r/science
•
u/mvea
MD PhD | Professor | Medicine
•
10h ago
•
1
1
Psychology Parents who spanked at age 35 had over twice the odds of losing their temper and hitting or throwing things at their children at age 40. The findings suggest everyday spanking and anger-driven hitting may have distinct roots even as milder discipline predicts harsher aggression later on.
https://www.psypost.org/parents-who-spank-are-more-likely-to-hit-a-child-out-of-anger-years-later-study-finds/
8.9k
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator 10h ago
Welcome to r/science! This is a heavily moderated subreddit in order to keep the discussion on science. However, we recognize that many people want to discuss how they feel the research relates to their own personal lives, so to give people a space to do that, personal anecdotes are allowed as responses to this comment. Any anecdotal comments elsewhere in the discussion will be removed and our normal comment rules apply to all other comments.
Do you have an academic degree? We can verify your credentials in order to assign user flair indicating your area of expertise. Click here to apply.
User: u/mvea
Permalink: https://www.psypost.org/parents-who-spank-are-more-likely-to-hit-a-child-out-of-anger-years-later-study-finds/
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
62
u/mvea MD PhD | Professor | Medicine 10h ago
Parents who spank are more likely to hit a child out of anger years later, study finds
A national study of American parents indicates that at age 35, routine disciplinary spanking and hitting a child out of anger are linked to largely different personal and household characteristics. In an overlapping sample followed over five years, parents who spanked at age 35 had over twice the odds of losing their temper and hitting or throwing things at their children at age 40. Published in Family Process, the findings suggest everyday spanking and anger-driven hitting may have distinct roots even as milder discipline predicts harsher aggression later on.
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/famp.70201
3.2k
u/innocentsalad 10h ago •
This is, of course, anecdotal, but all I and my friends who have worked with kids have found is that many kids who are physically punished at home don’t behave any better - but they do learn to lie about everything and refuse to take any blame for anything because they’re afraid of getting beaten.
923
u/randomname617 9h ago •
Who’s spanking their 35 year old
457
u/yobboman 10h ago
I used to get smacked, sometimes with a strap, ie leather belt, sometimes with a wooden spoon. Both of those items broke over time.
The one thing I learned was to cry in pain louder than necessary, as it would make them stop sooner.
They also used their hands on my bare arse.
I have children now. I did lightly smack the eldest once out of frustration. Felt extreme guilt. Realised it did more harm than good. Never did it again.
Later I discovered he had ADHD, disgraphia and dyslexia.
My children are beautiful souls and I am so glad that I chose to reject corporal punishment.
And yeah I have cPTSD but there was sooo much in my childhood that was absolutely terrible that I am not capable of attribution for that condition.
320
u/genericusername26 10h ago
I got spanked a few times as a kid, it never once made me think "wow I did something wrong" it just made me angry and scared
353
u/Otaraka 10h ago
The problem being of course proponents tend to deny any issues with escalation over time or the like. Which is why research about actual behaviour in practise is so important compared to anecdotes.
383
u/cheesyshop 10h ago •
It’s illegal to spank an adult without their consent. For some reason, though, it’s okay if the victim is a child.
115
u/Accurate_Potato_5626 10h ago
I was "tapped on the hand with two fingers" at two and spanked in preschool and early elementary school.
At fifteen I was thrown across a master bath and bedroom room and onto a bed while in the middle of a bratty teen sentence. It does indeed escalate, because children become more independent and difficult with time.
212
u/_fairywren 10h ago edited 1h ago •
I was very occasionally smacked as a child. Like maybe two or three times ever. As a young adult I thought "I mean I turned out fine, what's the big deal?" but now in my 30s as someone who is not a parent but regularly cares for children, I cannot imagine smacking them.
I've done so much reading about parenting and trauma-informed care (which is actually best practice for all children - it's just that kids without trauma are more resilient to poor parenting), I no longer believe that smacking is actually the most effective method, and using your words thoughtfully works better in the short and long term.
The idea is that all kids are doing the very best they can with the tools they have, and if they're not thriving, they need better tools - not to be hit.
59
u/PlayThingToy 10h ago
Being desensitized to your own actions tend to lead to heightened version of those actions
57
u/AReverieofEnvisage 10h ago
I was a jehovahs witness growing up.
My dad would open the Bible and told us how it was his job to punish us for misbehaving. Be it talking during church, falling asleep, or not raising our hand to comment propaganda.
He would also force us to do family Bible studies when he was angry at us.
26
u/mariahmce 7h ago
I’m in my late 40s. When I was a kid, my mom was a family therapist and used all the modern child rearing techniques at the time which included NOT spanking kids. I was never yelled at and never spanked. I was VERY unique as a child that my parents didn’t do those things. Now, I consider myself incredibly well adjusted. I have kids and did the same for them, but it’s the norm now. None of my friends would ever consider spanking their kids. Ending familial abuse cycles is a beautiful gift that I’m glad more people are giving their kids.
12
u/speciate 9h ago
This is one of the most obvious correlations I've ever seen on this sub.
23
u/xbleuguyx 8h ago
Is your child old enough to to learn reasoning? Yes? Use your words. No? They have no idea why you're hitting them. Terrible parents hit.
56
u/Totallynotokayokay 10h ago
Violence always escalates
19
u/anxious_tfem 7h ago
My mom always said, if a kid is old enough to understand how what they did is wrong then just explain it to them. If they’re too young to then they won’t understand why you’re hitting them. They’ll just remember that their parent, the person who was meant to take care of them and love them unconditionally, gave them emotional and physical scars.
90
u/Angry_Sparrow 10h ago •
Spamming kids has been illegal here for over a decade. It is weird when I remember it isn’t elsewhere.
17
u/CharasInCharge 9h ago
Can anecdotally confirm, my parents had me when they were ~28, my dad spanked me around 35, then in my teenage years when he'd get angry he'd pin me or choke me. Now I'm in my 30s and my heart stops any time his name shows up as an incoming call. Trauma is fun stuff
57
u/-businessskeleton- 10h ago
Slapped my son's hand once... Felt horrible. I didn't control my emotions because of his. Wasn't good enough. Changed that day.... Didn't hit again.
15
u/Vagetarian42069 10h ago
That would be me, and that is why I won’t have kids.
10
u/ent_wife_treeboobs 10h ago
Shocking to absolutely no one...
5
u/AproposOf0 9h ago
yeah, that tracks from personal experience. Mum was a horror growing up.
(she calmed down a lot when we left home/post-menopause. Now only Dad gets the snappiness but he deliberately winds her up half the time so I leave them to it)
5
u/LFAdvice0909 9h ago
This is so believable and honestly even now, it's hard for me to assign the word abuse to the discipline we had as a child. But belting until there were welts, smacked in the face over and over. We didn't get whooping every day but it's so clear now as an adult myself that my parents should not have had me at 24/21 or my sister 2 years later. By the time my brother came 10 years after me, it seems as though they finally were ready to be level parents.
Still love them, but don't talk to them and I do think it's for the best. These studies are always fascinating. Imagine taking out your anger, physically on a child.
16
u/figgypudding531 10h ago
Why is the parents’ age relevant?
15
u/mountaindoom 10h ago
Not all grown-ups are adults.
4
u/Forcedperspective84 9h ago
We got hit all the time and it was always in anger. I wouldn't wish that on any child.
4
u/Tomsoup4 8h ago
yep my dad spanked me but stopped spanking my little sister when she looked at him one time funny or something.
22
u/beamenacein 10h ago
Not gonna lie. I don't know who these parents are that can throw their 35 or 40 year old kid but I would probably just do what they said.
8
u/CleaRae 10h ago
No surprise that violence begets violence. The mix of parents who do it are the bad parents who are violent and those who don’t know better how to handle an escalation. So what happens for them when kids get older and what started as a swat has zero impact - they increase. They are also working from a place where they are at the end of their tether and irrational and liable to not think and do worse.
We see time and again in many ways that violence and negative punishment does very little in the long run. We should be progressing as a society but get stuck in old ways that never really worked then anyway.
70
u/Realistic-Piece7980 9h ago •
Everyday spanking? My mom spanked me 2x in life. Why are these studies always based on straight up abuse instead of reasonable punishment?
3
u/Bearded_Pip 9h ago
Violence begets more violence.
3
u/Mundane_Fox_1067 8h ago
My grown 33 & 35 yo kids would punch back if i tried to spank them now.
Poorly constructed headlines are getting ridiculous lately.
7
u/Keddlin 10h ago
The Authoritarian parenting style begetting children with a Permissive parenting style whos conclusion becomes "maybe a little spanking is okay" pipeline needs to be studied next. Neurodivergent parents have neurodivergent kids and wonder why their lives are so hard and seemingly assume the missing secret ingredient was violence.
No, it was to have SOME structure and discipline, a radical amount of patience and empathy, engage with them even when it was hard, and to not emotionally neglect them. Easier said than done, and I believe many Permissive parents lacked the bandwidth to put that necessary effort into parenting, but the generational trauma it's causing for spanking to be re-entering the conversation nowadays is awful to witness.
8
u/idiom_exon_0s 9h ago
Spanking is abusive. There are ALWAYS other solutions.
9
u/MyPigWhistles 10h ago
Yes, abusers are more likely to abuse others than normal people.
6
u/No_Translator_7949 9h ago
Is that like saying people that punch people are more likely to hit their spouse than people that don't hit people...
5
u/Middle-Bill3873 7h ago
I got spanked like 3 times in my entire life. They were all effective in keeping me out of serious trouble and knowing and remembering when I seriously messed up. I never did those things again.
I dont condone physical abuse by any means, but i think there are certain times when spanking can absolutely be effective. Especially when I see the little shits that run around today.
8
u/Slang_shat 10h ago
I'm nearly 35 now and I really can't see my parents even attempt to spank me.
By the time I'm 40 they will be close to 70 and I could probably take them both at that point.
2
u/Acceptable_Hunt_6677 9h ago
I have never once been so upset or angry with my children that I have found it necessary to strike them. I just do not understand that mentality. Could never break that trust with them.
2
u/AggressiveStorage534 9h ago
Good thing I’m 34 and this doesn’t apply to me.
2
u/WaldoHeraldoFaldo 8h ago
Dang I'm glad my parents didn't spank when i was 35
2
u/ramriot 8h ago
I think though if as parents you're spanking your child once they're over 30 something has gone seriously wrong
2
u/kinkycarbon 8h ago
Does this still apply if said father has a kid in range at 50 years old?
2
u/sweetbeard 7h ago
Agreed, getting spanked at age 35 sucked, and it only got worse when I was 40.
2
u/Impossible-Bowler770 7h ago
Yeah well I can tell you as an older millennial, this was still very acceptable late '80s mid-90s. Then late in the century then started to change. Hence I got physically punished, but my two younger sisters never did. I'm glad it's much more taboo now.
2
u/showmeyourchits 7h ago
Why would my parents be trying to spank me at age 35?
2
u/vgaph 7h ago
Age 35 is way too old to still be spanked.
2
u/WakeUpFriendly 6h ago edited 6h ago
My principal spanked me in the 3rd grade. We were allowed to bring one piece of candy to school for the after school program. What I brought that day was an Easter bunny jello mold my grandma made. The exact color and shape my teacher made at home for students who aced their spelling test. I didn’t ace it. But my best friend did. I showed him after school the one my grandma made. He told the teacher. My teacher sent me to the principal for stealing. My principal grilled me in the office from 330 - 430. I was 8. I was so worn down from the anxiety. I lied, and told the principal I stole it. I hoped it would get her off my case and end it. She paddled me with a wooden paddle 30 + times. I couldn’t sit down. I was ashamed. She proudly told my parents what she did. I remember her smug face. My parents were horrified. They asked her why she didn’t just call them to verify if I’d stolen a jello mold. Explained my grandmother made some for the family. And that they told me I could bring it for after school. Her name was Mrs. Seymour. She was shocked. I remember her face. She profusely apologized. My grandma went to the school and showed her the jello mold she used and chewed her out. My parents had an attorney draft a letter and send it to the school board threatening legal action if it happened again. The school changed its policy on spanking students after that. The principal wrote me an apology letter. Made me cookies. And apologized in person. I forgave her as best as I could. But I lost all trust for teachers, coaches and principals after that one event. This one situation is enough for me to never support spanking a kid. What if the kid is right? My parents said the light went out of me at school for a couple of years. I still made good grades, but I quit trying to bond with my home room teachers after that. As an adult looking back they were right. That situation was so fucked up.
Edit. Grammar. I’m exhausted. Tons of errors.
4
u/No_Implement611 5h ago
Right because all the kids nowadays are soooo disciplined.
5
u/meeplewirp 7h ago
Spanking is a creepy and gross punishment done by people with mental health issues