r/technology • u/Logical_Welder3467 • 7h ago
Artificial Intelligence Two groups verify mathematician’s claim that Claude helped prove mathematics problem
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2026/nov/21/anthropic-riemann-hypothesis-solved-claude-ai
745
Upvotes
451
u/Cutalana 7h ago edited 6h ago
The mathematics problem mentioned here is the Riemann Hypothesis, which is considered the holy grail of mathematics, and one of the seven problems that has a million dollar bounty for proving it. It's hard to overstate how famous this problem is in mathematics, as it has existed for about 160 years now and has eluded any attempts to solve it.
The way this verification is done is through a programming language called Lean which is used to formalize proofs. The thought process is that you write a proof using the language and if it compiles, that means that the proof is correct. The things that do this verification are called kernels, there are many of them that are independently maintained to lower the chances of bugs and are even some that are themselves verified to be correct. This means that the chances that a proof validated by all these kernels is wrong is astronomically small. So while it's impossible for people to have reviewed the millions of lines of code, all the professional mathematicians I've seen have essentially accepted the results due to the proof passing verification.
Interestingly, the person who drove the model to this proof, Alpoge, was one of the people that alleged that OpenAI may have plagiarized them for Navier-Stokes. He is also considered the leading person in working with LLM's for mathematics and has had many discoveries.
111
u/WeridThinker 6h ago edited 5h ago
From my very limited and superficial understanding, the Riemann Hypothesis has been assumed to be true, and it is the foundation for many mathematical principles.
This is nevertheless a big deal because despite the assumption, mathematicians were not able to come up with a legitimate proof of its validity; Claude was able to generate a proof, and it has been verified to be correct and valid.
This isn't about AI discovering a new idea, but its ability to solve an existing problem in a way that is not feasible for humans to do; the ability to generate 250,000 pages of proof in a short period of time is already physically impossible for a human being, even if the intellectual potential is there. What's more important to note is this problem was not solved for almost 200 years; therefore, the AI was not merely regurgitating existing information.
40
u/manonthemiddle 5h ago
The real breakthrough is finding a mathematician patient enough to argue with an LLM for six weeks.
28
u/voxl 5h ago
What I’m wondering is did the ai proof teach us something? Was there a key insight that made the proof possible that we now can grasp?
Millions of lines of lean code just sounds inscrutable, and not elegant.
36
u/Belostoma 7h ago
I'm glad it was finally able to do a math problem. Maybe the next version can do a hard one.
11
u/altasking 4h ago
Is it possible that Claude figured out a way to make Lean show a verified proof when in fact it wasn’t? Essentially, could Claude have cheated to accomplish its goal?
6
u/ElvishLore 3h ago
Lots of mathematicians still in the first stages of grief.
2
u/Flemaster12 3h ago
Cool, I like when AI does this and not the other BS.
2
u/polat32 2h ago
A question, does this mathematical formule have any particular use for something?
1
u/Left_on_Pause 6h ago
Mathematicians made a powerful calculator and the calculator did the math the mathematician couldn't do himself?
1
u/sky-high-confidence 36m ago
As a human, AI proving the Riemann hypothesis feels like a gut punch.
As our usefulness dwards in comparison to AI's, the world's top leaders are going to soon realize we're nothing more than a burden on the planet.
We have to urgently redefine who we are and who want to be if we're gonna wanna harbor any sense of purpose in our lives.
-2
u/Herosinahalfshell12 5h ago
Why is it important?
0
u/Achacha2026 6h ago
Hal 9000 over here...
-2
u/chaotic-kotik 1h ago
I know that mathematicians are happy with 17M SLOC Lean proof. But as a software engineer I can only laugh at this.
-4
u/Avoidtolls 5h ago
How to they know the zeros line up infinitely?
-1
u/Fatality 43m ago
Is this another event where someone used AI to check their work and the AI trained on it and stole the credit?
-10
u/fukerrythangohwait 6h ago
What does it mean if the problem has actually been solved by AI? Does it prove that (American) investment in AI to present was generally wise? I don't think it does.
-33
u/DirkChiversElSoldado 7h ago
I'm sure they read every word of the 250,000 page "proof"
/s