r/streamentry • • 1d ago

AMA Pivot Points — A new podcast about people's first transformative meditation experience

33 Upvotes

I'm the journalist behind a new podcast series on transformative meditation experiences, titled Pivot Points.

The series draws on my interviews with meditators (some from this very subreddit I believe, those of you who responded to my survey post a while back), contemplative scientists, and well-known meditation teachers, focusing specifically on people's first meditation experience they'd describe as "transformative." They function as something of a gateway between the popular world of beginner's meditation and the deep-end, which folks here will be familiar with.

I was surprised at how little I've found, despite the seemingly infinite number of lists used within Buddhism, that attempts something like a taxonomy, let alone examination, of the variety of these particular experiences. Nyams in Tibetan Buddhism are probably the closest, but there's no distinction or focus on a practitioners first nyam. Stream entry and kensho are also in the ballpark, but have much stricter criteria.

But I'm especially interested in these first experiences, and the variety of ways meditators find themselves wading into the deep end. There’s something unique about someone’s first extremely strange and powerful meditation experience. These are first encounters with alien worlds of experience. They're huge sources of motivation, belief, even faith in the value of deep practice. And I was really lucky to get to speak with teachers like Michael Taft, Henry Shukman, Tina Rasmussen, Charlie Awberry, and Richard Shankman about them. As well as scientists doing leading work on meditation research.

If anyone has any questions about the series, or thoughts about 'pivot points' as a category of experience in general, I'd be happy to answer any questions.

EDIT: A lot of people have asked to share their own pivot point stories. I’m happy to collect these stories in case I start working on a second season at some point. If you’re willing to share your experiences, you can do so here.


r/streamentry • • 2d ago

Practice Confused on how to implement investigation/vipassana

8 Upvotes

My practice is mainly inspired by the Thai Forest Tradition these days, and one of it's characteristics is the separation of Samatha and Vipassana.

I sit for meditation once in the morning and once at night; both with one pointed focus in the nostrils. I have read that when doing samatha, you should focus solely on the meditation object and save investigation for a different time.

I have a couple of ideas on what this could mean.

• Switch from samatha to an investigation sometime during my sit

• dedicate an entire meditation session to investigation

• Maintain samatha practice completely in my two sits and try and investigate during daily life

When I say investigation, I mean stuff along the lines of Asubha, Four Foundations of Mindfulness, loathsomeness of food, etc. If my understanding is correct, Right Mindfulness in itself is a kind of subtle investigation practice that makes use of every moment to gain insight. Despite this, I am not sure if just generating samadhi during sits and trying to maintain mindfulness during the day is enough, which is why I am asking this question.

I would appreciate if any of you could let me know how investigation as a practice actually works, and some ways to go about using it. Thank you for reading.


r/streamentry • • 2d ago

Practice TWIM / metta from a non-dual background — dualistic love vs awareness that loves

5 Upvotes

I’ve been doing TWIM / metta daily after mostly non-dual inquiry and open awareness practice. I wanted something that builds a bit of mental stability while also being kind.

The standard TWIM approach (self sending love to self, then to others) works well. It feels gentle, warm in the heart, and is actually building real self-love and a sense of worth. The intention spreads and can get quite strong.

At the same time, I keep slipping into something more like what I’m used to from non-dual practice: just awareness that is loving everything in the field. It’s spacious and directionless — a joy that includes me, everyone else, and whatever arises. It feels almost like being bathed in love from something bigger (or from awareness itself). Powerful, inexhaustible, and not really “me” doing it.

My questions:

  • Is this open, awareness-based love where metta eventually goes anyway, or is it something different?
  • Is it still worth deliberately building the more dualistic, self-based generation of love so the two can meet and become one?

r/streamentry • • 2d ago

Practice I keep turning 'being present' into a project, and the project is the whole problem

13 Upvotes

Every time I sit down I catch myself making presence into a task. Be present. Stay present. Notice when you're not present. And the whole time there's this quiet manager in the back keeping score.

The weird part is the managing feels like the opposite of what I'm after, but I keep doing it anyway, like if I just monitor hard enough I'll finally arrive at the thing that was already here before I started monitoring.

Lately I've been trying something dumber: just letting the scorekeeping happen too. Not fixing it, not watching it from above. Just... it's there, same as the traffic noise.

Anyone else notice the effort to be present is the thing that keeps you one step behind it?


r/streamentry • • 3d ago

Concentration Intense over-concentration on meditation: brain vibrations, head pressure, and tinnitus What happened to me?

2 Upvotes

​Hi everyone, I just joined Reddit to connect with you all and try to figure out what might have happened to me during one of my meditation sessions.

​My name is Mario, I'm 28, and for about 3-4 years I’ve been reconnecting with my spiritual side, little by little, exploring the worlds of yoga and meditation.

​Last December, I decided to attend a Vipassana meditation retreat for the first time in Lutirano, Italy. On day 6, something strange happened to me...

The technique, as explained by the teacher and the lessons, consisted of feeling all body sensations and simply observing them.

​During meditation, I mistakenly started visualizing the body areas and trying to force sensations, sort of doing a "mental body scan" across my entire body. Because of this, my mental effort and concentration were extremely high.

​I used my heartbeat as a reference point to move from one area of my body to another, trying to "feel" the blood flowing in my veins.

​As my concentration kept increasing, I began to feel "vibrations/pulsations" around my brain, like "waves." The more I concentrated, the more they intensified—as if my brain was emitting strong radiation or waves. It all kept building up hand-in-hand with my concentration... hard to explain.

​When I reached the peak, I started to feel a strange sensation throughout my whole body—neither pleasant nor unpleasant, but completely unfamiliar.

I had the sensation that my entire body was vibrating and that everything was hyper-connected, as if I had reached or unlocked something new inside myself.

At the same time, I felt a strong sensation on my forehead in the "third eye" area, almost like a very intense itch.

​I had no idea what I was experiencing, but everything felt like it came from another dimension. I felt connected to something, though I didn't know what to do in that state, and I was also terrified at the same time. Yet, my mind was very alert.

It lasted a few minutes, and not knowing what to do in that state, I decided to open my eyes and pull myself out of it.

​In subsequent meditations on the same day, it was as if I had learned how to "unlock" and reach that state whenever I wanted, and I deliberately did it two more times.

​My meditation teacher told me that I probably wasn't practicing Vipassana, because the technique requires no mental effort, whereas I was concentrating extremely hard to get into that state.

​I felt discouraged by his words, as he couldn't explain to me what might have actually happened.

The biggest problem occurred later that same day, after the meditation sessions;

I started developing very severe tinnitus in my head, like "distant sounds," loud ringing, and the sensation that my brain was vibrating. It was terrible and terrifying. I couldn't sleep or meditate for the following days, which forced me to leave the retreat early and go back home.

​The tinnitus has decreased up to today, but it hasn't completely gone away. I live my life normally now, though my relationship with silence has changed, and because of this, I drifted away from meditation, seeking to be more "grounded."

​What could this have been? Has anyone ever experienced something similar?

Thank you all in advance.


r/streamentry • • 3d ago

Practice Going headfirst into negative emotions - quite intense heat and dissolution. Anyone have experience with this?

5 Upvotes

I don't post here regularly, so for context, I have been on and off the path for more than 20 years. My highest attainment is what Ingram would call technical 4th path, which has remained more or less stable for 2-3 years. I have a very long history of abuse and mental health stuff which comes up more often than not.

With that out of the way, I can get to the meat of my query. :) The most recent development I had was clearing out my schedule so I could meditate more. What happened is that I focused completely on negative and anything that my mind shied away from until it seemed to become a concrete mass.

Almost immediately my body heated up and reality fractured. It's hard to put into words, but the core idea seemed to be "this shouldn't have happened" but when you go deeper, subject and object dissolve, and sadness is seen to be the same as bliss etc. This has happened before, but perhaps not at this depth.

It feels like the mind is keeping eternity at bay - an entire universe is blocked behind thought and needing to reconstruct a world. I keep feeling this urge to just rest and breathe. (probably related to abuse - hard to really rest in an abusive household)

I've read about this in related practices - go deeply into whatever happens, let go of beliefs (I believe Angelo Dilulo talks about this) So it's not completely uncharted territory, but it IS pretty intense. (my body is pretty hot as I'm writing this)

Some teachers I've spoken to who claim full realization say it's a good sign and I should follow the heat. I've been doing this for about 2-3 days since, and it's perhaps one of the most hardcore things I've done in 20+ years (this includs NDEs and other related experiences)

As such, I thought I would ask other people for their take, as it seems a little weird that my daily routine is "ok I've cleared up my schedule so that I can comtemplate all these reasons I almost committed suicide" - which sounds a little insane to be honest. :) (I do believe Angelo also writes that the mind will try to struggle when it feels it's going insane)

I'm still functional though - I have to be to plan a move and various other life things that are going on.

Thanks for taking the time to read, and any feedback would be appreciated.

EDIT : So for those who are still keeping track of this, the heat and related processing seems to be...doing itself, like it will fluctuate between negative thoughts and other things, while maintaining the heat. There's no strain or forcing involved.


r/streamentry • • 3d ago

Health Meditation Breaks, Focus, and Withdrawal-Like Symptoms

5 Upvotes

I’ve noticed a peculiar pattern during extended breaks from meditation.

When I’m deeply engaged in something enjoyable or intellectually demanding, such as studying, I generally feel fine. In fact, sustained concentration during ordinary activities can sometimes feel like I am meditating to some extent, even without intending to practice.

However, when I become bored, unfocused, or simply idle, unpleasant sensations such as burning and pressure tend to emerge, sometimes accompanied by anxiety.

It’s almost as though sustained attention temporarily stabilizes my nervous system, whereas the absence of focused engagement allows these symptoms to resurface.

This makes me wonder whether prolonged concentration and pīti cultivation can produce something resembling dependence on sustained attentional engagement, with withdrawal-like symptoms when that engagement stops.

Has anyone experienced anything similar during meditation breaks? Could concentration genuinely regulate or suppress these symptoms, or does distraction merely make them less noticeable? Is there any recognized Buddhist or scientific explanation for this pattern?


r/streamentry • • 4d ago

Practice What exactly is my practice? Open awareness, but with deliberate attention - can I keep going with this to reach (higher) jhāna?

12 Upvotes

Edit: I guess a part of what I'm asking is: "what does it mean to increase your awareness, if increasing your awareness is effortful?". It's hard for me to really differentiate attention and awareness. If the following wall of text below is too unclear, perhaps you could answer the question above in the context of my situation. I'd be very grateful :)

Hi everyone.

I'm relatively new to more intense practice (irregular, but on average 1h+ daily). I started a few weks ago. I'm still navigating the terminology, different practices, etc. I'm also a big fan of Rob Burbea.

I've been trying to get to the first jhāna, although I don't really know what exactly to do to get there, other than allowing pīti to arise when it does.

I've had a few very short-lived moments of what I think was pīti during my regular meditation practice (more to what this is later). I'm fairly confident it was pīti, as the experience was too unusual and clearly felt to be anything else. I felt intense joy and energy, had to smile very widely, and experienced these tingly-but-not-really-tingly sensations across my body, kind of moving upwards.

To my practice itself: I've been particularly enjoying open awareness meditation. I don't really enjoy breath-focused or other single-object concentration practices. Originally, I followed Shinzen Young's instructions for Do Nothing meditation: let whatever happens happen, and whenever you notice an intention to control your attention, let go of that intention. https://youtu.be/cZ6cdIaUZCA?si=VIckmLNBK3gSCXFG

The issue was that I felt very dull and uninspired doing this.

Experientially it seems there were different ways I could kind of "crank up" my awareness, but I'm not sure whether that would be considered controlling my attention. In a way, when I deliberately direct my attention to be more "aware," I enjoy meditation more, and it feels like I'm getting closer to the state in which pīti arises.

But if I understand correctly, this doesn't really fall under choiceless awareness / Do Nothing practice. At the same time, it's also not a single-pointed attention practice. Hence, the typical categorization of single-pointed attention vs. open awareness doesn't seem to work very well here.

To me, it feels like I'm projecting my attention outwards, almost as if I'm staring at a blank expansive whiteness. It feels like I'm focusing on everything and focusing on nothing simultaneously. This might not make much sense, but the experience compels me to phrase it that way. I don't really know how else to describe it.

Burbea said in the first video of his jhāna playlist that, as long as you can generate pīti with your practice, it doesn't really matter what you do. I just ran with that.

My questions now are:

  • What exactly is my practice? Why can't I find people writing about it, compared to how extensively choiceless awareness and breath meditation are discussed? It seems distinct from shikantaza as well.
  • Does anyone else practice this way?
  • Can I just keep doing this practice indefinitely to reach higher jhānas and "progess"?

- (the "Edit:" question at the top)

I realize that it doesn't really matter whether I give my practice a label. It can just be my practice. But knowing its name, if there is one, would facilitate communication, research, etc.

I should also clarify that, even though I'm posting this in r/streamentry, I'm not really committed to enlightenment and entering the stream. I mainly want to see what's out there and experiment with different states and practices. The benefits outside of meditation have also been insane and genuinely life-changing. I just really enjoy meditating.

Still, theoretically, if I were to follow a more structured path toward enlightenment (such as the stages of meditation laid out in TMI), could this practice work for that too?

There's definitely room for experimenting with other focus-based practices as well. These are mainly curiosity-driven questions.

Thank you! I love reading this subreddit for information!


r/streamentry • • 4d ago

Practice What exactly is my practice? Open awareness, but with deliberate attention - can I keep going lead to jhāna?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone.

I'm relatively new to more intense practice (irregular, but on average 1h+ daily). I started a few weks ago. I'm still navigating the terminology, different practices, etc. I'm also a big fan of Rob Burbea.

I've been trying to get to the first jhāna, although I don't really know what exactly to do to get there, other than allowing pīti to arise when it does.

I've had a few very short-lived moments of what I think was pīti during my regular meditation practice (more to what this is later). I'm fairly confident it was pīti, as the experience was too unusual and clearly felt to be anything else. I felt intense joy and energy, had to smile very widely, and experienced these tingly-but-not-really-tingly sensations across my body, kind of moving upwards.

To my practice itself: I've been particularly enjoying open awareness meditation. I don't really enjoy breath-focused or other single-object concentration practices. Originally, I followed Shinzen Young's instructions for Do Nothing meditation: let whatever happens happen, and whenever you notice an intention to control your attention, let go of that intention. https://youtu.be/cZ6cdIaUZCA?si=VIckmLNBK3gSCXFG

The issue was that I felt very dull and uninspired doing this.

Experientially it seems there were different ways I could kind of "crank up" my awareness, but I'm not sure whether that would be considered controlling my attention. In a way, when I deliberately direct my attention to be more "aware," I enjoy meditation more, and it feels like I'm getting closer to the state in which pīti arises.

But if I understand correctly, this doesn't really fall under choiceless awareness / Do Nothing practice. At the same time, it's also not a single-pointed attention practice. Hence, the typical categorization of single-pointed attention vs. open awareness doesn't seem to work very well here.

To me, it feels like I'm projecting my attention outwards, almost as if I'm staring at a blank expansive whiteness. It feels like I'm focusing on everything and focusing on nothing simultaneously. This might not make much sense, but the experience compels me to phrase it that way. I don't really know how else to describe it.

Burbea said in the first video of his jhāna playlist that, as long as you can generate pīti with your practice, it doesn't really matter what you do. I just ran with that.

My questions now are:

  • What exactly is my practice? Why can't I find people writing about it, compared to how extensively choiceless awareness and breath meditation are discussed? It seems distinct from shikantaza as well.
  • Does anyone else practice this way?
  • Can I just keep doing this practice indefinitely to reach higher jhānas and "progess"?

I realize that it doesn't really matter whether I give my practice a label. It can just be my practice. But knowing its name, if there is one, would facilitate communication, research, etc.

I should also clarify that, even though I'm posting this in r/streamentry, I'm not really committed to enlightenment and entering the stream. I mainly want to see what's out there and experiment with different states and practices. The benefits outside of meditation have also been insane and genuinely life-changing. I just really enjoy meditating.

Still, theoretically, if I were to follow a more structured path toward enlightenment (such as the stages of meditation laid out in TMI), could this practice work for that too?

There's definitely room for experimenting with other focus-based practices as well. These are mainly curiosity-driven questions.

Thank you! I love reading this subreddit for information!


r/streamentry • • 5d ago

Insight IMO directly experiencing fear, misery, trauma etc isn't effective for processing and here is what I think works

18 Upvotes

These are just my thoughts and my teacher gave a thumbs up to all of this but please do your worst, and if your own experience is different or you want to add details, I would love to hear about it, half of my motivation is to learn and the other half is to share what I have been working on, thanks!

So a bit of background, I experienced cessation for the first time about 6 months ago, and since then I went through a lot of intense stress, loneliness, inability to connect with other people, fear, and anxiety, seriously those few months were the hardest thing I have ever gone through, I wonder if that wasn't the full force of fear, misery, stress, etc that my mind could generate, ofc going through a divorce, dead end job, etc might be worse conceptually, but not on the level of sensation. So yeah not good, but I am fully back to connecting with people, enjoying my life, thinking about the future, and overall my life is much easier than before, there is a profound peace and openness that has become a regular part of my life. Normally people say to just sit and observe these experiences but for me that really did not work. It is true being with these states teaches you lots of different valuable things, but I feel strongly that pure observation does not lead to peace and acceptance but leads to states of disassociation.

Here is what I found does work: to respond to fear, misery, etc, with deep sadness. I have learned to quietly resign myself in a way that is emotional, vulnerable, and unclosed off/unjaded, I think to myself "so be it, this misery and helplessness is what the law of cause and effect has in store for me, and there will be much more misery and helplessness in my life, so be it". This sadness IMO is very important, because the path of insight is not a path of gain, but instead is a path of everything you know and love being taken away from you. Pre insight I thought I would be able to find some stability and safety in life and the dharma, I thought I had some control, and I thought all of my problems had solutions. But oh boy was I wrong, there are no solutions for many of life's problems, there is no safety, no stability, I have no control where it counts, and I won't ever be able to heal 100%. The worst part is the incredible peace and joy from mediation gets ripped away again and again, and then the fear sets in because the safety and stability you thought you were working towards doesn't exist and your mind can turn against you at any moment.

Trying to just "accept" doesn't work because it's not fine, it actually does really suck and it is really painful that this is how things are. So all you can do is give up, after all the thrashing and fighting eventually you just quietly resign yourself with tears in your eyes and deep sadness. The tears and emotion is really important btw. I really like the Serenity Prayer although I'm not Christian, "God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference." A good way of thinking about it is mourning your loss. If you've ever lost someone you loved you know the only way the grief calms down is by turning it into deep sadness, and with that comes peace. Insight is like everything is taken from you and you have to grieve it, and the only way panic, anger, and bargaining of loss stops is with sadness.

I try to apply this generally as my response to suffering but some specific ways this has been healing for me. With the third kind of suffering, the fundamental unease of being made of fluxing impermanent sensations that are just floating in nothingness. This became really painful for me after cessation, it's hard to describe why this is so terrifying and uncomfortable, I think it's just you always thought you were one thing that was grounded and safe, and then you see you aren't grounded and safe. Ofc no amount of problem solving or thinking will ever make this any better, cause it's not something that can be fixed, like at all, so eventually you just have to resign yourself with tears.

The other thing is fear, the biggest face to face I've had with fear is after a stretch of incredibly peaceful open mediation, I slipped into incredible anxiety. For a while I couldn't find peace because the fear of slipping into fear was so strong. Fear is a tough one because often fear is right, it's true, I am not safe and things are not stable. So the problem solving works and works to try get you back to safety and stability, but there is no solution here and so the fear remains. So here too I resigned myself because the fear is right, I am not safe, the depths of misery are always waiting, and that's terrifying, so let's grieve that too.

Before, I reveled in the safety and peace of mediation, almost like I was hiding in it. Now I see that there actually is no safety and I fully resign myself to that, and this actually leads to much deeper peace than before, it's like my mind totally gives up on any kind of problem solving or solution based thinking, and everything that arises is left untouched; and if something does arise that is painful, then I feel deep sadness that this pain has to be a part of my life. You might think, "Being sad that pain and suffering is a part of life is the opposite of acceptance! I should be unbothered by pain and suffering being a part of my life" But here's the thing, pain, trauma, fear, suffering SUCKS, if it didn't suck it wouldn't be suffering, so trying to be unbothered by it is really just denial. Last thing which might be slightly controversial, trying to actively notice non-self is quite unproductive, it's non-self not no-self. Having a sense of self is just how the human brain works, and the sense of self is deeply integrated with every part of the brain, so it's much more effective to embrace your humanity and vulnerability, working through your humanity rather than trying to sidestep it.

So how does this compare to your approach to suffering? Has a direct approach to sitting with the hard stuff worked for you? Anyway thanks for reading and I look forward to your thoughts!


r/streamentry • • 5d ago

Practice Feeling like sparkly goop

9 Upvotes

About 2 or 3 weeks ago, I just so happened to start practicing "reunition of subject & object". As in, throughout my day whatever I was observing, my breath, my thoughts, cup of tea, emotional feeling, my body, a person, my cat, the clouds, my laptop, etc, I'd just try to dissolve all barriers and feel reunited with said object. This was honestly very helpful and freeing, it felt quite pleasant too when I could really lock in and "do it right"

One thing led to another, and I got reintroduced to the 10 fetters module. I recognized the path was honestly synopsis of my own progress over the past few months; and i felt especially happy that I was already on lvl 6—dissolution of subject & object

But this was not actually the case. I had suppressed/weakened fetters 1-5 so much that I thought they were gone. Though, I had not truly saw through the notion of self, or the instability of the rites & rituals I was still upholding, or eradicated all feverish attachments. So I went back and started really meditating on the self, seeing if I could actually find it anywhere. Obviously, nothing substantial was found and so fetters 1-3 started actually falling away and the remnant desires/aversions I was suppressing came to surface as well.

What's most difficult about this is honestly the loss of rites & rituals, that was my solid ground i guess. I strictly believed that the best was to live was to consume as little as possible and avoid habits that are harmful to the environment (driving, ai, eating meat, using social media, using intoxicants, gaming, watching TV etc.). I believed that city life was fundamentally deranged and poisonous, and the best thing for all of society would be to get as many people as possible out of the city and create smaller communities in the rural country side that live in harmony with nature. I thought that anyone who wasn't committing their life to activism was wrong and my goal was to remove myself from society temporarily (!!) until I could find suitable means to help people see the "right" way to live.

Seems mostly reasonable, right? I know there's still some truth within that previous worldview, I'm just really, really, struggling to grasp what it is. and i dont even know what it is that is doing the grasping in the first place.

I can't say for sure that there is one correct way to live anymore, I can't say that consuming meat, intoxicants, driving, buying material things, or enjoying city life is bad or even harmful. How could it be? Who is it that's being harmed? To what extent is the collapse of the human race just the natural process of nature, who is it that wants otherwise? I dont understand. i dont know what it is, who it is that wants otherwise. i dont know im really confused and its really scary. ive started dabbling in non-duality and whatnot, seeing that nothing is inherently pure or impure, good or bad, created or destroyed. the question keeps coming up "what is it that desires to save the environment? what is it that views these substances as wrong?" i dont know. i cant find anything.

luckily, i've practiced the Four Establishments of Mindfulness enough to recognize when my mind is in a state of confusion or ignorance. And so, I know that my mind is indeed, in a state of confusion and ignorance. It's just difficult, because it seems like all of my desire to do good in the world was because of my aversion to what i claimed was bad. But there truly is no ultimate good or bad, the trees do not blame the lightning for setting them ablaze, the fire does not scorn the rain for putting it out. Nature thrives in the cycle of continuous birth and death, and it's very obvious to me now that humans cannot be separated from nature at all. These 'toxic' societies that we've built on the foundation of fossil fuels and over-consumption are made of the exact same substances of the beautiful mountain ranges and forests im trying to protect. What is being protected? protected from what? who is it that's striving to protect?

It's also difficult because the other day-to-day desires & aversions I had have resurfaced and I'm dealing with those as well. It's also very worrisome because I quit my job about a month ago, and have been trying to get a new one; but the dualistic ethics that i used as my guide no longer exist.

I try to return to the first noble truth. Suffering does exist, even if there is no ultimate perpetrator or victim. There is suffering here.

yeah idk, this is really probably the most vulnerable I have ever been ever considering layers upon layers of conditioning have dissolved. i am very worried though, because i need to sort through this issue asap and find a job and decide if i really do want to continue with my previous plan of living in a motor-home to be closer to nature/have more time for activism & spiritual practice. it's just so effing disorienting right now, i dont even know who feels lost


r/streamentry • • 5d ago

Practice Meditation, Emotional Amplification, Instability, & “The Shakes”

1 Upvotes

I’ve been considering a possible pattern in intensive meditation practice, particularly concentration and pīti cultivation.

In my experience, meditation can genuinely amplify positive emotional states, particularly through cultivating wholesome thoughts, joy, contentment, and pīti. These experiences don’t merely become more noticeable; they can be deliberately intensified and sustained through practice.

If meditation can amplify positive emotions, why wouldn’t the same attentional mechanisms also amplify negative emotions—anger, fear, sadness, anxiety, and physical discomfort? Not merely through increased awareness, but through an actual intensification of the emotional experience itself.

Could this heightened sensitivity in both directions produce what I’d call “the shakes”—a kind of emotional instability in which practitioners oscillate, sometimes rapidly, between intensely positive and negative states?

Perhaps such instability is an inherent, possibly even unavoidable, consequence of developing heightened emotional sensitivity before sufficient equanimity or emotional regulation has developed.

Is this a recognized phenomenon among advanced practitioners? Is it an inevitable transitional stage of deeper practice, or something that arises only under particular conditions?

I’d be especially interested in firsthand experiences from practitioners with deep concentration or jhānic experience, along with relevant Buddhist or scientific explanations.


r/streamentry • • 5d ago

Practice Watching life behind a window

4 Upvotes

Lately, I've spent some time in meditation and contemplation of God and consciousness. More recently, it's like I've lost my usual sense of a separate self. I mostly just observe, and things seem to happen on their own. It can feel a little empty. Like watching life behind a window. I think I've been focusing a little too much on the oneness of it all. From what I understand, it's a common experience. Anyone willing to share their experience going through this ? What helped you get to the other side ? What is waiting on the other side of this ?


r/streamentry • • 6d ago

Practice What Is Life Like Far Along the Contemplative Path?

14 Upvotes

For those who have reliably attained the jhānas and progressed far along the contemplative path, what is everyday subjective experience actually like?

Is this level of practice sustainable in modern Western society, while maintaining a career, romantic relationship, children, and other responsibilities? Or does meaningful progress eventually require substantial renunciation?

Does one gradually cease experiencing the ordinary emotional highs and lows of life, approaching a more consistently neutral or equanimous state? Or can profound equanimity coexist with intense pleasure, excitement, love, ambition, and emotional engagement?

Ultimately, what changes, what is sacrificed, and what—if anything—becomes incompatible with an otherwise ordinary, productive life?


r/streamentry • • 6d ago

Mettā Seeking metta teacher/guide

9 Upvotes

Hi folks, am just wondering if anyone has had a teacher or mentor help them with metta. It seems like such a beneficial practice but I just feel like I can't "get" it. Thank you :)


r/streamentry • • 6d ago

Practice Are samatha and body scan legitimate means for "entering the stream"?

5 Upvotes

Im new, I’ve realized that these are more body-oriented practices, yet I’ve felt a strong affinity for them; they relax both my mind and my body. They are mentioned in the Satipatthana Sutta: the cultivation of mindfulness, concentration, and conduct (sila).

During these months of practice, I’ve felt as though my mind is more "empty" of negative rumination; I’m simply attentive to what I’m doing, less reactive to negativity in general—or, at the very least, I recover more quickly from any distress. Personally, I do believe it can be helpful on the path—bringing me a little bit closer each day—despite criticisms that it’s a practice that is "too physical" or "too body-oriented." Any thoughts or opinions would be very welcome.


r/streamentry • • 6d ago

Science What about meditation causes location changes, in jeffrey martin's system?

0 Upvotes

What causes someone to go into location 3/4/5? (he also talks about layers 1-4). What is meditation doing that allows this?

And do 'samskara' have any relevance here?

Would love to hear your input. Thanks for hearing me out :)


r/streamentry • • 6d ago

Practice Goenka retreat daily schedule

7 Upvotes

Question is simply and hope it's OK on this sub. I'd like to get some idea on how the day is structured, such as a typical daily schedule, group vs individual activities, "mandatory" vs optional activities, etc. I hope the previous participants could share. Thank you.


r/streamentry • • 7d ago

Śamatha Why do people say it is harder to keep attention on a small area?

12 Upvotes

I have been following Culadasa's The Mind Illumiated for a while. Culadasa recommends using the breath at the nose as the meditation object. As far as I remember, the argument is that this is better for samatha practice because it is harder to keep attention focused on a small area.

I do not understand why it is said to be harder to keep attention on a small area. That would imply that it is easier to keep attention focused on a large area, such as the breath in the abdomen or the entire body. That is not my experience. When I try, for example, Rob Burbea's suggestion to attend to the "energy body" (the area around the physical body), I find that this is even harder than attending to the breath at the nose. I get grossly distracted even more easily. In comparison, attending to the breath at the nose feels easier.

Please help me understand this. What are the pros and cons for samatha practice of attending to a small area vs a large area?


r/streamentry • • 7d ago

Science Meditation and Nervous System Dysregulation

9 Upvotes

What is currently understood about the relationship between meditation, particularly intensive concentration practices and pre-jhānic/jhānic states, and autonomic nervous-system regulation?

Why do some experienced meditators report heightened anxiety, sympathetic arousal, insomnia, sensory hypersensitivity, exaggerated startle responses, and other symptoms resembling nervous-system dysregulation, sometimes persisting or becoming more noticeable after stopping practice?

What mechanisms might explain these effects, and is there evidence that deeper meditative absorption increases susceptibility, or is that association largely anecdotal?


r/streamentry • • 8d ago

Practice Can someone with a history of serious drug addiction genuinely free themselves from these patterns, or will they always remain a struggle?

21 Upvotes

I would like to hear your honest opinions and, especially, experiences from people who have walked a similar path.

I have a history of serious substance abuse, including crack cocaine, cocaine, stimulants, ketamine, cannabis and alcohol.

My addiction was not just occasional recreational use. There were periods when substances had a significant grip on my life, and I experienced the consequences of that.

I have been working hard to change my life, stay away from drugs and alcohol, and understand the underlying patterns of craving, attachment and dissatisfaction.

Buddhist practice, particularly Theravada Vipassana meditation, has become a very important part of this journey.

However, I sometimes wonder about something fundamental:

Is genuine freedom from these addictive tendencies actually possible?

Can someone with a history like mine eventually reach a point where the desire for drugs, alcohol and intense forms of gratification genuinely disappears? Not simply because they are resisting temptation, avoiding triggers or constantly monitoring themselves, but because the underlying craving has fundamentally weakened or ceased?

Or is addiction something that, even after years of recovery and spiritual practice, remains a lifelong vulnerability that one must always be careful about?

I am particularly interested in hearing from people with a history of serious addiction who have made significant progress through Buddhist practice, meditation or the path to Stream Entry and beyond.

I am not looking for comforting answers. I would rather hear honest experiences, including the difficult ones.

Thank you.

Edit : I have used AI to better translate from my native Language.

Thank you for the tolerance.

Edit : Thank you so much for the kind support you've been amazing. Just to let you know I finished recently my first Mahasi style Vipassana retreat @Dhammodaya meditation center in Thailandia https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kOtZ8mSm3mU

I have made a walking tour at the end. The center is amazing and is pure Mahasi style coming from Chanmyay Sayadaw, just mind-blowing.

I'll be going back there on the first of December for 90 days.

So yeah 👍🏻 thank you so much

Ps. I'm answering day by day to all the comments. Thank you 😊


r/streamentry • • 8d ago

Practice Tempering Your Practice in Daily Life

3 Upvotes

Like most people I find myself lost in my day to day affairs. The worst of it comes when I end up in conversations with people, or am working on a task that requires all of my cognitive attention. Even when all of this is not happening, it leaves a lasting impact on my mind. I find I am trying to navigate and contemplate my social relationships in the back of my mind based on the interactions I have with people throughout the day. Currently, I only have the morning and night to devote my complete attention to meditation whether that be walking or sitting. This itself is great and has changed my life tremendously for the better, but most of that concentration goes out the window during the day, and I can only be mindful in sporadic pockets of the day. It's easy to keep your mindfulness when you have nothing going on, but there's always something that comes up which you have to shift your attention to. Also, it gets harder the more tired you get.

Please correct me if I am wrong, but From what I have gathered, the Theravada perspective says that the only real solution is to put yourself in a situation that is free from all of this such as becoming a monastic, or living a hermit like life. This is definitely a solution, but I still would like to think that there is a way to use the chaos of daily life as an advantage to somehow hone your practice.

I haven't done much research on Mahayana, but I feel like it has some ideas that are in this direction. I may be wrong, but Mahayana developed to suit the needs of those living in more populated areas like cities. Would practicing the paramitas and trying to resemble a Bodhisattva in the real world be comparable to a monk?

One post I have seen that is relevant to what I am talking about is the one u/duffstoic made called "Practices for Daily Life from Zen Master Hakuin". There is a lot more to it, but it is basically about centering your attention in your lower belly all day as an energy practice. If I remember correctly, Hakuin also criticized the practice of Hinayana monks by saying it was unstable and fragile because it required seclusion from the outside world. I don't know if I agree with this, but this sentiment is definitely something I will keep in mind.

I plan on becoming a nurse in the future. This will likely require me to be working 12 hour shifts in an environment that requires your undivided attention. The busyness and fatigue over the course of the shift will likely make it pretty much impossible to maintain mindfulness. Although the are different specialties that have varying degrees of intensity. Despite this, I feel like this job offers a great opportunity to practice the Brahmaviharas and Asubha.

I am still a pretty young guy, so another concern I have is the impact living a reclusive life (even if devoted to practice) could have on my character without a firm foundation of life experience. I don't know what the Buddhist take on this is, but i feel accumulating life experience and really knowing samsara can serve to aid your practice. For example, I have never been in a relationship, but I feel like it can be used as a great opportunity to learn how people work by truly getting to know someone. I can only imagine what a unique perspective raising kids would give someone on life. Then again, maybe this is just a roundabout way and devoting all your time to meditation and living tranquilly would save you unnecessary trouble and attatchment, and insight into the four noble truths is truly all you need to know.

I would love to hear about how all of you use daily life to aid your practice, the level of importance general life experience has, and the degree of necessity you think living in a hermit like way has. Or as a monk. If you have personal advice for me, I am open to this as well. Thank you for taking the time to read.


r/streamentry • • 8d ago

Practice Is "Nada sound" simply tinnitus?

15 Upvotes

Been reading Right Concentration by Leigh Brasington and in one of the methods for developing access concentration he mentions this yoga term that sounds awfully similar to tinnitus (continuous, high-pitched white noise in the background).


r/streamentry • • 9d ago

Retreat Any online meditation bootcamps?

4 Upvotes

Hi all, are there any online meditation bootcamps? I'm happy to pay. I want structure, community and financial responsibiliy to keep my on the path and focused.

Frank yang (the YouTuber) had been running his Contemplative Crossfit bootcamp for a couple years now and the curriculum looks cool:

https://mindtraining.cc

However, the price seems slightly high (but I'd be willing to stretch it somewhere near) but the timings are more USA based whereas I am looking for something more European timing based.

Anything out there?


r/streamentry • • 9d ago

Insight Nothing holds anything up.

13 Upvotes

I'm posting this because i'm looking for those who feel or have felt similar to what i am about to write. I'm not here to argue or convince anyone of anything just pure curiosity, i found this sub on accident.

I have more and better friends than I ever had. I can talk to them about almost anything, and I’m doing that more and more. But then you go home, you continue your life, and you return to the void of your own consciousness. Like there’s something missing. I’ve been walking around with that feeling for a very, very long time and I always called it loneliness.

The void isn’t empty, it’s filled with constant narration. Scenarios, meanings behind meanings, questions behind questions with no answers. I thought that was just how my brain works.

It went quiet twice in my life. Once during a family weekend where I just said fuck it and walked for two hours to get cigarettes. And once on a balcony in Lagos, Portugal, right after EMDR. No narrator. It wasn’t like I didn’t have thoughts, I was just there. No scenario after scenario, just a guy sitting on a fucking balcony. The colors were brighter, higher contrast, especially the trees, water and sand. I even took off my sunglasses because everything was so bright and beautiful. I could hear the birds. A tree was a tree without any deeper meaning behind it just being a tree. I still don’t know if that’s something monks search for forever or just how most people are.

I tend to blog to get stuff of my mind and my hands often know more than i do when i start writing. When i was trying to feel what that feeling of the void was, my fingers typed, annihilation. The brain tried to come up with a reason afterwards and pulled a blank, and just reading the word did something in my chest.

It took a while to find out what it meant. Nothing has meaning, objectively. Only subjectively. Nothing holds anything up. I’ve known that as a sentence for years, anyone can know it as a sentence. This was knowing it in my body and it made me sad. A heavy chest, and for once no words to go with it. It’s not often I don’t have words for something.

The feeling is always there, even on MDMA. It hurts less, but it’s there. No matter what i do, what fucking drugs i take, how good the friends are, it’s still there.

And then everybody has answers. Camus has his revolt, the Stoics have their order, every therapy book has the healing arc, every thread on here ends with it gets better. To me they don’t sound like answers, they just sound like more fucking cope.

The closest thing I found is Ecclesiastes, more than two thousand years old. “For in much wisdom is much grief: and he that increaseth knowledge increaseth sorrow.” The word that gets translated as vanity or meaningless is hevel or ''Vapor''. The writer tried everything, pleasure, money, wisdom, came back with vapor, and landed on eat your bread, enjoy your work and the people you love, because that’s what there is.

So that’s it, sadness about nothing holding anything up. There’s nothing to accept, it just is. I don’t know what the fuck to do with it yet, except find something that makes it lighter to carry.

Edit: To be clear, I’m not talking about the feeling. Feelings come and go, i know. I’m talking about the fact. Life is objectively meaningless, you make the meaning yourself, and making it doesn’t change the fact.