r/technology • • 2d ago

Software Google will launch Android app verification requirement globally in January 2027 | Google says almost all developers have already gotten on board with verification.

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2026/11/google-will-launch-android-app-verification-requirement-globally-in-january-2027/
93 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

106

u/Major303 2d ago

I would support this system if not for the fact that Google Play is filled with malware and scams. Some of those applications are so obvious that even basic AI verification system would catch them and flag for human verification, meaning Google makes no verification at all - you can literally upload anything and it will get automatically accepted.

19

u/FollowingFeisty5321 2d ago

The whole premise of smartphone app stores being managed and curated is built on a lie that these companies are actually doing that. What they're really doing is collecting vast mountains of fees from apps, spending as little as possible policing them and a rounding error relative to their fees, and relying on section 230 immunity to shield them from any liability. Same with Google and Meta advertising, counterfeits on Amazon. It's all just privatizing the profits and socializing the costs.

40

u/donmcronald 2d ago

Make Google and Apple liable for the apps on their app stores. I think this is a scummy ploy so they can deliver “undesirable” app developers to special interests, like the copyright lobby. Does anyone think it’ll be the same for the thieves scamming regular people? I don’t.

In my opinion Google has been working really hard to make sure they’re the sole curator of apps you can use on Android. They should be liable at that point.

9

u/EmbarrassedHelp 2d ago

This gives them VETO power over what people can install.

1

u/Seasmokes 1d ago

Isn't that already the case with the iOS App Store?

7

u/40513786934 2d ago

Maybe if we made Apple liable (since they have been the sole curator of iOS apps for years) then Google would stop trying to copy them

31

u/Glum_Veterinarian988 2d ago

"almost all developers have already gotten on board with verification". No, that's not true. They're counting developers on the Google Play Store because OF COURSE they did. As a GPlay Dev, you are FORCED to verify, otherwise your app will get taken off the store. There's no option. And they're not counting the thousands of devs that post open source or on other stores.

-11

u/visceralintricacy 2d ago edited 2d ago

Did you read this article, like at all?

"And they're not counting the thousands of devs that post open source or on other stores."

And they don't have to verify at all? They can still post their apps on other app stores, and you're still perfectly free to install other app stores on your device.

This thread is full of so much misinformation and BS.

"Google also relented and created an opt-out system for users who don’t want their installations limited. The so-called “advanced flow” will let you install whatever you want regardless of verification status"

6

u/unlimitedcode99 2d ago

You know some banking apps will throw a fit if you just activated your developer mode/settings? And where do you think Google buried that "advanced flow" in the settings?

1

u/visceralintricacy 2d ago

I've got netflix, samsung pay and banking apps running with the advanced flow, all fine. They don't care, at ALL. I've only heard about banking apps not liking root access, for obvious reasons.

15

u/styckx 2d ago

Shovelware dominating the play store is still A-OK though

12

u/not_the_fox 2d ago

Just gotta keep moving to lineageOS or grapheneOS compatible phones. Don't buy anything with a locked bootloader.

4

u/iamthe0ther0ne 2d ago

Not an option if you have to use MS Authenticator for 2FA :(

1

u/Sweaty_Confusion1498 1d ago

It stopped working on GOS?

I used it like almost a year ago for work and it was working normally on P10P with GOS.

Currently using Samsung (Pixel is so bugged ffs), gonna get the Motorola S27 with GOS tho.

2

u/iamthe0ther0ne 1d ago

It might? work at this point, but MS doesn't support it and refuses to clarify if it will work going forward. I can't take the risk of walking in to work one day and not being able to log in. 

https://www.heise.de/en/news/GrapheneOS-Microsoft-Authenticator-does-not-support-secure-Android-OS-11200495.html

1

u/Sweaty_Confusion1498 1d ago

Oh well, welp, I'll keep my S25 Edge anyway, if I would need a non custom OS phone for smth.

Thanks for the link

-8

u/Negative-Fix5290 2d ago

why would you use ms authenticator on your personal phone?

3

u/iamthe0ther0ne 2d ago

The only way I can log into the university's email and computers  is through MSauth

-2

u/Negative-Fix5290 2d ago

ok i get it, thanks!

4

u/visceralintricacy 2d ago

Because many people don't want to carry 2 phones. duh.

-7

u/Negative-Fix5290 2d ago

why would you be carrying around your authenticator instead of leaving it at office, the only place you'd use it?

6

u/visceralintricacy 2d ago

Most businesses won't even issue another device. Many people also obviously need to access services remotely or WFH. You dind't think about that much, did you?

-3

u/Negative-Fix5290 2d ago

Most businesses won't even issue another device.

how many work phone do you need?

Many people also obviously need to access services remotely or WFH

when you wfh then put it at home. youre arguing as if ppl need to carry authenticator around 24/7 when they go out for dinner, grocery trips, or whatever everyday activities.

idk anyone that need to access their ms account asap and doesnt carry their laptop with them, at which point a 2nd phone weighted 200-300 gr isnt a big deal for mission critical work.

maybe lay off the personal insult and think first what is it that youre trying to argue about...

5

u/visceralintricacy 2d ago

rofl, it wasn't a personal insult, it was a statement of fact.

"idk anyone that need to access their ms account asap and doesnt carry their laptop with them"

I literally never carry my laptop with me and frequently need to fix things remotely from my phone. That's a very common thing in IT. Why would i carry a laptop out anywhere when I don't need to?

0

u/Negative-Fix5290 2d ago

That's a very common thing in IT.

this isnt factual but a personal preference. you made the choice to do work on your personal phone, at which point sure, go ahead and use it there.

1

u/Robot1me 1d ago

why would you use [...]

This is like fighting a symptom. Unfortunate reality is that Google has had big success with their Play Integrity API to punish users for unlocking their phones. If one has to ask people "why would you use XY" just to dodge the elephant in the room (bootloader checks locking people out, making two phones necessary, etc.), people understandably conclude "why would I unlock the bootloader then?"

0

u/Negative-Fix5290 1d ago

to dodge the elephant in the room (bootloader checks locking people out, making two phones necessary, etc.)

slighty off-topic but it's been more than a decade since i use android and many ppl that i know, myself included, keep their old phone as a spare bcus those usually are still okay for basic tasks in case of emergency or thinkering. so even if we set aside privacy issue, it's a good practice having a backup phone.

it's not like an authenticator app requires a flagship specs, though they might drop backward compatibility eventually. of course, i also get that not everyone keeps their old phone around but this is one of those cases where having two are better than one.

also, while installing custom rom have been easier & almost seamless than ever, knowing you have another device if things go wrong can give you the confidence to try it.

"why would I unlock the bootloader then?"

i cant help them with answering this, partly bcus i know how to turn off advertising id, disabling system apps, setting up private dns, picking privacy-focus apps, etc., which to me, is sufficient to anonymise my usage of the phone.

i've learned that most data leaks are done by companies that i trust with my personal info anyway, like network carriers, hospitals and banks. google is the last company i expect to leak or sell it.

20

u/EnvironmentalRun1671 2d ago

I'm sure this won't impact modded youtube apps, or unofficial game ports like GTA V, Forza Horizon, NFS and many many more /s

7

u/belkarbitterleaf 2d ago

From what I understand, there are workarounds. I've done a bit of research on the topic, and have been talking with Samsung corporate about how it will impact my company.

Enable developer options, enable side loading, wait 24 hours, install what you want.

Hook the phone up to Android studio, and install whatever.

If the developers sign the app with a valid certificate, and you can side load without the wait.

Or, if you enroll the phone in a "mobile device management" tool (there are some options out there) you are no longer restricted by this.

16

u/EX0PIL0T 2d ago

Why the fuck is there a waiting period on a device that I bought, paid for, and own? Am I a risk to myself when I install what I want? I’m sick of garbage patronizing authoritarian nanny features.

3

u/belkarbitterleaf 2d ago

I mean, I don't support it in any capacity, just sharing what I know on how to deal with it.

-10

u/visceralintricacy 2d ago edited 2d ago

This is one of the most braindead responses I've ever heard. The whole point is to prevent people being bullied into installing spyware during scam calls. Being forced to reboot your phone and wait 24 hours breaks this flow.

You only have to do this ONCE, per google account. Not even per phone. Calm your tits, it's not the end of the world. I've personally had to talk many people down from installing spyware, this is a legitimate problem.

"Am I a risk to myself when I install what I want? "

Yes, many people literally don't know wtf they're doing. This is for them. I'm sure you can wait 24 hours once before sideloading an app, AND THEN NEVER WAIT AGAIN!

"Why the fuck is there a waiting period on a device that I bought, paid for, and own? "

Because you don't own the operating system, and so allowances have to be made for the least intelligent users, too.

r/technology users are simultaneously some of the smartest and stupidest people in the world.

This comment section is full of people who want google to simultaneously be responsible for every app on the app store (apple isn't either), while removing all the guard rails and warning signs. You're a bunch of lemmings who don't understand the real world.

7

u/EX0PIL0T 2d ago

Other people’s stupidity should not be a justification for a poor experience that I have no control over on my devices. I don’t understand why you would defend this. It’s objectively a poor solution. Scammers can just call back a day later.

1

u/LePontif11 4h ago

You are the dumbfuck in another person's world. You don't live in a vacuum, other's inexperience in this or that will always make it so systems aren't as efficient as they could be if just everyone knew how everything worked.

-1

u/visceralintricacy 2d ago

"Other people’s stupidity should not be a justification for a poor experience that I have no control over on my devices"

And yet speed signs exist. Your comment is objectively false and incorrect, and there's millions of examples of this all over the world.

1

u/EX0PIL0T 1d ago

The only reason that the “reasonable and prudent” speed limit signs disappeared is because of federal overreach when they wanted to restrict alcohol sales. Of all the examples to pick, that might have been the worst. Natural selection is pretty cool though. Quit wanting everyone to be the same level of dependent that you seem to require to be able to function

-4

u/visceralintricacy 2d ago edited 2d ago

"It’s objectively a poor solution. "

It actually isn't. It's a giant huge warning that people have to read and understand, and it allows the the opportunity to discuss the issue with other people who will tell them it's a scam. I'VE LITERALLY SEEN THIS WORK PERFECTLY MYSELF. Numerous silly people have been stopped scamming themselves by reading these warnings, and by being forced to have that delay.

If it's so bad, what's your solution?

Telll people to be less stupid?

"poor experience that I have no control over on my devices"

Are you completely illiterate? Seriously? It's a ONE TIME DELAY, ONCE PER GOOGLE ACCOUNT. It's really not a bfd. You agree once, and never see the warning again, regardless of how many apps you install, even when you get a new phone.

4

u/EX0PIL0T 2d ago

It should be a zero time occurrence. Yes, I believe that stupid people should face the consequences of their actions. There could be a big ass pop up that you can close with one tap and id be fine with that.

-4

u/visceralintricacy 2d ago

lol, you sound like a scammer whinging that his job is going to be harder. cope more

-1

u/iamthe0ther0ne 2d ago

I've got some stuff side-loaded, including a few small tools I've picked up from Github repos. Will they just get deleted? Can Claude Code do anything to my phone to fix them?

-1

u/visceralintricacy 2d ago edited 2d ago

"Will they just get deleted?"

No. Not at all. You can still sideload all you want, this is practically irrelevant once you tick a box.

This sub is full of fear mongering and bs.

"Google also relented and created an opt-out system for users who don’t want their installations limited. The so-called “advanced flow” will let you install whatever you want regardless of verification status"

4

u/Future-Bandicoot-823 2d ago

They're coming for Mozilla, too. They actually fund Mozilla in large part, I think a billion a year? Roughly 80% of their yearly costs. The supposed reason is so they don't get hit with a monopoly lawsuit. The only large, heh "large" non chromium browsers are firefox and safari, but I imagine safari doesn't reach many windows or android users.

As we can all see, though, the United States seems to be taking a very very lax approach to monopolies these days, and I think in the near future Google will be willing to risk pulling the funding on Firefox. It won't outright kill Mozilla, and Google can then judge whether or not a monopoly suit would be filed. If it is, well, simple; just fund Mozilla again.

-9

u/visceralintricacy 2d ago edited 2d ago

It actually doesn't, at all, whatsoever.

You can still install other app stores. I've got the new advanced approval flow on my phone. It's a nothing burger. I've got noutube, among other unverified apps installed.

Edit: this is basically mandated by law now in several countries that have petitioned for seperate app market rights.

It's really that simple. You guys may not live in a country with working consumer protections, but many of us do.

But sure, fear monger away you silly trolls.

People said the exact same thing pre advanced flow release. They fear mongered over it blocking everything, and not being actually possible. That hasn't panned out, at all.

I seriously wonder if the people rallying about this are 13 year olds worried about losing their pirated games and porn apps (spoiler, you WON'T!), and scammers.

15

u/Cheetawolf 2d ago

You're a fool if you don't think they'll gradually restrict it more and more, until rooting and side loading are impossible, or will get your phone remotely bricked or your Google account terminated if they find out you've done it.

Google is an ad company first and foremost.

ANYTHING that Isn't filled to the brim with ads is losing them money, and they're large and stupid enough to fully destroy the Android ecosystem as we know it for the sake of getting a few more cents out of forcing us to watch ads.

4

u/konistehrad 2d ago

Yeah hard to see it as anything else. Feels at least like a rug pull from the Android we were promised back when.

1

u/visceralintricacy 2d ago edited 2d ago

You don't need to root your phone.

If they restrict sideloading, they'll face even harsher sanctions in the EU and other countries where alternative app stores ARE ALREADY MANDATED IN LAW.

It's really that simple. You guys may not live in a country with working consumer protections, but many of us do.

4

u/jomic01 2d ago

The part that actually changes things is sideloading, since Play Store developers already had to verify their identity and now apps installed from anywhere else need a verified developer too.

-7

u/visceralintricacy 2d ago

DId you read the article? Your comment is objectively false.

"Google also relented and created an opt-out system for users who don’t want their installations limited. The so-called “advanced flow” will let you install whatever you want regardless of verification status"

2

u/populusangustifolia 2d ago

You can already enable this, FYI, even if you're not in a region where the verification function is enabled. I sure have.

2

u/visceralintricacy 2d ago

Yeah, I have too. Everything works fine, that's why I'm trying to dispel some of the BS and misinformation in here...

3

u/Expensive_Finger_973 2d ago

The place I hear of distributing malware the most is the Play Store itself. Google really should learn to get their own house in order before complaining about their competition.

2

u/aerx9 2d ago

Fork you Android

2

u/tiradium 2d ago

*Google

Android is not at fault that google has play store garbage forced on non AOSP devices

1

u/aerx9 2d ago

Forking android and abandoning google play for an open source free ecosystem fixes the problem. With AI there is no longer a need for commercial software.

1

u/QF_Dan 18h ago

What's the point of even buying android phones anymore? I will never buy an iOS device because android phone has so much freedom to do whatever we want. And now they are attempting to take those luxury away from all of their users.

Go fuck yourself, Google!!!

1

u/fugogugo 2d ago

and the verification will put your full name and address in the play store. they are doxing every individual developer

1

u/Powerful_Brief1724 2d ago

Monopolies gonna monopoly.