r/starcitizen
•
u/Abriael
•
16h ago
•
1
DRAMA Feel free to criticize CIG, but at least learn what "pay-to-win" means.
I understand knee-jerk reactions to stuff, especially when fueled by influencer sensationalism and drama-queening, but let's at least try to keep the criticism rational.
Purchasing ships is Pay-to-Win.
The leaked subscriber bonuses are much, much, much further from pay-to-win than that.
They boosted your personal progression and lowered your downtime in a way that is basically irrelevant to the competition with other players.
It's basically a way to decrease the grind, which is very common in most MMORPGs out there.
It's called "Pay-for-convenience" (Yes, this is actually a recognized definition in MMOs), because no one is "winning" anything thanks to it. What you're buying is the convenience of having to grind a bit less and waiting for your favorite ships a bit less.
Good? Bad? That depends on your point of view, but saying that it's "pay-to-win" is waving around a loaded term irrationally for effect.
Now, feel free to downvote this. Can't care less. Some truths need to be said even if they hurt the drama queens' massive egos.
74
u/Ok_Arrival8948 15h ago •
Couldn't you say buying ships is pay4convenience since it skips the grind of getting a ship? You're just arguing semantics.
12
u/CorpseCaptain 15h ago •
Pay to win is anything that give a real money only advantage over game mechanics. Ships and weapons are obtainable in-game, rrp/insurance boost are not.
3
u/Shuggeh 15h ago
The proposed percentages wouldn't even account for variance in player skill or capability.
The entire game is pay to win. The outrage at this has my head spinning to the logic behind it.
I guess someone's favourite streamer told them what opinion to have today and that's what they've walked into Reddit armed with.
I'd personally prefer there was an optional sub as part of their monetisation post launch and they never sold another ship again.
33
u/PiibaManetta 15h ago edited 14h ago
You win time. And by winning time, you can progress faster, unlocking more potentially powerful item faster. Item that can help you have an advantage against other players.
Example, if you are a subscriber you can gain a BP faster then me, and so craft a weapon that is better then mine faster then me.
It's 100% a p2w scenario, no dubt.
But cig have confiremed that this subscriber perks will not be really implemented. "Apparently", someone have put that code in the PTU by "error"...
24
u/Deathless616 new user/low karma 15h ago
11
u/Diptothaset 15h ago •
Any advantage that you can gain by paying is pay to win. Never underestimate the human ability to justify stuff
1
u/Important_Cow7230 aurora 15h ago
Pay to win is subjective, lying isn’t
8
u/Casey090 15h ago •
By your logic, a 1 year login queue unless you pay is just a question of convenience. XD
12
u/Zap500 reliant 15h ago
To me when in a multiplayer PVP game, P2W encompass all the, 'pay to skip', 'pay for convenience', because time to do something will matter. Unpopular opinion in this sub though lol
I'd rather they push a slight rep boost sub than sell ships though, which under what I said above, is way more impactful. But doing both would be shitty.
12
u/Psycho7552 Human Supremacy 15h ago edited 15h ago •
Nope, the subscribtion bonuses are pay two win, just like ships, armor and weapons you dolt.
"pay for convinience" is simply another mental gymnastic to make pay two win seem less bad. Term was used for first time by bungie when they introduced instant level ups for real money in destiny2
At least don't lie to yourself with it being good thing.
7
u/AnOrdinaryChullo 13h ago
I see the brain dead astroturf bots have been engaged.
'This totaly anti-consumer Asian F2P crap is actually not bad at all and is in fact awesome, guys'
2
u/Careless_Joke3129 15h ago
Buying ships pay to win
Subscription = freemium but in a paid access title instead of a free to play title ick lol
2
u/Ravenask 15h ago •
I think the most ironic part about the whole drama is that we're arguing whether a $20 sub should get some in-game bonuses while there is a entire event where people sink hundreds if not thousands of dollars on ships going on. The fact that people are literally arguing that buying an entire ship isn't p2w right here really gives me the disturbing feeling that people are more okay with thousand-dollar capital ships than monthly sub.
Call me pessimistic if you want, but I'm genuinely worried that this drama would backfire in the worst possible way that CIG would take this as a "yes" for post-1.0 ship sale instead of transitioning to a more healthy monetization, and the playerbase would actually be fine with it. We are so psychologically conditioned to accept ship sales as the norm for well over a decade now, and I won't be surprised at the slightest if people end up choosing post-1.0 ship sale over a premium sub model.
2
u/AcanthaceaeRare2646 13h ago
>Odin / Idris
>Not pay to win
Pick one.
5
u/enbtest 14h ago
"Purchasing ships is Pay-to-Win."
No it's not! Lol. That's absurd. It's also "Pay-for-convenience". You can't "win" with a purchased ship that someone else can just as well get.
You correctly explain the subscriber being "Pay-for-convenience", and then in the same post incorrectly explain buying ships, which uses the EXACT same principle.
6
u/TheSubs0 Kiith S'Jet 15h ago •
Bad thing exist, therefore, we should stack more bad thing.
I am very smart game designer.
2
u/RedFlr 15h ago •
lemme translate for you folks, "im a subscriber and i like my pay to win"
funny how having premium accounts with extra exp and money boost has been considered pay to win for ages, but not for SC white knights xD
SC has both pay to wins, get new meta vehicles and premium accounts, i would just say that their vehicles pay to win kinda suck because now they nerf them even before the sales are over lol, before they used to wait a patch or two like any p2w game
1
u/Aggressive_Skill6188 15h ago
Agree.
1
u/Digitalzombie900 15h ago
You don't understand what win means. Win can be anything. I have 3-5 hours a week to play this game, if I pay ( and I would) to get more in that time than others, I am paying to win. I am not against it, you just need to get off your, let me TeaCh YoU GuyS whAt Pay TO Win Is horse.w
1
u/azkaii oldman 15h ago
P2W hasn't yet been established. Theres ever change still based on future decisions it will go either way.
1
u/Gypsydumb 15h ago
Most midwit take this year. I mean, there were some strong contenders, but you came swinging at the end of the year, leaving the rest of the contestants behind, and took the lead in the last hour. Outstanding job! You took issue with the general approach to the "game" and gave us much needed education. Now I know, back to the verse!
1
u/mrcalendar 13h ago
My opinion is the game has always basically been pay to win. The fact you can drop $45000 to own all ships by 1.0 gives whales a massive advantage come 1.0. In my mind anytime you can pay cash to skip/speedup game play, its pay to win. What are you winning is the question though. Alpha doesn't matter so shit like the blades fiasco i laughed heartily at. I get people complaining to prevent more pay2win marketing, but CIG does need to income the game long term. If they did implement something like this monthly perk, i still view it as pay to win. Faster rep may mean faster gains of rep bonus stuff (im not sure what you get from higher rep besides better paid contracts, so faster income)? Faster ship claim time could help those in large PVP battles where they could get back to a battle faster with said ship?
Again i ultimately ask what are you winning though. PVP may come down to skill but again a faster claim time could also help in big battles. Faster making money may lead to more powerful players. Maybe if some griefers were able to block off access to a planet or system due to spent money (is that winning)? But hopefully the game will be so large it wont be an issue, and maybe even add cool sandbox game play.
I for one do not want to pay a monthly fee to play the game. Played wow in 2004 and hated the sub fee, made me addicted and killed a lot of my free time and fun. I played guild wars 2 and thought their model was pretty good. I got to play for years while others paid for their nice costume armors and stuff. I hoped CIG could survive off that route, players paying for clothing, weapons, gear, furniture?, etc. But as others pointed out i don't want it to become like fortnight or some god awful shit like that. Just pumping out crap paints to keep the money coming in. A minor bonus to monthly fee may be fine, but also don't want the game play to end up catering to long grinding to incentivize paying the monthly fee to save a bit of time. Someone posted an early quote from Roberts that his long term vision did allow something like this though, to allow those with less time to get a boost by paying cash for currency or something. But again i do not want a forced monthly fee just to play.
I had been worried about land purchasing, like if whales can just buy up the planet what about us regular players wanting to build a nice home on some acreage. But having been flying around Nyx1 in 5.0 i've realized how absolutely massive it feels, there is so much space its insane to me. And finally makes me realize what in game exploration can be like (stoked).
1
u/vbsargent oldman 11h ago
I’d just point out that people aren’t waving the term irrationally.
Other than not understanding the term, a lot of people have a rationale: to piss people off and cause mostly negative reactions.
Too many people have moved to trolling others and getting reactions as their source of joy, validation, or whatever.
It’s so easy to see in the political and social arenas and it has been growing in the gaming arena as well.
:-/
1
u/Asmos159 scout 11h ago
This is why I don't have a problem with the pledge ships a few months after they are removed from the store because in a conflict there is no difference between someone joining 5 years after release coming across somebody that's bought an odin, or some of that earned one.
However, if my fleet can defend an operation from an attacking fleet, but that attacking fleet can replace their ships and come back sooner than I can replace my ships because they are subscribers. I would call bs.
1
u/taco-kiss 8h ago
Where do you draw the line?
1
u/joelm80 7h ago
P2W is anything that gives a paid advantage, including MMO leveling rates, discounts, cooldowns.
You can make a straw man argument about the meaning of a term all you want, but that doesn't change "pay $ for advantage" being horrible.
The ships being sold are bad enough, but something has to be the funding model and that has been it.
Can't have a $45 game, $ purchases and then also apply freemium model. Pick one, don't be greedy and want to stack them all.
1
u/jrsedwick Zeus MKII 15h ago
-2
u/Pkactus 15h ago edited 5h ago
do you get store credit for this post?
edit :// maybe you can purchase a sense of humour as DLC
1
u/PressFtoCutLeg "I'm tired, boss." 14h ago
"t's called "Pay-for-convenience" (Yes, this is actually a recognized definition in MMOs),"
And those are not loot boxes, they are surprise mechanics.
1
u/Blood-Wolfe Anvil Enthusiast 14h ago edited 14h ago
Agreed (mostly), and I've posted against who I can in all the other ridiculous threads pretty blatantly and I don't care if I'm downvoters either.
I don't agree though about purchasing ships being P2W because they can all be earned in-game after 4-6 period after release which means it's not pay-to-win. Also since aUEC bought ships perform the same and have no disadvantage vs pledged ships so no it's not P2W. P2W means they would be exclusively to paying cash for.
1
u/nicarras 13h ago
Convenience is not PTW. PTW is literally buying ships and weapons in the shop. The OP is right.
1
u/knsmknd ARGO CARGO 13h ago
At least one person with a sane and based take on this. Hope isn't lost.
-2
u/Nolsoth ARGO CARGO 15h ago
I really do t get the drama.
Having an optional sub that gives a small boost to rep and some subscriber flair was always going to happen and it's absolutely optional.
0
u/FarGodHastur 15h ago
Pay-2-win should be changed to pay-2-advantage since that whats it really is more often than not. But semantics just makes the conversation take longer for no reason when everyone in the room kind of already understands that.
0
u/TropicalxDepression new user/low karma 13h ago
Badfaithmaxxing
Shillmaxxing
Botmaxxing
Take your pick
0
u/nRGon12 Nautilus 12h ago edited 12h ago
This post belongs in r/confidentlyincorrect
-1
u/SOVERElGN_SC origin 14h ago
Buying ships is another prime example of pay for convenience and nothing more. There is no p2w in SC since it’s not competitive game to start with and players aren’t competing. There are conditions for competitive play, no matchmaker, no competitive modes aside AC. If someone is progressing faster than you - well, mind your own business.
0
u/MrRaymondLuxuryYacht aegis 15h ago •
I'd say shorter claim time and smaller claim cost would be a direct advantage in PvP.
A ship bought for real money will be worse than one earned and upgraded in game. I'm taking about tier upgrades through crafting in the future. But component upgrades today can make a big difference.
I'm not the biggest fan of selling ships, but I can't see any other way the project could have been funded. I'd prefer we move away from anything that could be construed as P2W if possible.
-7
u/Affectionate_Dark63 15h ago
Thank you for the clarification that idiots are going to read lol. But seriously, its sad that people don't understand this
-5
u/Ted_Striker1 origin 15h ago
I've been saying the same thing on Spectrum (and here) and getting a lot of flak for it.
Someone on Spectrum even said "to general gaming audiences this is exactly what pay 2 win looks like, so that is what it will be called. No amount of spectrum posting will change that."
So to them, because they believe subscriber perks are pay to win that is the definition, as if someone's opinion determines a definition, and they're too bullheaded to change their opinion because their emotions rule them. They don't like it, therefore shut up it's pay to win.
People are so aggravating lol.
0
u/Kernkraft3000 Bounty Hunter 15h ago
Its pay to progress. Pay to win would be for example "gold ammo" only for purchase.
But afaik there are ships only obtainable by paying money.
0
u/Personal_Still106 15h ago •
Incorrect.
Just looking at the claim timer -- The only cost to dying in SC is time. If you're in combat with other players, say over Hathor fighting for control, being able to get back to the fight quicker can have a direct impact on your victory or that of your friends. This is literally pay to win.
This post succinctly expands on some of the other bonuses and why it's bad: https://www.reddit.com/r/starcitizen/s/GKdjawWxrD
0
u/SmoothOperator89 Towel 15h ago •
We have always accepted that players could buy ships and have that advantage. That's been part of the funding model from day 1 of the Kickstart. Things like reputation and claim timers were going to be tools to mitigate that advantage. You still need to wait just as long as any other player if your ship blows up. You still need to put in the same number of missions to gain reputation to unlock the higher tier missions. Giving a paid option to reduce that isn't just about pay to win, it's removing the little bit of level playing field that still existed.
-2
u/taggyoureit new user/low karma 15h ago
Buying access to the game is pay-to-win! You'll be winning more than people without game access! CIG should stop selling access to the game immediately!
-2
u/DasPibe 15h ago
Lol, what a CIG´s wannabe boy
-3
u/Dracoxidos 15h ago
Thank you
-3
u/Lion_El_Jonsonn rsi 15h ago
Hundred percent true
-3
u/Shuggler123 new user/low karma 14h ago
No. Paying for shortcut is pay to win. Pay for convenience is pay to win, it's just a nicer term so people don't feel bad for buying shortcuts
-3
u/Akhi_Police 13h ago
Wrong, it is by definition pay2win. This debate was done so many times and it is a korean MMO tactic to force the word pay2convenience into common usage, enabling predatory systems to be implemented without them having to call it pay2win. This debate was also one that was in BDO, Ragnarok Online, and many other and current Korean MMOs. Of course there are levels to this. As an example Warframe is pay2win, you can literalty buy the items you'd grind for....but no one complains because the game has an open market (platinum being earnable through trading) and enables reasonable rewards for the players to engage in the market.
Convenience is Pay2Win. Even PoE 1 and 2 players say that (PoE having premium stash tabs)
-1
u/sergiulll new user/low karma 14h ago
This changes maybe wouldnt change much FOR NOW but i would be sign for CIG that we dont mind and add more bullshit like that in future.
-2
u/pandibear 14h ago
Split hairs all we want it’s still unacceptable.