If you're new to Sudoku and wondering, "Why can't this cell be X?"—this post is for you.
Why is this 8 wrong?
Let’s break it down so you can understand the logic behind solving Sudoku puzzles and avoid one of the most common beginner mistakes.
The Two Times You Should Place a Digit in Sudoku
There are only two situations where you should place a digit in a cell:
When it’s the ONLY PLACE that digit can go in the row, column, or box.
Even if other digits could technically fit in that cell, if a digit has no other valid spot in its row, column, or box, it must go there.
2. When it’s the ONLY DIGIT that can go in that cell.
If no other digit is valid for a particular cell—even if this digit could potentially fit elsewhere—it must be placed there.
Why Guessing Doesn’t (always) Work
Good Sudoku puzzles are designed to have one unique solution. That means every number you place must be based on logical reasoning, not guesses. A common beginner mistake is thinking, "If there’s no immediate contradiction, I can just place this number here." But that’s not how Sudoku works!
If you can’t logically prove why a number must (or must not) go in a specific cell - or why it can’t go anywhere else - then you’re not ready to place it yet. Keep looking for clues and deductions elsewhere.
Advanced Techniques and Complex Proofs
As puzzles get harder, you’ll encounter situations where more complex reasoning is required to rule out candidates. These advanced techniques (like X-Wing, XY-Wing, or Skyscraper) help you prove why certain numbers can’t go in specific cells. Mastering these methods will make solving medium and advanced puzzles much easier!
TL;DR: Use Logic, Not Luck, Not Assumptions!
To sum up:
• Only place a number when you’ve logically proven it’s the only option for that cell or location.
• Avoid guessing—it leads to errors and frustration.
• Use beginner techniques like Naked Singles and Hidden Singles first, then move on to advanced strategies as needed.
SOME EXAMPLES
Recall the rules: no repeats in every row, column and box
In box 9 (the right bottom box), there's only one spot for 8 so 8 has to go there.
No repeats
No repeats in every row and column so there's only one 8 in row 7 AND column 8.
Therefore, green cell has to be 8.
Row and Column
This one is trickier:
Trickier
There are 9 digits.
If a cell 'sees' all but one digit, that cell has to be that digit.
This green cell sees 14678 in row 2 and 235 in column 1. That leaves 9 as the only option for that cell.
If you're still confused, try thinking if there's any other digits you could place in the green cell apart from 9.
Eventual Impossible State
Even if the contradiction is not readily apparent, making a mistake will inevitably lead to a contradictory/impossible state later on.
If you're still stuck or want examples of how to solve without guessing, ask a question! The members here are willing to help you out. Happy solving! 😊
Special thanks to u/Special-Round-3815 who wrote this original guide, and the other members of r/sudoku who commented and who make this sub a pleasure to be involved with.
I played decent amount of sudokus on hell dificulty (sudoku coach) so now I am pretty familiar with AIC mechanics and how to spot (shorter) ones. But sometimes, I’m stuck, reaaly stuck, so a couple of questions:
- How do you find the correct AIC when there are very few on the board (<5) - When (and how) should i look for grouped AIC-s? I know how the grouping thing works, but it makes so much harder to spot for me. - Should I also practice the not chain-y tactics, like W, XYZ wings, ALS? I dont reaaaly like them, so almost never use them. - How long does it take for you to crack a harder puzzle on average? ~3-4000 points
If it’s something simple like a hidden double/triple or x-wing don’t tell me where it is i’ll find it. if it’s an xy-wing then please tell where it is i’m still shaky on my understanding of that strategy
Custom Sudoku puzzle for your Sunday evening. No special rules except dots and smaller/larger than indicators. Hope you like it, and I'm curious to hear how you approach it!
I’ve been stuck on this killer sudoku for weeks, and I’ve just restarted it. I really really want to know how to approach the next steps. Please help me😢
Scientific American came here and told us about their new sudoku puzzles. I LOVED those. The layout and color scheme and difficulty of their daily puzzles was absolutely lovely. It was a big part of my daily puzzle routine. I even subscribed to them just because I wanted to pay them a bit for the fun.
They just decided to get rid of the sudoku puzzles! I am heart broken. SI if you are out there please bring them back. Please!
Please do tell me if I’m correct or wrong in anything here, as I’m having issues with placing numbers in opposite boxes. I don’t want to check the back of the book as that is sending me kind of insane.
i believe there is something with row 1 and 2, column 1 and 5, the 4 & 3 must somehow be unique, so they both cant be in column 1 row 1&2, but i dont know what i can remove that way.
I'm not very good yet. all i can do is basic to medium difficulty techniques, so i have to make do with what i can do
tldr: my subject of elimination (or non-elimination) is r1c2, highlighted in blue.i was trying to prove it should be a 2 no matter what
I've marked the cells involved. that doesn't seem to make sense, right? but i assure you this is basic sudoku strategy. you guys probably see some techniques that either I'm missing or some advanced technique that i don't know how to implement yet
i was thinking if r3c7 is a 2, then the 2 in r1c9 would be false. and there would be no 2 in row 1 except r1c2. so that should be a 2. that's 1 possibility
other possibility is r3c7 is not a 2, any number except 2. then the cells with the yellow marks would form a unique rectangle type 1 of 4 and 8. that automatically makes r2c6 a 6. and if that is a 6, follow the cells with the green marks. r1c6 would be a 8. r1c3 would be a 6. r7c3 would be a 7. r7c2 would be a 4, making r1c2 a 2
so that means whether r3c7 is a 2 or not, r1c2 should absolutely be a 2
maybe there is a unique rectangle type whatever technique that would make this simpler, but all i can do is type 1. i kinda understand basic type 2 but haven't seen it yet in any puzzles I've played
The solution strategy for a 6×6 Killer Sudoku titled B6×6=85+? published on Sudoku Coach shall be discussed here.
Original puzzle
Rules of this variant Sudoku:
Killer cages: In a cage, numbers must add up to the small number in the top left of the cage, without repetition.
Here is the no-candidates solution strategy for this puzzle.
By the Rule of 21 for column 1, one can infer that r13c2 add up to 4, and therefore, can have {1,3} in them (blue).
Additionally, by summing all the cages in the first three rows, one can infer that the pink cells (see Figure below, which is also the first checkpoint) r1c5, r2c2, and r3c35, add up to 22, by using Rule of 21.
First checkpoint
There are two conditions when this can happen:
r3c5 = 4, and r3c3, r2c2, r1c5 all are 6.
r3c35 must be {5,6}, and r1c5 and r2c2 must also be {5,6}.
Now if r3c35 be {4,6}, then, there is no valid combo possible for r3c12. Therefore, r3c35 is deduced to be {5,6}, by the process of elimination. Thus, r3c2 = 3 and r3c1 = 4 (by Kakuro logic).
Second checkpoint
Again, using rule of 21 for column 6, r46c5 (orange) add up to 3 and hence can have {1,2} in them. Also, we have previously proved that r13c5 (gray) are {5,6}. Therefore, r2c5 is {3,4}. Now, if r2c5 is {3,4}, by Kakuro logic, one can visualize that r3c4 (blue) cannot be 2, because it leads to a contradiction.
Thus, r3c4 must be 1.
Since r2c5 is {3,4}, r2c4 also is {3,4}, so for r123c6, the valid combo totaling 9 is {1,2,6}. Thus, r1c6 is 6, r3c3 and r1c5 are both 5, while r2c2 and r3c5 are both 6.
Third checkpoint
After filling in some more numbers, we reach the position above. Now, given that r1c3 (orange) is {3,4}, the combo {2,3,4} is invalid for r45c3 and r5c2 (the three-cell cage totaling 9). Therefore, the only valid combos for this cage are {1,2,6} and {1,3,5}. In either case, 1 is locked to only r45c3 (pink), so r6c3 cannot be a 1, while r56c4 also cannot be 1. So, the only valid combo for r6c3 and r56c4 is {2,3,5}, which implies that r6c3 (green) is a 3.
From this point on, the puzzle is solved with basics.
The no-candidates solution strategy for the puzzle titled Fog of War #53 shall be discussed here.
Rules of this variant Sudoku:
Arrow: Numbers on an arrow add up to the number in the circle.
Ratio: Cells with a black dot between them have a ratio of 2. If there is a number within the black dot, this number is the ratio.
Fog of War: Only a certain part of the grid is visible at the start. A correctly placed number reveals the cells surrounding it.
Here is the no-candidates solution strategy for this puzzle.
Because of the interaction between ratio and arrow constraints, the original puzzle itself is the first checkpoint.
First checkpoint
Notice that the pink cell r2c4 and the yellow cell r3c4 have a ratio of 2 between them. This means that r4c4 (green) must be some multiple of 3. Possible options:
r4c4 = 3, r23c4 = {1,2}
r4c4 = 6, r23c4 = {2,4}
r4c4 = 9, r23c4 = {3,6}
Additionally, r5c4 (orange) and r6c4 (blue) have a ratio of 3. Possible combos {1,3}, {2,6}, and {3,9}.
Therefore, for r234c4, possibilities 1 and 3 are eliminated (because if r4c4 = 3, and r23c4 = {1,2}, no valid possibility for r56c4. Likewise, for the case r4c4 = 9).
By the process of elimination, therefore, r4c4 is 6. Now, once r4c4 is determined to be a 6, and r23c4 is {2,4}, the possibilities for r56c4 are {1,3} and {3,9}.
Second checkpoint
Because r6c4 (green) is one tip of an arrow, it cannot be 9. Furthermore, r5c4, being the circle, it cannot be 1. Additionally, if r5c4 were 3, then r5c56 would be {1,2}, which would empty r6c4, so r5c4 cannot be 3. Therefore, r5c4 must be 9, and r6c4 must be 3.
Third checkpoint
In column 4, r1789c4 are {1,5,7,8}. Notice that r6c4 (3) is one tip of an arrow involving r7c45 and r6c4. Therefore, the possibilities for r7c4 are {5,7,8}.
If r7c4 be a 7, by the rule of arrow constraint, r7c5 must be 4, however, no value in r7c6 can satisfy a ratio of 3 with r7c5. Same scenario occurs, when r7c4 is 8. Therefore, by the process of elimination, r7c4 is 5, and r7c5 is 2.
Likewise, using arrow constraint rules, r19c4 are {7,8}, therefore, we have a hidden single 1 in r8c4.
Fourth checkpoint
Notice that r89c6 (yellow) have a ratio of 2. In box 8, r7c5 is 2, r7c6 is 6, and r8c4 is 1. Therefore, the following possibilities for r89c6 are eliminated: {1,2}, {2,4}, and {3,6}. By process of elimination, r89c6 are {4,8}, and thus, r9c4 is 7. Also, r1c4 is determined to be 8. Additionally, in box 8, r9c5 is 3, and r8c6 is 4.
Now in box 1, r23c4 is {2,4}, and r3c56 have a ratio of 2. Therefore, the only possibility for r3c56 is {3,6}, which means that r3c6 is 3 and r3c5 is 6.
Fifth checkpoint
In box 2, there exists a locked candidate 1 in r1c56 (yellow). Therefore, r1c7 (pink) can be either 2 or 4, because r1c7 is a part of a ratio constraint with r2c7 (green), and the ratio is 4.
The only combos are {4,1} and {2,8}. Further, notice that r2c7 cannot be 1, by rule of arrow constraint, so r1c7 also cannot be 4. Therefore, r1c7 must be 2, and r2c7 must be 8.
Additionally, since r3c89 also have a ratio of 4, they must be {1,4}, which means r3c4 is 2, and r2c4 is 4.
Sixth checkpoint
Notice that in r3c7 (gray), 9 is eliminated, so r3c7 is {5,7} while r2c6 (green) is {7,9}. Therefore, r4c6 must be 2, because only the following combos are valid: r2c6 = 9, r3c7 = 7, r4c6 = 2; and r2c6 = 7, r3c7 = 5, and r4c6 = 2.
Additionally, r4c5 is determined to be 8, so r5c56 is {4,5}, therefore, r5c5 is 4 and r5c6 is 5.
Seventh checkpoint
In box 3, r12c7 is {2,8} and r3c89 (green) is {1,4}. One can prove that the arrow in box 3 is, therefore, of length 2, involving r1c8 and r2c9. You can prove this indirectly, by considering two possibilities. The arrow circle cell is r2c8 (yellow, given), and the first possibility is that r1c8, r12c9 are all part of the arrow. The second possibility is that r1c8 and r23c9 are part of the arrow.
With regards to the first possibility, r3c89 being {1,4}, one can immediately observe that there can be no valid combo for r2c8 that satisfies a length of 3, but cannot have 1 or 2 in it (recollect that by Kakuro logic, the three-cell sum combos are: 6 ⇒ {1,2,3}; 7 ⇒ {1,2,4}; 8 ⇒ {1,2,5} / {1,3,4}; 9 ⇒ {1,2,6} / {1,3,5} / {2,3,4}).
Therefore, we now test the second possibility, r1c8 and r23c9 being part of the arrow. In this possibility, r3c9 will be 1. Now, the only combo possible for r12c8 and r2c9, where 2 and 4 are both excluded, by Kakuro logic, is when r2c8 is 9, r1c8 is 5, and r2c9 is 3. Since, r3c9 is determined to be 1, r3c8 must be 4, which means that r4c89 is {1,3}.
But it has been proved above that r3c9 is 1 and r2c9 is 3.
This contradiction arises because of the false assumption, that r1c8 and r23c9 are all part of the arrow constraint. Therefore, this possibility is also discarded, and it is proved that the arrow length is 2.
The reason to prove all this is, because this is a fog of war puzzle, one can only work on a few local pieces of puzzle (rows/columns/boxes) at a time, and infer logic based on these local pieces of information, without having to undergo extensive stress-testing.
Therefore, r2c8, r1c8, and r2c9 are part of the arrow constraint, with r1c7 = 2, r2c7 = 8, and r3c89 being {1,4}. Thus, the only possibility is r2c8 = 9, and r1c8 and r2c9 being {3,6}. Thus, r2c6 is 7, r3c7 is 5, and r1c9 is 7.
Eighth checkpoint
From column 7, one can infer that r7c7 can be either 4 or 7, and r89c7 must be {1,3} or {3,4}. In either case, one can prove that r8c7 is 3, while r4c7 is 9.
Now, to prove that r7c7 must be a 4, we need to eliminate that r7c7 = 7 is a valid solution. Here is how:
Ninth checkpoint
Notice that r7c8 is one tip of an arrow in box 9, and one can also say that r7c8 and r8c9 are the cells on the arrow, and that they sum to be equal to the number in r9c9. There are two possibilities:
If r7c7 = 7, r9c7 = 4, and r9c9 = 6, in which case r8c9 is 5, and r7c8 is 1. Therefore, r3c9 is 1, and r3c8 is 4. We now see that r4c89 cannot have a 1 in them, but they sum to 4. This is impossible; therefore, we reject it.
If r7c7 = 7, r9c4 = 4, and r9c9 = 9, in which case, r8c9 = 8 and r7c8 = 1. There is no number that can go in r7c9 (pink). Therefore, this possibility is also rejected.
There is no other possibility for r9c9 that can work in this case, hence our assumption that r7c7 is 7 is false. Thus, r7c7 is proved to be a 4.
One can likewise, prove that r9c9 is 9, because it is established that r9c9 is the cell on the circle of the arrow, and r8c9 and r7c8 are the cells on the arrow. So, by Kakuro logic, (recollect the following are the two-cell sum combos for 5, 6, 7, 8, and 9):
Two-cell-sum
Possible combos
5
{1,4} / {2,3}
6
{1,5} / {2,4}
7
{1,6} / {2,5} / {3,4}
8
{1,7} / {2,6} / {3,5}
9
{1,8} / {2,7} / {3,6} / {4,5}
One can see, from the above table, that it is impossible to have r9c9 = 5 or r9c9 = 6, because r7c7 = 4, r8c7 = 3, and r9c7 = 1. Additionally, r9c4 = 7 and r9c6 = 8. Therefore, by the process of elimination, r9c9 = 9, and r8c9 = 2, r7c8 = 7.
Tenth checkpoint
In column 3, r5c3 and r6c3 (yellow) have a ratio of 3. Without {2,6}, the possible combos are {1,3} and {3,9}. Therefore, r6c3 is 9 and r5c3 is 3.
Now, in box 6, r5c9 (gray) is 1, which means that r3c8 is 1, r3c9 is 4, r4c8 is also a 4, and r4c9 is 3 (all pink). Also, r6c9 (green) is a 5.
Eleventh checkpoint
In box 7, it is given that r7c12 is {3,9}, while r7c3 is 1 and r9c3 is 4. Therefore, one can visualize that in box 7, the arrow covers r89c2 (is of length 2), and the only combos possible (by Kakuro logic) is that if r8c1 = 8, then r8c2 = 6, and r9c2 = 2; or if r8c1 = 7, then r8c2 = 5, and r9c2 = 2. In both cases, it is proved that r9c2 is 2, thus, r6c2 = 4, r1c2 = 5, and the puzzle is solved with basics from this point on.
Although this app disappeared years ago, I have continued to get my daily fix thanks to the software being copied to each new Samsung tablet I got ...... until now 😢
I am keeping my old tablet alive so I can continue with Megafauna as it has all the bells and whistles. Nothing else I have tried comes anywhere near it.
I have installed APKpure but despite the Megafauna icon being in the ad, it is not shown in the list of available downloads.
So if anyone out there has found an app like Megafauna Sudoku Killer, please let me know, and I will be eternally grateful 🙏
My solver says ALS ring (with an AHS chain node 238c2): (5=3)r6c9-3r4c78=(3-2)r4c3=r89c3-2r8c2=238r567c2-9r56c2=(9-5)r5c3=r5c789-5r6c9 => -3r5c3789, -3r6c78, -5r6c78, -6r4c3, -9r7c2
But I'm trying an easier interpretation as a kraken 3-Sector SdC. I say easier as it's larger, rank-0-ish and shorter to remember the components.
If 3r5c3 (fin) isn't true, 35r6c9 goes to one of r45c3, and 29r8c2 goes to another, which is rank-0. Potential eliminations are:
other 35s in r6
other 29s in c2
non-2359 in the blue intersection area. (2359 are locked here)
If fin 3r3c3 is true, 9 is eliminated in the same cell. r4c78 has a 3, so r6c5 is a 5, killing other 5s in the row, placing 5 in r5c3. 9 becomes hidden single in the box, placing an 2, killing other 29s. (fin 3, hidden single 8 in the column does the same job).
But my interpretation misses some eliminations 3r5c789, which are not obvious to me. One way to look at is when fin is true, they are eliminated. when fin 3 is false, two cases on the yellow cell:
if it's a 3 then eliminating those.
if not, it's a 5. and it forms an ALC with 29r8c2 going into r45c3. the strong link 3r4c3=r4c78 still eliminates the threes.
From this perspective -3r5c789 is invariant to the fin, but not shown directly as potential elimination of the original SdC either.