r/technology • u/ControlCAD • 11h ago
Networking/Telecom Prisons get OK to jam contraband phones. CTIA says nearby phones will be jammed too. | CTIA said jamming test showed “interference… up to two and a half miles away.”
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2026/11/prisons-get-ok-to-jam-contraband-phones-ctia-says-nearby-phones-will-be-jammed-too/
992
Upvotes
385
u/Educational_Work896 11h ago edited 11h ago
Surely old-school pre-GPS cell phone triangulation can identify phones within a prison. Block those phones at the carrier level.
Alternatively, contract a company to install a simple version of a Stingray system to intercept nearby non-whitelisted devices by their IMEI.
47
u/KidKarez 10h ago
If it could jam an innocent parties phone then it shouldn't be allowed period
138
u/edman007 11h ago
Why do they need jammers? Does noone make a cell phone locator?
I would think if you're so concerned about cell phone use in a prison, you'd just put cell phone detectors and it will give you the cell with the phone in it, which is way better than just jamming them. And no, it's not difficult to do this.
59
u/reverendsteveii 8h ago
America does this neat thing where there's no limit to who can get hurt or how much as long as you can also an argument that one person deserves it
60
u/Dalek_Chaos 11h ago
Gonna be real interesting for compounds like Fort Worth Medical Center where there's apartments within throwing distance of the compound.
29
u/Single-Pin-369 10h ago
how does this address the issue that most contraband like phones get in by the guards themselves?
26
u/Existing-Return-5308 11h ago
Sam, I Tried to call your lawyer as we agreed. But the prison made sure the phone connection failed.
Oh, and I called 911 about the heart attack of Miriam. Call would not go though…
12
u/PluralMimsy 11h ago
Seems bad?
19
u/HorzaDonwraith 11h ago
Be ashame if I needed to call police after witnessing a prisoner running free within two miles of the prison.
15
u/Time_Difference_6682 8h ago
this is gonna backfire so hard.
4
u/DaSpawn 8h ago
would be way smarter to put in a fake cell tower to capture the calls and/or triangulate the calls
so beyond stupid to block all calls which would include emergency calls
7
u/Zilithahz 10h ago
As a SWE this seems like the shittiest possible technical solution to this problem
3
u/AbyssumBorealis 10h ago
Makes sense to put jammers in a remote facility but what about prisons in metro areas. Even Bastrop fci has houses right next door.
3
u/rzarectha 4h ago
so no concern this may interfere with emergency services for people living nearby?
8
u/Bonerballs 9h ago
Just put a huge Faraday cage around the prison and only have wired phone lines. Make it the Battlestar Galactica of prisons
2
u/Bitey_the_Squirrel 7h ago
This won’t be a problem unless it affects a corporation. Then it will get fixed fast.
2
u/Taurondir 6h ago
Ok so maybe I have zero idea on how technolofy works, so feel free to correct me:
Why, ffs, can't a prison deploy an antenna ON the prison, in sush a way that ALL phones will try to connect to that and not DISTANT towers, so they can white list and black list phones and so whatever filtering they want.
The distant towers can triangulate, right? SO they can stop any calls from within the Prison area coordinates, so that one or more towers only allow traffic being passed to them from the Prison antenna.
What exactly am I missing here?
3
u/factoid_ 10h ago
These phones connect to networks. Ask the phone companies to block all phones not on a white list
2
u/creamersrealm 10h ago
Or just use a giant Femotcell like they do in big commercial buildings and allowlist them. Doesn't stop guards from handing over phones but sure as hell restricts it and they should be using walkies anyways.
2
u/bananajr6000 7h ago
Maybe prisons should be more than 2 1/2 miles from civilization
1
u/rudebii 9h ago
Shot callers and leaders of criminal organizations are already put in more secure facilities. It’s harder for them to get phones, but guards at those facilities are crooked too.
Inmates are getting contraband, including phones, from guards. Jamming signals causes all sorts of problems while only solving one.
1
u/teh_maxh 9h ago
Were they trying to come up with such a terrible R&O?
1
u/silentaba 6h ago
I spent time in a minimum security prison where good behaviour prisoners such as myself could buy a switch. You could absolutely walk around at night (yeah, no lockdown prison farm) and find open hotspots with the switch, it was Hella funny.
1
u/Party_Cold_4159 2h ago
Wonder if using a mobile cell tower would be better. Kinda like those cell interceptors used by governments.
Then they could track who’s phone is who based on distance. Possibly set up a geofence too. There are ways around that, but it seems better than jamming.
It’s also incredibly easy to bug sweep for phones. This just seems like a lazy solution more than it being something that works better.
1
u/locktheclocck 1h ago
A jammer can't tell a smuggled handset from a nurse's phone two miles away, because the RF ignores the fence. The targeted alternative is managed access, a local cell that only lets known handsets attach. Blanket jamming just moves the cost onto the neighbours.
1
u/welshdude1983 1h ago
Make a fake mast in the prison. It forces all the phones to connect to it imei details sent to local towers not to let them connect
1
u/Left_on_Pause 10h ago
Jammed so their inhumane treatment of people can't be shown.
1
u/Sterkzal 10h ago
Thus is already existing technology deployed at several prisons in California. Several prison sites I have worked at have cell jammers deployed. No service for miles outside the site.
1
u/viginti_tres 10h ago
Install these in cinemas.
-3
u/mattl33 10h ago
Sorry but what actually is the downside of just letting prisoners communicate? I realize that's probably naive but, I have fortunately not been to prison.
0
u/SnufferMonster 9h ago
How about instead we invest in a camera system that doesn't look like it records from an old potato and loses minutes every day?
Something that works even in high security areas maybe?
-1
u/ComedyBits 10h ago
Cells in the cells? Oh no
-27
u/AnarchySpeech 11h ago
About darn time. Crazy it took this long.