r/technology • • 11h ago

Networking/Telecom Prisons get OK to jam contraband phones. CTIA says nearby phones will be jammed too. | CTIA said jamming test showed “interference… up to two and a half miles away.”

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2026/11/prisons-get-ok-to-jam-contraband-phones-ctia-says-nearby-phones-will-be-jammed-too/
992 Upvotes

160 comments sorted by

385

u/Educational_Work896 11h ago edited 11h ago

Surely old-school pre-GPS cell phone triangulation can identify phones within a prison. Block those phones at the carrier level.  

Alternatively, contract a company to install a simple version of a Stingray system to intercept nearby non-whitelisted devices by their IMEI.  

280

u/Existing-Return-5308 11h ago • Bravo

US prisons are money making ventures.

Staff have ZERO incentive to find anything (since that allows the endless $10000 search efforts).

If you were to tell me that. Certain staff and certain long term inmates have a (shush) deal to arrange for search-failure, I would totally believe you.

Its USA; and corrupt to the core.

71

u/RarelyReadReplies 10h ago

It's pretty much a guarantee that every prison has at least 1 crooked CO. Probably one of the reasons people sign up for that job is to abuse prisoners and take advantage of the power dynamic.

28

u/probablynotaskrull 10h ago

Please explain about the $10000 searches. As a foreigner, I don’t understand.

34

u/Existing-Return-5308 9h ago

If you spend 100 hours, preparing for (10h), doing (10), continuing (30h), de-briefing (10h), articulating policy for (40),

At 10 people per stage, at union wages, plus contractor over head @3x,

It comes to $10, 000 dollars per intervention.

Given the tax payer is paying, who gives a shit?

8

u/goodguyatheist 10h ago

you have to pay the cops to come in and do these big searches I imagine alot of times they hire outside cops to come in for the big sweeps thats alot of money going into pigs pockets from gearing up to do the searches to forensics looking at the contraband than all the paperwork that goes into it and taking on new charges on the prisoners for having contraband to doing investigations on how the contraband got in etc etc. Every single person in every part of the chain is getting paid its alot of fucking money

2

u/khearan 4h ago

They are pulling it out of their ass. It’s obviously a safety concern for guards and inmates if an inmate has fashioned a knife out of something. Searches are conducted by guards who already work there. They stand paying hourly for a sweep. It’s a normal part of a guard’s responsibilities. Everything is a conspiracy on Reddit.

16

u/Mobile_Morale 8h ago

My local prison had an undercover bust by the FBI a few years ago. They found guards bringing in contraband and all sorts of shit. One female guard was fucking an inmate.

They found so much shit inside that prison. And the guards were the ones bringing it in. Except someone was using a drone to drop cell phones into the prison.

7

u/Leafy0 8h ago

I mean with the stingray they could just figure out who has the phones confiscate them.

1

u/Ecto-1A 6h ago

Many prisons are already running stingray type devices and monitoring all devices

1

u/airfryerfuntime 3h ago

They do, but it's pretty difficult when the phone is only on for as long as it takes to send a text message. 5G is also a lot more secure against Stingray type systems.

0

u/Black_Moons 1h ago

Alternatively, just extend a chicken wire cage over the top of the prison and you'll block all carriers (Faraday cage), and stop all those pesky drones from dropping contraband in the exercise yard as an added bonus.

But also they could just have their own triangulation equipment installed on the edges of the prison and detect if any RF signals are being emitted from inside the area and where, likely within a few feet.

-12

u/Blazing1 8h ago

whats the point most people use phones just to contact loved ones.

if they gave prisoners access to their loved ones on a normal device this shit wouldnt be needed

10

u/Hotrian 7h ago

Gang members use phones to continue operating from behind bars

-20

u/Blazing1 7h ago

Well maybe there's something wrong your countries culture

47

u/KidKarez 10h ago

If it could jam an innocent parties phone then it shouldn't be allowed period

28

u/slayermcb 9h ago

Last I knew it was a federal violation to do so as it restricts an individuals ability to call 911.

14

u/27Rench27 9h ago

Feds just said it was okay, so fuck it we ball I guess

10

u/slayermcb 9h ago

We'll see if there's not a lawsuit to follow

8

u/Frequent-Test-3012 8h ago

With a settlement paid by the oh so generous taxpayers

138

u/edman007 11h ago

Why do they need jammers? Does noone make a cell phone locator?

I would think if you're so concerned about cell phone use in a prison, you'd just put cell phone detectors and it will give you the cell with the phone in it, which is way better than just jamming them. And no, it's not difficult to do this.

148

u/FruitApprehensive603 11h ago

It’s a matter of the guards being the ones who bring them in and facilitate usage

9

u/junkyard_robot 10h ago

They also make cell phones small enough to sneak in without xray checks.

17

u/WhenAmI 10h ago

The new trend is drones flying over the prison walls and dropping packages off.

7

u/FruitApprehensive603 8h ago

Regardless of what you think, those drones are not going unnoticed by the COs. If the CO’s wanted to they could shut that down fast. They just don’t want to.

-4

u/Stunning_Grocery_762 8h ago

Back in the day when "Tent City" was still a thing in Arizona, people would literally just go to the side of the prison that abutted the street and throw packages of drugs over the wall. Worked pretty well.

25

u/liquorfish 10h ago

20 years ago i had a pen or something that woukd light up with cell phone activity. Usually let you know a call was coming in before the phone rang.

That was a toy. Pretty sophisticated stuff exists now I imagine.. just sounds like theyre lazy and stupid to come up with this idea.

18

u/mrizzerdly 9h ago

Lol man I remember when I could hear a tone pattern on my headset before my phone rang, like 20 years ago.

10

u/StanknBeans 9h ago

That was the wireless technology of the time, hasn't really been a thing since 3G came along.

-12

u/Ophiochos 10h ago

Maybe? Why does everyone on Reddit assume that people who know about stuff are all lazy or incompetent?

Someone is an experienced engineer and therefore gets asked to tackle this and they say ‘nah fuck it I’ll make up some shit so I can home early’. Or maybe things aren’t as simple as they look to someone who knows, from what you’ve said, virtually nothing?;)

Do you really think they asked some rando who doesn’t know about how it works?

19

u/liquorfish 10h ago
  • Cell Site Stimulators (Stingray). This uses fake towers that emit stronger signals that can then triangulate the cell phone location. Used by military, intelligence, and law enforcement.
  • Specialized hardware exists that can detect rf signals used by 3g, 4g,5g, wifi, Bluetooth etc - often used in prisons
  • RF receivers and spectrum analyzers can be used to detect signals / signal strength to detect devices in use.

I said I imagine much more sophisticated equipment should be available. Emphasis on sophisticated. I know the technology was there but didnt bother looking it up.

I 100% stand by what I said in regards to them being lazy fucks. The technology exists and has been in use in other prisons.

5

u/imbrickedup_ 9h ago

I’m willing to bet the deciding factor is cost

Also pooping currently

0

u/FreeToasterBaths 8h ago

Nice don't be turd burglar

0

u/Head_of_Lettuce 8h ago edited 8h ago

Stingrays are extremely illegal in most contexts, law enforcement has to jump through hoops to get approval use them and they usually have to be targeted at specific individuals. And usually for investigating very serious crimes. Often times when they're used by law enforcement, they get pushback from courts because they didn't follow the warrant to the letter, didn't disclose it properly, etc.

Your second and third bullets are valid points, but I seriously doubt stingrays are an option here.

-6

u/Ophiochos 9h ago

Ok cool, at this point it becomes a useful and informative post instead of something citing a random 20-year old ‘pen or something’. Thank you, genuinely, for taking the time (but…)

I’m sure the downvotes will continue but any particular reason this was only worth writing out when someone got fed up of weird apparently unsupported opinions being spouted?

5

u/liquorfish 9h ago

Yes, I tend to spend the time looking things up while on the toilet.

6

u/crysisnotaverted 9h ago

This is the laziest possible method. It let's guards sell cellphones to prisoners and not get in trouble.

Shit, a KrackenSDR would let you foxhunt a cell phone pretty easily.

4

u/DeviantDork 8h ago

Do you think it’s more likely that for-profit prisons are hiring experts to optimize solutions or that they’ll do the easiest, cheapest thing possible to maximize shareholder value with zero concern for who it affects?

I know which of those two I’d put my money on.

21

u/knatascheek 11h ago

Some prisoners have full social media accounts now. They let the situation build up so they can overhaul the system

7

u/junkyard_robot 10h ago

Some prisoners have access to computers.

2

u/EbonySaints 8h ago

Thanks for reminding me about this little bit of ingenuity from a decade ago.

3

u/Taurondir 6h ago

You dont need phone detectors. If the towers aoutside can triangulate ALL 4G/5G connections down to 1 meter, the hardware can deny a connection unless a specific phone ID is whitelisted.

0

u/PerfectOpposites 10h ago

Faraday cage it?

8

u/Zathrus1 10h ago

If you think this is even vaguely viable, you don’t understand how faraday cages work.

The size of the mesh is different for different frequencies. Cell phones use a pretty wide range of frequencies now.

The mesh must not be interrupted by ANYTHING going through the mesh. Non metallic objects create a hole in the mesh that signals can travel through. Metallic objects create an antenna. Any point of entry/exit becomes a major issue for all of this.

And you know something that kind of HAS to go through the mesh? Power lines. Water. Sewage. Communications (phone/internet).

Faraday cages are impractical for anything much larger than a closet.

1

u/Black_Moons 1h ago

The size of the mesh isn't different for different frequencies, it blocks all frequencies with a wavelength longer than the hole size. Hence you just need a mesh that blocks the highest frequency local carriers are using.

It also doesn't need to be perfect, small holes won't let much signal through, and combined with a low power jammer inside the cage you'll easily drown out any signal that gets in, while not spilling too much jamming power outside.

0

u/lapideous 9h ago

You could bury all of those connections, no?

2

u/Zathrus1 5h ago

It doesn’t matter. They STILL act as antennas. Which is the absolute last thing you want in a faraday cage.

0

u/thesweatervest 9h ago

So rebuild all correctional facilities?

4

u/edman007 10h ago

That's more expensive and there are legitimate uses.

Equipment to triangulate radio transmitters is not new. It shouldn't be hard to install in a few spots in a prison and identify every damn phone in the building and give a live location down to a few feet. That lets the prison guards keep their phones working, no harm for outsiders, and for inmates with a phone, well you basically have a name instantly. That's a lot better than can't use it because you can actually recover it and punish the person.

1

u/trextra 10h ago

There are legitimate use cases for staff to have working cell service.

16

u/ajnin919 10h ago

And yet they wouldn’t have that cell service if jammers are used. People outside of the prison will lose service

-1

u/PerfectOpposites 10h ago

Wireless signals will still work within the cage, but access points that allow the comms will reject connections to disallowed devices.

-7

u/Commercial_Wind8212 10h ago

Some rules need to be changed

0

u/echobravoeffect 9h ago

They’re likely doing it to sell devices and internet access to prisoners.

0

u/party_benson 8h ago

Are you expecting the guards to actually do their jobs?

0

u/QuarkGluonPlasma137 5h ago

Pretty useful to jam something when you don’t want someone’s words getting out.

-4

u/Cyclo_Hexanol 10h ago

The real question is why are cell phones banned?

Maybe the prison companies charge for calls?

6

u/guri256 7h ago

Correct. Prisons do charge for calls. They used to be able to charge a lot more, but now they are capped at “only” $0.18 per minute. (that’s about $10 for an hour long call)

That’s worse than almost any (non-international) long distance provider back in 1995.

Prisons like to use it as a method of farming income from their slaves residents.

Of course, the really messed up part is that this means almost all of the interactions the inmates are having are with other inmates, rather than people who aren’t criminals. This increases the chances that after the person is let out, they will do more crime.

And the prison is getting paid based on how many inmates they are taking care of. So these companies get paid more if the inmate gets convicted of a new crime and goes back to prison.

4

u/Osric250 4h ago

No need to cross out slaves. They literally are slaves as the 13th amendment explicitly carves out an exemption for slavery as a punishment. So prisoners can and are used as slaves. 

2

u/Cyclo_Hexanol 7h ago

My thought is if people in prison cant talk to their family and kids then they spend a lot more time with criminal elements and dont get reminded why they need to behave.

10

u/edman007 9h ago

Well they want to at least record all interactions and communication with the outside. I think that's reasonable,

4

u/blbd 8h ago

They charge usurious rates for the calls that are more criminal than many of the inmates. 

1

u/Serberou5 2h ago

What? Why cell phones are banned in prison? Because it's errr prison and you shouldn't have anything like that in prison it's obvious.

59

u/reverendsteveii 8h ago

America does this neat thing where there's no limit to who can get hurt or how much as long as you can also an argument that one person deserves it

18

u/Alucard256 7h ago

That's a good one... I've always liked "America is the place where there's no limit to who can get hurt or how much as long as at least one really really rich person makes at least $1 profit."

60

u/Dalek_Chaos 11h ago

Gonna be real interesting for compounds like Fort Worth Medical Center where there's apartments within throwing distance of the compound.

45

u/junkyard_robot 10h ago

Which means a full on FCC lawsuit for jamming signals. And, if they just use stingrays to MITM to supress, anyone in the area can FOIA records in a lawsuit, which means taxpayers will fund the settlement because feds are supressing discovery on purpose.

8

u/bp92009 10h ago

Remind me, why are the specific people involved in enacting those policies, which they know are against the law, not directly and personally liable for the harms committed when breaking the law?

Why are taxpayers on the hook for that inevitable settlement? It'd only be reasonable for taxpayers to pay for it, after every penny of the individual who made that decision, was appropriately seized by the courts (as per appropriate bankruptcy asset protections).

11

u/junkyard_robot 10h ago

Because we as civilians are nothing, and they are our legal superiors.

There are ways to change this.

1

u/Frequent-Test-3012 8h ago

Not to mention radio jamming is like one of the most illegal things on the planet 

4

u/BaconBourbonBalista 11h ago

I was gonna say at least the county jail in my city is quite close to downtown and other businesses. I would hope they wouldnt implement something like that

0

u/9-11GaveMe5G 8h ago

It's on the States to decide if they want to do so or not. The FCC specifically said they aren't requiring anyone to do it. With Texas becoming blue the blue governor hopefully will prevent it

1

u/Dalek_Chaos 7h ago

Dawg Fort Worth medical is a Federal compound. State can't do shit about it.

29

u/Single-Pin-369 10h ago

how does this address the issue that most contraband like phones get in by the guards themselves? 

16

u/Eric848448 10h ago

It doesn’t. Stopping that is hard. This is easy.

26

u/Existing-Return-5308 11h ago

Sam, I Tried to call your lawyer as we agreed. But the prison made sure the phone connection failed.

Oh, and I called 911 about the heart attack of Miriam. Call would not go though…

5

u/junkyard_robot 10h ago

Any supression of over the air communication is a direct FCC violation.

4

u/Existing-Return-5308 9h ago

When someone has a big stick, do you think they care about FCC violations.

0

u/junkyard_robot 8h ago

When an administration is legitimate, the FCC is the biggest stick in the executive branch.

1

u/Existing-Return-5308 8h ago

I thought that was CIA?

As proven in Iraq

Well the biggest users of damp towels, anyways.

(What a shame, USA is synonymous with brutality and torture…
At the same time, one has to recall what the trees outside american 1890s courthouses were really for….)

2

u/proudsoul 10h ago

Did you read the article?

12

u/PluralMimsy 11h ago

Seems bad?

19

u/HorzaDonwraith 11h ago

Be ashame if I needed to call police after witnessing a prisoner running free within two miles of the prison.

14

u/ComprehendReading 10h ago

They'll just violate your 4th Amendment rights and prosecute you until you're broke and in the same prison you tried to report an escapee from.

15

u/Time_Difference_6682 8h ago

this is gonna backfire so hard.

11

u/MoreGaghPlease 7h ago

Ask anyone who works in a prison and they’ll tell you that prison phones make their life easier. Who wants to start a prison riot when they could just sit on their ass and watch TikTok videos? Also, since debuting in February 1942, not one person has ever shanked someone while doing the New York Times crossword.

2

u/Taurondir 6h ago

What does internet access have to do with mobiles phones? You could deploy limited and filtered access to content, and not allow people to have entire conversations with oitside parties.

1

u/SebastianFerrone 6h ago

The point is the phones in prison are not so nice for the criminals because of ability watch YouTube tiktok and porn. But they are mostly used for crimes. Getting drugs inside, hiding evidence and so on

1

u/lobaway0001 6h ago

I’m about to just to have it on the contrarian record.

What’s a five-letter word that starts with ‘s’ that means “stab”?

4

u/NicoBeingAModelCitiz 8h ago

can't wait for uncontrolled unanticipated catastrophic interference with things like medical devices.

4

u/DaSpawn 8h ago

would be way smarter to put in a fake cell tower to capture the calls and/or triangulate the calls

so beyond stupid to block all calls which would include emergency calls

7

u/Zilithahz 10h ago

As a SWE this seems like the shittiest possible technical solution to this problem

3

u/AbyssumBorealis 10h ago

Makes sense to put jammers in a remote facility but what about prisons in metro areas. Even Bastrop fci has houses right next door.

4

u/mabhatter 9h ago

My town is like that.  There's the main prison complex outside of town, and then another amount of land the prison owns for farming. Then there's houses and subdivisions just outside that.  

My parents already have the crappiest cell service .. and they're POTS service was rendered unusable like five years ago.  Their whole area is going to be randomly cut off from services by this. 

3

u/rzarectha 4h ago

so no concern this may interfere with emergency services for people living nearby?

8

u/Bonerballs 9h ago

Just put a huge Faraday cage around the prison and only have wired phone lines. Make it the Battlestar Galactica of prisons

2

u/Bitey_the_Squirrel 7h ago

This won’t be a problem unless it affects a corporation. Then it will get fixed fast.

2

u/Taurondir 6h ago

Ok so maybe I have zero idea on how technolofy works, so feel free to correct me:

Why, ffs, can't a prison deploy an antenna ON the prison, in sush a way that ALL phones will try to connect to that and not DISTANT towers, so they can white list and black list phones and so whatever filtering they want.

The distant towers can triangulate, right? SO they can stop any calls from within the Prison area coordinates, so that one or more towers only allow traffic being passed to them from the Prison antenna.

What exactly am I missing here?

3

u/factoid_ 10h ago

These phones connect to networks.  Ask the phone companies to block all phones not on a white list

11

u/tooclosetocall82 10h ago

They do. It’s called your cell plan. Someone is paying for these phones (not the prisoners obviously) but there isn’t any real way for the service provider to know if a phone is contraband.

5

u/FoodTiny6350 10h ago

You’re telling me you can’t have towers inside the jail that give a geo fenced area where they’re sent through it and say nuh uh? Instead you have to full jam a neighborhood?

1

u/tooclosetocall82 9h ago

I don’t know enough about cell technology to know if femtocells could do that. That could be plausible, though if a corrupt guard is smuggling phones whitelisting them may simply be a hurdle.

1

u/factoid_ 9h ago

I have worked with distributed antenna platforms before.  The challenges of doing this are logistical not technical.

The guards would probably not be the ones in charge of adding devices to the white list.

But you’d probably need a way to relatively easily white list  specific phones. For lawyers, police officers, certain visitors, etc

But guest white listing would be temporary for each visit. 

-1

u/Zilithahz 10h ago

Triangulate them

8

u/DystopianRealist 10h ago

The call is coming from inside your butt!

2

u/uconnboston 10h ago

Plot twist….and twist…..and twist…..and twist…..and…..we’re in!

-4

u/factoid_ 10h ago

It’s very easy…you white list the allowed sim numbers and anything else geolocated inside the prison is blocked at network level

3

u/cantholdmedown4 9h ago

Cool, now you just disabled all guard cell phones. That will inevitably lead to a death

Some of yall do wild ass assertions with literally zero follow through thought to them

Also, as someone that had to support prison systems in a past role, my role would have been impossible if my cell phone didnt work inside. So you have also disabled all support systems for these prisons. At one point my C suite wanted to take phones away from my team and we told them flatly if they do that, we will no longer support prisons as we need cell phones to do our job in them.

Please, its not that hard to not say stupid shit.

1

u/factoid_ 7h ago

People really just look for every reason to say no to an idea don’t they?

Again this is a trivial fix

White list the phones of the people who should be allowed to have them

1

u/cantholdmedown4 6h ago

Stingrays with whitelists are already in place at a number of facilities. Been doin that forever

0

u/Alurely 9h ago

So the prison gets a dedicated land line, and the guards have wireless hand sets.
It's not hard to think outside the box :D We didn't always have cell phones, alternatives exist if they just put them into use again.

2

u/cantholdmedown4 9h ago

I literally just said that I, an outside entity, was responsible for systems inside prisons and could not complete that work as required without a cell phone. Shits changed, its a whole new world. Theres requirements now that must be met and prisons use contractors that rely on internet and other systems to remain compliant. Supporting those systems is impossible without cell phones. Please read slower than you type.

Stingrays are already in use at many prisons and inhibit cell communications and we were wholly unable to troubleshoot onsite at those locations. That would be 100x worse with this blocking bs

1

u/CaretakerColin 8h ago

Just let AI handle it /s

1

u/tooclosetocall82 9h ago

Geolocate within a concrete box? GPS likely doesn’t work well in prisons so the fence would need to be generous which would just entrap nearby phones similar to jamming.

-1

u/factoid_ 9h ago

The towers triangulate you without gps.

It really isn’t an enormous technical challenge.

If a cell signal penetrates the concrete box well enough to provide service it penetrates enough to geolocate a device and check it against a whitelist if it’s within the perimeter 

1

u/tooclosetocall82 9h ago

Tower triangulation isn’t as accurate as GPS. but even say it is, who controls the whitelist? A corrupt guard smuggling in a phone may also be able to get it white listed.

2

u/peppruss 10h ago

Then it’s an elaborate game of spoofing.

2

u/creamersrealm 10h ago

Or just use a giant Femotcell like they do in big commercial buildings and allowlist them. Doesn't stop guards from handing over phones but sure as hell restricts it and they should be using walkies anyways.

2

u/bananajr6000 7h ago

Maybe prisons should be more than 2 1/2 miles from civilization

1

u/rudebii 9h ago

Shot callers and leaders of criminal organizations are already put in more secure facilities. It’s harder for them to get phones, but guards at those facilities are crooked too.

Inmates are getting contraband, including phones, from guards. Jamming signals causes all sorts of problems while only solving one.

1

u/teh_maxh 9h ago

Were they trying to come up with such a terrible R&O?

1

u/silentaba 6h ago

I spent time in a minimum security prison where good behaviour prisoners such as myself could buy a switch. You could absolutely walk around at night (yeah, no lockdown prison farm) and find open hotspots with the switch, it was Hella funny.

1

u/Party_Cold_4159 2h ago

Wonder if using a mobile cell tower would be better. Kinda like those cell interceptors used by governments.

Then they could track who’s phone is who based on distance. Possibly set up a geofence too. There are ways around that, but it seems better than jamming.

It’s also incredibly easy to bug sweep for phones. This just seems like a lazy solution more than it being something that works better.

1

u/locktheclocck 1h ago

A jammer can't tell a smuggled handset from a nurse's phone two miles away, because the RF ignores the fence. The targeted alternative is managed access, a local cell that only lets known handsets attach. Blanket jamming just moves the cost onto the neighbours.

1

u/welshdude1983 1h ago

Make a fake mast in the prison. It forces all the phones to connect to it imei details sent to local towers not to let them connect

1

u/Left_on_Pause 10h ago

Jammed so their inhumane treatment of people can't be shown.

1

u/Sterkzal 10h ago

Thus is already existing technology deployed at several prisons in California. Several prison sites I have worked at have cell jammers deployed. No service for miles outside the site.

14

u/junkyard_robot 10h ago

Which is an FCC violation.

2

u/Mr_Enemabag-Jones 10h ago

Not it if is approved

3

u/WrongComparison321 10h ago

I mean it doesn’t matter if it is or isn’t. The government can’t deprive you things arbitrarily. If you are not a prisoner and the prison is built or located near residential or commercial areas you absolutely have a right to use your phone or rather you have a right to not be denied use of your phone by the government.

If the prison is in the middle of nowhere certainly it’s a much fairer argument to say the prisons use case is not infringement. So it does depend.

-2

u/FoodTiny6350 10h ago

The department of corrections has special privileges when it comes to their land and their prisoners

8

u/Motophoto 10h ago

But you are outside their land they have no right to violate my rights and interrupt my cell services.

0

u/[deleted] 10h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/WrongComparison321 10h ago

You are going to have to cite case law.

1

u/viginti_tres 10h ago

Install these in cinemas.

-3

u/mattl33 10h ago

Sorry but what actually is the downside of just letting prisoners communicate? I realize that's probably naive but, I have fortunately not been to prison.

19

u/GreenBeans23920 10h ago

You can organize more crime and threaten victims from prison 

1

u/mattl33 9h ago

Surely there's records of this that could be used in prosecution right? Seems like preventing phones from getting in isn't practical, but better monitoring and subsequent punishment would be doable.

1

u/Potential_Bill_4442 8h ago

Unfortunately not that simple. Burner/stolen phone = limited identifying info.

2

u/mattl33 8h ago

Right but if someone calls me to threaten me, there's a 100% chance the phone company can get that number, give it to police, they triangulate it etc. You don't necessarily need the identifying info of the caller. That'd get trickier with gang communication but still not impossible.

Anyway, something besides jamming several square miles of otherwise legal communication must be possible.

10

u/Not_Campo2 9h ago

Unmonitored communication can be used by gang leadership to continue calling shots from inside, can be used to organize more contraband smuggling in, can be used to try and intimidate witnesses. it also breaks the prisons monopoly and allows inmates to talk to their loved ones without the prison getting its cut and we obviously can’t have that

2

u/StanknBeans 9h ago

That's honestly probably one of the biggest motivators for them to ban cell phones. I mean, alongside the ability to use it to conduct further crimes.

3

u/Mcnuggetjuice 9h ago

They lead gangs from prison and they often call for murders from there

2

u/Hoochnoob69 9h ago

Idk about the US, but in my country a lot of scam calls come from prisons

2

u/funmler 9h ago

I seem to recall a lot of scams are run out of prisons e.g. jury duty , sex extortion scams https://www.themarshallproject.org/2019/11/11/how-did-they-run-an-elaborate-sextortion-scam-from-prison-cellphones

5

u/rudebii 10h ago

Then more people know what actually happens in prison and those in charge might end up accountable for it.

2

u/piedamon 9h ago

This sounds a bit like the rest of the world too, but on a different scale than prison

2

u/theyoyomaster 9h ago

Also there's the whole leading criminal conspiracies, organizing active crimes on the outside, ordering murders and such too, but yeah. 

0

u/sandwichman7896 9h ago

Sounds like an FCC issue

0

u/theyoyomaster 9h ago

Yes and no, the FCC is a government agency. While it's illegal for a civilian to jam cell service the FCC can very easily allow other agencies of the government to do so. 

0

u/SnufferMonster 9h ago

How about instead we invest in a camera system that doesn't look like it records from an old potato and loses minutes every day?

Something that works even in high security areas maybe?

-1

u/ComedyBits 10h ago

Cells in the cells? Oh no

-27

u/AnarchySpeech 11h ago

About darn time. Crazy it took this long.