r/tabletopgamedesign • • 4d ago

Announcement The Downvote Button is not a Disagree Button, and it is also not a "Protest Against AI" Button

0 Upvotes

I know Reddit has a general culture of treating it like the "like" button on Facebook, but this sub is not all of Reddit. We are system designers, we should know better.

The purpose of the up/down vote is comment or post relevancy.

Is it pertinent to the sub?

Does the comment stay on topic of the post?

Is it participation in a discussion?

Then upvote it.

Downvote things that are: derogatory insults, off topic tangents, spam, incoherent gibberish, accidental reposts, low-effort copypasta.

Everyone has big feelings about AI and AI art. Well, thankfully, this sub has had a flair and filter specifically for artists for hire that allows you dodge AI art entirely, and there's no shortage of people posting that way. This system was set up years ago, before AI art was a problem, out of a desire to operate the system in a logical and reasonable way. Tabletop Artists for Hire are, in fact, relevant to people in this sub. The result is we have human artists at the ready, and have been insulated from the slopification of art assets.

Every post regarding AI causes our traffic to triple or more over the normal level. Love it or hate it, it is a relevant topic of conversation and this sub exists to facilitate that discussion, not orient it.

If someone is feverishly defending the use of AI, respond to them. Disagreement, even combat of ideas, is encouraged...I don't expect anyone in this sub to be 8 years old or unable to think critically or handle criticism. I go in and manually approve comments the auto-mod is removing because of furious use of the disagree button.

A post with 7 net upvotes and comments with scores of downvotes ironically makes the anti-AI crowd look like the ones doing the botting, and it only serves to reinforce the belief that anyone who is anti-AI is willfully ignorant and pathologically unreasonable.

This is not an effective place to market a game. It's also not an effective place to litigate the future of generative AI and the building of data centers. We are people designing games here. Take it easy.

Your time is always better spent playtesting than arguing online.


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 3h ago

Mechanics I designed a tactical abstract using 42 physically identical cards to eliminate "marked cards" — curious how other abstract players feel about the "attack vs. draw" trade-off

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/tabletopgamedesign • • 15h ago

Totally Lost Where can I study the fundamentals behind tabletop RPG systems?

5 Upvotes

I've been wanting to learn more about what goes into designing tabletop RPG systems, especially things like probability, game balance, character progression, resource management and creating mechanics.

I'd like to understand how designers come up with rules from scratch, how they test whether a mechanic works, how they prevent abilities from being overpowered, and how all these different mechanics fit together within a system.

I'm not really sure where to start. Are there any books, courses, websites or specific subjects you'd recommend studying? I'm interested in both the mathematical side of things and the design process behind building a system.

Thanks!


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 1d ago

Artist For Hire [FOR HIRE] TTRPG Characters and Illustrations. 3 slots open. DM me to discuss details and get started!

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

r/tabletopgamedesign • • 11h ago

Announcement Campaign Updates! Free Gift Previews: Cards and Campaign Guide!

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/tabletopgamedesign • • 1d ago

Announcement Paper games by me✌️✌️

Post image
24 Upvotes

Hello, I'm Awi and I'm new to this stuff. It's a simple game with simple mechanics and gameplay.

The top left one, cursed night, is a social deduction game about villagers trying to figure out who's the werewolf among themselves.

On the right, rookie adventurer on a mission, is a solo game where you slain all evils with heroes that you hired throughout the game.

The last one, case zero, is a moderator led deduction game where you as detective investigating a death.Honestly, it's incomplete because I don't really know how to make murder mystery game.Also,I have an exam this week.

That's all from me.👋


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 15h ago

Artist For Hire [For Hire] Fantasy Artist. Character Design & Ilustration

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/tabletopgamedesign • • 1d ago

Publishing Pitching a family or party game? Three publishers with different submission criteria

5 Upvotes

I’m working on MeepleScout, a publisher research tool for board game designers. Here are three open calls whose requirements helped me see why “family or party” is too broad a filter on its own:

• AMIGO looks for short family and children’s games, especially card games, up to 45 minutes. Its guidelines exclude party games and games that only play with two.

• Very Special Games looks for family and party games that are easy to teach in about five minutes. It rules out voting party games and designs that lean heavily on drawing or performance.

• Kistler Games is interested in card and party games that people of different ages or abilities can play together. Its guidelines ask for a rules draft and repeated playtests beyond close friends and family.

I checked the publisher guidance on November 21. I’ve collected the official links and what to prepare at https://meeplescout.com/find-publishers.

If you’re currently pitching, did this give you a publisher worth looking into? What one detail would help you decide?


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 23h ago

C. C. / Feedback Thoughts on Drunquest's new death mechanic? Looking for player & designer feedback

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

It has been a few weeks since the release of Drunquest Vol. 2, along with the updated rules and the new death mechanic, and I would love to hear some feedback from those of you who have played it!

For those who are not familiar with Drunquest, it is a tiny solo zine adventure where you play as an always-thirsty bounty hunter equipped with a talking sword. Your goal is to slay as many adversaries as possible and gather as much fortune as your shallow pouch allows. The game is available for FREE here:https://wireddragonstudio.itch.io/drunquest

Looking at it now, the current death mechanic feels a bit too mechanical and clunky to me. Have any of you died (in the game, obviously) during your runs? How often did it happen, and what are your thoughts on the death mechanic? Does it feel overly complicated?

Allow me to share some of my design dilemmas:

To motivate players to actually try saving some coins—rather than spending them all in the pubs—I added a score system. All the coins you have left at the end of a volume convert into your score. With that said, let's get to what I consider the biggest issue in the game: death.

Because of a considerable amount of randomness (let's be honest), the game can sometimes be really challenging. You often rely on a lucky die roll—which is part of the game and, I believe, one of the main "fun factors." However, sometimes you hit a truly miserable streak of rolls where you just cannot strike your adversary and your Health drops lower with every miss. If that misfortune follows you long enough, you end up with zero Health Points—or, in game terms, dead.

So, what happens next?

Starting all over from Volume 1 upon every death would most likely discourage many players from continuing. Allowing players to restart their current adventure on the first page of the current zine feels like a better design choice.

But what if the player started the new volume with stats or items on their Player Sheet that differ from the initial setup? Should they simply Recover—resetting their stats to their starting positions and discarding any previously obtained items—and take a fixed score penalty? Right now, that sounds reasonable to me. No extra zine lengthily explaining what to do upon death, which completely kills the flow of the game.

That brings up the next question: how many times should players be allowed to die? Infinitely, losing score with every death until they slowly near zero? Or should there be a hard limit—perhaps three deaths, after which the adventure is over for good? A limit might push players to genuinely try surviving the adventure, rather than brainlessly restarting the volume every time they die.

What do you think? What are your thoughts on this mechanic, or on Drunquest in general?

Thank you for your time, and I look forward to your feedback.


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 1d ago

Mechanics Im making my own Murder mystery game. Are these character cards easy to understand? Any feedback?

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

any constructive feedback is feedback


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 1d ago

Artist For Hire [my art] Skulls

4 Upvotes

r/tabletopgamedesign • • 2d ago

Announcement The joy of collecting one mini at a time

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/tabletopgamedesign • • 1d ago

Discussion hey i wanted to pitch my game idea to the publishers but the game is in prototype and i haven't playtested the game. i don't have the people around me to test. should i pitch the game idea? i think its pretty good

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/tabletopgamedesign • • 2d ago

Publishing First-time board game publisher: Manufacturing in China – Shipping, customs, warehousing and fulfillment costs in Europe?

10 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm an independent board game publisher based in Italy, currently preparing to launch my first board game on Kickstarter.

I've received a manufacturing quote from a Chinese board game manufacturer, but I'm trying to understand the real total cost of importing, storing and distributing the finished product in Europe.

Here are some details about my project:

  • Initial production run: Approximately 1,000 copies
  • Box dimensions: 42 × 31 × 5 cm
  • Manufacturing location: China
  • Destination: Europe (Italy)
  • Sales channels: Kickstarter, direct online sales, board game conventions and potentially retail stores

I'd really appreciate advice from publishers who have already gone through this process.

1. Shipping and Import Costs

  • What additional costs should I expect beyond the manufacturer's quotation?
  • How much should I budget for sea freight, customs duties, import VAT, customs clearance, port handling and inland transportation?
  • Would you recommend FOB, CIF or DDP shipping terms for a first-time publisher?
  • Are there any hidden costs or unexpected fees I should be aware of?
  • How do you calculate the actual landed cost per game?

2. Warehousing and Storage

  • Once the games arrive in Europe, what is the best solution for storing the inventory?
  • Are there fulfillment companies that offer both warehousing and order processing?
  • What are the typical monthly storage costs for approximately 1,000 board games?
  • Do fulfillment providers usually charge per pallet, per cubic meter or per individual unit?

3. Fulfillment and Distribution

  • Can anyone recommend reliable European fulfillment partners specializing in board games and Kickstarter campaigns?
  • Would it be better to use a fulfillment center in Germany, Poland or Italy?
  • How do you handle shipping to Kickstarter backers across Europe, the UK, the US and other international destinations?
  • What are the typical pick-and-pack fees and shipping costs per game?
  • Are there fulfillment companies that can also handle VAT-related logistics and international shipments?

4. Single Fulfillment Hub vs. Split Inventory

This is one of my biggest questions.

Since I plan to sell the game through Kickstarter, my own website and board game conventions such as SPIEL Essen, I'm trying to determine the best inventory strategy.

Would you recommend shipping all 1,000 copies to a single European fulfillment hub, or splitting the inventory between a fulfillment center and a local warehouse for conventions, retail sales and direct orders?

For example, would it make sense to:

  • Store most copies at a European fulfillment center for Kickstarter deliveries.
  • Keep a smaller quantity in Italy for conventions, demonstrations and direct sales.
  • Replenish either location depending on demand.

Or would splitting inventory create unnecessary transportation, handling and storage costs?

5. Lessons Learned

If you've manufactured a board game in China and imported it into Europe, I'd love to hear about your experience.

  • What unexpected expenses did you encounter?
  • What would you do differently on your first production run?
  • Are there any freight forwarders, customs brokers or fulfillment partners you would recommend?
  • What percentage of the manufacturing cost should I roughly budget for logistics and fulfillment?

My goal is to calculate a realistic total cost per game, from the factory in China to the customer's doorstep, before finalizing my Kickstarter pricing and shipping strategy.

Any real-world examples, cost breakdowns or recommendations would be extremely helpful.

Thanks in advance for sharing your experience!


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 2d ago

Artist For Hire [For Hire] Open for DnD Character commission, creature, mechanics, etc.

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

I’m open for commision, you can order via VGEN too


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 2d ago

Discussion Lucky Guest guest artwork - Which is your fave?

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

For a recent prototype convention, I pushed myself to make art for all the guests of my drafting game, Lucky Guest! These are the "flat" versions - next to no shading - and some may yet get their artwork revised, but the personal deadline was satisfying to meet.
Here are my personal, prototype print sheets for those cards. Which guest is your favourite?


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 2d ago

Artist For Hire [For Hire] 2D Fantasy & TTRPG Character Artist — I’ll bring your D&D, Pathfinder, or OC designs to life! (PCs, NPCs & Party Art) | DM to inquire

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hi! I’m Jesi a 2D fantasy and character artist specializing in D&D, Pathfinder, and original characters (OCs)—from character portraits and playable designs to full party illustrations.

Limited Offer: I'm giving 15% off to my first 5 clients! (5/5 slots available)

What I draw:

  • Player Characters (PCs), NPCs & villains
  • Full adventuring party scenes
  • Custom character designs & fantasy concepts

r/tabletopgamedesign • • 3d ago

Publishing [PAID] Artist for "Sunbearer"

15 Upvotes

I am looking for an experienced tabletop game artist that does not use AI and can work in a particular style consistently for the entire product. You MUST be familiar with issues regarding preparing for print including but not limited to bleed, margin, DPI, CMYK color profiles, the effect of material finishing on color, etc.

Position is a paid contract position that would require a part-time commitment over the next year. Rate is dependent on artist experience and capability. I'd be interested in running a trial before committing to the full project.

The game I'm working on is tentatively called "Sunbearer." It is a 2-player, asymmetric, abstract duel, similar to Hive or Chess. One player (Sun) is trying to restore the sun to the sky, and the other (Moon) is trying to destroy the sun before they can do so.

Mood board: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1J4QBFby2inz1htk5pmEpXiOMRbKo-Kvb?usp=drive_link As you can see, we are leaning toward something between wayang kulit and shadow boxes. I like the stark contrast, line detail, and serious tone of the Indonesian shadow puppets in the mood board, but with the depth of the shadow boxes (and without their 'romantic' look). I think I would like something unique that sits between those. It doesn't necessarily need be Indonesian, since the myth we are creating is non-specific.

The first pieces needed would be the backs of tarot-sized move reference cards.


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 2d ago

Totally Lost D20 rolls for suppression based upon deviation roll on landing of a 105mm HE shell.

2 Upvotes

Looking for some ideas on writing the rules for a simple suppression based system on where the round lands based on the d20 Deviation table i am currently using.

https://docs.google.com/document/u/0/d/1PSMN9M4_CdgVg8CisHaiePOjx6J_x0OW/mobilebasic?pli=1

Thats my idea but its a quite hard aspect to write a rule for.

Any help would be appreciated


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 3d ago

Mechanics Making a print-and-play TCG to teach kids how to play. Help wanted.

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

Looking for any help on this idea


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 2d ago

Mechanics Are you interested in this open world, procedural, classic fantasy game?

2 Upvotes

For those who enjoy Magic Realm, Dungeon, procedural world generation, emergent gameplay, open worlds, adventure driven hack and slash, XP level grinding, and iterative character upgrading/specialization, my upcoming game, called Realmdeck, might be for you.

I made dozens of tabletop games as a kid. This is a culmination of around 13 years of on and off effort and revision dedicated to realizing one singular game: My conception of the perfect classic fantasy tabletop game which does not require a DM. 

Each game, players explore a brand new world and delve into brand new locations which are all created randomly through the exploration process in real time. Move your character around the world map, visit cities to trade, recruit allies, and gain quests, visit grand castles, fortresses and towers, delve into ruins, crypts, tombs, caverns, and more in order to gain loot and fight monsters. But be aware of your own player level: though it may be tempting to try to sneak into a high level room for some high level loot, the powerful monsters there might put an end to your character. It may be wise to level up your character beforehand.

The primary mode of gameplay is battle royale. Players explore independently to gather powerful items and magic in order to hunt down and kill the other players in the world. The last standing player wins. Rather than discarding a character after a game, players may choose to keep their stats written down to use the character during the next game together. Co-op, solo, and campaign modes are also easy to set up with this game.

Some core game mechanics:

  1. Procedural generation: In Realmdeck, the world map is generated by procedurally laying biome hex tiles down. The locations are randomly discovered and then generated by procedurally laying square room/street/wilderness tiles down. The objects and creatures/NPCs found in the room/street/wilderness are procedurally randomized, and the items/gear/magic/weapons/loot and other details of the objects, creatures, and NPCs are procedurally randomized as well. This system is carried out by drawing small cards from various decks.
  2. Emergent gameplay: There is no written campaign or progression, all gameplay is meant to emerge from the basic processes of the game world. The game provides a teeming open world simulation full of ways that players and components can interact, from which the story naturally emerges.
  3. Infinite leveling: The entire game hierarchy of power is a function of what level any given room/area is, compared to the level of the player and their gear. Higher level rooms have higher level loot, magic, and weapons, but also higher level foes. Both the player and the world have no cap on level magnitude, so the player can infinitely level up and find infinitely higher and higher level gear, but also infinitely higher level foes. Much of the game involves taking risks based on this level system. For example: I am level 10, and want to raid the level 18 wizard tower. Though it will be tough, I have a level 16 sword and armor, so should I take the risk?
  4. Inventory management: One big part of the game for players is managing inventory. The inventory is limited to strictly 8 items, with some exceptions for wearing apparel or having a backpack. Because of this, players are unable to build the classic skyrim-esque jack of all trades with every item in the game. Players are forced to make decisions to drop items, and to curate an inventory of items which all work off of each other well, as a pseudo-deckbuilding mechanic.
  5. Unique battle: Battle mechanics are the toughest to create. I wanted to avoid the intense complexity of multiple steps and boring “waiting around” during battle which is more indicative of D&D, but I also did not want to make battle completely abstract and intangible. I wanted to preserve the amount of strategy that could be found in a good combat game. I made a unique battle system which still allows for some movement mechanics, has an extremely simple turn system, and a very high stakes, immediately fun dice roll competition system. In playtests, battle is actually……fun?! Never thought  I’d see the day.
  6. Keep your character!: One of the most fun aspects of the game is the fact that you should keep your character sheet across multiple games. Each game then acts as an opportunity to level up and get better gear, and a way to compete with friends on who has the coolest character/loot. You can also steal your friends' newly gotten loot if you defeat them. It is fun to keep multiple characters, each meant to embody a separate build/fantasy class.
  7. Expansions: The base game is meant to be relatively simple, so anyone can play. However, there are many expansions that I have already formatted. Skill trees, advanced magic, alchemy, smithing, seafaring, survival mode, and vast wilderness are among them.

Would you be interested in following the development of Realmdeck? Any mechanics questions/ideas?


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 3d ago

Discussion Need ideas for the "Hearts" suit in my Slay the Spire-inspired 54-card game system

3 Upvotes

Need ideas for the "Hearts" suit in my Slay the Spire-inspired 54-card game

I’m currently designing a solo/dungeon-crawler card game system using a standard 54-card deck, heavily inspired by Slay the Spire. The main goal is to survive and defeat the boss stage.

Right now, I'm working on the core mechanics for each suit. Here is how it works so far:

• Every card acts as a unique item, and its number represents its power.

• You can hold a maximum of 6 items in your hand at a time.

• Every item starts with 4 Durability.

• Players can dodge enemy attacks, but they are forced to spend 1 Durability from any item every turn.

Here is my current suit breakdown:

• Spades & Diamonds: Attacking weapons.

• Clubs: Shields / blocking items.

• Hearts: ???

The Problem:

Originally, I designed Hearts to be healing potions. However, during playtesting, they felt like a total waste—and with a strict 6-card hand limit, holding onto them hurts even more. Because players can dodge, I rarely needed to heal. Meanwhile, my attacking weapons burn out way too fast because they get used constantly (shields are in an okay spot).

Since healing feels redundant and clogs up the hand, what else could Hearts represent? My current idea is making Hearts repair kits (restoring durability) or enchantments/buffs to boost other weapons.

What do you guys think? Would repair/enchantment fit better, or do you have other ideas that would make Hearts worth taking up one of those 6 precious hand slots?

EDIT: Thank you everyone for all the suggestions and feedback! Talking through these ideas really helped me lock in a direction that fits the game's core loop without adding extra rule bloat. I'll likely share the complete rulebook in my next update so the whole system is easier to see—time to jump back into playtesting!


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 3d ago

C. C. / Feedback Eve-Online Tabletop

Post image
9 Upvotes

Good morning/afternoon/evening,

For the last few months, I have been trying to replicate a game I have loved for years into a ship based tabletop game. I always loved Battlefleet Gothic, and I love Eve-Online, so why not try and put the two together? I want to throw in a quick note, the aim of this is to be a wargame - not a board game (War for New Eden).

This is the first time I have ever tried to design a game, so be nice haha seriously, I'd love some feedback on mechanics, the document...anything is welcome. I'd love to get even a couple of people say "this is cool" and give it a play test.

For those familiar with Eve, I'd love to hear your thoughts on missing 'key' elements of the game. I wonder, am I trying to make it too simple? I was trying to reduce admin over head (folks who've played legions imperialis). But Capacitor is something I really struggled with not including. I'd love to hear folks opinions on simplicity vs capture the essence of an IP when playing a game like this.

Thank you all for your time.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1mleyakXpsrgEMMY5AG3Q5TTQHzhGUW07/view?usp=sharing


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 3d ago

C. C. / Feedback Wargame playtest

Post image
6 Upvotes

Hi Everyone,

I put together this game as a campaign for tabletop wargames, and it's grown into something that could be a standalone game. It's my first time putting something like this together and I could use some extra eyes on it, so I'm offering up all the digital resources for anyone willing to playtest and offer feedback. I playtested an earlier version a little while ago with friends, and we all enjoyed it, but agreed it needs work.

If anyone is keen to playtest and give feedback please send me a pm and I'll send you the resources!


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 3d ago

Artist For Hire [FOR HIRE] Concept Artist & Illustrator | INFO in the comments!

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes