r/worldnews • • 9h ago • Bravo 1

British minister does not rule out EU membership - The possibility of the United Kingdom rejoining the European Union will be discussed in informal talks with Brussels, British Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband said

https://www.brusselstimes.com/news/2417090/british-minister-does-not-rule-out-eu-membership
246 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

70

u/eskimospy212 9h ago

I feel like this is inevitable, it’s only a question of terms.

Brexit is one of the all time own goals by a country. 

18

u/PuzzleheadedPen4675 9h ago

Thx Farage!

-27

u/soulstormfire 6h ago

It wasn't Farage. It was the British people voting.

18

u/versatile_dev 4h ago

With intensive misinformation campaign by Internet Research Agency et al.

7

u/plastic_alloys 4h ago

Yeah it was a stupid thing to have a referendum on anyway as it’s something that is far too complex for a layperson to truly understand, which made it ripe for a misinformation campaign. It was like explaining the function of the kidneys to a mouse, and someone telling the mouse that if it remove its kidneys it could have unlimited cheese.

-10

u/Alexap30 3h ago

Shouldn't the people have done their own research? There were voices of the opposite too. They chose to follow Farage. I mean there are people that still support the Brexit. Saying "thanks Farage", is a kick in the balls for people who didn't get misguided and voted to stay. Yes Farage is a jerk, but in the end the people cast their votes with their own hands. If they let themselves get pulled by a demagogue that's still on them.

1

u/KingLedleysKnee 2h ago

It's very difficult to research the impact of something that's never been done before.

I assume you are not British, so you didn't live through the absolute bombardment of information from both sides during the campaign. One side warning Brexit would tank our economy and send us into a recession, the other saying it was fear mongering and putting big billboards on busses about how much money we would save. Dominating the news for months, weekly leaflets through your door. You would honestly feel you've heard basically everything there is to hear on the topic.

The people who voted for Brexit were for the most part people who were just worn down and fed up with the state of the country and felt we needed a big change to correct our course. Of course, also with quite a few racist morons mixed in. That's not to say they couldn't have done better, but it's more understandable than you might think.

Regardless, though, you can't rely on any vote to not have uneducated morons. The government exists to protect the people from themselves, and that's where they failed here.

1

u/Alexap30 1h ago

I understand that, but as you said there was a bombardment of information from both sides. That's your common denominator that makes the floor even. People did choose, and chose poorly. Demagogues and populists are one part of the story, being gaulible and falling for people that tell you exactly what you want to hear is another. I give you that the opposition might have failed to provide the information needed, but this doesn't explain why there are people who still support the Brexit, now that it has happened.

•

u/wowohwowza 1h ago

The issue is that the side that won didn't bombard with information, it was mostly misinformation.

The £350mil that was parroted constantly that we'd save and put straight into the NHS... Which never happened, and never could have happened. Yet they were allowed this on billboards, busses, letters through our doors. It's criminal.

The "Breaking Point" poster that showed a queue of refugees to enter Britain... That wasn't real, and as we all know is more akin to the situation now than when we were in the EU

Telling us that the Turks were joining the EU "imminently", and with them would come a wave of immigration... Is Turkey in the EU 10 years later?

It was pure fear mongering. As the previous commenter said, people were fed up of the state of the nation and wanted change, and were made both false promises and outright lied to by the "Leave" campaign.

•

u/Alexap30 51m ago edited 40m ago

I understand. The point I'm trying to make, is that, if people are so easily deceived and lied to, and being taken advantage of, then where does that stop? Let's say Britain joins EU again. Is that it? Or is it until the next Nigel Farage? Who still continues his rhetoric, afaik. Removing the fault from the voters it just leaves room for the next demagogue who will do the same on the poor misguided people. To make it more clear, I understand the causes behind the Brexit, it still doesn't exonerate the British people who voted. I still haven't heard a Brexit voter saying "we've fucked up", there are still people supporting Brexit. Their numbers diminishing only because they are old and are dying.

1

u/Anaptyso 3h ago edited 2h ago

I'm not so confident. The Tories, Reform and Restore are polling at about 45-50% between them, and they massively oppose this. Given the UK's FPTP electoral system, a heavily Eurosceptic government is an inevitability at some point in the future. 

The whole process of convincing the public, convincing the EU, going through the negotiations, and actually rejoining, would need to happen before the next right wing government comes along.

•

u/wowohwowza 59m ago

I'm not sure the average Tory is against the EU these days. There's no longer a real debate around whether Brexit was a success for the average person i.e. not the ultra rich. A lot of Tory voters in Britain are small business owners/self employed, and in my circle which is filled with a lot of these people, I don't know a single one who is against our closer relationship with the EU these days, even those that were staunchly leave.

•

u/Anaptyso 48m ago

Tory voters, I'd agree. The problem is that the party leadership feels to me a significant step more anti-European than their voter base. Under Johnson there was a large purge of Tory MPs who had positive views on the EU, replacing them with new candidates and MPs who are against it. It may take them a while to realign with where their voters are. 

Badenoch is very critic of any step closer to the EU, and appears to be constantly worried of being outflanked by Reform. I can't see the Tories being accepting of EU membership while she is leader.

•

u/benebula 29m ago

I'm interested, as a lefty, if Burnham puts Breturn as a manifesto pledge for the next GE and, as you say, many voters are in favour of it won't that be political suicide for tory MPs? And how would you vote if it came to it?

Edit: nuisance aside, as I'm sure many agree it depends on the nature of the deal.

•

u/Anaptyso 4m ago edited 0m ago

My guess is that the Tories would say something like "we are against joining the EU, but will negotiate a better deal", and then just hope that their voters are loyal enough to stick with them anyway. Something vague enough to try and please everyone.

Another factor is that a massive chunk of the print media are vehemently against the EU. If Labour campaigned on rejoining then the Mail, Telegraph, Sun etc would swing in to action and churn out anti-EU articles even more than now. That might shore up the Tories, and change the minds of some of their voters on the issue.

14

u/Efficient-Youth-6985 7h ago

if there is a potential big scary war coming along

I want there to be smooth, uninterrupted movement of people, equipment and supplies (including food) between the UK and the rest of europe

I do not want paperwork

-1

u/ChazCharlie 2h ago

If there is a big scary war, I don't want to be one of the belligerents and I don't want easy movement from one of them.

0

u/Efficient-Youth-6985 2h ago

read what's written

1

u/ChazCharlie 2h ago

Um, I did? What's your point?

0

u/Efficient-Youth-6985 2h ago

I don't want to be one of the belligerents

Do you know what this word means? it means eager to fight. There's literally nothing in what I wrote that suggests eagerness to fight.

10

u/Tunggall 8h ago

Nature is healing.

1

u/Giddeeyap 7h ago

That's really taking the talks to another level, and could be a great thing ...if it doesn't create great turmoil and protests at home, because, I think, there are many who still favor Brexit above re-integration with EU. I could be wrong ...hopefully!

0

u/HairlessWookiee 7h ago

The next right wing government that gets in after the rejoining will simply Brexit again. Problem solved!

•

u/popeter45 1h ago

They are aware and probably trying to think of how to prevent that, such as massive treaty exit fees

1

u/radikalkarrot 2h ago

Will have to win a referendum again, let’s see if that happens again

1

u/ChazCharlie 2h ago

Not if there isn't one to rejoin.

•

u/radikalkarrot 1h ago

10 years have passed since the Brexit one, having another seems reasonable

•

u/ChazCharlie 1h ago

It isn't reasonable.

  1. it was a once in a generation vote.
  2. it was implemented by people who hated it and was undermined at every point.

•

u/radikalkarrot 1h ago

Sure thing kid, it will happen wether you like it or not

-15

u/Md__86 9h ago

I'm from the UK and voted to remain, I thought the whole thing was a ridiculous right wing psy-op likely backed by Russia.

That said, there was a referendum and for whatever reason(s), the country voted to leave.

I accept it has been a disaster with no benefit, but where does that leave the democratic process and the point of referendums, if it's possible to just undo it all?

4

u/paneuropeanism_ 8h ago

That referendum should be declared  completely null and void. It had only like 51% of the vote. It lacks a real mandate, especially since everything we now know about foreign interference, including from Moscow. All surveys show that Brits want to rejoin. Brexit is dead.

0

u/[deleted] 8h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/paneuropeanism_ 8h ago

What you're saying doesn't make much sense. 

15

u/UNSKIALz 8h ago

Rejoining will be voted on for sure, either by referendum or via general election (A party will have it in their manifesto).

The steps being taken now are either preliminary or simply common sense economic deals.

20

u/ScarZealousideal2147 8h ago

So we can only vote on something once? I’d it turns out to be a terrible decision then too bad, we’re stuck with it now? The British people were sold a lie and now the electorate recognises that, we have every right to have another vote.

7

u/flatandroid 8h ago

The referendum can be done again. Guarantee it would not pass again.

8

u/Outrageous-Split-646 9h ago

The point is in the UK’s political system, Parliament is sovereign, plebiscites have always been advisory on Parliament.

0

u/Pleasant_Narwhal_350 8h ago

Yup. If Parliament is sovereign and the ultimate expression of the will of the people in Britain, then why can't Parliament oppose a plebiscite? Is a plebiscite sovereign over an elected Parliament now?

7

u/buzziebee 8h ago

I don't really understand this argument. It's spouted a lot by the brexit types but I'm not sure why it would sway someone with more sense than that...

It's like saying we had a general election and voted in labour, therefore no more elections.

Some Brexit plonker saying it was a once in a generation thing on a non binding referendum that's been a totally disaster isn't a good enough justification to not present the option to the electorate again imo. We should change our minds based on the evidence, and that's what a majority of the electorate has done according to polling. It's more undemocratic to deny them the right to let them be heard imo.

3

u/Yeltsin86 8h ago

Worth pointing out that a lot of people voted "leave" only to send a political message, not expecting it to actually win

Also, a lot of the politicians pushing Leave were also only doing so to get votes, and themselves didn't expect to win. Which is also why no one had a real plan when it happened

So it wasn't so much a democratic process as it was an exploitation of the system

1

u/Adventurous_Money533 4h ago

"Worth pointing out that a lot of people voted for face eating leopards only to send a political message, not expecting to actually have their faces eaten by leopards Also, a lot of the politicians pushing face eating leopards were also only doing so to get votes, and themselves didn't expect to have their faces eaten by leopards. Which is also why no one had a real plan when face eating leopards came.

So it wasn't so much a democratic process as it was an exploitation of the system."

1

u/HelloThereItsMeAndMe 2h ago

Thered have to be a second referendum to undo it. These are just talks - they have to know what's on the table if they want to do a referendum in the first place.

-15

u/jphamlore 4h ago

At minimum, the UK better be prepared to surrender the Elgin marbles, and maybe even Gibralter. And the pound sterling.

Just date the changes 20 years in the future so that someone else presides over the actual transaction.