Realistic-Piece7980 9h ago • Popcorn

Everyday spanking? My mom spanked me 2x in life. Why are these studies always based on straight up abuse instead of reasonable punishment?

10

u/DigDugged 7h ago

You would not believe how many people in the U.S. would argue with you that daily spanking is abuse. My gut feeling is that one of our weaknesses as a nation is that we allow our parents to hit our children regularly, generation after generation. No public conversation or awareness.

13

u/ThomasEdmund84 8h ago

Did you even read the title of the study?!? No not every parent who spanked went on to abuse or was engaging in further abuse, but anyone who does spank has much higher odds of going on (or continuing) to abuse

89

u/fayemoonlight 9h ago • Bravo

Hitting a child is never reasonable punishment. If my boss hit me, I’d call the police. Why do that to someone who can’t even fight back?

14

u/Much_Difference 6h ago

I don't want my kid thinking it's okay for an adult to touch them against their will, especially for the purpose of hurting them, and doubly especially if the hitter is insisting they deserve it. Literally what good lesson could anyone expect from this? Why would you want your kid to be accustomed to that kind of thing?

→ More replies (105)

28

u/13thmurder 9h ago

It's pretty common to get it every day, multiple times a day in some families. That's how I grew up and I know plenty of other people who got the same.

16

u/Realistic-Piece7980 9h ago

Damn that’s crazy. I cant even imagine beating someone everyday

→ More replies (23)

52

u/Drafting- 9h ago

Because the majority of people who spank don’t have the control to stop at a few spanking or a few hits. They’re usually the kind of parents who regularly resort to violence because they can’t emotionally regulate. 

56

u/aggravated-asphalt 8h ago

I spanked my kid once and I whole heartedly agree that it’s an emotional regulation thing on the adults part. I was frustrated and overwhelmed and wanted the tantrum to stop. Guess what followed? Anger and more crying. Spanking isn’t for the child, it’s for the adult, and that’s awful.

→ More replies (39)

11

u/Rostin 8h ago

The majority? What makes you say so?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (31)

8

u/Fresh-Anteater-5933 8h ago

I don’t think that’s what the word everyday means there. I think it means prosaic or unremarkable, not literally every day

→ More replies (5)

4

u/GumSL 5h ago

Spanking isn't punishment. It's abuse. Period.

→ More replies (145)

3

u/Bearded_Pip 9h ago

Violence begets more violence.

3

u/Mundane_Fox_1067 8h ago

My grown 33 & 35 yo kids would punch back if i tried to spank them now.
Poorly constructed headlines are getting ridiculous lately.

7

u/Keddlin 10h ago

The Authoritarian parenting style begetting children with a Permissive parenting style whos conclusion becomes "maybe a little spanking is okay" pipeline needs to be studied next. Neurodivergent parents have neurodivergent kids and wonder why their lives are so hard and seemingly assume the missing secret ingredient was violence.

No, it was to have SOME structure and discipline, a radical amount of patience and empathy, engage with them even when it was hard, and to not emotionally neglect them. Easier said than done, and I believe many Permissive parents lacked the bandwidth to put that necessary effort into parenting, but the generational trauma it's causing for spanking to be re-entering the conversation nowadays is awful to witness.

8

u/idiom_exon_0s 9h ago

Spanking is abusive. There are ALWAYS other solutions.

9

u/MyPigWhistles 10h ago

Yes, abusers are more likely to abuse others than normal people.

6

u/No_Translator_7949 9h ago

Is that like saying people that punch people are more likely to hit their spouse than people that don't hit people...

5

u/Middle-Bill3873 7h ago

I got spanked like 3 times in my entire life. They were all effective in keeping me out of serious trouble and knowing and remembering when I seriously messed up. I never did those things again.

I dont condone physical abuse by any means, but i think there are certain times when spanking can absolutely be effective. Especially when I see the little shits that run around today.

8

u/Slang_shat 10h ago

I'm nearly 35 now and I really can't see my parents even attempt to spank me.

By the time I'm 40 they will be close to 70 and I could probably take them both at that point.

2

u/Acceptable_Hunt_6677 9h ago

I have never once been so upset or angry with my children that I have found it necessary to strike them. I just do not understand that mentality. Could never break that trust with them.

2

u/AggressiveStorage534 9h ago

Good thing I’m 34 and this doesn’t apply to me. 

2

u/WaldoHeraldoFaldo 8h ago

Dang I'm glad my parents didn't spank when i was 35

2

u/ramriot 8h ago

I think though if as parents you're spanking your child once they're over 30 something has gone seriously wrong

2

u/kinkycarbon 8h ago

Does this still apply if said father has a kid in range at 50 years old?

2

u/sweetbeard 7h ago

Agreed, getting spanked at age 35 sucked, and it only got worse when I was 40.

2

u/Impossible-Bowler770 7h ago

Yeah well I can tell you as an older millennial, this was still very acceptable late '80s mid-90s. Then late in the century then started to change. Hence I got physically punished, but my two younger sisters never did. I'm glad it's much more taboo now.

2

u/showmeyourchits 7h ago

Why would my parents be trying to spank me at age 35?

2

u/vgaph 7h ago

Age 35 is way too old to still be spanked.

2

u/WakeUpFriendly 6h ago edited 6h ago

My principal spanked me in the 3rd grade. We were allowed to bring one piece of candy to school for the after school program. What I brought that day was an Easter bunny jello mold my grandma made. The exact color and shape my teacher made at home for students who aced their spelling test. I didn’t ace it. But my best friend did. I showed him after school the one my grandma made. He told the teacher. My teacher sent me to the principal for stealing. My principal grilled me in the office from 330 - 430. I was 8. I was so worn down from the anxiety. I lied, and told the principal I stole it. I hoped it would get her off my case and end it. She paddled me with a wooden paddle 30 + times. I couldn’t sit down. I was ashamed. She proudly told my parents what she did. I remember her smug face. My parents were horrified. They asked her why she didn’t just call them to verify if I’d stolen a jello mold. Explained my grandmother made some for the family. And that they told me I could bring it for after school. Her name was Mrs. Seymour. She was shocked. I remember her face. She profusely apologized. My grandma went to the school and showed her the jello mold she used and chewed her out. My parents had an attorney draft a letter and send it to the school board threatening legal action if it happened again. The school changed its policy on spanking students after that. The principal wrote me an apology letter. Made me cookies. And apologized in person. I forgave her as best as I could. But I lost all trust for teachers, coaches and principals after that one event. This one situation is enough for me to never support spanking a kid. What if the kid is right? My parents said the light went out of me at school for a couple of years. I still made good grades, but I quit trying to bond with my home room teachers after that. As an adult looking back they were right. That situation was so fucked up.

Edit. Grammar. I’m exhausted. Tons of errors.

4

u/No_Implement611 5h ago

Right because all the kids nowadays are soooo disciplined.

5

u/meeplewirp 7h ago

Spanking is a creepy and gross punishment done by people with mental health issues

→ More replies (3)