r/technology • u/Hrmbee • Oct 14 '26
Software The Tragedy of AI Coding | AI-assisted software development could have liberated programmers. Instead, it has become the latest way for Big Tech to confine us
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/10/ai-programming-big-tech-regulations/688960/
501
Upvotes
108
u/Hrmbee Oct 14 '26 •
Some notable parts of this programmer's perspective:
For those working at a high level, whether with coding or anything else, having a working knowledge of the lower level nuts and bolts is still critical if one is to be effective at it. With the current LLM tools at our disposal, it allows people to work at that high level, but without the knowledge of how the underlying systems might be working. This might be adequate for the most simplistic systems, but as complexity grows so does the need to understand how, exactly, everything works (or not) together.
93
u/nosayso Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26 •
I'd say I'm fairly credible here, I have a good tech job, leaning in hard to AI, I do Spec Driven Development and everything and I have to say: I'm really not convinced it's going to work like Big Tech thinks it will.
It certainly doesn't now. You can produce code that's just accurate enough to be dangerous, maybe your seniors will catch edge cases, maybe they won't, but either way you're losing the entire learning process that goes along with writing new code. Trying an approach, seeing what works and doesn't, actually learning for yourself how to do this work. The more you use LLMs the more you lose critical context on your code. You can produce stuff that works pretty well faster, but you're also accepting a quality and maintainability risk to do that.
Short term we see some ruinous staffing decisions being made before the benefits are really proven. We're also seeing huge upticks in bugs. When I look at a "beacon" like Spotify I see 150 ongoing issues right now - https://community.spotify.com/forum/en/categories/ongoing-issues - doesn't seem like AI solves your problems.
Even as someone trying to do my best to comply with what's being asked of me, expectations on AI are currently unrealistic and big corporations are moving on it very prematurely and taking on a lot of risk. I think a year from now we'll look back and see this was a mistake, just like we look back a year ago from today and scoff at the idea that AI was magical tool that meant you could fire all your seniors and only have juniors write code (an idea that failed in a major way at Amazon). The "prompt engineers" who insisted AI could write all of your code last year on much worse models by just saying "you are a genius and make no mistakes" in your prompt just look like total fucking clowns now, when a year ago people were impressed and nodding along because execs were so excited to cut staffing costs.
LLMs are really cool and do some things really really well, but this idea that they can replace programmers without sacrificing quality is a pipe dream right now, and long-term it seems like a mistake to outsource actual knowledge of your applications to a 3rd party non-deterministic person emulator.
44
u/invyros Oct 14 '26
Bring back Web 1.0, where if we wanted to spread our shitty opinions, it took a little effort to create and host a website (or at least required money, a real investment).
Either that or you tried to get visibility in mailing lists or Usenet, neither of which were centralized like the forums and social networks of today.
55
u/mvw2 Oct 14 '26
It's a bit weirder, no wait, selfish, yes selfish.
So AI is a very good support tool for developers. It has good function and performance. And it's efficient and usable when utilized by skilled programmers.
It however does not replace people. It doesn't displace lower level work. It doesn't displace skilled work. It is a hammer to a carpenter. That's it.
The problem is we have a pretty bad economy. The problem is we have businesses, CEOs, shareholders, and stock prices that rely on the illusion of continued success. The selfish part is this is largely just a massive pile of layoffs to deal with project and sales problems, and AI is the cover story everyone wants to use as the reason the layoffs happen.
This is an economy problem, and AI is the narrative to narrate future growth and success, not real growth and success, just the illusion, the anticipation, and we are quite effectively futures trading on everything right now. We're futures trading on a bad market and massive debts across everything at massive scale. It is rather quite insane, but everyone just kind of decided to play the same game because it seemed to work for the first fella.
19
u/VVrayth Oct 14 '26
It's the tragedy of AI everything, it's being used to optimize the creativity and ingenuity and human touch out of everything, so we can spend our "jobs" trying to puzzle out what the AI has done wrong, or toiling in the mines. That doesn't sound like a rewarding and skillful career, it sounds like hell.
4
u/cowcowkee Oct 15 '26
I think AI is heading toward the wrong direction. Instead of trying to take away jobs that human is capable of doing, it should tackle problems that are too difficult for human to solve.
2
u/RadioactiveTwix Oct 15 '26
In my company the problem is we get $200 worth of tokens a month and expected to be as productive as people with $2000. I don't mind writing SQL by hand (smash that caps lock baby!) but it takes a lot longer than pointing AI to the tables, telling it do xyz and reviewing the output.
Instead of just asking my AI questions, I still google things like syntax, or error codes. I don't have a problem with this but I do have a problem with how the expectations scaled up.
3
u/PersonalityMiddle864 Oct 14 '26
If software is indeed cheap, then big tech is about to get a lot of competition no?
3
u/MrShrek69 Oct 14 '26
We use llms every day. Same things still apply to our SDLC process even before these systems existed. If u can’t answer a question about ur pr then did u really do work?
1
u/_dirtybrown_ Oct 15 '26
http://archive.today/MzCSO
1
u/Aubrey_D_Graham Oct 15 '26
I vibe code and Ive destroyed my wokspace more than once. Ive also ebuilt it to be moe resilient everytime.
1
u/headspreader Oct 15 '26
I think everyone dealing in abstractions might tend to view whatever lowest abstraction layer they functionally deal with as ‘substrate’. I think that this shift in AI coding is going to drive security and verification into the hardware layer.
1
u/understated_quokka Oct 15 '26
Nobody with half a brain ever thought AI would "liberate" programmers. This idea is just the same people buying the same fabricated schlock over and over again, helpfully deepthroating the capitalists every time. The people who believed this probably believed social media would "liberate" humanity, too.
1
u/random-malachi Oct 15 '26
We all thought it was a jungle gym but it’s just a laundry basket over our heads…
1
u/doubleyewdee Oct 19 '26
I think this is a well written treatise that is using AI to frame a longer running, social problem that has little to do with AI itself, which is that we have sold some of our agency with the things we ostensibly buy and “own” to large corporations for the “gift” of lower prices and the promise of simplicity.
I don’t have a philosophical argument for or against how our society is navigating this, beyond noting that given the number of people who seem deeply displeased, perhaps we have not balanced appropriately and should tread very lightly in further efforts to lock down our devices and experiences.
1
u/cadet-pirx Oct 19 '26
I’d argue AI does liberate builders. The article names YouTube among the Web 2.0 platforms that took back the web’s openness, yet with AI one person can now build a better YouTube, faster than ever before. That alone shifts power toward individuals.
Whether that product can compete is a separate question, and the answer depends. Against YouTube, almost certainly not. But ArtCraft, a free, open-source suite of Adobe alternatives built largely with AI, has a much better chance.
-18
u/TFenrir Oct 14 '26
I think people should try to imagine what AI coding will look like a year from now. It helps when you have multiple experience based data points, and many people have now been working with agents for 6+ months - enough to get at least a couple.
I think people still vastly underestimate where the ceiling of software development is, and in a year it will look arcane compared to today. I expect the entire loop to be automated, with minimal high level guidance here or there. I expect the amount of commits (I think we will not be using git as it is a year from now) will be up to 2 OOM greater than they are today. I think images and video will likely be viable, entirely coded in JavaScript and Python (or maybe some new ideal for the task language an agent writes up - which I don't think is crazy in a year). I think you will get entire video games at the scale of some AAA games, with similar visual quality - and from my most recent experience, taste and game design is improving with the latest and greatest - I expect more of that.
But I think in a year we will start to see in the horizon a completely different world of software. Everything transient, almost instantaneous, driven by our personal AI agents. All media code, and thus programmable/modifyable at exquisite detail, while being orders of magnitude cheaper - as models are able to use techniques humans could not to generate assets that can be much more compressed. I can share some early examples if people are curious.
In general, I really think it's hard for people to imagine just how weird it will get. Does anyone think what I'm saying sounds completely crazy anymore? Maybe some of you - but how many of you would have thought this was crazy a little while ago and suddenly aren't sure? I encourage all of you to turn that into curiousity. I think something truly epoch defining is happening right in front of our eyes. It will be increasingly hard to deny.
0
u/SignedInt32 Oct 16 '26
I cant write my opinion, they wont tolerate me being happy. ;)
0
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment