PSA: You can number MORE than 5 preferences in the Victorian upper house election. Polling staff should be making this clear.
Just early voted in the Victorian election, and the electoral official handing out ballot papers instructed me to vote “1 to 5 above the line or 1 to 5 below the line”.
That’s not quite right, and I think we should be angry at the VEC training if this is commonplace.
The requirement is to number AT LEAST 5 boxes, either above or below the line. You can keep numbering as many preferences as you like.
Why does this matter?
Victoria has abolished group voting tickets, meaning your preferences are now determined by you, not by backroom deals between political parties. More importantly, your vote can exhaust if you don’t number enough preferences.
This is particularly important if you’re voting below the line. Five preferences above the line can cover dozens of individual candidates, whereas five preferences below the line covers exactly five candidates. That gives your vote far fewer opportunities to transfer before exhausting.
What really bothers me is that this instruction came directly from a VEC electoral official. People reasonably assume that the person handing them their ballot paper is giving them accurate instructions on how to vote.
I’m not suggesting the official was deliberately misleading anyone. But unintentional misinformation from an electoral official is still misinformation, and arguably more concerning because voters have every reason to trust it.
There’s an enormous difference between explaining the minimum requirements for a formal vote and giving instructions that sound like a limit on how many preferences you’re allowed to express.
If this is how polling staff are being trained to explain the new system, it’s a serious problem.
And if it’s simply an individual official getting the wording wrong, the VEC needs to make sure it isn’t happening elsewhere.
We’re talking about a preferential voting system where the whole point is that voters get to determine their own preferences. Having the electoral authority inadvertently encourage people to truncate those preferences is a pretty fundamental failure of voter education.
PSA: You can number more than five preferences. Five is the minimum, not the maximum.

