TLDR: the software is completely unusable, ArtCraft is using unethical marketing practices, and stay away from them.
i'm a professional book designer who uses Adobe InDesign, and the Artcraft clones of Adobe software using AI caught my attention when they initially came out.
I had already reviewed it ~2.5 months ago but many pro-ai were complaining in the comments that it was just a few weeks old and that its development will accelerate a lot with more people contributing tokens.
(reposting since crossposts are banned)
So i promised to come back later and check it out again in ~1 month.
It's been almost 3 months now, and i decided to come back to see if they held up to the hype
note: The project claimed that in about "~180 agent hours of Opus 5.5" (whatever that means) and the product will be ready for a stable release. And one redditor (in a now deleted comment) claimed that in ~1 month the project will have 100% parity with the real product.
What they improved
I'm starting with the good progress they made (they will need it)
Master pages work now
before trying to add a master page just bugged out and it would make the screen black. You can open a master page, add text, even a current page marker, and it will do its job correctly (somewhat)
Text flowing works now (sort of).
Before when trying to add text and let the text flow automatically (basically, that means it automatically creates new pages to fit your text) it just didnt work. It would do nothing, crash, put a black screen,but now it can work, although at smaller sizes. Trying to paste something over ~50 pages will crash the app. Which makes this practically unusable.
A little bit more flexibility in PDF export options (but still totally unusable for real print)
I complained last time that the pdf export was super basic. It seems like the ArtCraft devs have been feeding my post into their AI, and it improved, very slightly. They added a few checkboxes to compress images and selectively export pages (which are both, completely useless). Still no real support for custom CMYK print options or PDF quality or anything in-between.
(If you dont know: CMYK is the colors they use for printing, and many publishers / printers will require you to use a specific custom CMYK preset, and using a default one is dangerous because it can look different when it's actually printed)
That's about it for what they improved.
The issues with the software
No paragraph styles support
How in hell these guys made an InDesign clone without paragraph styles? Paragraph styles is basically fonts on steriods, it lets you create custom "presets" for text and apply it to them so you can change like the font and stuff and it will automatically affect every text it was assigned instead of doing it manually. It has zero support for it, the panel opens but it gives an error at the bottom.
(This alone makes it totally unusable)
No image support (and/or Anchored object support)
You can sort of place an image into the file but i noticed it just doesn't work because it will randomly crash when dragging it around, and when i tried to place it inside the text as an anchored object (the text will flow around it), first it did nothing and then it crashed (not sure because of image support or general instability). EVEN THOUGH ArtCraft claims on the very front page of the supported features that it supposedly works!
(Completely unusable unless this is fixed)
Very unstable software
The program will randomly crash when moving text, (trying) placing images, changing fonts, sometimes just clicking around in the menu, And these aren't rare occurances, they can happen in < 3 minutes of using the software.
Unusable PDF export as i mentioned above
Margins/bleed system is almost completely unsupported
Basically, margins is the empty space you have to leave in your book design because the printer will cut it off, (its part of how books are printed). And it's basically one of the most important features in all of adobe InDesign. Without this implemented perfectly, your book has a chance to end up completely broken in print.
They "added" support for it but:
- None of the presets add it automatically
- InDesign lets you automatically calculate it based on the input size, but this doesn't
- Even when inputting manually there's something off with the display, i think their implementation is flawed because the margins are different to InDesign
- And god knows what these will actually look like in print when combined with all the other issues
And i can go on and on and on... about more issues with the software, but i think it's clear now, this stuff is just unusable and this point, pure slop.
⚠️The sketchy and unethical practices of ArtCraft
Changing versions
When i first tried it, the version was 0.6.0 i believe. The version on the front page and the actual version was different, but it didnt matter anyway.
But now i look at the product, and its version 0.20.1 ??? It's moved 4 versions back??
0.6.0 means its now in beta phase, 0.20.1 is pre-alpha and their page itself says it.
So they realised their product is nowhere, and decided to just, pretend its an earlier version? That is a massive red flag
What they say, and what they have is different
The frontpage says a different version, and it downloads a different version
They used to claim about max. 300 hours of agents that their product will have 95% parity, now that number moved up to 1300
They claim its about 47% ready for real work, with what metric? This is purely a misleading marketing claim that is completely untrue. It's 0% ready for real work, and a pre-alpha software by definition can't be pre-alpha and support 50% of "real work".
Their roadmap has claimed dozens of features that dont actually work
They generate examples of complex layouts themself using agents and code, but they are not even close to being reproducible in the app.
Stay way from these guys because they are liars, all they want is attention and they will lie about their product and make it look good at any cost.
Conclusion and final thoughts
As i already said, this product is 0% ready for real use.
One redditor claimed in 3 months they would've not only had 100% feature parity with InDesign, but also moved BEYOND indesign! Nice prediction.
The amount of "estimated agent hours" had grown exponentially, exactly as i expected. From ~200 to a "usable beta" to now ~1,900 hours. And next time ill check they gonna say 10,000 agent hours or they gave up entirely.
This software is pure slop, and they use unethical marketing tactics to grab attention and straight up lie to the user. Stay away from these guys. Who knows, it could even be a massive honeypot for malware, i mean, who could tell they hid malware in it, when there's hundreds of thousands of lines of slop inside?
And i see their development. They basically pasted my issues with the software into their AI, and their AI came up with a "fix." But it's like a shallow, hardcoded fix that looks good on the surface when reproducing it exactly, and then you go in and realise nothing is actually fixed. Thats the entire project anyway.