r/writingadvice • • May 29 '22

IMPORTANT Subreddit, Post Guide, and Discord Server Information

67 Upvotes

Hello, r/writingadvice!

[This subreddit is run by an entirely Christian team. We welcome all religious beliefs here and discussion of religion in relation to writing, and we ask you to be tolerant of ours in return. We do not expect you to interact with our beliefs, and we expect you to respect everyone regardless of their religion, ideology, and identity. Let us learn from one another so we can write better representation for ALL groups.]

Read our rules for our post guide, and please set a user flair for yourself so we can give you advice appropriate for your goals. (Feel free to have fun with “Custom Flair”. Just keep it appropriate.) We often assign a user flair if you are flair free, so it's best you do it yourself because we generally don't touch existing flairs.

We do not have any invisible rules. What you see is what you get. Posts must be between 50-300 words because long posts were often ignored and short posts did not provide enough context. Our account and karma requirements are 2 days old and 1+ karma.

Here is the link to our discord server: https://discord.gg/nn7cUSKxn3

Within the server, you can get more writing advice and find writing resources.

If you have problems, suggestions, or need clarification, please message us.

If you are banned and want to be unbanned, message us what you did wrong and what you should have done, or follow the instructions on r/adviceonwriting for the fun process. You may also use r/adviceonwriting to share the best and worst posts you've seen on writing reddit.

Keep in mind most of writers here are novelists and short story writers. If you are writing something different, the advice here is often not the best for other situations due to differences in craft and audience. If you choose to inquire here, please let people know in your post and user flair what exactly you are writing for (e.g. roleplay, comics, poetry, film).

This subreddit is not updated for Old Reddit. Please consider using New Reddit. Here is the link to our rules because Old Reddit doesn't display them and other features.


r/writingadvice • • 3h ago

Advice How to actually start writing a story

6 Upvotes

Not sure if this is the right sub but I’m really needing a help right now cause I’m so lost. I don’t wanna just start writing down whatever comes to my mind like others do cause I tend to have some writer’s block or writing it all over again because of perfectionism till I can’t no longer write a single thing anymore. I tried looking up online and see how other writers plan their story/book but there are sooooo many that I AM SO LOST.

I have so many story ideas I want to create and I can’t start a single one because of this lol. And I’m also in a bad shape in life right now that I’m trying hard to fight and I don’t wanna lose my spark in writing. I've also read somewhere that I should just start writing it bad and polishing and editing comes later but... I know it needs to be organized​ but again I’m so lost on which steps to follow 😂 please help this person out on how yall or how can I plan and organize my story step by step before writing the first draft. Your advice would mean so much. Thank you!


r/writingadvice • • 28m ago

Critique Did My Edit Ruin My First Chapter Or Make It Better?

2 Upvotes

Disclaimer:

First of all you do NOT need to mince words or worry about hurting my feelings any and all constructive criticism is welcome no matter how blunt or harsh its delivery.

I care about reaching the the best version. My ego is of no concern. I seek to learn and gain knowledge. If i have to cut 80% I will.

I edited the first draft, went line by line. I tried to cut everything I could without issues. I could have trimmed much more, Basically turning this 1.5k word chapter into one short paragraph "MC on way home, subway malfunction then finds platform" and make that like one short tight paragraph.

I didn't because I wanted to establish a baseline of normalcy and show the awfulness of school, the other kids, and the loneliness of his daily life.

Any and all feedback is appreciated, provided you actually read the chapters! I do not care how you say it I wont take ANYTHING personally I just want to learn and fix this to have the best possible story.

Original First Draft Of Chapter One

First Edit Of Chapter One


r/writingadvice • • 3h ago

Advice How to slow down scenes in a novel?

3 Upvotes

I recently started writing my first novel and I find myself going through the scenes very quickly. I’m currently at ~2k words, and quite a bit of the intro has already happened. I’m aiming for 80k words total so I’d like to learn how to slow down the scenes and add more details.

I’m also thinking about writing the first draft with my current writing style, and then going back and expanding later. What do you guys think?


r/writingadvice • • 3m ago

Advice how to tell if it's just first draft/editing blues or if i actually just don't like writing?

1 Upvotes

so i've finished the first draft of my first novel and i'm in the process of trying to edit, but this whole project has made me think that maybe this just isn't the path for me. i know everyone goes through a really tough period around the first draft/first edit but it's not that i don't think my book is good (objectively it isn't it's a first draft lol) or i'm a bad writer, it's that i just don't enjoy anything about this process anymore. maybe once or twice in the beginning of the draft i enjoyed writing it but it very quickly became a hassle that i had to force myself to do. i pretty much hated writing 3/4ths of the book and now i'm hating the editing process, half because i don't really know how to do it and half because i just don't want to.

i've loved reading and the idea of writing a book since i was a kid, but i didn't actually write anything other than the occasional fanfic until i decided to start writing this book. shouldn't i love writing most of the time if it's my passion? shouldn't my desire to publish this book outweigh the difficult parts like it has for hundreds of other authors? or am i just blowing these difficulties out of proportion and i need to get back to the grindstone even if it's not fun/enjoyable anymore?

for additional context in regards to advice: i've done all the suggestions for feeling burnt out on a project. i took a multi-month break before i even started editing, i worked on other projects for a bit, etc etc. nothing i've found online has changed how i feel.


r/writingadvice • • 4h ago

Advice My Fellow Writers Who Work Blue Collar Jobs, How Do You Find Time to Write?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/writingadvice • • 22h ago

Advice How do you deal with knowing nobody will ever read your book?

36 Upvotes

I've been working on a story for about a year now. I was in a pretty bad writing slump for a long time before that and hadn't finished anything in ages. This is the longest thing I've written in years and I'm nearing the end of the first draft. It's been tough at times but I've really enjoyed working on it, and it's really helped me to fall back in love with writing.

But now that it's nearly finished, it's hitting me that I'm going to finish it and then it will just sit in my documents and nobody but me will ever read it. I never planned to try and publish it or anything, and I know it's probably, objectively, not very good, but still, I worked hard on it and I'm proud of it. The idea that once it's finished, that's just... it, makes me feel a bit depressed lol. How do other people deal with this feeling?


r/writingadvice • • 11h ago

Advice How to write god status characters and dynamics while keeping them human, nuanced, and not flat

3 Upvotes

I am building a world mostly like ours until 2017, when a sudden cosmic radiation burst enhanced 40% of the population physically, mentally, or both, to varying degrees.

Among them stand three beings known as GODS. Thousands of years ago, when our mythological stories were written, similar beings existed—worshipped and feared for abilities far beyond normal humans. Now, with enhanced humans reappearing, these three stand far above even them. To illustrate the scale: the strongest, fastest, or smartest human of recent centuries is like a toddler compared to a Harvard graduate or an international powerlifter.

I have basic concepts for them, though I am unsure how to develop them further:

* The Antichrist: An Afghan journalist turned global leader. Charming, cunning, selfish, and manipulative, he is evil personified. Born in war-torn Afghanistan, he witnessed humanity's worst, using ruthless cunning to become a renowned journalist. Circumstances didn't corrupt him; he was always like this. Having had nothing as a child, he subconsciously wants everything, believing his power entitles him to rule.

* The Revolutionary: A South Sudanese resistance leader, fiercely protective of her people and intolerant of injustice—both her strength and weakness. She sees through the Afghan’s lies and feels burdened to stop him, willing to do whatever it takes. Yet, standing so far above everyone leaves her deeply lonely, unable to connect or be seen as human.

* The Sage: An Indian history professor turned passive spiritualist. Capable of gaining anything, he refuses out of fear that playing God always brings tragedy, preferring to let things flow rather than risk unintended consequences.

Though not protagonists, these three embody my core theme: what it means to be human despite being seen as Gods. With my world ready, any advice on developing these characters and the story?


r/writingadvice • • 12h ago

Advice How do I write a character who really desires a relationship but is scared of falling in love?

3 Upvotes

Okay, I'm definitely projecting right now, but I'm trying to write a bit about someone who so desperately craves love, but at the same time is terrified of it, even to the point of scoffing at romance novels and books despite longing for that sort of connection with someone. Even when they do find someone and feel like this might be it, they're still caught between idealism and cynicism, unsure of themself at every turn, wanting to pull away but also get closer...

While I experience this, and I can usually write what I experience without much difficulty, I am having a LOT of trouble with this concept specifically. It feels too contradictory, but I wanna try to write it anyway. Any advice would be appreciated.


r/writingadvice • • 7h ago

SENSITIVE CONTENT How do NOT accidentally write a stereotype???

1 Upvotes

For context, I am a half-Irish, half-Chinese person. I have lived in China for half of my life. My story is set in a Chinese middle school and there are exchange programs in it. the three main characters are representing some of the feelings I have had being regarded as an outsider within my hometown. One of these characters is a Blasian guy called Cole. He's aloof with those around him but loves being goofy with his friends (The other two protagonists). I've been thinking about doing his character arc relating to a leg injury that prevents him from doing sports (his passion), and that gets him treated differently by everyone, like he's fragile. It's supposed to be metaphor for being treated like an outsider in a community you've grown up in, and it's something I know well. But I'm starting to question my possible intentions writing his character. As someone who HAS experienced racism in China, I don't want to reduce this character I love to a lesson about racism or a distasteful stereotype. This is a vague question, but how I do write his character with the things mentioned above without accidentally turning him into just a plot device for the other non-black protagonists?


r/writingadvice • • 14h ago

Advice How do you incorporate romance into a thriller without making it feel forced?

3 Upvotes

I'm currently writing a thriller, and I'm a little stuck when it comes to the romance aspect.

I want my two main characters to gradually develop feelings for each other, but the story is so heavily focused on the thriller plot that I'm struggling to find ways to naturally incorporate romantic moments.

I don't want the romance to feel random or take away from the suspense. I want their relationship to develop organically through their interactions, conversations and experiences.

i would love to hear ur advice on it.

Thanks


r/writingadvice • • 14h ago

SENSITIVE CONTENT A Villain's Redemption not requiring forgiveness from those they harmed, Does it?

3 Upvotes

I had this idea for a story for the past few weeks about a group of Villain's put through a Rehab program that's intended to fix there behavior, have them solve problems instead of making them, and shave time off their sentences. The Organization behind this is running it as a pilot program to ensure it gets full funding from the Galactic government.

Each member had done horrible things to end up with multiple life sentences but personality-wise seems fit for change. One wants to see her kids again, another made a promise to a loved one, and another just finds being a Villain is not worth the hassle anymore.

Each person has passed the moral event horizon many times over. Can they be redeemed without forgiveness from those they harmed? Is it enough that when they are out in the galaxy doing good to the point that people unaware of their crimes only know them as a good people? Is it fair to those they hurt that they get a chance to see the light of day?

How should I go around writing this? Would this go over well given its bad people trying to do good?


r/writingadvice • • 9h ago

Advice How do I start writing a book?

1 Upvotes

I’m thinking of writing a book about the positive and negative sides of nursing career.
I have never had written anything more than 3 pages of essays.
Any advice from anyone?
I will name the book 📕 “Light and Dark”. I am hoping it will be helpful and smoothing for all nurses who are depressed and struggling in the field as well as a guide for nursing students and anyone who wants to become a nurse.


r/writingadvice • • 14h ago

Advice I'm having trouble deciding between first person vs third person.

2 Upvotes

I've just started writing a story, and I don't know if first person or

third person would be better. I'd like some advice.

I don't even really have a full, solid plot, but the main character

s a racecar driver who, after an incident that leaves her partially deaf and generally vulnerable, is influenced by her celebrity boyfriend into [doing things that are not good]. I like the idea of things happening all around the character without her knowledge, but 3rd person is annoying to write in for me. It feels clunky to say the main character's name and "she/her/herself" over and over again.

As writers, how do you know which pov will work the best?


r/writingadvice • • 1d ago

Advice I have a certain take on writing (and on being a writer) I would like to share

37 Upvotes

My dear fellow writers.

I have being 'writing' for nearly 2 full years now. I was lucky enough to realize a few things earlier than most seem to have. Here are my takes:

  1. To be a writer, one needs to write. Creating stories and procrastinating on the actual writing is not being a writer but being a story creator, or maybe a story teller (were you to share your stories with others in a way other than them reading it).
  2. An 'author' is one who should be able to finish writing at least one work, whether they polish it or not.
  3. Writing (and I mean the actual writing) is way more fun than I thought it to be. I am excited to start editing and hope it will be just as fun.
  4. This is something I've always been sure of, but everyone has their own processes. Your process being different from someone else's does not mean one of you is doing it the 'wrong way'.
  5. I did hear this piece of information quite a few times before, but only now do I realize the people who told them to le were right: Writing -anything, not just that exact story you are working in- daily, truly is important. I have seen my writing become better every single day (this is by no means an exaggeration), and it gets even better when I am not rushing the writing.

I've got a few more takes, but these shall be enought for now. What are your thoughts on them? Be free to give your opinion -wether you agree or disagree. Good luck on your journey (we all need luck, even those who do not need it 😉).


r/writingadvice • • 1d ago

Advice I love writing, but I feel like I don't have a voice.

12 Upvotes

It has been two years since I began writing an actual novel, and lately I've hit brick walls that I can't seem to get through. I've become so deep in my own head that I've started questioning whether I even have a voice as a writer. Every sentence gets reread and judged so many times that by the second paragraph, I've forgotten what I was trying to say in the first place.

I've always loved writing. Since I was a kid, I've created stories, drawn maps of places that don't exist, and built histories and lineages for characters I've made up. But those were small projects. Nothing I took as seriously as the novel I've spent the last two years writing.

In the beginning, I was writing 15–20 pages a week. It wasn't easy, but I enjoyed what I was making. Now, for the better part of six months, I've struggled to get through a single chapter. It started when I reached the climax and needed to give the reader time to believe a character was dead. I couldn't figure out what to write in the meantime.

Eventually, I went back to rewrite older chapters, only to find myself questioning everything I'd written. Entire chapters needed reworking, and now I can barely get through a paragraph without hating what I've made.

I know where I want the story to go. I know the plot, the characters, and the moments I want to write. But somewhere between my head and the page, everything gets lost.

I've tried plenty of the usual advice for writer's block, but nothing seems to help. I'm beginning to feel like I'm losing the voice I had when I first started.


r/writingadvice • • 1d ago

Advice Overwhelmed with writing as a beginner

10 Upvotes

I’m sure most beginners aren’t unfamiliar with this issue, but it’s frustrating me more than I’d expect.

Everything I write feels wrong. I couldn’t even begin to pinpoint the specific issue; I assume my writing will not translate properly and will only confuse the readers. After pushing through a first draft, I’ll over-edit sentences to the point that everything blurs. Whether it’s pacing, flow, word choice— everything seems to stand out to me as an issue.

It’s something I’m struggling to push past until I’ve built enough skill to be more confident in my ability.

Here’s a sample I’ve recently written:

“Champagne flutes gathered dust on the silver platter balanced between your hands. Two were swiped off your tray as guests, hunched and whispering, returned to the main hall. Candles lit the now-abandoned hallway, calling you to uncover the rest of the manor's secrets. Unfortunately, abandoning your post would be enough reason for Sir Buford to take you out the back and execute you.

Champagne spills over the rims of the guests’ glasses, staining the spotless floor. Beneath its sheen, the bronze of the tiles gleams. So intricate. Countless little artworks, each one on its own enough to catch anyone's attention. But the manor was unlike any venue you’d worked. Each corner—a piece of a puzzle, unique yet somehow perfectly belonging to the picture. All but for the murky corner housing you.”

Any advice or even book recommendations on writing in general would be appreciated.


r/writingadvice • • 17h ago

Advice Should I add wrong lessons to my stories

0 Upvotes

(On mobile and dyslexic so sorry in advance for misspellings)

Wrong lessons is just what I call any lesson that teaches a bad ethics to a character. Like, if a character steals, but dosen’t get punished and benefits from the theft.

I just wish to, and like stories with wrong lessons since it adds layers and complexity to the story. But also do not wish to say that "stealing is good" just that life is complicated and sometimes you learn the wrong thing.

I know that sometimes the consequences is just serverly delayed or happens in small intractshions. (Like the characters mom finding out years later and thinks less of them), or just having the consequences happen to other characters, (showing that the person they stole from now cant afford food or something).

I just dont know if I should or should not include wrong lessons. I dont know if the audience would be smart enough to understand that this is a bad lesson. I don't normally care about what the audience thinks, but I dont want a mob of people to go after me, the author, because they think I endorse stealing. Or for some random interviewer asking why I endorse stealing and rage baiting me. (I really can not stand people putting words in my mouth, so I will be extremely annoyed if that happens)


r/writingadvice • • 18h ago

SENSITIVE CONTENT Deciding pov and tense for my book.

1 Upvotes

New writer here, and I’m struggling to decide what kind of POV and tense fits my book best. I’m writing a sci-fi thriller that follows the journey of a kind, empathetic kid who eventually becomes the ruthless leader of a crime syndicate.

Originally, I wrote it in third person, past tense because of how common it is. It also allowed me to incorporate plot twists and aces up the protagonist’s sleeve. I’ve read first-person books where the protagonist purposefully withholds information from the reader to create a surprise, and I’ve always thought that felt kind of cheap. I feel like that works better in third person.

However, there’s also an argument for first person, present tense. One of the more intriguing parts of the book (I think) is the psychological journey of this kind, empathetic kid who, after experiencing something traumatic, gradually transforms into a ruthless and merciless person. The trauma causes his psychological pendulum to swing all the way in the opposite direction.

I feel like telling that story in first person would work really well because it allows the reader to understand his thoughts and watch in real time as his thinking evolves and he becomes less and less merciful. The thriller aspect also lends itself well to present tense, as it adds a sense of immediacy and creates a more visceral feeling that neither the protagonist nor the reader knows what’s going to happen next. Past tense, on the other hand, can sometimes make it feel like the story is already over and everything turned out okay.

I’d really appreciate some guidance. It’s my first ever book, so I could use all the advice I can get. Thanks!


r/writingadvice • • 19h ago

Advice Writing a story based on a dream?

0 Upvotes

I have a lot of ideas written down from dreams i’ve had, but I’m intimidated by them. I never know if I should try to water it down to make it less weird and surreal, or if I should just embrace it being wacky. Does anyone else write about things they have dreamt about? If so, how do you go about it? I feel like that’s where all my good ideas come from.


r/writingadvice • • 20h ago

Advice Is writing a film scene a good writing practice?

0 Upvotes

Hello there! Well, the title is self-explanatory, but I'll still talk here.

I was watching a show recently, and one of the scenes had a strong emotional effect that caught my attention. Suddenly, my mind decided it would be a great idea to write everything I just watched and describe the scene detail by detail (or whichever way I like).

To me, it sounds like a great practice: I already have a complete plot, and all I need to do is turn it into words. Plus, it doesn't have to be perfect. However, I'm not a skilled writer, or maybe lower than 40% skilled, so I don't feel like I can just assume this.


r/writingadvice • • 20h ago

Advice Writing prejudice in a dark fantasy/ romance.

1 Upvotes

Hello- after years of my story living in my heart I have decided to give a crack at writing it as a novel- currently I am Storyboarding. 😊 below is a general premise:
As her country begins losing a 200 year race war, demon hunter spy is thrust into high society through arranged marriage with the demon prince. Will she untangle the enemy nations conspiracy before it’s too late?

As I’m story boarding and plotting my novel
I’m running into a few things I want to make sure I get right.

In this world Demons and humans dislike each other- for very good reasons. Due to a unique circumstance with her upbringing, my MC does have biases but she generally fine with demons as a people.

Since this is a slow burn romantic fantasy, I’d like to hear some advice about writing convincing prejudice in romance.

Finally- my actually question: What are some things that make prejudice in fantasy settings believable? For me, I know that by the end of my book there’s no way everyone’s going to be suddenly un-prejudice by the end. But it’s important that my main cast develop meaningful relationships despite what they believe about each other initially.

Thanks all!

-edited I’m on a phone writing this and I can’t type lol


r/writingadvice • • 20h ago

SENSITIVE CONTENT I'm wondering how I can interpret a religion like Judaism into my story

0 Upvotes

Essentially in this story, god is replaced by a character called Azris, who is equal to him, but I wanna know how I can interpret 3 different religions who believe in said god so I can hopefully have the main character be of that ethnoreligion.

My current religion that I'm using in my world, known as Gaia, is more like Christianity than anything, especially since they worship Azris and her chosen "Messiah" who ended up corrupting.