r/thomasthetankengine • • 21h ago

General Chat The miller/nitrogen era was better than the Brenner era in everything BUT writing

Thumbnail
gallery
127 Upvotes

Yes this is another Hot-take of mine as much as I love the Brenner era I’ve been rewatching alot of stuff from seasons 13-16 and honestly I’ve come to the opinion that it is better than the Brenner era in everything but writing.

I love nitrogen studio’s animation more than ARC/jam filed everything looks industrial but still beautiful at the same time in nitrogen in Brenner (and BWBA) the animation is still good but everything feels to bright sometimes (not to mention the unrealistic animation and stunts starting from the great race onwards).

And also the songs, GOD I LOVE the songs from the nitrogen era especially these three that I’m about to list

  1. ⁠Hear the engines coming
  2. Go go Thomas
  3. Roll along

(HM: day of the diesel’s song)

I love how they were going for a more rock n’ roll style with the songs of this era

(Not to say that the songs from the Brenner era aren’t good they are we’ve got alot of bangers from that era but I just prefer the rock n’ roll style of nitrogen’s bangers)

And also the songs after nitrogen and Brenner are SO forgettable (except maybe don’t stop from season 23 but that still can’t compare to the songs from the nitrogen era)

And also not to mention the toys, the toys during the hit and nitrogen eras peak.


r/thomasthetankengine • • 18h ago

Funny The Troublesome Fallacy.

Post image
103 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 17h ago

Funny Why is this real

Thumbnail
gallery
89 Upvotes

Like why did marvel make these comics


r/thomasthetankengine • • 12h ago

Merchandise HOLY CRAP!!!

Post image
52 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 1h ago

Fanwork (not by OP) I'll say that this scene GENUINELY horrified me. Other than that, Duck had it coming in complete honesty.

38 Upvotes

Credit Video by Biscuit Crew Productions

https://youtu.be/lgbNHDLHwYE?si=-z1dW4VgW2zTd4Kx


r/thomasthetankengine • • 8h ago

Funny "...he's gay isn't he..? And im his biggest fan... that make me gay too don't it?"

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 5h ago

My Original Fanwork (OC) My edit of Thomas

Post image
32 Upvotes

In my honest opinion, he would be more fitting in a BR livery.

The editing is not perfect, but I tried my best putting effort in it.

Made in IbisPaint X.


r/thomasthetankengine • • 10h ago

Character Discussion there's two versions of brenner james

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 21h ago

Funny Remade a non Thomas meme from my time in the Thomas Soundfont.

26 Upvotes

If you don't know the meme you haven't lived in my era


r/thomasthetankengine • • 18h ago

Question Opinions on 1976 thomas

Post image
25 Upvotes

Like what was the story for the pilot would it be cartoony physics or realistic physics idk


r/thomasthetankengine • • 23h ago

General Chat Which toy line do you prefer? Trackmaster revolution or 2026 motorized

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 19h ago

Character Discussion A Henry Origin Theory

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

Ok so first of all I wanna clarify this is about the behind-the-scenes creation of Henry, not his actual lore.

So I was watching Tugs' video and I noticed something about Henry's Awdry illustrations. In them he is a 4-4-2 with a running board only raised over the drivers, a small round-top firebox between the frames and cylinders poking through the running board, as well as a relatively small boiler. These characteristics, in their entirety, all only apply to one specific class of locomotives, the GNR Small Boiler Atlantics/LNER Class C2. Which got me thinking further since Henry was always intended to be green, the LNER's colour of choice for their engines. There was, in fact, a real engine of the C2 Class named Henry, GNR No.990 Henry Oakley, which now has me convinced that, as envisioned by Awdry, Henry was intended as Henry Oakley. Of course this didn't get past the publisher request for the 4th story as that called for something that never happened (whilst the LNER had blue locomotives and whilst it is feasible for Edward to be ex-LNER there is no way an elderly Atlantic or 4-4-0 would ever wear the colour) and I frankly doubt 990 was ever bricked up in a tunnel, but I find the evidence convincing enough that, as originally envisioned, I reckon Awdry initially conceived Henry as a real engine.


r/thomasthetankengine • • 16h ago

Funny Who do you think you are fooling?

Post image
15 Upvotes

I swear this is not edited.


r/thomasthetankengine • • 21h ago

My Original Fanwork Whiff and Scruff in my American Thomas AU

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

Whiff is based on the Reading's Inspection Locomotive. He doesn't do as much shunting, but still pulls trash trains, functioning somewhat as an express freight locomotive, although he can't pull too many cars.

Scruff is based on NYC No. 1897, a Shay with a added shroud. He would be doing most of the shunting, but also slow long drag freights of trash and supplies for the waste dump.


r/thomasthetankengine • • 18h ago

Merchandise New Push Along 2026 Additions

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

New items I got are...

  1. Charlie (who is now merch-exclusive and is sadly not appearing in the show).
  2. Whiff.
  3. Salty.

4 and 5. Plastic versions of Thomas and Percy (Gotten used to the plastic versions of the characters).

6. Red Truck/Freight Car.

7. Clarabel (She and Annie are finally reunited).

8. Bill (No Ben, but he's confirmed and we have to wait next year for him).

9. Troublesome Tanker (First time we got a Push Along toy of a Troublesome Tanker).

10. Diesel and Troublesome Truck Two-Pack (Got this because I skipped out on buying Diesel individually).

Special thanks to my father and my aunt for getting these for me.


r/thomasthetankengine • • 3h ago

My Original Fanwork Splatters Unfinished Laughing Face If It Was Finished

Post image
13 Upvotes

It's easy to see why it was never finalized


r/thomasthetankengine • • 11h ago

Question What would a B-Unit character be like in the Thomas universe?

Post image
13 Upvotes

What would a B-Unit character be like in the Thomas universe? Would it be alive or not? Would it be treated kind of like a "special coach" that a character needs/wants to help them, or as a its own character that is always seen helping the other (Kind of like how Oliver and Toad are often portrayed)?

What would you guys prefer? Let's get a discussion going!


r/thomasthetankengine • • 18h ago

My Original Fanwork 2026 Old Shape Henry Edit i made (i could improve)

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 18h ago

Merchandise So I’m now starting to collect the 2026 Metal Collection die-cast’s

Post image
13 Upvotes

So today I went on a walk around my town and this time I went into ToyMaster and got some of these guys with my own money, I’ve seen videos of unboxing and showcasing them so I might give this a try
So far I’ll say I like how they look, especially Scruffy tho Toby is my least favourite design in my opinion, not to mention for me, the new faces will take a while to get used to
But the ones I’m looking forward to get will be Oliver & Toad since those two are my favourite characters

Also I got the Percy & Clarabel pack and the Toby & Henrietta pack


r/thomasthetankengine • • 2h ago

Funny Found this concept art for the next iteration of Tidmouth Sheds

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 5h ago

Merchandise Is there a reason behind why bachmann topham looks like ertl fat controller?

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 9h ago

General Chat My sad story of Henry’s theme

Post image
12 Upvotes

So, I’m in my school’s orchestra,I play the violin, with me are 2 other violinists, 2 years younger than me who are also Thomas fans. I’m in Grade 7, they in Grade 5. So, I can play Henry’s classic and hit era themes on violin, so one day, when we’re setting up, I play Henry’s classic theme, and they don’t know what song that is, I play it again slowly, still don’t know, only when I play his hit theme, they’re like, “ Oh that’s Henry’s theme.” kids these days. on the plus side they all hate all engines go.


r/thomasthetankengine • • 16h ago

Funny BRO THOUGHT HE COULD FLY😭

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/thomasthetankengine • • 13h ago

General Chat Can someone please explain what they were even thinking with this?

Post image
11 Upvotes

This is not a fan edit, this is in an official book, "Edward's exploit and other TTTE stories" to be precise.


r/thomasthetankengine • • 19h ago

Question 2026 Metal Collection is the most popular pick for best toy of Nia! What is the best toy of Rebecca?

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

rules:

  1. model trains DO count
  2. knockoffs and prototypes do NOT count
  3. trading cards and plushes DO count (obviously)
  4. the capsule plarail thomas hybrids do not count from now on
  5. cancelled toys do NOT count
  6. this is just a fun game, so please don't get mad if the one you picked didn't win