r/technology • • 11d ago

Software Linus Torvalds says that AI fixes drove most of the progress in latest Linux kernel — BPF saw more AI-written fixes than bug reports, possibly indicating a tidal shift for open-source maintainers tired of flood of junk reports

https://www.tomshardware.com/software/linux/linus-torvalds-says-that-ai-fixes-drove-most-of-the-progress-in-latest-linux-kernel-bpf-saw-more-ai-written-fixes-than-bug-reports-possibly-indicating-a-tidal-shift-for-open-source-maintainers-tired-of-flood-of-junk-reports
659 Upvotes

238 comments sorted by

83

u/sammybeta 11d ago

We need a torvards classifier for PR review

43

u/Logical_Welder3467 11d ago

Linus review skill for download

12

u/house_monkey 11d ago

now with 2x curse words

215

u/aging_like_fine_NFTs 11d ago edited 11d ago

Fucking hate these "Linus says" posts that don't leave what he actually said, how fucking hard is it??


Ok, a big -rc2 to go with the largest ever -rc1. But the diffstat looks fairly benign, and is dominated by some automated coccinelle updates that I got for the merge window but left for rc2 because I didn't want to deal with them when I was on the road (and had a hard time finding the motivation to deal with them afterwards too, to be honest).

That said, the scripted updates are largely just one- and two-liners, and they realy are very straightforward so they "dominate" the diffstat only in the sense that they are very spread out and do add a lot of noise.

When masking that noise out from the diffstat, the shape of it changes - not spread out over thousands of files any more. But it does not look unusual: a third is drivers (gpu, networking and sound account for most of it, but there's a bit of everything), another third is networking and bpf, and the final third is "the rest" (mostly filesystems, mm, arch updates).

And yes, much of this was driven by various AI fixes. I think I'll stop repeating that, and we can just take it for granted. But this time around Alexei claims that on the bpf side at least the fixes are now coming in faster than the new reports, and that sounds lovely if true.

I think most other areas haven't reached that point yet, but it's at least a sign that we may be starting to see the tide starting to turn.

Don't hold your breath, but maybe cross your fingers we'll be getting there in the not entirely distant future.

In the meantime, please keep testing,

Linus

12

u/williampaul0404 11d ago

This does not fit in a Reddit post title

5

u/Wilbis 10d ago

Nor does it fit into the brains of the average reader.

-45

u/abednego-gomes 11d ago

If it's mostly driven by AI fixes, who is carefully reviewing the slop? Human eyes are on each commit, right? Right?

39

u/scumbagdetector29 11d ago

Yeah. No one checks commits to Linux. You are a genius.

18

u/floralfrog 11d ago

This AI == slop mentality is just so ponderous by now. It’s not 2024 anymore and you clearly have not been paying attention to anything that happened since then. And if you believe the Linux kernel, the biggest open source project ever, pushes one shot make no mistake prompts to the entire planet then I don’t even know where to start.

-1

u/mcl_syndicate 11d ago

Totally agree with this. They are just telling on themselves by using the dated-ass term “ai slop”. Adapt or die guys, guys. All you’re doing is holding yourselves back and making it easy to respond to anything you say on the topic with…

“Okay boomer”

1

u/menzaskaja 10d ago

AI is not always slop, but it can be. i.e. vibe coded applications by people who have no idea how to design software.

1

u/BCProgramming 10d ago

And if you believe the Linux kernel, the biggest open source project ever, pushes one shot make no mistake prompts to the entire planet then I don’t even know where to start.

I think this is a bit cart before the horse, isn't it? I mean, they are asking what sort of code review process is in place and your response is to basically argue that it must be reviewed because it's Linux. That doesn't make any sense.

It actually contradicts facts as well. Of the 15,649 commits for Linux 7.1, only about half of them were reviewed by humans before being merged. Only 8% were actually tested.

This is because volunteers and reviewers are dropping out of the entire process. People who have been reviewing kernel patches for years have started to remove themselves from maintainer lists, and the reasons they cite are too many AI-driven contributions wasting their time.

If only half of those PRs were reviewed by humans before merging and only 8% were actually tested by humans, than the chance that the Linux Kernel is pushing "one shot make no mistake prompts to the entire planet" is far from the impossibility you are presenting it as.

0

u/porkusdorkus 10d ago

A few severely overworked and under appreciated maintainers, who are sifting through way more bad updates than good ones. The slop cannon is at full force.

0

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

18

u/realboabab 11d ago

Isn't his "the tide turning" rhetoric referring to the rate of automatic AI-reported bugs vs. rate of AI bug fixes?

97

u/jphamlore 11d ago

So when's the rewrite for most of the kernel to be in Rust.

82

u/mok000 11d ago

There aren’t enough Rust programmers in the world and of those not enough volunteers to be able to maintain a project like Linux. There are a lot more C programmers and C is very well suited for the kind of low level programming required for the kernel.

132

u/oduska 11d ago

I think he was joking because of all the projects being rewritten in Rust by AI lately.

-17

u/mok000 11d ago

Oh I missed the joke. And by the way I just read that AI typically writes junk Rust code that circumvents the borrow mechanism, which is what gives Rust the memory safety in the first place.

16

u/oduska 11d ago

Do you have a link to that? I have a basic understanding of Rust and I'm curious why AI would do that.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/porkusdorkus 10d ago

From what I’ve seen, Rust vibe coded apps are usually just Webview/React web apps that would normally just be Node.JS or Python on the backend. It’s just a type safe back-end known for catching more run-time errors, but it really doesn’t matter if most your code lives in JavaScript.

2

u/dijalektikator 10d ago

Never had an LLM do that when writing Rust code. Sure its not always completely idiomatic in all respects but never had it do something this unnecessary

2

u/bgibbz084 11d ago

That’s abundantly false. My company is full of rust experts who use these tools daily to output high quality code.

Mag 7 tech…

9

u/BCProgramming 11d ago

There is that entire Adobe suite vibe-coded in Rust. The source seemed off to me when I looked through it- but I'm not exceedingly familiar with rust. To my unfamiliar review, it does seem to use unsafe frequently to dodge the borrow checker and it was using mutables a lot more than seems appropriate in idiomic rust.

Can't speak to whatever code your people make with AI, of course.

2

u/cryptospartan 10d ago

unsafe doesn't dodge the borrow checker. The borrow checker still runs within unsafe blocks.

The unsafe keyword only unlocks 5 specific capabilities that the compiler cannot automatically verify for safety:

  • Dereferencing raw pointers (*const T and *mut T)
  • Calling unsafe functions or methods (including FFI / C code)
  • Implementing unsafe traits
  • Mutating mutable statics
  • Accessing fields of a union

0

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Wonderful-Habit-139 10d ago

Nope it’s pretty hard. You’re forcing AI to do something that is against most of what’s in its weights.

0

u/mok000 11d ago

Thanks for this convincing piece of anecdotal evidence.

8

u/Smallpaul 11d ago

Really ironic that you are being upvoted for spewing completely unsourced nonsense and when someone says they have first hand experience of the thing you are reporting on, they get downvoted.

Where is your evidence that LLMs undermine the borrow checker?

7

u/bgibbz084 11d ago

Lmao what? You just made a completely false claim based on some bullshit you read in a random Reddit post (Reddit very much hates AI FYI). I work as senior engineer at a major tech company that is heavily involved in AI. I trust my own insights on this.

-7

u/mok000 11d ago

You are extrapolating your own company’s use of AI to be valid everywhere. That is not a serious way to argue. And your use of expletive filled language doesn’t make it any more convincing.

6

u/rinseaid 11d ago

Expletive filled lol wat

5

u/bgibbz084 11d ago

AI is like any other tool. You give it to a fool and it will put out fool results.

Should I evaluate a hammer based on how some weekend dad uses it or on how a framer uses it?

You clearly are not knowledgeable enough on this topic to have a meaningful opinion, which is why you are regurgitating some shit you found on Reddit.

1

u/cryptospartan 10d ago

A weekend dad uses a hammer better than this fool uses AI lmao

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Irythros 11d ago

You post "by the way I just read that AI typically writes junk Rust code" and then when asked for source go "oops sorry dont have it lol"

Then get pissed at another guy going "by the way we dont have that problem" with the same level of sourcing as you?

Clown behavior.

10

u/mfi12 11d ago

But AI write the code

6

u/josefx 11d ago

It would take five minutes of exposure to the kernel mailing list for the AI to have an emotional breakdown and either resign from programming for life or to start creating elaborate profiles for the core kernel maintainers and threaten a public witchhunt over a patch that received constructive and positive feedback.

2

u/metahivemind 11d ago

To be fair, the kernel mailing list is basically 4chan without the porn.

1

u/mfi12 11d ago

Look again to comment I replied to

0

u/turlockmike 11d ago

But there's enough AI compute and there will be significantly more next year. IMO, we are 6 months until someone rewrites linux in rust.

2

u/tiajuanat 11d ago

The Linux kernel is truly a massive codebase, with 43 Million lines of code and growing. I think 6 months is honestly premature, but 2 years feels feasible.

1

u/turlockmike 11d ago

Every time i make a 6 month prediction, it usually happens within 2-3 months instead. Will be fun to watch.

2

u/tiajuanat 11d ago

u/RemindMeBot 3 months

3

u/turlockmike 11d ago

u/RemindMeBot 30 days.

I have a feeling it will be a lot sooner. Fable 5.2 designed and deployed its own OS from scratch including drivers a file system etc. 

6

u/New-Anybody-6206 10d ago

I have this conspiracy theory that the rust rewrite movement isn't about memory safety, but relicensing of GPL software and the slow removal of GNU.

Ever notice how most rust projects are not copyleft? And some companies are slowly replacing battle-tested essential system apps with buggy rust versions.

3

u/mrheosuper 11d ago

Do the opensource thingy and fork it

2

u/KlausDieterFreddek 10d ago

"Hello ShatGBD, do this but in Rust"

-16

u/tapsaff 11d ago

rust is legacy now. its unreadable and solves problems that only bad C programmers have.

13

u/Teiktos 11d ago

Put the crack pipe down bro 

120

u/MairusuPawa 11d ago

In a way, no shit Sherlock. AI feeds on open (as "in the open") information and Linux (and related) project are exactly the data it will ingest, whether you want it or not.

It's a feedback loop, thanks to code stolen from hundreds of thousands contributors to opensource these last few decades. And these people will never get recognized for providing that work. Only Altman will be famous for exploiting these commons.

20

u/Dsphar 11d ago edited 10d ago

One of my webserver-hosting providers just told me today that AI will injest my own hosted code.

They are coming for you whether you open source or not...

Edit: Paid service. Render hosting.

10

u/QuickQuirk 11d ago

fucking horrifying. Is that for a paid service, or a free one?

If it's paid, I would tell them 'no thanks, I'm moving' - just to make sure they see a consequence to this anti-customer behaviour and think twice in the future.

7

u/cosmic-parsley 11d ago

I’d go further and suggest name and shame, so others can look out

1

u/QuickQuirk 10d ago

Even better.

3

u/Dsphar 10d ago

Paid. Render hosting

15

u/vahntitrio 11d ago

Same reason why I think it's ridiculous to expect the gains in coding to be matched in other sectors. There is tons and tons of open source code, but as you move into other areas a lot more things are proprietary so there are large voids of information.

0

u/edgmnt_net 11d ago

Proprietary code that tends to be steaming crap, much of the time. And they're using AI rather differently.

1

u/Wonderful-Habit-139 10d ago

Misses the point.

0

u/Unlucky_Topic7963 10d ago

If the structure and the libraries and the syntax are available, any code can easily be learned by an SA transformer. Coding languages have finite permutations and when outcomes are known it’s really easy to back into.

Engineers thinking they’re a special sunflower that knows super secret ways to code ain’t gonna cut it. Their job is to think bigger picture now, like constraints, NFRs, and system design.

62

u/FlyingFishManPrime 11d ago

I mean it's not like the people who contribute to open source projects get much recognition.  

10

u/will_dormer 11d ago

Still there is an honor to it

20

u/swagonflyyyy 11d ago

Yeah the point is to give back to the world for nothing in return. How could some people be so selfish to think otherwise about OSS?

9

u/Nikoladge 10d ago

I think there's a difference between doing work for the betterment of humanity and having that work get stolen by the Infinite plagiarism machine.

1

u/Officialedmart 9d ago

>infinite plagiarism machine

this is kinda nuts when you think about it… are you suggesting that “infinite monkeys on infinite typewriters” , or perhaps a real “library of babel”, if it existed would be stealing from everybody? as it contains everything that could possibly exist?

3

u/[deleted] 10d ago

You don't see the problem with someone making billions off charging for access to someone else's generosity?

1

u/AliceCode 8d ago

That's not all open source is about, otherwise we wouldn't have open source licenses with attribution clauses.

7

u/NMe84 11d ago edited 11d ago

That is a pretty unnuanced take. Agentic AI will not just write stuff, it will also analyze, test and identify errors. As we've seen this year with the crazy amounts of CVEs, AI is helping devs find and fix security issues and other problems, some of which had been in their respective software for over a decade.

I get it, most LLMs were trained on data they didn't pay for, or in an otherwise immoral way. But it's not as if the software it was trained on doesn't benefit from that AI existing.

Edit: getting downvoted for offering nuance. Gotta always just hate on AI, I guess!

16

u/azurensis 11d ago

This sub is the Reddit bubble personified. They're completely disconnected from the reality of the world we all live in now. AI is here and it's not going away.

3

u/Rometac 10d ago

Crime is here, we cant do anything about it, might as well use it to our benefit.

2

u/azurensis 10d ago

What crime? Why would you want to do anything about AI?

3

u/Rometac 10d ago

AI doesnt exist in its current state without mass criminal activity, its just the truth of our world, and just like crime its not going away, whats wrong, im just saying what your saying.

2

u/azurensis 10d ago

The only crime I'm aware of is Anthropic's illegal downloading of books that are a small part of their training data, for which they paid billions of dollars to settle with the authors.

Is there something else I'm not aware of?

1

u/AliceCode 8d ago

There are attribution clauses in many open source licenses. Also licenses that state that any projects that use the open source code must also be open source. But Anthropic doesn't care what the licenses say. It's theft.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Rometac 10d ago

All the image training data used was stolen in the say way, and theres likely a ton of stolen videos in there too, plus more we dont know about, its more than enough that the heads of anthropic should have gone to prison and the models deleted, I still believe all currently trained models should be deleted, if you wanna train LLMs thats fine, but you have to do it from free information or information you own.

1

u/azurensis 9d ago

All the image training data used was stolen in the say way,

It was? If you put an image up on your website, are you not explicitly giving anyone who visits that site permission to download it? That's exactly how websites work. If I legally download it and then use it for training, another legal activity, at which point is any copyright violated, let alone inexplicably stolen?

1

u/Rometac 8d ago

Although copying images you dont own off the internet is not legal, it is not prosecuted because noone really cares that wage slaves do it, distribution and commercial use of said image, like how AI uses the images to train so it can be used commercially, is however incredibly illegal, you are not allowed to distribute the image and use it in training, and I know what your next argument will be, its fine, AI learn like humans and we cant prove their alive or not, cool, if that's the case if AI can think and learn like humans. The owners and employees of every AI development company get to go to jail for slavery.

→ More replies

-2

u/Teiktos 11d ago

And it’s only getting better and better and better.

0

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/azurensis 10d ago

But why? 

3

u/TFenrir 11d ago

Beyond that, increasingly these models are becoming more capable not from reading human code, but from increasingly advanced environments for models to train on via RLVR.

This mechanism is why they are also starting to exceed human capabilities in math.

5

u/Teiktos 11d ago

At this point most AI code is better than most human code. Gotta admit it. And labs are were already synthesizing training data for multiple months now. People really don’t understand the current state of AI and how things work in the slightest.

1

u/AliceCode 8d ago

I take it that you're not a programmer, then. AI generated code is atrocious.

0

u/Teiktos 8d ago
  1. You seem to confuse aesthetics with quality
  2. I’m not a programmer, I am a software engineer.
  3. cope 

1

u/AliceCode 8d ago

No, I don't. Neither quality nor aesthetics is good. It's just mediocre code, and any software engineer that has any inkling of skill can tell you that. You thinking that it's good just goes to show that you're not skilled enough to see where it goes wrong.

-6

u/scumbagdetector29 11d ago

Immoral only if you view training as akin to "copying". Many people think "reading" is a more appropriate interpretation.

Interpretations aside - the important issue is how the courts see it. So far they have ruled that training is fair use.

8

u/NMe84 11d ago

Illegal and immoral are two different things.

-1

u/azurensis 11d ago

Sure, and in the case of AI, it's neither illegal nor immoral to train them.

4

u/NMe84 11d ago

It's not by definition immoral to train AI. But various publicly available models have indisputably been trained in an immoral manner anyway, with neither any notification of the fact that someone's content was used, nor permission or accreditation.

2

u/azurensis 11d ago

Do they need to be notified when someone reads one of their books?  For that matter, does anyone need their permission to read them? 

2

u/NMe84 11d ago

You're being obtuse. They're not just reading them. They're training an AI on it, which can then reproduce the content. Not word for word, but close enough that copyright comes into question, even if judges so far haven't ruled against the people doing this.

And it's not like they are just reading the information for fun. They're training AI on it with the goal of making money off of your creation. Without crediting you, or paying you for your contribution. That's simply not fair, no matter how you slice it, or try to liken it to reading a book.

I'm not even one of the people that is against LLMs, so I can't believe I have to argue with you about the one thing that a child can see is immoral about how pretty much all public LLMs have been trained.

1

u/azurensis 11d ago

LLMs cannot reproduce the content. Not more than a sentence or two at most. And there have already been two courts who have decided that training LLMs doesn't violate copyright because it's an exceptionally transformative function. There's nothing immoral about it at all.

→ More replies (1)

-3

u/scumbagdetector29 11d ago

Yes, of course they are.

In the case of morality, my interpretation carries more weight than the legal aspects.

Training is precisely the same as reading insofar as how the reader uses it.

0

u/space-envy 11d ago

Are you aware that humans usually need to purchase the material they want to read? And part of that money goes to the owner of such material so they can eat and survive?

Well, LLMs somehow have a "free pass" and judges have ruled that is totally legal for LLM providers to illegally download and destroy copyrighted material from the internet.

Yeah, now try to do that yourself and see how many years of jail that shit lands you.

I wonder if frontier LLMs would be as smart as they are if they had respect of the consent of the copyright owners...

1

u/scumbagdetector29 11d ago

None of what you just said is true.

In the few cases where books were not purchased, the companies have paid penalties.

But hey - factual reality has no relevance to this discussion, does it. AI SUX!!11!!1!!!!

1

u/space-envy 11d ago

None of what you just said is true. In the few cases where books were not purchased, the companies have paid penalties.

I would ask you to read but thats asking too much from a clanker, you may be already struggling just to breath oxygen, better take it easy buddy, you don't want to overload those two neurons.

Two other Northern California judges who have already weighed in on the closely watched issue have split on whether generative AI training generally makes ⁠fair use of copyrighted material, which would shield tech companies from liability for using millions of copyrighted works to train their systems without content owners' permission. Now-retired US District Judge William Alsup sided with Anthropic last year on its argument that its AI training made fair use of books. Two ⁠days later, US District Judge Vince Chhabria ruled for Meta in a similar lawsuit but warned that AI training “in many circumstances” would not be fair use. In the case being heard by Lee, music publishers UMG, Concord and ABKCO sued Anthropic in 2023, alleging its use ⁠of their lyrics to train Claude to respond to human prompts infringed their copyrights in hundreds of songs by artists including Beyonce, the Rolling Stones and the Beach Boys. Anthropic has argued that its AI training makes transformative use of song lyrics to "help Claude understand human language and enable progress and productivity in science, business and education."

2

u/scumbagdetector29 11d ago

Didn't you mean to call me a clanker-lover?

That wall of text doesn't refute anything I said above. Stop wasting my time with your bullshit. All it says is that two judges agreed with me and there's a case before a third judge.

Nitwit.

1

u/pellets 10d ago

The silver lining is that the commons also benefits from the LLMs.

1

u/AliceCode 8d ago

Only if you can fork up the money. They are trying to make programming pay to win.

0

u/Shukrat 10d ago

Can you steal opensource software? I thought that was the point, that anyone could fork it and modify it freely.

3

u/porkusdorkus 10d ago

Depends on licensing. Most is free to use and modify for personal usage, while acknowledging the original work is not your own and crediting the author.

Some have stricter guidelines. Some require you make public your entire source code if you use theirs. Some require monetary payment. Some only allow personal usage, not business.

Much of the world runs on the honor system with code, AI companies broke everyone’s trust.

1

u/Rometac 10d ago

Thats like asking if taking a free sample from a store was theft after you robbed the tills.

0

u/Serious_Bite_7613 8d ago

Big sad babies in this comments section. If they can't say AI is useless they need to complain about something. They can't accept a good thing.

0

u/thortgot 10d ago

How does one steal open source code?

2

u/AliceCode 8d ago

By not adhering to the terms of the license.

-1

u/thortgot 8d ago

If this is a loose reference to GPL, you can learn how a GPL solution works and then write your own inspired one. Exactly what LLMs do.

2

u/AliceCode 8d ago

LLMs copy code. They aren't inspired by it. They are next token predictors. They are glorified markov chain bots, and they can spit out licensed code verbatim if you tell them to.

→ More replies (3)

-27

u/TheThirdDuke 11d ago

Like all those Wikipedians who stole the work of historians and other academics to write articles so Jimmy Wales could get credit. If people like you had their way we’d still be living in caves, shitting in holes, and mostly dead by the age of 30.

23

u/Snauser 11d ago edited 11d ago

Wikipedians cite their sources, write their own summaries, and don't make a single dime from it. Tech billionaires have scraped people’s data without credit to train commercial, closed-source models for massive corporate profit. They are not the same.

Only talentless grifters who see AI as their ultimate savior because they can’t produce anything of value on their own would get this defensive.

7

u/negamuse 11d ago

It's an unpopular opinion which will get voted down because that magic AI is so gosh darned useful. But you're right.

3

u/TheThirdDuke 11d ago

I’ve written a lot of those open source programs that got scraped and more than a few Wikipedia articles (if you think every that every fact has a citation, despite what policy says, I would invite you to read a Wikipedia article. Modern LLMs do cite their sources quite extensively. Which source does it more consistently is up for debate) I’m glad to have contributed to the development of LLMs with my contributions and I know lots of people who feel the same.

While I acknowledge your personal expertise on the subject of talentless grifters I do not share your opinion.

15

u/MairusuPawa 11d ago

That's the most computer illiterate thing I've read today. Congrats.

-16

u/negamuse 11d ago

The GPL is dead, we're all getting public code ingested by the AIs fed back to us by the slop pipe and Linux is happy to go along wit it. GG, I guess.

10

u/ithinkitslupis 11d ago

What do we expect linux to do really? Leave tons of vulnerabilities that AI can help find and patch?

Because bad actors aren't going to stop using AI to surface them and exploit them.

-3

u/negamuse 11d ago edited 11d ago

What I expect them to do is not what I think they should do. The AI companies and the people pushing them into every available space are well funded and the same tools that give the bad actors things to exploit are just so gosh darn useful.

But it makes a mockery of the whole legal framework that the software licenses undergirding the industry have been built around. Things like the GPL were honed over decades to protect against human actors looking to get something for nothing. We barely even have humans in the loop any more.

Am I surprised Linux developers are using AI? No. I just don't like what that says about the industry and I'm glad to be out of it

Edit: And its hilarious that I'm getting downvoted rather than argued with. Hey ChatGPT write me a counterargument.

2

u/porkusdorkus 10d ago

Well it’s an end of an era. I’m glad you got out.

Nobody is going to open source anything new again, not unless it’s been vibe coded. Contributors are going to keep bombarding with low effort, maintainers will just say fuck it.

Frameworks, new languages, new ideas, there is no real motivation to create and share when your effort has no value and can be taken from you and monetized.

1

u/AliceCode 8d ago

I've stopped open sourcing my code, and I've also stopped contributing to open source projects. My code will still be stolen regardless, but I'm not giving to the world when they are just going to shit on my offering.

0

u/Vandius 6d ago

Ok, and coding is one of the most time consuming things on this planet with no promised return.

0

u/porkusdorkus 10d ago

“For the jobs who are about to die, we salute you”. -Linus

-27

u/silverbolt2000 11d ago

  thanks to code stolen from hundreds of thousands contributors to opensource these last few decades.

Yep! Just like how calculators stole calculations from mathematicians - right??

1

u/AliceCode 8d ago

Calculating things isn't all that mathematicians do. In fact, you can barely call calculating mathematics.

0

u/silverbolt2000 8d ago edited 8d ago

I can’t tell if you’re being deliberately obtuse.

Prior to calculators, you needed to spend a lot of time manually doing calculations and so mathematicians (or human “computers”) were called in for work that required regular moderately complex calculations.

Then calculators and computers came along.

Did calculators steal the calculations that humans provided?

Did mass unemployment ensue? Was it the end of civilisation?

Or did people adapt?

1

u/AliceCode 8d ago

Mathematics is not just calculating things. Calculating things is supplemental to math, but math is so much more than simply calculating things. Calculators took nothing from mathematicians because the job of a mathematician never was to calculate things, it was to prove or disprove theorems.

0

u/silverbolt2000 8d ago

OK.

And what’s your view on the point I was trying to make?

Do you believe that AI stole from people because it used information that was made freely available?

1

u/AliceCode 8d ago

If the information were truly "freely" available, then no, but the problem is that they used training data that they did not have the rights to. Open source code is not just code you can do whatever you want to. Every open source license has terms that you are legally obligated to follow in order to use that software. These terms can be more or less restrictive. Some licenses are totally public domain, and you can do whatever you want with the code with no special terms. This is the content that it is okay for LLMs to train on. There are also licenses that simply require attribution. Currently, there is no way to see if your licensed code was used as training data, which means that they are not adhering to attribution clauses. Some licenses even require that any projects that use their code must also be under the same open source license, such as the GPL license.

These licenses don't give people free reign to do whatever they want. Free and open source just means that you don't have to pay anything, and the source code is available, often even available for modification. It doesn't mean that you gain ownership of the code and can do whatever you want with it.

-1

u/Serious_Bite_7613 8d ago

Stolen open source code lmao.

2

u/MairusuPawa 8d ago

I am getting really tired of illiterate people who can't understand that yes, open source code can be stolen.

-2

u/Serious_Bite_7613 8d ago

I'm tired of people who think it can, so I guess we are both tired.

3

u/MairusuPawa 8d ago

You have no fucking clue what you're talking about.

1

u/AliceCode 8d ago

Do you know what a license is?

0

u/Serious_Bite_7613 8d ago

A little text file nobody reads?

→ More replies (8)

0

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/TribeWars 10d ago edited 10d ago

At least with copyleft it arguably violates user freedom, since the AI model itself is not open source. Before AI one could reasonably assume that publishing code under the GPL license would make it so other people who want to use that code would have to do it in a way that would carry the open source ethos forwards. There surely are some developers that may have invested their time and energy differently had they known that trillion dollar companies hoovering up all of the source code on the internet and laundering it through LLM model weights would count as fair use.

4

u/y-c-c 11d ago

It’s kind of a legal gray area.

In reverse engineering, clean room reverse engineering is generally considered the gold standard. Once you have seen a codebase your mind is tainted and it makes it hard to trust you when you say you aren’t violating the NDA or whatever. This has been used in lawsuits before.

When an AI is trained on GPL open source code you have similar issues. If you use the AI to write say non-GPL clone of Linux, and the AI was trained on Linux source code, I really think this may be a legal murky area as you can say the AI is doing a non-clean room reverse engineering of Linux based on having read its source code and reimplementing it.

8

u/RummoLiguori 11d ago

It's not a gray area. AI training is fair use and legal.

3

u/Jhuyt 11d ago

But is using a model trained on a GPL project to generate a non-GPL project legal? Also that mught be different in jurisdictions without fair use like Europe

2

u/RummoLiguori 11d ago edited 11d ago

I do not think an LLM would count as a derivative work of the GPL project. This is why clean room designs (decomplications) are legal and not even big corporations can prohibit it with their own licenses.

The LLM, however, can generate a GPL project or a derivative of it by accident or when asked. That would be a violation of the license.

Training wouldn't be a copyright violation in Europe either. You would need to distribute copyrighted material.

4

u/y-c-c 10d ago

Ok, so your point is training on GPL code is fair use but usage of said model may not be. What’s the point of this comment exactly? Who is training AI without using them?

1

u/RummoLiguori 10d ago

No, you seriously lack reading comprehension. Using them is 100% legal.

Training is legal and fair use but the output these models generate may violate IP laws in some scenarios. For example, ChatGPT generating Pokemon characters without permission images violates IP laws. OpenAI is offering you a service that does that, you can use it, OpenAI gets in trouble if they don't limit that.

3

u/y-c-c 10d ago

Ok. The problem is if you ask it to write an OS. How do you know it’s not reverse engineering GPL Linux code? You may not have explicitly asked it to reverse engineer Linux but it is one of the most popular OSes in the world and it’s definitely not a clean room then. And an “OS” includes a lot of stuff from kernel to user land stuff.

Maybe you just didn’t think hard enough of the problem instead?

1

u/RummoLiguori 10d ago

How do you know it’s not reverse engineering GPL Linux code?

But Reverse engineering is legal though? And to reverse engineer, you would need to hand it something first.

I've been personally contributing to the reverse engineering, decompilation and recompilation of The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom to PC on GitHub.

What you cannot be absolutely certain about is that it doesn't copy or exactly replicate copyrighted code

→ More replies

0

u/Jhuyt 11d ago

This analysis sounds right according to my understanding, but has there been any lawsuits related the GPL and LLMs?

1

u/porkusdorkus 10d ago

Legality and morality should go hand in hand. Rarely do when money is involved.

2

u/TrekkiMonstr 11d ago

Except that training is fair use, so license terms are irrelevant

2

u/Unfair-Sleep-3022 10d ago

I mean sure, the capitalist pigs are defending each other in their pursuit of eliminating the need of the peasants, who would have guessed

1

u/y-c-c 10d ago

That is not tested in court. Fair use is case by case.

1

u/TrekkiMonstr 10d ago

Dude have you not been paying attention Anthropic v. Bartz literally held training is fair use. Ofc district court so not precedential and we could well see a circuit split and/or SCOTUS go the other way, but it literally has been tested in court and came out as I said.

-4

u/Tintiifax 11d ago

Licenses dont matter in general anymore with AI. Everything can and will be "Reverse engineered", noone will be able to proof without a doubt that something uses his Code or Not.

2

u/y-c-c 10d ago

Reverse engineering software not done in a clean room has always been legally dicey. There have been lots of legal cases on stuff like this.

3

u/VaporousMote 11d ago

If you think that LLMs care which license that source code has, you are high.

2

u/azurensis 11d ago

It's not stealing in any way. Just like it's not stealing to train on books or movies or anything else. LLMs don't store copies of anything. No copy, no copyright infringement.

18

u/Unfair-Sleep-3022 11d ago

If you take a book and put it in a zip, can you claim it's not a copy? No.

Model weights are multi dimensional compression

The information is definitely there and proven to be recalleable

3

u/azurensis 11d ago

A zipped file is a copy because it can be restored to it's original form. LLMs don't compress the data - they don't store it at all. 

It's absolutely not recallable. Try it yourself if you like.

5

u/cosmic-parsley 11d ago

I don’t think they had a great example, but it is more or less _lossy_ compression. More similar to asking whether a copyrighted RAW photo taken by a professional photographer is still protected when converted to heavily compressed JPEG. Can’t get the exact original back but you can get something close

0

u/No-Consequence-1863 10d ago

LLMs dont really do that either. They can potentially reproduce exact copies but it’s never guaranteed. OSS code might actually be the least likely to be reproduced exactly since most of it is very non-unique and there are tons of competing copies in the training data.

LLMs are more like a slot machine that takes text a chops it all up into a slurry. Then when you roll it gives you the most likely smoothie.

1

u/Ahmouse 11d ago

Saying it's not designed to store the data, versus its not possible to store the data, are two different things. The fact that there are numerous cases of LLMs regurgitating proves that it is possible. As always in engineering, what you design on paper, and what happens in reality, tend to be different.

0

u/azurensis 11d ago

Sure, so have you tried to make them reproduce any copyrighted material? If they do, how is that not on you? You can use a typewriter to reproduce copyrighted material, but that's not the typewriter manufacturers fault. Why is it the AI company's fault if someone uses their tool to violate copyright?

3

u/Unfair-Sleep-3022 10d ago

https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.12546

Several models shown to recall some books in their entirety

2

u/azurensis 10d ago

"With respect to our specific extraction methodology, we find that most LLMs do not memorize most books -- either in whole or in part"

And this is about llama 3.1 - a model more than 2 years old. This cannot be done on any modern model.

1

u/Unfair-Sleep-3022 10d ago

You don't know how models work, do you?

The data is there. They just put some guardrails on the harness to not give it out and get into trouble right now.

The stolen content is still there. They're still profiting from it.

→ More replies

3

u/MiekoOnReddit 10d ago

False analogy. If they can recite information from copyrighted material (without making a web request), then are storing said information, by definition.

A typewriter does not store anything. It converts keystrokes into ink on paper, the information comes from the writer.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ahmouse 11d ago

Many cases of it happening without any request to do so. It does it willingly on its own, without users knowing or requesting it to do so. It's hard to say how often.

It's more like hiring a mechanic, who decides to fix your car cheaper by stealing the part from someone else's car. There's no way you would know, and it's fully their responsibility.

→ More replies (1)

-2

u/RummoLiguori 11d ago

Human brains would be the same then.

2

u/Jmackles 11d ago

The bobiverse series actually touches on this exact dilemma and I quite like their solution which boils down to if you make a backup of yourself and send it to another body and shut down your initial “body” and what was backed up while the copy is in transit, the booted backup will be the original. The person in question could do this as often as needed. In the context of the book it’s basically only useful for vast distances (like Astronomical units).

However the moment two are active at once one of them splits off as a new person while one remains the original. The distinction comes down to which was running before the other instantiated.

Given all that I’d say it fits with your rebuttal and I rather subscribe to the theory myself, though I seriously doubt there will be a point in my lifetime or the next generations where such technology exists.

2

u/Unfair-Sleep-3022 10d ago

Human brains are not a product

And it's still illegal for you and me to pirate books. It is widely known the training was done without paying licenses.

2

u/RummoLiguori 10d ago

Human brains are not a product

Nice, a goal post shift. It's stealing because it's a product...

Not entirely true always and in the future fore sure. Researchers in England are using biological cells to create "neurospheres" (small clusters of neurons) to treat Alzheimer's. Anytime in the future if someone something similar into their brain, copyrighted content is banned because it is stealing and part of their brain is a "product"?

It's illegal for anyone to pirate books, they've been paying multi-billion dollar fines/settlements for them.

1

u/Unfair-Sleep-3022 10d ago

It's really not that hard to understand.. I think you're being disingenuous

Copyright infringement is ALL about business

If you start making money using the IP from another firm without paying the respective licenses or getting an agreement, you get sued

Models make money using everyone's IP without consent, violating licenses and pirating books. Ergo it's theft and it should not be tolerated.

It's only been called fair use because it's in the best interest of the capitalist pigs to stop needing peasants.

2

u/RummoLiguori 10d ago

No, you really misunderstand copyright law.

If you start making money using the IP from another firm without paying the respective licenses or getting an agreement, you get sued

Image generators already get sued for this. The LLM itself is not a copyright violation though. The output could be.

Models make money using everyone's IP without consent, violating licenses and pirating books.

Not a copyright violation. If I learned to code using stolen books and pirated material and started earning money, that is 100% fine under the law. My work is not a copyright violation

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Waste_Philosophy4250 11d ago

It's stealing the same way distillation is.

1

u/porkusdorkus 10d ago

I swear I laugh when I see any AI company whining about distillation of their models. Bitch you stole it first lol.

1

u/D_nordsud 11d ago

Are the models providing copyright attribution for code it may have borrowed? Open source doesn't mean there is absolutely no cost to be paid.

-3

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/N_T_F_D 11d ago

It depends on the license

-1

u/LustyLamprey 10d ago

If it has restrictions it's not open source. Stalman weeps

-20

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Snauser 11d ago

Yeah those sociopathic tech billionaires love communism/socialism!

4

u/Holzkohlen 11d ago

History has taught me only one thing: It's only ever gonna get worse

4

u/imaginary_num6er 11d ago

Is this the same Linus that said “Fuck you, Nvidia” ?

2

u/Wilbis 10d ago

The one and only.

1

u/GoTheFuckToBed 7d ago

it is the same that said you should shut the fuck up

0

u/silverbolt2000 11d ago

I don’t know. Was it?

4

u/Ancient-Bat1755 11d ago

Linus is a solid 5 but wasnt interested in bootlegging chips

-8

u/brakeb 11d ago

So, just to make sure:

Windows = boo, bad, AI is evil, fuck you Redmond!
Linux (and LInus) = “Bless the AI and its code. Bless the coming and going of AI, May its passage cleanse the world, And may he keep the world for his people. ”

Did I get that right?

12

u/jippiex2k 11d ago • Heartwarming

AI is inert by itself, it amplifies the intent of who wields it.

Conpany that just wants to make as much money as possible, uses AI to make as much moneymaking bullshit as possible.

Open source developer community that just wants to make as good software as possible, uses AI to make software betterer.

12

u/Korkman 11d ago

Very different context.

Windows = Marketing AI in your face, in ways everybody hates
Linux = AI is kept for coding, where it is both the problem and the solution

0

u/brakeb 11d ago

you're not wrong.

I appreciate that take... I'd imagine I'd need my asbesto thong on if I went into the r/linux sub with my take on things... LOL

I've no hate for any OS at this point, many find comfort in what they like to use. As someone in cybersecurity, I've spent the last 25 years dealing with Java, windows, oracle, and a good number of OSS. We talked about the 'Cyber Pearl Harbor' for a decade+, wondering when it would get here... Seeing it happen, I feel bad for IR and other folks working that frontline, and I look forward to AI being a force multiplier for our blue team and IR/TDR folks.

0

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Korkman 11d ago

Because he doesn't celebrate it like MS marketing does, which is because Linus doesn't have to make money off it.

"Here let's take screenshots and digest it with AI, default on next release! Also, we fire devs to save money because AI can code, your Windows Updates will be fine!"

"It's a tool. Use it well and it's actually helpful."

Two very different stances.

0

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/unholey1 11d ago

The linux kernel is not niche, most of the internet is built on (and relies on) linux.

15

u/Radium 11d ago

Windows = AI pulling your privacy data in tricky ways with settings that keep being changed/added in frequent updates.

Linux = open source code that you can view and verify exactly what it does, and (depending on the distro you pick), doesn't pull your data into any databases or have any interest in that.

AI = trained by the same AI code standards, knows the first principles way that machines and code work, and now can analyze huge swaths of code allowing it to pinpoint human-made errors that no human has a large enough context window to comprehend. And the output code is reviewable and open source, just like the code it reviewed and trained on.

-3

u/brakeb 11d ago

" open source code that you can view and verify exactly what it does " <<< this has only been true for a small percentage of open source. the last 50 years worth of cruft is finally coming to the fore because we have tools that are scaling to handle the 'many eyes' doctrine/fallacy people have been preaching that few did...AI lowered th bar to enable more people to review code than ever before.

It's gonna be rocky for the next couple years.

https://cve.icu

11

u/Radium 11d ago edited 11d ago

As noted by Linus here in this exact post by him, apparently it's having the exact opposite outcome, it's a benefit! Every vulnerability is being patched faster, so while the AI is helping expose vulnerabilities quicker, the AI is in turn being used to patch the vulnerabilities at an equal pace.

In other words, the more bugs you find, the more stable your software will become.

It's likely because they are using the AI in a white-hat hacker way to actively locate and patch the exploits before the bad hackers do it.

It's because of the context window issue that human's have. They just can't fit it all into their heads and make all the logic connections required to notice the bugs.

0

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Radium 11d ago

But the reason Linus states it’s outpacing the bad hackers is that the patches seem to be outpacing the vulnerabilities. It’s just more exciting time to be a developer. Biggest computer enhancement in ages

→ More replies (2)

4

u/silverbolt2000 11d ago

Yes, but only if you spend 24/7 on social media.

Otherwise, no.

3

u/DreadCoder 11d ago

Updoot for dune reference

-5

u/i_can_has_rock 11d ago edited 11d ago

the threshold where "AI" or "Human Intelligence" is reduced to a brute force machine having simply just tried every combination and how thats indistinguishable from a false positive that anything is actually intelligent and not just some problem solving machine at the abstract

people would still argue emotons, art, music etc

still just input being processed by an engine

eventually you would assume that for every paradigm that we would find the Archimedes screw

the point where you cant improve further without diminishing returns without altering the context

using AI as a brute force tool (which it cant escape being) to "fix" things and thinking about people that are "Anti AI"

i think most people are just anti-"how ai is being handled at the moment" and not actually anti cracking a nut with a rock

-14

u/NesNobnaz 11d ago

Man, watching Linux get worse over the next 5 years is going to amazing.

-2

u/Marwheel 11d ago

But if said fixes are any good, that's the thing…