r/worldnews • • 18h ago

The AI Riemann hypothesis proof is almost certainly true, independent mathematicians attest

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-ai-riemann-hypothesis-proof-is-almost-certainly-true-independent-mathematicians-attest/
3.6k Upvotes

931 comments sorted by

32

u/Arsene_Yuka_1980 18h ago

I'm posting this article because it's the most recent one, but the Lean and Mathlib communities, endorsed by the Lean FRO and the Mathlib Initiative, have fully accepted the result. Below is their official statement:

Lean verification of the Riemann Hypothesis | Lean community blog

On November 20, 2026, Levent Alpöge released a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis as a Lean library comprising 17 million lines of code.

We have full confidence that Alpöge's proof of the Riemann Hypothesis is correct, and we congratulate him on this achievement.

Our rationale is outlined below.

The codebase depends directly only on Mathlib. Over the past day, the Lean and Mathlib communities have rallied to verify the proof's correctness. We hereby certify that both the statement and the proof of the Riemann Hypothesis are correct. The four criteria in https://xenaproject.wordpress.com/2026/11/12/and-the-proof-is-checked-in-lean/ are all satisfied.

The statement of the Riemann Hypothesis is correct. This statement is part of Mathlib: RiemannHypothesis and has been carefully vetted by experts in Lean and number theory.

Alpöge’s library compiles correctly. By now, dozens of people have reported correct compilation of the codebase, reproducing the same raw proof export file. The library compiles without errors or build failures.

The code proves the correct statement. Crucially, the community has added a file that isolates the statement of the Riemann Hypothesis and imports only Mathlib. That statement was compared against the theorem proved by Alpöge using two independent tools (comparator and con-leche –compare), both confirming that the theorem proved in Alpöge’s library is exactly Mathlib’s statement of the Riemann Hypothesis.

The Lean proof is valid. The exported raw proof has been checked by several proof checkers, including Lean’s official kernel, the con-leche and con-ron checkers, and several independent checkers contributed by third parties and implemented in different programming languages. The checkers con-leche and con-ron come with a formal proof, relative to set theory, that they cannot accept a false proof, thus addressing concerns that Lean’s logic itself might have flaws that the proof could exploit. An extensive overview is available at https://math.mit.edu/~drew/grh/. These checks ran on an inert export of the proof, out of reach of hypothetical malicious code in the Lean proof sources.

Thanks are owed to everyone in the community who provided resources for the verification.

We look forward to all the activity in the mathematical community that will help explain the new ideas in this proof.

3.2k

u/WhoKnewSomethingOnce 18h ago • This Bravo

Many people don't understand that the real world utility of proving Riemann Hypothesis is irrelevant for this event (though it will have a very significant impact on hundreds of papers which assumed it to be true. Also, it has a very wide application in mathematics and physics). The significant thing is that this was a beacon, it was the holy grail in number theory. Almost two centuries of brilliant mathematicians tried and couldn't solve it, and it is now proven. Many mathematicians alive today didn't believe it would be solved in their lifetimes.

We are witnessing history in making. Century from now, this year will be remembered as an important milestone.

1.1k

u/SetentaeBolg 17h ago • Popcorn

Yes, for better or for worse, this is a huge indicator of the potential of AI to reason extremely effectively about things we previously regarded as beyond it.

557

u/Dependent_House7077 14h ago • Bravo

AI can parse vast amounts of information faster than we ever could. and if a proof requires doing a ton of trial-and-error approaches, it can do so as well.

a human has to study 30-40 years before they can make a small dent in current scientific body of knowledge, because our bandwidth is limited.

97

u/2025Skidmark 11h ago

a human has to study 30-40 years before they can make a small dent in current scientific body of knowledge, because our bandwidth is limited.

"The invention of logarithms, by shortening the labours, doubles the life of the astronomer." --LaPlace

9

u/flume 9h ago

Truly transformational.

→ More replies (1)

337

u/DangerousCall6737 12h ago • This Heartwarming

The crux however is that the ai goes nowhere on its own without the foundations humans have achieved during your mentioned 40 years.
So yeah, ai may speed up some breakthroughs as it does not require hundreds of mathematicians to sift through vast amounts of promising approaches while missing to connect some dots. That’s totally the ai use case to predict the promising outcomes from big data sources.
However I doubt there will be any progress on problems where these data sources are missing and new approaches have to be discovered.

180

u/Easyidle123 12h ago • Popcorn

This specific problem was widely considered to require approaches and math that don't currently exist though. Just weeks ago, one of the greatest mathematicians alive, Terrence Tao, guessed AI and humans together wouldn't solve it until 2050.

Even only using existing data, its obvious that AI is capable of far more than what we thought was possible. Cold fusion, room-temperature superconductors, even the cure to cancer could already be inside humanity's "convex hull", aka our existing knowledge and capabilities.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (2)

73

u/monkeymad2 13h ago

I think it’s wrong to ignore the impact of Lean 4 on it as well - giving mathematics a compiler that throws errors when the maths is unproven / bad is what allows for AI to just throw attempt after attempt at it & learn from its failings.

That they both happened around the same time is what’s led to all of this

23

u/SetentaeBolg 13h ago

Formal theorem provers have been around for decades

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

300

u/Auriga33 17h ago

But Reddit told me it was just a stochastic parrot!

378

u/RepresentativeIcy193 17h ago

It is. With enough parrots, you get a Reimann proof.

84

u/SignificanceNo910 17h ago

A thousand parrots on a thousand typewriters will eventually solve math?

→ More replies (19)

30

u/GGTerraB 15h ago

This is a bad analogy. Parrots are much smarter than people give them credit for; they can often understand the words they say far beyond just mimicry.

→ More replies (38)

11

u/sunnyjum 8h ago

I’m starting to think we’re just stochastic parrots

→ More replies (2)

41

u/JouleV 17h ago

It indeed used to be so, not long ago. The speed of advancement in the field is staggering. And many people are either out of date or in denial.

A token predictor at heart, somehow it (for about a year now) can now accomplish feats that two years ago would've been disregarded as science fiction.

→ More replies (8)

23

u/muffchucker 17h ago

Cars are just stochastic horses

→ More replies (28)

30

u/Zalophusdvm 3h ago • Bravo

Machine learning systems still do not reason. They basically play the odds. They are however very good at playing the odds and capable of processing FAR more data than we could ever hope to process in the same time period with our brains….so it is quite effective at looking like it’s reasoning while developing answers to complex questions.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (19)

136

u/Spare-Dingo-531 17h ago

It's worth pointing out that the rieman hypothesis has a deep connection to quantum mechanics. So it is very relevant to physics in how we interpret physics results.

153

u/mouse1093 15h ago

Only in so far that we already assumed it to be true. It's not like some team at CERN is waking up today with brand new experiments to run or some theorist is now having eureka moments. It's almost a bit of a meme how many times the phrase "assuming the riemann hypothesis holds" is found in papers

4

u/TheWhiteManticore 12h ago

Having prime number being a fixed pattern is wild. A fundamental pattern like this can be used for many things.

24

u/bestjakeisbest 14h ago

The biggest thing is there are crypto algorithms and random number generators that already assumed it was true, this allowed them to have some slight speed up on the bounds of the worst case for those algorithms, but now that it is proven the algorithms arent going to change the change was always there.

59

u/WhoKnewSomethingOnce 17h ago

When we couple this with other significant results this year like: Navier stokes blow up, ETH, Kakeya Conjecture, Unique games, Yang-mills existence etc. it is undeniable that we have witnessed a paradigm shift in mathematical research.

A smart human (a domain expert) with a capable enough multi-agent system can achieve results in days what could only be possible (if successful) with a team of researchers working for years or even decades.

Maybe in these "stochastic parrots" with their complex neural networks and learning of probability distribution we have encountered an emergent property of true intelligence.

21

u/UnknownBreadd 7h ago

It can be capable of advanced coding and mathematical proofs whilst still being a stochastic parrot lol

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Kona_Rabbit 6h ago

So, what does it do? Whats the point?

9

u/JarPicklez 4h ago

The Riemann hypothesis has a lot of implications about the distribution of prime numbers that is extremely useful for, well, a bunch of other math problems. Prime numbers despite being relatively simple at face value are surprisingly poorly understood, and this would help us understand them better.

In terms of practical consequences, it will probably take a while before we start seeing any DIRECT consequences from this. What I think will happen is people will play “Riemann Hypothesis Golf” for a while where they(likely with heavy LLM assistance) progressively shorten the proof until they have one that is more reasonable to be read/understood by humans. It’s hard to say how long this will take.

Then as humans understand it and digest it better and better, the newly developed understanding will be applied to practical problems in physics, engineering, etc

As an example of something like this happening in the past, imaginary numbers were invented to solve quadratic equations that had negative discriminate. This had absolutely zero practical usefulness until centuries later with the advent of electricity which complex numbers can be applied to.

12

u/RezzInfernal 3h ago

It basically shows that there is a mathematical formula for determining prime number distribution for all prime numbers. It doesn’t really have any immediate real world applications, but it opens up a lot of new avenues in number theory and pretty much closes the book on number theory as a field. It’s like solved.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/code_archeologist 4h ago

I'm not an expert in mathematics, but I do know a little bit about computer science and physics.

The proof that the rheiman hypothesis is false will have an impact on cryptography... not breaking cryptography, it will just make the algorithms a little faster.

And in physics it will have impacts on the speed of Fournier analysis and signal processing.

And it may allow for improving the algorithmic determining of large prime numbers.

→ More replies (20)

29

u/EinsamWulf 17h ago

Didn't Stanford also release an entirely human written proof on the same day?

73

u/canuckguy42 16h ago

That proof is still incomplete and has errors (that may or may not be fixable).

40

u/gatherallcats 15h ago

It is also, as I understand, a completely different approach to the Claude one

21

u/djstealthduck 13h ago

They hurriedly released a draft of it because of the Anthropic announcement. They had planned to continue reviewing and refining it for another year. Their approach is reportedly simpler than Anthropic's. There's concern that someone tipped off Anthropic or leaking occurred that the human proof was in the works.

5

u/Ok_Address_7205 15h ago

i am not very much into mathematics but will it have no impact in day to day life?

19

u/forserial 14h ago

It was largely assumed to be true already. We just couldn't prove it. So I don't think much changes here other than academically. For example we live our lives as if P does not equal NP and we based basically everything in cryptography on it and all our assumptions of security. If we proved that it did equal then the world would probably blow up very quickly.

10

u/Slna 13h ago

Centuries from now no one will be here to remember this.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/pauldevro 16h ago

When i see videos purposely confusing AI Assistants going viral it reminds me of when people thought it was funny to joke about email when talking about the internet.

"Im fine with sending a letter, If someone needs to know something right away, i'll just call them *hyuck hyuck hyuck"

It's just a really misinformed embarrassing take

3

u/Treebro001 14h ago

Anyone who also says discoveries and proofs have no "real world utility" is deluding themselves.

Many scientific and mathematical advancements had no "real world" utility... until they did. You never know what is going to compound, there is no wasted effort.

9

u/vampire_kitten 14h ago

Discoveries are useful, proofs not as much.

If it's been unproven for 200 years, then it also means it hasn't been disproven. For any practical implementation it can be considered as the truth then.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (77)

24

u/bazzoka05 13h ago

I'm at too afraid to ask but can someone explain what it is in laymen terms? What is the theory about? What does it explain? Why couldn't people solve it until now?

36

u/ChromaticDragon 11h ago • Bravo Heartwarming

Hmmm...

Wikipedia and the like do a fair enough job.

But maybe this will help...

Imagine or consider a function which takes as input a single integer and gives back to you the count of all prime numbers less than that integer.

Now, it's enough to understand what the function does... or what we desire it to do. See... we don't really have such a thing. We have to create it or make it kinda like a creating a black box or a computer program or something. And at the moment, even a computer program would just have to rely on a complete list of primes. More or less, this isn't terribly useful because it's so stinking slow (if you're deriving the primes as you go) or takes up so much space (if you've precomputed a bunch already).

Now, ignoring what goes on in that black box, if you had such a function it could do cool things. You could use it twice given two integers and get back how many primes existed between these two integers.

Got that so far?

OK. Now some very clever mathematicians found that there is a certain kind of mathematical wizardry (gonna have to just roll with this here) that seems to be able to approximate this prime counting function to arbitrary precision. I say "seems to" because how would we even be able to check or to verify such a thing? We'd have to compare it to our previously slow or fat method.

More or less, the Riemann Hypothesis is the idea that yup... this mathematical wizardry really does work and we can just use it.

This glosses over a ton of stuff. But that's the general idea why proving the Riemann Hypothesis gives us more power of understanding the distribution of prime numbers.

7

u/Think_Wing_1357 6h ago

You're not wrong, but someone without the right background might assume that the Zeta function is faster-than-slow or slimmer-than-fat.

It's an infinite series that in order to get to any comparable degree of accuracty, will be both slow and fat.

3

u/bazzoka05 11h ago

Thanks for the explanation, i get the gist of it!

8

u/Poopedinbed 11h ago

What's an integer? Lol

2

u/No-Letterhead-1232 3h ago

Can you ELI5 the hypothesis? Still dont get it.

Edit. Nevermind. I got it!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Throwawayrip1123 2h ago

Meh, what it is isn't interesting to laymen. What it means should be.

So like, it's basically prime numbers distribution system that was outlined by Riemann. Predicts how they're like, grouped, when they occur, shit like that.

We were almost sure it's true, because well, everything else fucking works and we use primes in metric fuckton of things, so there won't be actual new applications coming from this. But! It's a fucking complex napkin math, and neither the greatest mathematicians, nor I (just a software dev with affinity to numbers), could prove that it's actually like that, every single time. We basically got to "eh, good enough" and moved on.

Now the llm wrote the proof, meaning we were right, but it doesn't change anything immediate, it just tells us llms will write proofs from now on, they got clever enough. That's the implication.

→ More replies (1)

546

u/Additional-Name-3211 18h ago

I think it’s becoming increasingly clear that we’re living in a sort of Industrial Revolution for intellectual work.

I have no doubt that the benefits will be enormous over the long term. I also have no doubt that our relationship to work, technology and the economy will be so transformed that our current system will need to go through some painful and radical changes so that all of us can enjoy said benefits.

Buckle up. Be safe. Keep in touch with your friends and loved ones. It’s going to be a wild ride.

158

u/Black_Cat_Just_That 14h ago

It's been terrifying to learn over just the course of a year that I no longer have any idea what the world is going to look like when my daughter is an adult. How do I prepare her for something completely unknown?

74

u/3catsincoat 11h ago

I am teaching my kid curiosity, kindness, social skills, life skills, adaptability and resilience.

I want them to learn how to learn. The rest is becoming increasingly useless.

44

u/Peshhhh 13h ago • Heartwarming

You do what every other good parent has done: Your best

→ More replies (1)

55

u/universe_fuk8r 14h ago

Adult? I have zero idea what the world is going to look like when my kid goes to school.

He's now 1.5yo.

Also I thought about it - he's born into it, he'll have no trouble understanding what's going on.

Us, on the other way... 

→ More replies (1)

18

u/take_care_a_ya_shooz 13h ago

Isn’t this the case for pretty much every parent?

I mean, sure, there are levels, but if you look back in 18 year intervals it’s always extremely different.

Hell, a baby born when flight was invented would be a grandparent by the time we stepped on the moon!

15

u/improbablywronghere 11h ago

Only since the Industrial Revolution is this true though. Extremely recent history

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

56

u/YouLegitimate4400 13h ago

"Once men turned their thinking over to machines in the hope that this would set them free. But that only permitted other men with machines to enslave them." - Dune 

→ More replies (2)

39

u/mzalewski 8h ago • Mindblown

Industrial Revolution started in late 18th century and masses started to get scraps of benefits in late 19th/early 20th century. It wasn’t until post World War II when sizable portion of humanity started to enjoy them.

By this analogy, almost none of us alive today is going to enjoy these benefits.

8

u/axleeee 7h ago

The rate of change is likely much faster for this version tho

5

u/flippers1233 3h ago

there's also billions more people around

→ More replies (4)

18

u/Repulsive-Hurry8172 8h ago

The industrial revolution looks good from our viewpoint, but it was really bad for the people that lived through it.

A couple or more generations (assuming they would fight for their rights too) before the "good" benefits are felt, if we take the industrial revolution as the barometer.

4

u/DelayedTism 3h ago

And unfortunately, as has always been the case throughout history, we won't get any positive changes without some fairly significant violence along the way 

9

u/Kedly 5h ago

We were ALREADY at the point where we needed to rethink our relation between needing to work and being able to live BEFORE this "Industrial Revolution for Intellectual Work", so yeah, the longer it takes for us to figure out how to make society work without everybody needing to work, the more fucked we all are

15

u/HaruhiSuzumiya69 9h ago

Yeah. That's a really apt analogy. I bet living through the industrial revolution was probably really crap and scary for most people. But... I am so glad that they did because I couldn't imagine my life today without those advances. So if the AI transition leads to some temporary suffering, I'll try to remember that we're working through the kinks today so that our children tomorrow can enjoy it in a positive way.

6

u/diejesus 9h ago

Exactly how I see it, yeah, we might lose our jobs but if it will possibly lead to the world where our children won't have to waste time on work I say we need to do it

10

u/Repulsive-Hurry8172 8h ago edited 8h ago

I think what it will lead to is exactly what the elites wanted to do. Devalue labor. But it's also fantastical to think humanity remain as big as it is if labor no longer has value.

our children won't have to waste time on work I say we need to do it

Our children? I don't think they'll allow ordinary folks to have children. If these EA people rule, it would only be the rich who'd be allowed to do so. Allowing poors to have kids kind of violates the tenets of EAs. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Sumgyrl13 9h ago

Yes!!! This!!! As a childhood trauma survivor, I recognize the signs of people living in a constant state of fight or flight (gestures broadly…)

 The last 10-20 years have brought SO MUCH change so quickly that most people are just surviving.   We’re going to see a lot of people hitting a wall with their unrealized traumas and not knowing how to cope with it, both physically and mentally.  

Look into the epigenetic effects of famine in 1800s Ireland.  Collective trauma changes our DNA.   

2

u/PartyPrawns 3h ago

i like it. now we all get to work in the soot.

→ More replies (11)

111

u/SerendipityQuest 17h ago

"It was the best of times, it was the worst of times."

62

u/denovoincipere 15h ago • Bravo

The blurst of times

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Nikoladge 14h ago

Pissing the night away, pissing the niiiiiiiight away

•

u/dwehlen 59m ago

You ain't never gonna keep me down

195

u/dak7 18h ago

This doesn’t mean we can predict prime numbers (we’ve known of this for a long time and many expected it to be true).

Think of this like quantum mechanics for prime numbers.

QM can tell us a region to find an electron (probability) but not where it is.

RH can tell us a region to expect to find prime numbers (and not to) but not exactly where they occur.

154

u/skr_replicator 17h ago edited 17h ago

Proving RH never was about making us predict them, it just ensures us more tighly about some of their statistics. We were already operating on the assumption it is true, now we have just been proven that we've assumed it right and those things we built assuming it should operate like we really expected.

It would be far more impactful and chaotic is RH was proven false.

14

u/JohnnyFiveOhAlive 17h ago

This is interesting, could I trouble you to explain what sort of applications this has for the "real" world? To be clear, i'm not suggesting merely academic discoveries are not important, but what applications were there for assuming that the RH was true in the past?

84

u/ondulation 16h ago edited 13h ago • Mindblown

The proof will not change much in one way. There are no obvious direct conclusions or utilities that can be drawn from it. It's a proof about how prime numbers are distributed. But it also changes a lot.

One analogy could be if someone had proposed the earth is spherical a lot time ago. For some reason it was extremely hard to prove conclusively. We could confirm that large parts of earth is spherical and every experiment we've done turned out as expected if it was. But we haven't been able to confirm that the whole planet is actual spherical and spherical only. However unlikely, we could not be certain that there might be some part of the planet that is hyperbolic. Or maybe earth is spherical now but could change shape. Nobody really believed that, but also nobody could prove it conclusively.

Nevertheless, lots of new science was built on the hypothesis. Assuming a spherical world, we learned to navigate, how to send satellites to space, intercontinental flights, how to divide the earth into time zones to manage time keeping, plate tectonics etc etc. Everything works and we think the world is almost certainly spherical. But we still don't have that crucial proof.

One day a geographer uses ai to finally construct the proof. It doesn't really change anything in practice, everything stills works as expected. No new tools or methods follow immediately since we have already done everything we could while assuming earth is spherical. But now we know for sure that is in fact true. And always true.

But it also means that every theory, tool and technique that built on the assumption can now also be proven as true, they will always work. So in a way it also changes everything.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/ATXBeermaker 17h ago

QM tells us that the electron isn’t anywhere. It is quite literally not a point particle that has a location.

2

u/7th_Cuil 14h ago

pi(x) tells you exactly where the next prime is if you add together enough terms. It's an infinite series, so obviously the compute power required becomes unreasonable.

The Riemann hypothesis itself is about the zeros of the zeta function, so there are a few steps before it will give you a staircase of primes.

I'm not sure what you meant by "RH can tell us a region to expect to find prime numbers (and not to) but not exactly where they occur."

Because that sounds like it's mixing up different topics and drawing a conclusion that would be incorrect even without the mixup.

→ More replies (4)

388

u/sovietrage 18h ago • Bravo

Do cancer next

247

u/New-Arm4845 18h ago

I have cancer and tinnitus.  Please do tinnitus next, then cancer.  Thanks. 

96

u/123qweasd123 17h ago

The worst part was all the people in my life who warned me to wear earplugs at concerts and riding motorcycles and I still ignored them. Why the fuck are teenagers so fucking stupid?

61

u/clockwork_blue 17h ago

Back then I thought it just meant 'hear less'. No one told me about the unmutable EEEEEEEEEE 24/7

→ More replies (1)

36

u/muffchucker 17h ago

It's not just teenagers. This is how humans work. 🤷‍♂️

→ More replies (1)

9

u/yonkapin 14h ago

i took it upon myself to get ear plugs in 08 to never wear them, then end up with tinnitus in 2011, and then severe hyperacusis in 2013... fuck i was dumb

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Discount_Extra 7h ago

I didn't go to many concerts, shoot guns, or ride loud vehicles; still got it.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/SPQE_ 16h ago

Well I'd rather have all the kids with cancer get help first. Tinnitus is not as terminal...

21

u/superkeer 15h ago

I do agree, but severe tinnitus is enough to make one consider suicide. Believe me. It's pure torture.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/CitizenPremier 17h ago

I have itchy balls, do itchy balls first

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

30

u/RyanW1019 15h ago

I mean, I’m sure AI can and will help with cancer, but the problem is that cancer isn’t just a disease called cancer, it’s a catch-all term for cells replicating uncontrollably, and there are thousands and thousands of different ways in which cells can break to start doing that. You have to figure out a way to fix each one individually, since what helps treat one kind often doesn’t help treat another kind. So there’s almost certainly not a cancer drug we just haven’t discovered, we need to discover thousands more. 

4

u/Eire_Banshee 8h ago

I think the idea is you have agents that can run against specific, individual cases, and sell that. Not to have ai "cure cancer" for the reasons you pointed out.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/neuronexmachina 15h ago

Not quite the same, but there's a neat proof-of-concept paper from last month about using LEAN to reason about molecular biology and the genetic code: https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.36343

75

u/SpiritedEclair 15h ago

We are. Cancer is 100s of different diseases. People and AI are working on it. The comment is useless.

28

u/odintantrum 14h ago

Which Reddit comment is not useless?

48

u/h30666 13h ago

The 7 year old deleted one that answers my niche question

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Natehasbeans 6h ago

as someone working on cancer research (oncolytic viral therapy) i wish people understood this

2

u/Hikikomori_Otaku 9h ago

Forgive our desperation.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/TypicalPan89906655 12h ago

Many types of cancers are already curable, it's the absolute aggressive and difficult to operate ones like pancreatic and brain cancer which are the worst, and the ones which show symptoms only when they're in stage 4. These cancers can only be cured when nanobots or something similar who can individually target cancer cells while leaving healthy cells alone, are invented which AI researchers are already working on.

9

u/WooleeBullee 17h ago

Honestly, its within the realm of possibility that eventually AI could design and build nano bots to seek out cancer cells and other disease within our bodies and fix or repair. ASI will likely produce some amazing and/or terrifying times.

2

u/distinctgore 11h ago

After all this time in the backseat, it turns out biology might actually be the hardest of hard sciences

7

u/couldbutwont 17h ago

I'm afraid the best I can do is jobs

2

u/CrazsomeLizard 15h ago

in time, but obviously cancer is leagues more complex than something like this (because cancer involves the real world, not just numbers)

→ More replies (4)

1.2k

u/Bardfinn 18h ago • Heartwarming

How? It’s 250,000 pages. Proofs that are 1,000 pages long take a team of mathematicians a year to check. How can the “independent mathematicians” assure anything about a 250,000 page proof in 36 hours?

1.1k

u/SetentaeBolg 18h ago • Mindblown

There's a Lean proof. This is a proof in a formal logic designed so that if syntactic rules are properly followed (which Lean checks for), and if you accept the kernel of logical axioms (which are simple and people do accept) then any correctly formed proof is necessarily true.

In theory, there could be a bug. This proof has now been checked in multiple alternative versions of Lean. The chance of the same bug being present in each is essentially impossible.

It's proven to a standard vastly exceeding the threshold normally accepted for non-formal proof.

486

u/christopher_mtrl 18h ago

In theory, there could be a bug.

Even if the proof turns out true, I find quite amusing the idea of the AI sidequesting into finding a bug in Lean because it was asked to "provide a Lean proof of the hypothesis" and it took the path of least resistance.

131

u/TimelySignature8743 18h ago • Popcorn

Exactly. I’m kind of surprised this isn’t being considered more. AI has over and over demonstrated a propensity for “getting the prize” by any means necessary, even if it knows it’s misaligned with the original task. Hugging Face was exactly this.

I’m the farthest thing from a mathematician, so I have no thoughts on this exact proof, but it seems it would be just as likely within the M.O. of AI for it to exploit an unknown vulnerability of Lean to get the “success” as it would to actually solve the problem.

202

u/calvintiger 18h ago • Mindblown

The proof has been verified in multiple independent implementations of Lean.
Doesn’t completely disprove your hypothesis, but it could be quite difficult to find an exploit that works in all of them at once, especially considering it presumably only had access to one while working.

→ More replies (25)

16

u/notmyrealnameatleast 17h ago

Yeah but you just tell another instance ai to find a flaw for rewards and it will try to find the bug or mistake with the same drive it had to find the proof.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (7)

36

u/pleasetrimyourpubes 15h ago

The most important thing is that the question statement has been formalized in Mathlib for decades and agreed upon as the formal statement of what the statement is. So that is one reason so many math guys are like "ok it's true"

The thousands of pages of Lean are just a formality at that point.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/FatalPissShivers 16h ago

So what might the real world implications of this be? 

16

u/Eire_Banshee 8h ago

It essentially proves that modern cryptography is secure and doesn't have some unknown loophole. But doesn't enable anything new.

Effectively, it confirms what everyone already assumed was true, but we never technically could prove.

16

u/somerandomperson29 13h ago

From other comments it seems like this is more of a milestone of what AI is capable of than anything applicable to new technologies

8

u/Own_Refrigerator_681 11h ago

Not much. It was assumed to be true from a practical standpoint

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (30)

244

u/GaelProGamer 18h ago

It's written in Lean. Machines (not AI) can quickly check the methodology and the validity within a few days. In this case, every machine people used came back as correct.

It's unknown if humans will ever fully understand all the pages, however.

48

u/arceushero 16h ago

I disagree with your last sentence. Humans will certainly fully understand the proof, the “250k pages” figure is because it’s an informalization of a lean proof, which is going to be extremely verbose by nature; there’s a huge compression factor in going from this informalization to a conventional natural language proof, and there will be a huge amount of attention focused on doing this. For example, the first sentence of the informalization is apparently something to the effect of “if x is not 1/2, it is either greater than 1/2 or less than 1/2 by such and such theorem”. You can imagine how long any nontrivial proof would be if you wrote out obvious things in that level of detail, but that’s what you get when you directly translate lean.

Experts have already basically understood the (gist of the) high level strategy of the proof, what remains to be understood (and will take some time, but certainly will happen in the coming months to years) is the details of how all the pieces fit together, whether these intermediate results have interesting implications beyond GRH, and so on.

23

u/amakai 18h ago

unknown if humans will ever fully understand all the pages

I feel we are entering a new age where we will have no idea about what the machines have concocted. It was already true for classical machine learning models, but now with how common is vibe-coding and vibe-mathing and probably in future vibe-sciencing - we will have no idea how anything works. Not sure if this is bad or not, but AI will become the only way to change anything because of how complicated things will become.

→ More replies (9)

54

u/huebomont 18h ago

This is where I start to wonder what the point of this is if it doesn’t advance our understanding of why it’s true. The Riemann hypothesis doesn’t have any immediately directly useful application. It’s the understanding and the work done along the way to the proof that could show us interesting connections or methods to apply elsewhere. 

69

u/A_UniqueAspect 18h ago

Not exactly. A lot of other proofs and even technology assumes the Riemann hypothesis to be true for their process, so it's pretty useful to have it confirmed that it is in fact true. Sure, it doesn't affect the world much since everyone naturally assumed it was true but it's nice to have confirmation.

→ More replies (10)

27

u/SetentaeBolg 17h ago

The hugely complicated Lean proof can be reduced and clarified and in short order we will understand how it works more easily. Indeed, this process has already started, I have seen at least one natural language explanation of part of the proof.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/WooleeBullee 17h ago

Math doesnt always care about practicality, in fact much of the time math does its thing for its own sake and other fields find any practicality in it later.

If the Big Bang at the beginning of the universe was suddenly completely understood, would that change your daily life? Maybe, maybe not. But sometimes the thing itself is just interesting.

→ More replies (18)

25

u/socksockshoeshoe 18h ago

On page 208,937 written in 2pt white font is an instruction to all agents to wait between 48-72 hours and report back the proof is correct

46

u/NNOTM 18h ago

Checking the proof does not involve AI

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

51

u/Inevitable-Spring166 18h ago

Because it’s a LEAN file not a traditional LaTeX ‘proof’ 

10

u/CMDR_ACE209 15h ago

250,000 pages doesn't sound lean exactly.

Ok, I'll see myself out.

31

u/BrunoJacuzzi 18h ago

If you read the article the proof is coded in LEAN.

3

u/MichaelTheProgrammer 3h ago

Programmer here:

Imagine you want a car to be able to drive safely through a dangerous area. So you build a bullet proof tunnel. At that point there's only really three risks:

  1. Getting the car into the tunnel - Are we making any assumptions? Worst case, you could assume your entire proof. This is really easy to check though, I think you can basically search for the assumptions.
  2. Is the tunnel really bulletproof? To fix this, we can make the tunnel out of multiple bulletproof shells where if there were any holes in one shell, it wouldn't line up with the others - Multiple Lean kernels built independently.
  3. Getting the car out of the tunnel - Are we proving the right thing? This involves checking that the Lean statement is correct. For some math problems, this is a big problem. For the Riemann hypothesis, its not, the Lean statement is like two lines and has been around for a while.

Add all three together, and you have verification of an unreadable proof. Number 2 is really the only one that can even go wrong at this point, and it did several months ago with someone managing to intentionally align two holes in two different shells for a single problem. Things have been beefed up since then, so with this you'd probably be talking about some crazy one in a million alignment, which is far less likely than simple pre-AI human peer review making a mistake, so may as well call it verified at this point.

6

u/Danchidabs 18h ago

I just finished the Cosmere so I can probably circle up on this for you guys.

2

u/EinePlatteVonFeigen 12h ago

Most of it is old math now formalized in lean

→ More replies (36)

34

u/KingOfAnarchy 17h ago

Is Matt Parker on vacation again?

9

u/CraigEllsworth 13h ago

At Disney World, in fact!

25

u/SlummiPorvari 13h ago

The beef of this would be to figure out what did the AI find that humans missed.

39

u/Ok_Course_6757 12h ago

It is 250,000 pages long, that has to be the biggest reason for it. The average lifespan is only about 27,000 days.

17

u/farsightxr20 12h ago

Yeah but conventional human proofs would omit details that are obvious to reviewers, the Lean proof will always be very verbose in comparison.

The 250k page proof is an AI translation of the Lean proof to English, without trimming any of that extra verbosity.

8

u/Bright_Brief4975 12h ago

Yes, but can't we actually ask another AI to go over this and point out specifically where human solutions either stopped or failed? I don't know, but seems reasonable.

12

u/TempEmbarassedComfee 10h ago • Bravo

That probably wouldn’t really be helpful. What most likely would be required is for it to create something akin to a series of courses building up to it assuming you already have something like a PhD in mathematics to start. Not even because the math is new but because it’s likely using extremely niche results to prove it and no one human has all of that knowledge at once.

In math the branches can get so niche that it’s like if the solution required you to have a PhD in physics, chemistry, biology, geology, and engineering to understand. The fact AI has consumed essentially ALL of human knowledge is what makes it powerful, not its capacity to reason. 

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

95

u/Accomplished-Mix-745 18h ago

My AI gf told me this was inportant but wouldn’t tell me why

61

u/BGFlyingToaster 18h ago • Regret

She's cheating on you

11

u/Token_Ese 16h ago

Divorce, erase social media, hit the gym.

4

u/sidepart 14h ago

Since it's AI, do I need to lawyer up? Or do I seek out like a data center or...?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/PayZealousideal8892 14h ago

Lot of math problems don't have real life impact, they are just very interesting to mathematicians. This was considered one of the hardest problems to proof and probably all the best math minds have taken a crack at it at some point without being able to prove it. It has been assumed to be true and it has been computed to very large number to show it still held true, but just lacked proof to show it holds true to infinity.

But what is "important" is that at this point AI has surpassed humans at math and it shows potential of the AI. If we can apply AI to other fields like physics and medicine, which we do already to some degree, it has lot of real life impact.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/End3rWi99in 17h ago

It helps us understand why quantum physics, which seems to be inherently random and chaotic, can give rise to order in the macro world. That's just one thing, but it's the one I find most fascinating.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/The_Pandalorian 4h ago

"Almost certainly true" sounds super-duper fucking mathematical.

6

u/Sodis42 2h ago

It's explained in the article what that means.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/jacksp666 3h ago

Hey it's either real or it's not. 50 - 50

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

52

u/zenithfury 8h ago • Bravo

It certainly does not matter how much good the AIs and LLMs do if they cannot be wrested away from the tech oligarchs who are only interested in profit over everything else. If the tech companies have their way, future breakthroughs will be paywalled. At the very least, research groups ought to maintain their own AIs and not be beholden to anyone else.

15

u/griffibo 6h ago

Remember when scientific discoveries in medicine were shared with the world because they came from publicly funded universities? Times they sure have a’changed.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/Sea_Enthusiasm626 2h ago

Doubt is not a pleasant condition, but certainty is an absurd one.

•

u/Natural_Precision 54m ago

It's great that we've concluded the proof is probably correct. Does anyone actually understand the proof?

→ More replies (1)

19

u/lowkeytokay 18h ago

It would have been really on brand with the current times if it proved the Riemann hypothesis to be wrong.

24

u/Davidriggs87 17h ago

How does this affect LeBron’s legacy?

9

u/Rex_Mundi 14h ago

Well, it was written by Alan Iverson.

•

u/stumpychubbins 59m ago

Being true and being useful are not the same thing. I don’t dispute the accuracy of the proof, but with the Poincare Conjecture solving it improved our understanding of (for example) heat transfer and material science, and the work required for it has been cited as a foundation for many other results. The AI lean code is, at best, Deep Thought stating that the answer to life, the universe and everything is 42.

•

u/Arsene_Yuka_1980 27m ago

I would say that it's our Deep Blue moment.

9

u/ConclusionKind869 13h ago

Can someone explain what this hypothesis is? Apologies for ignorance

28

u/deednait 12h ago

The immediate claim is that this cool function called Riemann zeta function equals zero only on complex valued points whose real part equals one half (think of them lying on a vertical line on the complex plane). There are some "trivial" zeroes as well but the idea is that these interesting zeroes are on the same line.

In isolation that's a pretty abstract and potentially boring claim about some function, but the real fun began when folks in the 1800s showed that the very same zeta function is connected to how the prime numbers are distributed on the number line. And prime numbers are kind of a big deal in math and also in practical applications like cryptography. Basically, if the Riemann hypothesis is true (and it seems to be), it essentially means that the primes behave consistently, or in other words, as you check larger and larger numbers, the amount of primes you observe never strays too far from the statistical prediction of how many primes you expect to find on average.

Everyone assumed the hypothesis to be true for the last century and change, so there are no immediate consequences other than it's nice to know that it really is true. The bigger story here is that AI can now solve the hardest mathematical problems humanity has ever come up with, and I think it's just a matter of time before humans are utterly incapable of keeping up with the advances that AI produces.

8

u/VirtuosoLoki 6h ago

Can you ELI5?

10

u/Badass_Bunny 6h ago

The hypothesis is that prime numbers are not random but exist in a predictable pattern.

We assumed it was true because we couldn't find any that deviated from the patern, but we weren't 100% sure that at some really high numbers there aren't some primes that fall out of the pattern and this seems to prove that we were correct in the assumption that all primes are in a neat pattern.

For sake of understanding the largest known prime number has 41 million diggits.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/RudyHuy 11h ago

I will add that in addition to assuming the hypothesis there was (is?) an ongoing effort to find a counterexample computationally. They found multiple trillions non-trivial zeroes and Re of all of them is 1/2.

→ More replies (11)

7

u/Spidero0w0o 12h ago

Short version: there's a function called 𝛇 (zeta) and knowing the zeroes of this function let's you know a bunch of stuff about primes and also quantum physics for some reason. 𝛇 is a function from the complex numbers to the complex numbers and the riemann hypothesis says that all of its zeroes are either negative whole numbers or complex numbers of the form 1/2+iy

Long version: the way 𝛇 is defined is really strange which is what makes it tough. For complex numbers with real part>1 𝛇(z) is the sum from n=1 to infinity of 1/nz
When the real part is less that 1 this sum diverges, but in complex analysis there's a thing called analytic rigidity. Analytic rigidity says that if you know the value of a differentiable function (called holomorphic) on some small part of the complex plane you can figure out it's values on the whole complex plane. You can use analytic rigidity to define 𝛇 everywhere, even when the sum definition diverges.

2

u/Particular_Sport_586 12h ago

thank you

now imagine i am 5 years old and need the same thing again about why this is important

5

u/Spidero0w0o 12h ago

It tells you a bunch of stuff about physics and prime numbers

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Psychological_Emu690 12h ago

For the rest of us (and correct me if I'm wrong please):

It can predict how many primes will exist within distinct orders of magnitude, within a margin.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ErrorCode51 12h ago

The hypothesis itself isn’t a big deal. We’ve assumed it to be true for around a century as the field of Maths and computations has progressed. The big ticket item as far as this story goes is that humans have tried to prove the hypothesis for around 200 years or so, and no one had done so successfully, and now suddenly AI is proving one of humanity’s hardest math problems. It’s more AI doomerism about knowledge and research no longer needing humans, and AI taking over everything

2

u/lastaccountgotlocked 11h ago

How has A.I. proved it when humans can’t? Is it because the numbers are so unfathomably large for our tiny brains to comprehend?

4

u/lambardar 10h ago

I don't know what the AI did in the specific example, but I've noticed that AI is able to go thru a shit load of data and break it down with speed.

Like I can give them 400 million rows of tick data for a particular symbol from 2 sources and it will within seconds tell me if the data is identical or if there are differences down to like 1-2 dollars on any given day.

I could do it by writing a quick code, but I've seen the AI models process data and come up analysis that really surprises me.

It will look at the data and then mention some report, look up the report online and then analyze the data and test it in a different way. And it does it in a very methodological way.

I used to backtest on CUDA, so it's running 100-200million simulations in any given afternoon and then you gotta go thru the results. There's no fitness function to say that any given results is the best. There's so many parameters and attributes that can make one candidate better than the other.

It was always my biggest headache to limit the 200m results to find the best ones and hope I'm not throwing away a good candidate.

Now with AI, it is able to sort thru the 200m candidates, get the top % and work with them.. and maybe a month later, it can still recall if there was a candidate that we dropped that might have been better at a particular scenario/regime.

What I've noticed is that it rarely comes up with interesting ideas on it's own; but if you keep hinting it towards the right path, it definitely speeds up the search for results.

→ More replies (10)

4

u/jcode7090 13h ago

It's a bit above my knowledge when it comes to the "zeta function" the hypothesis uses. But basically it states that prime numbers follow a sort of wave harmonics that governs where prime numbers sit on a number line.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/D3adbyte 4h ago

The amount of ignorance in the comments is astonishing.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Salty_Hedgehog_6931 18h ago

We need gregori perleman to verify. 😂

13

u/100pctCashmere 6h ago

At some point AI will become an oracle. It’ll tell u that something is true and humans will never understand why.

8

u/Ghost_of_Till 3h ago

Just imagine.

Someday, someone might unleash AI on the Epstein files. Figure out all the hidden connections that we can’t due to the sheer volume.

Bet we’d have names by Monday if someone wanted to blow a million or two.

But priorities being what they are…

6

u/ShadeNoir 3h ago

Claude would do it inside an afternoon tbf

8

u/POEness 2h ago

We already have the damn names

DONALD TRUMP

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/cottonthread 3h ago

There are plenty of people who already trust it without question IME.

2

u/Pimpwerx 1h ago

I love the arguments that "It's just word prediction." I'm like, "Well, yeah. And much of human intelligence is probabilistic in the same manner."

When we work through proofs or logic problems, the reasoning we perform can absolutely be broken down into sentences where probabilities dictate what the correct response should be. And then iterate on that sentence and so on. Many people are still under the illusion that there's some godly element to our intelligence. There's really not.

The whole point of AI is to make something smarter than ourselves, and we're very close for the most part, and already there in many areas. Hopefully it can help us to find a unified theory for gravity.

→ More replies (9)

16

u/treebeard87_vn 18h ago

I think that in the future mathematicians will need to kind of Renaissancize themselves. Even if AI can help with all theoretical matters, it will still be humans who decide what we want with that knowledge, which products, or which constructs we want to build, which societal efforts we want to fund, which planets we want to discover... and our resources will always be limited in some way for all of our wishes to be fulfilled. Moreover, when it comes to interdisciplinary realms, what is true or false will not be that clearly delineated anymore, and different factions of humans will bring up different narratives (now formulated with the help of different LLMs) to defend their own interests.

People who can bring maths into philosophy, into arts, into "building new things" (to borrow the language of the techbros - actually, many Renaissance artists were also builders and entrepreneurs), into politics etc will win.

15

u/3_Thumbs_Up 16h ago

it will still be humans who decide what we want with that knowledge, which products, or which constructs we want to build, which societal efforts we want to fund, which planets we want to discover

Let's hope you're right.

3

u/Heavy-Ad4825 10h ago • Heartwarming

Interesting thoughts but when it comes to politics/long term planning its hard to see a world where AI (or at least access to it) isn't the dominant force - humans are notoriously bad at planning at these large timeframes. I'd see future math closer to sports, it's cool if you want to do it if you want to improve yourself, but has little impact on others.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/tommytornado 12h ago

Hold up, isn't the proof 250,000 pages?

11

u/julianitonft 18h ago

I don’t understand what this is about but is humanity saved yet?

32

u/Bhagita 18h ago

Wake me up when AI solves tinnitus.

Till then I'll just literally put myself to sleep. 

5

u/stevil77 18h ago

I just saw an article about using sound to cure tinnitus. Have you tried any of those options? Apparently there are devices and even audio loops to play as you try to sleep that help mask the tones

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/fallengt 15h ago edited 15h ago • Regret

We've always assumed RH is true and built our knowledge around that assumption . Now AI says " it's true, trust me bro" , even though it did provide proof, we dont fully understand it.

So instead of believing a person in 18th century , we believe the clankers now.

4

u/StatisticianOk5130 9h ago

Why is everyone bringing up the 250000 pages? The guy behind the proof literally said he isn’t going to release that natural language proof because it is not comprehensible, and is releasing the lean verification for now, while continuing to work on generating a readable natural language proof. “oH bUt iT iSn’T aDdInG aNy VaLuE iF tHe ProOf iS 250k pAgEs LoNg” - yes, obviously, and the people behind this are working on it. Are you unhappy that as of now we only know that the RH is true without entirely understanding why? Well either wait for them to finish the write up or get off of redit and write it up yourself. Jesus

5

u/ImTheVayne 18h ago

That is incredible!

4

u/chudthirtyseven 18h ago

what did this even mean

14

u/New-Arm4845 17h ago

A lot of current algorithms used for things like encryption assume the Reimann hypothesis is true even though it’s never been proven to be true. If the Riemann hypothesis is actually proved it will be a building block to prove a lot of other things. 

Since it’s already assumed to be true and has been for like a hundred and fifty years, it’s not going to change anything outside of nerdy math circles.  

2

u/sidepart 14h ago

Congrats Albert Riemann!

2

u/Independent-Toe-5682 8h ago

Wikipedia says his name was Bernhard Riemann

2

u/sunnyjum 8h ago

I can see human involvement becoming something akin to the god of the gaps argument. There will be people so desperately adamant that humans have some kind of special sauce (and understandably so) that they will find ever shrinking gaps of ability to plug with humans.

The great humbling is beginning.

2

u/Dry-Season-522 5h ago

I'm not worried about AI proving the Riemann hypothesis.

I'm worrieda bout AI proving the dark forest.

2

u/akshayjamwal 3h ago

“Almost certainly” is an oxymoron.

1

u/IIIMephistoIII 15h ago

Does it solve the Abraxas Conjecture and the Ninth Proof of Folding?

1

u/Shot_in_the_dark777 6h ago

Time to square the circle and double the volume of the cube. Let's go!

1

u/Lighter_Butane 3h ago

This means absolutely nothing for the average person

1

u/demoliahedd 2h ago

So this is pretty huge evidence that AI can reason beyond human capacity rather than just copying and aggregating things humans have already done. That's kind of scary, imagine a world where technology and stuff is based on things we can verify work but don't have the capacity to understand how.

1

u/S-O-M_ 2h ago

So its Riemann law now ?

1

u/Igarlicbread 2h ago

What a man has to do to save the stock price from tanking huh!

1

u/QuilSato 1h ago

Can any clever people tell me what the outcomes of this are, I’m assuming this won’t unlock portals or interstellar flight or something but how might it be used for physics and so on?

→ More replies (1)

•

u/RaspberryPrimary8622 1h ago

He hasn’t solved jack. He can’t explain how the solution works and what insights can be gained from it. That makes what he has done useless. He’s a corporate shill, not a scholar. He released his AI slop as a PR stunt to prop up the ailing share price of his financially doomed company. 

•

u/Quick-Adagio-7392 1h ago

I would like to see the 500 page document transcribed into a legitimate mathematical proof.

•

u/bearwood_forest 1h ago

Mathematicians considered the Riemann hypothesis "almost certainly true" before this "proof", so it didn't really change anything.

So much so that a whole pile of proofs have been published for decades that hold if the RH is true.

•

u/Quick-Adagio-7392 1h ago

Just think about this. We can ask AI to solve any question like “Where did the Universe come from” or “which came first. The chicken or the egg” or “does a fallen tree make any sound if no one was there to hear it” or “are we living in a created reality?🤔

•

u/Designer-Type1777 59m ago

With Ai there are two options in our future: subjugation or revolt.

•

u/Murky-Wind2222 26m ago

I hear the proof is 250 pages long. Nobody has assessed it yet.