r/technology • • Oct 14 '26

Software The Tragedy of AI Coding | AI-assisted software development could have liberated programmers. Instead, it has become the latest way for Big Tech to confine us

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/10/ai-programming-big-tech-regulations/688960/
501 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

108

u/Hrmbee Oct 14 '26 • Bravo

Some notable parts of this programmer's perspective:

In the 1980s and 1990s, ordinary people’s ability to construct their own software ebbed and flowed. Hypercard users made databases, cookbooks, and games on their Macs; gray-cubicle office workers used Visual Basic to build Windows programs to automate tasks, often for themselves alone. The World Wide Web let ordinary people publish websites for the whole world, rather than just themselves, their friends, or their office mates.

By the mid-2000s, the Web 2.0 economy had begun to roll back the web’s openness, shepherding people into using platforms such as Blogger, YouTube, and Facebook. The priesthood was back, and the wealthy tech giants served as its bishops.

AI programming does not challenge that power. It entrenches it.

...

Computer scientists sometimes talk about “high level” and “low level” programming. Low-level programming involves a lot of very small-scale, specific instructions; high-level programming abstracts that effort into simpler methods that are easier and more accessible. Low-level programming is sometimes considered more technical and therefore more righteous, but high-level coding is often understood to produce faster results. The latter value has prevailed, and over the years and decades, software development has moved to higher levels of abstraction because doing so streamlines output. Low-level work is used only when necessary—and often just to build tools or infrastructure to facilitate high-level programming.

Vibe coding continues this tendency. Coding has always involved a repeated process of giving a computer instructions for an intended outcome or experience, making the machine run them, and then revising the instructions based on the result. At first, those instructions were immensely basic: Move a number or perform a mathematical operation. Over time, the instructions became more complex and abstracted: Write a file to disk, draw a circle, plot a location on a map. Under the hood, computer programs often generate and run code at a lower level as a part of their work. AI programming does not disrupt that process at all. It extends the effort.

This makes the aesthetics of vibe coding entirely familiar to programmers. The moment-to-moment experience of coding feels the same, but you do so at a greater remove. Realizing this made me understand why programmer types might find generative AI so immediately compelling, and also why they might not grasp the objections of people in other walks of life who oppose it. Using AI to create prose or illustrations seems to erase the experience of the writer or artist and their participation in the act of creation. It clobbers the process in favor of the outcome. But for a programmer, the outcome and the process improve all at once. Nothing about AI programming feels like a compromise or cheat. It just feels like programming.

...

Reflecting on my vibe-coding journey, I now realize that I began the effort insufficiently aware of what I should have known to be true: that software had already mostly been captured by the high-tech industry long before AI-coding tools arrived, and that those tools were doomed to worsen as much as improve the situation. I fell into the ever-enlarging chasm between the small-scale, personal-software fantasy and its scaled-up, big-business reality. Even the AI services I use to write software change so frequently that the methods I used last week to make something might change next week when Claude or ChatGPT updates. The whole structure feels erected on a sheet of ice.

For those working at a high level, whether with coding or anything else, having a working knowledge of the lower level nuts and bolts is still critical if one is to be effective at it. With the current LLM tools at our disposal, it allows people to work at that high level, but without the knowledge of how the underlying systems might be working. This might be adequate for the most simplistic systems, but as complexity grows so does the need to understand how, exactly, everything works (or not) together.

232

u/monkeymad2 Oct 14 '26

I couldn’t disagree more with “the moment-to-moment experience of coding feels the same”, it feels like someone else is doing all the fun parts for you & then you’re left struggling to work out what they’ve done.

179

u/krileon Oct 14 '26

It's 24/7 code review. It's exhausting.

41

u/QuickQuirk Oct 14 '26

My CEO is insisting that's the attitude that is slowing us down. We should trust the LLM more. It's great now. His CEO buddies told him, and look at his vibe coded app!

23

u/manachar Oct 14 '26

I just want off this ride.

54

u/hbprof Oct 14 '26

As a writing professor, that's exactly how I feel about AI writing.

9

u/PhaseLopsided938 Oct 14 '26

Genuine question, are there any "real" writers you know of who use AI in their writing process? I do a lot of writing and programming, and while I feel that LLMs have gotten so good at coding that I can't imagine debugging without one, their writing quality seems to have plateaued at the okay-but-not-great level a year or two ago. Even the "better" writing models still can't get rid of that low-perplexity stink.

8

u/hbprof Oct 14 '26

Not that I know of, but that doesn't mean there aren't. But I agree that the quality of worrying is just OK. And I don't think it'll ever improve as long as the systems keep being designed on the same flawed theories of cognition and literacy that they currently are. Just throwing more compute at them isn't going to solve that problem.

-2

u/anarchyx34 Oct 15 '26

I think it’s just because most of the focus is on coding and academic style writing. Some models do write well though. Mistral Nemo 12b writes surprisingly good, nuanced prose which makes it a favorite for the roleplaying crowd. It’s also a fairly dumb model with a small context window but the bitch can write.

7

u/NightSpaghetti Oct 15 '26

It feels like cleaning up after a party you weren't invited to.

20

u/robby_arctor Oct 14 '26

That's because this person is an academic and not actually a professional programmer. (But is nonetheless opining on what AI means for programming)

2

u/leanman82 Oct 21 '26

OH MY GOD!!! THAT'S IT!!!! ITS LIKE THE DUMBAZZ ENGINEER YOU HATE CAUSE THEY DON'T SHUTUP BUT THEY SPIT OUT CODE FASTER THAN YOU CAN SPEAK (in this case AI does this literally) AND YOU HAVE TO KEEP REDIRECTING IT UNTIL IT GETS IT!! ITS SO BORING!!!

1

u/YoghiThorn Oct 15 '26

Debugging has never, ever been the fun part.

1

u/Suitable-Name Oct 16 '26

We're definitely very different persons😄

-12

u/Thefuzy Oct 14 '26

Don’t know any devs who feel like this, only hear this take on Reddit.

Real devs opinion is it removed all the cumbersome parts of implementing all the syntax of a solution, we still think through the problem and how to implement a solution, an AI just does the implementation, and it does so in a very logical clean way. It’s not hard to read, and you don’t even need to read most of it anyways, you can verify the outputs and see that it works as expected.

Coming up with a solution to apply technology to a problem is the fun part, not writing syntax. We still do that, nothing was lost just as nothing was lost moving from writing machine code to modern OOP.

8

u/littletray26 Oct 14 '26

My experience has been that all the old dudes / senior devs that are a few years off retirement, own their homes, kids already moved out etc love it. It makes their life and job easier.

All the younger devs that still have 30-40 years of their career in front of them, own nothing, have bills to pay etc are the ones feeling the overwhelming dread about what's to come, and their sudden lack of job security.

4

u/biyopunk Oct 15 '26

Exactly this, one of colleagues was already retired after 30 years of career but was working for fun. He’s safe and secure in his life already. AI is just a salt to his remaining life, a thing to enjoy a new excitement. Of course he’s one of the most ardent advocates of AI, he’s vibe coding his cochlear implant to use it in zoom meetings. He won’t be here in 2050 while we’re suffering under AI age capitalism

1

u/Vegetable-Ad-7184 Oct 17 '26

Is that a critique of AI, or corporate America  ?

12

u/ryuzaki49 Oct 14 '26

 It’s not hard to read, and you don’t even need to read most of it anyways, you can verify the outputs and see that it works as expected.

Then they ask you about a specific change in a line, and your only option is to rely on an LLM to give them the answer.

I really hate your comparison with moving from machine code to OOP. It's not the same. At all. 

Writing OOP code never felt like hiring someone to write machine code. It feels that way with LLMs

12

u/Forward_Problem_8982 Oct 14 '26

I like solving problems by writing code, going step by step, observing the results and continuing accordingly. If a machine writes the code, you still have to understand it and validate it, or you're just trusting a black box.

You'll run into weird unexpected bugs that would never happen if you crafted the code yourself, had a mental model of the solution, and actually understood what happens.

You can create a lot of code fast with a machine, but if quality is actually important, I would not vibe code the product.

-9

u/Thefuzy Oct 14 '26

So why aren’t you writing binary? I’m sure you understand how your code is converted to the various layers of lower level language. Or are you just trusting a “black box”.

I’ve never seen an LLM write code I don’t understand, because I understand code and the languages I use. I don’t have to write it to understand it or ensure its quality.

4

u/SwitchShift Oct 14 '26

The reason they’re only here is because they know management has drunk the Kool-Aid and their careers currently depend on saying nothing bad about AI. Reddit offers anonymity. Saying this slop is easy to read is laughable, instead you just click approve on thousands of lines of code.

What I find is that things that used to take a hundred lines of code and a day now take a week and a thousand lines of code, because everyone has AI creating huge parallel implementations of what should be common tasks, but the code is so bespoke that there is no generalization. And because each piece redoes the work of the others, no one is quite sure which piece is actually being used and what specifically it does. Regressions are introduced and buried in a multi-thousand line PR and are only discovered months later (if we’re lucky) and are only solved until someone pushes through a new parallel implementation that forgets to avoid the problem.

But hey, my PR and Lines of Code metrics are shooting through the roof

6

u/nekronics Oct 14 '26

Not saying I agree or disagree with you, but saying “real devs” is so fucking stupid. Different people will enjoy or dislike different parts of the job.

2

u/rollingSleepyPanda Oct 14 '26

How does one get to be a real dev? Does one go to real dev school and get a real dev medal? Build a SaaS in COBOL? I'm curious.

0

u/crash41301 Oct 14 '26

Depends on the programmer. To some people syntax is the fun part.   For those that think the outcome is the fun part and syntax was a means to an end, its very exciting times.   Agree you need the ability to understand the syntax, especially in crucial parts of the software.  Still, the outcomes you can make with this multiplier are huge If you enjoyed that part. 

1

u/tommyk1210 Oct 18 '26

This is the real answer. Some people love the physical act of solving the problem, the debugging and coding.

Others enjoy the output and the wider macro scale architecture and the debugging and coding was always “in the way”.

The latter love AI because it unlocks a lot of velocity without requiring them to be in the weeds. The former are in a state they hate.

The big issue is what happens when those in the latter camp are pushing software so fast they’ve completely lost touch with how it works…

-2

u/newDell Oct 14 '26

Totally agree. I think in reality you choose your own adventure with AI assisted coding. You can just let Claude entirely take the wheel, or talk through the logic and problem solve as a team (my favorite), or play architect and just dictate to the AI exactly what you want it to implement. One of my devs insists on writing all code himself and just uses Claude to review

43

u/ActiveCollection Oct 14 '26

Do you know the quote “Coding is poetry”? Writing software was fun. Vibe coding is like being a boss of a developer. You may review some parts of the code (still don’t understand the whole), but more or less you accept the result and hope for quality. It is why so many developers never wanted to climb the ladder and lead other developers. Now they can either do that (with AI, for less money) or lose their jobs.

35

u/Electrical-Page-6479 Oct 14 '26

Exactly. If I'd wanted to be an architect then I'd be doing that. I like building things, learning new languages and new ways of working. AI "development" is to software development what building flatpack furniture is to carpentry.

11

u/DoshmanV2 Oct 15 '26

I disagree. As a software guy, assembling flatpack furniture is satisfying and therapeutic in the same way as building Lego. It's tactile, there are no unpleasant surprises if you follow the procedure, and you have a tangible end result. It's not intellectually stimulating, but it doesn't have to be in order to be enjoyable and relaxing. You can even combine it with some music or a radio program or podcast to occupy that part of your brain if it needs to be worked.

AI development is like getting flatpack furniture off of Kijiji or Craigslist and having to inspect it to figure out how the person who assembled it fucked it up to the point that it's wobbling

10

u/ramkitty Oct 14 '26

Great analogy

4

u/Cautious_Boat_999 Oct 14 '26

Yeah, I was an architect for a long time and just didn’t enjoy it. I wanted to be the builder. I don’t want to tell someone/something how to build it. I want to CREATE.

9

u/itsjusttooswaggy Oct 14 '26

I know the "power tools" analogy is overdone but to your point if you hand someone a nailgun who doesn't have the knowledge and experience to build a chair, they aren't going to be able to build a house.

2

u/_trouble_every_day_ Oct 15 '26

Yeah that’s a terrible analogy.

2

u/SimoneNonvelodico Oct 15 '26

I think part of what he bemoans is simply a function of software becoming bigger. It feels more impersonal and unfun because it can't be otherwise, a single person couldn't write enough code to build most modern large applications and frameworks in useful time. Now with AI coding the optimal size of codebase you can get away with balloons up again and soon most software will literally be too large and complex for human minds to understand. It's inevitable with the economics we have because there's no real penalty for software size or complexity other than maintainability, and so we make it as big as we can get away with.

(some small software exists, of course, for things that need nothing else. But it's not very profitable and will only grow to be less so because now a single wish to Claude can conjure an entire small app in a few minutes)

2

u/redAI123 Oct 16 '26

Yeah, its essentially become a "black box" where we know the code work through output result but we don't know why. And when company keeps pushing for code to release faster, a human may overlook these code and then nobody knows how its work anymore.

6

u/Scheeseman99 Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26

For those working at a high level, whether with coding or anything else, having a working knowledge of the lower level nuts and bolts is still critical if one is to be effective at it.

See, but, no it isn't. There's plenty of software engineers, frankly most of them, who would find it difficult to parse byte code, but still have a grasp of code design and architecture. Software development has been using abstractions forever and for decades there's been entire classes of developers who specialize only in those abstractions.

I'm not sure how what you quoted supports your argument, if anything his words convey the opposite of what you're saying. The issue he has isn't with the abstraction, but the market capture by the AI companies and rapid iteration (and some enshittification) of the tooling. He isn't arguing against AI development, or even vibe coding.

I disagree that the problem of it handing over and centralizing power to inherent to the tech giants is inhrent to the technology, though. He gives an example of an app he made called Taptimer, then talks about being limited by what he could do by Apple, the platform holder. Would have he had the same issue on an Android phone? One running a custom OS? Probably not. Apple's locked down platform has existed for decades, it's nothing new, which isn't to say it isn't a problem, but I don't see how it's AI coding's problem.

He follows that with criticism of the growing strengths of the new models and harnesses at planning, at doing end-to-end work. This is optional and the result is generally worse, but it also came with other improvements like a sharp increase in code and documentation quality and a drop in mistakes made. You can still be as hands-on as you want.

But overall, he's positive about it as a technology and fearful of centralized control of it.

14

u/FatHat Oct 14 '26 • Bravo

I think the current state of software disproves your thesis. Things are extremely bloated and slow in a way that's completely unnecessary. Most apps shouldn't require gigabytes of memory and an entire browser built in. I think a lot of people making software right now don't even realize how much faster and more capable there machine is compared to what they write. As a profession, we've completely failed in this regard. The low level details matter still, but we've pushed the problem onto end users by forcing them to buy expensive machines to make up for, basically, our laziness.

3

u/Scheeseman99 Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

My thesis? I'm correcting an incorrect interpretation of the article, not making a statement about the quality of software in the industry.

Also, people tend to have the wrong idea about browsers and RAM usage. They cache aggressively which gives the appearance of bloat, but that RAM use is transient, it gives it up to anything else that needs it. That you can have about a hundred tabs open with video, audio and image data sitting in memory (both real and virtual) and have the application not break a sweat is an engineering miracle.

0

u/AthiestCowboy Oct 14 '26

Exactly. Vibe coding is simply another abstraction layer. For those who want to code “for the love of the game” and even go to low level assembly optimization there is nothing stopping them.

In fact one could argue it could give them more of an opportunity to do the things they enjoy while having AI do the grunt work - which I imagine is what a lot of actual engineers are doing.

1

u/mediandude Oct 14 '26

With the current LLM tools at our disposal, it allows people to work at that high level, but without the knowledge of how the underlying systems might be working.

You mean development based on analysis models, not necessarily on design models.
Analysis Model driven development.

But is the analysis model actually properly defined and updated as a model? Where is AI supported round trip engineering with proper analysis model version control?

-1

u/MrClavicus Oct 14 '26

Claude, please summarize this

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/_zoso_ Oct 14 '26

Do you make sure you tell it’s an experienced software lead before you begin?

Jokes aside, it really depends on where you deploy it and in how big or small of an increment. It’s very useful for rough prototyping for example. I find it’s less bad if you restrain it, add a small component, verify it thoroughly before moving on. Or just use it for other things that are annoying and time wasting. Dry boilerplate, finding some bug, interpreting an explain plan, analyzing trace data, or just describing existing code in various useful ways.

It is what you make of it really.

93

u/nosayso Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26 • Bravo Heartwarming Mindblown

I'd say I'm fairly credible here, I have a good tech job, leaning in hard to AI, I do Spec Driven Development and everything and I have to say: I'm really not convinced it's going to work like Big Tech thinks it will.

It certainly doesn't now. You can produce code that's just accurate enough to be dangerous, maybe your seniors will catch edge cases, maybe they won't, but either way you're losing the entire learning process that goes along with writing new code. Trying an approach, seeing what works and doesn't, actually learning for yourself how to do this work. The more you use LLMs the more you lose critical context on your code. You can produce stuff that works pretty well faster, but you're also accepting a quality and maintainability risk to do that.

Short term we see some ruinous staffing decisions being made before the benefits are really proven. We're also seeing huge upticks in bugs. When I look at a "beacon" like Spotify I see 150 ongoing issues right now - https://community.spotify.com/forum/en/categories/ongoing-issues - doesn't seem like AI solves your problems.

Even as someone trying to do my best to comply with what's being asked of me, expectations on AI are currently unrealistic and big corporations are moving on it very prematurely and taking on a lot of risk. I think a year from now we'll look back and see this was a mistake, just like we look back a year ago from today and scoff at the idea that AI was magical tool that meant you could fire all your seniors and only have juniors write code (an idea that failed in a major way at Amazon). The "prompt engineers" who insisted AI could write all of your code last year on much worse models by just saying "you are a genius and make no mistakes" in your prompt just look like total fucking clowns now, when a year ago people were impressed and nodding along because execs were so excited to cut staffing costs.

LLMs are really cool and do some things really really well, but this idea that they can replace programmers without sacrificing quality is a pipe dream right now, and long-term it seems like a mistake to outsource actual knowledge of your applications to a 3rd party non-deterministic person emulator.

25

u/MaintenanceSpecial88 Oct 14 '26

I’m seeing this in action. Recently joined a startup. Realized that my team was decimated about a year ago, I think because the founder tried to leverage AI. Now the code is a mess and the people who helped build it are gone. The job is not fun. There are constant bugs and leadership keeps telling me to use AI to solve them. I don’t think I’ll stay long. And if a few of us leave in a short window, the place falls apart. Or you know leadership can try to AI it themselves. L.O.L.

1

u/Bogus1989 Oct 19 '26

Yep. This is always funny, when management thinks they know better than IT folks, instead of listening to them. (Hopefully they are a united team).

Ugh just watched my org go thru the same, they let people go based on some metrics they wouldnt tell us, but we later found out anyways. Made total sense, cuz it seemed random as hell. What it did do is absolutely RUIN morale. Lots of SMEs being let go, as it seemed, at random. That backfired and a bunch were like, k bye thx.

16

u/mrbrucel33 Oct 14 '26

If I could reward this, I would

5

u/colony-ship-for-sale Oct 15 '26

There's always free awards you can give posts.

1

u/Bogus1989 Oct 19 '26

I gotchu ill do it

8

u/forgot_previous_acc Oct 15 '26

but this idea that they can replace programmers without sacrificing quality

Most of the management doesn't care about the quality tbh. I am kind of in a similar situation to yours, but my team mates are worst. Juniors have no intention of learning or understanding the claude generated output. Most of them stopped using ides be it sts, intellij or any other actual ide that is needed to test the changes locally. If you try to teach them something, they get offended and start arguing. All these AI tools gave everyone this false sense that they all are genius.

Technical seniors are creating more claude folders and md files in the name of skills and what not that I have legit some microservices that have more claude specific files than the actual code.

I am trying my best to manage but slowly realising that i should start acting based on my salary and just say f it.

I am tired.

7

u/CondiMesmer Oct 14 '26

Spec-kit? I personally thought it was a bad idea when I tried it. I think the best way to do AI is in smaller reviewable chunks. Too much at once is way too much coding review fatigue for me and I definitely stop paying as close of attention. I do find that it's useful to write a spec like document that states implementation intention though.

4

u/themanalyst Oct 15 '26

Vibe coding is not bad per se, but leadership has increased the pressure to do more with less people, and do it faster. We dont even have time to break down problems and document the changes properly. So, I sometimes don't fully know how the code works because there's barely any time to review. My work typical day is me testing vibe coded updates on the front end, have an agent running to write new/fix features, and an agent to create documentation so I can update jira/confluence. Just roll up dev/pm/qa/ux into one person.

Our leadership want results immediately because one time someone vibe code a solution in hours, so now that has become the norm. Or a VP used copilot to create a mockup or cursor to create a prototype and its a "simple lift and shift" to them...

1

u/Bogus1989 Oct 19 '26 edited Oct 19 '26

Yeah, no programmer here. More like sysadmin infrastructure engineer type. This was my prediction, and what ive seen too. I obviously dont drive the software development like you guys do, but obviously am involved in between and in my environment do what I can to help.

This was a pretty good article btw.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/SansSariph Oct 15 '26

It found three bugs in an internal tool that had been deployed for a few years? Was anyone encountering these bugs? Did they matter?

Edit - I'm an engineer who uses these tools every day, and agentic code review is consistently useful - but this kind of dialogue is exactly what makes me raise an eyebrow. Comparing Astra's architecture to something some guy built likely as a prototype years ago and then it became useful enough to be adopted by the team just doesn't say very much.

1

u/YoghiThorn Oct 15 '26

You're skeptical that an internal tool had bugs? Really?

We are doing these processes at my job and we're finding and fixing decades old bugs in software that runs critical infrastructure.

Reddit has this weird AI derangement and honestly some of the skepticism is just stupid at this point.

1

u/NylonRiot Oct 17 '26

The point they’re making is that, if these bugs were around for years and no one noticed them before now, they aren’t significant. It sounds like you’ve been running a decades long scream test and nobody was screaming.

AI can catch plenty of minor bugs but that doesn’t mean what’s it’s doing is actually valuable. Bug detection matters because of how of how the issues impact the value and usability of the product, not because it finds the highest number of barely meaningful flaws.

44

u/invyros Oct 14 '26

The World Wide Web let ordinary people publish websites for the whole world, rather than just themselves, their friends, or their office mates.

By the mid-2000s, the Web 2.0 economy had begun to roll back the web’s openness, shepherding people into using platforms such as Blogger, YouTube, and Facebook. The priesthood was back, and the wealthy tech giants served as its bishops.

Bring back Web 1.0, where if we wanted to spread our shitty opinions, it took a little effort to create and host a website (or at least required money, a real investment).

Either that or you tried to get visibility in mailing lists or Usenet, neither of which were centralized like the forums and social networks of today.

26

u/wayoverpaid Oct 14 '26

Seriously. I know I'm here on reddit but I miss when there were more than like six sites. I don't want YouTube, I want video podcasts with a torrent stream to make the server load easier. I don't want Discord, I want IRC version 2. I want people self hosting their own shit.

The centralization of everything is antithetical to the internet at large.

Maybe one day local models will be good enough that developers will rely on that. But who knows.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26

people are bringing back web 1. it's called the indie web.

2

u/LowestKey Oct 15 '26

Forums of today?

Where?!

1

u/Ecstatic-Network-917 Oct 20 '26

There are still quite a lot of forums still around. Spacebattles, Sufficient Velocity and AltHistory are the three I use.

1

u/TheVenetianMask Oct 19 '26

Blogger and Facebook were such a blight.

Before that you needed a lot of word of mouth about your content to get an audience, at most you may have been getting extra attention by being in the right web rings, SEO was a thing already but a lot more fair and crude (people would put some keywords in the page headers and think they were hackermans 3000). The modicum of technical competence needed to set up a blog was a filter too for quality.

Then these came around offering a zero setup cookie cutter free place for content that could potentially be shown to a wider audience. In practice it was just shuffling and muddying the space, bringing in boatloads of filler and attention merchants, in the case of Facebook putting it in silos difficult to find from outside, so you never really saw good content anymore. And that was by design, the longer you had to look around the more ads you would view.

55

u/mvw2 Oct 14 '26

It's a bit weirder, no wait, selfish, yes selfish.

So AI is a very good support tool for developers. It has good function and performance. And it's efficient and usable when utilized by skilled programmers.

It however does not replace people. It doesn't displace lower level work. It doesn't displace skilled work. It is a hammer to a carpenter. That's it.

The problem is we have a pretty bad economy. The problem is we have businesses, CEOs, shareholders, and stock prices that rely on the illusion of continued success. The selfish part is this is largely just a massive pile of layoffs to deal with project and sales problems, and AI is the cover story everyone wants to use as the reason the layoffs happen.

This is an economy problem, and AI is the narrative to narrate future growth and success, not real growth and success, just the illusion, the anticipation, and we are quite effectively futures trading on everything right now. We're futures trading on a bad market and massive debts across everything at massive scale. It is rather quite insane, but everyone just kind of decided to play the same game because it seemed to work for the first fella.

9

u/tobi914 Oct 15 '26

As much as id like to support your view, from a pure efficiency standpoint, if you offered me either a junior developer or 2 or one of the top ai model subscription, i would take the ai model.

Theyre just better, less errror prone, more precise, faster, dont need to learn specific concepts first for some time, and stick exactly to your instructions if they are clear and well laid out.

When were talking about the future of a company, id go for the juniors, because at some point, they need to be able to carry on.

But very bluntly put, an ai agent tops a junior very very easily. And since the junior and the ai agent both work off of my instructions, its not like the junior would add any convenience for me as the senior whos responsible for delivering stuff towards a deadline. (If anything, they add work for me for quite some time until they become somewhat independent in doing their tasks)

When im not invested in a company and my only concern is to get my tasks done and be as efficient as can be, i dont need no junior anymore to take some simple tasks off my hands

13

u/funkywimhd Oct 15 '26

If that's your experience working with juniors your company is either hiring shit profiles or you should do some self reflection on your guidance capabilities as a senior.

3

u/Ray192 Oct 16 '26

At this point, most of the juniors are just feeding the exact same instructions you give them to AI.

4

u/tobi914 Oct 15 '26

Nope, im just being realistic, knowing that this opinion will not go well with many.

Thats why im saying efficiency wise, im not saying its the better plan for a good future for the company.

Juniors need training amd guidance, as you know since you think im not capable of that. But providing guidance means im not doing anything that brings me closer to my deadlines so in that context it is inefficient and will not lead to me being done sooner, it will lead to me being done later if anything.

Sure, in the future the junior will not be a junior amymore and will provide a net value to the company, but that takes time.

Juniors are an investment im the companies future, but when i need to improve output right now, they just cant do that in the same way as ai can.

-10

u/funkywimhd Oct 15 '26

A decent junior, with decent guidance, will out code an LLM within his first 3 months tops.

3

u/tobi914 Oct 15 '26

After about a year of looking into ai capabilities and adapting it in many workflows, im sorry to say, but no, they will not.

Depends on what you mean with "outcode", even that is likely not true. Do you mean writing the code? Planning out new features or solutions?

In pure "writing code" capabilities, ai outcodes every human, junior, senior or anything in between. The planning and proper guidance of the llm is where the software development skills of the person come into play, as well as for reviewing and bughunting.

But in terms of speed? Im sorry, but just no

1

u/maxim360 Oct 15 '26

You gotta understand that discussing this stuff on reddit is like discussing the power loom with hand weavers. 

Like it sucks and sure it’s not 100% there yet some of the finer stitchers the power loom can’t do, but it will get there. 

2

u/favorite_stuff Oct 17 '26

How much more expensive would the models have to get for this to change?

1

u/FlyHamster Oct 15 '26

I disagree that ai to programmer is like a hammer to a carpenter, it's not even a toolbox, tools won't do work FOR you, they will help YOU do the work

You can't rent tools for 20$ a month and expect them to build you a shed, while you sit in the shade and explain to them what kind of shed you want, you need people with knowledge on how to use those tools

The end goal of LLMs is to displace human workforce, to automate skilled workers out of the economy

Can LLMs replace ALL developers? Right now - no, for serious work they need oversight, this doesn't matter, good experienced dev with ai can do a work of 10 people without, this is 9 jobs company can cut to save money, and many will, some already did

Agree with you about everything else you wrote

35

u/Helkafen1 Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

We're still waiting for evidence of this 10x productivity claim. So far, controlled studies show a slight increase, or a slight loss of productivity.

People often mistake activity and value. LLMs generate a lot of activity. Lots of code, lots of PRs, walls of text, quick prototypes and tools.

The generated value is not that impressive. Also, it de-skills your engineers, and that's a risky bet.

To give you an example: LLMs were used at my company to generate ~50k lines of code recently. Experimenting on a few features showed that LLMs created about 5 times more code than hand-made. And did we actually need all this new code? Nope! With proper project management, this code would have been made into libraries and reused instead of created anew.

5

u/FlyHamster Oct 15 '26

Agree, unfortunately some managers and CEOs view activity as productivity and they are people who make decisions about employment, in some cases they even start vibecoding themselves

Genuinely glad to hear, that your company is being cautious with LLMs, but some other people's stories paint a different picture

Friend of a friend of mine is in a webdev and their company kept everyone for now, yes, but projects that took 30 days or so now being done in days with no real space for creative work, they also ask almost 10 times less to stay competitive, how long until this isn't sustainable, how long untill someone automates the whole thing GOOD ENOUGH and starts asking $300? Who knows.

Guess time will tell, right now things look bleak to me tbh

-4

u/LifeIsARollerCoaster Oct 15 '26

If you are waiting for evidence then it came and went. A year ago it was ok, now it’s fairly good, in another year it will be outstanding.

The capabilities are growing exponentially so it’s very clear where it’s going.

Why maintain old code when you can just spin up entirely new functionality with a few prompts.

It looks terrible from an architectural perspective now. But that is just another thing that they will resolve. Eventually it will first analyze any existing libraries for closer integration

-9

u/Nearby-Echo-1102 Oct 15 '26

I’m like 20x more productive. It’s existing processes that is slowing productivity down - human testing, pull requests/reviews, release processes and so forth. If you still require humans in the loop for things AI can do then this is why you are not productive. I’m still shocked at how developers ain’t using AI to its full potential.

The rapid pace of how far it’s come in the last year is insane. Peoples memories are short or their living in a denial bubble.

9

u/Helkafen1 Oct 15 '26

Sure, and we're all impressed by the quality and abundance of software over the last couple of years. /s

-3

u/Nearby-Echo-1102 Oct 15 '26

Code for software doesn’t need to be perfect, it just needs to work at the scale required. Too many devs get caught up in the art of crafting the most readable and reusable code possible.

Now that AI will likely take more and more of that responsibility it will become less important. AI doesn’t need perfect abstractions, re-usability, perfect naming conventions and etc.

I know this is hard to hear. I’m not happy about it, my lively hood is disappearing before my eyes. I have no clue what I’m going to do next and provide for my family. I refuse to live in denial however.

9

u/DM_ME_UR_BOOTYPICS Oct 15 '26

God forbid we actually test software on humans who are the ones who will actually be using said software. I mean fuck it why bother asking people what they even want and how they use it? Just build solutions and find problems!

A factory making a billion useless widgets that nobody wants to buy is a time and money sink. Congrats on making shit nobody wants and nobody enjoys, think of the productivity!

5

u/solidsieve Oct 15 '26

Before AI, if we had gotten rid of processes, QA, anything except me writing code, I would've also been 20x more productive. The stuff I built would also have been less stable and probably not what the customer actually wanted.

Were the processes and teams bloated? Absolutely, we could have cut 2/3rds of the team and probably increased velocity (we were actually almost there for a few months, until management decided to "help"). But if we had removed all people and processes, then we wouldn't have had an application.

2

u/Saittama Oct 15 '26

I think you’re both right. Their premise (as i read it) is that they are implying that the business workflow is not allowing engineers to engineer and that the ai slop is a result of that.

Saying claude is replacing engineering is basically claiming a jackhammer can replace a demolition crew. Sure lay it on the sidewalk and turn it on and it will be “demolished”.

1

u/SpecialistOwl218 Oct 16 '26

I’m always so fascinated by the people that knows the “end-goals” of a.new technology, developer by multiple concurring company nonetheless.

19

u/VVrayth Oct 14 '26

It's the tragedy of AI everything, it's being used to optimize the creativity and ingenuity and human touch out of everything, so we can spend our "jobs" trying to puzzle out what the AI has done wrong, or toiling in the mines. That doesn't sound like a rewarding and skillful career, it sounds like hell.

4

u/cowcowkee Oct 15 '26

I think AI is heading toward the wrong direction. Instead of trying to take away jobs that human is capable of doing, it should tackle problems that are too difficult for human to solve.

2

u/RadioactiveTwix Oct 15 '26

In my company the problem is we get $200 worth of tokens a month and expected to be as productive as people with $2000. I don't mind writing SQL by hand (smash that caps lock baby!) but it takes a lot longer than pointing AI to the tables, telling it do xyz and reviewing the output.

Instead of just asking my AI questions, I still google things like syntax, or error codes. I don't have a problem with this but I do have a problem with how the expectations scaled up.

3

u/PersonalityMiddle864 Oct 14 '26

If software is indeed cheap, then big tech is about to get a lot of competition no?

-8

u/MilaKunisWatermelon Oct 14 '26

The biggest risk to that theory is the attitude of the average Redditor. Because they are anti-AI in everything, they don’t give an individual entrepreneur using AI a chance, while they still continue spending money with established companies who pivot to AI while laying people off.

2

u/Hayden2332 Oct 14 '26

The average redditor isn’t your average consumer, and your average consumer cares about price more than anything. I guarantee you it’s not the attitude of redditors that’s causing “entrepreneurs” to fail

3

u/MrShrek69 Oct 14 '26

We use llms every day. Same things still apply to our SDLC process even before these systems existed. If u can’t answer a question about ur pr then did u really do work?

1

u/Aubrey_D_Graham Oct 15 '26

I vibe code and Ive destroyed my wokspace more than once. Ive also ebuilt it to be moe resilient everytime.

1

u/AlwaysShittyKnsasCty Oct 15 '26

Your “wokspace” doesn’t seem to have access to the letter “r.” How is that more resilient?

1

u/Aubrey_D_Graham Oct 15 '26

My r key on my phone is broken. Thats hilarious.

1

u/headspreader Oct 15 '26

I think everyone dealing in abstractions might tend to view whatever lowest abstraction layer they functionally deal with as ‘substrate’.   I think that this shift in AI coding is going to drive security and verification into the hardware layer. 

1

u/understated_quokka Oct 15 '26

Nobody with half a brain ever thought AI would "liberate" programmers. This idea is just the same people buying the same fabricated schlock over and over again, helpfully deepthroating the capitalists every time. The people who believed this probably believed social media would "liberate" humanity, too.

1

u/random-malachi Oct 15 '26

We all thought it was a jungle gym but it’s just a laundry basket over our heads…

1

u/doubleyewdee Oct 19 '26

I think this is a well written treatise that is using AI to frame a longer running, social problem that has little to do with AI itself, which is that we have sold some of our agency with the things we ostensibly buy and “own” to large corporations for the “gift” of lower prices and the promise of simplicity.

I don’t have a philosophical argument for or against how our society is navigating this, beyond noting that given the number of people who seem deeply displeased, perhaps we have not balanced appropriately and should tread very lightly in further efforts to lock down our devices and experiences.

1

u/cadet-pirx Oct 19 '26

I’d argue AI does liberate builders. The article names YouTube among the Web 2.0 platforms that took back the web’s openness, yet with AI one person can now build a better YouTube, faster than ever before. That alone shifts power toward individuals.

Whether that product can compete is a separate question, and the answer depends. Against YouTube, almost certainly not. But ArtCraft, a free, open-source suite of Adobe alternatives built largely with AI, has a much better chance.

-18

u/TFenrir Oct 14 '26

I think people should try to imagine what AI coding will look like a year from now. It helps when you have multiple experience based data points, and many people have now been working with agents for 6+ months - enough to get at least a couple.

I think people still vastly underestimate where the ceiling of software development is, and in a year it will look arcane compared to today. I expect the entire loop to be automated, with minimal high level guidance here or there. I expect the amount of commits (I think we will not be using git as it is a year from now) will be up to 2 OOM greater than they are today. I think images and video will likely be viable, entirely coded in JavaScript and Python (or maybe some new ideal for the task language an agent writes up - which I don't think is crazy in a year). I think you will get entire video games at the scale of some AAA games, with similar visual quality - and from my most recent experience, taste and game design is improving with the latest and greatest - I expect more of that.

But I think in a year we will start to see in the horizon a completely different world of software. Everything transient, almost instantaneous, driven by our personal AI agents. All media code, and thus programmable/modifyable at exquisite detail, while being orders of magnitude cheaper - as models are able to use techniques humans could not to generate assets that can be much more compressed. I can share some early examples if people are curious.

In general, I really think it's hard for people to imagine just how weird it will get. Does anyone think what I'm saying sounds completely crazy anymore? Maybe some of you - but how many of you would have thought this was crazy a little while ago and suddenly aren't sure? I encourage all of you to turn that into curiousity. I think something truly epoch defining is happening right in front of our eyes. It will be increasingly hard to deny.

-9

u/hoffsta Oct 14 '26

I’m a layman. I was completely shocked at how easily I could build software that actually works very well with just a handful of prompts. I’ve already replaced a few apps I’d been unsatisfied with for years, with something 10x better for my needs. And it was all done in a couple of hours with extremely minimal revisions.

With this pace of advancement, I can’t imagine anyone will be paying for any software other than AI tokens in the near future.

-5

u/TFenrir Oct 14 '26

Yeah I think the moats will be like... Legal, financial, stuff like that. There will still be some walls around those kinds of digital products, but everything else will just be... There when we need it.

5

u/Helkafen1 Oct 15 '26

Please keep LLMs away from legal and financial services. They requires actual expertise, and mistakes are pricey.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-9

u/TFenrir Oct 14 '26

I think people really don't like to think the future in describing comes true. Packaged in comes a lot of other truths - for example, the idea that we will have less AI in our lives over time, will die. It's an important idea for a lot of people. Anything that challenges that idea is a really hard fucking sell, and I get it.

I'm not trying to sell something that you can choose to not buy though, I'm trying to really get people to see what's coming whether we like it or not, as early as possible. The sooner we all are seeing it clearly, the better I think.

That being said, people are a lot less hostile with me than they were a year ago. I think it's hard to deny what is happening in front of all of us.

-7

u/hoffsta Oct 14 '26

Looks like everyone who has anything positive to say about AI coding is just getting blanket downvoted. I understand the sentiment. It’s going to put most of us out of work, (not just software devs, but like almost all office workers, creatives, etc).

It’s such a double-edged sword. And then you’ve got Musk claiming there will be universal income and everyone can just kick back and enjoy all the free work being done on our behalf, as if they would ever share their wealth. Unreal.

12

u/Olangotang Oct 14 '26

No, it's that the same hype bros have said the same thing over and over for years and everyone knows they are full of shit when they see their username. TFenrir is deep in psychosis.

-4

u/TFenrir Oct 14 '26

What is it, explicitly, of what I've said that you disagree with?

0

u/SignedInt32 Oct 16 '26

I cant write my opinion, they wont tolerate me being happy. ;)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/WhiskyFalcon Oct 15 '26

How does your own branded OS help you feel chill?