Womens Game
Some unreal hurley work from the throw-in gave Ireland the first chance, but they failed to capitalise on a golden effort. Another minute later, the camógs cut through the Scots with ease. It looks like it's going to be a long game for the lassies, especially factoring in that the hurlers and camógs take some time to settle into the rules.
Aimie Nolan got the first points over the Scottish bar as the Irish took an early lead. The Irish are in complete control in the early stages.
The first sustained Scottish attack led to Megan Ralph getting the first points on the board for Scotland after a well placed strike sailed over the bar.
The Irish chances come thick and fast, hindered by the need to strike directly instead of the usual strike from the hand.
Lorna MacRae gets the Scots ahead with a calm strike over the bar. The Scots are able to be far more clinical with their chances.
Megan Ralph then gets the first Scottish goal, shooting into the bottom corner and leaving the Irish keeper Amy Lee with no chance.
Scotland need to keep this momentum going. They are looking far stronger after their very poor start.
Another glorious chance for Ireland, but they fail to even get points after having the time and space to probably go for goal.
After some sublime solo running from Aimie Nolan, Ireland get their first goal! Her first touch kills the ball dead, then she loops round the Scottish defence and audaciously lobs the Scottish keeper. That goal will take some beating today....
A big mistake from Scottish keeper Elizabeth McGregor as she lets in a ranged shot from Sinéad Wylde. Ireland take the lead!
Ireland are finding their touch as Aimie Nolan gets more points for Ireland. Ireland's superior athleticism is clear to see, and the running power is hard to match for the Scots.
Aimie Nolan again for Ireland gets another goal. Ireland are really starting to get their solos and passes together.
Ireland's first kick of the match in the 25th minute, second nature to them but not allowed today!
Ireland have hit the woodwork a good few times already. They dominate the scoreline 4-2 to Scotland's 1-2.
It's the 28th minute and someone would have to have a heroic rest of the game to have a chance of beating Aimie Nolan to player of the match... unreal skill from her, her tally will only grow from here.
Laura Hayes fires in a long ranged strike to put Ireland further ahead. I think Scotland will do well to keep the deficit as it currently is.
Laura Hayes again finds herself in acres of space as the Scottish defence are stranded defending a 2v1 situation. She steadies herself and fires in another Irish goal.
Half time comes with the score 5-4 to 1-2 in Ireland's favour. 19-5 for those of us with dyscalculia.
Ireland continued the pressure in the second half with Scots keeper McGregor being called upon numerous times. Ireland were missing a lot of points but remained in complete control of the game, with some poor goalkeeping hit outs failing to get the ball away from the danger area.
After 10 minutes of lots of missed points, Ireland finally got a point over by Naoise Hughes. Hopefully for Scotland's sake this isn't the Irish finding their sights.
Scotland's Natalie MacDonald had Scotland's best chance of the half but failed to capitalise on the 1v1 situation with the Irish keeper Lee.
In the 48th minute, Scotland's Iona McCulloch went for points. With the scoreline, it was probably better to try to go for goals, as points were not going to do much to cut the deficit.
Ava Fitzgerald for Ireland got another point to tick up the scoreline further.
Ireland's Isobel Sheehan gets another goal for Ireland with a lovely run and a precision shot in the top corner. It's been damage limitation for much of the match for the Scots.
Anais Curran for Ireland slotted a spectacular volley from close range to finish off the best passage of play from the Irish, which started from their own keeper Amy Lee to Ava Fitzgerald, who made a lung-busting solo run to get the assist of the match.
Isobel Sheehan of Ireland must have felt some mercy as she went for the points rather than going for a goal when 1v1 with keeper Elizabeth McGregor.
Saoirse McCarthy of Ireland solos past her marker and bears down on the Scottish goal, shooting to keeper McGregor's left to score a great goal.
A few moments later Naoise Hughes found herself in a similar area with the ball, but this time the Scots keeper McGregor managed to save the goal but deflected the ball between the posts to give away a point.
Aimie Nolan again for Ireland scores a beautiful goal, running rings round the Scots defenders and firing a shot into the bottom corner.
r/shinty Player of the Match - Aimie Nolan Incredible viewing, an absolute magician with the ball, with ridiculous running power cutting through the Scots defence with ease at times.
Scotland's player of the match has again been Elizabeth McGregor. She was called upon many times and left high and dry many times, but pulled off a string of good saves to keep the scoreline down.
Men's game
Scotland launched the first attack into the Irish half, getting a sideline "cut" in a great position to get points on the board early. Ruaridh Anderson strike looked as if the ball went through the posts. The goal judge disagreed with his signal, but the video editor marked it as a point for Scotland. Will need to check this one later...
Ireland came roaring back with an attack of their own, Cian O'Sullivan with a one on one chance. Keeper Bob McGregor was quick off his line to force some ground hurley the Dublin man scuffed his lines... close call.
Was good to see a few of the Scots playing without helmets, perhaps the last time we will see this.
After a kick from Scotland in the midfield, Aaron Dunphy took the free directly on the halfway line and got it on target, floating in the top corner. Keeper McGregor managed to get a stick to it and calmly play it away.
In the third minute we heard the first real clash of the ash between Thomas "Tuck" Borthwick and Ireland's Ian Shanahan. I think Tuck came off slightly better, but no real advantage was gained.
Another sideline attempt from Ruaridh Anderson. Slightly more acute than the last, but it didn't get close. Scotland really need to make these chances count as they have a huge advantage in this kind of attempt on goal. It's far more difficult for the hurlers with their sideline cuts.
Ireland's Fiachra C. Fennell sent Thomas "Tuck" Borthwick for a spice bag as he juggled the ball over the Kingussie man's head, but he failed to get his shot on target. Bob McGregor was marched back as he tried to take the subsequent bye hit from the wrong place. The exact rules of the game take some time to get used to, even for those playing.
After 5 minutes Scotland lead by a single point in the game so far.
Gerard Walsh got the first point on the board for Ireland after a ranged shot from the left sideline looped high into the night sky, just having the legs to creep over the Scottish bar.
The video editor has reset the scoreline to Ireland now leading with the single point: Anderson's first sideline attempt was indeed called wide.
In the 8th minute we had the first Irish hurl breaking after a 50/50, a good omen perhaps.
Zander Michie had Scotland's first "65" (the composite rules equivalent of a corner) and channeled his inner Kevin Bartlett to equalise with a clean strike over the Irish bar.
In the 10th minute Scotland scored the first goal of the game. Blair Morrison won the contest in midfield, for Danny Kelly to hit the ball up the park, Iain Robinson playing a shirt pass to an onrushing Anderson, who played another smart pass to Calum McLay. He looked like he had taken too much time and had to shoot from a difficult angle, but he made no mistake, leaving Irish keeper Billy Nolan stranded and striking the ball into the back of the net.
Ruaridh Anderson, with a sublime touch (could have been a nutmeg), turned on a swivel to fire from range and get another point on the board for Scotland. The hurlers haven't started to click just yet, but over the years the trend is clearly that Scotland start strong and Ireland come roaring back into the game once they get their hitting on point. Scotland need to get the scoreboard ticking along to give them the best chance.
Zander Michie had another chance for points after an Irish kick. Again he fired the ball over the bar for a point.
Scotland are really starting to command the match. Good play from Anderson got the ball to Calum McLay in space. It really looked like he was trying to put a shot on the net, but the ball ended up high in the air and over the bar. It doesn't matter how they go over, as long as they do go over. Scotland lead 1-4 to Ireland's solitary point in the 13th minute.
Ireland's Aaron Dunphy had a solo run towards the Scots' goal. He went for goal with a good shot bound for the top corner and forced a fine save from Scottish goalkeeper McGregor.
Ireland's Gerard Walsh lined up a sideline cut, and the ball had the legs and the direction as it sailed over the bar to get another point on the board for Ireland. Worth noting, the sideline cut is an incredible piece of skill to master. A recent rule change in hurling now puts 2 points on the board for a successful sideline cut, as the GAA want to reward this fine stick work. But in the words of Gimli, it still only counts as one, today.
Ruaridh Anderson, being the absolute whippet that he is, chopped with his trademarked "Anderson Turn" and got a shot on target away, but a diving save from the Irish keeper Billy Nolan kept it out, forcing the ball wide to give Scotland another 65 attempt. Zander Michie went 3 for 3 for his attempts at points.
Zander Michie lost his 100% record as he pulled a sideline attempt wide.
Scotland had the hurlers in defence at 6s and 7s, with multiple saves in quick succession needed to keep the ball out of the net. Great last ditch defending from them. In these situations the hurlers are hindered, as usually they could scoop the ball up to hand and run out of the danger area, or even kick it out, but they are forced to rely on ground hurling to clear their lines.
Blair Morrison now with the sideline attempt. It didn't have the legs and was stopped by the Irish defence, but only as far as Innes Blackhall, who first timed his stop but pulled it well wide. He is very angry at himself over this one.
After another Irish kick, Zander Michie fired his free hit from his own half right down the throat of the Irish keeper Billy Nolan, who did well to save the ball and clear it.
Scotland's Blair Morrison absolutely clears out Ireland's Darragh Neary as he solos past a few Scots. He puts on his best innocent face, "who me?", but the ref is having none of it. Andrew Ormond scoops the ball up and strikes cleanly over the bar to get Ireland another point.
Luca McCusker has a marauding run down the wing and skins both of Scotland's Ruaridh Anderson and Zander Michie. He managed to get a pass away before a Scottish defender chops down the hurler to give away another free hit in point range. Andrew Ormond steps up and gets a point for Ireland.
Calum McLay gets his second goal of the evening. He needed two bites of the cherry to eventually get it past the Irish keeper Billy Nolan, who did well to stop the first shot from point blank range. Scotland are beginning to run away with it early on, leading 2-5 to 0-4 in the 30th minute.
At the throw-in Darragh Neary takes another caman to the shoulder, not for the first time today. It will be a rough day at work for him on Monday. But after a few seconds of recovery he was bounding towards goal with the ball glued to his stick. He flicked the ball and volleyed it towards goal. Duncan Matheson managed to get a touch on the ball but was unable to do anything other than divert it past a helpless McGregor into the net. Ireland finally get a goal after some individual brilliance from Darragh Neary.
A broken band on a hurl led to some fine sportsmanship, as the Irish defender asked Calum McLay to use his caman to hammer in the pin on the band. Good as new.
Lewis Cameron was clearly tripped as he was bearing down towards the Irish goal. The ref looked to play advantage as he did manage to get the ball to his fellow attacker Neily McNaughton, whose well struck, low driven shot forced a save from keeper Billy Nolan, but the ref still brought it back to the original foul on Lewis Cameron.
Anderson placed the ball down but gave Declan Brennan the close range free hit duties. This is foreign to shinty players, but he could go for goal direct from the free, as 5 Irishmen lined the goal line to try to stop him. But he was playing percentage shinty as he elected to go for points instead of trying for goal. Not the most exciting option, but probably the smartest.
Just before the first half ended, the hurlers were really finding the sweet spot. Some terrific soloing from the entire right wing led to Diarmaid Stritch scoring a peach of a goal. Ireland are right back in this game.
The last action of the first half saw Declan Brennan getting his second point of the match after a well struck 65. Scotland are ahead with only 3 points. Everything to play for in the second half.
Disaster for Scotland at the opening of the second half. Ruaridh Anderson takes a sore one to his left leg and has to leave the pitch for treatment. Not sure how bad it is, but the Kingussie talisman is the most in-form player in the country at the moment, and with a title defining game still to play for Kingussie, they could do without losing him.
Ireland's Damien Healey body checks and sends Donald Nixon to the deck. He looked to have hit the deck already out cold, an ugly one. Damien Healey is booked. The ref is incredibly lenient with where he allows Zander Michie to take the free hit from, and he knocks the ball over the bar to increase his personal haul.
Cian O'Sullivan fires straight back with a ranged shot going over the bar. Still only 3 points in this game. Andrew Ormond gets another point for Ireland as he too gets one over the bar. Is this the usual Irish second half storm about to hit Scotland? Séamus Harnedy then knocks over a close range free hit to cut the Irish deficit to 1.
Luca McCusker, with an over the shoulder volley from deep, sails a ball over the Scottish bar to equalise for Ireland. We are all square in the 55th minute.
Scotland get a chance to stop the rot and get at least a point from a free hit. Innes Blackhall steps up and sends it for the points, but it's too low and an Irish hurl stops it and sends it away.
Aaron Dunphy then, with a free over the bar, puts Ireland ahead for the first time in a long while. Scotland are falling apart, again.
Iain Robinson, who is being well marshalled by hurlers, finally gets involved in the game. He turns his marker and strikes from a difficult angle, but he's exactly on the mark and equalises for Scotland. This match is anybody's at the moment.
A top drawer save by the Irish keeper Billy Nolan stops Danny Kelly from a certain goal after a well struck volley.
The game is spicing up. Every swing has a counter swing, a great contest on show.
Aaron Dunphy sends another free over the bar to put Ireland back in the lead. Scotland's Daniel MacVicar fires right back and gets a point for Scotland.
Sam O'Farrell scores probably the point of the match. A few touches to steady himself running away from goal, and an over the shoulder shot from the sideline sails dead centre through the Scottish posts. Beautiful stick work.
With 10 minutes to go, Ireland are ahead by 1 point, with the scores at 2-11 to 2-10.
A lovely dribble by Daniel MacVicar gets the ball to Innes Blackhall, who takes a dig at goal and gets it completely wrong as he duffs it. Luckily for Scotland, it falls to the top goalscorer in the Premier League, Iain Robinson, who buries the ball into the back of the net from close range. Scotland take the lead!
Ireland are quick to get the ball forward from the throw-in, as Pearse Óg McCrickard sends the ball over for a point. Scotland lead by only 1 point now.
It's the Irishmen's turn to have the Scots defence at 6s and 7s, with no less than 3 saves needed to keep the ball out of the net. Two teams giving their all now.
The ref wants to get involved, it seems, as he gives an Irish free hit from close range for reasons unknown to me. Kingussie's Bob McGregor isn't used to dubious decisions going against him... Ireland's Aaron Dunphy sets up to take the free and smashes it over the bar to tie the game, 7 minutes remaining.
Damien Healey solos from deep in his own half, only to be taken out by Daniel Sloss. Innes Blackhall is booked, for what I assume is back chat. Aaron Dunphy takes the free and puts Ireland ahead again, 5 mins left.
Declan Brennan tries to clear the ball but the ref judges it to be a foul. That's one that's never a foul in shinty, he's entitled to go for that all day long. Ireland get the free hit just inside the Scots half. Aaron Dunphy, who has been fantastic when going for points all match, continues his form to put Ireland 2 points ahead with 2 and a half minutes remaining in normal time.
Daniel MacVicar is brought down as he dribbles by a few hurlers. He quickly gets up and Zander Michie takes the free hit, goes for the point and gets it. Cuts the deficit to one.
As we get to the 80th minute, Ireland's Sam O'Farrell goes on a mazy run and scores another point to put Ireland 2 points ahead. But there are 5 minutes of added time still to play after the few injuries in the second half.
Zander Michie sends in a free hit into the mixer, and Innes Blackhall finds himself 2 yards out with the ball dropping dead at his feet. He calmly strokes the ball into the bottom corner as Scotland take the lead. One point in it.
Irish keeper Billy Nolan trots up to take a free hit from his own half and leathers it over the bar to take the point. After 82 and a half minutes of unreal play, we are all level. Next point wins it surely.
Some great wing play from Scotland leaves Innes Blackhall alone in the box, bearing down on goal. Everyone this side of the Irish Sea is screaming "shoot", but he seems to decide to do nothing... The Irish player tracking back eventually gets there, and he looks to kick the ball though. The ref blows the whistle for a foul while Iain Robinson simultaneously fires the ball into the back of the Irish net. No idea what Innes Blackhall was trying to do, but by Joe he has just set up the most spectacular of finishes. The ref awards a penalty.
Zander Michie steps up to take it. It's all level, so he doesn't "need" to go for goal, and with only 15 seconds remaining, surely he just goes for the point and all but seals a famous win. He calmly goes for the point, and Scotland are 1 point ahead with 8 seconds left on the clock. The Irish keeper Nolan is scrambling to get the ball in play as fast as possible. He sends the ball up into the midfield, Scotland clear the ball away (anywhere will do at the moment), and the ref blows the final whistle.
As the saying goes, shinty is the real winner today, but the composite rules were the real winner today, producing a nail biting finish after 80 minutes of unreal play.
r/shinty Player of the match - Innes Blackhall.
Apart from his decision making in the final moments, he played an absolute blinder, flew fearlessly into tackles, and got a last gasp goal, and an assist too. Innes adapts well to composite rules with his ability to strike the ball cleanly no matter the situation, and his general running power and physical attributes.
Irish Player of the match - Sam O'Farrell. He made some moves and showed some skill that still don't seem possible after the third rematch, a really exciting and attacking minded player to watch.
Some important things to mention, to put more context on what these results mean, for the women's game, the Irish Camógs were a class above, but considering there are over 100 times more camógs than women's shinty players, this is clear to see. For the mens, hurlers outnumber the shinty players by about 50 to 1. The huge base difference is clear to see as every single hurler and Camóg were Athletic specimens.
when you also factor in its not the creme de la crème of irish players who make up the squads, but players from mostly the second and third tier of the Hurling/Camogie structure. But the scots are made up of the best players available (with some players who may not be described as "the best")
Finally, and i can't stress this enough, the rules don't really hinder the Scots at all, if anything they have the advantage of a new avenue to score with the points over the bar, but the Irish are heavily hindered, For example the irish will successfully shoot points about 65% of the time in a hurling matches, but across these games the success % was lower than 25%.
So i don't think Scotland's mens win mean that shinty is the superior sport, not that this is the intention of these games. The intention is to share two great cultural sports, and I think across both games this was a titanic success!