r/worldnews • u/Arsene_Yuka_1980 • 18h ago
The AI Riemann hypothesis proof is almost certainly true, independent mathematicians attest
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-ai-riemann-hypothesis-proof-is-almost-certainly-true-independent-mathematicians-attest/
3.6k
Upvotes
32
u/Arsene_Yuka_1980 18h ago
I'm posting this article because it's the most recent one, but the Lean and Mathlib communities, endorsed by the Lean FRO and the Mathlib Initiative, have fully accepted the result. Below is their official statement:
Lean verification of the Riemann Hypothesis | Lean community blog
3.2k
u/WhoKnewSomethingOnce 18h ago •
Many people don't understand that the real world utility of proving Riemann Hypothesis is irrelevant for this event (though it will have a very significant impact on hundreds of papers which assumed it to be true. Also, it has a very wide application in mathematics and physics). The significant thing is that this was a beacon, it was the holy grail in number theory. Almost two centuries of brilliant mathematicians tried and couldn't solve it, and it is now proven. Many mathematicians alive today didn't believe it would be solved in their lifetimes.
We are witnessing history in making. Century from now, this year will be remembered as an important milestone.
24
u/bazzoka05 13h ago
I'm at too afraid to ask but can someone explain what it is in laymen terms? What is the theory about? What does it explain? Why couldn't people solve it until now?
546
u/Additional-Name-3211 18h ago
I think it’s becoming increasingly clear that we’re living in a sort of Industrial Revolution for intellectual work.
I have no doubt that the benefits will be enormous over the long term. I also have no doubt that our relationship to work, technology and the economy will be so transformed that our current system will need to go through some painful and radical changes so that all of us can enjoy said benefits.
Buckle up. Be safe. Keep in touch with your friends and loved ones. It’s going to be a wild ride.
111
u/SerendipityQuest 17h ago
"It was the best of times, it was the worst of times."
195
u/dak7 18h ago
This doesn’t mean we can predict prime numbers (we’ve known of this for a long time and many expected it to be true).
Think of this like quantum mechanics for prime numbers.
QM can tell us a region to find an electron (probability) but not where it is.
RH can tell us a region to expect to find prime numbers (and not to) but not exactly where they occur.
388
u/sovietrage 18h ago •
Do cancer next
1.2k
u/Bardfinn 18h ago •
How? It’s 250,000 pages. Proofs that are 1,000 pages long take a team of mathematicians a year to check. How can the “independent mathematicians” assure anything about a 250,000 page proof in 36 hours?
34
u/KingOfAnarchy 17h ago
Is Matt Parker on vacation again?
25
u/SlummiPorvari 13h ago
The beef of this would be to figure out what did the AI find that humans missed.
95
u/Accomplished-Mix-745 18h ago
My AI gf told me this was inportant but wouldn’t tell me why
36
u/The_Pandalorian 4h ago
"Almost certainly true" sounds super-duper fucking mathematical.
52
u/zenithfury 8h ago •
It certainly does not matter how much good the AIs and LLMs do if they cannot be wrested away from the tech oligarchs who are only interested in profit over everything else. If the tech companies have their way, future breakthroughs will be paywalled. At the very least, research groups ought to maintain their own AIs and not be beholden to anyone else.
5
u/Sea_Enthusiasm626 2h ago
Doubt is not a pleasant condition, but certainty is an absurd one.
•
u/Natural_Precision 54m ago
It's great that we've concluded the proof is probably correct. Does anyone actually understand the proof?
19
u/lowkeytokay 18h ago
It would have been really on brand with the current times if it proved the Riemann hypothesis to be wrong.
24
u/Davidriggs87 17h ago
How does this affect LeBron’s legacy?
•
u/stumpychubbins 59m ago
Being true and being useful are not the same thing. I don’t dispute the accuracy of the proof, but with the Poincare Conjecture solving it improved our understanding of (for example) heat transfer and material science, and the work required for it has been cited as a foundation for many other results. The AI lean code is, at best, Deep Thought stating that the answer to life, the universe and everything is 42.
9
u/ConclusionKind869 13h ago
Can someone explain what this hypothesis is? Apologies for ignorance
12
u/D3adbyte 4h ago
The amount of ignorance in the comments is astonishing.
6
u/Salty_Hedgehog_6931 18h ago
We need gregori perleman to verify. 😂
13
u/100pctCashmere 6h ago
At some point AI will become an oracle. It’ll tell u that something is true and humans will never understand why.
16
u/treebeard87_vn 18h ago
I think that in the future mathematicians will need to kind of Renaissancize themselves. Even if AI can help with all theoretical matters, it will still be humans who decide what we want with that knowledge, which products, or which constructs we want to build, which societal efforts we want to fund, which planets we want to discover... and our resources will always be limited in some way for all of our wishes to be fulfilled. Moreover, when it comes to interdisciplinary realms, what is true or false will not be that clearly delineated anymore, and different factions of humans will bring up different narratives (now formulated with the help of different LLMs) to defend their own interests.
People who can bring maths into philosophy, into arts, into "building new things" (to borrow the language of the techbros - actually, many Renaissance artists were also builders and entrepreneurs), into politics etc will win.
6
u/tommytornado 12h ago
Hold up, isn't the proof 250,000 pages?
11
u/julianitonft 18h ago
I don’t understand what this is about but is humanity saved yet?
4
u/StatisticianOk5130 9h ago
Why is everyone bringing up the 250000 pages? The guy behind the proof literally said he isn’t going to release that natural language proof because it is not comprehensible, and is releasing the lean verification for now, while continuing to work on generating a readable natural language proof. “oH bUt iT iSn’T aDdInG aNy VaLuE iF tHe ProOf iS 250k pAgEs LoNg” - yes, obviously, and the people behind this are working on it. Are you unhappy that as of now we only know that the RH is true without entirely understanding why? Well either wait for them to finish the write up or get off of redit and write it up yourself. Jesus
5
u/ImTheVayne 18h ago
That is incredible!
4
u/chudthirtyseven 18h ago
what did this even mean
2
u/sidepart 14h ago
Congrats Albert Riemann!
2
u/sunnyjum 8h ago
I can see human involvement becoming something akin to the god of the gaps argument. There will be people so desperately adamant that humans have some kind of special sauce (and understandably so) that they will find ever shrinking gaps of ability to plug with humans.
The great humbling is beginning.
2
u/Dry-Season-522 5h ago
I'm not worried about AI proving the Riemann hypothesis.
I'm worrieda bout AI proving the dark forest.
2
u/akshayjamwal 3h ago
“Almost certainly” is an oxymoron.
1
u/IIIMephistoIII 15h ago
Does it solve the Abraxas Conjecture and the Ninth Proof of Folding?
1
u/Shot_in_the_dark777 6h ago
Time to square the circle and double the volume of the cube. Let's go!
1
u/Lighter_Butane 3h ago
This means absolutely nothing for the average person
1
u/demoliahedd 2h ago
So this is pretty huge evidence that AI can reason beyond human capacity rather than just copying and aggregating things humans have already done. That's kind of scary, imagine a world where technology and stuff is based on things we can verify work but don't have the capacity to understand how.
1
u/S-O-M_ 2h ago
So its Riemann law now ?
1
u/Igarlicbread 2h ago
What a man has to do to save the stock price from tanking huh!
1
u/QuilSato 1h ago
Can any clever people tell me what the outcomes of this are, I’m assuming this won’t unlock portals or interstellar flight or something but how might it be used for physics and so on?
•
u/RaspberryPrimary8622 1h ago
He hasn’t solved jack. He can’t explain how the solution works and what insights can be gained from it. That makes what he has done useless. He’s a corporate shill, not a scholar. He released his AI slop as a PR stunt to prop up the ailing share price of his financially doomed company.
•
u/Quick-Adagio-7392 1h ago
I would like to see the 500 page document transcribed into a legitimate mathematical proof.
•
u/bearwood_forest 1h ago
Mathematicians considered the Riemann hypothesis "almost certainly true" before this "proof", so it didn't really change anything.
So much so that a whole pile of proofs have been published for decades that hold if the RH is true.
•
u/Quick-Adagio-7392 1h ago
Just think about this. We can ask AI to solve any question like “Where did the Universe come from” or “which came first. The chicken or the egg” or “does a fallen tree make any sound if no one was there to hear it” or “are we living in a created reality?🤔
•
u/Designer-Type1777 59m ago
With Ai there are two options in our future: subjugation or revolt.
•
u/Murky-Wind2222 26m ago
I hear the proof is 250 pages long. Nobody has assessed it yet.