r/starcitizen • • 16h ago • Popcorn 1

DRAMA Feel free to criticize CIG, but at least learn what "pay-to-win" means.

I understand knee-jerk reactions to stuff, especially when fueled by influencer sensationalism and drama-queening, but let's at least try to keep the criticism rational.

Purchasing ships is Pay-to-Win.

The leaked subscriber bonuses are much, much, much further from pay-to-win than that.

They boosted your personal progression and lowered your downtime in a way that is basically irrelevant to the competition with other players.

It's basically a way to decrease the grind, which is very common in most MMORPGs out there.

It's called "Pay-for-convenience" (Yes, this is actually a recognized definition in MMOs), because no one is "winning" anything thanks to it. What you're buying is the convenience of having to grind a bit less and waiting for your favorite ships a bit less.

Good? Bad? That depends on your point of view, but saying that it's "pay-to-win" is waving around a loaded term irrationally for effect.

Now, feel free to downvote this. Can't care less. Some truths need to be said even if they hurt the drama queens' massive egos.

0 Upvotes

184 comments sorted by

74

u/Ok_Arrival8948 15h ago • Bravo

Couldn't you say buying ships is pay4convenience since it skips the grind of getting a ship? You're just arguing semantics.

-18

u/Abriael 15h ago • Heartwarming

It's ALSO pay4convenience. But it also directly puts tools in your hands to help you overwhelm someone who doesn't buy ships. So it's also pay2win, and massively so. If I buy a heavily equipped fighter and go against a pilot of similar skill in an Andromeda, the poor sod is fu*ked.

I'm arguing facts.

10

u/Early_Ad_899 15h ago

You're arguing like a bootlicking fool. You can earn the ships in game, most of my fleet is aUEC purchased at this point. There is nothing I can do ingame that will confer a +15% rep bonus.

1

u/Abriael 15h ago • Bravo

The fact that you can't have a discussion without insulting proves your irrational approach to this topic beyond doubt.

Thanks for supporting my argument, I suppose.

6

u/Early_Ad_899 15h ago

No, I'm just sick of the whiteknighting idiocy being shown by people who are apparently perfectly fine to pay an ongoing stipend to CiG after already purchasing the game and backing for much more.

CiG have walked back many things over the years, but fundamental partitioning the game experiece in a way that punishes non-subbed players is too far. Pretending that the gameplay won't be tuned to the subscribed experience is just plain ignorant.

I say this as an OG backer who's been here since the start and has had my monocle for longer than I can remember. I love the game and have supported or accepted many changes along the way, but this is a step too far.

0

u/Abriael 14h ago

You're being absolutely ridiculous. Literally none of these alleged subscribed perks affect other players in any tangible way. It's a small convenience with zero relevance besides for those who receive it.

It's also hilarious that you talk about "step so far" when you likely have a hangar full of bought ships. 😂

4

u/Early_Ad_899 14h ago

They certainly affect other players, every game that's done this ends up balancing gameplay around the subscribed players experience. CiG will be no different, they're incentivised to do so just as every other company that implements such systems is.

2

u/Ted_Striker1 origin 15h ago

But that +15% rep bonus does not give you any combat advantage whatsoever. It gives you a time advantage sure but not a combat advantage.

5

u/Early_Ad_899 14h ago

Why are you fixated on the combat aspect? No individual battle has the same impact on progression as the rep grind.

Edit to add: what do you think about subscribers getting +15% weapon damage, shields & hull hp over non-subscribers? That'd be the analogy to the impact it has on the rep grind.

-1

u/Ted_Striker1 origin 14h ago

Combat is the competitive aspect of this game that's why, and "competitive" is the crucial aspect of the definition of pay to win. The rep grind is not competitive except for bragging rights, and there's no leaderboard for it or anything.

Progression is not competitive either except bragging rights.

And wow yeah if subscribers got those perks it would be blatant pay to win lol.

3

u/Early_Ad_899 14h ago

Yeah, I disagree that combat is the only competitive aspect of the game. CiG themselves have said players will compete with crafting to mine/fabricate/sell the best gear, which require blueprints that are gated by rep levels.

-1

u/Ted_Striker1 origin 13h ago

Well that's competitive too but the advantage of slightly faster blueprints will run out as others catch up. It's a temporary advantage depending on how much time you can play.

Not quite the same.

3

u/Early_Ad_899 13h ago

Quite the same I think, the advantage of having early access to a ship runs out too.

1

u/Samuel_Janato new user/low karma 12h ago

Yes, You do! But You facts are Not a thing the vocal CIG community can deal with.

-2

u/H1tSc4n 15h ago • Bravo

Pay for convenience is part of the pay to win spectrum.

-14

u/MarkyMarkFr RSI Galaxy 15h ago • Bravo

Well you can't buy, say, a Marauder in game. So no, it's pay to win

11

u/Low-Departure-7024 15h ago

Can't buy it in game yet but in 3 months you can.

-8

u/MarkyMarkFr RSI Galaxy 15h ago • Bravo

So, we agree, with each ship release, buying it is pay2win

3

u/AbnormallyBendPenis STAR-SQ4V-RFQ9 15h ago • Bravo

But you can’t buy the reputation boost after 3 months can you? These are fundamentally different things. One can eventually be obtained by all players given enough time and effort. The other can never be obtained by anyone unless you pay real world money. That’s why people are pissed. No sure what’s so difficult to understand

-2

u/MarkyMarkFr RSI Galaxy 15h ago

The reputation doesn't give you advantages in a PvP fight, whether it's FPS or ship combat... Where is the pay2win of you don't win more easily?

3

u/AbnormallyBendPenis STAR-SQ4V-RFQ9 15h ago • Bravo

Pay2win is not the issue. CIG is putting something non cosmetic in the game that you cannot obtain without real world money. That’s the thing most people have an issue with. It’s the same thing with the flight blade debacle. Real world money exclusive stuff should be cosmetic only. It’s 15% today, what’s next? 100% next year for $50 a month? Where does it stop ?

0

u/H1tSc4n 15h ago • Regret

Yes. That is correct.

Can we not make the game more pay to win?

3

u/Celeste_3333 15h ago

People are winning in the Marauder?

2

u/MarkyMarkFr RSI Galaxy 15h ago • Bravo

It's an example, don't be the annoying troll

2

u/Celeste_3333 15h ago

Oh my god it was a joke

-1

u/H1tSc4n 15h ago • Bravo

Yes. Buying any ship beyond your starter for real money is.

SC is indeed P2W, and always was, by definition. We can, however, not want it to be more pay to win.

2

u/MarkyMarkFr RSI Galaxy 15h ago • Bravo

Well that's exactly my point...

3

u/H1tSc4n 15h ago • Heartwarming

(i think i replied to the wrong comment sorry)

0

u/Early_Ad_899 15h ago

Ships have an initial store exclusive period before becoming available ingame, this isn't new & is a fair compromise to encourage backers to pledge for ships.

0

u/Xeydnys 12h ago

The only pay to win ship is the Idris currently.

12

u/CorpseCaptain 15h ago • Bravo

Pay to win is anything that give a real money only advantage over game mechanics. Ships and weapons are obtainable in-game, rrp/insurance boost are not.

10

u/Psycho7552 Human Supremacy 15h ago • Bravo

Pay to win also encompasses so called "time savers" so if it speeds up, or help skip grind it is also pay to win.

3

u/Shuggeh 15h ago • Bravo

So being able to buy a ship with money 6 months before anyone can buy it in game isn't pay to win?

Pull your head out of your arse.

Both are pay to win.

The reputation bonus significantly less so.

1

u/OrganizationTrue5911 15h ago • Bravo

That is specific to the Alpha, that won't (Hopefully) be a thing post 1.0.

That said, buying a ship outright when someone else has to grind for it, is indeed P2W. Especially in the case of some ships like the Idris.

0

u/Shuggeh 15h ago

If that is the case then it's almost a guarantee we'll have something like this sub bonus after launch.

Some of CIGs biggest money makers are small ships.

When there are no more wipes why would someone buy them with cash when they can just buy them in game?

I'd be interested to know where they've communicated there will no longer be a delay in releasing them in game after launch or is just something you hope will change?

0

u/underwaterair new user/low karma 14h ago

If you bought the newest heavy fighter that isn't out in the game yet what did you win?

Let's say you got the M80 on release and I didn't get it in the game. I have my Guardian MX.

=======

Let's say you bought the Javelin right now and it's in the game and you roll into the game with a Javelin and you go to TSG to win it.

You know who's also at TSG? Me. I'm the random pub in your group. Or I'm the guy in your org.

What did your Javelin win? I got the same credits as you. I got the same blueprint lootpool. We're sharing the same hangar loot at the end. If I derp and fail the mission you also fail the mission.

=======

What did you win by buying the Javelin? By buying the M80? By buying the Hyun?

-1

u/CorpseCaptain 14h ago

So if I am a miner that owns an in-game mole, and they release a new starter miner that i can't buy for 6 months, that's p2w? Your logic is a little off.

0

u/Shuggeh 14h ago

Cherry picking a stupid example to suit your perspective.

Great argument.

How about a $5000 dollar battlecruiser that's objectively better than every single ship in the game?

How about a solo Idris that one shots other ships?

How about a miner so big your mole would fit in its ore bag?

Get a grip.

0

u/CorpseCaptain 13h ago

$5000 ship that doesnt exist and will be totally useless in atmosphere, not p2w, solo idris that can't maneuver enough to keep its 1 pilot weapon on target so it dies to polaris torps, again not p2w...seems you are the one attempting to cherry pick when you haven't considered the actual usefulness of ships. Bigger isnt always better.

1

u/mort1331 Industrialist 13h ago

Do you remember the hornet MK2? 

-11

u/Abriael 15h ago

No. Pay-to-win, as the wording clearly indicates, is something that helps someone who pays in the activity of winning.

Buying ships gives you a massive advantage against someone with an Andromeda. It effectively helps you win against them in a direct confrontation.

These subscriber advantages were literally just trading money for time. And the concept behind this kind of stuff in MMOs is very simple: Money is time. So you're trading time for time.

People who have more free time can grind a bit more. People who work more for money (and have less free time) can reduce their grinding time a bit.

If someone does that, it doesn't impact me, you, or anyone else one bit. The only thing impacted is their personal time invested in the game.

Oh, the travesty. 🫡

12

u/czartrak SlipStream SAR 15h ago • Bravo

I'm so.tired of these stupid ass semantic arguments. Pay 2 win has NEVER meant you literally have to be winning something. If the term was 100% literal then P2W wouldn't exist because someone with superior skill could always beat you

-6

u/Abriael 15h ago

That's not how it works.

The definition of "winning" obviously applies to the confrontation excluding the factor of skill.

If something makes you win against someone with similar skills, it's pay-to-win.

If you're tired of the industry-accepted definition of pay-to-win, you may want to find your entertainment in another industry.

6

u/czartrak SlipStream SAR 15h ago • Bravo

It's not the "industry accepted definition". You're literally just fucking wrong about that. The industry considers P2W to be anything you can buy with real money that confers an advantage over not paying. Just like anybody who's not a fucking bootlicker

-1

u/Abriael 15h ago

Obviously, you have zero experience with the MMO industry, like a pretty large percentage of the Star Citizen community.

You'll learn.

2

u/H1tSc4n 15h ago • Bravo

The definition of pay to win is any game thar allows a paying player to gain an advantage by paying real money beyond the initial purchase of the game.

So, buying ships is by definition pay to win. Skipping the grind is also pay to win.

SC is and always was to an extent pay to win. We can want it to not be more pay to win.

There is also the general understanding that ship sales will stop with 1.0 (lol)

2

u/DrJack3133 15h ago • Bravo

You’re really trying to cut hairs aren’t you? Pay to Win has always meant to gain an advantage by paying real money. This is a dumb bullshit argument. Maybe make a petition to rename pay to win as paid advantage in the gaming community and see how that pans out. Ultimately these rep gains could give you speedy grinds to buy a better ship so is that not paying to win?

2

u/H1tSc4n 15h ago • Bravo

Buying ships is p2w

Sc is p2w as literally anyone outside of this community will tell you.

We can, however, not want it to be more p2w.

3

u/Shuggeh 15h ago

The proposed percentages wouldn't even account for variance in player skill or capability.

The entire game is pay to win. The outrage at this has my head spinning to the logic behind it.

I guess someone's favourite streamer told them what opinion to have today and that's what they've walked into Reddit armed with.

I'd personally prefer there was an optional sub as part of their monetisation post launch and they never sold another ship again.

0

u/Abriael 15h ago

Indeed, Star Citizen streamers were a mistake.

0

u/Personal_Still106 15h ago • Bravo

Yeah... you've just invalidated anything you ever say on this subreddit in future.

Streamers are a part of marketing and community outreach for any company in the entertainment space. If you can't understand this basic premise, nothing else you say can be taken seriously.

1

u/Abriael 14h ago

Star Citizen streamers usually have a small reach, and their outreach outside the existing community is minimal, if not zero.

Variety streamers with a much bigger reach occasionally covering Star Citizen have the real effect on outreach.

If you ask people who joined the community where they learned about Star Citizen, it's infinitely more likely that they did so from people like Linus, or from the generalist gaming press than from grifters like saltemike, camural, or morphologis.

What most dedicated Star Citizen streamers do is stir the pot WITHIN the community, mostly amplifying, if not manufacturing, the drama because their small reach also means small earnings unless they desperately push the controversy as far as it can go to claw in some more traffic.

But you just identified yourself as a simp, and there are few things more ridiculous than a streamer's simp.

0

u/Personal_Still106 13h ago edited 13h ago

Ah, the losing argument insult, there it is.

Many streamers individually are small, but combined they are a huge force for marketing. Media like Linus are all part of the package too.

What most dedicated Star Citizen streamers do is stir the pot WITHIN the community, mostly amplifying, if not manufacturing, the drama because their small reach also means small earnings unless they desperately push the controversy as far as it can go to claw in some more traffic.

This is patently not true. Again demonstrating you don't understand the basics of media, outreach, and marketing. I worked in the industry for 30 years. This is how I can say that with statements like yours, anything else you say can't be taken seriously.

1

u/Abriael 5h ago

Things aren't "patently not true" just because you say they are.

"I worked in the industry for 30 years" doesn't help your argument either. I actually worked in the industry for over 25 years, and that's how I know that you did not. If you did, you'd know better.

The way you describe the influence of small streamers simply isn't how media algorithms work. Not even a whole army of smaller streamers can get close to the effect of a fraction of the reach with potential new players of a single bigger generalist streamer, or a single article on IGN, as reach works in a basically exponential way.

The fact that Star Citizen streamers like those I named are prone to amplify and manufacture controversy to prop up their relatively paltry earnings would mostly turn off potential new players, even if they were to occasionally reach their "for you" lists.

More often than not, they're effectively detrimental.

1

u/Personal_Still106 1h ago edited 1h ago

I actually worked in the industry for over 25 years, and that's how I know that you did not.

What you say here and what you've so far are contradictory.

The fact that Star Citizen streamers like those I named are prone to amplify and manufacture controversy to prop up their relatively paltry earnings would mostly turn off potential new players, even if they were to occasionally reach their "for you" lists.

This is your bias against these streamers. It is your opinion, not fact. And utilising streamers as a branch of promotion only requires results, irrespective of how they run their channels. As long as they don't break an agreement, they are the experts in reaching their audience.

a single article on IGN

*sigh* A single article on gaming site provides a spike, not a long tail, like streamers do. Both are valuable, but you can't dismiss one for the other.

This whole conversation started with you saying "Indeed, Star Citizen streamers were a mistake." which is a really odd statement (what, people shouldn't be able to stream SC? how does that work in your mind?) and reveals you have some strange personal beef with people you don't even know streaming a computer game online. Something that is completely detached from results-driven marketing and outreach and for which someone who worked in the industry simply would not care.

I'm sorry, I'm not going to further converse with you in this subject. You do not know what you are talking about.

2

u/OrganizationTrue5911 15h ago • Heartwarming

While I wasn't outraged, since it was never official.

I do think it is different from the rest of the P2W, since it would be the first thing introduced to SC that players could pay $ more, but you could not obtain it in game. And I think that line is extremely important to uphold.

0

u/Personal_Still106 15h ago • Bravo

You're not seeing the bigger picture then. Slippery slope aside, which is also a concern, this post sums up just some of the problems that would arise from it: https://www.reddit.com/r/starcitizen/s/GKdjawWxrD

2

u/Shuggeh 15h ago

And you have obfuscated the rest of the bigger picture to suit your perspective.

If I have an org that has bought all of the capital ships and have access to them all from day 1, compared to an org that doesn't, the speed at which we are able to establish ourselves and the eye watering advantage we would have over their progression wouldn't even allow them to be in a position to compete with us in the first place.

Ultimately their little 10% bonus doesn't matter any more because my org is literally years ahead of yours.

Stop being so naive. The whole game is P2W.

1

u/Personal_Still106 13h ago

Ship sales absolutely are P2W, or Pay to Progress, and it's been that way since the start. That ship has long sailed and it's an evil we all accept for the funding model for Star Citizen. And the game balance, for what it is worth, is made around this.

Adding in subs that give players benefits as another layer on top of this is stupid, no matter how small or large those benefits are. By all means have a sub, but make it cosmetics, hangar flairs, furniture for base building -- there are million things that can be done. But never anything that changes the in-game mechanics to give one player a boost over another for spending $20.

33

u/PiibaManetta 15h ago edited 14h ago

You win time. And by winning time, you can progress faster, unlocking more potentially powerful item faster. Item that can help you have an advantage against other players.

Example, if you are a subscriber you can gain a BP faster then me, and so craft a weapon that is better then mine faster then me.

It's 100% a p2w scenario, no dubt.

But cig have confiremed that this subscriber perks will not be really implemented. "Apparently", someone have put that code in the PTU by "error"...

11

u/NotTheParaMagician 15h ago • Bravo

"error"

9

u/Ted_Striker1 origin 15h ago • Bravo

Yeah error lol

2

u/Wunderbliss 12h ago

To be fair, they said there are no plans to introduce the perks. The code is there, so whenever they get around to making the plans to switch it on it could still show up. Or a stealth drop with no introductions lol. But wither way, they did not say the perks would not be implemented, just that there are no plans to do so...yet.

1

u/Scavveroonie drake enganeer 12h ago

A subscriber wont beat you in a fight because they got “better” gear faster than you, they will beat you because you fucked up. Not a p2w scenario in a million years.

Not to mention that the day between the both of you having reached the same “BP-point”, the other person would still need days to mine enough gear to craft enough of these “better” weapons, and then out of pure luck the two of you would need to somehow run into eachother, you would fight, and if you for some reason dont see that you’re getting outmaneuvered in the fight and decide to not run, then it doesnt matter if the subscriber had better gear than you, your defeat would be inevitable either way.

This is all fucking pveer paranoia and doesnt hold up in actual PU pvp scenarios.

What is p2w however is a rookie flying around in an aurora and in jumps a fucking tiburon and vaporizes the rookie.

0

u/PiibaManetta 12h ago

You could not be more wrong. Any kind of perk that let you skip gameplay can result in an advantage. If me and you play the same amount of time, but you have spent more money, you can indeed get better gear faster. You can't argue with that.

Ships or subscriber perk doesn't matter: they can be advantage gained by spending real money. Maybe you win just one time against me before i catch up, but it doesn't matter: you have win because your wallet is bigger then mine, plain simple. And you can win another thousand times for the same reason against thousand of other players.

The game always has been p2w since the very beginning. This debacle about subscriber gear is just another level down the rabbit hole.

Nobody would ever screamed p2w ever if they only thing they sold would have been cosmetic. But to build a AAA studio for 14 years, eventually it wasn't possible to do without p2w mechanics.

2

u/Scavveroonie drake enganeer 12h ago

But im not wrong and nothing you said demonstrated how I would be.

The only time better gear matters is in pvp, and the timedifferences we’re talking about in regards to how long it takes to get better gear for pvp is insignificant in practice.

2

u/PiibaManetta 12h ago

You are absolutely wrong, because the time difference can be more or less depending on what CIG can may decide. It's almost i significant in the long run if it's 10%, it more significan if it's 100%. The problem is that you don't know how much can be worse in the future, because the p2w Pandora's box is already open.

Also, PvP can be unconsensual in SC, as you know, you can force pvp into others. So, if i have just a Nomad and you have bought instead an F7A i'm tosted, but if instead i have bought an ironcald i'm almost immune to you.

The monet a game step into p2w mechanics, you don't know how much deep it can go. You are instead sure it will never go deep if you never step into any p2w mechanic.

1

u/Scavveroonie drake enganeer 11h ago

Im still not wrong, you still havent demonstrated why I would be, and you actually repeated what I had already said.

If you’re in a nomad with stock gear, and Im a sub in a hornet with upgraded gear, I fucking guarantee you that it’s not because of the upgraded gear that you instantly melt. And yeah, if i bought the hornet with real cash then thats absolutely a bit p2w in a combat scenario - again, I already said exactly this. But a rep boost to unlock some blueprints and more usually just pve missions and skins for weapons that we both could already get, absolutely fucking not. Sorry bud, Im right, you’re wrong, and Im getting tired of saying the same thing with different words.

1

u/PiibaManetta 2h ago

I don't see how you can be right. You are also contradicting yourself: you can't say it's a bit p2w and then say it's not. It's not hard to understand: if you can buy any kind of advantage with real money, it's p2w.

You can argue if one advantage is more or less impactful, but if a game allow you to buy advantages, it's p2w, point fact.

1

u/Scavveroonie drake enganeer 2h ago

Not contradicting myself at all, and I’ve explained in great detail how the scenarios differ. Your main reply has been “nuh-uh!”.

1

u/PiibaManetta 2h ago

You are contradicting yourself, please read your own reply. You have said that if you have bought the F7A with real money then it's a little bit P2W.

So, or it's p2w or not. Even if it's just a libble bit, it's always a little bit p2w.

You can't make this stuff up, it's literally your words.

Arguing with someone that contradtict himsepf and fake to do not understand basic logic is a waste of time.

Stay in your ignorance then, i hope that defending the multimillionaire company that is lying to you will being joy in your life... until you realize it.

1

u/Scavveroonie drake enganeer 2h ago

No im not, feel free to re-read what I’ve said a couple of times lol. Maybe one day you’ll get it.

→ More replies

1

u/Zzyxzz 15h ago

I believe, a rogue developer put that in there, because he loves the game and his work and wanted to blow it up, before CIG will bring it in officially. specially during IAE.

-1

u/PiibaManetta 15h ago

that would be cool!

0

u/suchla12 15h ago • Bravo

oh yea, some dev put on mask and under the veil of darkness came into the studio, implemented it all by himself and then put it in the PTU build without anyone noticing. Seriously, who the fuck believe this shit..

2

u/PiibaManetta 15h ago

in fact i was sarcastic.

1

u/suchla12 15h ago • Bravo

you never know in this cult ...ehm ...subreddit

1

u/PiibaManetta 14h ago

you're right, i will make it more obvious

-1

u/MrRaymondLuxuryYacht aegis 15h ago edited 15h ago

The best light I could put on it is that dataminers could have misinterpreted something in code.

Edit: added "could have"

Edit: I'm 1,000,000% against adding anything that could be construed as P2W. I'm just playing devil's advocate here.

1

u/NotTheParaMagician 15h ago

It isn't even on the dataminers, people verified it on video in game on PTU comparing the same ship claim costs/times on different accounts, with the variable being subscriber status. It was actually in the game, although I'm unsure if it still is after all the backlash.

1

u/PiibaManetta 15h ago

dubt, because CIG said today that those subscriber perks will not be implemented. They haven't said that those data was something else...

24

u/Deathless616 new user/low karma 15h ago

2

u/OrganizationTrue5911 15h ago

I don't think SC is a multi-billion dollar company though....

-2

u/Topherak907 Multi-Moderator 15h ago

Yeah, this reply is just the ree in the other direction.

1

u/Psycho7552 Human Supremacy 15h ago • Regret

You send this meme, but people complain or bitch here, and then end up still giving money to company that made them so upset.

11

u/Diptothaset 15h ago • Bravo

Any advantage that you can gain by paying is pay to win. Never underestimate the human ability to justify stuff

1

u/Important_Cow7230 aurora 15h ago

Pay to win is subjective, lying isn’t

0

u/Psycho7552 Human Supremacy 15h ago • Bravo

It's not subjective. It encompasses things like time savers, conviniences, and items/boosts providing direct advantage.

-3

u/Abriael 15h ago

Because you say so? Because the whole gaming industry disagrees with you.

1

u/Psycho7552 Human Supremacy 15h ago edited 15h ago • Bravo

Here are links. Sorry it took so long, but most sites that was show was dictionaries.

Hope 4 links are enough rest was either talking about some random bullshit, were dictionaries and one even tried to touch on ethics or philosophy. Yes, boosts, are time savers and time savers are pay to win.

Edit: even ai will tell you time saving things you acces for real money is pay to win, for all it's worth (which is not much, but still)

8

u/Casey090 15h ago • Regret

By your logic, a 1 year login queue unless you pay is just a question of convenience. XD

1

u/Topherak907 Multi-Moderator 15h ago

Lol, outrageous

12

u/Zap500 reliant 15h ago

To me when in a multiplayer PVP game, P2W encompass all the, 'pay to skip', 'pay for convenience', because time to do something will matter. Unpopular opinion in this sub though lol

I'd rather they push a slight rep boost sub than sell ships though, which under what I said above, is way more impactful. But doing both would be shitty.

-8

u/thecornersking 15h ago

Thanks to prove OP is right.

1

u/Zap500 reliant 15h ago

Well if you think its not P2W then sure, but I also think buying ships is P2W, so for me, OP is wrong. It is subjective, but ultimately, any paid advantage in a PVP multiplayer game is p2w in my book. Its just not as apparent as pay for increased damage, which apparently is the only kind of thing a lot of this sub would draw the line as P2W lol.

-3

u/thecornersking 15h ago

No look. I didn't came here to educate you guys, but laugh at you.

1

u/Zap500 reliant 15h ago

1

u/H1tSc4n 15h ago

Not reall, their definition is the correct one. It's op that is wrong. SC is and always was pay to win, we can howeevr not want it to be more pay to win.

-3

u/thecornersking 15h ago

I mean, you're free to be wrong, im just here to laugh reading your bs

12

u/Psycho7552 Human Supremacy 15h ago edited 15h ago • Bravo

Nope, the subscribtion bonuses are pay two win, just like ships, armor and weapons you dolt.

"pay for convinience" is simply another mental gymnastic to make pay two win seem less bad. Term was used for first time by bungie when they introduced instant level ups for real money in destiny2

At least don't lie to yourself with it being good thing.

-2

u/Ted_Striker1 origin 15h ago edited 15h ago

No, calling pay for convenience "pay to win" is the mental gymnastics. No one with a subscription perk has any combat advantage over someone without.

Unless you're going to try to argue the definition of "win"

Are Elder Scrolls Online's subscription perks pay to win?

• 1,650 Crowns per membership month plus exclusive Crown Store and Gold Coast Bazaar offers.

• +10% Tome Points from Challenges, plus 1 Cache of Tome Points and 1 Premium Tome Token per month.

• Full access to DLC game packs available in the Crown Store while subscribed, plus free access to companions Tanlorin and Zerith-var.

• Unlimited crafting material storage in the Craft Bag, doubled bank space, doubled furnishing and collectible limits in homes, Furnishing Vault access, and a doubled Transmutation Crystal cap.

• +10% to Experience, Gold, Alliance Points (currency, PvP skill lines, and Alliance rank only), Tel Var Stones (from monster kills only), Archival Fortunes, Crafting Inspiration, and Trait Research speed, plus doubled Antiquities lead timers and costume dyeing.

Look at all those perks. Are people subscribing paying to win? Faster XP, more gold, more alliance points, unlimited crafting storage, doubled bank and housing space.

-2

u/Psycho7552 Human Supremacy 15h ago • Bravo

Scroll down a bit. I provided 4 links in other comments. Subscribtion offering boosts is pay to win.

1

u/Ted_Striker1 origin 15h ago

No it's not, not unless those boots are combat boosts, like premium ammo or extra shields or more maueverability or something.

I mean these now defunct perks would have helped you "win" the rep grind a little faster, if that's how you want to define "win".

-1

u/Psycho7552 Human Supremacy 15h ago • Bravo

Are you buying paint for armor and weapons or whole armor and weapons with paint on it in star citizen?

You get gear, that offers protection depending on it's class, painted in specific way. You are fucking stupid.

1

u/Ted_Striker1 origin 15h ago

Subscription perks are not gear so who is fucking stupid?

-3

u/Psycho7552 Human Supremacy 15h ago • Bravo

You, dumbass. Boosters (sub perks are boosts) still provide advantage. You earn money, and rep faster than people who don't have subscribtion.

3

u/Ted_Striker1 origin 14h ago

"According to the Cambridge English Dictionary, it applies to computer games where real-money spending yields weapons, abilities, or content that create a competitive advantage. [1]"

A competitive advantage. Boosts like slightly faster rep time aren't a competitive advantage unless you're competing to see who can complete rep the fastest.

Stop with the mental gymnastics. You are wrong. Wrong.

1

u/Psycho7552 Human Supremacy 14h ago edited 14h ago

Yes, one link out of 4. Congrats you got me. Other link states that pay 2 convinience also count as pay to win.

Somewhere innyour immediate vincinity there is a plant that works very hard to make oxygen you waste. Approach that plant, and apologizie to it for wasting that oxygen. If you keep trying to gotcha me, i will be ripping into you until i get bored, tired or banned. Your choice, beacuse im having a blast rn.

0

u/Blood-Wolfe Anvil Enthusiast 14h ago

No it's not lol

-2

u/Blood-Wolfe Anvil Enthusiast 14h ago

Your the dolt not knowing what P2W is. Ships can be earned in-game too so no it's not P2W. In-game bought ships perform the same and someone with an aUEC bought ship can destroy Ayers with pledge ships. So no it's not P2W.

P2W is having a competitive advantage only obtainable by spending real money and unable to be earned in-game by playing the game.

So the dolt here is you.

1

u/Psycho7552 Human Supremacy 13h ago

Then it's a time skipper/saver, which is also considered pay to win. If you buy it for real life currency, and have access to it faster than someone else, which is advantage, whether is competetive or not is irrelevant. So yes, OP is a dolt and so are you.

7

u/AnOrdinaryChullo 13h ago

I see the brain dead astroturf bots have been engaged.

'This totaly anti-consumer Asian F2P crap is actually not bad at all and is in fact awesome, guys'

2

u/Careless_Joke3129 15h ago

Buying ships pay to win

Subscription = freemium but in a paid access title instead of a free to play title ick lol

2

u/Ravenask 15h ago • Heartwarming

I think the most ironic part about the whole drama is that we're arguing whether a $20 sub should get some in-game bonuses while there is a entire event where people sink hundreds if not thousands of dollars on ships going on. The fact that people are literally arguing that buying an entire ship isn't p2w right here really gives me the disturbing feeling that people are more okay with thousand-dollar capital ships than monthly sub.

Call me pessimistic if you want, but I'm genuinely worried that this drama would backfire in the worst possible way that CIG would take this as a "yes" for post-1.0 ship sale instead of transitioning to a more healthy monetization, and the playerbase would actually be fine with it. We are so psychologically conditioned to accept ship sales as the norm for well over a decade now, and I won't be surprised at the slightest if people end up choosing post-1.0 ship sale over a premium sub model.

2

u/AcanthaceaeRare2646 13h ago

>Odin / Idris
>Not pay to win

Pick one.

5

u/enbtest 14h ago

"Purchasing ships is Pay-to-Win."

No it's not! Lol. That's absurd. It's also "Pay-for-convenience". You can't "win" with a purchased ship that someone else can just as well get.

You correctly explain the subscriber being "Pay-for-convenience", and then in the same post incorrectly explain buying ships, which uses the EXACT same principle.

6

u/TheSubs0 Kiith S'Jet 15h ago • Regret

Bad thing exist, therefore, we should stack more bad thing.

I am very smart game designer.

2

u/RedFlr 15h ago • Regret

lemme translate for you folks, "im a subscriber and i like my pay to win"

funny how having premium accounts with extra exp and money boost has been considered pay to win for ages, but not for SC white knights xD

SC has both pay to wins, get new meta vehicles and premium accounts, i would just say that their vehicles pay to win kinda suck because now they nerf them even before the sales are over lol, before they used to wait a patch or two like any p2w game

1

u/Digitalzombie900 15h ago

You don't understand what win means. Win can be anything. I have 3-5 hours a week to play this game, if I pay ( and I would) to get more in that time than others, I am paying to win. I am not against it, you just need to get off your, let me TeaCh YoU GuyS whAt Pay TO Win Is horse.w

1

u/azkaii oldman 15h ago

P2W hasn't yet been established. Theres ever change still based on future decisions it will go either way.

1

u/Gypsydumb 15h ago

Most midwit take this year. I mean, there were some strong contenders, but you came swinging at the end of the year, leaving the rest of the contestants behind, and took the lead in the last hour. Outstanding job! You took issue with the general approach to the "game" and gave us much needed education. Now I know, back to the verse!

1

u/mrcalendar 13h ago

My opinion is the game has always basically been pay to win. The fact you can drop $45000 to own all ships by 1.0 gives whales a massive advantage come 1.0. In my mind anytime you can pay cash to skip/speedup game play, its pay to win. What are you winning is the question though. Alpha doesn't matter so shit like the blades fiasco i laughed heartily at. I get people complaining to prevent more pay2win marketing, but CIG does need to income the game long term. If they did implement something like this monthly perk, i still view it as pay to win. Faster rep may mean faster gains of rep bonus stuff (im not sure what you get from higher rep besides better paid contracts, so faster income)? Faster ship claim time could help those in large PVP battles where they could get back to a battle faster with said ship?

Again i ultimately ask what are you winning though. PVP may come down to skill but again a faster claim time could also help in big battles. Faster making money may lead to more powerful players. Maybe if some griefers were able to block off access to a planet or system due to spent money (is that winning)? But hopefully the game will be so large it wont be an issue, and maybe even add cool sandbox game play.

I for one do not want to pay a monthly fee to play the game. Played wow in 2004 and hated the sub fee, made me addicted and killed a lot of my free time and fun. I played guild wars 2 and thought their model was pretty good. I got to play for years while others paid for their nice costume armors and stuff. I hoped CIG could survive off that route, players paying for clothing, weapons, gear, furniture?, etc. But as others pointed out i don't want it to become like fortnight or some god awful shit like that. Just pumping out crap paints to keep the money coming in. A minor bonus to monthly fee may be fine, but also don't want the game play to end up catering to long grinding to incentivize paying the monthly fee to save a bit of time. Someone posted an early quote from Roberts that his long term vision did allow something like this though, to allow those with less time to get a boost by paying cash for currency or something. But again i do not want a forced monthly fee just to play.

I had been worried about land purchasing, like if whales can just buy up the planet what about us regular players wanting to build a nice home on some acreage. But having been flying around Nyx1 in 5.0 i've realized how absolutely massive it feels, there is so much space its insane to me. And finally makes me realize what in game exploration can be like (stoked).

1

u/vbsargent oldman 11h ago

I’d just point out that people aren’t waving the term irrationally.

Other than not understanding the term, a lot of people have a rationale: to piss people off and cause mostly negative reactions.

Too many people have moved to trolling others and getting reactions as their source of joy, validation, or whatever.

It’s so easy to see in the political and social arenas and it has been growing in the gaming arena as well.

:-/

1

u/Asmos159 scout 11h ago

This is why I don't have a problem with the pledge ships a few months after they are removed from the store because in a conflict there is no difference between someone joining 5 years after release coming across somebody that's bought an odin, or some of that earned one.

However, if my fleet can defend an operation from an attacking fleet, but that attacking fleet can replace their ships and come back sooner than I can replace my ships because they are subscribers. I would call bs.

1

u/taco-kiss 8h ago

Where do you draw the line?

1

u/joelm80 7h ago

P2W is anything that gives a paid advantage, including MMO leveling rates, discounts, cooldowns.

You can make a straw man argument about the meaning of a term all you want, but that doesn't change "pay $ for advantage" being horrible.

The ships being sold are bad enough, but something has to be the funding model and that has been it.

Can't have a $45 game, $ purchases and then also apply freemium model. Pick one, don't be greedy and want to stack them all.

1

u/jrsedwick Zeus MKII 15h ago

1

u/Creative-Improvement ARGO CARGO 15h ago

I am sure a sensible and thoughtful discussion will ensue while drinking my high tea and a scone. tips hat

-2

u/Pkactus 15h ago edited 5h ago

do you get store credit for this post?

edit :// maybe you can purchase a sense of humour as DLC

1

u/PressFtoCutLeg "I'm tired, boss." 14h ago

"t's called "Pay-for-convenience" (Yes, this is actually a recognized definition in MMOs),"

And those are not loot boxes, they are surprise mechanics.

1

u/Blood-Wolfe Anvil Enthusiast 14h ago edited 14h ago

Agreed (mostly), and I've posted against who I can in all the other ridiculous threads pretty blatantly and I don't care if I'm downvoters either.

I don't agree though about purchasing ships being P2W because they can all be earned in-game after 4-6 period after release which means it's not pay-to-win. Also since aUEC bought ships perform the same and have no disadvantage vs pledged ships so no it's not P2W. P2W means they would be exclusively to paying cash for.

1

u/nicarras 13h ago

Convenience is not PTW. PTW is literally buying ships and weapons in the shop. The OP is right.

1

u/knsmknd ARGO CARGO 13h ago

At least one person with a sane and based take on this. Hope isn't lost.

-2

u/Nolsoth ARGO CARGO 15h ago

I really do t get the drama.

Having an optional sub that gives a small boost to rep and some subscriber flair was always going to happen and it's absolutely optional.

0

u/FarGodHastur 15h ago

Pay-2-win should be changed to pay-2-advantage since that whats it really is more often than not. But semantics just makes the conversation take longer for no reason when everyone in the room kind of already understands that.

0

u/TropicalxDepression new user/low karma 13h ago

Badfaithmaxxing

Shillmaxxing

Botmaxxing

Take your pick

0

u/nRGon12 Nautilus 12h ago edited 12h ago

This post belongs in r/confidentlyincorrect

-1

u/SOVERElGN_SC origin 14h ago

Buying ships is another prime example of pay for convenience and nothing more. There is no p2w in SC since it’s not competitive game to start with and players aren’t competing. There are conditions for competitive play, no matchmaker, no competitive modes aside AC.  If someone is progressing faster than you - well, mind your own business.

2

u/VapourAesthetic new user/low karma 14h ago

I swipe for an Idris and park it outside of whatever activity you wanted to do, I win

0

u/inar038 14h ago

I break into your idris with a railgun found in game, i shoot you in the head with my ripper, you die, i self distruct your idris. I win.

0

u/manickitty 13h ago

And if I also have an idris what then?

2

u/inar038 13h ago

missing the point.

1

u/manickitty 8h ago

How so? How does their point about having an idris make any difference if it was a credit card or bought ingame

1

u/inar038 6h ago

the point is the pay 2 win argument., just cuz you buy a idris with cash doesnt mean you can walk all over another player. same with any other ship.

1

u/manickitty 3h ago

Yes that was the point i was making

0

u/SOVERElGN_SC origin 11h ago edited 11h ago

And very moment you dare to commit an act of aggression, an intended law system will make reconsider your life choices and make sure you pay for your mistake.

None a ship will help you to preserve a whole location for yourself, forget about that approach. Its mmo and nothing is yours even if you have a large ship. Want to act against everyone abusing ship advantage, its your choice but you will pay for that.

You completely missing how the game is expected to work.

P.S.: or i will just play my activity in my own instace and give a sock your big ego. You already lost with that disrespectful attitude about other’s interests.

1

u/AgonizingSquid 11h ago

You're delusional

0

u/knsmknd ARGO CARGO 13h ago

It's not, a good player will still shred you.

0

u/MrRaymondLuxuryYacht aegis 15h ago • Heartwarming

I'd say shorter claim time and smaller claim cost would be a direct advantage in PvP.

A ship bought for real money will be worse than one earned and upgraded in game. I'm taking about tier upgrades through crafting in the future. But component upgrades today can make a big difference.

I'm not the biggest fan of selling ships, but I can't see any other way the project could have been funded. I'd prefer we move away from anything that could be construed as P2W if possible.

-7

u/Affectionate_Dark63 15h ago

Thank you for the clarification that idiots are going to read lol. But seriously, its sad that people don't understand this

-5

u/Ted_Striker1 origin 15h ago

I've been saying the same thing on Spectrum (and here) and getting a lot of flak for it.

Someone on Spectrum even said "to general gaming audiences this is exactly what pay 2 win looks like, so that is what it will be called. No amount of spectrum posting will change that."

So to them, because they believe subscriber perks are pay to win that is the definition, as if someone's opinion determines a definition, and they're too bullheaded to change their opinion because their emotions rule them. They don't like it, therefore shut up it's pay to win.

People are so aggravating lol.

3

u/Abriael 15h ago

The funny part is that to general gaming audiences, this is absolutely not what pay-to-win looks like, and the general gaming audience likely won't give a flying F. about something like this. They know the ship has sailed ages ago.

Unfortunately, a lot of people in the SC community play ONLY SC and are completely out of touch with the general gaming audience.

0

u/Kernkraft3000 Bounty Hunter 15h ago

Its pay to progress. Pay to win would be for example "gold ammo" only for purchase.

But afaik there are ships only obtainable by paying money.

0

u/Personal_Still106 15h ago • Bravo

They boosted your personal progression and lowered your downtime in a way that is basically irrelevant to the competition with other players.

Incorrect.

Just looking at the claim timer -- The only cost to dying in SC is time. If you're in combat with other players, say over Hathor fighting for control, being able to get back to the fight quicker can have a direct impact on your victory or that of your friends. This is literally pay to win.

This post succinctly expands on some of the other bonuses and why it's bad: https://www.reddit.com/r/starcitizen/s/GKdjawWxrD

0

u/SmoothOperator89 Towel 15h ago • Bravo

We have always accepted that players could buy ships and have that advantage. That's been part of the funding model from day 1 of the Kickstart. Things like reputation and claim timers were going to be tools to mitigate that advantage. You still need to wait just as long as any other player if your ship blows up. You still need to put in the same number of missions to gain reputation to unlock the higher tier missions. Giving a paid option to reduce that isn't just about pay to win, it's removing the little bit of level playing field that still existed.

-2

u/taggyoureit new user/low karma 15h ago

Buying access to the game is pay-to-win! You'll be winning more than people without game access! CIG should stop selling access to the game immediately!

-2

u/DasPibe 15h ago

Lol, what a CIG´s wannabe boy

-3

u/Dracoxidos 15h ago

Thank you

-3

u/Lion_El_Jonsonn rsi 15h ago

Hundred percent true

-3

u/Shuggler123 new user/low karma 14h ago

No. Paying for shortcut is pay to win. Pay for convenience is pay to win, it's just a nicer term so people don't feel bad for buying shortcuts

4

u/Blood-Wolfe Anvil Enthusiast 14h ago

No it's not lol.

P2W is paying for a competitive advantage over other players that are unobtainable by in-game means.

Nice try though.

-3

u/Akhi_Police 13h ago

Wrong, it is by definition pay2win. This debate was done so many times and it is a korean MMO tactic to force the word pay2convenience into common usage, enabling predatory systems to be implemented without them having to call it pay2win. This debate was also one that was in BDO, Ragnarok Online, and many other and current Korean MMOs. Of course there are levels to this. As an example Warframe is pay2win, you can literalty buy the items you'd grind for....but no one complains because the game has an open market (platinum being earnable through trading) and enables reasonable rewards for the players to engage in the market.

Convenience is Pay2Win. Even PoE 1 and 2 players say that (PoE having premium stash tabs)

0

u/nicarras 13h ago

Convenience is not PTW. PTW is literally buying ships and weapons in the shop. The OP is right.

-1

u/sergiulll new user/low karma 14h ago

This changes maybe wouldnt change much FOR NOW but i would be sign for CIG that we dont mind and add more bullshit like that in future.

-2

u/pandibear 14h ago

Split hairs all we want it’s still unacceptable.