r/stephenking • u/NewPatron-St • 18h ago
Discussion I just watched The Shining miniseries and this is my review
It's well known that Stephen King hates Stanley Kubrick's version of The Shining as it isn't like his original novel, so he decided to make a three-episode TV miniseries in 1997 to be a more faithful adaptation, but this miniseries proves that just because that adaptation doesn't have to be faithful to be good and that Stanley Kubrick was right to deviate so much from the original book. While he is no Jack Nicholson, Steven Weber is great as Jack Torrance as he plays a deeply flawed, frustrated man who is trying to face his inner demons, which makes him the best part of the miniseries. I know that people hate Courtland Mead as Danny, but personally, I have a high tolerance for child actors.
There are some minor things that I think are better than the film, but the film is way better. One thing I think is better is Melvin Van Peebles is a better Dick Hallorann than Scatman Crothers. I also like that the ghosts do more than in the movie. The miniseries does have its good moments and even some genuinely creepy moments, but the biggest issue with the miniseries is its runtime. Each episode is an hour long and the overall runtime is 3 hours. It spends way too much time on minor details that might work in the book but not on film. I think it would have worked better as a TV movie or an audiobook rather than a miniseries. Overall, it’s not bad, but Kubrick's film is way better and a much better use of your time. Sorry Mr. King, but Kubrick wears the crown.