I run a small creative business and work with a freelance designer who bills hourly. I’ve noticed a few timesheet discrepancies recently, and this latest one has really affected my trust.
I scheduled him for 4.5 hours to transfer content from an Excel spreadsheet into one existing design template I’d already created.
Here’s the timeline:
12pm: His timesheet started.
1:30pm: He messaged saying he was starting work and opening the design file, as he had a question about the file not opening properly
4:30pm: His timesheet ended, recording exactly 4.5 hours - the same amount I’d scheduled.
4:30pm: Last recorded activity on the Dropbox file.
When I questioned the hours and asked for more information on the 1.5 extra hours, he explained that he sometimes enters his timesheets retrospectively. He then changed the finish time to 6pm, maintaining he’d worked the full 4.5 hours (1:30pm-6pm)
He claimed he’d moved the file to his desktop around 4:30pm, continued working until 6pm, and uploaded the completed work to Dropbox at the end of the next day.
However, Dropbox showed repeated file revisions throughout the following day, which if he was working from his desktop it would have only shown one final upload at EOD.
I’ll also clarify it is part of our process to bill hours legitimately worked not just the hours scheduled
When I called him, he became upset, telling me he worked 4.5 hours, that he isn’t lying, and suggesting I bill him for just one hour that day. I declined because I wasn’t asking for a discount, just accurate billing and honestly. He dug his heels in maintaining he’d worked the hours but pushed back when I asked him to show me the local working file on his desktop , which would prove he was being truthful
I really want to stress that I’m genuinely not a micromanager. I’ve never had to check file activity or monitor when freelancers are working. The only reason I investigated this was because I’m managing the project budget and the original timesheet didn’t seem to match when he’d told me he was starting the work, and I was feeling dubious
This is also the third timesheet discrepancy I’ve noticed.
I’m of course happy to pay every hour genuinely worked, but I need to trust the accuracy of the billing.
Would you believe his explanation? I really don’t believe it and feel he is stuck in a lie. Am I overthinking this, or would you also be questioning the hours? I’m not going to take this particular issue any further as its not worth it, I’ll have him bill me the 4.5 hours. However if he is lying which I genuinely believe he is from the evidence I have, I may need to start scheduling him less work