My whole life I typed on keyboards by hunt and peck, and about 6 months ago I read an article about layouts and typing. That's when I realized I was typing inefficiently. I found the history of Dvorak really interesting, and I realized that the usual problem (being so used to QWERTY that you can't migrate efficiently to another layout) didn't apply to me, because I had never learned QWERTY. So, as an experiment, I decided to learn touch typing with Dvorak.
Learning the layout took me very little time (a week), and I used a layout different from standard Dvorak (one where R is swapped with H) to adapt it to Spanish. First of all, even though Dvorak is a layout designed for English, it adapts very well to Spanish if you swap R and H. Its main purpose (hand alternation) was fulfilled quite well, and I noticed it a lot during the first month. After reaching one month and crossing the 60 wpm barrier, I moved from keybr to Monkeytype, and over the next 5 months I doubled my wpm. My 30-second peak is 126 wpm.
I have several things to say. First, so as not to taint the experiment, I tried to learn as cleanly as possible. I tried not to pick up odd finger positions or tics. Everything done orthodoxly, all 8 fingers on the home row, and that's it.
What cost me the most was coordinating the vowels (and it remained a thorn in my side until the end). Especially at the beginning, the transition from U to I felt extremely uncomfortable, and unfortunately I never managed to get rid of the tic where, after using I, I would leave the finger there instead of returning it to U, which made me make a lot of positioning mistakes.
Mastering the top row with the right hand was also hard, especially F, G and C. They were always a bottleneck for my speed, although my accuracy stayed quite high.
I didn't have many problems with the bottom rows, in fact it was the one that took the least effort to master, even though I didn't practice it much (since those keys aren't used very often). At the beginning I would mistakenly type B when I wanted M, but I guess that falls within the margin of error.
I never got comfortable with X and F.
At the beginning, using the pinky fingers was terribly hard, but over the months I got used to it and they stopped being bottlenecks.
The ring finger always felt uncomfortable, while the index finger was the easiest to use.
Things I noticed when typing sentences and long texts: although I had mastered the bottom row for individual words, when I had to use it frequently, errors were very common.
60% of my errors involved vowels, especially coordination errors between E and O, or U and I.
I think the position of the period, comma and (in my case the dead tilde, but for you the ') is very unergonomic, because it relies on weak fingers for punctuation, although I suppose it's a necessary evil.
My biggest complaint is that many word combinations become uncomfortable and very prone to errors. I don't know whether this is mostly because I've only been learning touch typing for 6 months, or whether it's the layout itself, or if it's because I'm using a layoit designed for English to wirte mainly in Spanish. That's exactly why I'm going to learn QWERTY.
My keyboard is a Keychron Q1 (mechanical), a 75% ANSI.
I plan to learn QWERTY until I cross the 75 wpm barrier. Once I get there, I'll see whether I feel more comfortable using QWERTY. If not, I'll try Colemak until I reach 75 wpm and then make my verdict.
This post isn't meant to claim anything about the nature of the layout; I'm just sharing my experience over these 6 months. Thanks for reading.