Oooh man, I just spent so many hours smoking a Tri Tip for the first time. It’s my 3rd time smoking anything and I was ready for the challenge. I don’t even know how long it took me to smoke this bad boy, but it must have been 3-5 hours. I lost count because I was doing so much but I started everything including the prep around 530pm and didnt finish until 1am. I’m pretty confident I didnt throw the tri tip in till like 730pm and I had 2 times where my temperatures dropped significantly that I had to restart another set of coals so that added time to my smoke, I know now how to keep the fire going.
I smoked at 230°F and until the internal temperature showed around 145-150°F before I pulled and reversed seared 4 mins on each side for a total of 8 mins. I smoked with some applewood and hickory chips.
I started off the whole thing by trimming all the silver skin and trimming off a lot of the fat cap, but left some fat to be able to render into the meat.
I then seasoned the tri tip with a Worchester sauce as a base before seasoning it with heavy salt, peppercorn, garlic and onion powder and paprika.
Then I let it rest for about an hour+ while I prepared some of the other food and the fire.
Finally, once I got the sear where I liked the nice crust how I wanted, I removed the roast and I let it sit for 20 mins before I sliced it. (I know tri tip has 2 different grains) I think I forgot how to properly slice it, but it didn’t matter because the roast was still so dang tender that I am a full believer in smoking now. My picky sister gave the tri tip roast a solid 9/10.
I served it with some homemade bacon mac and homemade garlic mashed taters, with my first attempt at a chimichurri sauce. I wanted to make some homemade dinner rolls but felt it was just too much work and decided on buying a pack at my nearby grocery store for $1.09 for a pack of 12.
Anyway, I know it’s my first time doing a tri tip but I will say that I LOVED how it came out. I can’t tell if it was a well done or medium because it wasnt dry and it was immensely tender. Temperature said it was fully cooked before I seared it. Anyway, this came out sooo good that Im already planning on buying a few more tri tips I see on sale. This was my first time eating tri tip and Im just going to say it, I preferred this tri tip over a lot of the steaks Ive had, lol, but hey that’s just me.
Overall, after calculating all the expenses, this plate cost about $6.00 per person to make. Not bad at all. Im super proud of myself and I happy i did this.