r/technology • • 12h ago

Security Defense firm’s EMP ‘Dragon’ weapon fries 51 jam-proof drones simultaneously — high-power electromagnetic system relies on 120-year-old vacuum tube tech to defeat fiber optic UAVs

https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/drones/defense-firms-emp-dragon-weapon-fries-51-jam-proof-drones-simultaneously-high-power-electromagnetic-system-relies-on-120-year-old-vacuum-tube-tech-to-defeat-fiber-optic-uavs
431 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

55

u/West-Vacation8190 11h ago

first, no mention of how far these 51 were away from the dish. that they're not bragging it's 20km away suggests they drones were lined up in front of it. the magic 120yo vacuum tube tech used is probably a magnetron. there's one inside every microwave oven. .

25

u/discostu52 10h ago

Most high power RF broadcasts amplifiers still use vacuum tubes. Hard to believe but they are still arguably better than solid state

31

u/mytyan 9h ago

Silicon breaks down at high voltages. It's that simple. You can stack them for higher voltage performance but they have a cascading failure problem.

Vacuum tubes have a long proven record of reliable high energy applications and try as they might the solid state crowd has not come up with anything better

8

u/Zilithahz 9h ago

Nobody tries to make anything better because vacuum tubes are really good and inexpensive. Even if we had a better solid state solution it would probably cost significantly more.

11

u/mytyan 9h ago

Actually they did try. I participated in some trials when I was working in the field decades ago. They worked but were not robust enough

2

u/Zilithahz 9h ago

Oh wow, thats pretty cool :)

1

u/-hh 6h ago

IIRC, must have been at San Antonio, as Leonardwood didn’t get approved.

3

u/hootblah1419 2h ago

This is so false it has to be an AI hallucination. All new Navy radar's like Spy 6 is GaN, thaad big radar GaN, next patriot radar - GaN, newest and next gen air radars - GaN..

2

u/Future-Bandicoot-823 7h ago

Does carbon?

I've read some interesting articles about graphene microchips, it'd be interesting what we could accomplish with something more stable at high voltage than silicon.

1

u/TowardsTheImplosion 6h ago

Do you think GaAN or SIC will be able to catch up?

2

u/hootblah1419 3h ago

it already did. Every modern top end radar going on ships/air/land is GaN, GaN on SiC, or LDMOS

1

u/adaminc 4h ago

Some advanced phased array radar systems use GaN semiconductors.

Epirus has developed a directed energy weapon called Leonidas that uses GaN already, I don't know if it uses phased arrays, but it uses a Software Defined Radio, and it's APV mountable. They also made a tiny version that goes on larger quadcopter style drones.

I wonder if this other company is using vacuum tubes because they may not be as susceptible to counterattack with similar weapons.

1

u/ChPech 1h ago

Semiconductors already have. Most people are not aware about the improvements they made in the last 25 years because it was a series of small steps. Only now that GAN is being used by marketing people, it's entered the public awareness.

Look at very high voltage DC transmission lines up to a million volts. Those have only become possible due to the semiconductor advancements. With regular transformers you can only do AC and tubes are not so happy when you try to push several gigawatts through them.

3

u/CatsAreGods 9h ago

I saw the video and you're basically right (maybe 500 meters away). And a huge installation and dish.

1

u/nemesit 2h ago

its also a huge target due to its rf signature

1

u/socialmedia-username 10h ago

Scaling up is the key for sure. 

-2

u/Talkie123 10h ago

Kind of like in the movie "The Pentagon Wars". They had to strap dozens of hot plates and parabolic bathroom heaters to a tank so that a heat seaking missle that was fired from 50 feet away could hit it.

51

u/mytyan 11h ago

Frying electronics with massive blasts of electromagnetic energy is something many people have been working on since the first atomic bomb tests.

The US military has been testing them for years

28

u/vbpatel 10h ago

They’ve even been already in use by burglars since at least Oceans 11

11

u/DukeOfGeek 8h ago

Obligatory Explosively Pumped Flux Compression Generator wiki

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Explosively_pumped_flux_compression_generator

The image that looks like a Kodachrome snap isn't a filter, the tech has been around that long.

-8

u/1_am_not_a_b0t 8h ago

My personal conspiracy theory is all of these data centers, and AI is a push by the billionaires to create digital immortality. Sort of skan your brain then upload. And the EMP‘s are the reason that muskrat wants to place the data centers in space.
Obligatory fuck musk/fuck Nazis

19

u/mytyan 8h ago

EMPs work way better in space

2

u/warbastard 2h ago

Yeah it’s something war gamed in a nuclear exchange if a nuke goes off in the upper atmosphere all the satellites get fried by EMP which would be catastrophic for modern life and its reliance on satellites.

1

u/A_Harmless_Fly 37m ago

There are naturally occurring EMPs in space stronger than anything we could put together as a species.

eg. coronal mass ejections, high speed magnetic body collisions, solar flares etc.

44

u/1_am_not_a_b0t 11h ago

Now launch them at the data centers

59

u/Fateor42 11h ago

Not the first company to go that route.

And you can't really protect "cheep" drones against that sort of technology.

10

u/9-11GaveMe5G 8h ago

That's the hope. Raise the cost of attacks to lower the prevalence

14

u/This-Construction926 11h ago

In this case, you got to make sure your drones.. and other electrical systems aren't in the path of the EMP 

12

u/richardelmore 10h ago

How to tell us you've never heard of Klystron tubes, without telling us you've never heard of Klystron tubes.

Tube amplifiers are rare in low power applications these days but are still widely used in high power RF applications like radar and deep space communications.

5

u/Quarkspiration 10h ago

Oh yeah, me and my buddy made one of those a couple years back from an old satellite dish and 4 magnetrons we got out of some microwaves at the dump

3

u/DotExternal9961 11h ago

Defense firm? Why not give the name?

2

u/DoNotMakeEmpty 4h ago

This comment chain also did not say the name.

It is ASELSAN, a Turkish (and biggest one in Turkey currently) defense firm.

0

u/serrated_edge321 10h ago

Maybe they're trying to entice you to actually read the article?

Or the name is obscure enough that it's better just to describe who they are. Both could be valid in this case.

1

u/DotExternal9961 9h ago

For some reason they are the only one who thought of not giving the name would be enticing for readers, oh and sure this firm is so obscure better not give the name of it in the header..

3

u/serrated_edge321 8h ago

I mean it's written in the article...

It's a Turkish defense company that even I've never heard of, and I've worked in the industry (also with Turkish people) for some decades now. It's not exactly a big/well-known name.

0

u/DotExternal9961 8h ago

The biggest defense company in Turkey, among the top ten in Europe. There is no way you haven't heard of it.

3

u/serrated_edge321 8h ago

You're definitely not working in the field yourself.

This company (I looked it up) sells almost nothing in the markets I've lived in/worked in. Just starting now we're going to potentially have an overlap. Also: they went on a hiring spree in the last 3 years... It wasn't nearly as big until very recently.

Anyone in the aviation sector of defense has plenty of other/much larger companies to know vs this one. Ground systems don't make much of an appearance at our conferences, expos, & other events.

2

u/U3011 7h ago

I do not work in your industry but I have heard of them, but for lesser hardware most of it used within their country. I find most of their indigenous hardware is sold to partner nations but western nations tend to buy from bigger well established companies or specialist companies from Europe. It is a bit like the wingman some other company made the news with this week. Great advancement, but most nations would sooner buy from better known more west friendly countries.

TLDR: I am in full agreement with you.

3

u/Future-Bandicoot-823 7h ago

"120-year-old vacuum tube tech"

That's the interesting thing about technology. New technology mixing with old, long forgotten methods provide for some impressive results.

I wonder if we'll hear more about technology that mixes the old with new in coming years.

2

u/boli99 11h ago

51 = suspicious precision

0

u/PartyClock 11h ago

Numbers 52-100 seemed to still find the target just fine

2

u/tarpit84 4h ago

Warm vintage tube amp tonez

1

u/RevenueChemical6910 5h ago

There was a video earlier today covering a system from a different firm: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vrjdv9F74KU

0

u/super_shizmo_matic 7h ago

What they aren't telling you is the warm-up time. This is why the active area denial system has a horrific warm-up time. It's because it has tubes in it. You can't turn this system on and hit drones. It has to be on at least four hours ahead of time.

2

u/pbizzle 4h ago

So just have it on all the time?

1

u/ThoseWhoAre 3h ago

Most likely you gotta use what intelligence you can gather to know the best times to turn it on. Not an impossible feat to achieve but certainly not easy. Its capability is certainly limited by this but its not useless either.

1

u/jphamlore 4h ago

Just call it the Death Star.

-3

u/NullContribution 10h ago

Okay, so one (1) cruise missile to knock out the jammer, and then it's just buisness as usual.

5

u/Fateor42 9h ago

These kind of defenses are usually layered to prevent things like that.

So you would have this for cheap drones, a laser system for expensive drones, and interceptor missiles for cruise missiles.

4

u/A_Seiv_For_Kale 10h ago

Needing to expend a cruise missile to unlock the ability to use cheap drones seems like a hard counter to inexpensive warfare tactics.

-2

u/NullContribution 9h ago

I was using cruise missiles as a example since it was the first ranged weapon that came to mind. Doesn't have to be cruise missiles, you could just make one hardened drone that is resistant to this type of jamming and then knock the defense out.

-5

u/hugelkult 11h ago

Fiber uavs are obsolete

1

u/mtranda 2h ago

This thing fries electronics in general. The fiber part was mentioned in contrast to radio controlled drones which could be jammed from further away.