r/worldjerking • u/unclesoppa • 4h ago
What is the maximum radius for a planet so that being a flat earther makes no sense?
Everyone knows flat earthers are a silly bunch. But obviously they have something of an inkling of a point. If you're just hanging out on a field, the curvature of the Earth is pretty much irrelevant and local topological variation will obscure it, so "in practice", the Earth is flat.
From the perspective of the everyman, the Earth is close enough to flat, thus it's somewhat reasonable to arrive at the conclusion that the planet we live on is flat if one misses the several signs pointing towards this not being the case out of ignorance.
However, if we imagine a planet with a truly massive radius, assuming that it's flat is much more reasonable. Humans proved the roundness of the thing we lived on in antiquity, but such measurements become harder and harder as the radius of the planet increases. And of course, a round planet with practically infinite radius would be basically flat, at least to anyone on it. Thus I posit that being a flat earther is more valid, the larger the radius of your planet is.
The inverse will also apply. If your planet is basically a Super Mario Galaxy level or from The Little Prince, it's absolutely obvious to even a small uneducated child that the world is not flat, since you can circumnavigate it within minutes. Thus, smaller the radius, the less reasonable it is to be a flat earther.
Therefore I must pose the question: "What is the smallest radius for a planet where it makes no sense to be a flat earther?"
Of course one might say "it makes no sense on our planet", but I'd argue that from the perspective of, let's say a medieval peasant without education, it makes at least "a little sense" even if it's incorrect.
So I guess I would rephrase this to: "What is the smallest radius for a planet where it makes no sense for even an uneducated peasant to be a flat earther?