r/technology • • 16h ago • Bravo 1

Software I've only sold five copies of GTA 6, says Leicester shop owner

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cmqj5dr01e85o?xtor=AL-71-%5Bpartner%5D-%5Bbbc.news.twitter%5D-%5Bheadline%5D-%5Bnews%5D-%5Bbizdev%5D-%5Bisapi%5D&at_link_origin=BBCNews&at_bbc_team=editorial&at_campaign_type=owned&at_campaign=Social_Flow&at_link_id=5B1C57FE-E5CC-11F1-B5F4-8F4F68BBA22D&at_format=link&at_medium=social&at_ptr_name=twitter&at_link_type=web_link
10k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

16k

u/Bulleveland 16h ago • Bravo Popcorn

The physical copy of GTA is simply a game case with a download code, there’s no advantage over a digital purchase.

5.2k

u/Funsuxxor 16h ago • Bravo

You get to wrap it as a present, I suppose...

1.8k

u/adavidmiller 16h ago • Popcorn

Yeah, wait for Christmas and I imagine there will be a couple more sales from parents who don't know or don't care that it's just a box, something to wrap.

1.0k

u/GivinUpTheFight 16h ago • Bravo

100% on something to wrap. We switched my son to all digital for his switch 2 (had a couple too many lost game cards on switch 1). When he wants a game for Xmas I'll go get the little cardboard picture of the game with the download code, load it on his switch when he goes to sleep, and put a label on the cardboard card "from Santa" that says to check his Switch 2. Santa magically put the game ON his switch and he has something physical to tell him to go check.

→ More replies (75)
→ More replies (53)

89

u/Double_Soup_3834 14h ago • Heartwarming

My brother did this last Christmas, took a different PS game case, exchanged the paper from the other game for some white paper with tanks and soldiers drawn on it in his best creative style he could, wrote battlefield on it and put a PS card in there with enough to cover battlefield 6. Even though he could have just given me the card with the money the case meant a lot to me. I even took it with me when I moved out of the US.

→ More replies (2)

36

u/Po0opyCatButt 15h ago • Mindblown

It's on my Xmas list because I'm in no hurry to get it. My wife or in-laws will get the joy of wrapping ang giving a gift, and I'll be so grateful to unwrap and receive the gift. My wife's family is so generous and thoughtful, and they still celebrate Christmas to the fullest. I feel like a kid again with them(I haven't been a kid for decades).

I love that people who prefer the ease and simplicity can just download the game or redeem a code. The empty box still has value to some of us, as tradition or a collectible, or a means to give a gift.

Live and let live, enjoy what you like; asking questions is good, but passing judgement is pointless.

I'm actually glad I saw this post, and that you mentioned gifting the game, because I only assumed there would be a physical package for this game. I wasn't sure if my in-laws would have to get creative for this one.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (21)

33

u/Tammer_Stern 14h ago

In Argos, it’s £65 compared to £70 in the PlayStation store.

14

u/yannichaboyer 13h ago

In France I paid 59€ instead of 79€ by buying it at my local supermarket

6

u/LostLobes 13h ago

If you buy a psn card, you can get a £70 one for £60 atm

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

247

u/chief_yETI 16h ago

you also get a free poster

it's not much (tbh it's nothing), but I'll take the free poster since it's the same price

86

u/obi1kenobi1 15h ago

I was so bummed to realize it was just a poster when I first saw photos of people making fun of the code written in the box art. It looked like a map, and even GTA V came with a map long after every other game stopped providing anything besides the game in the box. But apparently the map is a separate purchase.

→ More replies (4)

30

u/Deshes011 16h ago

I didn’t even know you get the poster. I wanted the box as a momento. Opened it, found the poster, and was like yoooo that’s lit

→ More replies (1)

17

u/oshdwtf 15h ago

I didn't have to pay sales tax for downloading thru PSN so the poster would've costed me.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (28)

581

u/fuzzum111 14h ago edited 7h ago • Bravo

This is the goal, it kills off game shops. It also kills off second-hand market.

Remember kids the big push for digital only game downloads isn't to save you money, it's to remove the ability for second-hand gaming to exist. No more cheap used copies at game-stop, no more trading games with friends.

Buy it for $80 forever, or don't.

Edit: Just to be clear. I understand that a "majority" of people find the digital purchase more convenient. It has some legitimate merits. The core of the issue is, it still kills off 2nd hand gaming. It kills letting a friend borrow a copy. It kills the ability to resell your console + games collection later on if you want to do so. Sure the console can still be sold, but your hundreds, or thousands of dollars of games dies with it. That isn't right.

It's YOUR purchase, you should be the right to do with it as you see fit. Resell, borrow, etc. If buying a digital copy is not ownership, then piracy is not theft.

63

u/ExodusPHX 13h ago

It’s not even guaranteed “forever” it’s only as long as the platform continues to support it.

112

u/Kiu88 13h ago

We can blame the consoles and game publishers until we're blue in the face, but digital outsells physical sales all the time. Gamers did it to ourselves

70

u/SxySale 12h ago • Bravo

For all the praise that steam gets, they normalized this.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (7)

21

u/-Nightopian- 13h ago

I choose the third option...

Ahoy!

→ More replies (20)

46

u/BrillsonHawk 13h ago

Not everything is a conspiracy. PC gaming has been digital only for decades and you still get games regularly on sale/discounted. 

Why would any game company want to waste money manufacturing discs in the modern world

→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (59)

50

u/weekendroady 16h ago

They tossed a poster in the box as a freebie inside so technically there is something tangible included for the exact same price as the digital version.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/eduadinho 14h ago

Cheaper by $20 in New Zealand at least to get the game at the shops. 

64

u/cr0ft 15h ago

Arguably it's a disadvantage, some unscrupulous person may have cracked it open, gotten the code and resealed. Plus you have to haul your butt there in the first place. If it was a physical copy, then sure, but a code? Easier to buy online.

27

u/moose_dad 14h ago

I saw a reel from a guy not realising there was no disc, showing it off at how dumb it was when he opened the case.

A few minutes later he posted another one, someone had used the code that was visible inside the open case on the previous reel. He had to pay twice to play lmao.

→ More replies (2)

53

u/incarnate_devil 15h ago

um, you don’t need to crack the case.

The code is visible with a flashlight. They didn’t even bother to use that lotto scratch stuff to protect the code.

This is a known issue.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/takemetoyourrocket 15h ago

I got a poster and a box to show for my code at least

7

u/-SideshowBlob- 14h ago

It was cheaper for me, and a free poster. Also nice to have something to add to my collection, albeit minus the disc.

12

u/HanzJWermhat 15h ago edited 15h ago

The gta box is so iconic tho.

But yes a waste of plastic

7

u/Endda 15h ago

and folks are paranoid about the code already being used

→ More replies (2)

3

u/PackyJO 15h ago

i got my gta physical at 55 USD. it’s much cheaper than a digital purchase

3

u/cknewdeal 15h ago

There's a poster inside the box tho

→ More replies (1)

23

u/tanke_md 15h ago

This is completely wrong. "Physical digital copies" contains a case, map, the same digital code and DISCOUNTS. My copy cost me 15€ less than the digital one. At the end I can sell the case and map to any person and get the game even for less money.

It's hard to me to understand why people is focussed in pay more.

13

u/cantstraferight 14h ago

There's no map. Just a poster sadly.

You can also buy psn top up cards at a discount. So I bought a £70 card for £61 and basically got £9 off gta6.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Qualimiox 16h ago

Don't get me wrong, Rockstar (and Sony) are crooked for abandoning physical media, but there can still be advantages over a digital purchase.

GTA 6 in PSN in Germany costs 79,99€. Müller (a German retailer) had a sale on all video games, including pre-orders, which brought the price down to 63,20€ and Amazon matched the price. I bought that and then sold the case with the included poster for another 15€, so I effectively paid 48,20€ (-40% off the PSN price)

15

u/PsychologicalTea3426 15h ago

In some countries there are also consumer protections for physical goods but not digital ones, so you can return it or get a refund if there are issues with it.

→ More replies (14)

2

u/LegacyofaMarshall 15h ago

It comes with a poster/map I believe

2

u/SomeNamelessNomad 14h ago

It was cheaper in Smyths as a physical here in Ireland. Only like €5 less but that plus a poster made me go for it instead.

→ More replies (171)

2.8k

u/TheTylerDurden 15h ago • Bravo Heartwarming

I bought a copy from my local game store because I wanted to support that particular store. I asked the owner of the store if they actually make any money on the sales or if they are just selling them at cost and it turns out they were set to make around $10 per copy. So I ended up grabbing that and a used copy of Motorstorm to add to my actual physical collection. Anyway, support local.

332

u/Little-Mushroom-3961 14h ago • Regret

Local game shops are great. Wish I could say the same about local TCG shops, a majority of those are just ran by scalpers.

53

u/Chem1st 11h ago

Yeah 2 new card stores have opened up near me, and both of them are just cases of slabbed cards.  Nobody is playing at those places, just buying price inflated bs.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/Calereliya 13h ago

Can confirm the $10 margin number. It's $14 CAD for the store I work at.

→ More replies (2)

35

u/Chummmp 14h ago

Motorstorm is banging so fair enough

→ More replies (1)

179

u/Murky-Bus-2191 15h ago

Peak mentioned.

47

u/LtG_Skittles454 14h ago

It came with my PS3 and I loved that game so much. I got pretty far in the game for a 10 yr old I think haha

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/jasonefmonk 13h ago

Do you have a favourite MotorStorm? I only have Pacific Rift but I think it’s pretty well liked. It’s fun as fuck.

4

u/TheTylerDurden 13h ago

I’ve only really played the first one but it’s a ton of fun. I really want to add Pacific Rift to the collection but I haven’t actually seen a copy out in the wild in years.

→ More replies (8)

77

u/cryptomausi 11h ago

Kind of feel for him, but when the "physical copy" is just a case with a download code inside, there's no reason to drive to a shop for it. You still have to download the whole game anyway. The only people buying these are parents who want something to put under the tree, and a few people who want to support their local store, which is honestly a nice reason

13

u/Silver3lement 9h ago

I traded in a bunch of games and from my useless “will never touch again games pile” on my shelf and got half of the value taken off, can’t do that digitally.

2

u/CAPSLOCK_USERNAME 6h ago

but when the "physical copy" is just a case with a download code inside, there's no reason to drive to a shop for it.

In fact, that's exactly what the shop owner says in the article.

→ More replies (3)

4.0k

u/Evilbred 16h ago

Why would someone go to a store to buy a code to download a game online when they can just download the game online?

1.4k

u/bacan_ 16h ago

I feel bad for the guy being stuck with useless merchandise though

800

u/Evilbred 16h ago

Anyone running a store that depends on revenue from selling physical copies of games will find things to become progressively more challenging as more and more consoles have no way to read physical media.

292

u/Th3_Admiral_ 15h ago

Time to start selling Funkopops or Minecraft plushies or whatever it is Gamestop actually does these days. 

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (6)

69

u/BossaNovva 15h ago

He popped on r/Leicester a couple of days ago, apparently a right bellend

17

u/stokesy1999 11h ago

Been to his shop a few times, its quite neat in that it has a lot of old school consoles and games, has a cafe bit, has a number of comics and has a few classic arcade machines you can play. A lot of products though are massively overpriced and the shop has got a massive amount of overpriced scalped Pokemon TCG stuff.

Tbh I doubt new game sales are much of this shops revenue at all, its about a 3 min walk from a Game store (UK version of Gamestop) and a CEX (UK 2nd hand games/electronics shop) and hidden away in a relatively quiet shopping arcade. Its more a shop for TCG fans, retro gaming fans and memorabilia collectors

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

35

u/7952 15h ago

And the game maker does not actually need to charge the game shop upfront when it is a download, they could activate at the till and take payment then.  

→ More replies (3)

30

u/No_Piece4797 15h ago

apparently he’s a right dickhead that is rude to customers and massively overcharges on pokémon cards and stuff

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (11)

48

u/cheeseinsidethecrust 15h ago

In nz it’s about $20 nzd cheaper for the box and you get a poster

6

u/Perfect-Insurance-33 13h ago

In Portugal it was also 15%/12€ cheaper on box pre sales

140

u/usenetguy99 16h ago

I bought it just to have something to give to my kid.

87

u/weeklygamingrecap 16h ago • Bravo

This is the answer the hive mind can't seem to understand. People still like to give gifts and a box just feels better than a slip of paper.orngift card. Even if that's all there is in the box. A box just looks nicer wrapped and that's all there is to it.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (19)

41

u/ThisKidIsAlright 15h ago • Bravo

I bought the physical copy so that the local independent game shop in my area gets at least a small cut of the GTA VI financial tidal wave.

19

u/DoubleSkew 15h ago

Present

Someone buying both console and GTA6 at same time

Physical video game collector

Gift card/in store credit/discount

9

u/Primary-Picture-5632 15h ago

some people collect them just for the box

→ More replies (1)

19

u/MonsTurkey 16h ago

I tried to get a box copy for the poster and to avoid giving Sony my credit card info. Walmart was sold out. So I bought PS gift cards from Sam's Club for below face value and bought it online.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/puudji 15h ago

The reason I keep coming up with is that maybe they need to pay with cash or some other transaction related reason.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Rebelgecko 14h ago

I wanted the poster

3

u/Elmusicoo 15h ago

Bought it through Walmart and got $10 of physical.

3

u/aspis 15h ago

I saved about 14 dollars on physical purchase vs PS Store. May depend on region, but competition between multiple stores can be helpful on pricing.

3

u/Educational_Eye3765 14h ago

Some people want the case, some people want to support a local store.

5

u/BuxtonEU 15h ago

To support the local business?

2

u/blissfully_insane22 14h ago

Cheaper in some places and get a poster. Easy

2

u/tidus9000 14h ago

I did this for one reason. It's £5 cheaper. Unfortunately I imagine being a small store, he has to charge at least the same or maybe even more to make a tiny profit

2

u/FastBinns 14h ago

I think you get a poster too

2

u/cjyoung92 14h ago

To support local businesses 

2

u/Frequent_Research690 13h ago

In my country it’s $20 cheaper to buy in store

→ More replies (71)

67

u/rensch 15h ago

I think the poster that came with my code-in-a-box was pretty neat.

Having that motherfucker download for nine hours was not.

6

u/blahblahshowmeurcat 6h ago

Oh dang you get a poster?? I am waiting until break to get it… I might go get the physical one now :)) I’d love one of those!!

→ More replies (13)

96

u/Have_A_Jelly_Baby 9h ago • Popcorn

I run an indie game store, and we didn’t bother with carrying it at all. Yeah, there’s been a few sad pandas that would have used store credit for it, or people that somehow didn't know it was a code in a box, but it wasn’t worth even attempting.

Also I can’t speak to every distributor or every store, but our cost would have been $63 to sell for $79. There’s a million other things I’d rather spend that money on with a far better margin.

33

u/Leviticus_Sux 8h ago

I mean, it's a 20% margin. That's not awful. But I imagine you sell a lot of used stuff which has a much higher margin I'm sure.

10

u/Have_A_Jelly_Baby 7h ago edited 6h ago

It's usually more like $60 for a $70 game. I can only assume GTA was the price it was because of its code in a box nature.

And the cheaper the game, the worse the margin. If I want Minecraft for instance, it's $25 for a game that sells for $30.

Point is, no one is getting rich from new game retail.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Talone7 7h ago

Also an indie game store owner and I’d love if you can DM me your distributor!

We go through Alliance and we’re much closer to $69 per unit.

6

u/Have_A_Jelly_Baby 7h ago

Royal Electronics Inc.

→ More replies (1)

672

u/danielzur2 16h ago

“I’ve only sold 5 pictures of bread”, says Leeds breadmaker.

113

u/lightningbadger 15h ago

Don't wanna assume we're dunking on this guy to support Sony now cause it's not his fault they stopped supplying stock

16

u/rivalrobot 13h ago

It was Rockstar’s decision in this case. They could have had a disc version if they wanted it. But even then you’d still need to download the game to your console’s storage. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

10

u/_Thermalflask 15h ago

Or "I've only sold 5 monkey jpegs" says tech bro

4

u/altodor 11h ago

The one difference in this case is that the guy's industry has historically been selling actual monkeys

→ More replies (2)

54

u/MrReesh 10h ago edited 6h ago

This was also posted to the Leicester subreddit where it was revealed that the shop owner is an arsehole. So yes it's a code in a box, but also the dude just sucks.

25

u/BigCommieMachine 13h ago

I am in the US and my local Walmart sold out of physical copies by noon.

Not sure if it is supply or demand issue.

→ More replies (3)

168

u/HibbletonFan 16h ago

Not to victim blame, but it was a bad idea to stock them in the first place. Unless he had an agreement with his distributor, there was no good reason to sink funds into inventory for GTA VI

58

u/OldGuto 15h ago

I wouldn't be surprised if he found out about the download codes at the same time as everyone else and there was no way out because of the contract. In the UK B2B contracts don't have the same protections as consumers do.

11

u/OfficeMagic1 15h ago

It would have helped if you could buy the box before launch day. I was thinking of stopping by Gamestop because I like having a box on my shelf, but I’d have to wait an extra day to start downloading it - and there were reports the codes were stolen on the supply chain. They were too cheap to make the codes a scratch off

→ More replies (2)

36

u/teraflux 16h ago

Also if it's just a download code, does he really have to spend $$ on it upfront?

28

u/Moonie-chan 15h ago

The thing with a physical release is that it's easier to return the product as is and get a refund. For a box with a download code it's a nightmare to refund you're better off doing that through digital platform.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/ThatMisterM 14h ago

His shop is mainly focused around retro games, Pokémon cards and geeky merch. They don't get huge numbers of many new releases anyway, so yeah, I don't know either.

→ More replies (1)

60

u/shiva_MMIV 15h ago

Meanwhile my sister works in a media store and they're selling hundreds of copies, an individual account is just anecdote, not proof of a trend.

→ More replies (4)

628

u/Silly_Off 16h ago

Dudes in the business of selling Pokémon to adults trying to do a get rich quick scheme. The time of selling video games from a game store is done.

344

u/DinobotsGacha 16h ago

A lot of gamers are very upset about this reality. Physical media is on life support.

74

u/ND7020 16h ago edited 15h ago

It’s the exact same thing as how car enthusiasts talk about manual transmissions. From car forums, you’d think there’s an ENORMOUS number of people just dying to buy manual versions of the cars.

Then when the car companies now occasionally do a manual version, they sell fucking abysmally. 

There are people who care deeply about physical media, yes. They’re pretty loud online. There aren’t enough to make it worthwhile for the companies to offer physical versions. 

→ More replies (9)

114

u/Silly_Off 16h ago

Gamers literally did it to themselves with their purchasing…..

48

u/GhostalMedia 15h ago

IMHO, people are mostly upset about the loss of secondary markets and software that can be bricked or deleted by a cloud provider.

Downloading software is great, but we need to have consumer protection laws that reflect the 2020s. A lot of our laws were drafted in the age of physical media.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (36)
→ More replies (24)

16

u/LePontif11 15h ago

No one opens a game shop expecting to get rich, let alone quick

→ More replies (1)

50

u/theonlydjm 15h ago

Card and games shop owners are not scalpers dude...

→ More replies (7)

23

u/Jwagner0850 15h ago

Wow what a crappy way to frame that

39

u/LeastResistancePath 16h ago edited 16h ago

That's a very weird way to say he's a licensed vendor of the pokemon trading card game. A legitimate business that sells cards to children and adults.

For some reason you make it sound like he's snarling and laughing as sobbing children walk out of the store because the evil adults bought them all.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/rokman 16h ago

I have friends who run game stores, they are working hard to build gaming events. The days of sitting behind a counter and waiting for money to fall in your lap is over. You have to actually work now

18

u/llamapanther 15h ago

I have no idea why this comment attacking a business owner trying to make it on a legitimate business model is this upvoted? Get rich quick scheme? What the fuck are you even on about you act like this is some billionaire owner??

The time of selling video games from a game store might be done, but what does that have to do with Pokemon cards?? God I fucking hate smug redditors like you

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Syndfull 14h ago

Yikes you're completely right. Just went to that local subreddit and they hate him.

He caters to Pokemon card customers and treats everyone like shit, apparently.

2

u/itsapotatosalad 15h ago

Those cards will be way overpriced, making people think everything he sells is scalped.

→ More replies (9)

47

u/Sea_Scientist_8367 9h ago

They did this on purpose.

Release "physical" copies. Then are gonna prattle these shop owners out saying "I didn't hardly sell any" as "proof" that no one buys physical games anymore.

Even though the "physical" game is just a digital download, which is why no one gave a fuck about them in the first place.

Yes it's dumb, but these are the Tech companies we're talking about, they really do think you're that fucking stupid.

10

u/BigImplement3949 7h ago

They don't need to prove anything, they made a business decision. If they want to reverse it they can if they want to keep it going they will

→ More replies (3)

73

u/GullyBean 15h ago

It’s crazy. We really gave up ownership in reality

→ More replies (15)

52

u/escientia 15h ago

For as much money take 2 invested in the game they should have done the fans some service with a full physical release featuring a disc, map, poster. Everything that made opening a R* game memorable.

8

u/xiaz_ragirei 15h ago

i mean…isnt there a $200 collectors edition that doesn’t even include the game?

3

u/ronreadingpa 13h ago

I'm not up on gaming, but presume games with discs often don't contain everything and still need to download patches to actually play.

The days of new game physical releases are long over. Game makers offloading the cost onto ISPs and one's time for downloading.

Certainly see an opportunity for gaming studios to release physical games after they've been out for a while as a retro thing. Issue is many newer games rely on remote servers to remain playable for an extended period of time.

Much of the 21st century gaming will be lost as digital downloads degrade, are deleted, servers go offline, etc. Traditional pressed discs can last decades. And for those taking time to archive, even longer. Emulators also exist for older game systems.

14

u/OverLordJezus 15h ago edited 14h ago

No disc is so shit. Though the pin up poster made my girlfriend gasp. That was pretty memorable lol

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (32)

7

u/BloOdy_Jo 7h ago

Nobody goes outside to buy an empty box

53

u/szucs2020 15h ago

I don't know if this is a hot take or whatever but I'd still rather buy the stupid game code copy of GTA. Let me explain. When the publishers run their own stores they take a bigger cut of sales. Now normally that would result in somewhat lower prices, or at least some steam levels sales. However these console publishers refuse to lower the prices while taking often 30-40% more of a cut. That's just greedy. EB Games just got bought back in Canada. If we can't have lower prices then I'd rather spread that money around and provide a few local jobs than have it all go to one or two greedy corporations.

9

u/crownpr1nce 15h ago

When the publishers run their own stores they take a bigger cut of sales

That doesn't make sense: the publisher doesn't run the digital store. Take Two doesn't sell directly, Sony or Microsoft (or Steam in the future) is the storefront. So Sony takes their cut, the same way Best Buy does, for a different kind of service. We can debate whether the service is worthy of an equivalent cut, but that's a different argument than comparing physical stores to online stores when both are ran by third parties. 

→ More replies (6)

12

u/Kougeru-Sama 10h ago

that's the goal. Sony rakes in most of the money

33

u/jamsonDASH 16h ago

This guy is a massive prick so I don't think he should get any sympathy

14

u/withloveandsqualor99 15h ago

Can confirm. Leicester subreddit says it all.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/HumansNeedNotApply1 16h ago

Sadly, there's no much point in buying the physical version as it doesn't have a disk.

2

u/elegance78 15h ago

If the virtue signallers crying about death of high street (which they never visit anyway) could read, they would be very upset...

10

u/Rhylanor-Downport 8h ago

No one comes in for VHS tapes any more says Leicester video rental store owner.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Smallville456 15h ago

Because it's not an actual copy of the game

5

u/Strugglingaccordian 13h ago

I bought it in a local shop. It’s was £5 cheaper and I got a poster. 

5

u/Infinite-Prune3612 4h ago

As expected for a digital only game

30

u/InfaSyn 14h ago

210gb on launch day though - That would be 6 blu rays if physical. Who in their right mind would buy a physical box with a download code when you could just buy it online? (Other than needing to pay cash)

11

u/The_Schwy 14h ago

"CARTRIDGES", billion dollar missed opportunity.

→ More replies (8)

12

u/Weak-Design-3207 14h ago

Bluray is 100GB

6

u/InfaSyn 14h ago

Only the quad layer ones. Single layer was 25GB, dual layer 50GB's became "the standard"/most common. Quad Layer wouldn't be cost effective plus youd still need a third disc (thats larger than the 8.7GB dual layer DVD)

→ More replies (2)

8

u/xAeroMonkeyx 13h ago

I bought the physical on Amazon because it was £65 whereas it was £70 on the ps store

→ More replies (12)

10

u/PM_ME_YOUR_BUG5 14h ago • Bravo

Doesn't need to hold a whole game. Just needs to hold a license.

→ More replies (12)

2

u/gandalfmarston 13h ago edited 13h ago

In my country it was cheaper than buying it on PSN

→ More replies (72)

4

u/OctoMatter 14h ago

They should have added a physical map minimum.

4

u/TottallyNotToxec 13h ago

The only time it makes sense to buy a case with a code in is for other people. So probably get a few sales for christmas.

4

u/Dreams-Visions 12h ago

Did you really sell a “copy” if there is nothing in the box?

4

u/jleonardbc 12h ago

You wouldn't steal a Grand Theft Auto...

4

u/Soft-Bad-7127 11h ago

How many people want the case and poster 

4

u/Slow-Worth-7685 9h ago

The downside for consumers, you cant trade anything in anymore 🤷‍♂️.  No secondary market exists for video games.  

14

u/IssueEmbarrassed8103 16h ago

It’s just a case with a download code. Why would people leave home for that?

9

u/Toothache42 15h ago

Some cases dont even have the code in, and refunds are less than forthcoming

6

u/crownpr1nce 15h ago

There's a few reasons - gift, game collection display, gift cards, rebate - but they are overall a small percentage of people. 

A good reason could be supporting a local shop rather than a multinational or chain, but in the physical game industry that seems to be a Sisyphus task. 

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Ornery_Run2700 15h ago

I bought it for the poster. People will miss out on it and not care, but it's the little things that feel less dystopian.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/metahipster1984 11h ago

In June, developer Rockstar Games said physical copies would contain a code for a digital download rather than the more traditional format.

Why even call it a "physical copy" when it's not lol.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/rockadial 12h ago

The thing that bothers me the most is game companies will point to the sales of GTA and be like see we don't need to make physical media even though it's a false data point since consumers weren't given an option to buy something in the format they prefer.

9

u/catadvice02143 11h ago

They’ve been given that option for everything since the PS4 days and the data has pretty loudly indicated that they’re ready to move on from discs at this point

→ More replies (3)

6

u/GroinShotz 11h ago

That's crazy... 95% of games in 2024 were downloaded versions... Seems like people preferred the download.

Even on consoles... 30% of games sold were physical copies...

The only platform that sells more physical copies is Nintendo... And I'm guessing that crowd is mostly under 18.

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (10)

14

u/Lythieus 13h ago

Man selling a code in a box is shocked that nobody is buying said code in a box. 

→ More replies (1)

6

u/anarchychaotic 16h ago

Not just games, the entire highstreet is drying up. Its all online now. 

6

u/BaconBourbonBalista 15h ago

Well ya. I would have preferred to buy the game in a brick and mortar store, but if it's not on a disk I'm not going to buy an empty case for no reason

6

u/TheSauciestBoss 13h ago

Right, because it’s digital, I’m not traveling to purchase a code

8

u/Sybertron 8h ago

IMO this is just some ridiculous game industry shit. They need to get the fuck over themselves. Discs aren't THAT expensive to produce and yet more than support themselves with sales and who wouldnt like to save around 100gb in the download size.

And hey if ya really want, since ya know the language the box is printed in, hey look at that you dont need to include the language packs for every single language the game ships in. You can cut that file size down MASSIVELY. Hell you can even have an in game option to download a different language if ya really want.

Which are all great points; but also this game is gonna make 4 billion dollars in its first weekend. Pay for the fucking discs guys.

3

u/smokincuban 14h ago

We've sold 6 copies of an empty box

3

u/NotANokiaInDisguise 12h ago

Yeah? It's a download code in a plastic case man. I want the map/poster too but not that badly. Especially not with all the posts I've seen of people using a flashlight on the case and redeeming the code before anyone buys it

3

u/corporateavengerkast 11h ago

well yeah. what's the point of driving down to the shop to buy a case with a code in it when you can just buy it via the online store? for a poster? no. there's no point.

Of course you weren't going to sell them Richard, why did you order them in the first place?

3

u/markender 8h ago

Dwnvoye for misleading title you scumbags bot.

3

u/b100jb100 6h ago

Must be because of the bike lane they installed on the shop's street last year

/s

22

u/Vegetable_Treacle326 15h ago

I bet if he had a record shop he wouldn't sell many CDs either.

23

u/Lingo56 15h ago

The funny thing is this isn’t even true, many record shops are opening CD sections these days because they’re more trendy and cheaper than Vinyl.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Yourdjentpal 15h ago

Idk they’re coming back right now man

7

u/Illustrious_Mess2654 14h ago

People aren’t buying physical versions because of reports of people using flashlights to look into the digital code without even opening the box or the plastic wrap

7

u/jcode7090 12h ago

Everyone wanted to pre load it anyway. You were behind if you bought it in store to punch in a code and THEN went to download it.

2

u/impactblue5 12h ago

Amazon and other retailers shipped it a week before launch to pre load

→ More replies (2)

5

u/graffiksguru 15h ago

Unfortunately, that is bound to happen when you make it download only. I hate that they did this. I used to sell them to GameStop after I beat them.

He should have more sales come Christmas when people buy and wrap presents, hard to wrap digital.

5

u/Free-Pound-6139 13h ago

Sure, but last month he sold 0.

4

u/PrinceCastanzaCapone 13h ago

Nobody wants to take a chance on an already redeemed code

→ More replies (1)

4

u/FrogsJumpFromPussy 11h ago

Because it makes no sense to buy an empty case. 

7

u/Sasquatchjc45 15h ago

And Rockstar sold nearly $4b worth of digital downloads.

Just like that, the consumers have told the industry "we actually dont care if you get rid of physical media, we'll still buy the games!"

2

u/browhodouknowhere 15h ago

Nah my wife gave me the game for my birthday...I wanted the box haha

2

u/MiyamotoKnows 13h ago

I'll buy it in the future when it comes out on disc(s). If there will be no physical version though I will skip it. So many other game studios to reward for their commitment to physical media.

2

u/Silver-Original-4088 13h ago

You get a poster tooo

2

u/Aggravating_Solid560 12h ago

I live in Leicester and have been here a few times, great place and everything, but why would anybody get a physical copy of a digital only game. Bring back discs

2

u/FuryMaker 11h ago

Some people think the physical box will be worth something.

I heard that the code expires after a few years though?

2

u/gibbon_dejarlais 11h ago

But it has the automatic pre-order of Metal Gear Solid 5, and a map of Japan!

2

u/deffener 11h ago

Still waiting for the pc release :)

2

u/Negative_Prize1587 11h ago

The Pokemon tcg crowd and the gt6 crowd might not have as big of an overlap as he expected.

Might also be noone has an idea he sells gta6, in this photo for gta6 there is 0 promo material at least.

2

u/8BitsAreEnoughForMe 11h ago

Lets see ... in the UK they could have released an instore only, internationally highly desirable, collectors edition. They could still do so. Physical media only. Ding. Oh, £99. Why not if it's good?!

2

u/dedokta 8h ago

The game is 212gb. PS5 disc can hold 100gb, so you'd need 3 discs and you'd have to install it anyway. Might be worthwhile for people without good internet access, but otherwise there would be little point.

A cartridge system might be a better deal, with the cartridge holding SSD drives so it doesn't fill your main drive.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/faafoe 4h ago

It was cheaper to buy in-store here in NZ so there's that

2

u/Deervember 3h ago

There was a quote about his shop on another sub.

"I'm probably going to get downvoted for this, but honestly, I don't really care.

GTA aside..

I've known Richard on and off for around 15 years, and I've never found him particularly pleasant to deal with. In my experience, his prices are often excessive, and he can be incredibly awkward. One minute he's friendly and acts like he knows you, and the next he'll completely ignore you.

Personally, I've never been a fan of how he treats people or runs his business, and I certainly wouldn't recommend his overpriced shop. "

On his Facebook store page he only brought 4 copies of gta6, so people are wondering how he even sold 5.

Everyone is calling him a terrible person and to avoid his store. 

2

u/justvoop 3h ago

I went to buy a copy from gamestop so i could get the poster and box for the shelf but they were sold out. I guess it depends on the location

2

u/Snoringdog83 1h ago

Hes not bothered about GTA sales coz they are a sale or return item. Hes literally advertisong the scalper priced pokemon cards behind him.

2

u/istefan24 1h ago

Yeah the game is a flop /s

2

u/ratherbewinedrunk 8h ago

I'm really tired of my feed being astro-turfed by posts about this fucking game.

2

u/cloudsourced285 6h ago

Seems Australia had a rare experience compared to the rest of the world. Most people I know bought the game physically from a store becuaee we could get it slightly cheaper than purchasing online. Makes zero sense and actually frustrates me. But in this economy I'll take any discount I can.

2

u/jasonology09 1h ago

There was no reasonable way to sell a game that size on physical media. If there was, I would've gotten it, as I always prefer physical media.

7

u/Dubante_Viro 15h ago • Bravo

I think a lot of the "digital is dead" comments are bots. Why the fuck would anyone care so much about people buying a fysical box dor a digital game. If you are human, you're a loser if you are unwilling to understand that some people like to give a gift to their friend or family that you can hold in your hand. You do have to have people in your life that you care about, maybe that's your problem?

Also, some people like to collect things. You don't have to get mad at them just because you lack the abbility to understand that.

4

u/krossoverking 14h ago

No disc no buy. 

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Humble_Hipster 15h ago

I work in small town video game store and in the last 4 days we’ve sold probably 60+ copies 🤷

4

u/Brofessorofnothing 14h ago

but why get the digital without case when you can get the case for the same price with the code?

10

u/gottagetstabbed123 14h ago

I want a physical version with the actual disc that I own. Not just to own the case sitting on a shelf.

→ More replies (11)

3

u/Joszef77 13h ago

Somebody from Spain is posting videos on tiktok explaining how she bough a copy in MediaMarkt just to find out the code was already used. MediaMarkt of course has been nothing but unhelpful.

11

u/WillingPlayed 14h ago

Why bring plastic crap into this transaction? It does nothing.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/CranberryStock7148 13h ago

Why would I want some kind of plastic case that holds nothing and that I will eventually just toss so it winds up in a landfill somewhere?

If it's really important to you to show it off on your bookshelf or something like a collectible, then fantastic for you. No judgment.

But for the 99% of people who don't need random plastic shit cluttering up their house, you can understand why they prefer to get digital without the case for the same price.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/globalrebel 13h ago

I fully believe they did that shitty “code can be seen through packaging” shit just to drive home that physical copies should go away.

It’s fucking annoying