r/technology • • 10h ago

Business Lenders aim to bar SpaceX from launching $40bn of chips into orbit

https://www.ft.com/content/33b5643c-2957-4d42-9116-5e34a3c54e29?syn-25a6b1a6=1
461 Upvotes

93 comments sorted by

121

u/casualfrog68 10h ago

How do you repossess something launched into space?

50

u/Mirageswirl 5h ago

It’s easier to train repo men to be astronauts then train astronauts to be repo men.

7

u/Adasha 51m ago

I don't wanna close my AIs...

45

u/PersonalitySenior360 10h ago

You don't?

35

u/Johnnnyb28 9h ago

That's the issue

-24

u/This-Construction926 9h ago

ask the Chinese ? they've got a space spy plane too 

17

u/Harold_v3 9h ago

You hire another space company to go get them! Or maybe we just take the earth up to the chips! Hey I’m just throwing out ideas here man. What do you mean, it’s fine, I can totally do that much K.

9

u/webternet 6h ago

Are you an HBO max developer? Cuz that is a LOT of ketamine.

5

u/H1Ed1 8h ago

Sounds like a job for Space Force! Simply pay $1Bn to Trump directly and he'll win that repossession so hard. "The likes of which youve never seen."

6

u/dalgeek 1h ago

I surmised that one of the main reasons to push data centers into space is to avoid legal issues, like when Grok starts churning out so much CSAM that no one can ignore it. Avoiding the repo man is a good reason too.

6

u/Working_Analyst_1988 8h ago

How do you repossess a factory? You don’t get a tow truck; you get new operators.

The joke for GPU asset-backed lending is repossession is changing the SSH keys. There’s provisions for taking over contracts in place.

I do agree though that it’s more complicated for satellites. Read the contract? Don’t lend against SpaceX’s assets until you understand those provisions. These are sophisticated lenders and sophisticated borrowers.

4

u/themagicmarmot 8h ago

Would be interesting to see if any nations would try a space heist. $40bn of chips is quite a bit... that's gotta be at least twenty 5090s.

3

u/WoolaTheCalot 9h ago

You send Andy Griffith to go get them. (Deep cut, I know.)

-2

u/MorningMan464 9h ago

Remember the scene of Consuela the maid from Family Guy saying “Come get it, beech!” then hanging up the phone?

39

u/supercali45 10h ago

Tick tock for Musk .. he is going to have a crapload of investigations launched at the state level and federal

35

u/Pocketz7 9h ago

Re opened you mean, they had so much on him

-16

u/anon1mo56 9h ago

The only stuff that could have carried criminal conviction is federal and that is if he is proven guilty, but Trump has already said he would give him a pardon before leaving office. All the estate level stuff he could be found guilty off just means fines.

1

u/Careful_Honeydew_549 9h ago

Thats why nothing happens until new president.

11

u/ITDummy69420 8h ago

And then nothing happens when new President. 

2

u/anon1mo56 8h ago

Nah, democrats aren't going to do anything to invalidate presidential pardons since it also protects them. I mean Biden pardoned lots of his people, before leaving office to protect them including his son. Had he not pardoned them they would be behind bars.

52

u/BSSolo 10h ago

SpaceX has said it plans to use the chips involved in the debt deal on Earth. But lenders have expressed concerns that if the group later decided to shoot the valuable chips that underpin their loans into space, it would prevent them from reclaiming and selling the semiconductors in the event of a default, according to people familiar with the matter.

Ok so SpaceX, which says it wants to build space data centers that most people think won't be feasible, says that they don't even want to send these GPUs to space.  So lenders are worried about... Basically nothing.

30

u/PersonalitySenior360 10h ago

Think?? With current tech it is not. How are you planning to cool that space data center? In a vacuum, nope

1

u/Medium_Notice_3512 3h ago

Radiation does an excellent job. One shouldn't think of space as being like a thermos; a thermos has a reflective layer inside that bounces radiation back. In a vacuum, however, heat simply escapes. Similarly, in a room, objects radiate toward one another, thereby maintaining a balance; in space, by contrast, one can position radiators so that radiation is emitted out into the depths of space, while almost nothing comes back in return.

5

u/tommyk1210 2h ago

Radiation does an excellent job in some circumstances. Mainly when the temperature is high. A cooling loops radiator from a datacenter isn’t likely to be much above body temperature.

To counteract this you need a LOT of radiators, which isn’t a problem in terms of space (you have loads of it) but it is a problem in terms of materials. You’ve got to actually get all those radiators into space.

The radiators alone for a single datacenter in space might be similar in mass as the ISS. That’s before the actual datacenter build itself which is likely 2x as much again.

0

u/Medium_Notice_3512 2h ago

We have a remarkable piece of technology called a heat pump, which allows radiators to operate at temperatures above the boiling point of water.

3

u/tommyk1210 1h ago

Sure, but you’re just moving the effort. Now you need more energy to run your DC, which also requires more energy generation equipment. You’ve introduced more mechanical complexity into the system too, so you need more upkeep/maintenance/redundancy.

If your heat pumps fail you will cook your DC.

A theoretically perfect heat pump needs 20MW to take 100MW of waste heat at 40C and turn it into 120C. This would slightly more than halve your radiator size.

But a perfect heat pump doesn’t exist. In reality you’re looking at probably closer to 40-50MW of additional power.

Sure, your rads will be smaller but now your solar panels are bigger too…

1

u/Medium_Notice_3512 1h ago

It seems you believe these satellites will be radically larger than they actually will be. Starmind satellites will have a peak power of 250 kW and an average power of 175 kW.
Furthermore, the conversion level for heat pumps is essentially an optimization problem balancing solar panels, the capacity of the heat pump, and the size/mass of the radiators. I specified that particular temperature simply to demonstrate the feasibility of raising the temperature to the desired levels.

3

u/tommyk1210 1h ago

Of course, you can reduce the size of each “datacenter” but 175kW is approximately 1 rack of GB100 GPUs + ancillary services.

When people like musk are talking about putting AI datacenters in space, they surely don’t mean 1 rack…

Musk spoke about up to 1 million satellites, at 120kW each, and appropriately 2-3 tons per satellite. That’s stil 3 million tons of mass to get into space.

Nothing, ultimately, is impossible. You can make many smaller sats or fewer big ones. Either way you’ve got to get that mass into space, and you’ve got to maintain it there.

The “getting it there” is the hard bit. Even Starship will only be able to lift about 30 tons at a time. With Falcon, musk can get about 220MW of compute into space per year. Or you can just build a datacenter on the ground for a fraction of the price. Given that most AI companies are barely profitable with ground based DCs I just don’t see how this might work economically…

1

u/Medium_Notice_3512 1h ago

They are literally referring to a single stand. Musk published the schematic and technical specifications for the AI ​​1 satellite a long time ago. I will state its characteristics.

https://www.spacex.com/spacexsi/starmind

-12

u/peepeedog 10h ago

Radiative cooling works. It is just that it increases costs and complexity because you need a lot of surface area in the cooling panels. So it is unclear it is even viable for so many satellites producing so much heat.

11

u/pumpkinfarts23 9h ago

That larger the radiator, the larger the atmospheric drag. The larger the drag, the shorter the lifetime of the satellite. Starlinks already have a ~5 year lifetime because of drag, these "data center" satellites would be even shorter. It's completely realistic that they would only have 2ish years of usable life in orbit.

21

u/mmertner 9h ago

It’s not unclear at all, it’s entirely unviable. You need to launch like 100 international space stations just to cool one rack. Some science youtuber did the math and it makes Elon look like the clown he is.

-7

u/Overall-Persimmon-64 8h ago

Why is a comment like this that is completely wrong up voted? Radiative cooling is viable

3

u/PersonalitySenior360 8h ago

Link us your research paper proving that

-4

u/ResilientBiscuit 8h ago

Looks like about 15m^2 in daylight to a data center card.

That doesn't seem particularly impossible, but it is a lot more practical to do it terrestrially. But if no one lets data centers get build and you can launch into space at cost, maybe at some point the financials work out.

5

u/ProfessionalTank3818 6h ago

15 square meters for 1 card where a data centre uses tens of thousands of cards, you also need to do more than cool, you need to bring in kilowatts of power to even use them, which means solar, so you need a reflective surface to radiate heat from the cards but also solar panels that don’t reflect to bring in energy. Not impossible but wildly stupid. This also doesn’t account for area need led for space, how you would move something like that to avoid other satellites. How you would prevent a dead space zone if it was damaged, etc

-1

u/ResilientBiscuit 3h ago

That's 15 square meters radiating in sunlight.

you need to bring in kilowatts of power to even use them, which means solar, so you need a reflective surface to radiate heat from the cards but also solar panels that don’t reflect to bring in energy.

It becomes more efficient to cool if solar panels are shading the cards and radiators and the radiators are radiating perpendicular to the panels. Solar panels shading the structure help the radiation situation rather than hurt it.

The radiative sheets are incredibly thin and light, around 200nm. If you use soft compressible tubing for routing the coolant it becomes not impossible to deploy thousands of square meters of the material.

how you would move something like that to avoid other satellites

You could park these at any orbit. Space gets much less crowded at higher orbits because the sphere is much larger and because there are fewer satellites at those altitudes.

Again, building on the ground is far simpler and cheaper if government allows it, but it isn't impossible to build these things in space. It will be between that or at sea/underwater which comes with its own set of challenges.

-11

u/skariel 9h ago

Ohhh if a youtiber did the math! then it must be right. 

6

u/TheRKC 7h ago

Pretty sure the "YouTuber" is Neil deGrasse Tyson. So not just "some YouTuber".

0

u/skariel 7h ago

here you have Scott Manley arguing it is quite feasible. He's Scottish, so you know he's right! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FlQYU3m1e80

7

u/mmertner 9h ago

You dont need math to figure it out, a bit of basic science understanding will do.

0

u/PersonalitySenior360 8h ago

Found musks blow buddy

-14

u/_badwithcomputer 9h ago

With radiative cooling. The cooling panels need to be 1/5 the size of the solar panels that problem isn't a difficult one to solve.

5

u/mattl33 8h ago

You need a liquid to do that. Lots of it.

-3

u/SNRatio 8h ago

SpaceX agrees: "We plan to advance thermal control systems – many of which have been proven on Starlink – by using radiators, vapor chambers, active cooling loops, and coatings to dissipate the heat generated by AI hardware in space’s vacuum. "

https://content.spacex.com/cms-assets/FINAL_Documents%20and%20Updates/SpaceX%20-%20EU%20Prospectus%20%28Approved%20by%20Bafin%29%20-%20June%205%2C%202026.pdf

-11

u/_badwithcomputer 7h ago

I'm glad SpaceX has all of these Redditors doing free engineering for them so they can go ahead and fire all of those rocket scientists and satellite designers wasting all of their time working on this.

7

u/mattl33 7h ago

Found the $225/share $SPCX holder lol

-5

u/_badwithcomputer 7h ago

127 cost basis actually

But I've seen this same thing all through SpaceX history
You can't certify a cargo spacecraft for human rating
You can't land a booster
You cant refly a booster more than 10 times so it will not be profitable
Starlink is flawed, cant work, etc
You can't put 33 engines on a booster
Raptor 3 is fake it is missing plumbing
You can't catch a booster with a tower
and on.

Somehow I feel like making large enough solar panels, and cooling grids, and the fluid to operate them isn't going to be a huge challenge.

6

u/mattl33 7h ago

!remindme 2 years

Let's see if that still works. Good luck disregarding thermodynamics.

-1

u/PersonalitySenior360 6h ago

But he's a redditors that "knows things" duh

-1

u/PersonalitySenior360 6h ago

Relevant username

0

u/lyfe_Wast3d 4h ago

Eli5. Space is cold so why can't heatsinks cool it with dispersion into space.

16

u/haadrak 4h ago

Space is not cold. Temperature is a property matter has. Technically speaking to say space is cold is like saying the solar system feels depressed. It makes no sense. Now the absolutely tiny amount of matter in space is very cold but there's also basically none of it. When people say "space is cold" or variations of, it's a shortcut to talking about the matter in space, but it's really important to remember there's basically none of that there.

The way we tend to cool things here on earth is to have matter with low thermal energy crash into matter with high thermal energy and the matter with high thermal energy transfer some of that thermal energy to the lower energy matter. Repeat this process trillions of times and you get traditional cooling.

In space you can't realistically do this with any efficiency so you rely on thermal radiation. Now this obviously does remove heat. However at least with our current level of technology the amount of heat you're removing is orders of magnitude lower than you'd achieve with say, standard air conditioning here on earth.

See the problem?

5

u/tommyk1210 2h ago

“Space” is not cold.

The matter in space is cold and there’s not very much of it due to it being a near total vacuum.

“Cold” happens, largely, when heat is conducted away to other matter. In space there’s basically no conductive cooling, your only option is radiative cooling - turning your heat into things like infrared radiation. This is massively less efficient, unless the item is very hot (which is why you can feel hot things that are nearby, like fire).

The amount of radiators needed is just too much.

This calculation is very napkin math but: a single GB100 GPU rack uses about 130kW of power. A hot loop liquid cooling system might run at 45-55C in terms of coolant temperature, and the radiator needs to be cooler than this to act as a heat exhanger. So let’s assume the radiator temperature is 40C.

To calculate the heat dispersion via radiative cooling we can approximate using the Stefan-Boltzmann formula. This describes how the 4th power of temperature is the key here. At 40C, this 130kW needs about 242m2 of radiator to cool it. And that’s for one rack.

A typical AI datacenter might have 750 racks which would require 183,000m2 of radiators - about 26 football pitches. All of those radiators weigh a LOT - you might be looking at 350+ tons (assuming 2kg/m2 of radiator, which I have no idea if that’s reasonable or not! It feels…low.)

All of that mass you need to get into space, you need to assemble the datacenter, then you need to power it

1

u/AstralElement 2h ago

Then you need to protect it from outside radiation, and determine the reasonable distance you wish to place that data center. In LEO, it’s coming back to earth one way or another eventually, and if you don’t want it to… that needs another system to stabilize it built onto it.

1

u/Foreign_Implement897 2h ago

Heatsinks need some medium which is good at transferring heat, like air or water. Vacuum is the opposite, excellent insulator.

1

u/dalgeek 1h ago edited 1h ago

You can read the technical details of the ISS thermal regulation system here: https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/473486main_iss_atcs_overview.pdf

In total, the PVR can reject up to 14 kW of heat into deep space. The PVR weighs 1,633 pounds (740.7 kilograms) and when deployed measures 10.24 feet (3.12 meters) by 44.62 feet (13.6 meters). When the ISS assembly is complete, there will be a total of four PVRs, one for each PV module (S4, P4, P6, S6)

The ISS requires 4 radiators that weigh nearly a ton each to keep it cool. A single AI data center rack generates about as much heat as the entire ISS.

-14

u/KaneMarkoff 10h ago

Radiators lol

2

u/PersonalitySenior360 8h ago

Not viable at all lol

-6

u/KaneMarkoff 7h ago

Why? Are radiators no longer able to cool things in space anymore?

-9

u/Overall_Funny_5474 8h ago

If he puts it on the other side of the sun (or is it the moon) whichever is cooler. I hear gravity is also a thing there.

5

u/Youutternincompoop 9h ago

they're worried because Elon Musk has talked about data centers in space before.

1

u/Dazzling_Meat1233 10h ago

Then I guess warfare is the answer. If I can't reclaim it, I can blow it up so you can't use it if you default

25

u/_badwithcomputer 9h ago

The headline is sensationalist.

A bank can't prevent SpaceX from launching anything into space. They just won't let them borrow money to put an insanely expensive data center into space because it is unrecoverable collateral.

But there are ways to do it without a bank directly funding it, they could easily use R&D funds, borrow against something else that can be used as collateral, raise funding from entities that aren't banks and are willing to gamble.

Not to mention, as soon as they are operational and generating cashflow the banks will be beating down SpaceX doors trying to invest in it.

45

u/Unlucky_Topic7963 7h ago

lol data centers in space is the stupidest fucking thing.

Radiation, heat, latency, debris, repairs… so fucking dumb.

6

u/Former_Farm_3618 7h ago

Not sure why you’re getting downvoted. I haven’t seen any credible science to show how cooling a data center is possible…unless every GPU was its own separate satellite and not in clusters.

3

u/Medium_Notice_3512 3h ago

According to the plan, each satellite will consist of a single server rack, and there will be a million such satellites.

3

u/5up3rK4m16uru 3h ago

For every area of solar panel, you need about 1/5 of radiator area, to stay in a temperature range of 60-80 °C*, which is fine for GPUs. A big advantage over the ISS is, that this is quite a bit hotter than earth, so you can actually dump substantial heat in that direction as well.

The energy the solar panels provide in that case, is the energy you can work with and how many GPUs you can build in. No need to separate them.

This of course just shows that it works technically, whether it is economically viable is a whole other question.

* This is pretty much straight from the Stefan Boltzman law, assuming usage of both radiator sides and 250W/m2 of solar panel power. Emissivity of the panels can be assumed to be about 0.95. Radiation background of space is about 3K and of earth around 255K (emissivities 1 and 0.95, earth takes about 30% of the sky in LEO).

-1

u/omfgDragon 6h ago

Even if they were separated, the issue isn't collective heat- it's that the heat cannot dissipate. The vacuum of space offers nothing to carry the heat away from the vessel.

Neil DeGrasse Tyson gives a much smarter explanation than I can do, so I'll spare you my thoughts.

0

u/Wyvernz 6h ago

  Even if they were separated, the issue isn't collective heat- it's that the heat cannot dissipate. The vacuum of space offers nothing to carry the heat away from the vessel.

You can expel heat through radiation, it’s just not very fast. If each gpu had its own satellite and a big radiator heat wouldn’t be a problem (though the expense would be immense).

0

u/AstralElement 2h ago

And atmospheric drag.

-12

u/_badwithcomputer 7h ago

Microsoft already proved that isolated from human contact data centers are totally viable, and the most common data center issues were human induced.

The cost of building a data center on earth continues to climb, and municipal hostility is only going to rise which makes building them in space more viable.

Research has also been done showing keeping data centers extremely cool is also unnecessary. Performance improvements are minimal, and longevity is only marginally impacted (the equipment will long be obsolete before heat induced issues start to show up). Keeping data centers over 40C saves tremendous amount of power and will have little impact on operation.

6

u/SouthHovercraft4150 7h ago

The longest tenured gear in a datacenter is maybe 8 years. There is no way a data centre in space provides an 8 year ROI.

5

u/JWAdvocate83 4h ago

If a term in the loan says "Don't do this with the secured asset," and they have a credible basis to believe you're about to do that thing, i.e. the harm is imminent and irreparable, the bank isn't obligated to wait until you actually do it. The bank can pursue an injunction ordering the debtor not to do the thing.

2

u/rlook1000 5h ago

Good luck with FAFO with your lender

1

u/Thunder_Will 1h ago

What problem does sending data centres into space solves? If it's energy availability, then accelerate renewables and nuclear development and deployment that has additional benefits for everyone

Increasing the chances of a Kessler effect type event because billionaires are chasing the latest shiny fad seems somewhat ill-advised.

1

u/tidwell 4h ago

Did someone publish a paper on how to deal with the massive thermal problem for data centers in space that I missed? Sigh people are dumb.

7

u/MrShigsy89 3h ago

I don't understand the advantages at all. It's genuinely easier to cool a datacentre in a desert than in space. Also, dramatically quicker, cheaper and easier to maintain, as well as replace failed hardware. Space is the worst location imaginable. Under the ocean is better in every possible way, plus it's already been done so there are no unknowns.

2

u/Foreign_Implement897 2h ago

The idea must be ”edge computing” which is the idea to do computing straight in GSM links. Now when SpaceX has Starlink, they might want to do computing right at the link site. I can’t come up with anything better.

You can find the edge computing use cases for terrestial things. They sounded pretty iffy for me always.

2

u/scavno 1h ago

Edge computing is cool. Especially on earth since there is no vacuum here.

I guess the argument could be made for low powered and efficient nodes, sort of like what we do today in satellites, but this is just more dumb ideas from Musk. We all know this is going to be compute nodes for AI so Grok can be racist off planet.

1

u/Sixth_Ronin 57m ago

Could be were our AI overlord can reside. Out if harms way with a maximum effect cone.

1

u/Foreign_Implement897 54m ago

It must be Musk’s dream to move to Mars and be racist towards all earthlings, what more could he want?

1

u/Jaded_Ad9605 4m ago

Many modern day DC Hardware ist Not replaced... IT IS Just shut off

1

u/Single-Pin-369 2h ago

the real advatange it is the peasants can't easily smash them when they're in space

1

u/Single-Pin-369 2h ago

yes, travis beals who is in charge of googles attempts at space data centers has phd from uc berkley in physics. it's not a question of a  impossibility it's just a question of how large of a radiator you need and there is calculated to be more than enough space to make one. Space is incomprehensibly big and even having a global spanning grid of satellites it would be invisible from some small distant from earth. Each satellite wouldn't be that big and it would communicate with every other satellite with a laser connection grid and they would each individually have radiating systems.

-1

u/Smashego 2h ago

There aren’t thermal problems. There are literally radiators and heat exchangers that work like a heat pump or air conditioner but with fluid heat exchangers like your PC already likely uses. The hotter the radiators get the better their heat dissipation will be.

The rumors and absolute lies and myth being spread right now is that they’ll need football field size radiators. Thats simply not true.

We already have the technology and space x has always done the math. The only ones claiming otherwise are just detractors. Not actual engineers who can back up what they are saying with science or math.

-2

u/ZergvProtoss 2h ago

Exactly. It's weird how many people don't understand that SpaceX has already got this figured out. Elon doesn't get this far into a project unless he knows he can do it. He's got 22,000 of the world's best engineers. They've got this solved.

2

u/ThePlanck 43m ago

laughs in Hyperloop

0

u/LordBird1 1h ago

well i mean if your not worried about burning several kilowatts pumping heat into a near glowing radiator sure

1

u/Smashego 1h ago

They won’t be worried about it. With virtually 100% sun facing solar panels there isn’t really a power problem in space.

1

u/jh937hfiu3hrhv9 9h ago

Did they just disclose the real value of chips?