r/yimby • • Sep 26 '18

YIMBY FAQ

193 Upvotes

What is YIMBY?

YIMBY is short for "Yes in My Back Yard". The goal of YIMBY policies and activism is to ensure that our country is an affordable place to live, work, and raise a family. Focus points for the YIMBY movement include,

  • Addressing and correcting systemic inequities in housing laws and regulation.
  • Ensure that construction laws and local regulations are evidence-based, equitable and inclusive, and not unduly obstructionist.
  • Support urbanist land use policies and protect the environment.

Why was this sub private before? Why is it public now?

As short history of this sub and information about the re-launch can be found in this post

What is YIMBY's relationship with developers? Who is behind this subreddit?

The YIMBY subreddit is run by volunteers and receives no outside help with metacontent or moderation. All moderators are unpaid volunteers who are just trying to get enough housing built for ourselves, our friends/family and, and the less fortunate.

Generally speaking, while most YIMBY organizations are managed and funded entirely by volunteers, some of the larger national groups do take donations which may come from developers. There is often an concern the influence of paid developers and we acknowledge that there are legitimate concerns about development and the influence of developers. The United States has a long and painful relationship with destructive and racist development policies that have wiped out poor, often nonwhite neighborhoods. A shared YIMBY vision is encouraging more housing at all income levels but within a framework of concern for those with the least. We believe we can accomplish this without a return to the inhumane practices of the Robert Moses era, such as seizing land, bulldozing neighborhoods, or poorly conceived "redevelopment" efforts that were thinly disguised efforts to wipe out poor, often minority neighborhoods.

Is YIMBY only about housing?

YIMBY groups are generally most concerned with housing policy. It is in this sector where the evidence on what solutions work is most clear. It is in housing where the most direct and visible harm is caused and where the largest population will feel that pain. That said, some YIMBYs also apply the same ideology to energy development (nuclear, solar, and fracking) and infrastructure development (water projects, transportation, etc...). So long as non-housing YIMBYs are able to present clear evidence based policy suggestions, they will generally find a receptive audience here.

Isn't the housing crisis caused by empty homes?

According to the the US Census Bureau’s 2018 numbers1 only 6.5% of housing in metropolitan areas of the United States is unoccupied2. Of that 6.5 percent, more than two thirds is due to turnover and part time residence and less than one third can be classified as permanently vacant for unspecified reasons. For any of the 10 fastest growing cities4, vacant housing could absorb less than 3 months of population growth.

Isn’t building bad for the environment?

Fundamentally yes, any land development has some negative impact on the environment. YIMBYs tend to take the pragmatic approach and ask, “what is least bad for the environment?”

Energy usage in suburban and urban households averages 25% higher than similar households in city centers5. Additionally, controlling for factors like family size, age, and income, urban households use more public transport, have shorter commutes, and spend more time in public spaces. In addition to being better for the environment, each of these is also better for general quality-of-life.

I don’t want to live in a dense city! Should I oppose YIMBYs?

For some people, the commute and infrastructure tradeoffs are an inconsequential price of suburban or rural living. YIMBYs have nothing against those that choose suburban living. Of concern to YIMBYs is the fact that for many people, suburban housing is what an economist would call an inferior good. That is, many people would prefer to live in or near a city center but cannot afford the price. By encouraging dense development, city centers will be able to house more of the people that desire to live there. Suburbs themselves will remain closer to cities without endless sprawl, they will also experience overall less traffic due to the reduced sprawl. Finally, less of our nations valuable and limited arable land will be converted to residential use.

All of this is to say that YIMBY policies have the potential to increase the livability of cities, suburbs, and rural areas all at the same time. Housing is not a zero sum game; as more people have access to the housing they desire the most, fewer people will be displaced into undesired housing.

Is making housing affordable inherently opposed to making it a good investment for wealth-building?

If you consider home ownership as a capital asset with no intrinsic utility, then the cost of upkeep and transactional overhead makes this a valid concern. That said, for the vast majority of people, home ownership is a good investment for wealth-building compared to the alternatives (i.e. renting) even if the price of homes rises near the rate of inflation.

There’s limited land in my city, there’s just no more room?

The average population density within metropolitan areas of the USA is about 350 people per square kilometer5. The cities listed below have densities at least 40 times higher, and yet are considered very livable, desirable, and in some cases, affordable cities.

Citydensity (people/km2)
Barcelona16,000
Buenos Aires14,000
Central London13,000
Manhattan25,846
Paris22,000
Central Tokyo14,500

While it is not practical for all cities to have the density of Central Tokyo or Barcelona, it is important to realize that many of our cities are far more spread out than they need to be. The result of this is additional traffic, pollution, land destruction, housing cost, and environmental damage.

Is YIMBY a conservative or a liberal cause?

Traditional notions of conservative and liberal ideology often fail to give a complete picture of what each group might stand for on this topic. Both groups have members with conflicting desires and many people are working on outdated information about how development will affect land values, neighborhood quality, affordability, and the environment. Because of the complex mixture of beliefs and incentives, YIMBY backers are unusually diverse in their reasons for supporting the cause and in their underlying political opinions that might influence their support.

One trend that does influence the makeup of YIMBY groups is homeownership and rental prices. As such, young renters from expensive cities do tend to be disproportionately represented in YIMBY groups and liberal lawmakers representing cities are often the first to become versed in YIMBY backed solutions to the housing crisis. That said, the solutions themselves and the reasons to back them are not inherently partisan.

Sources:

  1. Housing Vacancies and Homeownership (CPS/HVS) 2018
  2. CPS/HVS Table 2: Vacancy Rates by Area
  3. CPS/HVS Table 10: Percent Distribution by Type of Vacant by Metro/Nonmetro Area
  4. https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2018/estimates-cities.html
  5. https://www.census-charts.com/Metropolitan/Density.html

r/yimby • • 18h ago

Article ‘20 percent of zero is zero’: Some progressive cities are slashing their affordable housing mandates. Should Boston?

Thumbnail
bostonglobe.com
105 Upvotes

submission statement: San Francisco cut its inclusionary housing mandate from 15 percent to 5 percent to boost construction, pairing the reduction with increased housing trust funding. Mayor Daniel Lurie and officials like Leigh Lutenski and Myrna Melgar support the shift; advocates including Kyle Smeallie accept it conditionally. Boston maintains 20 percent, while Chelsea, Waltham, and Cambridge consider cuts.

paywall: https://archive.ph/DOCUr


r/yimby • • 1d ago

Article Manchester approves 16-story tower

Thumbnail gallery
148 Upvotes

Much too many parking spaces, but some progress…


r/yimby • • 15h ago

Discussion There are planners and there are planners

6 Upvotes

You guys ever watch the 1960 movie Kidnapped?

There's this memorable (to me at least) scene where a Scottish dude tells off the protagonist. He says (at the 55 minute mark):

There are Highland gentlemen and Highland gentlemen, and as you are only a Lowlander you have not the sense to tell the one from the other!

This is how I feel about urban planners in 2026.

Back in my early years of awakening to the evils of Euclidean zoning, I blamed everything on professional planners. They were the villains. They created zoning and they were its high priests and arbiters. They were evil!

Fast forward several years, and I finally realized that actually there are loads of planners (especially of the more recent vintage) who have fully come to grips with those same evils and are now actively working to repair the excesses of the past.

In my region of the world, almost any time a municipality requests a blank-slate zoning revamp or updated UDO, the consulting firms that they engage provide uniformly good ideas, including advocating for all the missing middle, smaller minimum lot sizes, smart density, blah blah blah

So more recently, I've started to think of planners as allies of the YIMBY cause.

So it's a shock to read an article like the one below and be smacked in the face with the reminder that there are planners and there are planners.

An excellent planning firm which I've never heard of called Houseal Lavigne provided the standard YIMBY/urbanist/deregulatory recommendations that I've become accustomed to to the City of Aiken here in South Carolina.

But behold, out of the ranks of the city councilmen comes a former planner, very much of the old guard, who is absolutely ransacking these excellent recommendations as he has apparently teleported directly out of the 1950s.

It's good planner versus bad planner, and it ain't pretty:

Revamp of Aiken's zoning being shaped by City Council


r/yimby • • 1d ago

Article The Rise Of The Socialist YIMBY Mayor

Thumbnail
newrepublic.com
32 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 19h ago

Article Democrats are already fighting over affordability. Which side is California on?

Thumbnail
sfchronicle.com
9 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 1d ago

Video How to actually solve the affordability crisis

Thumbnail
youtu.be
17 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 13h ago

Meme https://www.reddit.com/r/eastbay/s/38sKzZu4Kv

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

If you want you can also look for a similar homeless proposal seeking to get the Governor's attention. It is under "Hey Governor you want to solve the homeless problem, see this proposal." Written by me also


r/yimby • • 1d ago

Video Every mayor wants to cut a ribbon. No mayor wants to fix a pipe

17 Upvotes

Quick 60-second version of the to-do list from Your City Sucks!.

The argument: fixing US infrastructure isn’t really an engineering problem, and it isn’t even a money problem. Over ten years we spend more on other big numbers than it would take. It’s a soft systems problem: who decides, who maintains, and whether anyone trusts the plan.

A few of the 21 “laws” in the video:

  • Maintenance first: fund the pothole before the ribbon.
  • The 2% rule
  • Bring back the third place
  • No hostile design
  • Empathy audits
  • The transit test

Honest question: which one would your city fail first? And which one do you think is unrealistic?

(Disclosure: I work with the author.)


r/yimby • • 2d ago

Article Jeff Bezos says 2 policies drive up housing costs, and it's 'not hard to figure out'

Thumbnail
thestreet.com
96 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 2d ago

Construction/Permitting Update A New 15-Story Building Fits on 25 Feet of Third Avenue. Why Not One Block East?

Thumbnail
danieltrubman.substack.com
6 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 3d ago

Article The Rise of the Socialist YIMBY Mayor

Thumbnail
newrepublic.com
151 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 2d ago

Study APSR study: Survey experiments show that "genuine aesthetic distaste for tall buildings is widespread and causally affects support for development." Voters are more supportive of dense development when it is proposed in already-dense neighborhoods where it “fits.”

Thumbnail cambridge.org
14 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 3d ago

Article Housing abundance isn’t just about affordability

Thumbnail
domainexpansion.substack.com
34 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 2d ago

Discussion Worse than i thought!!! 😭

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 3d ago

Legislative Update Boston city council votes to eliminate off-street parking requirement for new housing

Thumbnail
wbur.org
133 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 2d ago

Discussion https://www.reddit.com/r/eastbay/s/38sKzZu4Kv

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 2d ago

Legislative Update Willow Park Project Lawsuit Heating Up

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 2d ago

Effort post Why aren't ecological concerns/"neighborhood character" valid arguments?

0 Upvotes

I am not "deep" into the arguments of both sides but roughly familiar with the notions. More supply = lower cost, one way or another. Politicians looking for a larger tax base who are in bed developers have a conflict of interest, especially when mostly luxury housing is built. Those are some broad strokes.

I can only give my personal experience. I probably count as a "NIMBY" in that I am sick of McMansions and other oversized units being built in what were quaint, tree-filled neighborhoods in Northern Virginia. In the Dominion Hills area, a 9-acre property known as the Rouse Estate was considered for conversion into a public park by the Arlington County board. It was ultimately turned into "The Grove," a location for 40 McMansions, packed nuts to butts (priced at an affordable ~$2 million). In the Pimmit Hills Area, an entire forest was torn down to create Idylwood Hill, a townhome community starting $900k and, I shit you not, including four-level units featuring an elevator starting $1.3m.

I don't want to hear any bullshit about affordability when these companies build units with in-home elevators to cater to the wealthiest. It would be hard for me to value "beauty" and "aesthetics" over the ability for people to have housing security, but this ain't affordable housing. That said, beauty and aesthetics have value, too, and all the more so when we are talking about green spaces.

So why would it be wrong to say "no, sorry, you can't build your shit here to expand the community, this is a green space for the community that's already here"? What about the environment, runoff, CO2 emissions or just a sense of decency that ripping down that many trees can't be right? Are all those dwarfed by the desire for new units at any cost? Even when it's hypocritically and inefficiently turned into low-density, unaffordable housing?

Why the hell can't we build more skyscrapers in already dense urban areas, and leave the small green towns small and green? What would be wrong with zoning hyper-density and low density? If that's more expensive than building on undeveloped properties, why not use some of those beloved wealth taxes (the progressive go to for all life's problems) or taxes on megacorps/tech to partially fund the building of affordable units so that the job is "worth it" to the big builders? Why not a comprehensive and robust progressive solution rather than just caving in to "eh, anything just to get some more units"?

I know I'm ranting but genuinely I want to know if there's something I'm missing here, because I feel like I never see this angle and it runs across the typical YIMBY/NIMBY right/left lines


r/yimby • • 3d ago

Article Developers 'redline' L.A. over DWP costs and delays

Thumbnail kcrw.com
9 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 3d ago

Effort post "The first budget is really just a down payment.” A former SF mayor actually wrote this. Is voting no on big projects NIMBYism or pattern recognition?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 4d ago

Article Raleigh Rents Fell After Wave of New Townhouses and Apartments

Thumbnail
pew.org
157 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 4d ago

Economic dev/Construction report New study on the multifamily pipeline

Thumbnail reddit.com
8 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 5d ago

Study Raleigh Rents Fell After Wave of New Townhouses and Apartments

Thumbnail
pew.org
102 Upvotes

r/yimby • • 4d ago

Article Becerra doesn’t call himself a YIMBY. Will he be one anyway?

Thumbnail
ocregister.com
35 Upvotes