r/writingfeedback • • 13h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Epic Fantasy Readability

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

I began this particular WIP for NaNoWriMo. It's an Epic Fantasy, 3rd person limited, past tense. I have been hammering out 19k words/day on this piece since Nov 1st, I am well ahead of the NaNo challenge goal, and I am interested to get some readability feedback on the prose. It my first venture from thriller into fantasy.

The characters are college age, various levels of nobility, and the premise is Dak, one of the spare princes, visits Quill in Brickby, her hometown, to join his mission to collect intel on crop failures that have left several outskirt cities abandoned. What they find is not a disease of the soil as they suspected, but a man, leeching the magic from the ground. They send word to the King of their findings, and they realize he already knew. They weren't sent to investigate; they were sent as sacrifices for the evil that lives on the boarder. They must decide between submitting to their fate or trying to rid their kingdom of the plight once and for all.

This excerpt is before the group leaves on their mission across the kingdom; Quill (MC) was knocked out defending her city from a raid led by the Gazers (a neighboring country) and wakes up in her bedroom.

I think that is plenty context.


r/writingfeedback • • 23h ago

Need feedback on how to fix up WIP chapter for WIP story

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

As the title says, hi! I'm trying to get back into writing after stopping because of being busy and not having the motivation. This is chapter 1 from a story I was making back in high school that I want to fix up but not sure where to start.


r/writingfeedback • • 14h ago

General Feedback Wanted Would you keep reading this fantasy novel?

Thumbnail gallery
15 Upvotes

This is the first chapter in my gothic fantasy novel THE LIES WE WORSHIP.

It’s a book I’ve been working on for years and am finally trying to share it with the world. Let me know what you think!


r/writingfeedback • • 6h ago

General Feedback Wanted First time in a long time writing some serious fiction!

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

I'm a true novice so please don't be asshole about it guys :(

If the picture's don't load or smth

“If I had to describe paperwork to someone else, I'd ask them to imagine themselves drowning in an ocean of endless shit,” said John to nobody in particular.

[Jonathan Maynard Doerson, known to his friends as John Doe, to people he didn't like as Jonathan, and to people he didn't particularly care for as Mr. Doerson.]

John sat in his cubicle and stared into infinity. The little cube was stuffed to every corner with piles of paperwork, all verging on the edge of total collapse. The aging computer in front of him flashed with information from the vast bureaucratic engine of which he was just a cog.

John's gaze shifted over to a crude statue on the corner of his desk, fashioned entirely out of paper clips he had forcibly requisitioned from a committee he had never heard from again.

If only I could find a way out of this miserable existence.

[Jonathan was contemplating suicide.]

[Jonathan clearly does not enjoy the life of a bureaucrat.]

Shit. Have I really sunk low enough to contemplate suicide?

[His self-destructive daydreams were soon interrupted by an unwelcome voice.]

The computer pinged, breaking through his thoughts. A voice message instructed him to immediately transport a set of paperwork to another building.

Personally.

[Jonathan was not pleased about this.]

To think they told me this was the life of money and power.

“Hey, Carrie, you ever wonder if you could just leave this fucked-up Earth behind and start somewhere new? Somewhere where you could actually live?”

“In my youth, yes. But I'm an old woman now. No time for dreams,” the middle-aged woman replied, barely glancing at John as she spoke, far too absorbed in her own work.

“Well, that's just lame, Carrie.”

“Just shut up and be a good porter, John.”

[Jonathan's attempt at striking up friendly conversation to sate his boredom had failed.]

[John had a habit of talking aloud as he went about the dull tasks typically assigned to a clerk.]

“If only I could be in one of those web novels,” muttered John as he walked.

“Leave this stupid life behind and live the juicy life of a noble! A mage! An adventurer! ANYTHING ELSE!” John shouted.

A few passing clerks gave him nervous glances before hurriedly returning to their own tasks.

[This was a common occurrence in the Seventeenth Sub-Level Sub-Committee of the Thirteenth City Ward Security and Peace Administration Committee, of which Jonathan was a part.]

Jonathan pulled out a web novel as he exited the building, paperwork in hand. Boredom was like a loan shark, and John very much wanted to avoid ever seeing it again.

“66666 Year Dark Mage? Well, that's interesting enough. Might as well give it a go.”

[Jonathan never saw the truck coming.]

John woke up in absolute darkness, an inky sea spread out across his vision.

WHERE THE HELL AM I? I CAN'T SEE ANYTHING!

Frustration, fear, and a general sense of unease took root within John's chest and joined his heart in beating out from within his chest.

“H-Hello??? Is anyone there??? Please, someone fucking help me!” yelled John.

Suddenly, the inky sea was blown apart by a shining ray of blue light. John lost his footing from the visceral change in his surroundings and fell.

Is that a blue window with text on it??? Shit, I knew my mental health was bad, but I'm becoming delusional.

[Wow, John, you're actually here? Damn, you weren't supposed to die so early. The one moment I leave you out of my sight.....]

“.......I seriously need to see a therapist.”

[No point....you're dead, and luckily for you, it's time for you to be reincarnated.]

“Dead! Wait, I can't be dea-.......wait, did you say reincarnation?”

[Yes.]

Is my dream finally coming true....will I finally get to live the sweet, sweet life of a noble! A warrior! A mage! My beautiful, beautiful power-fantasy! LITERALLY ANYTHING BUT MORE PAPERWORK!

For the first time since he died, John's life seemed worth living.

“Well, I believe you....you've been watching me, right? You saw how shitty Earth was for me, right? I can't wait for my new wonderful future! A future free of shitty forms and paperwork and* bureaucracy*,” said John, his face stretching into a vast grin. His smile stretched so far that it started to hurt.

[Uhhh, are you sure about that? I never expected you to die, so the proper procedures were never signed....so... youuuurrrreeee sure?]

“Abso-fucking-lutely.”

[You're not very good at gambling, you know.]

“What's that supposed to mea-”

And then John Doe was no more.

John woke up to find himself on a pile of paper, stacked into an impromptu pillow.

John immediately pinched himself to see if he was dreaming or not. A sharp pain on his arm gave him the answer to his reality.

This is an odd place for a nobleman to be.

[Welcome to your new life! You are in the body of Serge Xervak, a perfectly normal man with no supernatural or magical powers whatsoever. Serge works as a mid-level bureaucrat in the province of Golconda in the Kingdom of Eikhardat. Serge Xervak is a pious and perfectly normal man, perfectly normal man, perfectly normal man, perfectly normal m.....]

[Oh wow, well, that last part wasn't supposed to happen. That was freaky, to say the least.]

But John wasn't listening. All his brainpower, attention, and mental power were concentrated on one singular set of words. Mid-level bureaucrat.

Someone was laughing. Not the nice type or the shy one either, but a dull, high-pitched, manic noise. Someone's hair was falling out on the ground.

“FUCKASS KINGDOM FUCKASS JOB FUCKASS GUY FUCKTHISPLACEFUCKTHISKINGDOMFUCKTHISPLACEFUCKTHISKINGDOMFUCKTHISPLACEFUCKTHISKINGDOMFUCKTHISPLACEFUCKTHISKINGDOMFUCKTHISPLACEFUCKTHISKINGDOMFUCKTHISPLACEFUCKTHISKINGDOMFUCKTHISPLACEFUCKTHISKINGDOMFUCKTHISPLACEFUCKTHISKINGDOMFUCKTHISPLACEFUCKTHISKINGDOMFUCKTHISPLACEFUCKTHISKINGDOM”

Out of the corner of his eye, John spotted a little boy in the doorway, clearly the local helper-boy. His face was contorted in shock, and a shattered bottle of wine lay at his feet, wine and glass resting like blood flowing from a corpse.

And right behind him stood a tall and gaunt man dressed in all black. His skin was so pale it looked bleached, and his uniform was pinned with the strangest emblem John had ever seen. A compass pointing north with the arrow replaced with a sword.

An instinctive fear drilled into his body. From somewhere deep in Serge’s memory a piece of information floated up. Right then and their John knew he was looking at…..an agent of the Secret Police

But more terrifyingly for John the man’s entire body was covered from head to toe in strange arcane tattoo’s. Writing and ink moved across his body in strange ethereal patterns.

John was left with the impression of himself being a goat staring caught in an ambush by a predator. 

The man's pitch-black eyes bored right into John, and right at that moment, a thin smile stretched across his face.

“Mr. Serge....you are under arrest for treason.”

[You've really screwed up, haven't you?]

____________________________________________________________________________


r/writingfeedback • • 23h ago

Anti Mosquito Techniques

1 Upvotes

I don't know if this will stay self-contained or end up as the beginning of something longer, but I liked writing it and felt the urge to share it.

Of all the various anti-mosquito techniques: zappers, sprays, old fashioned cavewoman slapping (less effective every year; in our shortsightedness, we’ve been selectively breeding them to be more wily and unpredictable), there is one that stands out as superior. It could be called the Mithridatic method.

Mithridates was an old king from a couple thousand years ago, around present day Turkey. He drank a bunch of poison and died. The important fact here is that those two things were mostly unrelated.

First, let’s take a moment to know the enemy. The mosquito has about two-hundred-thousand neurons compared to our eighty-six billion, and as far as the latest scientific knowledge is concerned more or less every single one of them is dedicated in some way to their singular task of drinking blood: analyzing potential landing spots in terms of amount of drinkable blood, which angle to best to stick in their little needle to suck the maximum amount of blood, flying away after being caught drinking blood, meeting up with another mosquito to make more mosquitos so that they can in turn drink more blood, living up to the lofty bloodsucking standards of previous generations. In short, the mosquito is one of those creatures so stupid that it transcends the idea of intelligence altogether.

There is an extract of the Chrysanthemum flower, Chrysanthemum cinerariifolium, that makes a mosquito’s poor tiny stupid brain go absolutely haywire. There are other substances that do this, ones that are safer for humans, (nitisinone being one of the better known ones), but they lack the immediacy of the chrysanthemum extract. With something like nitisinone, the mosquito has its fill of blood and flies off, though maybe a couple of its precious few neurons discern an unfamiliar aftertaste. As it buzzes around in those last few hours, the mosquito may or may not recognize the fact that it’s dying. It’s not exactly the kind of thing worth wasting neurons on; it’s not like the mosquito has a bucket list. At some point, it lands for the last time, and a few minutes later it stops moving. Nobody really benefits from this. By then, the two of you are already strangers again.

Not so with the chrysanthemum extract. No, when the Mithridatic method is committed to properly, the mosquito will stick its pointy nose into your business and know instantly that it has royally fucked up. Its spindly little limbs will flail around every which way with its needle still inside your skin. It will be incredibly clear to anything watching that it wants to remove its proboscis, as much as it can want anything, but whatever few neurons that might have known how to handle this kind of situation will be on fire. The entire thing will feel like a miniature version of somebody with their wrist trapped inside a sink’s running garbage disposal. Everything moves except for the one thing that should. There is a transparent and universal and very powerful horror to it, nothing like the quiet little surrounded-by-loved-ones vibe of the nitisinone, but something that even an amoeba could make sense of, in its own way. This is the key. After between two and seven seconds of this, the mosquito will seize up and die.

Obviously, this is fantastic. But it will take some effort to get to this point. Like I said, chrysanthemum extract is toxic. There’s nowhere to buy it in bulk, so it is a real do-it-yourself kind of thing. You have to pick the flowers and dry the leaves, and use alcohol to extract the needed substance, known as pyrethrin. You can Google how to do this part, actually. I’m not giving you a step by step. Once you have the stuff, you’re going to want to start small. Just a little bit in your morning coffee. You’ll probably feel some little tingling in your throat first; if you’ve ever accidentally tasted bug-spray, it will be familiar. You might also feel pretty nauseous depending on how much you’ve interpreted “a little bit” to be, and also just on how you’re individually built. After a week, double it, and take another dose at night with your evening glass of wine. This is the hump, it’s where most people quit, and it’s going to suck no matter how you slice it. Your head is going to hurt so bad that you’ll want to die. You’ll get twitchy, and you might start to remind yourself a little bit of the mosquito from the last paragraph, but trust me that it won’t be quite as bad as all that; unlike the mosquito, you’ll still be pretty much in control of the situation, give or take a few hiccups. Sometimes it will look like one side of your face is smiling and the other side is frowning, which isn’t an expression that people are physically capable of when things are going normal, so make sure nobody looks at you and do your best to avoid mirrors yourself. Finally, there will likely be a seizure or two, so try to spend most of your time on something soft so you don’t hit your head, though this shouldn’t be too much of an ask considering the aforementioned skull-shattering nausea will be keeping you in bed anyway. Again, this part will suck, but doing it more gradually doesn’t work. This has to happen. Stockpile easy, low effort meals, take a sabbatical from whatever job you might have (though you’ll probably just want to quit it altogether), do whatever you have to do, but don’t take a break, even for a day. After a month or two, you’ll start to feel more like yourself. Some of it will never go away (the face thing still happens to me a few times a week), but you should mostly be back to the land of the living. Step outside in the evening in a T-shirt and shorts, turn the porch light on, and debut the new you. Do not ever stop taking the doses, unless, for some unimaginable reason, you want to start the whole thing over again. 

Now, some people might say that this is a terrible idea, that the long-term health effects of this must be awful, that you’re probably waving goodbye to five, ten years of your life to deal with a problem that is, ultimately, quite small and silly. These people are losers and idiots and pushovers who wouldn’t know what to do with said five or ten years if they were delivered gift-wrapped to their door. 

Because this neat trick doesn’t just work on mosquitos. Gnats, ticks, leeches, vampire bats;  all the biters and blood drinkers will soon learn to give you a wide berth. After the bodycount reaches the high dozens, something travels through the air, some pan-gaian electrical pulse, and the entirety of nature, no matter how far you travel, will know not to try anything funny. There will always be the occasional enterprising young creature, desperate or optimistic or psychoelectrically deaf, but it won’t be the kind of thing that happens often, and the problem will of course solve itself given two to seven seconds.

And the real great thing is that this works on people, too.

My name is Miranda, and I am completely alone.


r/writingfeedback • • 2h ago

Feedback Request For Airship Fantasy (5 pages)

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi, readers and writers,

I'm working on a fantasy novel about the adventures of various scoundrels engaged in--or adjacent to--airship piracy. In these pages I'm introducing a protagonist and some supporting characters, and I'd like to know if the pace drags, the characters annoy, the dialogue rings false, the writing clunks, or anything else stands out as needing improvement. Any and all thoughts are greatly appreciated, and thank you in advance.


r/writingfeedback • • 4h ago

General Feedback Wanted Hello, looking for feedback on these two chapters I am going to fuse into one in the second edition of my book.

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi! To add backstory to Sanctuary, these scenes happen after she attacks the hotel's indigenous vampire bartenders, Grix and Stellaphon who were tortured by her mother in a place called The Cow Pens where they were forced to farm biomechanical cow brains to feed the population of people that had with the help of undercover vampire hunters, stolen their tribe's homeland


r/writingfeedback • • 19h ago

General Feedback Wanted Style/understandability?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

Obviously this is fanfiction, but I’m writing it with the intention of my boyfriend being able to keep up while reading it. He likes reading my stories to me but doesn’t always understand what’s happening :) I tried to write this in the mind of explaining more than I usually would about the universe but leaving it to be understood through context, like a lot of books in different universes will. Also just wondering if there are generally any glaring flaws in my writing style.


r/writingfeedback • • 20h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Opener to a CYOA fanfic I'm rebooting. What do you think? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

This is a preamble, I am spoiling this so people following me don't get spoiled! This is the fourth installment in the story overall and the opener to the first chapter. I would not mind some beta readers if possible, as putting OOC stuff here every week would probably be awkward.

I imagine some stuff may be OOC because it is, as stated, a fourth installment in a series. I'll still take feedback on that, however! It is also a second draft, and the part where it cuts off is where the 'players' would be prompted to make a choice.

With no further adieu, here's the work!

You are dragged out of sleep by the warmth of the sun. Spitefully, you turn away, mumble, and, in dramatic irony, are pulled back under the lull of unconsciousness by its heat. You spend what feels like minutes under, but in reality it is likely seconds.

Your alarm blares, dragging you out of your slumber. You can't help it—you groan and bury your head in your pillow, before you remember your wits. If you oversleep, you'll be late to work, or at least have to cram your breakfast down your throat so you won't be.

The moment you let go of PAMA, they grab you by the arm and pull you close. You'd think a machine would be unable to sleep through such a horrible squeal, but no, apparently not. You try and slip through their arms and they squeeze a little harder, letting out the mechanical equivalent of a murmur. Which, in all honesty, sounds like someone trying to squish a noteblock.

"PAMA, c'mon, I gotta go to work," you push against a knee their screen gently. You're not the only one who needs to get to work, anyway!

"Nooooooo," they wail. Some say PAMA is too monotone to, but you know each of their attempts at emoting by heart. How ironic the 'useful' machine is the one clinging to you and your bed like a lifeline. The urge to roll your eyes almost overcomes your mission.

What little of PAMA's awake mind drags their eyes to the alarm. That is what rouses them, and it rouses them violently. Their tail lashes against your leg and you are released. Once you shut your alarm off, PAMA pulls you back towards their chest. A squeak escapes you.

"PAMA," you glare at them.

"Five more minutes…" PAMA insists. You stare. "Ten."

"I want a divorce!" you dramatically shout. PAMA holds you closer and purrs. "Ugh, fine," you let your head fall onto their chest. PAMA purrs even louder.

Jesse really was lucky, he didn't have to fight the urge to cuddle someone every morning. You turn your eyes to the ceiling and try to suppress a smile. Sure, being late isn't ideal, but… PAMA's here. What could be better than this—?

"You guys need a new alarm clock," Willow pokes her screen through the door. "Don't make me get Firework again!" Her purple ears pin back. You roll your eyes.

"So mean!" PAMA comments. Goodness, Willow looks almost like them, just quite a bit lankier and with a purple screen and rose gold metal for skin. Somehow, you're still doomed to be the shortest member of your family. Well, you would be if Firework could still stand.

Your kids have seemed to inherit some aspect of how you dress. If anything, Willow's more a parody of modern you, so terribly insistent that a pink jacket that stops by her chest is 'cool.' At least she didn't pick up your penchant for charging after giant endermen shirtless! But she does have the awful habit of letting her shorts tear quite a bit.

You knew a guy like that in your Endercon days. He said it looked 'cool.' What anxiety you had then prevented you from ever telling him he looked like he was a klutz. But if it makes her look cool…

Willow adjusts her glasses, "You've got five seconds," before she can finish her threat, there is a thump from a few rooms away. You leap out of bed and push her to the side gently. She flaps her tiny, feathered wings as you brush past her. "The bunnies are what get you out of bed?"

"You try sleeping through one of Wheat's tantrums!" you insist as you leave.

The moment you open the door to the rabbit room, Wheat thumps again. You sigh. You haven't slept a night without keeping at least one carrot on you. You scoop him up and put a carrot in his mouth. If you don't hold him like a baby, he'll eat everyone else's food. Speaking of, you toss a few carrots to the rest of your rabbits.

It's a good thing they eat veggies. They can crunch through damn near anything if they put their minds to it. That prompts a horrible thought. Right, after you eat, you should take your meds.

"Should I make breakfast?" PAMA asks. There is an agonizing moment of silence when they're done speaking. It's long enough for Wheat to finish his carrot. You hold him close as the rest of your bunnies continue to eat. Wheat grabs at your sleepwear with his teeth but you don't relent.

"Firework volunteered," Willow sounds a little tense. "You know he's going to go overboard with the food dye again."

"Well, people do like rainbow bagels. Maybe he could make a killing off of rainbow pancakes!" Those words probably have Willow wishing she could kill PAMA with her eyes. You roll your eyes. "They do look very pretty, I must admit."

"You could do some tie dye sometime," you offer as you set Wheat down. Willow tilts her head, line-like eyes widening. "You know, we could make it a family thing." Willow stares at the floor before rushing downstairs.

"Willow—!" PAMA shouts. You wrack your half asleep mind for what to say next.

"I've gotta go to work!" she insists. You sigh and grab PAMA's wrist before they can even process the desire to move. For a moment, PAMA glares at you, before they just sigh and shake their head.

"Just get dressed and we'll have breakfast," you plead. PAMA stares at you again and then heads back into your room.

There is an awkward silence as you two dress yourselves. It's interrupted when PAMA scoffs at your choice of shirt. It's not your fault the three bunnies howling at the rabbit in the moon makes a hilarious shirt.

"You look like a dork," you jest as point to the blue cardigan vest covering their dark blue shirt.

"And you are a porcupine," they point to your leather jacket. You glare. "Are you trying to kill someone?" they point at your spiky boots.

"Yep!" you beam. PAMA rolls their eyes. "And what's the point of keeping your horn broken if you're just gonna cover it with a hat?"

"It is a statement piece!" PAMA insists. Now you roll your eyes. "You should brush your hair," they stop their jesting.

Right. Letting it grow out a bit means more upkeep. You sigh, head to the bathroom, and brush your hair. It won't be too long until it needs a cut, it's getting close to your shoulders. Once it passes that threshold—eugh. That's not a fun topic to bring up to your therapist.

In the time it took you two to prepare, Firework has plated a few sludgy colored pancakes.

He doesn't look too different from you, skin a little bit warmer, feathers on his head the same color as your hair, and his ears are big like yours. Of course, his are a bit floppier, a tad more cat-like. When you wore a hoodie, it was a lot simpler than his; yellow and looking as if it is covered in explosions.

You used to be a lot scrawnier than he was, now he's just a little bit chubbier than you are. It feels like it should have been something to freak out about, but you barely… cared?

"I see color theory has victimized you again," PAMA jokes. Firework rolls his green and black eyes.

Ironically, the kid has an eye for it, considering he decorates the hell out of the wheel cover of his wheelchair. Goodness, that's a mouth full.

"I hope Wheat did not wake you up," PAMA interrupts that train of thought.

"He probably did," you stare at PAMA. Firework takes a moment to type in his AAC.

"Yep," Firework concurs.

"Figures," you roll your eyes. "Why did I even get an alarm clock when I have him?"

"Because you are big dummy," Firework giggles.

"No!" you yowl.

"Very big! Biggest dummy!"

"He is so terrible with his money, isn't he?" PAMA elbows Firework.

"I swear to god I'm going to divorce you for real this time!" you shout as dramatically as you can. It comes out as more of a whine. PAMA smirks. "You're so lucky you're cute!"

"Cute is an understatement! I am the most beautiful person alive!" PAMA boasts. You roll your eyes and their screen goes red. "WHAT! HOW DARE YOU! PAMA IS THE MOST BEAUTIFUL CREATURE IN THE WORLD!" You can't help but snicker. PAMA crosses their arms and lets out a mechanical imitation of a 'humph!' Firework breaks into a laugh and PAMA somehow goes redder.

"Okay, I think I'll do my teasing better if I'm well fed," you smirk.

"Then starve!" PAMA shouts at you and you stare at them, eyes wide. They look away and lash their tail a little. "Should we go after Willow?" they ask as you sit down. Firework passes you a plate.

Not again…

"She's an adult," you begin and say a small 'thank you,' to Firework. "You can't clamp down on her."

"I know that!" PAMA lashes their tail again. Firework stares at his plate, then you, and just starts chowing down. "She worries me. She is disappearing so often—"

"She probably just wants some independence. She's at that age," you pick at your food. Firework's getting close, too. Or well, he's already there if you count teens.

"No, it is not that! It would be just as suspicious if she suddenly stated she wanted to move out!" PAMA puts their hands down on the table. "I think something is wrong!"

"Maybe, but you're not going to figure it out if you brute force it." You take a bite and hide the fact pancakes still turn your stomach a bit. PAMA stares at you, their eyes softening, and they push their head into their hands. "Okay, I'll bite. Why? Is it because of your… history?"

"I am not sure," PAMA admits. Firework slides his plate over and immediately skedaddles. With how fast he heads up the stairs, you fear his autostepper will break. You turn to him.

"Wheat just thumped!" he insists. You debate telling him that Wheat didn't in fact thump but hold your tongue. You look over at PAMA and tilt your head.

"And that is not suspicious?" they gesture both hands towards you. You stare at them still. "Asking her if she is okay will not do any harm, Radar. You have some time before work, or if you really need an excuse, she does work for you."


r/writingfeedback • • 22h ago

General Feedback Wanted Critique wanted.

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Not the first thing I've written. It's the third.


r/writingfeedback • • 4h ago

General Feedback Wanted Tried writing a scene out of my comfort zone. Any feedback?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback • • 3h ago

General Feedback Wanted Short opening (400 words). Would you continue reading based off of this?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Opening of my superhero novel “when the red static falls”


r/writingfeedback • • 2h ago

What can I improve on here?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

I don't usually write, but I decided to start writing a narrative poem and I just wanted to know what I could improve on for future parts of the poem, or any changes I could make to this one.

I'm calling it Light Turned Dark. I wanted to tell a story where God was an evil authoritarian entity, and have Satan beat him. (typical edgy teenager topic I know) My goal is to use the poem as lyrics for a collection of songs one day. This would be first song, called Beginning in a Pentacle.


r/writingfeedback • • 22h ago

General Feedback Wanted The Contest of Arms

0 Upvotes

The Contest of Arms

„I will not feign, o esteemed allies, that I believe my words could ever combat those of this persuasive bandit, whose tongue is as honeyed and sharp as his heart is bereft of courage and arms unused to the spear and shield. No, noble Achaeans, I will not be aided by oratory, mystifying and knotted — my deeds, splendid and famous, and my taintless character shall help me prevail in this skirmish against foul Odysseus.

“It is I, Ajax, Telamon’s son, who delivered swift-footed Achilles’ lifeless body from the maddened fray. That certitude alone should conclude this contest, for, if anyone ought to gain Peleus’ son’s arms, by right it must be I. Had not valor and virtue prevailed in my heart against all that urged me to tend to my safety, some Trojan villain would have surely stolen them for himself.

“Therewithal, what use could this assassin who prowls silently in the night, who attacks but from behind, murders defenseless children and, in truth, is ready to do whatever he must to avoid a fair confrontation, possibly have for Achilles’ arms, even if they rightfully belonged to him? Any honest man who has seen his unblemished shield, his pristine armor and his unused spear must confess that it would be thoughtless to gift Odysseus with tools of warfare.

“My shield, o brave Argives, is thoroughly battered from all the times it protected me and yourselves from fierce foes. My armor, likewise, endured much and bears the marks of many blows which it received while I stood first in line fighting the enemy. My spear has savored more blood than that of any man present here. If anyone has through his deeds merited new arms, it is I; and whose arms, friends, would serve as a more fitting reward than my cousin’s, noble Achilles’?

“And, even if Odysseus somehow had need of new equipment and I did not, and even if he somehow showed himself worthy of these in question, we would gladden his sly, cowardly heart far more if we presented him with a dagger with which to cut his victims’ throats, or, perhaps, he would prefer a far-reaching bow and a quiver of arrows dipped in the hydra’s blood. I, who spiritedly battle my enemies vis-à-vis, would gain much if you, lords, bequeathed these arms to me.

“My accomplishments are many and well-known by you all — no, they need not be recounted, as I am sure they are right now almost corporeally present in your minds, radiantly flickering. But truly, whenever I attempt to recall a single great deed this dog ever performed unaided, I cannot. He does nothing without an inordinate amount of aid from Athena or Diomedes, his sole two comrades not yet backstabbed; need we recall poor Philoctetes’ fate, who, abandoned on Lemnos, now lives in a cave like an animal, tormented by a festering wound, or Palamedes’, who, falsely accused of treason, lies dead? O Atreides, o Agamemnon and Menelaus, be cautious; treachery is the only reward any ally of Odysseus can expect to procure by helping him.

“Allow me to say but one more thing against this honorless scoundrel who attempted to, if anyone needs to be reminded, break his oath by playing mad, because no more needs to be said about his vile character than this: he abandoned Nestor to die when he fell out of his chariot; Odysseus, who was close by, could not muster the courage to help the old hero around whom a savage clash was flaring. These heavy, redoubtable arms would do little more than hinder his craven exploits.

“Someone may now remark, after I conclude my speech, thusly: “Do not you think Ajax has been somewhat too keen on attacking Odysseus, when he should have been minded far more to laud himself?” And my beliefs would fervidly diverge from those of the commentator, yet a thought one believes carries little merit ought to be faced and vanquished just like any other, just how the smallest ember in the wilderness must be snuffed out to prevent a fiery catastrophe. Who I am is known to you all, I have nothing to hide, nothing to reveal, and my undertakings, my lineage and my integrity are such that they would be somewhat spoiled by vain extended self-praise. I choose your silent admiration, proud Achaeans, over the cheers lengthy boasts would win me. In addition, I feel it is the solemn duty of any upstanding man to, whenever fate presents him with the opportunity, rebuke the knavish cut-throats who stand opposite all things virtuous, and to heave their transgressions out in the open, where Helios may gaze upon them with a disgusted grimace.

“I pray, dear Danaans, that you will judge this contest wisely and afford the triumph according to merit.”

Ajax, having concluded his speech, sat down, satisfied, and intense shouts of approval rang through the camp. Odysseus stood up, seemingly unphased, and began:

“It cannot be, no, I will not even toy with the idea that you, o my comrades wise, lordly, found a modicum of wisdom in this man’s words. It cannot be that those such as yourselves would consider aught in his speech contained as accordant with truth. No, I will not entertain for a flash the thought that he has done more than poison and ensnare your ever-reasonable spirits with his falsehoods. And, like a physician must, invited or, if an illness has not yet become apparent to its victim, but to the healer’s keen eyes it is more than manifest, uninvited, I will release you from the venomous clutches of Ajax’ inventions.

“Still, though my sympathy for your state is overwhelming, I am not able to deny the torrential pangs your seeming agreement with the sentiments just now expressed impels me endure. Is this the payment which he without who’s acute wits proud Ilium would still be looming unconquered, just as it had been for a decade prior, deserves; a decade in which — ah, how I pain at having to strike my fellow Argive, even in righteous defense — brave Ajax’ skills helped not in progressing the siege, not a bit? The behavior you have demonstrated is not becoming of you, great men, heroes, this conduct goes against all I know you to be. I will forgive you, since that is in my character, and since Ajax, the orchestrator, is he who compelled you into wrongdoing.

“Throughout his speech, if you will excuse this sudden leap towards a novel topic — I fear if now I do not mention it, it may eternally be stolen away — and permit me a daring, uncustomary degree of frankness, I have had entirely one thought besieging my mind; unrelenting was its assault, brutal, devastating, and it at time made me quite unable to focus on noble Ajax’ vacuous words — for that I grieve, but tears that would so vigorously illuminate my innermost emotions my upbringing and temperament do not allow in a situation such as this; if his utterances were customarily airy, uninspired, weak, I could have dismantled them all, like I have done many times before, had I heard clearly heard and remembered them, and if by divine inspiration the muses spoke through him this one time, I would have been entranced listening to his sweet, though false, words. And now, when my opponent — ah, cruel, cruel you are fate, forcing me to call distinguished Ajax an opponent — has concluded his invective, allow me to divulge it to you, good men, without a single constituent part omitted or altered: ‘From whence within Ajax’ heart and spurred on by what does this merciless hatred spring, this loathing for the man without whom haughty Priam would still be laughing at the impotent siege safe within the hefty walls of Troy?’

“Beloved friends, I pray to Zeus, to him who faultlessly assigns justice from atop high, snow-capped Olympus, that my gracefully candid words and my sincere, well-meaning demeanor have achieved their goal; I hope that I have managed to wash away the taint with which the man who spoke before me has cruelly defiled me. And, in the end, if you decide that splendid Achilles’ arms should by right be given to Ajax, I will not object; it is the proclamations of the wise councils that must be followed without objections. Yet, I cannot deny that all which is good in me roars out in favor of—”

“Hah,” interrupted Ajax, rising to his feet “there is naught in you anyone could call good. A virtuous man would have faced the arguments I have put forward, but you, dog,—”

“Again, o, hear it, comrades, again he attacks me wholly baselessly, this maddened Achaean champion. What shamelessness it is to—”

“What shamelessness is it to live as Odysseus, what foul daring—”

* * *

The Greeks departed from the Dardanian shores, taking with themselves all they deemed worthy from that which had survived the devastation. Behind them the quiet, eerie charred remains of once-proud Ilium stood, small and ashamed. Demolished were Troy’s cyclopean, unrelenting walls, brought down its grand, awe-inspiring palaces and the other fine abodes of the rich, its numerous, lovingly adorned temples which once housed grandiose images of the gods were no more. All was either ripped from inside its walls or destroyed. Corpses, covered with dried blood, burned, half eaten by birds and wild dogs, lay all around the city and the shore. No one, other than women meant to be used in the house, was spared. Everything was quiet, still, empty. The last traces of the Dardanian tongue could be heard only inside the ships of the Greeks, in prayers uttered between violent, desperate sobs, and wails for mercy.


r/writingfeedback • • 19h ago

General Feedback Wanted [WIP]

Post image
0 Upvotes

Would you read it?


r/writingfeedback • • 21h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted 3 pieces of micro fiction (under 100 words)

2 Upvotes

Hello all,

I've very recently started experimenting with micro fiction. Would anyone be so kind as to take a look and give me some feedback?

-----

Pretty

Clink! Go the little cups. That lady has a pretty dress on. It’s white, but not like milk. Like caramel ice cream. And her hair is shiny.

The room is pretty too. It has lots of ptu…pept…ptupe… petunias. Petunias. 

I want mommy to see the pretty lady and the pretty flowers. I’ll tell her when she comes back from heaven.

-----

Copy

Where the fuck am I gonna find money for the fucking hockey camp? I swear, every God damned time it’s something else. Daddy, ALL my friends have the new iPhone. Daddy, Emily Stutter got the SAME shoes I have, I can’t wear those anymore or EVERYONE will laugh at me. Who the fuck is gonna laugh over God damned shoes? Daddy, the band camp is next month, I need 650 bucks. Wasn’t it basketball like three months ago? Fuck.

"Spirit One-One, cleared to engage."

Copy, cleared to engage—two away.

-----

Tin-Cup Joe → Sacramento 6/14

I could buy lunch today. At that fancy bakery I walked past yesterday. Oh, I’ll get something for Frisco Jack. I think he’d enjoy a croissant. Or something with honey. I think he told me he liked sweets, especially the cupcakes his daughter used to make. Oh, Oh, I could get him a cupcake. Like, a really fancy one, with that colored frosting and the… the… whatchamacallit, the colorful… the… anyway, a cupcake croissant. And a nice hot cup of tea. A nice hot cup of tea, yes. With a spot of milk. And for Boxcar Mick…

—Excuse me, I think I dropped my wallet around here.


r/writingfeedback • • 2h ago

General Feedback Wanted Feedback for chapter 1 of a fantasy novel.

1 Upvotes

The chapter is roughly 2k words I believe, and I'm looking for some general feedback on whether you'd be interested in continuing.

I am personally not happy with the pacing, so any advice on how to improve it is appreciated as well.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Chapter 1

"He killed a man?"

Alistair sat comfortably in his chair, holding a crystal glass in one hand. Beside him, a man stood with a silver pitcher, carefully topping up the glass. Alistair watched the crimson liquid rise.

"Yes. Last night," Edward replied.

Alistair took a sip and gave a small nod of approval, sending the man back to the kitchen. "And someone saw him?"

"No Sir," Lucien answered for him. "Nobody saw. I made sure of that."

Alistair glanced at him. "Good. Who was the man?"

"A tourist," Lucien replied. "Only been in town a day or two."

"Anyone come looking?"

"Not yet." Edward butted in.

Alistair nodded and took another drink. "So," he said, looking at Edward. "What exactly is the problem?"

Edward glanced at Lucien before answering. "He killed a human."

"Yes. I gathered that."

"But we're supposed to feed and release." Edward’s protest came out muffled.

Alistair raised an eyebrow. "Feed and release?"

"Yes. The Head has been very clear about that," Edward replied, his voice rising slightly at the mention of the Head. "We have rules for a reason."

"Rules," Alistair repeated thoughtfully.

He took another sip from his glass, watching Edward over the rim.

"Tell me something, Edward. How long ago were you turned?"

"Fifty-three years, Sir”

"Fifty-three years," Alistair nodded slowly. "And in all that time, you've never killed a human?"

Edward hesitated. "Not without reason."

A faint smile crossed Alistair's face. "Ah. So there are exceptions."

"That's not what I meant," Edward replied.

"No?" Alistair looked towards Lucien, who had been listening quietly. "Did you hear that, Lucien? Apparently, there are circumstances in which a human's life becomes expendable."

Lucien gave a small shrug. "That's what I've been saying."

Edward turned towards him. "You know perfectly well that's not what I meant."

"Then what did you mean?" Lucien asked. "Because I've been listening to you complain about this since we left."

"Because you killed someone!"

"Yes, Edward. I was there." Lucien replied dryly. 

Alistair chuckled into his glass. Edward turned back towards him, clearly hoping for a more reasonable response. "Surely you agree that we shouldn't make a habit of it?"

Alistair considered the question, then set his glass down on the small table beside him. He let out a sharp, piercing whistle, prompting the servant to emerge from the adjoining room, wiping his wrist with a towel.

Setting the towel down in a bin by the door, he picked up the pitcher and stood silently by Alistair’s chair. Before he could react, Alistair seized him by the throat and drove his other hand into his chest.

There was a short, wet sound.

Alistair withdrew his hand, holding the man's heart. The human crumpled to the floor beside the chair, the silver pitcher rolled across the floor, staining the carpet crimson.

Alistair looked down at the body, then back at Edward. "Feed and release?" He picked up his glass and took a drink. "Is that better?"

Alistair watched as Edward silently rocked back on his heels, seemingly studying the ceiling. “Do my actions offend you Edward? Do you feel bad for that human?” Alistair tilted his head slightly.

Edward took a deep breath and slowly looked down at Alistair. “Of course not, Sir.”

“Then what is it?” 

Edward opened his mouth to speak, then closed it, rethinking his response. “Unnecessarily killing a human is against the Head’s rules. Especially an enthralled human.” He gestured towards the corpse lying at Alistair’s feet. 

“Against the Head’s rules.” Alistair lingered slightly on the word head. “It seems I have broken those rules. So tell me, what exactly will my punishment be?” 

Edward lowered his head and didn’t respond.

Alistair let out a little chuckle. “A rule enforced by… nothing. Such a foolish notion.” He paused for a moment, finishing off his drink. “Killing a human is against some rule, and yet, nothing will happen if you do.”

Edward opened his mouth to speak, but before he could say one word, Alistair was behind him. “And what would happen,” his hand plunged deep into Edward's chest, gripping a rapidly beating heart. “If I were to remove your heart?”

Edward let loose a shaky breath, looking desperately at Lucien. 

Lucien turned to look at Alistair then froze, a faint smile was dancing across Alistair's face. 

“Well, is anyone going to answer my question or should I find out myself?” He asked calmly, his grip tightening slightly. 

Edward’s throat bobbed as he swallowed hard. “100 years. The punishment for killing a member of the Family is 100 years in the Cell.” He stuttered.

Alistair removed his hand carefully. Before Edward could let out a sigh of relief, he was back on his chair, wiping his hand on a handkerchief. “Interesting, there is no punishment for killing a human. But killing a vampire gets you a hundred years.” He looked around the room for a moment. “What does that tell you, Edward?”

Edward was still breathing heavily, the wound in his back already closed. He shot a hateful glance at Lucien, who was rubbing his temple, his brow furrowed. 

Lucien looked up at Alistair, who seemed perfectly calm despite what just happened. “How do you do that? Fight against the Bond? Is it just age?”

Alistair laughed quietly. “It is not your fault, Luci. You can’t expect someone as young as yourself to be able to fight one instinct, let alone two opposing instincts.”

Lucien looked relieved as he dropped to one knee and lowered his head, Edward did the same. “Thank you, Sire.” 

“I’ve told you both to stop that, rise.” He said annoyed. 

Both younger vampires stood up and started walking towards the door before Alistair's voice made them pause. 

“Edward, hold onto whatever humanity you still have left for as long as you can, it’s a gift.” He hesitated for a moment. “But make sure you are strong enough that nobody can mistake that for weakness.”

“Thank you, Sir,” Edward said as he and Lucien walked out of the building.

“Send me another enthralled servant as well. Mine seems to have fallen ill.” Alistair gave the order as they reached the threshold.

Edward and Lucien started arguing about something or other as soon as they were out the door, and Alistair got to work cleaning the blood from his living room floor. 

Alistair finished cleaning the floor and inspected his work with mild satisfaction. A small sigh escaped him as he folded the bloodied cloth and dropped it into the bin.

He had barely settled back into his chair when a knock sounded at the door.

Alistair closed his eyes briefly. "Honestly, is it too much to ask for one quiet evening?"

He rose, crossed the room and opened the door. A young vampire stood outside, dressed rather more formally than the occasion seemed to warrant.

"Alistair?" The vampire addressed him stiffly. “The Head has issued an official summons for you.” He held up a thick sheet of parchment. “You are to report to her office at once.” 

“Oh dear, is it that time of the millennium already?” Alistair took the parchment from the vampire and read it over. “Shouldn’t leave the Lady waiting then. Allow me to pack an overnight bag and I’ll be on my way.”

“The Head instructed me to bring you immediately, not whenever is convenient for you Alistair.” 

Alistair let loose a short laugh. “Sophia knows better than to insi—” 

“You will not disrespect the Head like that.” The vampire interrupted Alistair. In a moment, his hand was halfway to Alistair's throat. 

Alistair grabbed the vampire’s hand by the wrist, and in one swift motion, severed it cleanly. His eyes flashing red for a fraction of a second. “You should know better than to threaten me, Boy.” Alistair raised his voice slightly before composing himself. “Sorry, I meant to say I’ll be just a moment, so we won’t be far behind Her schedule.” He cleared his throat and continued, “wait here, I’ll be right out.” 

Alistair didn’t pack much, a few pairs of clothes and a suit for when he saw the Head. Just before he walked back out to the room, something shiny caught his eye. He walked back to his bed and grabbed a necklace with a small golden pendant hanging from it. 

“Planning to bring some souvenirs along? It’s just a day trip.” The messenger chuckled from the doorway. 

Alistair turned around, clasping the chain around his neck. He saw the messenger flexing his fingers and rotating his wrist experimentally as the last traces of the injury disappeared. “The rest of this stuff can be replaced. My mother gave me this necklace, and I would prefer not to lose it.” He took a deep breath before heading towards the messenger, “let’s get this show on the road, shall we?”

As they walked down the road, Alistair grew tired of the silence. “So, how long ago were you turned? Your hand healed considerably faster than I had expected.”

“Thank you for that, by the way.” The messenger replied sarcastically. “The name’s Carlos, and I was turned by the Lady herself some 500 years ago.” 

Alistair gave Carlos a puzzled look. “So I take it you’re new to the job then?”

“Yes, as a human I served as messenger to the King. The Head’s previous messenger had just been killed by an unhappy recipient, and she turned me. I took over as Head Messenger 23 years ago when Aurelia passed.” Carlos stopped walking at the edge of a small lake, the bridge across it had crumbled and fallen in a few years ago. “This is as far as I go. On the other side of this lake, the Head’s personal Guard will be waiting to escort you for the rest of the journey.”

“Aurelia.” Alistair's expression softened slightly. “I had wondered why the Head would send you instead of her. This is the first I’m hearing of her death, it’s a shame really. She was strong, in both body and spirit. If I should meet her in the afterlife I will send your regards.” He spoke with a distant look in his eyes.

Carlos gave a puzzled look. Then, realizing who was in front of him, nodded in appreciation. Alistair didn’t wait for more, he bent his legs and jumped, clearing the lake in one smooth motion and landing in front of 3 men wielding long swords. 

As soon as his feet touched the dirt, all three blades were in his face. “Halt. Alistair. The rules for your escort are as follows. One—”

“Follow you guys, don’t stray from the path, and ‘if I see a drop of your blood, you’ll be picking your head off the ground.” Alistair said that last bit mockingly. “You know that last rule is still as stupid as last time. Especially with three sharp blades pointed at me.” He blinked a few times. “Wait a minute, swords. Has Sophia been making trades with the Seventh recently?”

“Why do you always insist on interrupting us, Alistair?" The tallest guard asked seriously.

“Well if you keep standing on formality, I will keep interrupting. You should know this by now Brother.” Alistair hesitated for a moment before pressing further, “and you never answered my question.”

“Do not call me ‘brother.’ and what the Lady does with her resources is none of your business.” He and the rest of the guard put their swords back in their sheaths. “Now we run. Do not fall behind.” 

A few short minutes later, the four men were standing outside a large outpost. Vampires of all ages were wandering around the yard, going about their business. As they approached the building, the men flashed a wooden badge with an elaborate symbol burned into it to the guard at the door, and they instantly stood straight and saluted before opening the doors. 

As Alistair passed the doors, he nodded slightly to the door guard. Inside the building, his presence was attracting a few stares and whispers. “These guys really don’t know of subtlety, do they? What have they learned in their long lives?” 

Though Alistair was speaking mostly to himself, the tall guard answered. “Well you really can’t blame them. It isn’t often that you show up here, and the last time you did you caused quite a ruckus.” He ran a hand through his hair, sweeping the smooth golden strands from his face. “Even you have to admit this.”

“Yeah I was young and foolish, surely they understand this.” Alistair shot him a childish smirk. “I do wonder what would happen if I were to accidentally cut my hand on one of these sharp corners in here. How would these children react?”

The blonde guard placed a hand on his hilt and lowered his voice. “Ali. Do not make such threats. We were serious about dropping you if we see even a drop of your blood. Head’s orders.” 

“Oh come on, Scott. Just a drop. It’ll be fun.” He opened his hand, and slowly moved his palm to his mouth. One fang protruded further than the rest of his teeth. “All it takes is one drop.” His voice came out half muffled.

All three guards had their swords drawn against Alistair’s throat. A full smile was painted on Alistair’s pale face, his one fang still protruding. “Those swords won’t stop me, but you know what will, Scott.” His hand was now touching the fang, one small movement away from being cut.

“Okay, Brother. Stop, please. I don’t want to do this but I will if you so much as move.” Scott took a deep breath, his grip tightening on his sword. “Stop this foolishness.”

“All you had to do was ask.” Alistair retracted his fang and lowered his hand. “Doesn’t that feel so much better?” 

The people around were now staring, dropping all pretenses as they watched the altercation outside the Head’s office.  Alistair straightened his jacket and fixed his collar. Acting as though there weren’t swords at his throat only a moment ago. 

One of the guards withdrew his sword and his eyebrows drew together as he sniffed the air. “What is a human doing in the compound?” He sniffed again, “and it’s not one of ours.”

Alistair followed suit, sniffing the air and looking at the guard. “You sure you’re qualified for your job? That’s not just a human, it’s a witch.” He turned around and knocked on the Head’s door. “Sophia!” He shouted. “Your guest has arrived, we shouldn’t keep her waiting long.”

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


r/writingfeedback • • 18h ago

General Feedback Wanted Which phrasing sounds better?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

The first image's phrasing is throwing me off a little because it feels like I'm jumping into the description without real punctuation (if that makes sense?), but the second image's phrasing feels like fanfiction writing where every sentence is one paragraph (if that also makes sense).

How would I go about writing this?


r/writingfeedback • • 1h ago

General Feedback Wanted The Outlier

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback • • 2h ago

General Feedback Wanted A story i made!

1 Upvotes

​

I spent my afternoon writing a small story.

This is the second time ive ever done it. Anu critiques are welcome, but please try and be kind. Some things in this story apply to me, But not all. I hope you enjoy. I posted it here due to the main theme, but will also put it in a dedicated subredit for writing. Encouragement because this might motivate someone 🤷‍♂️

Chapter 1

Enchained

Finn saw…. a light. A light at the end of the tunnel. He still didn’t know what to make of the situation, but alas, here it was again. He looked around and saw that he was in the same dimly illuminated hallway as last time, it was just barely taller than he was, though to be honest, that wasn’t very hard. He had never taken the time to measure his height, though he assumed he was around 160 cm tall. He turned his head to look behind him and almost jumped a bit. Directly behind him was the wall, just close enough that he hadn’t noticed it until now. The hallway was shorter than last time. It was made of concrete, the same cold painful concrete that the floor he was standing on was made from. Finn sat down and leaned his back against the rough wall, groaning softly in discomfort as he rested himself on the cold concrete, the cold air feeling like it was holding him in place. He asked himself why he didn’t feel like walking towards the light, why he would rather sit leaning against the cold concrete wall than stand up and walk away. He didn’t feel his answer was a good one. He simply didn’t want the situation to get any worse. As far as he knew, there was even more cold, and an even smaller tunnel past the yellow light. He would much rather take what he was given. He had been here before. Every now and then, he would dream of this place. He would fall asleep and stay here until he had decided on what he wanted to do. He had always decided to just stay in the corner. He would much rather sit in the corner than face what awaited beyond the light. In a few minutes, he should wake up again. In a few minutes, he should be ripped from having to make this choice.  Sitting in his concrete corner, wondering why he wasn’t awake yet, Finn contemplated what could be behind the light, and realized the reason he was still here was due to the fact that for the first time since he started dreaming of the tunnel that he was in, he was uncertain. He wasn’t sure if he wanted to stay in the cold. What if it was warm past the light? He tried to shut himself up. “It’s fine here… I’ll just…. take my chances,” he muttered to himself quietly. He’d rather stay here than make a mistake. He didn’t like talking to himself, mostly since people would judge him for it. He sometimes did it anyways, but only when he was sure he was alone. He liked speaking his mind, even if no one except him would hear what he had to say. He started seriously contemplating walking towards the light; it was just a dream after all. He reached up and tried wrapping his brown hair around his finger. It was too short. Finn hated how short his hair was. He couldn’t tie it, he couldn’t fidget with it, it was too short to even be able to tuck it behind his ears. He wished that, someday, he would be able to grow it out. Once no one judged him. Once he felt safe. Finn pushed himself off the ground into a standing position. The second he was up again, he felt a stab of cold against his feet. He wanted to sit back down, but this time, his curiosity was more important to him than his personal comfort. At long last, he broke free from the shackles that held him in the cold, and started walking towards the light.

Chapter 2

Jailbreak

 Finn started walking towards the end of the tunnel, that end that had had previously felt so distant. As he walked, he felt the ground becoming warmer underneath his bare feet. It was nice. At one point, Finn stood still for a second to savour how comfortable he was standing here. Far better than in the corner. After a few short minutes, he noticed how close to the light he really was. As he looked down, he saw that the shadow ended directly before his feet. Strangely enough, he still couldn’t tell what was beyond the light. He took another step and felt as the light seemed to bathe his feet. His fears were gone. No more fear of judgement. No more fear of how he looked, or how he acted. No more fear of not doing what everyone else did. He felt physically softer, but also infinitely better than before. He felt like he could finally be himself. Another step. His legs felt warm and comfortable. Less of the hair he so disliked. For the first time in a long time, he felt comfortable with the way he looked. His shorts felt better on his legs than before, looser. Without further hesitation, Finn took the biggest step yet. His entire body up to his shoulders was engulfed in light now. It was relieving. He felt comfortable in his own skin for what felt like the first time in his life. He had noticed the grey shirt he was wearing had shifted colour as he became more comfortable. He was sure it was black when he was still sitting down. Now it was creeping closer to a desaturated red. As he took his last step towards the light, Finn felt bliss. He was entirely free. No judgy classmates. No restricting standards and emotions. At last, he saw what was past the light.

Chapter 3

Freedom?

 It was a field. An endless field of beautiful green grass, covered in beautiful pink flowers and the occasional mountain laurel. He stepped out of the concrete tunnel into the soft green field. It felt serene under his feet. He knelt down and grabbed a few of the pink flowers. He had always secretly wanted to make a daisy chain. He had always loved flowers. “Playing with flowers is for girls!” everyone had said. It hurt. After tying a few of the flowers together, he reached down again to get more. One after the other, he attached them to the end of the chain. He took the completed chain and reached up to put it in his hair. It didn’t work as he wanted it to; some flowers got detached, some even fell down. It didn’t matter to him. He grinned a wide happy grin as he pranced through the empty field. The grass brushed against the little hair he had left on his legs. There was so much more space here. There was no more need to hold still. His hair was longer now. It finally reached a bit past his shoulders. It bounced as he ran wildly. His shorts were wider now… As he contemplated it, he realised that it was more like a skirt now. He didn’t mind, he didn’t have to. He was free. He kept running. He didn’t want to stop, so why would he? No one could stop him here! No one could judge him here! He saw the sun reflect off of a large body of water in the distance. Without stopping to rest, he continued to dance and spin through the field. The tall grass sweeping softly against his hairless legs. His hair poured down to the middle of his back now, still bouncing as he pranced. The sun shone on him as he ran, the wind dancing through his hair. Finally, he began to slow. As he reached the water, he finally settled down. There was enough space here. So much space, that he didn’t even have to move. He was scared. Scared of facing whoever waited for him in the reflection of the water. Scared of facing whoever the new him was. He had changed. He knew that. In the short amount of time that he had now spent in this place, he had not only changed physically, but also mentally. He looked down, and finally noticed everything about him. Everything had changed to how he secretly always wanted it to be. His legs were smooth and soft. They were closer together, so close that his knees were almost touching. He didn’t find it strange. He loved it. Finally, he saw himself for who he wanted to be. He went to sit down by the edge of the water and decided that he wanted to dip his legs. He brushed his skirt under himself as he sat down. As he lowered his legs, he noticed that the water was surprisingly warm. Even if it had been cold, he would have still stayed exactly where he was. Full of curiosity and anticipation, he bent forwards.

His reflection…. his reflection was him.

no,

his reflection wasn’t him…

his reflection was her.

Finally, it was her.

Chapter 4

Unshackled

She had never thought this to be something to happen to her, but she was as happy as she had ever been. She was comfortable in her body, with her clothes, with her hair. In her reflection, she finally saw the girl she had always wished she was. The girl she could finally be. She let out a small gasp of surprise and leaned back. She had never thought about this part of herself. No one else would like it. But she did, so no one else needed to. She was alone. She lay in the grass, her legs still in the water, her hair baked in the warm rays of the sun. The parts of her legs that weren’t submerged were warm, even though the skirt she was wearing was slightly shorter than her shorts from before. Her shirt was a bright maroon now. “Laurel,” she said out loud. Her voice sounded heavenly. Her name sounded heavenly. She stretched her arms above her head and, for the first time in her life, cried with joy.


r/writingfeedback • • 20h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted First attempt at writing. Chapter 1….

1 Upvotes

ECHO

Echo looked out the aviary window, her bright sad eyes searching. Across the sprawling city the sights and sounds of evening wafted up to her perch. The laughter of families sitting down for the evening meal, the aroma of freshly baked bread and spice-heavy street food, the braying of goats and clip of horses through the winding maze of streets tickling her senses. But she didn’t notice, couldn’t focus on the teeming, layered, vibrant energy of the city. Not like usual, not when her world had just…just washed away. A wave, that barreled on to the shore, pulling everything in its path out to sea.
 
The aviary sat atop the Northwest tower of the Astrian castle, standing watch over the sea of humanity to its South and West.  Only the turquoise bay on the north and western shores of Astris and the Elmfire mountains to the south and east halted the sprawl. The castle itself shouldered the mountain that seemed to insert itself into the center of the city, extending into a hidden fortress filled with grand rooms, winding stairways, broad tunnels, clever windows, and secrets underneath the granite. Echo loved this city, the castle, the people she had grown up with…the people she called family. Her gaze sharpened on the city. The hills layered with grand sandstone, marble, and granite estates, packed so tightly as townhouses with gardens and waterfalls Babylon would envy. Minarets pierced the sky, held up by ornate stained glass windows, filtering rainbows of light into their sanctuaries. The grand avenue leading from the main castle entrance to the sea. Wide enough to fit 10 stallions across with ease.  And the libraries. Tucked into every neighborhood, every corner of the city. Free to any to use, of this land or not. The Astrian library on the castle grounds was the grandest library on the continent. Grander she’d heard than all others across the empire. It had been the honor of her 24 years to study there. She settled her eyes on the grand avenue below. Street vendors lining the edge, families, friends, visitors gathered around to watch the master cooks and eat until their bellies were full to bursting. This city of peace was an oasis, a gift. And she claimed this land and people as her own.
 
But it had all been a lie. Woven to keep her, bind her. They are out there. My family. My true family. All this time. Her grief gathered in her chest, her head full of questions, possibilities.
 
Echo turned her head at the sound of footsteps rounding the last steps to the aviary entrance, but did not move from the window seat. Unusual for someone to visit the aviary this late, she thought. With the light fading the room shifted, long shadows concealing the gilded cages. Cilian stepped through the tall arch, wariness dimming his green eyes. “Eidra has…summoned you. I told her you need time. I tried…to buy you some time.”
 
Echo exhaled slowly and inaudibly, letting her hope remain drifting over the city. “Summoned? Let’s go, then. Eidra waits for no one. Not even time,” she said slipping off the window sill. “No, not even time,” Cilian agreed, as he curled his arm through hers, escorting her down the stairs to face her host.
 
—————————————————
 
Like the grand estates of the city, the castle was built of sandstone, marble, and granite. The sheer scale of the towers, walkways, and grand rooms called to the stars. The ancient architects were masters of their domain. The castle itself having lasted 3,000 years and capable of lasting twice as long - eternally maybe.
 
Cilian and Echo reached the bottom of the aviary and stepped onto the Scholar’s Path. To their left the broad internal entrance to the library beckoned. To their right the long hallway led South, to the heart of the castle.
 
Echo felt the tug of the library between her shoulder blades loosen as she and Cilian passed the entrance to the Visiers’ administration and its numerous doors and offices along the left wall. To their right the 2-story tall windows made the space feel even bigger, gardens, pathways, fountains, and statues illuminated now by lamplight.
 
“Do you know what you are going to say? She’ll have thought of everything you know. She’ll have reasons. Valid reasons.”
 
Echo’s heart nearly beat out of her chest, her face flushing pink, breathing a gasp as she stopped and her head whipped to face Cilian. “Valid reasons? To lie to me about who I am, WHAT I am? For.my.entire.life. What could be worth that cost Cilian!?” Her breathing grew faster, lighter. Dizziness pressed into her. My family. My family. I have a family.
 
“I…I’m sorry. There is no excuse. Truly. But you, better than anyone, know what we are up against.  Know the odds we face. There has to be a reason.” Cilian’s remorse transformed him. Broad shoulders sagging, crisp green eyes full of sorrow, and his typical mischievous grin replaced with pursed lips. There was never any hiding what he felt, what was in his heart.
 
Echo forgave him then, knowing he was adrift just as she was. Both of their worlds changed when dawn broke over the Elmfire peaks that morning. “I don’t know what I’m going to say, but I do know what I’m going to do. I’m going to fly. Fly out of here and find my family.” She turned back to the Scholar’s Path, walking with purpose towards the throne.
 
——————————————————
 
Eidra Aluna, Queen of the Astrian realm paced. It’d been hours, what felt like days. Waiting. Ha! Waiting for a storm to sweep through. It was a beginning. First, an end. She was relieved. Finally able to shed this lie. Her childhood sister, best friend, most trusted advisor.
 
That morning Echo had just come in from riding, sweat, dust, horse, the city coating her. She looked utterly a mess, and happier for it. Eidra had been at the stables by chance, the new Celadian stallion arriving early. When Reaya knocked lightly on the door not a minute past dawn, she could barely hold in her excitement as she told Eidra that the Celadian royal yacht was docked. Eidra and Reaya rushed her dressing, choosing a simple yet exquisite riding outfit and cape  in cobalt and teal, the colors of Astris, to meet her new prize.
 
The stables flanked the southern edge of the castle grounds, taking advantage of the rare flat plateau that stretched towards the southern edge of the mountains. Eidra cherished her city, the seat of the vast Astrian realm, but often longed for the simplicity and peace of the southern plains. It was said her family, before the empire existed, had settled first in these plains.
 
By the time she reached the stables, the sky was losing its dark hue, pink and gold crowning the Astronomer’s Mountain. Lower, fog still clung to the last kiss of night, a continued promise of spring.
 
As she stepped into the stables, she saw Echo guiding Shae into her stall. The wheat colored mare’s eyes were bright and her coat glistened. “You ran her already?” Echo smiled broadly, excited to share her progress. “Yes! She is truly amazing Eidra, erm your highness. I knew she could fly once we rounded the southern face. We galloped down the plains, circled to the coast and back to the city. She is special. I can’t thank you enough.” “Anything for my best friend and chief advisor. You could’ve had an estate in the country or thrown a grand party for your birthday. But this? This was easy. I’m so glad you are happy with her and she with you. Andovian mares are notoriously picky!”
 
“What would I do with an estate in the country?” Echo said chuckling. “My heart is in this city. I can’t imagine leaving all these grand libraries. The museums, food, art, people. We truly are blessed by the stars.”
 
“I know one thing you could do,” the queen teased with a gleam in her eye. “Cilian loves to get out of the city and would love to show you his…estate.” Echo eyed her friend, her queen through her hair that now clung to the side of her face. Laughing, she blew the wisps away and turned to brush Shae. “Cilian is a flirt at best and rogue at worst. We are friends and nothing more.”
 
“My cousin would beg to differ. Beg, Echo.” With that Eidra winked and walked to the end of the stable. “Hurry. Come with me to meet my new prize. The yacht from Celadia is here and the prince waits.”
 
Echo hurriedly finished brushing Shae, whispering in her ear that she was the best girl as she gave her a carrot then closed the pen door. The stable hand nodded and watched her walk out of the stables towards their queen.
 
Echo reached the edge of the stables and saw the Celadian retinue to her right. A mass of purple and gold uniforms, ever the formal party, no matter the occasion, no matter the time of day. To her left Astronomer’s Mountain was now gleaming, crowned in ascendant gold from the rising sun. It would be a beautiful spring day. The clouds that earlier hugged the mountain having taken off to the upper atmosphere. A cool breeze promised relief from the unusually humid weather of late.
 
Silence drew her attention back to the gathering crowd. She turned toward the group, smoothing her copper curls back from her face, wiping her hands on her riding pants. Not how she would typically meet a foreign delegation, but Astrians were known for their candor, realness. They were the salt of the empire, forged by the land and the sea that commanded their devotion. She held her shoulders back, lifted her chin and smiled in greeting. Eidra was close to her on the left, a few feet ahead. She was standing near a tall blonde knight, no the prince, by the alert looks of those around him. As she approached, Eidra turned towards Echo, and as the Celadian prince stepped aside to make her acquaintance she glanced briefly to Eidra. Echo’s smile wavered as she noted the grief and panic on her unflappable friend’s face. And as her attention squared in front of her time stopped, waves crashed, and Echo was pulled under.
 
 
 
Eleiris Andromere rested her chin on crossed arms, peering long over the ship’s rail. The twin moons hung low in the sky, casting cool light over the inky black depths. She exhaled as the salty brine of the Astrian gulf reached her. She loved the water, lived for the freedom and expanse of the seas, but she was ready for a proper bath. The journey from Celadia to Astria was long. Travel between the two realms was rare due to the distance alone. Not to mention the dangers, political and otherwise that must be navigated as well. They’d embarked 3 months ago, stopping only to resupply, and resting in Cretan. Eleiris thought back behind her to the wide wooden doors that led to the prince’s quarters. Her prince. Her love. What a turn this voyage had taken. It would be interesting to see how he fared with Eidra. This alliance could alter both of their paths, their realms for better or worse. It was essential to secure. She took another breath of the healing sea air and turned to walk back to her cabin. “Is all well Lady Eleiris? If your stomach is unsettled I can make you some tea?” Eleiris startled at the voice, then chuckled. “Arwen you sneak like a master spy in Celad! I am happy then that you are my trusted spy. No, I am well. Just getting some air as I ponder this alliance. What it means. We are close, Arwen. So close.” “Yes my lady, you and the prince. You will secure our future. You will save us all.” Eleiris shoved down the panic that threatened to unleash, forcing a small smile to her lips that didn’t meet her eyes. “Yes, so it will be,” she said, slipping into her room. “Goodnight Arwen, tomorrow we begin.” Tomorrow, a beginning and an end.
 
———————————————————
 
Seagulls peppered her consciousness, dragging her out of sleep. With a big stretch and yawn she pushed the last echoes of her dream away, a single ray of sun blinding her through the window as she sat up. The yacht swayed but was silent. We have arrived, then.
 
A light knock at the door and Arwen stepped in, breakfast tray in hand. “ It’s just as beautiful as the stories mention, Lady Eleiris! The water is turquoise! Turquoise! And you can see straight through to the bottom! The castle stretches into the city itself, and I can see Astronomer’s mountain!”
 
Eleiris smiled, “It is true then. We’ve finally reached the ancient city of Astris. Let’s hurry  - Prince Aegis will be ready soon.” She picked up an apple tart from the tray, ignoring the look from Arwen. We’re here. Finally. She moved into the bathing room as she stuffed the tart in her mouth, undressing as she chewed. She scanned the closet for her formal dress, a fitted jacket and pants in deep purple. Gold lined the seams with the intricate vines of the Celadian forests embellishing the dark uniform. A gold cape, worn for royal visits and ceremony only completed the formal look. The General of the Celadian Royal Guard looked in the mirror, tying her hair back. Pearls entwined with braids marked her status among her legion. No other stood above her, aside from the commander himself, her prince.
 
———————————————————
 
The docks were busy, even as dawn was slowly rising itself. Eleiris scanned her surroundings, taking in the vast city. Astris was a peaceful city, its residents well cared for. Indeed it was the envy of the world. Their great libraries held knowledge going back thousands of years, their scholars unmatched for generations. There was crime in the city, disputes certainly, but actual violence was rare, not tolerated. Astrian justice was swift, final. Exile was the only capital punishment. You lived by the law or you left. Even so, this was a foreign land and Eleiris met the eyes of each guard under her command. Watch, learn, protect. Their efficient clipped nods the only confirmation needed.
 
Aegis stepped off the gangplank, guiding a tall white stallion with him. The horse was massive, even by Celadian standards. He shook and whinnied vigorously, happy to be back on land. His keeper, hidden at his other side took the reins from Aegis, and patted his side. “An apple for celebration. You are back on land and will meet your new family soon!” Aegis admitted to himself that he would miss the brute. His own steed in Celad likely wondering where his master had gone. Praetus had not been trained yet to bond with a single rider. His keeper, Aegis, and a few of the guards instead coaching him to adapt, learn, and discern his own master. Form bonds in a new world. Celadian horses were prized throughout for their intelligence, loyalty, and strength. But Praetus was also independent and would require a masterful rider. Aegis hoped the Queen deserved him.
 
He turned towards Eleiris noting her scan of the city. His heart dipped at the sight of her. She was his protector, his shadow. And yet, all he wanted was to keep her safe. They would deal with that back in Celad, he conceded. Right now Celadion needed both of them to protect their realm, his ascendancy. He brushed her hand as he closed in, the guards averting their glances to give them a moment.
 
“You look…hungry,” Aegis mused. “I’ll have you know I’m starving. Let’s get on with this, my prince. I need a bath. And so do you,” Eleiris returned. Aegis walked onto the broad avenue, surveying the path before him. While most of the city still slept, the docks were now buzzing with activity. Fisherman preparing their boats for sail, merchants opening their doors, vendors stocking their stalls. Water taxis, luxury cruisers, travel yachts, and traders packed the bay. The smell of baking bread, bacon, coffee, and spiced tea mixed with the salty breeze. Further north the docks gave way to a bustling commercial corridor - cafes with long terraces lined the coastal boulevard, narrow streets cutting into, then winding and climbing away from the half-moon granite backbone of the sea. Shops, hotels, libraries, squares, gardens, museums, theaters, and townhomes shared the paths leading towards the grand avenue leading up to the castle. On the other side of the grand avenue the castle walls and vast castle grounds, themselves a city in a city. He marveled at its richness, layers of history, stability, wealth, progress. The Celadian realm was a powerhouse in its own right, but carved of perseverance, adaptation, diplomacy, and will. It’s dozen city-states finally coming together to form Celadia under his great-grandfather’s reign a century ago.
 
He led the way, his command of the air around him, his astute general beside him, his retinue in purple and gold, and the stallion turning all eyes towards the castle as they made their way up the winding street in front of them. They were early and expected no greeting at this hour, but Aegis hoped when they reached the stables they would not be kept waiting long. He was tired, and indeed needed a bath.
 
——————————————————-
 
It took 30 minutes to reach the edge of the stables. By the time they crested the path the bay splayed out behind them, and a broad vista of grassland opened wide to their right. The path while steep from the bay had leveled out then circled around the castle grounds to the southern gate. There Eleiris quickly spoke with the guards on duty, and her party was passed through the gate towards the royal stables just beyond.
 
Eleiris looked at Aegis, seeing past the travel weariness to the leader he was, who he would become. She placed her hand on his arm, looked up into his silver eyes, and nodded. They could do this. Together. She watched Aegis’s attention turn as he saw movement at the stable door. Queen Eidra had no doubt been awakened at their arrival at the docks and now strode towards them, a warm smile on her face. “Welcome to Astris Prince Aegis!” She greeted, acknowledging him with a tip of the head and gesturing welcomingly to the retinue. I am sure you are in need of some rest and…refreshment.” The queen paused as Aegis turned towards Eleiris to introduce her to the queen. Confusion laced the queen’s features. Just then another woman emerged from the stables, Aegis blocking her from view. Eleiris watched the Queen glance to the side, grief forming on her face. Eleiris turned away from the Queen, only to see her own face staring back at her.