r/tolkienfans • • 4d ago

REMINDER: There is no discussion of Amazon's Rings of Power on this subreddit. Click here to see where you can discuss episodes 5 and 6

288 Upvotes

/r/tolkienfans does not allow discussion of any adaptations, including Amazon Prime's The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power. However, we recognize that some users here will wish to discuss the most recent episode together, and so when the show started we prepared a different subreddit, /r/RingsofPower, run by the some of the same mods, where users from our subreddit can go to discuss this together, from the perspective of the books.

Click here for the /r/RingsofPower post linking all threads for the recent episode releases.

For people interested in other places to discuss the show, there is also /r/LotR_on_Prime, which tends to have a more supportive outlook, and /r/rings_of_power, which tends to have a more critical outlook. Every subreddit has a slightly different feel and you're encouraged to find the one that best fits your needs. Some of the more general subreddits like /r/lotr will also have their own discussion threads, as will other Tolkien communities outside of reddit.

However within /r/tolkienfans all discussion about this show and other adaptations is not allowed. To this end, this post itself is being locked. You are encouraged to report threads and comments that fall foul of the rules whilst showing patience and civility to newcomers who are learning more about Tolkien for the first time.


r/tolkienfans • • 16h ago

did gil-galad never marry?

98 Upvotes

I was looking up Gil-Galad because the actor’s performance in Rings of Power is quite good, and on the One Wiki to Rule them All, it says he’s never married. I wonder why that is? He seems to be a good elf with good moral sand stuff and we see pairs with Galadriel-Celeborn, Elrond-Celebraín, even Thranduil is mentioned to have a wife. Anything particular in the lore?


r/tolkienfans • • 2h ago

I think I found a mistake in the Complete guide to Middle-Earth by Robert Foster

3 Upvotes

p. 298 - ‘Fëanor’ here should be changed to ‘Finwe’, if I am not mistaken. In the previous page it says that Orodreth is a brother of Finrod, thus a son of Finarfin and nephew of Feanor, not a grandchild.


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

Théoden’s Last Ride: Grace, Courage and the Goodness of Men

34 Upvotes

A few rather lengthy musings on Théoden's charge at the Pelennor Fields, particularly its theological implications. This turned into something of an essay, so apologies for the length. Hope some of you enjoy it.

The Pelennor at Dawn

For a moment, as the Rohirrim look down upon Minas Tirith, Théoden seems to grow old before our eyes. He sits motionless on Snowmane, staring at the city under siege, and Tolkien describes him as cowed by age. It is a strange introduction to one of the great charges in heroic literature. The king has brought his people across dangerous country to honour an alliance, only to be struck silent by the sight of what awaits them. The defences of Gondor are breaking. Whatever he imagined his arrival might achieve, the scale of the enemy is now plain.

Then a flash rises from the city and a great sound rolls across the fields. Théoden straightens, calls his men to him and blows his horn so fiercely that it bursts. His riders answer, and the narrative gathers speed with them. Soon he is ahead of his banner, beyond the reach of his household knights. The king whom Merry has just seen diminished by fear becomes almost impossible to follow.

Tolkien’s description does something more complicated than celebrate a sudden recovery of nerve. “Fey he seemed”, the narrator says, before offering another possibility: the battle-fury of his fathers may be running through his veins. He is borne upon Snowmane like Oromë the Great, a power from the world’s earliest days. The comparison magnifies a mortal king, but fey casts a shadow across the splendour. The word carries an old sense of doom, of a man marked for death. Tolkien leaves us with the excitement of the charge and knowledge of its cost in the same breath. Even the cause of Théoden’s transformation is left open: something uncanny may be at work, or the fierce inheritance of his own people may have awakened in him.

That uncertainty matters because Théoden arrives at the Pelennor with a history he cannot escape. Théodred is dead. Saruman’s influence has grievously weakened Rohan, and Gríma has helped turn the king’s age and grief into a kind of captivity. Gandalf’s coming to Edoras restored his capacity to act, though it could not give him back the time he had lost. At Minas Tirith, dread threatens him again. The charge therefore belongs to a longer struggle over what sort of man he can still be. His courage is neither inexhaustible nor untouched by failure.

Augustine’s account of evil as a privation of good offers a useful way of reading that struggle. Created human nature is good, bearing the image of God; corruption wounds and distorts it without making goodness irrecoverable. In Théoden we see a man whose loyalty, affection and authority have survived long years of misuse and despair. When he rides, these qualities are suddenly exercised together. The Christian language of grace can illuminate such a recovery, provided we do not mistake a literary comparison for proof of a supernatural event. His kingship, long reduced to a title that others could manipulate, has become an active responsibility again. Before Minas Tirith, stripped of every promise of safety, he chooses to ride first.

The Courage to Answer

When Hirgon brings the Red Arrow to Rohan, he brings a request that might reasonably be refused. Gondor is in peril, but Rohan has only recently endured war with Saruman and cannot spare men without risk. Théoden nevertheless tells the messenger that even if his own country faced no danger, he would go to Denethor’s aid. The qualification is revealing. His obligation to Gondor does not depend entirely upon whether Gondor’s survival serves Rohan’s interests.

There is an old oath behind this decision, as well as the pride of a king who knows what his forebears would have done. Tolkien takes both seriously. Théoden is a man of the Mark, formed by its language of loyalty, honour and remembered deeds. Yet the oath becomes meaningful when honouring it is dangerous. He must send men who have families and homes of their own into a battle from which many will never return. Friendship between kingdoms has become a claim upon his conscience, with consequences he cannot make safe.

Christ’s command to love one’s neighbour has force here because Théoden’s neighbours are people for whom he must incur a cost. Affection alone would be inadequate to the situation. He is called upon to recognise a need outside his own household and kingdom and to answer it with the means available to him. His motives need not be purified of every concern for honour before the act can be good. In Tolkien’s world, the love of one’s people and the desire to be worthy of one’s fathers can lead a person towards generosity. They can also narrow his sympathies. At the Red Arrow, Théoden allows an inherited duty to carry him beyond the borders of the land he rules.

The men defending Minas Tirith make a less glorious demand upon our attention. For them the battle begins long before the horns of Rohan sound. The Nazgûl have filled the city with dread; fires burn, the Great Gate is broken, and those still resisting have little reason to believe that they will live to see relief. Their courage is measured in hours spent holding ground and caring for what remains. If they abandon the city, there may be nothing for Théoden to rescue when he arrives.

This endurance belongs beside the king’s charge, though it is easier to overlook. Philippians 4:11–13 is often made to sound like a promise of limitless achievement. Paul is speaking there about learning to live through hunger and plenty, need and abundance. His claim to strength through Christ concerns fidelity under conditions he cannot command. It offers a more searching comparison with the people of Gondor than the expectation that virtue will somehow guarantee victory. Their task is to continue while hope of success grows faint. Théoden’s is to come, knowing that he may be too late.

Grace and the Turning of the Light

The first sign of Mordor’s defeat on the Pelennor is a reversal of fear. Sauron’s servants have used terror to weaken resistance, and the Nazgûl have made even the air above Minas Tirith an instrument of despair. Now the Rohirrim break upon the besieging army, and “terror took them”. The phrase is brutally satisfying: an army accustomed to frightening others discovers the sensation for itself.

Tolkien makes the riders sing as they kill. That detail is difficult to domesticate into a simple account of Christian charity. The Rohirrim are exhilarated by battle; the passage has wrath and violence in it, and their enemies are trampled beneath the charge. Heroic joy is part of the poetry of Rohan, not a synonym for holiness. Yet the question of what this fury serves remains essential. These men have crossed the plains to defend a city that is not theirs. The force of their attack is made possible by a willingness to spend their lives on behalf of others. Sauron can exploit the instinct for self-preservation, but he cannot count on it being the strongest motive in every human heart.

The change in the battlefield’s light is woven into this reversal. A wind comes from the sea; morning breaks through the darkness; Théoden lifts a shield that shines like the sun. Beneath Snowmane, Tolkien says, “the grass flamed into green”. It is a wonderfully exact image. We need not imagine grass literally springing into existence. The returning light reveals the living colour of a field that darkness had concealed. For an instant the land itself seems to answer the riders, as though the world they are fighting to preserve has become visible again.

That image can bear a theological reading without being turned into an allegorical code. Tolkien called The Lord of the Rings a fundamentally religious and Catholic work in Letter 142, while elsewhere resisting the reduction of his stories to imposed allegorical meanings. Within his mythology, creation has its source in Ilúvatar and remains good despite the damage inflicted upon it. Even Manwë’s association with the winds gives the sea breeze a mythic resonance. Still, the text does not tell us that a Vala has sent it to reward the Rohirrim. The wind can be wind, the sunlight sunlight, and the conjunction of their arrival with Théoden’s courage can retain its force.

Catholic Providence works through a world with its own integrity and through creatures capable of genuine choice. A providential account of events therefore need not compete with an account of cavalry, weather or the decisions of kings. At the Pelennor these causes meet in a moment that none of the participants could have arranged. The defenders have held on; the riders have come; the darkness begins to lift. The narrative allows us to perceive a larger order in that convergence, without giving us the authority to name every movement of a divine hand.

Tolkien is much more direct about grace in Letter 246. Writing about Frodo at Mount Doom, he refuses to treat the hobbit’s inability to surrender the Ring as a straightforward moral failure. Frodo has reached the limit of what he can bear. His earlier mercy towards Gollum, an act whose consequences he could never have calculated, helps make the destruction of the Ring possible. Tolkien also writes of the grace given to Frodo in accepting the quest and enduring it. Here the relation between human action and Providence is unmistakable: Frodo’s choices matter, although the final deliverance exceeds his strength.

Tolkien adds a sobering qualification to his account of Frodo: the grace given to a creature is not without limit. The quest can carry him to the end of his strength. This makes it harder to read the Pelennor’s dawn as a promise that brave men will be preserved from harm. The possibility of Providence gives a deeper meaning to their choices, while leaving them exposed to everything the battle can do to them.

Mortality, Freedom and the Goodness of Men

The light that makes Théoden’s charge so magnificent does not last. As the Witch-king returns, Tolkien writes that the new morning is blotted from the sky. A black dart strikes Snowmane, and the horse rears and crashes onto his rider. Soon Merry finds the king dying on the field, able to take comfort in the thought that he will go to his fathers without shame. It is a fitting measure of a king of Rohan: he still thinks in terms of honour, kinship and the deeds of those who came before him. His final satisfaction is that his own life will bear comparison with theirs.

Tolkien gives the mortality of Men an importance that reaches far beyond the battlefield. Their death is called the Gift of Ilúvatar: they leave the circles of the world for a destiny that even the wise cannot fully describe. Such a gift is difficult to recognise as one when loss is near. The history of Númenor shows how disastrously fear of death can deform a great people. Sauron exploits the Númenóreans’ resentment of their limits until Ar-Pharazôn attempts to take immortality by invading Aman. He has extraordinary power, but wants the one thing force cannot give him.

Théoden, with his failing strength and few years left, moves in the opposite direction. He cannot enlarge his life or secure his legacy against every possible loss. He can decide what those remaining years, and perhaps his final morning, are for. The comparison with Númenor does not make him indifferent to death. His moment of dread before Minas Tirith shows how humanly he feels its approach. That fear remains part of the courage Tolkien asks us to admire. His consent to the ride has weight because he knows what he stands to lose.

After the Pelennor, Gandalf tells the captains of the West that it is “not our part to master all the tides of the world”. He speaks of doing what lies within their power for those who will come after them. Earlier, Tolkien described the foremost riders of Rohan as a breaker foaming towards the shore. They had seemed, for a few moments, like an irresistible force. Gandalf’s words return us to the limits beneath that image. The captains have won a battle; they cannot command the history that follows it. What remains in their power is the work immediately before them.

The last conversation between Théoden and Merry brings this immense struggle down to a more intimate scale. The dying king forgives the hobbit for disobeying his orders and asks him to remember him when he is sitting peacefully with his pipe. Théoden had once promised to listen to Merry’s talk of herbs at Meduseld. They will never have that conversation. The lost prospect is so small beside the fate of kingdoms that it is easy to miss its force. The ordinary peace Théoden has helped to defend is a peace he will never share.


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

Finally diving into the History of Middle Earth after the Athrabeth blew me away. Any recommendations?

10 Upvotes

I've read a lot of Tolkien, but I would like to step up and dive into the History of Middle Earth and the History of the Lord of the Rings, since I have all the volumes at home.

Right now I'm awestruck by the Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth. I bumped into it while looking through Morgoth's Ring, and I'm surprised I didn't know about this literary gem before. It is a great piece of philosophy and theology that I'm truly captivated by. If you haven't heard about it, just check it out!

Since the History series is huge and not the easiest read in the world, do you have any chapters or sections you recommend? Thanks!


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

Recording of Tolkien saying all 13 Dwarf names

88 Upvotes

Here's a short clip of Tolkien reading a paragraph that contains all 13 dwarf names, extracted from that elusive "Roast Mutton" tape recording he made in (presumably) 1952.

https://od.lk/s/NTdfMTA5MDExODg0X0hwcTdR/Roast-Mutton_dwarf-names.wav

I did some EQ work on it to improve the quality a bit.

Note how he pronounces Óin and Glóin as two short syllables, and Thorin with a long [ɔː].

The most interesting part is that he pronounces Bifur and Bofur as /bivur/ and /bovur/, in accordance with the intervocalic lenition rule.
Everyone gets it wrong.


Soon Dwalin lay by Balin, and Fili and Kili together, and Dori and Nori and Ori all in a heap, and Óin and Glóin and Bifur and Bofur and Bombur piled uncomfortably near the fire. “That’ll teach ’em,” said Tom; for Bifur and Bombur had given a lot of trouble, and fought like mad, as dwarves will when cornered. Thorin came last—and he was not caught unawares.


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

Sauron's Gradual Loss of Shapeshifting Powers

28 Upvotes

Hello-

On a YT comment forum I'm getting into it with a person who claims that in the SA Sauron could transform into a flying creature if they wanted. I said to this person that Sauron had lost the ability to do this by the SA, because his abilities get weaker every time he dies.

I base this on a couple of tidbits of information: we're told for sure that he lost his ability to have a "fair form" after he gets killed in Numenor, and we know he shapeshifts into monstrous forms in the FA but not the SA or TA. So my working assumption is that he loses physical form during the sinking of Beleriand at the end of the War of Wrath, which causes him to lose his ability to morph into anything. Then at the fall of Numenor he gets weaker again and loses the ability to hold a pleasing shape. Then after dying for a third time after the War of the Last Alliance he's even weaker and needs centuries to be able to hold a shape again.

Does this hold up? I don't know if Sauron's ultimate fate at the end of the War of Wrath is explicitly given. The person debating (well, mocking) me says he only started getting weaker after the fall of Numenor since part of his essence is now in the ring. But that doesn't account for why he then only takes humanoid shapes in SA. This person is also claiming Sauron was cursed by Illuvatar, but I'm not aware of anything like that happening.

EDIT: thanks to all who replied. If I'm going to summarize what I see here, it's "he lost his universal shapeshifting powers from lack of use, and MAYBE could have still turned into anything in SA but at a cost of energy that likely wouldn't be worth it".


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

Translating "On Translation"

5 Upvotes

For people like me who do not live in English-speaking countries, how did the Tolkien translation deal with the second part of Appendix F? My edition simply gave up.


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

My greatest regret is not having known Tolkien much earlier in my life

36 Upvotes

Tolkien's Legendarium saved my life when I was 22 years old, almost 10 years ago and yet, much too late. Since then, I wish everydays I knew of his universe when I was a pre-teen, or even as a child, when I went through the darkest and most traumatic years of my life, so it could've provided me the shelter I needed, and find the strength I needed to endure. I feel the same with my second favorite universe: the forgotten realms especially Drizzt book series. I really needed this escapism. And aside this, I would've been more free to engage with it than during adulthood. As a child, I had daydreams and topics I would obsess over, but they were unhealthy and made me feel more depressed. My life and my true self started from the day I watched the Lord of the rings for the first time. I am so envious anytime I see someone mentioning having read Tolkien or Drizzt books in their childhood. I mourn the too many years that were wasted without knowing them. However, I am still grateful this wonderful escapism has been in my life now since 2017.


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

Lúthein

16 Upvotes

When she died the second time did her soul go where men's souls went when they die?


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

Why Valar were so passive?

33 Upvotes

I find it weird that Valar remained passive before War of Wrath, while elves and men fought Morgoth for a long, long time. I get that they were afraid of engaging in full scale confrontation, which might destroy Arda, but they could at least provide more help.

And even War of Wrath would not happen if Earendil did not get to Valinor by miracle. Valar would just keep sitting doing nothing while Morgoth rules Arda and makes everyone suffer...

Another case of their passiveness was doing nothing for 3000 (!) years after War of Power when Morgoth was imprisoned. Surely they could have used this time to eradicate evil remaining after him (like balrogs, other fallen Maiars and orcs) instead of letting it live and grow later into threat again?

Perhaps there were other examples of their strange behavior too - did I miss something?


r/tolkienfans • • 2d ago

Why did nearly all dragons stay in Withered Heath?

85 Upvotes

The dragons survived the First Age escaped to Withered Heath and multiplied there. They only re-appeared in record at third millenia of Third Age, during the war with the dwarves. And after that, only 1 dragon crossed the Grey Mountains to attack Erebor.

Dragons are famous for their greed, so what keep them staying in wasteland of the north so long? I doubt there is any settlement for them to pillage and gathered wealth- so for thousand years they just lived there like wild beast, hunt animal to survive and breed? And after drove the Dwarves away, what keep them from cross Grey Moutains to pillage the south like Smaug did? The gold left behind by Dwarven settlements are enough to satisfied their greed for so long?


r/tolkienfans • • 19h ago

Gandalf is the Archangel Raphaël

0 Upvotes

Everyone points out the obvious Christ parallels in Lord of the Rings, but Gandalf’s actual role mirrors the Archangel Raphael in the Book of Tobit (a standard part of Tolkien’s Catholic Bible).

The overlap explains why Gandalf doesn't just spam magic to solve every problem:

* Undercover angel: Raphael disguises himself as an ordinary man ("Azariah") so he doesn't overwhelm mortals. Gandalf is an immortal Maia bound to an old man's body for the exact same reason.

* Guide, not the hero: Raphael acts as a hired travel guide, letting Tobias actually complete the quest. Gandalf nudges Bilbo and Frodo along without carrying them.

* Holding back: Instead of snapping his fingers to fix things, Raphael teaches Tobias to ward off a demon and heal his father himself. Gandalf similarly limits his magic so mortals have to step up.

* Fighting peers only: Both keep a low profile around humans, only unleashing their true power against demonic equals (Raphael binding Asmodeus vs. Gandalf fighting the Balrog).

* Refusing the reward: Raphael turns down half of Tobias's gold, reveals his true nature, and returns to heaven. Gandalf refuses the Ring and sails back to the Undying Lands once his work is done.

Gandalf wasn't sent to be the hero—he was sent to walk beside ordinary people until they could handle things themselves.

Has anyone else noticed this, or know if Tolkien ever mentioned Tobit?


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

Forgotten Gandalf

1 Upvotes

Bilbo not immediately recognizing Gandalf, makes no sense to me. Maybe he never actually saw him, forgetting a tall firework wielding wizard, loosely connected to your family seems unlikely. Then suddenly getting a human visitor while Living in an isolated community.


r/tolkienfans • • 2d ago

Classical music fans, is there a piece that tries to pay homage to the Ainulindale?

24 Upvotes

I hope I accurately portrayed what I am asking for. I would have thought that someone would have tried to put some music to such a wonderful piece of literature on a music creating the world


r/tolkienfans • • 2d ago

Could Manwë wield the Ring without turning to evil?

94 Upvotes

Any Maiar would fall. Iluvatar is so powerful the Ring is irrelevant. But Manwë? If not him, what about, say, Tulkas?


r/tolkienfans • • 2d ago

Why was the culvert of Helm's Deep left undefended?

64 Upvotes

Seems like a pretty obvious weakness. Or were the defenders simply planning to shoot any orcs that tried to get through from the ramparts above?

The explanation that I came up with is that unlike the movie depiction, the culvert was placed in the middle of the stream like these images, surrounded by water and therefore requiring a precarious and slippery climb in the rain to get to:

https://c8.alamy.com/comp/B7W6GP/ancient-culvert-B7W6GP.jpg

https://nhgardensolutions.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/7-box-culvert.jpg

Which would make the orcs mission to climb through the culvert more impressive and daring than in the movie, where they can simply walk up to it!

Edit: this question is not about why the defenders obviously didn't expect explosives lol, but about the moment in the book where the orcs get through the culvert to the other side of the wall, and actually hide there for a little while before jumping out! Why didn't they expect that?


r/tolkienfans • • 2d ago

"The one all-seeing eye" appears in a poem by one of Tolkien's closest friends, Geoffrey Smith. The poem is titled "For R.Q.G." (Robert Gilson, their mutual friend who had died in battle that month). Smith died a few months later, and Tolkien edited and helped publish his poems.

2 Upvotes

See the second line in the poem below. No idea if this actually inspired Sauron's all-seeing eye, but it's a beautiful and bitter poem so I wanted to share it.

For R. Q. G.

July 1916

O God, whose great inscrutable purposes
(Seen only of the one all-seeing eye)
Are as unchangeable as the azure sky,
And as fulfilled of infinite mysteries:
Are like a fast-locked castle without keys
Whereof the gates are very strong and high,
Impenetrable, and we poor fools die
Nor even know what thing beyond them is:
O God, by whom men’s lives are multiplied,
Are scattered broadcast in the world like grain,
And after long time reaped again and stored,
O Thou who only canst be glorified
By man’s own passion and the supreme pain,
Accept this sacrifice of blood outpoured.


r/tolkienfans • • 2d ago

Secret weapons from mithril?

51 Upvotes

As we know from LoTR, mithril was coveted by Sauron, as “all folk desired it”. HoME 7 adds another angle: “Mithril is now nearly all lost. Orcs plunder it … They give it in tribute to Sauron, who has long been gathering and hoarding all that he can find. It is not known why: not for beauty, but for some secret purpose in the making of weapons of war.”

Any guesses what those secret weapons could be? Maybe something trivial, like mithril coats for all Nazgul (those Arnorian blades are such a nuisance). Or maybe not. We know that Aragorn successfully provoked Sauron into starting the war earlier than he planned it. Could there be a 99% ready “Big Bertha” hiding under the ruins of Barad Dur?


r/tolkienfans • • 2d ago

What do we know about the Blue Wizards' influence in the East?

14 Upvotes

Tolkien's letters give us only fragments about Alatar and Pallando, yet their mission seems to have been fundamentally different from the other Istari. We know they traveled far into the East and South, and that one late note suggests they may have founded magical cults or hindered Sauron's recruitment there.

I'm curious how much weight people give to the various versions Tolkien left behind. Did their efforts meaningfully weaken the Enemy's eastern armies, or were they simply absorbed into the local cultures and lost to the main story? Any references I'm missing that clarify their purpose or fate?


r/tolkienfans • • 2d ago

Question about the outcome of everything in tolkien's work

9 Upvotes

So what comes to be in Middle Earth/ Arda is a result of the music made by the ainur. But ultimately everything comes from the thought and will of Eru. Eru gives his children and the ainor freethinking and ultimately intervenes when he deems it necessary. Does that mean melkor and sauron never had a chance of ever succeeding in their goals?


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

After buying, The Silmarillion, I directly went to the chronology .org

0 Upvotes

To create my customised table for the series, now there are a lot of abbreviations like aa, ea, ab can someone explain me where can I find their meanings


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

What was the significance of Éowyn revealing her hair at the "I am no man" moment when the Rohirrim men also have long hair?

0 Upvotes

When Aragorn & co. first encounter Éomer and his men, the Rohirrim are described as having hair that streams behind them in the wind, and it's also said to be braided. Seems like the men of Rohan have pretty long hair themselves.

I'm assuming their culture probably had a different "long" for men's hair vs women's hair??


r/tolkienfans • • 3d ago

which part of middle-earth's history deserves a full book?

25 Upvotes

I've always been fascinated by how much history exists beyond the events of the The hobbit and LOTR. The first age especially has so many fascinating characters, conflicts, and tragedies. I'd love to read even more about the smaller events that shaped the world before the War of the ring. Which period or historical event from Tolkien's legendarium would you most like to see explored in greater detail?